The Company has aggregated the Bruker MAT, Bruker BioSpin and Bruker CALID operating segments (the “Operating Segments”) into the Bruker Scientific Instruments (“BSI”) reporting segment based upon the guidance within FASB ASC 280-10-50-11 (“ASC 280”), which states as follows:
“[T]wo or more operating segments may be aggregated into a single operating segment if aggregation is consistent with the objective and basic principles of this Subtopic, if the segments have similar economic characteristics, and if the segments are similar in all of the following areas:
a.
Rest of the answer
The nature of the products and services b. The nature of the production processes c. The type or class of customer for their products and services d. The methods used to distribute their products or provide their services e. If applicable, the nature of the regulatory environment, for example, banking, insurance, or public utilities”.
Principles of Aggregation
The Company believes that aggregating the Operating Segments into the BSI reporting segment is consistent with the objective and basic principles of ASC 280-10-50-11. Given the similarities amongst the Operating Segments, as discussed below, disclosure on an aggregated basis provides investors the relevant information that is meaningful to understanding the Company’s financial performance and future prospects. Accordingly, the Company has concluded that aggregation of the Operating Segments into a single BSI reporting segment is appropriate.
Economic Characteristics
ASC 280 specifically references comparable long-term average gross margin as an indicator of economic similarity. ASC 280 does not, however, define “comparable.” The following provides the Company’s historical gross profit margins for each of the Operating Segments:
ACTUAL
Gross Margin:
2010
2011
2012
Bruker BioSpin
[**]
%
Bruker CALID
Bruker MAT
Based on the historical gross margins noted above, the Operating Segments have had, and the Company believes each of the Operating Segments will continue to have, comparable long-term gross margins because of the similarities in the nature of products and services, production processes, methods to distribute the products and services and the types and classes of customers.
We are not aware of any external or internal factors that would change this relationship; in fact, we expect the gross margins of the Operating Segments to move closer together in the future as we implement additional Company initiatives (shared service centers and common ERP systems, among others) and this is reflected in our internal 2013 business plan and our internal 2014 and 2015 outlook.
In reviewing the internal 2013 business plan and our internal 2014 and 2015 outlook with respect to the individual Operating Segments’ gross margins, we found that the individual long-term gross margins are within (+/- 10%) of one another in the long-term, further supporting a determination that the Operating Segments have comparable long-term average gross margins.
Specific Aggregation Criteria
The following presents the Company’s conclusions on each of the aggregation criteria noted above:
a) The nature of products and services: All of the Operating Segments in the BSI reporting segment design, manufacture, and service analytical scientific instruments to address the needs of customers in life science research, pharmaceutical, biotechnology and molecular diagnostics research, as well as in materials and chemical analysis in various industries and government applications. While the specific technologies and applications may be slightly different, there is substantial overlap and each of the Operating Segments sells to very similar customer bases (and often to the same customers). Each of the Operating Segments offer products and solutions that analyze and provide accurate information on the identity, quantity and key attributes of atomic and molecular structures. This analysis can be performed by magnets (Bruker BioSpin and Bruker CALID), mirrors (Bruker CALID) or X-ray tubes (Bruker MAT), but in the end the customers are identifying and analyzing the quantities and structural make-up of molecules and atoms using the Company’s technologically sophisticated analytical instruments. The various products offered are highly complementary and are often used by the same group within an organization to perform the research or commercial applications in which they are interested. The services provided in connection with these products are also similar and primarily include maintenance service agreements or fee for service arrangements, as well as accessory sales.
b) The nature of the production processes: The production processes are similar in nature mainly due to the similarities discussed in a) above. Each of the Operating Segments has similar products in that they include standardized products that are often conformed to customer specifications and involve similar integration processes during production. Moreover, the Operating Segments manufacture in the same regions, primarily Germany and Switzerland which account for over [**]% of products manufactured by each of the Operating Segments, with varying levels of production in the United States. The Operating
Segments also have very similar processes for procuring, handling, storing, testing and assembling and final testing the instrumentation. Each of the Operating Segments outsources non-core items such as power supplies, cabling and wiring, digitizer cards and sheet metal for its instruments. Additionally, each of the Operating Segments maintains the critical sub-assemblies and final testing processes in-house and has procedures to protect intellectual property and internal know-how. Support for these similarities can be seen when looking at typical average inventory levels, inventory turns, sourcing logistics and management, as well as overall working capital metrics.
c) The type and class of customer for products and services: The Operating Segments operate in the same core markets and share similar types and classes of customer for products and services. The largest class of customer within each of the Operating Segments is government and academia. The second largest class of customer within each of the Operating Segments is industrial and applied markets. In addition, the nature of the revenue mix within these markets is similar within each of the Operating Segments as each derives approximately 80% of its revenues from system sales, approximately 14% of its revenues from service related activities, and the remainder from system component upgrades and consumables. Finally, the Operating Segments share a common basis for competition as each competes on the basis of technical ability to meet customer specifications, product quality, reliable service and aftermarket support, and ability to develop new products and applications.
d) The method used to distribute products and services: The method used to distribute products and services is similar in nature for the Operating Segments. Distribution is typically direct once critical mass has been achieved. Prior to achieving sufficient volume levels to operate on a direct basis, third-party distributors are typically used for sales and service. In many cases the Operating Segments share sales and service offices around the world, including in Canada, the United Kingdom, Western Europe, Australia and China.
e) The nature of the regulatory environment: The Operating Segments are generally subject to the same local, federal and state regulatory environments.