Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0001714174 /10-K filed Feb 26, 2026, compared with Mar 3, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
NYSE Financials · Financial Services

Burford Capital Ltd BUR

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

4 reviews of BUR's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 4 latest letter Jul 7, 2023
Questions asked 83 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 2 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 15 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 83 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 14 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 2 of 4 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 263 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 6-K

2023-07-07 to 2023-08-24 · 17 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2023-08-24
Critical estimatesLegal and contingenciesLiquidity and cashResults discussion (MD&A)Non-GAAP measuresAcquisitionsIncome taxes
Economic and market conditions · Inflation, page 27
SEC asked (1)
Please tell us your consideration for disclosing the impact of higher interest rates associated with inflation on the fair value of your capital provision assets and related unrealized gains or losses.
BUR answered
We respectfully advise the Staff that our disclosure on inflation in the “Economic and market conditions” section was focused on the potential impacts inflation could have on the overall performance of the business, consistent with the focus of other topics in that [email protected] www.burfordcapital.com section (e.g., Covid-19 and sanctions on Russian business and individuals).
Rest of the answer

The disclosure in this section did not, and was not intended to, specifically address the potential impacts that higher interest rates driven by inflation could have in relation to unrealized fair value gains or losses in capital provision asset valuations, just as fair value is not specifically addressed in the other topics in that section. An interest rate sensitivity is currently disclosed and, to the extent it is relevant in future filings, will include commentary on the impact inflation has had on discount rates and capital provision income in the results of operations and financial position (refer to the proposed revised disclosure in Burford’s response to question 2 below).

Read in the reply
Statement of operations for the year ended December 31, 2022 compared to the year ended · Capital provision income, page 29
SEC asked (2)
Please provide us proposed revised disclosure to be included in future filings that provides a more robust and quantified explanation for the increase in your consolidated capital provision income from $194.6 million in 2021 to $319.1 million in 2022, consistent with the requirements in Item 303(b)(2) of Regulation S-K.
Rest of the question

In your proposed revised disclosure, at a minimum, address the following: • Quantify the "higher volume of favorable case resolutions, which drove higher realized gains" in terms of number of cases and the realized gains. In this regard, from the tables on page 30 and Note 6 on page 109, realized gains relative to cost only contributed $8.1, or 6.5%, of the $124.6 million increase in capital provision income. • Explain why the "higher volume of favorable case resolutions" resulted in slightly higher realized gains when it is apparent from disclosure in the tables at the bottom of page 59 and in Note 7 on page 109 that overall consolidated realizations declined from $455.1 million in 2021 to $426.7 million in 2022. • Quantify separately the number of cases with positive case milestones achieved and negative case milestones suffered during the year and the impact of each on your fair value adjustment during the year. In this regard and notwithstanding your Chief Executive Officer's (CEO) statement of intent in your June 13, 2023 earnings conference call to not provide case milestone information in the future we note, for example, discussion of the number of case milestones achieved in the first quarter of 2023 by your Chief Investment Officer during your May 16, 2023 conference call on Full-Year 2022 Results. Also in this regard, we note your CEO's statement from your May 16, 2023 conference call that the largest driver of value in your business is court decisions and that they will remain the key driver of your valuations. In addition, discuss any individually significant fair value gains or losses and any trends over time. • Quantify the impact of changes in market interest rates and the resulting changes in your discount rate included in your fair value adjustment. In this regard, for example, we note your discussion related to slide 12 in the presentation slide deck accompanying your May 16, 2023 conference call where you indicate that the increase in discount rates over the last four years resulted in about $400 million in foregone income from your portfolio. • Quantify and discuss the impact of any other material items impacting capital provision income.

BUR answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment, and it is addressed in the proposed revised disclosure below. The number of favorable case resolutions was 45 and 32 in 2022 and 2021, respectively.

● Explain why the “higher volume of favorable case resolutions” resulted in slightly higher realized gains when it is apparent from disclosure in the tables at the bottom of page 59 and in Note 7 on page 109 that overall consolidated realizations declined from $455.1 million in 2021 to $426.7 million in 2022.

We acknowledge the Staff’s comment, and it is addressed in the proposed revised disclosure below.

●
Rest of the answer

Quantify separately the number of cases with positive case milestones achieved and negative case milestones suffered during the year and the impact of each on your fair value adjustment during the year. In this regard and notwithstanding your Chief Executive Officer's (CEO) statement of intent in your June 13, 2023 earnings conference call to not provide case milestone information in the future we note, for example, discussion of the number of case milestones achieved in the first quarter of 2023 by your Chief Investment Officer during your May 16, 2023 conference call on Full-Year 2022 Results. Also in this regard, we note your CEO's statement from your May 16, 2023 conference call that the largest driver of value in your business is court decisions and that they will remain the key driver of your valuations. In addition, discuss any individually significant fair value gains or losses and any trends over time.

A milestone, as we use the term, is a step in the litigation process of sufficient significance to potentially affect fair value. However, we respectfully advise the Staff that different milestones can have different impacts on the underlying litigation and thus the fair value of related assets. For example, while a motion to dismiss is a milestone, we so rarely have commercial cases that lose at the motion to dismiss stage that we do not adjust fair value upwards simply for when we win a motion to dismiss (although a loss at the motion to dismiss stage would cause a write down). On the other end of the spectrum (with many points in-between), a trial result is a very significant result generally causing a meaningful change in fair value. Moreover, milestones are one of several factors that impact fair value. Other factors include discount rates as well as future spend and entitlement forecasts, inclusive of the duration of the underlying litigation. Milestone events can, and frequently do, also have indirect impacts on these other factors (e.g., the entitlement and duration can change as a result of a milestone).

Following discussions with the Staff in 2020, we have historically provided information about milestones and their aggregate impact on fair value in the form of an expanded table in the notes to our financial statements, found at pages 119-120 of our Annual Report on Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2022 filed with the SEC on May 16, 2023 (the “2022 Form 20-F”). We do not believe that it is meaningful or helpful to investors from a financial performance perspective to quantify milestones simpliciter given that the numbers are essentially financially meaningless without case details.

Our recent use of milestones in our commentary with investors was not to show financial performance, but to illustrate the macro trend of the reopening of courts since the Covid-19 pandemic. We did not previously discuss milestones in this way and we do not intend to continue to do so, as we made clear during our first quarter earnings call on June 13, 2023 (excerpt below from Chris Bogart’s commentary during the earnings call):

I should say something though about the concept of milestones.

So, we provided this data to try -- when we were trying to sit back and think about how to convey to people, the short-term information about what we saw happening in the courts and the return of velocity.

We hit upon this idea of using milestone factors just to show people the sheer level of difference that we were feeling in the '23 year as opposed to the '21 and '22 years. Jordan has only been here since the beginning of September last year. And he said -- I've heard him say to people sometimes when he first got here, there was sort of one e-mail every once in a while, about something happening in a case.

And now there's like e-mails all the time. Like it was -- so it's that sort of feeling in the business that we were trying to convey in some sort of numerical way. And so, we came upon the -- because before I've been using just the aggregate court statistics, backlog, statistics, and so on. The problem with those is that they don't really capture accurately necessarily what's going on with complex cases. So, we came up with this concept of milestone factors just to try to convey to you the velocity, but I want to be clear that I don't think it's a financial metric.

So, I don't think that people should be all of a sudden trying to tie these milestone factors to other numbers in the business, and I don't intend to continue to provide them. We just did them as a way and the reason that we didn't disclose this 50 or 60 or whatever the number is for the rest of the year, is it's not something that we track. It's not a KPI that I look at on a weekly basis.

We just used it as a proxy because I think it was difficult for us to get all of you as investors to understand the dynamics of what was going on in the court system without having you actually be sitting inside the business. So that's where these came from, but don't think of them as something that you take to the analytical grail now.

(Emphasis added.)

We will continue to discuss any individually material case changes and plan to augment our discussion of the drivers of capital provision income with commentary on the data to be provided in our proposed expanded disclosure of the Level 3 inputs data as set out in Burford’s response to question 14 below. Specifically, the commentary will leverage the addition of the cost, unrealized fair value adjustment and fair value data that is to be provided for the key positive and negative milestone types.

● Quantify the impact of changes in market interest rates and the resulting changes in your discount rate included in your fair value adjustment. In this regard, for example, we note your discussion related to slide 12 in the presentation slide deck accompanying your May 16, 2023 conference call where you indicate that the increase in discount rates over the last four years resulted in about $400 million in foregone income from your portfolio.

We acknowledge the Staff’s comment, and it is addressed in part in the proposed revised disclosure below whereby in future filings we will include reference to the sensitivity analysis when discussing the impact changes in discount rates have on the fair value of capital provision assets. This disclosure will quantify how much higher or lower the valuation of the capital provision assets would have been at the end of the current period if the discount rate had not changed from the prior period end. The discount rate applied to the forecasted cash flows for our assets is intended to reflect a market-based cost of capital that excludes asset class-specific litigation risk. That is, the discount rate consists of a market-based cost of capital input and asset class-specific overlays. The market-based cost of capital is an observable market input which is impacted by changes in applicable benchmark interest rates. As discount rates across multiple currencies and tenors are applied in our portfolio, there is no clear single measure to quantify the impact that changes in market interest rates have had on the discount rate. That is, there is a different impact for each currency and for each tenor, and the relative significance of each tenor in each currency is also further impacted by the relative composition of the portfolio throughout the period.

We note your reference to slide 12 of the presentation slide deck accompanying the May 16, 2023 conference call. This illustration is simply showing the estimated impact on the portfolio at the end of each reporting period if you were to apply the weighted average discount rate from the prior period. It is intended to provide an alternative illustration of the sensitivity the portfolio has to the discount rate using the actual recent history.

● Quantify and discuss the impact of any other material items impacting capital provision income.

There are no other material items impacting capital provision income. Discussion of the ‘Foreign exchange’ and ‘Other’ income/(loss) items will be included in future periods to the extent they may be material to those future periods.

We have reviewed our disclosure of the explanation for the increase in capital provision income for the year ended December 31, 2022 as compared to the year ended December 31, 2021 and have included below a proposed revised disclosure for that historical period that will be used as a template for corresponding disclosures in future filings. As noted above, the fair value calculation is a bespoke multi-variable calculation for each asset. This also includes some interdependencies between those variables that make a quantitative disaggregation of separate drivers of the fair value adjustment during the period extremely complex. We are therefore unable to provide such a quantitative disaggregation of the fair value adjustment and, given the complexities that would be involved to provide a practical explanation of the basis of the calculations, we believe that the results would not be useful to investors. We have therefore provided a predominantly qualitative analysis in certain of the sections of the proposed revised disclosure below.

“Capital provision income increased 64% to $319.1 million for the year ended December 31, 2022 as compared to $194.6 million for the year ended December 31, 2021 driven largely by an increased resumption of court activity in 2022. The table below sets forth the components of our capital provision income for the years ended December 31, 2022 and 2021.

Realized gains relative to cost were $161.7 million and consisted of $176.5 million of realized gains offset by realized losses of $14.8 million for the year ended December 31, 2022. Realized gains relative to cost were $153.6 million and consisted of $162.4 million of realized gains offset by realized losses of $8.8 million for the year ended December 31, 2021. This activity generated $426.7 million in realization proceeds in 2022 as compared to $455.1 million in realization proceeds in 2021. While the realization proceeds were lower in 2022, the relative return on the assets that resolved in 2022 was higher resulting in $8.1 million higher realized gains.

The fair value of capital provision assets is principally impacted by changes in the adjusted risk premium and discount rates. During 2022, the fair value adjustment was predominantly driven by the occurrence of a litigation milestone on an antitrust portfolio matter which accounted for $113.1 million of the $169.1 million total fair value adjustment for the period. In contrast, there were no individually significant fair value adjustments in 2021.

The weighted average risk premium adjustment applied to the forecasted cash inflows from capital provision assets increased to 38.1% at December 31, 2022 from 36.0% at December 31, 2021. This metric is a risk adjustment (haircut) applied to the potential proceeds due to Burford in the event of a successful litigation outcome due to the remaining litigation risk. While there have been significant net positive developments across the portfolio during 2022 driving the overall increase in fair value, the weighted average metric at the end of the year is higher as it also includes the impact of newly acquired or originated assets during the year which generally have higher risk premiums at the start of the asset’s life.

The weighted average discount rate applied to the portfolio increased to 7.3% at December 31, 2022 from 5.8% at December 31, 2021, which includes the impact of increases in the underlying market rates have had across all currencies and tenors driven by inflationary pressure in the period. The increase, expressed in basis points, is approximately 150 basis points and, in isolation, resulted in lower net present values. As an indication of the impact, the fair value of the capital provision assets had a sensitivity of a $122 million decrease in capital provision income for an assumed increase of 100 basis points in discount rates at December 31, 2022. The impact to the capital provision asset portfolio fair value had the discount rates not changed from December 31, 2021 to December 31, 2022 using the sensitivity data is approximately $180 million. The sensitivity figure is a point in time calculation at December 31, 2022 and therefore an approximation of the impact the change in discount rates would have had on capital provision income.”

Read in the reply
Portfolio · Overview, page 44
SEC asked (3)
Please tell us why it is appropriate to characterize your undrawn commitments as assets in the tables on pages 45 and 46. In this regard, please tell us your consideration for revising in future filings the captions of total capital provision-direct assets and total capital provision-indirect assets as we note that undrawn commitments do not qualify for asset recognition under GAAP.
Rest of the question

In addition, consider reconciling this disclosure to capital provision assets on your balance sheet and clearly identifying the columns in this table and other tables that provide Burford-only, other funds, BOF-C and Group-wide information as being non-GAAP consistent with your indication on page 7. Please provide us any proposed changes to be included in future filings.

BUR answered
We respectfully advise the Staff that our intent in the portfolio overview disclosure is to present to investors a comprehensive view of the scale of the business activity undertaken across the Burford group, including its non-consolidated private funds. The most meaningful metric used by management for this purpose includes the fair value of the capital provision assets as reported in the relevant entity’s statement of financial position, split between the capital (or cost) deployed to those assets and the net unrealized gains or losses, together with any remaining undrawn committed amount
Rest of the answer

of capital that may be provided. Undrawn commitments reflect the amount of future deployments which, if deployed, would give us greater interest in the underlying assets and an increased potential return. We have included a revised format below to be included in future filings, and the ‘GAAP’ and ‘Non-GAAP’ identifiers will be consistently applied in other similar tables in our future filings.

Read in the reply
Portfolio · Overview, page 44
SEC asked (4)
Your tables on pages 45 and 46 as well as those on page 48 in your fair value of capital provision assets disclosure have captions labeled carrying value. As you carry your capital provision assets at fair value, please tell us your consideration for clarifying in the tables that carrying value is fair value. Provide us any proposed revised disclosure to be included in future filings.
BUR answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and will revise the captions to include the more specific label of ‘fair value’ instead of ‘carrying value’ in future filings for the applicable line items which are measured at fair value.
Read in the reply
Undrawn commitments, page 51
SEC asked (5)
In the second paragraph in this section you disclose that your consolidated undrawn commitments were $1.9 billion, $1.7 billion and $1.6 billion at December 31, 2022, 2021 and 2020, respectively. As these amounts appear to refer to your group-wide totals in the tables at the bottom of page 51 and not the consolidated totals presented in the table in Note 21 on page 128, please represent to us that in future filings
Rest of the question

you will properly identify the amounts in your narrative disclosure.

BUR answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and will identify Group-wide versus consolidated undrawn commitments in future filings.
Read in the reply
Summary of capital provision-direct portfolio, page 55
SEC asked (6)
We note the table provided on page 48 of your report for the first quarter of 2023 provided as Exhibit 99.1 to your Form 6-K filed on June 13, 2023 where you provide a table with deployed costs and realized proceeds by vintage.
Rest of the question

Please tell us your consideration for augmenting your interim vintage information with information about the status and number of assets underlying the current period activity so that investors may have a better understanding of the progress in your portfolio, similar to your presentation on page 55. Provide us any proposed revised disclosure to be included in future filings. Critical accounting estimates

BUR answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment on whether this disclosure should be augmented for all interim periods. Management believes, analogizing to the guidance in Item 303 of Regulation S-K, that the augmented annual information is not required for interim periods. In our judgment, an annual frequency sufficiently discloses the material changes to the vintage performance reporting data given the lower volume of activity and degree of change historically observed during interim periods.
Rest of the answer

However, management further notes that this information has been provided on a semi-annual basis in prior years.

Given the above requirements, our intention is to continue to provide the full vintage performance table as included on page 55 of the 2022 Form 20-F on an annual basis. The full vintage table disclosure incorporates information on the status and number of assets. We also intend to continue to voluntarily provide the full vintage table on a semi-annual basis (at June 30 each year) and the more limited vintage table disclosure as provided in Form 6-K dated June 13, 2023 in our March 31 and September 30 quarterly filings. The more limited vintage table disclosure provides information on the core cash activity by vintage being the main information that we believe is useful to investors but is not otherwise required.

Read in the reply
Fair value of capital provision assets, page 61
SEC asked (7)
We note that the sensitivity analysis provided in this disclosure is the same as the sensitivity analysis provided in your Fair Value footnote on page 110. In light of the fact that you disclose that the estimate of fair value is largely based on management’s estimate of forecasted cash flows, please tell us the extent to which you considered providing a sensitivity of a 10 percent increase or decrease in the most
Rest of the question

likely expected entitlement assumption of your capital provision asset, which you refer to as your win node in your May 16, 2023 Investor Presentation available on your website. Similarly, in light of the significant range between the minimum and maximum difference of the duration unobservable input assumption, please tell us whether you considered providing a sensitivity of that assumption to show how a change in that assumption could impact your results. Provide us any proposed revised disclosure to be included in future filings. Consolidated statements of operations, page 85

BUR answered
We have considered exploring a sensitivity for entitlement that the staff suggests and concluded that it would not be appropriate or relevant given the bespoke nature of our assets and contracts. The expected entitlement is generally a readily calculable figure based on the contractual terms between Burford and its counterparties and a legal expert’s view on the potential damages, thus providing a plus or minus 10% sensitivity would not, in management’s view, be beneficial to investors since there is no significant judgment involved in the calculation of the entitlement itself.
Rest of the answer

One could then consider a 10% sensitivity on the potential damages figure that flows into the entitlement calculation (or is essentially upstream from the proceeds received by Burford) but that sensitivity is one that is not applicable on an aggregate level or in many cases even applicable to a single asset. For example, in many of our contracts the amount that we receive in the future is driven by the capital we have provided and timing of when we provided that capital and thus the increase in damages received by our counterparty would have no impact on our proceeds. The reverse is also true in that reduction in the overall proceeds received might not have an impact on our return of capital as our contract could have certain floors or minimums to be received assuming there are enough initial damages received. This becomes increasingly more complicated when you look at portfolios in which cases may be cross collateralized or have varying impacts on the ultimate proceeds that we receive. We have thus concluded that the bespoke and idiosyncratic nature of each of our contracts does not lend itself to typical sensitivities.

We have included an interest rate sensitivity in our periodic reports to date and plan to augment this disclosure with an equivalent duration sensitivity in our future filings. A template of this intended disclosure is set out below:

“Further, at December 31, 2022, should duration have been 6 or 12 months longer or shorter, as applicable, than the actual durations used in our fair value estimates, while all other variables remained constant, our consolidated income and net assets would have increased or decreased, respectively, by the following amounts:

($ in thousands) At December 31, 2022

+ 6 months duration##

+ 12 months duration##

- 6 months duration##

- 12 months duration##”

Read in the reply
Fair value of capital provision assets, page 61
SEC asked (8)
In your financial and operational review disclosure on page 31 you indicate that your case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost includes situations where you are the claimant in a litigation matter, either due to the acquisition of assets, or the assignment of a claim.
Rest of the question

Please address the following: • Quantity how much of this expense relates to matters you acquired or that were assigned to you for all periods presented. • Tell us the process by which you become the claimant in a litigation matter, separately for the acquisition of assets and the assignment of claims. • Quantity the number of litigation matters where you are the claimant and explain how these litigation matters are disclosed in your filing, from the time of acquisition until the time of resolution. • Provide an illustrative example of the accounting applied from the acquisition/assignment of a claim to you, until resolution of the claim, including the line items in the financial statements where the activity is recorded. • As you no longer apply a “cost plus” methodology for the recognition of capital provision assets, tell us your consideration for renaming this expense to remove the reference to cost. • Provide us proposed revised disclosure to be provided in future filings that more clearly describes the nature of these expenses.

BUR answered
Historically, the majority of this line item related to legal expenses associated with BCIM Strategic Value Master Fund, LP (the “Strategic Value Fund”), which is a private fund that is consolidated in our financial statements. The strategy of the Strategic Value Fund focused on merger appraisal situations, where we would initially typically take largely offsetting long and short equity securities positions in a public company that is expected to complete a merger process.
Rest of the answer

At the close of the merger, we would invoke the appraisal process which disputes the proceeds offered for the long equity securities and starts a judicial appraisal of the fair value of the acquired company’s equity securities to determine whether an adequate control premium was offered. At this stage, there has been no settlement of the equity securities, instead the offered proceeds have been rejected and Burford retains an interest in a financial instrument. Once the appraisal process commences, the equity securities are no longer traded and the typically Level 1 actively traded securities are transferred to Level 3 in the fair value hierarchy at the fair value of the proceeds offered in the merger. The Strategic Value Fund appoints third-party law firms to pursue the appraisal claims on its behalf and these expenses are included as case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost. The conclusion of the appraisal process, either through negotiated settlement or judicial award, determines the final amount of merger proceeds to be paid.

The Strategic Value Fund has not been making active new investments for some time, and the $12.7 million remaining balance at December 31, 2022 relates to two remaining Level 3 appraisal claim assets. The assets are included within ‘Capital provision assets’ in the consolidated statement of financial position and the associated income or loss is included in ‘Capital provision income’ in the consolidated statement of operations. Further detail of the asset balance is included in footnote 15 starting on page 115 of the 2022 Form 20-F in the line item ‘Complex strategies (Strategic Value Fund)’ in the section for ‘Assets of consolidated investment companies’ under ‘Capital provision assets’.

While active, the Strategic Value Fund positions represent assets acquired where Burford is also the claimant in the litigation matter. These expenses accounted for approximately 55% to 75% of the total case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost from 2019 through 2021. As the activity of the Strategic Value Fund continues to decrease, the proportion of the expense relating to the Strategic Value Fund in 2022 has dropped to less than 10% of the total case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost in 2022.

Aside from the Strategic Value Fund’s positions, less than 1% of the total case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost in each period relate to positions where Burford is the claimant in the underlying litigation matter. This relates to two positions which are immaterial in our view. The remaining immaterial balance of the expenses included as case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost relate to expenses incurred directly by Burford that do not form part of the agreed funding to be provided to the counterparty. For example, management may decide to pay for some additional legal advice or expert opinion regarding the underlying litigation. In such circumstances, this does not constitute or count towards part of the agreed funding amount in the applicable agreement and there would also be no incremental return entitlement due to Burford relating to such expenditure.

We acknowledge the Staff’s comment that the fair value methodology is no longer dependent on cost as a key input as it is a discounted cash flow model which uses expected future cash flows. While cost is not a key input to that model, it is still a relevant metric used to estimate the potential future cash flows (proceeds) due to Burford and to quantify the amount of unrealized fair value gains or losses on the portfolio. Management therefore respectfully submits that the current caption used for the line item remains appropriate and is the most informative to investors. We have set out below a proposed revised disclosure for this line item that will be used as a template for future filings:

“Case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost increased 56% to $8.2 million for the year ended December 31, 2022 as compared to $5.3 million for the year ended December 31, 2021. The increase reflects an increase in the number of situations where we incur legal or other related expenses that are directly attributable to a capital provision asset but they do not form part of the funded amount under a capital provision agreement. These expenses accounted for $7.6 million and $2.2 million of the total case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost for the year ended December 31, 2022 and 2021, respectively. Examples of such expenses include fees paid to third parties when Burford’s management has sought its own legal advice or expert opinion with respect to matters related to a capital provision asset.

Case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost also include some situations where we are the claimant in a litigation matter either due to the acquisition of assets or the assignment of a claim. The primary driver of this activity relates to the Strategic Value Fund and the legal expenses incurred in seeking appraisal of merger- related proceeds due on positions owned by the Strategic Value Fund. These expenses accounted for $0.6 million and $3.1 million of the total case-related expenditures ineligible for inclusion in asset cost for the year ended December 31, 2022 and 2021, respectively. While we report these Strategic Value Fund related costs as expenses for accounting purposes, we treat them for return and performance purposes no differently than traditional legal finance arrangements.”

Read in the reply
Notes to the consolidated financial statements · Note 7. Due from settlement of capital provision assets, page 109
SEC asked (9)
We note your $11.3 million unrealized loss in 2022 and your disclosure in Financial and operating review on page 38 that it relates to an $86.3 million receivable in your Strategic Value Fund. Please tell us: • The nature of this loss; • How you determined its amount; and • Why you consider it an unrealized loss when it presumably resulted from a realized gain when you reclassified it from capital provision assets
Rest of the question

to due from settlement of capital provision assets.

BUR answered
As noted above, the Strategic Value Fund pursues a merger appraisal strategy. For one of the assets (“Class 7”), a final judgment was received during 2021 entitling the Strategic Value Fund to $65.5 million in proceeds. While partial payments were received during 2021 against the judgment, of the total $86.3 million due from settlement balance at December 31, 2021, a balance of $22.8 million remained attributable to the Strategic Value Fund’s Class 7 asset.
Rest of the answer

Further payments of the Class 7 proceeds were made during 2022 reducing the outstanding balance to $11.3 million.

The judgment debtor entered a Chapter 11 voluntary bankruptcy proceeding on September 7, 2022, without a restructuring support agreement or plan of reorganization. Following this event, Burford’s entitlement to proceeds became subject to the bankruptcy process along with the judgment debtor’s bond holders and other creditors. The Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings therefore effectively removed any significant likelihood of receiving the entire remaining $11.3 million due to the Strategic Value Fund given its status as an unsecured creditor.

At December 31, 2022, the judgment debtor had continued to not file a plan of reorganization and, given the uncertainty of future receipts, the valuation committee approved a fair value adjustment of $(11.3) million to reduce the fair value of the position to a nominal amount of $1,000.

By June 28, 2023, the judgment debtor had filed, and the court approved, a plan of reorganization which extinguished the possibility of recovering further proceeds. At June 30, 2023, the matter is now recognized as a realized loss.

Read in the reply
Note 15. Fair value of assets and liabilities · Valuation methodology, page 115
SEC asked (10)
On page 116, you disclose that you have elected the fair value option for certain equity method investments, marketable securities, due from settlement of capital provision assets and financial liabilities relating to third-party interests in capital provision assets.
Rest of the question

We also note your disclosure that “there were no gains or losses recognized in the consolidated statements of operations with respect to these assets and liabilities.” Please tell us, and provide us proposed revised disclosure to be included in future filings that clarifies, why no gains and losses were recorded for each group of assets and liabilities for any of the reported periods. Additionally, as part of your response, please clarify whether the amounts for these assets and liabilities reported in the “Income for the period” columns on pages 117 and 118 solely represent interest and dividend income.

BUR answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and note that the sentence “there were no gains or losses recognized in the consolidated statements of operations with respect to these assets and liabilities” is incorrect. Income with respect to these assets and liabilities, consisting of realized and unrealized gains and losses, interest and dividends, where applicable, was recognized in the consolidated statements of operations and disclosed elsewhere within the consolidated financial statements for the years ended December 31, 2020, 2021 and 2022.

For future filings, we propose to include the following
Rest of the answer

revised disclosure: “The Group has elected the fair value option for certain equity method investments, marketable securities, due from settlement of capital provision assets and financial liabilities relating to third-party interests in capital provision assets in order to provide a consistent fair value measurement approach for all capital provision related activity. Realized gains and losses, unrealized gains and losses and interest and dividend income on these assets are recognized as income and presented in the consolidated statements of operations when they are earned.”

Read in the reply
Movements in Level 3 fair value assets and liabilities, page 117
SEC asked (11)
We note that the balances and activity for your total capital provision assets and for your due from settlement of capital provision assets do not necessarily agree with comparable balances and activity presented in the separate rollforwards presented in Note 6 for the former and Note 7 for the latter.
Rest of the question

Please tell us why the following amounts differ between the relevant rollforwards and reconcile for us the following differences: • The opening balance for capital provision assets at January 1, 2020; • The realization and income for the period amounts for capital provision assets during 2020; • The deployments, income for the period and foreign exchange amounts for capital provision assets during 2022; • The ending balance for capital provision assets at December 31, 2022; • The opening balance for due from settlement of capital provision assets at January 1, • The deployments and realizations amounts from Note 15 and the relevant captions in Note 7 for due from settlement of capital provision assets during 2020; and Note 7 for due from settlement of capital provision assets during 2022. Sensitivity of Level 3 valuations, page 118

BUR answered
There was a Level 1 asset in the Strategic Value Fund which was accordingly not included in the movement in Level 3 table.

● The realization and income for the period amounts for capital provision assets during 2020;

There was a Level 1 asset in the Strategic Value Fund which was accordingly not included in the movement in Level 3 table.

● The deployments, income for the period and foreign exchange amounts for capital provision assets during 2022;

A Level 1 asset was acquired in 2022 that had activity for deployments, income and foreign exchange during 2022.
Rest of the answer

Accordingly, this Level 1 asset is not included in the Level 3 roll forward table.

● The ending balance for capital provision assets at December 31, 2022;

As noted above, there was a Level 1 asset balance at December 31, 2022 included as part of the capital provision assets balance in Note 6 that is not included in the Level 3 roll forward table.

● The opening balance for due from settlement of capital provision assets at January 1, 2020;

The opening balance should match the amount reported in Note 7. The correct balance is $48.1 million, i.e., $(4.4) million lower than reported.

● The deployments and realizations amounts from Note 15 and the relevant captions in Note 7 for due from settlement of capital provision assets during 2020; and

The balances reported should match Note 7. The correct deployment amount is $540.3 million, i.e., $13.7 million higher than reported, and the correct realization amount therefore is $(557.9) million, i.e., $(9.3) million higher than reported.

● The deployments and realizations amounts from Note 15 and the relevant captions in Note 7 for due from settlement of capital provision assets during 2022.

The realizations and income columns should match Note 7. As a result, $8.7 million of income should have been reported in the ‘Income for the period’ column but was instead included in the ‘Realizations’ column.

We believe the differences noted in the last 3 bullet points are not material and will be updated in future filings so that the comparative 2022 data for Note 15 matches the Note 7 data as and when it is included in those future filings.

Read in the reply
Movements in Level 3 fair value assets and liabilities, page 117
SEC asked (12)
In the second paragraph in this section, you disclose that for cases where cash flows are denominated in a foreign currency, forecasts are developed in the applicable foreign currency and translated to US dollars.
Rest of the question

We note your disclosure from Note 6 on page 109 that exchange differences arising from non-US dollar-denominated capital provision assets held by US dollar functional currency entities are recognized in capital provision income while all other foreign exchange translation differences arising from capital provision assets held by non-US dollar functional currency entities are recognized in other comprehensive income. Please tell us why your disclosure regarding forecasts in foreign currencies is limited to the translation into US dollars instead of translation into the functional currency of your relevant subsidiary/operations. In this regard, we note your disclosure on page 100 that certain subsidiaries operate and prepare financial statements denominated in pound sterling and euro. In your response, reference, where appropriate, the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your accounting and address the following: • Clarify whether subsidiaries with functional currencies other than the US dollar hold capital provision assets denominated in currencies other than their functional currencies. If so, clarify if changes in the exchange rates between the functional currency and the contract currency are included in your operating results; • Explain why the foreign exchange loss for 2022 in the capital provision asset rollforward in Note 6 on page 108 of $13.1 million differs from the $11.2 million amount as disclosed in Note 15 on page 117; and • Clarify whether the difference between the $13.1 million foreign exchange loss presented in 2022 in the rollforward in Note 6 and the $6.4 million foreign exchange loss in the components of your capital provision income table on page 109 represents translation of non-US dollar-denominated functional entity capital provision assets and related activity into the US dollar reporting currency and is included in other comprehensive income.

BUR answered
To clarify, our valuation process includes developing a cash flow forecast for each capital provision asset in the applicable currency of the transaction. Where applicable, and in accordance with Accounting Standards Codification Topic 830—Foreign Currency Matters (“ASC 830”), when a fair value amount is determined for any non-US dollar denominated capital provision asset, it is then revalued to the functional currency of the subsidiary which holds the asset.
Rest of the answer

Then for reporting purposes, all non-US dollar-denominated functional currency subsidiaries that hold capital provision assets are translated to US dollar and that value is used in the financial statements and footnotes. The disclosure referenced above omitted some of this detail and will be updated in future filings to reflect the actual practice in accordance with ASC 830.

● Clarify whether subsidiaries with functional currencies other than the US dollar hold capital provision assets denominated in currencies other than their functional currencies. If so, clarify if changes in the exchange rates between the functional currency and the contract currency are included in your operating results;

Generally speaking, most of our non-US dollar-denominated capital provision assets are either held in (i) a US dollar-denominated subsidiary or (ii) a subsidiary with functional currency that is the same as the non-US dollar-denominated capital provision assets. However, there are a few occasions in which subsidiaries with functional currencies other than the US dollar hold capital provision assets denominated in currencies other than their functional currencies. In those situations, we revalue the capital provision asset into the functional currency of the subsidiary entity and the resulting gain/loss on the foreign exchange revaluation is recorded as capital provision income in the consolidated statements of operations. We then translate the foreign currency of the relevant subsidiaries into US dollar for reporting purposes and also recognize foreign exchange translation differences in other comprehensive income in the consolidated statements of comprehensive income.

● Explain why the foreign exchange loss for 2022 in the capital provision asset rollforward in Note 6 on page 108 of $13.1 million differs from the $11.2 million amount as disclosed in Note 15 on page 117; and

The reason that the $13.1 million foreign exchange loss in Note 6 does not match the $11.2 million foreign exchange loss in Note 15 is because Note 15 only includes Level 3 capital provision assets and Note 6 includes both Level 1 and Level 3 capital provision assets.

● Clarify whether the difference between the $13.1 million foreign exchange loss presented in 2022 in the rollforward in Note 6 and the $6.4 million foreign exchange loss in the components of your capital provision income table on page 109 represents translation of non-US dollar-denominated functional entity capital provision assets and related activity into the US dollar reporting currency and is included in other comprehensive income.

Yes, this is correct that the difference between the $13.1 million foreign exchange loss in Note 6 capital provision asset roll forward and the $6.4 million foreign exchange loss in Note 6 capital provision income table is due to the translation of non-US dollar-denominated functional entity capital provision assets into the US dollar reporting currency and is reported as “Foreign currency translation adjustment” as part of the “Other comprehensive income/(loss)” line item in the consolidated statements of comprehensive income.

Read in the reply
Movements in Level 3 fair value assets and liabilities, page 117
SEC asked (13)
In the second paragraph on page 119, you disclose that your fair value policy provides for ranges of percentages to be applied against the risk adjustment factor to more than 70 discrete objective litigation events (or adjudicative events) across five principal different types of litigation.
Rest of the question

However, in your January 26, 2023 response to the fourth bullet of prior comment 4 from our January 12, 2023 letter you indicated that during 2022, you applied a fixed percentage. Please tell us, and provide us proposed revised disclosure to be included in future filings as appropriate, to address the following: • Which periods you apply a fixed percentage for each discrete adjudicative event and which periods you applied a range of percentages. • For all periods where a range is applied, how you determined what percentage within each adjudicative event to apply on each asset.

BUR answered
We no longer apply the historical valuation approach described in our January 26, 2023 letter to the Staff; that approach was a new approach that we rescinded once we adopted the revised fair value methodology. Instead, for all periods presented in the 2022 Form 20-F and the Form 6-K filed on June 13, 2023, we apply the point within a range of adjustment factors for specific adjudicative events detailed within the Company’s historical fair value policy, that we believe to result in the estimate that is most representative of an asset’s fair value under then current market conditions.

In
Rest of the answer

accordance with ASC 820-10-55-8, the percentage applied against the risk adjustment factor reflects an update to the amount a market participant would demand for the remaining risk in the cash flows of the asset resulting from the progression of the litigation. The range for each event is ten percentage points, most frequently five points above and five points below the percentage adjustment that we consider as most representative of an asset’s fair value under then current market conditions in the absence of investment-specific circumstances that would otherwise impact a market participant’s view.

To decide which percentage to apply to a given asset, our valuation committee considers the kind and degree of legal, procedural or other investment-specific circumstances that may be present. In the limited circumstances such factors are present, an alternate point within the range may be selected by our valuation committee to reflect these factors’ impact on the asset’s fair value under then current market conditions.

Read in the reply
Movements in Level 3 fair value assets and liabilities, page 117
SEC asked (14)
Your tables on pages 119 and 120 present positive case and negative case milestone factor ranges for various aggregated capital provision assets that in total represent more than 65% of total assets as of December 31, 2022 and 2021.
Rest of the question

Given that the fair value information is shown at such an aggregated level, it is difficult to relate the individual unobservable inputs disclosed to various types of capital provision assets. Please tell us your consideration of providing additional information to allow users of your financial statements to evaluate the quantitative information disclosed, as outlined in ASC 820-1050-1D(d). In your response, at a minimum, tell us your consideration of the following: • Disaggregating the single capital provision asset category (consisting of single, portfolio, joint ventures and equity method, legal risk management, litigation finance (BOF-C) and financial liabilities) into separate capital provision asset categories, including the following five categories, each separately broken out for those capital provision assets with positive case milestone factors, and those with negative case milestone factors: (1) significant ruling or other objective event prior to trial court judgment, (2) trial court judgement or tribunal award, (3) appeal judgment, (4) settlements, and (5) portfolios with multiple factors. In this regard, we note that this presentation would be consistent with the categories used for this type of disclosure on page 110 of your Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2021. To the extent you determined this presentation was not meaningful or feasible to disclose, please tell us whether there are other ways that this category could be more disaggregated to meet the objective in ASC 820-10-50-1D(c). • Disclosing the interrelationship between positive and negative case milestone factors and your adjusted risk premium as stipulated in ASC 820-10-50-2(g). • Disclosing the identity of the "other" case positive milestone factor and its impact on fair value as it has a 100% weighted average impact in each period presented. Additionally, provide some quantitative information so investors understand how much of the capital provision asset balance is impacted by that assumption (e.g., X matters out of total capital provision asset matters, or the dollar amount of capital provision assets out of the total dollar amount of capital provision assets). Form 6-K filed June 13, 2023 Exhibit 99.1 Burford Capital Limited Interim Report...

BUR answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have set out below a proposed revised disclosure that we will include in future filings. Subject to the exception described below, this proposed revised disclosure reintroduces a break-out of the cost, unrealized fair value adjustment and fair value capital provision asset balance for each category of positive and negative milestone, respectively.
Rest of the answer

The proposed revised disclosure below excludes the YPF-related assets in the minimum, maximum and weighted average percentages applied by milestone type data and instead includes a separate line item for the YPF-related assets for which the cost, unrealized fair value adjustment and fair value data will be provided. Including the YPF-related assets in the metrics for any particular milestone type bucket would clearly identify the relevant bucket due to the fair value of the YPF-related assets relative to the rest of the portfolio. It would therefore also be reasonably clear what percentage factor had been applied to that specific position given it would dominate the weighted average calculation. This level of detailed data for a single asset could then be used to solve for the expected undiscounted cash flow prior to any litigation risk adjustment. This data is commercially highly sensitive and subject to legal privilege as it would potentially reveal to litigation adversaries an amount at which a potential settlement could be reached. We respectfully submit that providing the break-out of the cost, unrealized fair value adjustment and fair value capital provision asset balance for each category of positive and negative milestones, respectively, other than with respect to the YPF-related assets will provide meaningful additional detail regarding the impact of unobservable inputs on the portfolio and the separate data for the YPF-related assets strikes an appropriate balance of incremental disclosure and the protection of highly sensitive, privileged information. For the avoidance of doubt, we also confirm that the YPF-related assets are, and will continue to be, included in the unobservable input minimum, maximum and weighted average disclosures for discount rate, duration and adjusted risk premium.

We respectfully advise the Staff that we do not believe that disaggregating the single capital provision asset category into separate categories (single case, portfolio, etc.), and then showing the range of milestone factors for each category, will be particularly informative. The ranges for each category will likely not change appreciably from – and by definition will be within – the ranges already shown at the aggregate level. The ranges themselves are meant to illustrate to what degree we are adjusting fair values of our assets within the fair value policy framework in response to milestone events, and we believe the proposed revised disclosure accomplishes that.

We currently disclose on pages 118 and 119 of the 2022 Form 20-F that the milestone event factors are applied to the risk premium. In practice this works as follows: the risk premium at the inception of a new asset is solved for by quantifying, as a percentage figure, the haircut that needs to be applied to the expected proceeds in order to arrive at a net present value equal to the transaction price. This risk premium percentage is then adjusted when milestone events occur by the applicable milestone factor. For example, assume the risk premium at inception is calculated to be 65% which is held constant until there is a milestone event. If we assume there is a favorable trial court ruling one year later for which the applicable milestone factor is 50%, then the risk premium would be adjusted to 32.5%, effectively releasing 50% of the original 65% risk premium haircut that was applied. Conversely, if there were instead a negative event with a (50)% factor one year later, the risk premium would be adjusted to 82.5%, effectively closing the gap between the original risk premium of 65% and 100% by 50%.

Finally, the proposed revised disclosure also includes a quantum for the “other” positive case milestone factor line item of 100% for the years ended December 31, 2020, 2021 and 2022. We further note that this relates to a single asset.

Read in the reply
Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements · Note 4. Income taxes, page 17
SEC asked (15)
We note that although your income tax provision doubled from $3.4 million in the first quarter of 2022 to $7.1 million in the first quarter of 2023 the effective tax rate decreased from 4.5% to 2.3%. We also note that these effective rates are substantially lower than those presented in your annual financial statements for 2019 through 2022.
Rest of the question

Finally, you attribute the higher tax expense in the first quarter of 2023 to higher taxable income in the United States driven by realized gains on capital provision assets, offset in part by the reversal of previous valuation allowances. As it appears from the table on page 17 that your valuation allowance declined only $2.2 million from December 31, 2022 to March 31, 2023 and that absent this reversal your effective tax rate would be 3.0% for the quarter, please tell us why your effective tax rate is so low given the significant overall increase in pre-tax income. In your response specifically tell us the deferred tax provision recorded during the first quarter of 2023 associated with the significant unrealized gains related to the YPF matters.

BUR answered
The effective tax rate is low for two main reasons. First, the relative size of the valuation allowance required relating to the deferred tax asset associated with the interest expense carryforwards decreased during the period. The analysis performed at December 31, 2022 supports an expected greater recovery of this deferred tax asset which results in an increased current benefit in the tax rate for the period. The second reason is because of the low tax rates applicable to a portion of the significant increase in overall pre-tax income.
Rest of the answer

Regarding YPF matters, we generally do not comment on the individualized tax results of particular assets. There were no deferred taxes recorded during the three months ended March 31, 2023 regarding the YPF-related assets.

Read in the reply
Note 15. Fair value of assets and liabilities · Sensitivity of Level 3 valuations, page 118
SEC asked (1)
We acknowledge your response to comment 13. Please represent to us that, in future filings, you will revise your disclosure about the ranges of percentages to be applied against the risk adjustment factors to include disclosure about the breadth of the ranges and how you select the specific percentages within each range, consistent with your response. See the disclosure objective in ASC 820-10-50-1C(a).
BUR answered
We respectfully advise the Staff that we will revise our disclosure in future filings about the ranges of percentages to be applied against the risk adjustment factors to include [email protected] www.burfordcapital.com disclosure about the breadth of the ranges and how we select the specific percentages within each range.
Read in the reply
Note 15. Fair value of assets and liabilities · Sensitivity of Level 3 valuations, page 118
SEC asked (2)
We acknowledge your response to the second bullet of comment 14. To clarify for financial statement users the interrelationship between case milestone factors and the risk adjustment premium, please represent to us that, in future filings, you will disclose the example provided in the second full paragraph on page 20 of your response.
BUR answered
We confirm that we will disclose the example (cited above and copied below for reference) that illustrates the interrelationship between case milestone factors and the risk adjustment premium in future filings.

“For example, assume the risk premium at inception is calculated to be 65% which is held constant until there is a milestone event. If we assume there is a favorable trial court ruling one year later for which the applicable milestone factor is 50%, then the risk premium would be adjusted to 32.5%, effectively releasing 50% of the original 65% risk premium haircut that was applied.
Rest of the answer

Conversely, if there were instead a negative event with a (50)% factor one year later, the risk premium would be adjusted to 82.5%, effectively closing the gap between the original risk premium of 65% and 100% by 50%.”

Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2023-08-24

Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2021

2022-04-29 to 2023-04-25 · 24 questions · 4 letters from the SEC, 5 from the company
No closing letter
Liquidity and cashRevenueSegmentsIncome taxesLegal and contingenciesDerivatives and hedgingGoodwill and impairmentAcquisitionsNon-GAAP measures
Consolidated statements of comprehensive income, page 78
SEC asked (1)
Please tell us how your presentation of your consolidated statements of comprehensive income complies with the requirements of Rule 5-03 of Regulation S-X. In your response, specifically address the following matters: • Tell us how the use of "income" and "total income" is consistent with the concepts of sales and revenues in sub-paragraph 1 of Rule 5-03.
Rest of the question

• Tell us why it is appropriate to include "marketable securities income and bank interest" and "unrealized gain/(loss) relating to third-party interest in capital provision assets" as components of "total income" when they appear to be non-operating income under sub-paragraph 7. • Tell us why you do not present "costs and expenses applicable to sales and revenues" separate from "other operating costs and expenses" as required by sub-paragraphs 2 and 3. • Represent to us that in future filings you will present aggregate comprehensive income and then separately allocate it to noncontrolling interests and controlling interests consistent with sub-paragraphs 22, 23 and 24. In this regard, we note that although you indicate that your comprehensive (loss)/income computation begins with "net (loss)/income," the amounts presented are your "net (loss)/income attributable to ordinary shares." In your response, tell us why none of the other comprehensive income in any period presented relates in part to your noncontrolling interests.

BUR answered
[email protected] www.burfordcapital.com

● Represent to us that in future filings you will present aggregate comprehensive income and then separately allocate it to noncontrolling interests and controlling interests consistent with sub-paragraphs 22, 23 and 24. In this regard, we note that although you indicate that your comprehensive (loss)/income computation begins with "net (loss)/income," the amounts presented are your "net (loss)/income attributable to ordinary shares." In your response, tell us why none of the other comprehensive income in any period presented relates in part to
Rest of the answer

your noncontrolling interests.

The Company has reviewed and reconsidered the requirements of Rule 5-03 of Regulation S-X and has addressed below each of the four points in the order they were raised:

● The Company has reviewed sub-paragraph 1 of Rule 5-03 of Regulation S-X and, while the Company’s activities do not align well with the definitions and examples provided, the Company agrees that in future filings the nomenclature will be updated to “revenues” and “total revenues.”

● The question covers two separate line items in the consolidated statements of comprehensive income:

o

“Marketable securities income and bank interest” – the Company’s historical view and treatment under the International Financial Reporting Standards (“IFRS”) was that the Company holds cash and other liquid assets to facilitate the funding of litigation finance commitments, including definitive commitments, that the Company has made but not yet funded, and that cash and marketable securities are an integral part of the Company’s revenue-producing operating activities. The amount of gains and losses relating to the marketable securities is related to its liquidity management and is not a material component of its revenues. Management did not identify any specific difference between IFRS and the generally accepted accounting principles in the United States (“US GAAP”) with respect to this treatment and noted it is consistent with other US GAAP filers in comparable lines of business, such as Blackstone Inc.

“Unrealized gain/(loss) relating to third-party interest in capital provision assets” – this item relates to the third-party interests held in Colorado Investments Limited ("Colorado") as well as third-party interests resulting from capital provision asset subparticipations. The amounts reported are correlated to the capital provision income and therefore considered a core part of the Company’s operating activity. Please refer to the Company’s response to Comment #5 below for further details regarding the nature of this item.

● Sub-paragraph 2 of Rule 5-03 of Regulation S-X requires separate presentation of “(a) cost of tangible goods sold, (b) operating expenses of public utilities or others, (c) expenses applicable to rental income, (d) cost of services, and (e) expenses applicable to other revenues. Sub-paragraph 3 of Rule 5-03 further requires separate reporting for “any material amounts not included under caption 2 above.” The Company’s primary assets are all financial assets (i.e., derivatives) and, therefore, the Company does not have any tangible goods sold nor any material direct expenses associated with the gains and losses on capital provision assets. The most significant costs for the Company are personnel and related costs, which are included in operating costs.

● The Company agrees that in future filings it will present aggregate comprehensive income and then separately allocate it to non-controlling interests and controlling interests consistent with sub-paragraphs 22, 23 and 24. The Company’s other comprehensive income relates to the change in foreign currency translation adjustment, none of which relates to entities in which the Company has non-controlling interests.

Read in the reply
Consolidated statements of cash flows, page 80
SEC asked (2)
Please tell us why it is appropriate to classify your proceeds and funding of both capital provisions assets and marketable securities as operating activities. Reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your classification. In your response, tell us whether you actively trade the various securities in your marketable securities portfolio. Note to the consolidated financial statements
BUR answered
The core business purpose of the Company is the provision of capital and expertise, to clients or as a principal, in connection with (i) the underlying asset value of litigation claims and enforcement of settlements, judgments and awards, (ii) the amount paid to law firms as legal fees and (iii) the value of assets affected by litigation. These contractual arrangements are presented as capital provision assets on the consolidated statements of financial position and the returns on those assets form the principal revenues earned by the Company.
Rest of the answer

The Company therefore believes the cash flows associated with capital

New York

London

Chicago

Washington

Singapore

Sydney

Hong Kong provision assets represent the operating activities of the Company and should be presented as cash flows from operating activities on the statement of cash flows, given it is the Company’s principal source of revenue and the core to the Company’s operations. This view is consistent with the Company’s prior classification under IFRS, and management did not expect or identify any differences in US GAAP with respect to this classification.

Accounting Standards Codification (“ASC”) 230 statement of cash flows sets out the principles to be applied in the presentation of cash flows and, in a number of instances, requires judgment in the classification of certain cash payments and receipts. ASC 230-10-20 (Master Glossary) defines operating activities as follows:

“Operating activities include all transactions and other events that are not defined as investing or financing activities (see paragraphs 230-10-45-12 through 45-15). Operating activities generally involve producing and delivering goods and providing services. Cash flows from operating activities are generally the cash effects of transactions and other events that enter into the determination of net income.”

ASC 230-10-45-16 “All of the following are cash inflows from operating activities:

a. Cash receipts from sales of goods or services, including receipts from collection or sale of accounts and both shortand long-term notes receivable from customers arising from those sales. The term goods includes certain loans and other debt and equity instruments of other entities that are acquired specifically for resale, as discussed in paragraph 230-10-45-21.

b. Cash receipts from returns on loans, other debt instruments of other entities, and equity securities—interest and dividends.

c. All other cash receipts that do not stem from transactions defined as investing or financing activities, such as amounts received to settle lawsuits and refunds from suppliers.”

ASC 230-10-45-17 “All of the following are cash outflows for operating activities:

a. Cash payments to acquire materials for manufacture or goods for resale, including principal payments on accounts and both shortand long-term notes payable to suppliers for those materials or goods. The term goods includes certain loans and other debt and equity instruments of other entities that are acquired specifically for resale, as discussed in paragraph 230-10-45-21.

b. Cash payments to other suppliers and employees for other goods or services).

c. Cash payments to governments for taxes, duties, fines, and other fees or penalties.

d. Cash payments to lenders and other creditors for interest, including the portion of the payments made to settle zero-coupon debt instruments that is attributable to accreted interest related to the debt discount or the portion of the payments made to settle other debt instruments with coupon interest rates that are insignificant in relation to the effective interest rate of the borrowing that is attributable to accreted interest related to the debt discount. For all other debt instruments, an issuer shall not bifurcate cash payments to lenders and other creditors at settlement for amounts attributable to accreted interest related to the debt discount, nor classify such amounts as cash outflows for operating activities.

e. Cash payment made to settle an asset retirement obligation.

ee.

Cash payments, or the portion of the payments, not made soon after the acquisition date of a business combination by an acquirer to settle a contingent consideration liability that exceed the amount of the contingent consideration liability recognized at the acquisition date, including measurement-period adjustments, less any amounts paid soon after the acquisition date to settle the contingent consideration liability. See also paragraph 230-10-45-15(f).

f. All other cash payments that do not stem from transactions defined as investing or financing activities, such as payments to settle lawsuits, cash contributions to charities, and cash refunds to customers.”

EY Financial Reporting Developments on Statement of Cash Flows section 3.5 states:

“Operating cash flows include all transactions and other events that are not defined as investing or financing activities. That general rule is overcome if the transaction meets the definition of financing or investing activities. For example, all cash received from the sale of property, plant and equipment is usually classified as an investing activity. However, real estate companies that acquire real estate for resale in the normal course of business might classify the cash flows of the real estate sales as operating cash flows.”

The Company’s normal course of business is the origination of capital provision assets and the receipt of proceeds on such capital provision assets when they conclude. Consistent with the guidance set out in the EY Financial Reporting Developments on Statement of Cash Flows referenced above that uses the example of a real estate company, management considers the most appropriate classification for the cash flows associated with its core activity as operating cash flows and not investing activity.

With respect to marketable securities, the Company’s response to Comment #1 above notes the Company’s view that its cash management activities are an integral part of the Company’s operating activities.

Read in the reply
Note 2: Summary of significant accounting policies · Fair value of financial instruments, page 84
SEC asked (3)
Please tell us why and how your single case, portfolio, portfolio with equity risk and legal risk management capital provision assets meet the definition of a derivative and qualify for derivative accounting. Reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your accounting.
Rest of the question

In your response address each element of the definition of a derivative in ASC 815-10-15-83, with specific discussion as to how these capital provision assets have no initial net investment or an initial net investment that is smaller than would be required for other types of contracts that would be expected to have a similar response to changes in market factors and how they are net settleable.

BUR answered
In its assessment of whether single case, portfolio, portfolio with equity risk and legal risk management capital provision assets met the definition of a derivative, the Company considered the definition of a derivative provided by ASC 815-10-15-83, and the related guidance as follows:

ASC 815-10-15-83: A derivative instrument is a financial instrument or other contract with all of the following characteristics [emphasis added]:

a. Underlying, notional amount, payment provision.
Rest of the answer

The contract has both of the following terms, which determine the amount of the settlement or settlements, and, in some cases, whether or not a settlement is required:

1. One or more underlyings.

2. One or more notional amounts or payment provisions or both.

b. Initial net investment. The contract requires no initial net investment or an initial net investment that is smaller than would be required for other types of contracts that would be expected to have a similar response to changes in market factors.

c. Net settlement. The contract can be settled net by any of the following means:

1. Its terms implicitly or explicitly require or permit net settlement.

2. It can readily be settled net by a means outside the contract.

3. It provides for delivery of an asset that puts the recipient in a position not substantially different from net settlement.

We concluded that each of the single case, portfolio, portfolio with equity risk and legal risk management capital provision assets contains the following four key elements of a derivative:

One or more underlyings. [ASC 815-10-15-83(a)(1)]

The underlying is occurrence or nonoccurrence of a settlement or a favorable / unfavorable court judgment that is consistent with ASC 815-10-15-88(h) for the “occurrence or nonoccurrence of a specified event.”

One or more notional amounts or payment provisions or both. [ASC 815-10-15-83(a)(2)]

Each of the capital provision assets contains a payment provision that specifies a payment amount based on the occurrence of a settlement or a favorable court judgment. Although the amount paid upon settlement is not fixed in the agreement, it is determinable based on the Company’s capital provision agreements. Once the outcome of the underlying litigation is decided, the capital provision agreements specify how to determine the Company’s entitlement. For example, there is a formula within the contract that specifies how the proceeds should be calculated such that the Company, as the capital provider, is entitled a certain amount of the overall proceeds.

Initial net investment. [ASC 815-10-15-83(b)]

Since the potential payoff in the contract could be significantly greater than the initial net investment (i.e., the upfront payment and the present value of any future funding (if applicable)), the initial net investment is considered to be “smaller than would be required for other types of contracts expected to have similar responses to changes in market factors” (consistent with ASC 815-10-15-83(b)) and also “less, by more than a nominal amount, than the initial net investment that would be commensurate with the amount that would be exchanged to acquire the asset related to the underlying” (consistent with ASC 815-10-15-96).

Although the guidance does not provide examples of how to determine an initial net investment in the context of a contract having a fixed or determinable payment provision, when a contract has a payment provision, one needs to consider the amount of the initial investment required in the contract and compare that to the potential settlement amounts under the contract.

The nature of the Company’s capital provision assets is option-like because the payoff-profile is one sided. The greatest amount the Company can generally lose is its investment in the contract. If the plaintiff in underlying litigation is successful, the Company receives a payment (which can be multiples of the Company’s initial investment in the contract) and, if the plaintiff is not successful, no recovery is received. Unless an option contract is significantly in the money at inception, it generally has an upfront investment (i.e., the premium) that is less, by more than a nominal amount, than what would be required to own the underlying.

For example, pursuant to an insurance contract, there is amount paid upfront and, if an insured event occurs, a large payment would be received under the insurance contract. This is similar to the capital provision assets in that an amount is paid upfront and, depending on the outcome of the legal proceeding, a settlement amount will be received. Pursuant to ASC 815, an insurance contract would meet the definition of a derivative, but it receives a scope exception. Absent the scope exception, most insurance contracts would be required to be accounted for as derivatives. Given the nature of the Company’s contracts is similar (i.e., an insurance contract and a capital provision asset), where there is a small upfront payment with the potential to receive a large pay out (i.e., settlement) under the contracts based on the occurrence of a contingent event, the Company believes the capital provision assets meet the initial net investment criterion.

Net settlement. [ASC 815-10-15-83(c)]

The Company’s capital provision assets only require payment from the counterparty (under the payment provision) if there are realizations from the underlying litigation matter (i.e., a successful outcome to the counterparty), which meets the contractual net settlement condition under ASC 815-10-15-100 because there is no requirement for the counterparty to deliver an asset associated with the underlying. If there are no realizations, in accordance with the non-recourse provision of the contract, the counterparty is not obligated to return the proceeds received to finance the litigation matter. Therefore, the terms of a capital provision assets are determined to explicitly require or permit net settlement.

Read in the reply
Note 2: Summary of significant accounting policies · Fair value of financial instruments, page 84
SEC asked (4)
Please tell us why you elected the fair value option for each of the instruments identified in the second paragraph of this policy note. Represent to us that you will disclose the reason for each election in future filings as required by ASC 825-10-50-28a or tell us where you have made this disclosure in your filing.
BUR answered
The Company made such fair value option elections in order to have a consistent basis of presentation for all similar capital provision activity. The Company notes reference to the disclosure requirements under ASC 825-10-50-28a and will disclose the reason for each election in future filings as required by the ASC subparagraph.
Read in the reply
Third-party interests in capital provision assets, page 86
SEC asked (5)
Please provide us your analysis supporting your consolidation of Colorado Investments Limited ("Colorado") and why the third-party interest in Colorado is accounted for as a collateralized borrowing rather than a noncontrolling interest in shareholders' equity. Reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your accounting.
Rest of the question

In your response, tell us: • The equity interest you hold in Colorado; • The relevance of your assessment that Colorado does not meet the definition of a business; and • Why it is appropriate to charge/credit the statement of operations impact of a collateralized borrowing on your income/revenue line item in your statements of comprehensive income.

BUR answered
The Company owns 20.92% of the voting ownership interest of Colorado through one of its wholly owned subsidiaries, Prospect Investments LLC ("Prospect"), with the remaining 79.08% of the voting ownership interest owned by unaffiliated parties. Colorado is a Cayman company and was established (as set forth in Colorado’s memorandum of association) to engage in activities associated with the participation interest into the Petersen claims. Colorado was initially formed as a wholly owned subsidiary of Prospect.
Rest of the answer

When the Company sold interests in Colorado to third parties, it first determined that it had retained a controlling financial interest in Colorado, and then determined how to account for the change in interest transaction and the appropriate financial statement presentation.

Control assessment

In accordance with its consolidation policy (as disclosed under note 2 (Summary of significant accounting policies—Consolidation) in the Company’s Annual Report on the Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2021), the Company assessed which consolidation guidance should be applied to Colorado. The Company has determined that it is exposed to the expected losses and expected residual returns of Colorado through its holding of a 20.92% equity interest and therefore holds a variable interest in Colorado. Pursuant to Article VI of the Sale and Contribution Agreement entered into in connection with the formation of Colorado, Prospect acts as the administrator and manager of the claims on behalf of Colorado.

While Colorado is legally managed by a board of directors, the board of directors has no decision-making authority over the activities that most significantly affect Colorado’s economics (i.e., the only relevant activity is ownership of the participation in the Peterson case and the directors cannot directly take any decisions on the case). Prospect, not the board of directors of Colorado, manages the litigation strategy of the Petersen case pursuant to Prospect’s contractual arrangements with the plaintiffs in the case, under the supervision of the Spanish bankruptcy court. Colorado acknowledges that in Article VI of the Contribution Agreement.

When assessing control, the Company considered the guidance in a December 6, 2004 speech made by SEC Associate Chief Accountant Jane Poulin:

Other "activities around the entity" that should be considered when applying FIN 46R include …service arrangements with investors and non-investors…. These activities can impact the entire analysis under FIN 46R including the assessment of whether an entity is a VIE as well as who is the primary beneficiary.”

The only activity that will significantly affect the economic performance of Colorado is the management of the claim, which is undertaken by Prospect by contract and is not a right held through its equity.

Based on the above assessment, the Company determined that Colorado is a variable interest entity (“VIE”) and should be consolidated under the variable interest model in ASC 810, which requires consolidation by the holder of a controlling financial interest as further described in the next paragraph.

After evaluation of the specific facts and circumstances surrounding Colorado, the Company concluded that Prospect is required to consolidate Colorado. This conclusion was based on the Company’s determination that it has both “power” through managing the significant activity via Prospect and “benefits” through its 20.92% equity holding, which results in being identified as the primary beneficiary and therefore having control of Colorado. The nonaffiliated investors do not have kick-out rights through voting interests over Prospect nor do they have substantive participating rights with respect to the decisions related to the activity that most significantly impacts Colorado’s economic performance.

Accounting for the change in interest

Once it initially determined that Burford had retained control of Colorado, management then determined the appropriate accounting to apply to account for the change in interest in Colorado, pursuant to ASC 810-10-45-21A(b). When there is a decrease in an ownership of a subsidiary, the appropriate guidance first depends on whether the subsidiary is a business.

To determine whether Colorado is a business, management considered paragraphs 55-5A and 55-5B of Accounting Standards Codification Topic 805 – Business Combinations (“ASC 805”), which provides guidance on whether a set of assets and activities constitute a business. ASC 805 requires first an evaluation of whether substantially all of the fair value of the gross assets is concentrated in a single identifiable asset or a group of similar assets. If that threshold is met, the set of assets and activities is not a business.

As per the above guidance, management concluded that Colorado is not a business since its only asset is a financial asset, which meets the “substantially all” threshold.

Pursuant to ASC 810-10-45-21A(b)(2), ASC 810’s change in interest guidance does not apply to a decrease in ownership of an interest in a subsidiary that is not a business if the substance of the transaction is addressed by other guidance.

Because Colorado is an entity that only holds financial assets (i.e., the participation in the Petersen claim), the substance of the transaction related to the issuance of equity interests in Colorado to third parties is a transfer of financial assets subject to the scope of ASC 860. The transfer of the ownership interests in Colorado should therefore be viewed from the perspective of the financial assets within the consolidated subsidiary as opposed to the transfer of shares of the consolidated subsidiary. Given Colorado (the “transferee”) remains consolidated by the Company (the “transferor”), after the issuance of the equity interests in Colorado to third parties the financial assets in Colorado will remain on the balance sheet of Burford and will not be derecognized. ASC 860-10-40-4(a) states that, if a transferee would be consolidated by the transferor, then the transferred financial assets would not be treated as having been sold in the financial statements being presented. That is because the determination of whether a transferor has surrendered control over transferred financial assets first considers whether the transferee would be consolidated by the transferor. In this case, Colorado remains consolidated by the

Company and the transfer of the ownership interests in Colorado does not qualify for sale accounting. As a consequence, the issuance of equity interests in Colorado by the Company is accounted for as a collateralized borrowing (i.e., as a liability) rather than as non-controlling interests. Therefore, the cash received related to the third-party interests is recognized as a collateralized borrowing, which the Company has referred to as “Financial liabilities related to third-party interests in capital provision assets” in the Company’s consolidated financial statements.

Income statement presentation

The Company has elected the fair value option to account for the liability related to the collateralized borrowing in order to match the fair value accounting for the related assets. The changes in fair value of the liability are recognized as “unrealized gain/loss relating to third party interest in capital provision assets” within income in the Company’s consolidated income statement. The changes in the fair value of the participation in the Petersen claim (which is a capital provision asset) are included within capital provision income. Please see the Company’s response to Comment #1 explaining why the Company believes it is appropriate to present the change in the fair value of the liability included within income/revenues.

Read in the reply
Compensation and benefits · Equity compensation, page 88
SEC asked (6)
Your disclosure appears to imply similar accounting for restricted stock grants with service and performance conditions versus those with service and market conditions. Please confirm that you apply the differing guidance in ASC 718-10-30-12 for the former and ASC 718-10-30-14 for the latter. Otherwise, tell us the impact on your financial statements for applying the differentiated accounting.
Rest of the question

In any regard, represent to us that in future filings you will modify your policy disclosure to explain the differing accounting for these awards.

BUR answered
The Company can confirm that it has applied the differing guidance in:

● ASC 718-10-30-12 for restricted stock grants with service and performance conditions; and

● ASC 718-10-30-14 for restricted stock grants with service and market conditions.

All costs for restricted stock grants with service and performance conditions are charged to compensation, including any adjustments where employees forfeit because a service condition or a performance condition is not satisfied.

The costs for restricted stock grants with service and market conditions are charged to compensation based on a
Rest of the answer

calculation as to the fair value of the award at the date of grant. The expense based on the initial fair value relating to the market condition is recognized over the service period regardless of when, if ever, the market condition is satisfied. The only adjustment to the compensation expense would be with respect to any forfeitures relating to employees leaving and not meeting the service condition.

In addition, the Company confirms that in future filings the Company will modify its policy disclosure to explain the differing accounting for these awards.

Read in the reply
Note 4: Income taxes, page 92
SEC asked (7)
Please tell us how the $3,177,000 of deferred tax asset for net operating loss carryforwards at December 31, 2021 in the table on page 94 is reasonable. In this regard, at the US federal maximum statutory rate of 21%, the $21 million in US federal net operating loss carryforwards would equate to a deferred tax asset of about $4.4 million; an amount in excess of the deferred tax asset you disclose and this does not
Rest of the question

include the $31 million of US state and $8 million of other foreign net operating loss carryforwards. Note 5: Segment reporting, page 94

BUR answered
The US federal net operating loss is lower for tax purposes than for accounting purposes due to the inclusion in US taxable income of amounts that are not included in book income. Therefore, the federal tax loss base from which the $3,177,000 deferred tax asset is calculated is lower than the book taxable loss. Further, the deferred tax asset is calculated at a 25% US tax rate, which includes a blended 4% rate for US states, as well as the 21% US federal rate.
Rest of the answer

There is a valuation allowance that fully offsets the deferred tax asset for the foreign net operating loss carryforwards that results in no impact to the net deferred tax asset position.

Read in the reply
Note 4: Income taxes, page 92
SEC asked (8)
We note that your segment tables presented beginning on page 95 are essentially full statements of comprehensive income that include multiple profit measures while ASC 280-10-50-22 requires the disclosure of a single measure of segment profit or loss.
Rest of the question

Please provide us proposed revised segment disclosure to be provided in future filings that presents only a single measure of segment profit or loss in your financial statement footnotes.

BUR answered
The Company notes reference to the disclosure of a single measure of segment profit or loss as required under ASC 280-10-50-22 and will disclose its segment tables in future filings pursuant to the ASC paragraph as follows:

Total

($ in thousands)

Capital

Asset Management and

Other

Burford-only

Adjustment for third-party

December 31, 2021 provision other services corporate segments interests consolidated

Capital provision income

99,754

—

27,795

127,549

Management fee income

10,510

(1,843)

8,667

Performance fee income

5,729

Income from BOF-C

9,798

(9,798)

Other services
Rest of the answer

income

6,320

774

7,094

1,091

8,185

Income/(expense) relating to third-party interests in capital provision assets

2,028

Total segment revenues*

32,357

132,885

19,273

152,158

Operating expense

(87,420)

(33,280)

(21,488)

(142,188)

(3,635)

(145,823)

Total segment operating expenses

Segment income/(loss) from operations

12,334

(923)

(20,714)

(9,303)

15,638

6,335

Other expenses

Finance costs

(52,537)

(1,360)

(4,750)

(58,647)

Loss on debt buyback

(1,477)

(38)

(134)

(1,649)

Foreign currency transactions gains/(losses), net

(5,482)

Segment loss before taxation

(41,680)

(2,321)

(31,080)

(75,081)

(59,443)

Read in the reply
Note 6: Capital provision assets, page 98
SEC asked (9)
Please tell us why it is appropriate to include items other than realized gains/losses and the change in fair value of your capital provision assets in your capital provision income revenue line item as depicted in the table on page 99.
Rest of the question

In your response reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your position and address each of the following line items from the table: • interest income on certain capital provision-indirect assets; • interest and other income/(loss); • impairment of other asset; • foreign exchange gains/(losses); • net gain of derivative financial instruments; • loss on financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss; and • gain/(loss) on equity securities.

BUR answered
All the items noted above are directly related to the capital provision asset activity and represent less than 10% of the sum of the items per the guidance in Rule 5-03 of Regulation S-X. The Company has addressed each item in more detail below.

● Interest income on certain capital provision-indirect assets – this is income earned on capital provision assets held in the consolidated BCIM Strategic Value Master Fund LP.
Rest of the answer

The assets are measured at fair value and a component of the revenue earned relates to statutory interest applied to the amount of the original merger proceeds.

● Interest and other income/(loss) – this primarily relates to immaterial amounts of interest and other income earned on certain due from settlement of capital provision asset balances.

● Impairment of other asset – this relates to the write-off of an immaterial asset (the $500k recognized in the year ended December 31, 2021 was the final remaining amount) that was the residual position from a book of legacy capital provision activity. There is therefore no expected continuing activity for this line item.

● Foreign exchange gains/(losses) – this is the foreign currency gain or loss component associated with capital provision assets that are not denominated in the functional currency of the entity that holds the asset. For example, this would include the EUR/GBP foreign exchange difference relating to a EUR denominated capital provision asset held by a wholly owned entity within the Burford group with a GBP functional currency. This is therefore a component of the overall unrealized and realized gain or loss on the applicable capital provision assets.

● Net gain of derivative financial instruments – this relates to immaterial gains and losses on two derivative financial instruments, one relating to an option in connection with the sale of an interest in a capital provision asset and the other relating to an option contract held as an economic hedge to a capital provision asset in the consolidated BCIM Strategic Value Master Fund LP. Both instruments directly impacted the revenues earned on the associated capital provision assets.

● Loss on financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss – this relates to losses on short equity positions that were held as an economic hedge to offset the market-based gains and losses on long equity positions, all held within the consolidated BCIM Strategic Value Master Fund LP. The underlying investment strategy is focused on earning an underlying litigation related return and not an outright position in a pure equity return.

● Gain/(loss) on equity securities – this relates to one specific situation where the Company received equity securities in lieu of cash proceeds as part of a negotiated settlement relating to a capital provision asset. The value of the equity securities impacted the Company’s overall return on the associated capital provision asset and the immaterial amount of gains was therefore included in capital provision income.

Read in the reply
Form 20-F for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2021 · Consolidated statements of cash flows, page 80
SEC asked (1)
We acknowledge your response to prior comments 2 and 1 and your assertion that cash flows associated with your capital provision assets and investments in marketable securities are classified as operating cash flows because the former is your principal source of revenue and the core of your operations and the cash management activities associated with the latter are integral to your operations.
Rest of the question

Please address the following: • You provide an example that a real estate company that acquires real estate for resale in the normal course of business might classify related cash flows as operating cash flows. Tell us your consideration of the fact that the real estate company in your example acquired the real estate for resale in the normal course of business and the fact that you do not appear to sell your capital provision assets or hold them for resale in the normal course of business. In your response specifically tell us your consideration of the guidance in ASC 230-10-45-20. • Tell us your consideration of the guidance in ASC 230-10-45-12a and 45-13a that requires investing activity classification of loans held for investment and that banks, who make such loans in the normal course of their operations, classify these cash flows as investing activities and not operating activities as demonstrated in ASC 942- 230-55-2. • As previously requested, please tell us whether you actively trade your marketable securities in a trading account. Also, tell us your consideration for the guidance in ASC 230-10-45-12a, 45-12b, 45-13a, 45-13b, 45-19 and 45-20. • Tell us for each period presented in your filing:o The amount of cash received that would represent the returns on capital provision asset funding and on marketable securities that would appropriately be classified as operating activities under ASC 230-10-45-16b and 45-16c; o The amount of cash paid for the acquisition of marketable securities; and o The amount of cash received from maturities and other principal payments on marketable securities.

BUR answered
[email protected] www.burfordcapital.com

The real estate example was provided to highlight that the differing activities of entities can lead to differing judgments about the characterization of those activities as operating, investing or financing activities; an operating activity in one business may be, for example, an investing activity in another.
Rest of the answer

The example was not intended to be directly analogous to the Company’s activities; as our capital provision assets are neither acquired for resale nor held in a trading account, ASC 230-10-45-20 is not applicable.

As discussed with the Staff during the course of the Company’s initial registration in 2020, the Company’s business is unique among US public companies, and activities that the Company regards as its core operating business – the provision of capital against litigation matters – would be regarded as ancillary activities by many other kinds of businesses.

● Tell us your consideration of the guidance in ASC 230-10-45-12a and 45-13a that requires investing activity classification of loans held for investment and that banks, who make such loans in the normal course of their operations, classify these cash flows as investing activities and not operating activities as demonstrated in ASC 942-230-55-2.

The guidance in ASC 230-10-45-12a and 45-13a states that the requirements are specific to “loans made by the entity”, “debt instruments of other entities” and “collections on a transferor’s beneficial interests in a securitization of the transferor’s trade receivables”. The illustration in ASC 942-230-55-2 then provides a demonstration of how that guidance would be applied by a banking institution that holds a loan portfolio for the collection of principal and interest.

The Company’s capital provision assets do not meet the definition of the activities covered by these references, and management does not therefore consider the guidance as applicable to its capital provision activity. Specifically, management considered the definition of a loan in US GAAP and determined that the Company’s capital provision assets are not loans because they do not provide a contractual right to receive money on demand or on fixed or determinable dates. Rather, the nature of the capital provision activity undertaken by the Company is to participate in the outcome of underlying litigation events, which is unpredictable as to both timing and quantum, and meets the definition of a derivative financial instrument as previously discussed in the response to comment 3 in the Company’s letter to the Staff dated May 26, 2022. The monitoring activities required in managing the portfolio extend beyond the assessment of credit risk associated with the counterparty.

As capital provision assets are principally derivative instruments, management considered ASC 815-10-45-11 and 12 and ASC 230-10-45-27 which provides guidance on other-than-insignificant financing element. However, that guidance generally addresses the cash flow presentation from a borrower’s perspective. No such other-than-insignificant financing elements exist for capital provision assets.

Management then considered ASC 230-10-45-27 that notes, when not required to be classified as a financing activity, cash receipts and payments related to a derivative instrument should be classified based on the instrument’s nature of use. In assessing the nature of use, management used its best judgment in concluding that the cash receipts and payments represented operating activity and considered that capital provision assets are acquired by the Company as its principal operating activity with the objective to generate profits on the positive resolution of one or more underlying litigation events or through resale. Further, capital provision assets are not accounting hedges nor do they function as an economic hedge.

● As previously requested, please tell us whether you actively trade your marketable securities in a trading account. Also, tell us your consideration for the guidance in ASC 230-10-45-12a, 45-12b, 45-13a, 45-13b, 45-19 and 45-20.

Yes, marketable securities are held in a trading account and are actively traded; regular trading of the securities occurs with an average of more than one trading transaction daily during the year ended December 31, 2021. The objective of this trading activity is to earn a higher yield on the Company’s liquidity balance than that earned on cash or cash equivalents while preserving principal and providing near-term liquidity to deploy into capital provision assets and for other operating needs. These marketable securities are generally in the form of money market and fixed income instruments, for which liquid and actively traded markets exist.

New York

London

Chicago

Washington

Singapore

Sydney

Hong Kong

Management considered the guidance in ASC 230-10-45-12a, 45-12b, 45-13a, 45-13b, 45-19 and 45-20. Based upon our intent to hold marketable securities specifically for resale to achieve desired yields, the Company carries these assets at fair value in a trading account and presents the associated cash flows as operating activities in accordance with ASC 230-10-45-20.

● Tell us for each period presented in your filing:

o The amount of cash received that would represent the returns on capital provision asset funding and on marketable securities that would appropriately be classified as operating activities under ASC 230-10-45-16b and 45-16c;

Of the amount of cash flows included in operating activities, the amount of cash received that would represent the returns on capital provision asset funding and marketable securities included within reported cash flows from operating activities for each year ended December 31 is as follows:

$'000

2021

2020

2019

Capital provision assets

132,502

202,940

83,687

Marketable securities

2,615

1,096

1,987 o The amount of cash paid for the acquisition of marketable securities; and

The amount of cash paid to acquire marketable securities for each year ended December 31 is as follows:

569,885

3,172

6,310 o The amount of cash received from maturities and other principal payments on marketable securities.

The amount of cash received from maturities and other principal payments on marketable securities for each year ended December 31 is as follows:

92,954

3,570

5,636

The Company respectfully advises the Staff that $81.5 million of the cash received from maturities for the year ended December 31, 2021 was attributable to securities acquired at or near maturity or for which there were partial disposals during the time held.

Read in the reply
Notes to the consolidated financial statements · Note 4: Income taxes, page 92
SEC asked (2)
In your response to prior comment 7 you indicate that the US federal net operating loss is lower for tax purposes than for accounting purposes due to the inclusion in US taxable income of amounts that are not included in book income.
Rest of the question

As ASC 740-10-50-3a requires the disclosure of the amounts of operating loss and tax credit carryforwards for tax purposes, tell us the amount of your net operating loss carryforwards for tax purposes at December 31, 2021 for US federal taxes, US state taxes and foreign taxes. Represent to us that, in future filings, you will disclose the net operating loss carryforwards for tax purposes and not for accounting purposes.

BUR answered
The Company’s response to prior comment 7 stated the US federal net operating loss is lower for tax purposes than for accounting purposes but it was not intended to further imply the net operating loss carryforward disclosure was presented on an accounting and not tax basis. Management can confirm that the $21 million, $31 million and $8 million disclosed at December 31, 2021 are the net operating loss carryforwards for tax purposes for US federal, US state and foreign taxes, respectively.
Rest of the answer

Management further represents that this will continue to be the basis used for the same disclosure in future filings.

The Company respectfully advises the Staff that the deferred tax asset of $3,177,000 for net operating loss carryforwards disclosed at December 31, 2021 reflects that the US federal net operating loss includes amounts related to intercompany gains that are eliminated for accounting purposes. The tax effect on the portion of the US federal net operating loss that relates to the intercompany gains is presented as a prepaid tax asset within other assets in accordance with the requirements of ASC 740-10-25-3(e), as opposed to being included in the deferred tax asset balance at December 31, 2021.

Read in the reply
Note 5: Segment reporting, page 94
SEC asked (3)
We acknowledge your response to prior comment 8. The reconciliation of each segment income/loss from operations to segment loss before taxation in your proposed disclosure effectively provides two segment measures of profit or loss.
Rest of the question

Assuming that you believe that your segment income/loss from operations is your single measure of segment profit or loss, please represent to us that, in future filings, you will reconcile the total of your individual segment income/loss from operations to consolidated income/loss before taxation in the aggregate.

BUR answered
The Company’s segment measure of profit or loss is income/(loss) before income taxes. Accordingly, the Company represents that, in future filings, the individual segment income/(loss) before income taxes will be reconciled to consolidated income/(loss) before income taxes only in the aggregate.

Provided below is a proposed segment presentation and reconciliation, which the Company will adopt and include in future filings:
Read in the reply
Consolidated statements of cash flows, page 80
SEC asked (1)
We acknowledge your response to prior comment 1 and our discussion on October 4, 2022. Once you fund a capital provision asset, please describe for us any role you play in managing capital provision assets until settlement. As part of your response, describe the circumstances under which you have decision making ability over the litigation activities and costs incurred to support the matter.
BUR answered
As we discussed during our conversation on October 4, we are an active manager of our capital provision assets, with a full-time team devoted to the oversight of those assets following the entry into a capital provision agreement and the commitment of tens of thousands of hours annually to these activities; as a rough estimate, we spent approximately 80,000 hours last year thus engaged. Our engagement will vary depending on the circumstances of each individual matter, including not only the matter’s litigation dynamics but also the experience and sophistication of our counterparties.
Rest of the answer

It would be routine for us to consult on litigation strategy, to participate in choosing arbitrators and expert witnesses, to comment on draft pleadings, to assist in the creation of the damages theory, to consult on potential settlement and to manage spending and performance against budget.

Burford devotes meaningful resources to managing our capital provision assets and working collaboratively to improve their value. Our interest is aligned with our counterparties in an effort to maximize value. While our counterparties are generally [email protected] www.burfordcapital.com not obliged to follow our advice, there is a clear alignment of interest that makes our advice valuable to our counterparties and worthy of serious consideration. In short, we normally do not have decision making authority in a contractual sense, such that we can actually veto a decision by a counterparty; rather, we have active engagement that makes us a valued and influential advisor to the litigation team.

We do note that there are some exceptions to the foregoing discussion when we are specifically contracted to assume some control of a litigation matter or the underlying asset. In those instances, we have control over the conduct of the litigation matter subject to whatever contractual terms have been agreed.

As to costs incurred, when we are providing capital over time to meet the costs of pursuing the litigation matter, as is often the case, we track and manage spend to ensure that the costs being sought are consistent with an agreed budget and the progress of the case, and we generally have various rights with respect to those costs, such as declining to provide capital in excess of agreed budgets or in excess of an agreed total or withholding capital in the event of a materially negative change in the prospects of the litigation matter.

Read in the reply
Consolidated statements of cash flows, page 80
SEC asked (2)
We note in your cash flows from operating activities you include a subtotal for net cash provided by/(used in) operating activities before funding of capital provision assets and net (funding of)/proceeds from marketable securities.
Rest of the question

Please tell us why you believe presenting a total other than net cash provided by (used in) operating activities is consistent with the Form and Content guidance provided in ASC Subtopic 230-10-45. Tell us how you concluded this was not a non-GAAP financial measure, which would be prohibited from inclusion in the financial statements under Item 10(e)(1)(ii)(C) of Regulation S-K.

BUR answered
While we believe the subtotal is helpful to investors in understanding the cash flows of our business, we will revise our presentation of cash flows from operating activities in future periodic filings to remove the subtotal for net cash provided by/(used in) operating activities before funding of capital provision assets and net (funding of)/proceeds from marketable securities.

Note 2: Summary of significant accounting policies

Fair value hierarchy

Valuation processes

Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85

Before turning to the Staff’s specific questions, we thought some
Rest of the answer

broader context would be useful.

Burford was founded more than 13 years ago. Its founders had been engaged in legal finance for some preceding years, making them among the pioneers of this asset class. Since Burford’s founding, it has grown into the clear market leader, providing billions of dollars of legal finance around the world with a team approaching 150 people who rival a leading law firm in terms of litigation experience and breadth. Indeed, Burford has already recovered almost $2 billion in cash proceeds from litigation matters and is one of the largest purchasers of legal services in the world.

As part of that history, Burford has an extraordinary amount of data and experience about complex commercial litigation, and we put those data to work in our investment and valuation processes. Our approach to asset valuation has been consistent for our entire existence and focuses on objective litigation events, which we believe to be the best expression of fair value in this unique asset class. While we explain below our methodology and its consistency with the relevant accounting principles, we would also be pleased to continue our ongoing dialogue with the Staff on this topic.

We also note that this is unlikely to be a static approach but rather one which has evolved over time and continues to do so. This is a young asset class and every passing year brings more sophistication, larger pools of data and more analytics around them and increased capital flows.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (3)
ASC Topic 820 defines market participant as a buyer that is knowledgeable, having a reasonable understanding about the asset and the transaction using all available information that might be obtained through due diligence efforts that are usual and customary.
Rest of the question

As it relates to the valuation of your capital provision assets, please tell us: • the information you obtain and consider as part of your due diligence process to determine the amount you will agree to pay to acquire contractual rights to litigation settlements or amounts receivable under court judgments; determine whether you should increase the amount you pay to acquire additional contractual rights to litigation settlements or amounts receivable under court judgments for cases (or pools of cases) in which you already have investments; • whether you believe gathering and considering the information you consider would not be usual and customary for a knowledgeable party to obtain to have a reasonable understanding of the price that party would pay to acquire the right under the contracts you enter into, and if not why not; and • whether you view yourself as a market participant, and if not why not.

BUR answered
Many of Burford’s capital provision assets relate to litigation matters that are at the beginning of the litigation process, and thus Burford’s diligence is in aid of the effort to attempt to predict how a court will ultimately decide the case. Not only is there not a judicial decision to consider as part of that process, but often we do not even know which judge has been assigned to the case or even which court the case will be filed in. Thus, we are reliant on non-judicial inputs to our diligence.
Rest of the answer

Sometimes, however, we are providing capital in connection with cases that have advanced through the process and obtained various judicial rulings, and perhaps have even already succeeded at trial in obtaining a judgment. When that occurs, then our diligence pivots to considering those judicial inputs as by far the most significant factors in our consideration.

When Burford begins substantive discussions with a potential counterparty about providing capital in connection with a litigation claim, a first step is to execute a non-disclosure agreement that extends relevant legal privileges to Burford and enables us to receive confidential material that is legally privileged and/or protected from disclosure by the attorney work product doctrine (together referred to here as “privileged” material). There is clear law protecting a litigant’s legal privilege from waiver – the risk of the material losing its privileged status because of its disclosure to a third party – in such circumstances. Any waiver of legal privilege would be an extremely serious matter with real detriment to the litigant.

Burford then conducts extensive diligence. That diligence has three main areas of focus: (i) the merits of the claim determined by the rigorous application of the law to the developed facts; (ii) the damages that could be awarded on the claim in an adjudication as well as the realistic settlement value of the matter were it to be resolved without adjudication; and (iii) the enforceability of an ultimate judgment or award, including consideration of credit risk as to both our counterparty and the litigation defendant.

Burford’s diligence is tailored to the facts and circumstances of each case. For example, in a breach of contract case, we focus on the language of the contract and the specific facts relating to the argument of the breach; in a patent case, we focus on the validity and infringement of the patent; and in a competition case, we focus on the market dynamics and the elements of monopolization.

However, constants in Burford’s diligence are the privileged assessments of the case by the client’s outside counsel; the key primary documents and witness evidence; and financial and economic analyses. The Burford team engages in extensive interaction with the litigant and its counsel on all of these issues as well as the economics of a potential provision of capital. Depending on the case, other diligence will occur: in a patent case, we may tear down or reverse engineer a product; in a fact-dependent case, we may conduct witness interviews or mock cross-examinations; in a case with enforcement risk, we may do preliminary work on the location and quality of assets. We regularly engage with technical and economic experts. We also consider the quality of the lawyers proposed to take the case forward.

An integral part of this process is arriving at an appropriate economic arrangement with our counterparty. That is, the outcome of our diligence will determine the amount we are willing to pay to acquire the contractual rights to litigation settlements or amounts receivable under court judgments. We believe it is relevant to observe that our economic terms are also protected by legal privilege, as they disclose our evaluation of the case which is based in part on legally privileged material.

On average, it takes three months of diligence to go from initial contact to closing.

We believe Burford’s due diligence and underwriting efforts described above, including execution of a non-disclosure agreement and access to privileged information, are generally consistent with those performed by other market participants in connection with evaluation of initial capital provision opportunities, albeit with Burford having more experience, scale and resources than many other market participants. In contrast to the secondary market for capital provision assets (discussed below), there is a competitive market for initial capital provision opportunities and should we be competing against one or more other capital providers for the opportunity, we would expect all of those competitors to have general parity of information from the counterparty at the stage of the initial capital provision transaction because the counterparty is incentivized to provide that information to enable a transaction.

The approach described above relates to litigation matters at their inception, without any meaningful progress through the adjudicative process and thus without objective adjudicative events in the case; to the extent we consider matters as to which there is already substantive adjudicative progress, we consider the outcomes of objective adjudicative events as a predominant part of our investment process. In other words, court decisions always trump our own assessments; for example, if we finance an appeal of a trial court judgment, by far the most important element of our diligence is the trial court’s ruling.

● the information you obtain and consider as part of your due diligence process to determine whether you should increase the amount you pay to acquire additional contractual rights to litigation settlements or amounts receivable under court judgments for cases (or pools of cases) in which you already have investments;

It is unusual for Burford to acquire additional rights in litigation matters following our original capital provision agreement, although it can happen from time to time. As requested, we discuss that eventuality below, but this is not ordinary course of business for Burford.

When Burford agrees to provide capital to cover the ongoing legal fees and expenses of a litigation matter, we typically agree up-front to a certain level of capital to be provided over time and generally pursuant to a budget provided by the litigant’s law firm. Then, as the matter progresses, Burford makes periodic payments pursuant to that agreement, which also provides for Burford’s ultimate return if the matter is successful. Burford is generally contractually obliged to make those payments. In other words, Burford is not re-underwriting or re-diligencing the matter at the time of making each payment; we are simply making those payments consistent with a pre-existing contractual obligation.

Burford does have in many of its agreements the ability to cease providing capital mid-way through a matter if there has been a material negative change in the merits of the case, but that is a right exercised extremely rarely, both because it would be injurious to Burford’s reputation in the marketplace should it be seen to be withdrawing support for pending litigation and also because cases that develop material weaknesses tend to be resolved by settlement rather than pursued through adjudication.

In those unusual instances where a commitment of additional capital is sought in an ongoing matter (perhaps because events in the case have caused the budget to be exceeded or perhaps because the counterparty is seeking further capital for other purposes), Burford re-underwrites the matter consistent with the discussion of its underwriting and diligence process above. Were we to find ourselves in this situation, Burford would expect to negotiate new economic terms for the entire matter; we do not tend to have multiple tranches of capital committed to the same matter with differing economic terms.

● whether you believe gathering and considering the information you consider would not be usual and customary for a knowledgeable party to obtain to have a reasonable understanding of the price that party would pay to acquire the right under the contracts you enter into, and if not why not; and

As described above, in connection with an initial provision of capital to counterparties, Burford believes it would be usual and customary for any knowledgeable competitor to obtain the kind of information, including legally privileged information, previously discussed.

However, the situation is very different when it comes to secondary market transactions, whether actual (of which there are very few) or hypothetical, and is inextricably intertwined with unique issues around legal privilege.

Legal privilege belongs to the client, not to the lawyer (or to Burford). It is not in a client’s interest to provide third parties with access to privileged material, both because of the risk of legal waiver discussed above and because the fewer people who have access to sensitive information about large dollar commercial litigation the better from a client’s perspective. Thus, the practical reality is that a client is very unlikely to consent to the sharing of its privileged information with a potential buyer of Burford’s contract rights; there is absolutely no incentive for a client to do so, and every reason not to. Thus, while a hypothetical secondary market buyer would doubtless like to have access to the same privileged information that Burford does, and in a world unconstrained by issues of legal privilege we believe it would be usual and customary for a knowledgeable party to obtain and consider that information, the reality is that it will generally not be able to; as a result, there are very few secondary market transactions in this asset class.

Instead, secondary market buyers need to rely on public information to engage in secondary transactions – namely, judicial decisions. For example, Burford was able to effect several secondary market sales of a portion of its contractual rights in a case without providing buyers with any privileged information because there were strong court decisions available publicly and the underlying matter turns on questions of law as opposed to disputed facts.

● whether you view yourself as a market participant, and if not why not.

Yes, Burford views itself as a market participant in both the initial capital provision market and, to the extent one exists, for purposes of the very limited secondary market for capital provision assets.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (4)
ASC 820-10-35 requires that the fair value measurement as of the reporting date use the assumptions that a market participant would use in pricing the assets, acting in their economic best interest. In your period end fair value measurements of your capital provision assets, please describe all of the significant observable and unobservable inputs that you assume a market participant would use to estimate the price
Rest of the question

they would pay as of that date for your capital provision assets. If you do not base your assumed market participant assumptions on relevant data available to you, tell us why you believe not incorporating this data is consistent with the guidance in ASC 820-10-35-54A that states that, “A reporting entity shall develop unobservable inputs using the best information available in the circumstances, which might include the reporting entity's own data.”

BUR answered
There are typically no significant observable level 1 or 2 inputs as defined in ASC 820 that Burford uses, or assumes a market participant would use, in the valuation of the capital provision assets. The valuation of capital provision assets typically relies entirely on unobservable level 3 inputs.

At the closing of the initial funding of a capital provision asset, given that Burford and its counterparty are at arm’s length and both have access to available information (as would any other market participant seeking to initially acquire the capital provision asset), the transaction price
Rest of the answer

prioritizes privileged information, in the absence of objective adjudicative events, and reflects fair value at the time of closing.

For purposes of subsequently measuring a capital provision asset, pursuant to ASC 820-10-35-54A, the principal unobservable input Burford relies upon are the occurrence of significant objective adjudicative events at various stages of the litigation process. By far the most significant input in litigation is a court decision, whether final or interlocutory. Thus, we prioritize consideration of court decisions, just as we believe any market participant would.

While we have access to a variety of other data (including privileged information) about pending litigation, it is unusual for those data to be material to our – or a market participant’s – view about the litigation prognosis or value in comparison to objective adjudicative events; the privileged information is simply considerably less predictive and reliable than adjudicative events. In the occasional event when that does occur, our valuation policy contains a proviso to address circumstances where we do not believe that objective adjudicative events are alone a satisfactory outcome. The policy language reads as follows:

While it is expected that the foregoing policies will address the considerable majority of situations that arise, litigation and its legal and factual underpinnings are varied and idiosyncratic, and there will inevitably be a small number of situations with unique factual and legal dynamics that will not fit neatly into the foregoing policies and where the rote application of those policies would lead to an untoward result. In such cases the company will document the inapplicability of the foregoing policies to the asset at hand and endeavor to arrive at the valuation it believes appropriately captures the essence of the overall valuation policy and approach to financial reporting, and will report on such instances separately in its disclosures.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (5)
ASC 820-10-35-24A describes three valuation approaches, the market approach, cost approach, and income approach. Please tells us whether the valuation technique you use to fair value your capital provision assets is consistent with one or more of these approaches, and if so the basis for your determination.
Rest of the question

If you used an income approach, please clarify how you specifically considered the expected timing of payments in applying the guidance in ASC 820-10 55-3F which states: “The income approach converts future amounts (for example, cash flows or income and expenses) to a single current (that is, discounted) amount.”

BUR answered
Burford has adopted a valuation approach that is consistent with the principles of the income approach in accordance with ASC 820-10-35-24A. Burford’s valuation policy identifies each event (generally an adjudicative decision) in each type of litigation process, the outcome of which objectively indicates whether the underlying case is more or less likely to result in a favorable outcome.

Each stage of the various litigation processes has an uncertain duration as well as an uncertain outcome, including how many stages may be needed to get to a final outcome.
Rest of the answer

Moreover, litigation matters often settle during the course of the litigation process, and those settlements can occur unexpectedly and without regard to time but are instead more likely to be precipitated by a court decision or other adjudicative event. Unlike many types of financial assets, because of the degree of uncertainty and unpredictability of litigation duration, time and duration do not play as meaningful a role in this asset class, just as legal contingency fees are generally expressed as a fixed percentage without regard to time.

Thus, the value of the asset does not become higher as each day passes in the lead-up to the next litigation event which would be the outcome if a more traditional discounting method were applied where an adjustment would be recognized purely for the passage of time. The discount is instead reassessed and reset on each date when there is an applicable litigation event which is considered to be the date on which there is a change in the current market expectations about the future amounts that may be payable on the asset. It is our view that a knowledgeable market participant would not pay more for a capital provision asset on the day before the next litigation event may be due to occur than they would pay the day following the previous litigation event. Therefore, in accordance with ASC 820-10-55-3F, our fair value measurement approach therefore reflects current market expectations about those future amounts.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (6)
Please tell us whether you consider the price you pay to acquire a capital provision asset to be fair value, and if so how you calibrate your valuation technique, consistent with the guidance in ASC 820-10-35-24C, such that the initial recognition of your valuation technique equals your transaction price.
BUR answered
When we originate a new asset as a transaction between two arm’s length parties in a competitive principal market, we consider the purchase price, whether deployed at close or over time, to represent fair value. As set out above in our response to question 3, the Company undertakes an extensive diligence process for each new asset that includes an in-depth understanding of the underlying risks and an extensive negotiation to arrive at a commensurate market-based return profile that the holder of the asset is then contingently entitled to.

The Company’s valuation technique cannot incorporate
Rest of the answer

a calibration to an initial fair value as would typically be performed for other asset types such as, for an example, assets designed to earn a lender’s return based on credit and prepayment risks. The Company’s technique relies on the identification of observable events on the occurrence of which either (i) a percentage of asset cost is recognized as a fair value loss, or (ii) a percentage of the expected profit is recognized as a fair value gain and added to the cost of the asset.

Burford reassesses the appropriateness of the percentage valuation changes to be recognized on the occurrence of objectively identifiable litigation events, as well as the identification of those events on at least an annual basis. Changes or adjustments to the valuation policy may also be made on a more frequent basis if and when relevant information becomes available. The reassessment of the Company’s valuation technique is underpinned by tracking the individual performance of each asset in the portfolio through its full life cycle. This includes, and is not limited to, the underlying litigation process, timing of deployments and recoveries, and the progression of fair value to final resolution. The data, also aggregated by asset vintage and asset type, is used by management to monitor and assess the appropriate granularity of litigation events by asset types and the percentages to be applied in each instance.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (1)
We acknowledge your response to prior comment 5 and our discussion on January 4, 2023 where you stated your valuation approach is consistent with the principles of the income approach, as described in ASC 820-10-35-24A.
Rest of the question

As it relates to the initial valuation of your capital provision assets, please respond to the following: • Tell us whether when determining the terms you are willing to offer for contractual rights to litigation settlements or court judgments, you perform a probability-based outcome analysis of potential cash outflows to be received under the proposed terms that explicitly applies a discount rate to take into consideration the differences in timing of the potential cash flows. For example, tell us whether your methodology discounts for time value the potential cash inflows that would come from a future litigation settlement based on the expected timing of such a settlement or stage of litigation, and if so, provide a representative example of how this is done. • Tell us whether any probability-based outcome analysis you perform when deciding to enter into a capital provision rights agreement can be reconciled to the initial purchase price paid for the capital provision asset. If not, tell us why not. • In response to prior comment 3, you stated that you are a market participant under ASC Topic 820. To the extent you consider the impact of the time value of money in determining the terms for entering into a capital provision rights agreement, tell us whether you believe there would be any basis for not considering changes to the time value of money (for example, market interest rate changes) on the fair value of the capital provision assets each reporting period. • Tell us whether you factor in other potential risks, such as credit risk or foreign exchange risk, in determining the terms you would offer to initially acquire a capital provision asset, or in subsequent fair value measurements. If not, tell us why you do not believe a marketplace participant would consider this information.

BUR answered
[email protected] www.burfordcapital.com

When determining the terms we are willing to offer for contractual rights to litigation settlements or court judgments, we do not use a discount rate for cash flows given the highly uncertain and unpredictable nature of the duration of individual litigation matters. Rather, we arrive at our commercial terms based on our assessment of litigation risk as well as the competitive dynamic at issue. Moreover, our terms usually contain a time-based element which protects our returns in the event of a long duration outcome.
Rest of the answer

We perform initial probabilistic modeling to ensure that, under all realistic scenarios when resolution could occur, we maintain our expected returns given the proposed terms and based on the litigation risk we assess.

The primary driver of pricing in the legal finance industry is the risk of loss of the capital deployed. The offer of litigation finance is generally non-recourse. In other words, if the litigation does not produce any proceeds, the counterparty owes nothing to us as the capital provider and there is a total loss of the capital deployed. Because there is an inherent unpredictability in each outcome given that each matter is before a different decision-making tribunal each time, there is material risk of loss in every capital provision asset of the entire capital deployed.

In addition to litigation risk, our terms are generally influenced by general perceptions of duration, even though they are likely to be inaccurate at an individual level. For example, we will generally seek higher pricing (whether through an increased multiple and/or a higher back-end share of proceeds) for an international arbitration matter at the World Bank than for a commercial case in US Federal court, because the former is likely to take much longer than the latter, even though there are meaningful differences among individual jurists or tribunals. Nonetheless, those differences in pricing are expressed in blunt terms, such as in different multiples of capital, rather than applying the impact of a time-based discount rate. On the other hand, we would generally not seek different pricing for the same case being brought in US Federal court in the Northern District of Florida, which on average has a very fast docket (12 months at present), or in US Federal court in the Eastern District of New York, which on average has a very slow docket (54 months at present), because our particular case in front of our particular judge may not perform anywhere close to those averages; indeed, we regularly price matters without knowing which court they will be filed in. Further, the annual interest-style rates applied in our deal structure (see below) have not increased from prior levels despite the recent higher interest rate environment.

Said another way, in assessing how to price a particular capital provision asset, we do not discount cash flows or create a net present value; rather, we use deal structures that produce varying results depending on duration with a focus on internal rate of return (“IRR”) and return on invested capital and we satisfy ourselves that we will generate an acceptable return under any set of likely durations and outcomes other than a loss. For example, it would be common for us to structure a deal as follows:

o First, the return of deployed capital;

o Second, a multiple of that deployed capital beginning at 1.0x and rising by 0.5x per annum to a cap of 2.5x, and an annual interest-style rate thereafter (with the rate being set based on risk and negotiating leverage); and o Third, a 15% share of net proceeds.

This kind of structure recognizes the potential for significant variability in a case’s duration and essentially compensates us for accepting that duration risk; it also makes it inapplicable for us to consider a traditional discount rate approach in our modeling when determining the terms we are willing to offer.

We note that our approach to pricing our initial terms in a capital provision rights agreement is consistent with the enormous US contingency fee market, which often does not vary the level of contingent fee based on duration. For example, a comprehensive study of contingent fees in New York across almost 300,000 cases determined that “[a]ttorneys’ fees were exactly one-third of net recovery in most cases”, without any allowance for the duration of the case’s resolution1.

● Tell us whether any probability-based outcome analysis you perform when deciding to enter into a capital provision rights agreement can be reconciled to the initial purchase price paid for the capital provision asset. If not, tell us why not.

We have not historically performed a reconciliation or calibration of our probabilistic models to the transaction price for the capital provision assets as the models are not designed for, or used in, our assessment of fair value. The purpose of our probabilistic models is to estimate likely recoveries and at what point in a litigation or arbitration recoveries could be achieved. Indeed, we do not apply a discount rate to the output of our models given the challenges associated with predicting litigation duration as discussed above and, when we publish the aggregate output of our probabilistic models, we make it clear that we are only providing that output on a nominal, and not a present-valued, basis. The starting point of our modeling is our entry into the relevant transaction, and we compute probabilistic-weighted profits from that starting point. Moreover, our probabilistic models are already risk-weighted and thus any appropriate discounting of their outputs if undertaken would initially appear to be at a risk-free rate. Discounting our probability weighted outcomes at a risk-free rate (or our weighted average cost of capital) would yield a higher value at the time of transacting than the initial purchase price paid.

An example may assist. While our actual probabilistic models are more complex than this, assume that we assign probabilities to a case losing, settling and winning. The probabilistic model’s output (which is its probability weighted computation of those three outcomes) is thus already reflecting the risk of obtaining the output. While we could then discount that output back using a risk-free rate for purposes of time value of money, or even consider the application of a discount rate that includes a factor for our cost of capital, it would not be appropriate to add a further risk premium into the discount rate as the model output has already been reduced for risk.

Were we to repurpose our probabilistic models for fair value purposes and calibrate the modeled outcome to the initial purchase price, we could theoretically do so by solving for a discount rate that would result in a net present value of the probabilistic model cash flows that equals the initial purchase price. However, an analysis for purposes of responding to this letter suggests that such implied discount rates would generally be 30% or higher. This is not surprising given that the Company has historically generated returns of around 30% IRR across its portfolio.

The Company has prepared an illustration of how the calibration would theoretically work on a simplified but representative example of one of the Company’s capital provision assets that is based on the following basic assumptions:

● Initial upfront funding of $10 million and no further funding is provided; and

● The Company is entitled to its deployed capital back plus a 2.5x multiple return payable only out of any proceeds successfully realized from the underlying litigation event.

At the capital provision asset’s inception, the implied discount rate to solve for a present value of the probabilistic model’s expected cash flows that is equal to the transaction price is 31.9%. The illustration then further assumes the following occurs during the uncertain path and duration of the litigation to arrive at an ultimately successful outcome:

1 Eric Helland, Daniel Klerman, Brendan Dowling, and Alexander Kappner, Contingent Fee Litigation in New York City, 70 Vanderbilt Law Review 1971 (2017).

● Inception to March 31, 2022 – there are no adjudicative events and no revisions to any model assumptions during this period. The inputs for the probabilistic model and fair value for the capital provision asset remain unchanged.

● April 1, 2022 to June 30, 2022 – an adjudicative event occurs in the form of a trial win and an award issued in favor of Burford’s counterparty. Both the probabilistic model and the fair value of the capital provision asset are updated to reflect this event, the latter recognizes 60% of the expect profit.

● July 1, 2022 to September 30, 2022 - there are no adjudicative events and no revisions to any model assumptions during this period. The inputs to the probabilistic model and fair value for the capital provision asset remain unchanged.

● October 1, 2022 to December 31, 2022 – an adjudicative event occurs in the form of confirmation that the Burford’s counterparty’s adversary’s as-of rights to appeal the outcome have lapsed. Both the probabilistic model and the fair value of the capital provision asset are updated to reflect this event, the latter now recognizes 80% of the expect profit.

● January 1, 2023 to March 31, 2023 – the cash is settled during this period.

The graph below illustrates the calibration at inception and then how the fair values implied by the calibrated model would compare to the Company’s assessment of fair value under the current valuation policy following these assumed events.

The results demonstrate the significant difference in fair values resulting from the approach based on a calibrated discounted cash flow model versus the approach the Company, and a market participant, would employ to assess the price they would pay to acquire the capital provision asset in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date. This is because the fair values derived from the former approach would imply that a market participant would be willing to pay significantly more for a capital provision asset as it approaches each adjudicative event simply because of the passage of time at a robust discount rate, even though nothing more is known about the likelihood of the outcome of that adjudicative event and there remains continuing uncertainty over the timing of when it may be known. This is not the case in practice; using the above example, Burford could not sell a capital provision asset for 30% more than its initial purchase price after a year simply because of the passage of time if no adjudicative event had occurred in the interim. This is why we do not believe using our probabilistic modeling for valuation purposes at this stage of its evolution is appropriate.

● In response to prior comment 3, you stated that you are a market participant under ASC Topic 820. To the extent you consider the impact of the time value of money in determining the terms for entering into a capital provision rights agreement, tell us whether you believe there would be any basis for not considering changes to the time value of money (for example, market interest rate changes) on the fair value of the capital provision assets each reporting period.

Refer in general to response in bullet 1.

● Tell us whether you factor in other potential risks, such as credit risk or foreign exchange risk, in determining the terms you would offer to initially acquire a capital provision asset, or in subsequent fair value measurements. If not, tell us why you do not believe a marketplace participant would consider this information.

Litigation outcomes stand apart from the remainder of the conventional credit universe because they do not arise as a result of a contractual relationship between the judgment debtor and creditor, unlike essentially all other forms of credit obligation. Thus, for example, for a debtholder to recover on a defaulted debt, there are many steps involving notice, a cure period, usually a subsequent judicial or insolvency proceeding that will generally sweep in other creditors and a meaningful risk of the debt being impaired or compromised. By contrast, a judgment creditor has immediate and unfettered rights of action to, for example, seize assets and garnish cash flows. Thus, conventional debt metrics like a decline in credit ratings or a decrease in debt pricing do not generally read across to litigation collection outcomes.

Moreover, foreign exchange risk is often dealt with in the damages phase of a case. For example, if a US company is damaged because of some interaction with, say, a Chinese company, the US company’s damages will be computed in terms of its US dollar losses, and if the Renminbi has depreciated in the interim, that will be something taken into account in computing those damages. Additionally, where we invest in a capital provision asset outside of the USA (or when the investment is denominated in other than USD), at each reporting period, the investment value in local currency is translated into USD at the then spot rate (an exit price).

Above we described that it is litigation risk that fundamentally drives the initial terms of our transactions. To the extent that this question asks about financial risks other than that litigation risk, those are generally binary decisions as to whether to proceed as opposed to being relevant factors in setting those initial terms. For example, if we believe that there is a significant risk of a defendant not being able to pay a judgment or a settlement, we will decline to enter into a financing transaction as opposed to increasing the price of that transaction. Similarly, we believe that other market participants will look to adjudicative outcomes instead of market sentiment changes in a judgment debtor’s credit position.

Below is an example in which we financed litigation against an operating company that went through a period of financial distress. The case against the defendant was very strong and the fundamental question was just the quantum of damages. During the course of the legal proceeding, the defendant became distressed and its debt traded down sharply. However, we won the case and obtained an enforceable judgment. Notwithstanding the decline in the defendant’s fortunes, because we had an independently and immediately enforceable judgment – in that we could simply begin seizing assets and garnishing bank accounts – we were able to achieve the complete recovery of our deployed capital at once because we had a very different level of leverage over the judgment debtor than its debtholders did. Despite the change in trading levels of the defendant’s debt, we would not have considered ourselves necessarily affected by that change in circumstance and would not necessarily have written down our asset value, a decision vindicated by the outcome, nor do we believe that other market participants would have looked to the defendant’s debt pricing had we offered our position for sale.

Of course, there are some rare circumstances where this does not work out – for example, when we have achieved a victory but in the interim the defendant has actually entered bankruptcy or insolvency proceedings. In such an event, we would of course adjust our carrying value. We had one such example some years ago where our position was subordinate to a senior debt stack that became insolvent, and we wrote off the entire deployed capital for fair value purposes some years before we crystallized our actual loss. But those events are rare in litigation generally and in our portfolio specifically.

We believe that other market participants would approach these issues in the same way as we do.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (2)
To the extent that a capital provision rights agreement can be resolved by a court judgment that includes additional compensation for time value, please tell us whether you reflect the potential increase in cash inflows to be received under a court judgement in your fair value estimate as of each measurement period. If so, tell us how you reflect this potential increase in cash flows in your fair value estimate.
Rest of the question

If not, tell us why not.

BUR answered
We reflect preor post-judgment interest in our fair value estimates when a judgment or award has been issued that confirms whether interest is being awarded and the terms on which that interest should be calculated (e.g., the applicable periods and components of damages it should apply to are often contested). When interest is reflected in a fair value estimate, the calculated amount is included in the estimate of proceeds on which the applicable percentage fair value adjustment is based at the measurement date.
Rest of the answer

This calculation is refreshed at each subsequent reporting date to incorporate the applicable amount of additional interest that will have accrued during that period in the fair value estimate at the new measurement date.

We do not take preor post-judgment interest into account in calculating our fair value estimates prior to it being affirmed in a judgment or award. This is consistent with market practice in the conduct of litigation and settlement, which is what determines what we or any other market participant would pay for a litigation asset. While interest may technically accrue in the background of a litigation matter, that interest is often not relevant in the cash payment made to resolve the matter. Accordingly, we do not believe a market participant would ‘price in’ such an accrued interest amount were they to acquire our investment from us prior to interest being affirmed in a judgment or award.

An illustration may assist to provide further context. Assume a simple litigation matter for ease: a traffic accident that caused $10,000 in property damage. If that case were to go all the way to trial and win, then the court would award $10,000 in damages plus pre-judgment interest at the applicable rate (9% in Washington, DC) from the date of the accident to the date of the court judgment. And if the defendant were to appeal, post-judgment interest would run at the applicable rate (6% in Washington, DC) from the day after the judgment until the matter was finally paid.

However, the reality of US litigation is that the odds of that case actually going to trial are infinitesimally small. Instead, the case will settle. And it will almost certainly settle for somewhat less than $10,000. Moreover, when that settlement is being negotiated, the fact that interest is theoretically running will not make any difference to the settlement amount. For example, if the defendant makes a settlement offer to the plaintiff, that offer will be for a sum certain, such as $8,000; it will not include any concept of interest. And if the plaintiff takes a month to consider the offer and then accept it, the $8,000 will not go up by a month of interest, nor will the $8,000 go up if the defendant takes another month to send the check.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to prior comment 4 where you provided your policy to consider whether there are situations that arise, outside of an adjudicative event, that result in a change to the estimated fair value of one of your capital provision assets.
Rest of the question

Please respond to the following: • Describe the procedures you put in place to determine when the price that a market participant would pay to purchase one of your capital provision assets would change, outside of an adjudicative event. • Provide an example of how this policy was applied in one of these situations, and the procedures performed to determine the appropriate fair value. • Describe the documentation you maintain to support your determination that events outside of adjudicative events do not have a material impact on the fair value of your capital provision assets.

BUR answered
The Company engages in ongoing real-time monitoring of the litigation matters in its portfolio. It does so by accessing public docket filings and reviewing the substance of court filings and decisions as well as receiving regular reporting from its clients about the progress of cases and engages in active oversight of those matters. We also monitor non-litigation-related matters relevant to a specific asset, which can include matters of credit or financial position or even systemic issues such as, for example, the war in Ukraine or the impact of the pandemic.
Rest of the answer

That monitoring feeds into a disciplined process of capturing and rolling up individual case feedback to senior management, which includes a number of components such as real time reporting of significant developments, monthly reporting about the status of every matter complete with commentary from the responsible case manager and quarterly board of directors and management reporting and review and, if necessary, revision of our probabilistic risk modeling on a case-by-case basis.

When assessing the price that a market participant would pay to purchase one of our capital provision assets and the estimated fair value of our capital provision assets in accordance with our valuation policy, management considers, as one of our management review controls, whether any information outside of an adjudicative event exists resulting from the above procedures that must be evaluated as possibly triggering the exception clause in the valuation policy. This process is a fundamental part of our business and an integral part of our internal control framework that we test and certify each year under our reporting requirements pursuant to Section 404(a) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, as amended.

● Provide an example of how this policy was applied in one of these situations, and the procedures performed to determine the appropriate fair value.

Virtually every development in a litigation matter has only speculative value outside of an adjudicative event. For example, we may review deposition testimony and feel either enthusiastic or despondent about it, but the actual impact of that testimony is very difficult to predict absent an actual adjudicative event. Thus, we do not rely on our sentiment to adjust a valuation based on our emotive reaction to such a development. We also do not believe that all market participants would have the same reaction to these kinds of developments and indeed reactions may vary extremely widely. Moreover, also as discussed, very significant non-adjudicative developments would be expected to lead to settlement of a matter in short order.

That said, our valuation policy envisages there being, from time-to-time, developments of such significance in a case that they would affect its market value regardless of an adjudicative event. This is likely to be a rare event, but an example would be a case dependent on testimony from a company’s chief executive officer who we discover to be a fraud – having lied about his credentials, engaged in fraud and dismissed by the company’s board of directors. In such an event, we would take the view that a market participant would pay less than our carrying value for our interest in the case and we would make use of the exception clause in our valuation policy to reduce the carrying value of that matter notwithstanding the absence of an adjudicative event. Happily, however, that is a hypothetical factual situation and we have not experienced such an event thus far in our existence.

Indeed, the application of the exception clause in the valuation policy in the past has been infrequent to date with only one or two instances per year. An example of its application relates to a fair value adjustment the Company recognized on a matter that had reached an agreement in principle to a settlement at a reporting period end. An agreement in principle to a settlement is not an identified adjudicative event in the valuation policy, only an executed settlement agreement is considered an adjudicative event. However, the facts and circumstances regarding the agreement in principle to a settlement, representing a situation outside of a non-adjudicative event, were identified and reported through the procedures set out in the response to bullet 1 above to be evaluated as possibly triggering the exception clause in the valuation policy.

The facts of the matter, including a quantitative analysis of the expected impact to fair value, were assessed by management and reviewed by the valuation committee. The conclusion reached supported the application of the exception clause to recognize a fair value adjustment based on the proposed terms of the settlement agreement as there was a preponderance of available evidence indicating that a market participant would view the execution of the settlement agreement with sufficient certainty for it to form the basis of assessing the price that the market participant would be willing to pay to acquire the asset.

● Describe the documentation you maintain to support your determination that events outside of adjudicative events do not have a material impact on the fair value of your capital provision assets.

In terms of documentation, we maintain contemporaneous information in our case management database, which includes both inputs and assessments from case managers as well as importing other information such as court docket information as described in the response to bullet 1 above. This data also forms the supporting basis for the monthly and quarterly reporting as further referenced in that response.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (4)
We note your response to prior comment 6 where you described a technique that relies on the identification of observable events that result in a percent of an asset’s cost being recognized as a fair value loss or the percentage of the expected profit being recognized as a fair value gain.
Rest of the question

Please respond to the following: • Describe the analysis you use to develop the percentages you apply to an asset’s cost for a particular observable event to determine the amount of fair value loss. • For fair value gains recognized, tell us how you develop the expected profit and the related percentage to be applied for each material type of return you earn on your capital provision assets (for example, time based returns, multiple of funded capital, percentage of net realization, etc.). • Outline for us the various groupings of capital provision assets for which you have developed expected profit or loss percentages. Describe to us how you have grouped these assets together, including your considerations related to the asset vintage, asset type, case jurisdiction and adjudicative events. • Discuss how frequently you have revised the percentages applied using this technique, and what the driver of the revisions would be. When percentages are revised, tell us whether these updated percentages are applied to existing expected case outcomes at the next valuation date. • To the extent you believe the percentages applied under this policy capture the expected time horizon for recovery, tell us how. In addition, tell us how you considered events impacting the expected time horizon of resolution such as delays due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

BUR answered
To develop the percentage markups or markdowns to apply to an asset for each particular observable event, we review the lifecycle of the typical litigations and arbitrations in which we deploy capital. Each kind of case has a typical set of milestones until resolution. The observable events to which we ascribe fair value marks are publicly known stages of progress of litigation and arbitration to resolution (further details are included in the response to bullet 3 below). In order to proceed to successful resolution, milestones must be achieved.
Rest of the answer

So we will mark up an asset if the case overcomes a given milestone and mark down an asset if the case does not succeed at a given milestone.

We arrived at percentages associated with each milestone based on what, given our experience, judgment, data and back-testing, we consider success or loss at that stage is worth in terms of what we believe a market participant would pay at that stage for our asset. However, as we have noted, there is not yet a robust secondary market to validate our assumptions.

Our valuation policy is clear about how we determine the expected profit factor for the application of those percentages. When we are entitled to an outcome tied to the capital we have deployed or some other fixed measurement (e.g., a rising multiple or a fixed IRR), we apply the valuation policy’s percentage to the amount we are due. For example, if we are entitled to 2.0x our deployed capital, we will apply the percentage to that 2.0x return. When we are entitled to a portion of the case’s recovery, such as 25% of the damages awarded, we will look to either the agreed damages or a reasonable expectation of those damages based on the case’s record, which will include data such as expert damages reports. This calculation is refreshed each reporting period to account for incremental changes in fair value due to changes in expected profit due to Burford arising from (i) any additional funding provided, (ii) the occurrence of a time-based step-up in multiple or change to the percentage of proceeds to which we are entitled, (iii) a running interest rate that is part of our entitlement, and/or (iv) an increase in the expected proceeds (such as through the accrual of preor post-judgment interest if awarded).

● Outline for us the various groupings of capital provision assets for which you have developed expected profit or loss percentages. Describe to us how you have grouped these assets together, including your considerations related to the asset vintage, asset type, case jurisdiction and adjudicative events.

The Company’s valuation policy and matrix of litigation events consists of five main groupings of capital provision assets which are defined as follows:

1. US Commercial

2. Patent

3. Arbitration

4. Non-US Commercial a. Antitrust / competition matters b. Other than antitrust / competition matters

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (5)
We note that the June 2022 (slide 9) and November 2022 (slide 12) Investor Presentations available on your website include disclosure of the implied cash realizations that you would receive from your capital provision assets based on a “probabilistic model.” Please tell us whether there are any events that would result in a change to the implied cash realization for a capital provision asset in this probabilistic
Rest of the question

model that do not result in a change to your estimate of the fair value of that capital provision asset in accordance with ASC Topic 820. If so, explain what those events are, and why you believe those events would not be considered by a marketplace participant.

BUR answered
Across these five groupings, the Company has documented a total of 77 discrete types of adjudicative events (both favorable and unfavorable) that are assessed as having a fair value impact. These groupings and related events have been identified and evolved through the Company’s 13 years of experience in applying the process described in the response to bullet 1 above as well as the judgment and experience of the Company’s many experienced litigators, and include factors such as the different procedural steps associated with different kinds of cases and the impact of progressing through each
Rest of the answer

step. That cumulative experience has not identified vintage year relating to either the underlying litigation or the initiation of the agreement with the counterparty as a differentiating factor in valuation. That is, the Company is not aware of any differences in the litigation process relevant to any of the types of litigation underlying its assets that would apply to one vintage year and not another.

There is no further delineation for case jurisdiction to the groupings noted above. The groupings are based on, and account for, the different types of litigation processes that the Company’s capital provision assets are subject to. The factors that drive the groupings principally include consideration of the number of stages in a litigation lifecycle, the process of any appeals process and the win / loss / settle ratios associated with each. The Company generally only enters capital provision assets where the underlying litigation is subject to a recognized common or civil law approach.

● Discuss how frequently you have revised the percentages applied using this technique, and what the driver of the revisions would be. When percentages are revised, tell us whether these updated percentages are applied to existing expected case outcomes at the next valuation date.

As discussed during our conversation and more fully described below, prior to 2022, the Company used ranges of percentages to apply to adjudicative events and moved to using specific percentages instead of ranges only in 2022. The ranges were rarely revised prior to 2022, and the specific percentages in the version of the valuation policy adopted in 2022 have not yet been revised.

The prior valuation policy typically provided ranges of percentages that would apply based on the more generic type of adjudicative event, and the Company, through its valuation committee, assessed the appropriate point within the range of percentages that should apply to each particular litigation matter. As the Company’s experience with its growing portfolio of capital provision assets has developed, the valuation policy evolved to provide the more specific groupings noted above together with the expanded list of adjudicative events that also resulted in ranges of percentages no longer being required. The Company reassesses the appropriateness of the groupings, adjudicative events and percentages each reporting period based on back-testing and refinements of its valuation methodology. To the extent percentages are revised, the new percentages are applied at the next valuation date (each reporting period).

● To the extent you believe the percentages applied under this policy capture the expected time horizon for recovery, tell us how. In addition, tell us how you considered events impacting the expected time horizon of resolution such as delays due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

We discussed earlier the fact that timing differences do not, in our view as a market participant, drive litigation case valuations. The percentages applied under our valuation policy are not set to the expected time horizon to recovery, but to stages of litigation. Each litigation milestone that follows another is later in the litigation lifecycle. Later success is associated with greater markups because progressing to that stage usually means a greater chance of the case resolving successfully for the plaintiff. But we do not associate reaching any particular milestone with any particular remaining time to resolution. Indeed, even a case that has proceeded fairly far along the various milestones – securing a final arbitral award, for example – may have many years to go before a final resolution and recovery. Also, there could be many cases at the same stage procedurally that take different amounts of time to resolve for various reasons, whether it is the caseload of a particular court, settlement discussions or other interlocutory steps that may be available to the parties as part of their litigation strategies. There are also cases that resolve by settlement early in the litigation lifecycle. In relation to the COVID-19 pandemic, we have disclosed publicly that we believed that the pandemic delayed a minority of our cases but when delay occurs it is also not fundamentally different than conventional litigation delays for other docket-based reasons. For example, civil cases in the Eastern District of New York move slowly because the John F. Kennedy International Airport provides a meaningful number of criminal drug and terrorism cases, so having that District move slowly because of the pandemic did not fundamentally alter our expectations.

As discussed under question 1, the structure we use for our capital provision assets recognizes the potential for significant variability in a case’s duration and essentially compensates us for accepting that duration risk; thus, the percentages used when applied to the expected outcome capture the uncertain time horizon for recovery in the valuation of the capital provision asset.

5. We note that the June 2022 (slide 9) and November 2022 (slide 12) Investor Presentations available on your website include disclosure of the implied cash realizations that you would receive from your capital provision assets based on a “probabilistic model.” Please tell us whether there are any events that would result in a change to the implied cash realization for a capital provision asset in this probabilistic model that do not result in a change to your estimate of the fair value of that capital provision asset in accordance with ASC Topic 820. If so, explain what those events are, and why you believe those events would not be considered by a marketplace participant.

The objective stages of litigation events that drive valuation are captured in our models, but the models contain different nodes as well as possible events that enable qualitative assessments to be made particularly about the time each stage might take to happen and the likelihood of settlement happening at different points throughout the litigation. The reason for these different nodes is that there is a critical difference in the methodologies of probabilistic modeling and valuation. In one (modeling) there is a weight ascribed to the likelihood of any event happening and its impact on cash realizations were it to occur based on the speculation of our team, whereas the other (valuation) ascribes a value to the event once it has happened, but with a forward-looking consideration of the remaining risk (which is encapsulated in the percentages applied as described in the preceding question). That means it is not possible to simply carry over modeled outcomes to a valuation mark. A probability assessment builds in an underwriter’s assessment of the chances of an event or outcome not happening. That is why multiple different nodes about timing and settlement outcomes are built into the model. A valuation mark, on the other hand, assesses the value of an event having happened and where that event sits in the progress of a litigation to a resolution. Neither the time to resolution or the parties ceasing to litigate or arbitrate by settling their dispute are predictable with great accuracy, as Burford publicly discloses. This is why a market participant would look instead to what has verifiably happened in a litigation in order to price it as an asset.

As noted in the response to question 1 above, the Company does not apply a discount rate to the models to calculate a net present value. Post initial pricing, the models’ main purpose is to assess potential portfolio returns and to aid the Company in liquidity planning. This data and analysis are helpful in forming views for the portfolio as a whole but does not work at the unit of account, which is the individual capital provision asset level. For example, the Company may have 10 similar assets that each are predicted to have a 30% chance of settling in a 12-month time horizon that would be expected to generate $10 million of proceeds on each asset. The models would show each of the 10 assets as expected to generate $3 million of proceeds, aggregating to $30 million in total. In reality, the Company has reasonable confidence that 3 of the 10 assets should settle generating $10 million each for a total of $30 million of proceeds, but does not know which of the assets that will be until the actual settlement has occurred.

With regards to the role of time estimates in the model, the time each stage in a litigation lifecycle will take cannot be known with accuracy by Burford (or any market participant) because of one very simple fact: we do not control the litigation process. Nonetheless, one of the inherent purposes of the model is to ascribe time predictions to each stage occurring. If a time prediction is adjusted at one or numerous nodes in the model, then this will result in changes to estimated cash realizations. That happens because changing any input in a probabilistic model that runs Monte-Carlo simulations, as ours do, necessarily impacts the result. Time prediction runs through, and is inextricable from, the modeling. The model ascribes a role to it as one of all the random variables. For instance, any change in speculation about the probability weighting of a node (e.g., a view that civil cases in the Eastern District of New York are taking even longer that official statistics suggest) will alter the outcome of the model. However, that is no reason to change the valuation mark of winning at first instance in the Eastern District of New York if that ultimately were to happen and we would not do so.

Similarly, the model will ascribe weights to settlement occurring (and at particular amounts) prior to a final resolution. That assessment may alter in the course of modeling, but, as with timing, settlement cannot be controlled or therefore predicted with accuracy. The model builds in settlement weightings and this is generally set to particular stages in a litigation. For instance, there is some chance of settlement, but generally quite low, after filing a claim, if a defendant seeks to avoid the costs of litigation entirely. Then again there may be a chance of settlement after some motion practice and before the massive costs of discovery which will not just be very costly to a defendant’s business but disruptive. If the litigation proceeds, there might again be a chance of settlement after evidence is filed. We may feel good about our evidence and so rate our chances of a good outcome highly but a market participant would look instead to the verifiable data that there are higher chances of settlement if a litigation has progressed this far, than at earlier points in the proceedings.

Read in the reply
Valuation processes · Valuation methodology for Level 3 investments, page 85
SEC asked (6)
We note in your disclosure on page 31 that you continue to carry the YPF-related assets (both Petersen and Eton Park combined) at the same carrying value since June 2019, with the exception of increases in the cost basis due to costs deployed on the assets since that date that are recoverable.
Rest of the question

Please describe the procedures you performed to support the determination that there have not been any changes to relevant information and market conditions since June 2019 that would materially impact what a market participant would pay to acquire your YPF-related assets.

BUR answered
The Company performs and documents a comprehensive review of the fair value assessment for the YPF-related assets each reporting period. The review includes an assessment of the following factors from the perspective of a market participant, and we believe any sophisticated market participant would approach evaluation of the YPF-related assets in the same way:

● Existence of market data evidencing a transaction price between a willing buyer and a willing seller;

● Occurrence or lack of any adjudicative events that would trigger a change in fair value; and

● Comprehensive update of progress
Rest of the answer

in, and the current status of, the litigation matter.

In performing the determination that the fair value of the YPF-related assets remains equivalent to the June 2019 observed traded level, the Company notes that:

● As with the vast majority of our assets, we have valued YPF-related assets based on case milestones, unless there is a significant market transaction from which we can observe its value. Here, we have based our fair value on a market transaction in June 20192.

● June 2019 is relevant because that is when the US Supreme Court ruled in plaintiffs’ (our clients’) favor on a key jurisdictional issue in the case, and we rapidly concluded a significant market transaction at that time.

● Since then, the case has been remitted back to the trial court, the US District Court for the Southern District of New York.

● Because the initial proceedings that went to the US Supreme Court only affected jurisdiction, the case was at that stage essentially beginning its substantive progress through the litigation process.

● Thus, discovery began and the parties embarked on a lengthy period of fact and expert discovery, including document discovery and depositions.

● That process – which lasted until early 2022 – did not produce any adjudicative events and there would not have been any basis for a market participant to change its view of valuation from the June 2019 level.

2 A prior correspondence between the Company and the Staff dated August 20, 2021 provides information of the lack of any ongoing secondary market activity in the response to question 1 in that letter.

● Once discovery ended in early 2022, the parties then briefed their summary judgment motions, a process that took until late June 2022. Those summary judgment motions did not alter either our view of the case or, we believe, the views of market participants based on investor feedback we received and some public commentary, so that there would not have been any basis for a change in fair value even if we took account of sentiment – and of course there was no adjudicative event.

● The summary judgment motions have been submitted for decision since June 2022, and there has not been any judicial action, even to schedule oral argument, so there is no basis for any change either in sentiment or in fair value based on any event and we do not believe that there has been any other change that would affect what a market participant would pay.

● Again, consistent with our approach on the vast majority of our assets, we have not relied upon a model given the significant challenges associated with modeling the inherently unpredictable legal process.

● Since there have been no significant case milestones, significant market transactions or items identified for evaluation as possibly triggering the exception clause in the valuation policy (following the management review control described in the response to question 3 above) regarding the YPF-related assets since the June 2019 transaction, we have not changed our fair value assessment of these assets.

● We would expect to review and revise our fair value assessment of the YPF-related assets as soon as there is a case milestone and/or if there were to be a significant secondary sale.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Apr 25, 2023

Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2020

2021-08-09 to 2022-04-29 · 7 questions · 4 letters from the SEC, 4 from the company
Review closed 2022-04-29
RevenueIncome taxes
Note 2: Basis of preparation and principal accounting policies · Valuation Policy on Capital Provision Assets, page 118
SEC asked (1)
You disclose that in a small number of instances, you have the benefit of a secondary sale of a portion of an asset and that you then factor the market evidence into your valuation process. In the second paragraph on page 63 you disclose that the use of your sale of a portion of your Petersen capital provision asset in June 2019, that was used to value your YPF assets at year-end 2019, "does not imply that these
Rest of the question

assets will henceforth be carried based on trading in the secondary market for the Petersen interests." Please provide us your analysis explaining why the value of your YPF assets did not change from year-end 2019 to year-end 2020. In your response, address the following: • Tell us whether you considered any transactions in the secondary market for the Petersen asset in your valuation at December 31, 2020. • Tell us whether there were any transactions in the secondary market for the Petersen asset during 2020. If so, tell us the transparency of pricing information. • Explain your consideration to use secondary market transactions of others to value your YPF assets given the measurement principle in IFRS 13.9 to derive a price received to sell an asset in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date. Address each of the elements of IFRS 13.B2.

BUR answered
There were no secondary market transactions used in the valuation for the Petersen asset at December 31, 2020 other than the historical observation in June 2019 of an orderly transaction when, following an organized marketing process, the Company sold a significant portion of its interest in Petersen which, together with other organized secondary sales at that same time, represented approximately

15% of the total asset and involved multiple market participants.

Consideration was given to other transaction activity observed during

2020 as set out under the bullet below.

· Tell us whether
Rest of the answer

there were any transactions in the secondary market for the Petersen asset during 2020. If so, tell us the transparency of pricing information.

Response:

There was very limited transaction activity for the Petersen asset during 2020. Management’s assessment of that data for the year ended December 31, 2020 concluded that the transactional activity lacked any due marketing process, and was of insufficient size and nature, individually and in aggregate, to represent an orderly transaction between market participants. The nature of those transactions during

2020 is further explained below.

To the Company’s knowledge, the transactional activity is limited to private sales of shares issued by a Cayman limited company (the “Vehicle”) that was established by the Company in March

2017 in order to sell portions of its asset to third party investors. The sole asset held by the Vehicle is a participation in the Petersen asset. Details regarding the transactional activity are not public data but are available to the Company since an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company is the investment manager to the Vehicle. There were only 14 trades during the year 2020 that, on average, represented less than 0.5% of the total asset and, we believe occurred as a result of asset managers altering investment strategies.

· Explain your consideration to use secondary market transactions of others to value your YPF assets given the measurement principle in

IFRS 13.9 to derive a price received to sell an asset in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date.

Address each of the elements of IFRS 13.B2.

Response:

We have set out the elements of IFRS 13.B2 below and included commentary addressing management’s consideration for each item.

New York

London

Chicago

Washington

Singapore

Sydney

13.B2. The objective of a fair value measurement is to estimate the price at which an orderly transaction to sell the asset or to transfer the liability would take place between market participants at the measurement date under current market conditions. A fair value measurement requires an entity to determine all the following:

a) the particular asset or liability that is the subject of the measurement (consistently within its unit of account)

The YPF assets consist of the Petersen and Eton Park capital provision assets, both of which represent interests in the YPF litigation. A consistent fair value measurement approach is used for both of these assets.

b) for a non-financial asset, the valuation premise that is appropriate for the measurement (consistently with its highest and best use).

N/A – the YPF assets are financial assets.

c) the principal (or most advantageous) market for the asset or liability.

There is no established principal market for the YPF assets. It is a bespoke and illiquid asset where any ownership transfer is via the private buying and selling of the shares in the Vehicle noted above.

d) the valuation technique(s) appropriate for the measurement, considering the availability of data with which to develop inputs that represent the assumptions that market participants would use when pricing the asset or liability and the level of the fair value hierarchy within which the inputs are categorized.

The valuation of the YPF assets at December 31, 2020 follows Burford’s valuation policy, which prioritizes the use of reliable market data when available. The last such observable data point was the June 2019 transaction activity following which there were no transactions that were determined to represent an orderly transaction between market participants.

During the period following that June 2019 data point through to December 31, 2020 there were no significant litigation developments that management has assessed as having a substantive positive or negative impact on the fair value for the asset. The only events in the litigation were a number of fact discovery extensions experienced during 2020 that are normal course from defendants seeking to prolong litigation.

The timing of any litigation process is inherently uncertain and subject to a number of different factors that are outside of the control of the Company or our counterparties. While inherently subjective, Management considered this factor in the valuation of the asset at December 31, 2020 concluding that there was no material passage of time implication for the June 2019 valuation.

Management’s projected outcomes, and the potential timing for realization of those outcomes, remained generally consistent at December 31, 2020 with those at December 31, 2019. Accordingly, the fair value for the YPF assets was kept at a consistent level with the June 2019 transaction level as of December 31, 2020.

Read in the reply
Note 10: Asset management income, page 131
SEC asked (2)
Please provide us your analysis supporting why you apparently fully constrain the variable consideration associated with your performance fee income for each of your funds with a "European" structure. In your response, specifically address the following: • Tell us why you recognize none of the estimated $30 million you would expect to collect on the performance of the Partners II and III funds if those funds were to
Rest of the question

be liquidated at their net asset values today. • Given the performance metrics you disclose on page 38, tell us the likelihood that all the assets in the Partners II and III funds will incur adjudication losses sufficient to offset the entire estimated $30 million in performance fees from the preceding bullet to warrant full constraint of this variable consideration. In this regard, it appears that you may have sufficient information to ascertain potential losses and that some amount of these fees can be reasonably estimated as the amount that is highly probable that a significant reversal in the amount of cumulative revenue (including the amount of regular management fees) will not occur. • Tell us the amount of regular management fee income recognized through December 31, 2020 for each of the Partners II and III funds.

BUR answered
Under IFRS 15, recognition of performance fee income necessitates that revenue only be recognized to the extent that it is highly probable that a significant reversal in the amount of cumulative revenue recognized will not occur when the uncertainty associated with the variable consideration is subsequently resolved.

For Partners II and III the amount of estimated performance fee income noted above is based on the funds’ US GAAP stand-alone financials that calculates an accrued carried interest amount in accordance with ASC 946.
Rest of the answer

The ASC methodology assumes the funds were liquidated at their net asset values at December 31, 2020.

As with many of Burford’s capital provision assets, ultimate financial performance is linked to binary litigation outcomes. Substantially all the $30 million estimated performance fee income is related to Partners III. The minimal amount of estimated performance fee income on Partners II is dependent on the outcome of nine remaining active positions. For Partners III, the ultimate performance fee income earned by Burford depends not only on litigation outcomes but also the duration over which the underlying proceedings resolve.

The Limited Partners of Partners III receive a preferred return. “Preferred Return” means an eight percent (8.0%) cumulative investment return on all contributions by Limited Partners that have not been returned. The estimated performance fee assumes no further Preferred Return past December 31, 2020, consistent with

ASC 946 methodology.

Partners III has 38 unresolved or partially resolved positions of which five positions make up a majority of the portfolio fair value at December 31, 2020. The fund has significant outstanding capital contributions from Limited Partners that continue to accrue preferred return. Further, the fund had unfunded commitments to capital provision assets of up to $129 million, which may necessitate additional capital contributions to meet the commitment obligations of the fund.

Given the remaining uncertainty in Partners III around investment performance, duration and the pace of further capital contributions, Burford does not have sufficient evidence to conclude that any portion of the estimated performance would meet the highly probable threshold defined by the standard.

· Given the performance metrics you disclose on page 38, tell us the likelihood that all the assets in the Partners II and III funds will incur adjudication losses sufficient to offset the entire estimated $30 million in performance fees from the preceding bullet to warrant full constraint of this variable consideration. In this regard, it appears that you may have sufficient information to ascertain potential losses and that some amount of these fees can be reasonably estimated as the amount that is highly probable that a significant reversal in the amount of cumulative revenue (including the amount of regular management fees) will not occur.

Response:

The performance metrics on page 38 of Form 20-F pertain to the Burford-only portfolio which does not include private fund performance.

All of the Partners II investments and a portion of the Partners III investments were underwritten prior to Burford’s acquisition of the asset manager (Gerchen Keller Capital) in December 2016, which may have applied different underwriting standards from the Burford team. The fund investments underwritten by the asset manager prior to the Burford acquisition are not directly comparable to Burford’s balance sheet-only performance given differences in vintage, strategy and mix of litigation type.

In addition, the page 38 table includes only concluded investments.

Using concluded balance sheet performance as a proxy for fund performance only works to the degree that the concluded investment population is representative of the unresolved investments for the funds at December 31, 2020. While it may be reasonable that Burford balance sheet performance is representative of a broadly diversified portfolio, the remaining unresolved investments in Partners II and Partners III are far less diversified and more likely to be impacted by the divergent outcomes of a subset of investments. Excluding unresolved investments from the representative population also does not address the uncertainty created by the duration of capital provision assets. Given the binary outcomes inherent to litigation finance capital provision assets, we do not believe that the remaining uncertainties are sufficiently mitigated to allow for recognition of performance fee income in accordance with the highly probable standard under IFRS 15.

· Tell us the amount of regular management fee income recognized through December 31, 2020 for each of the Partners II and III funds.

Response:

Under the terms of the LPA, Partners II and III, are outside of the period in which they pay management fees. The final management fees for these funds were accrued and paid in 2019.

Read in the reply
Consolidated operating results · Six months ended June 30, 2021, compared to six months ended June 30, 2020 Operating Expenses, page 17
SEC asked (1)
At the bottom of page 17 carrying over onto page 18 you discuss a $45 million additional accrual in the first half of 2021 related to a change in accounting estimate related to certain "carry plans." You indicate that historically you recognized carry plan expense only upon realizations of the related capital provision assets and not on the basis of unrealized gains.
Rest of the question

Please tell us why this charge in 2021 is the result of a change in estimate and reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your position. In your response, address the following: • Tell us how your prior accounting complied with the guidance in IAS 19. • Tell us your consideration of the guidance in IAS 19.24. • Tell us how your current accounting complies with the guidance in IAS 19. • Explain why your change is not a change in accounting policy that should be reflected retrospectively under IAS 8.19(b). • Explain why your change is not the correction of an error that should be reflected retrospectively under IAS 8.42(b).

BUR answered
New York, NY 10017

+1

(212) 235-6820 [email protected] www.burfordcapital.com

· Tell us how your prior accounting complied with the guidance in IAS 19.

The “carry plans” compensate certain executives in cash for services provided, forming part of their overall compensation package. Accordingly, we assessed the arrangement under IAS 19 to determine its classification as a shortor long-term benefit and the associated recognition of the appropriate expense.

Short-term employee benefits are defined in IAS 19 paragraph 8 as “employee benefits (other than termination benefits) that are
Rest of the answer

expected to be settled wholly within twelve months after the end of the annual reporting period in which the employees render the related service”. Long-term employee benefits are employee benefits (excluding post-employment and termination benefits) that are not expected to be settled wholly before 12 months after the end of the annual reporting period in which the employees render the service that gives rise to the benefit.

The benefit payable is a fixed percentage of realized cash profits, net of any realized cash losses, from a defined population of qualifying assets. Because it may take many years for some of the investments to realize a cash profit from the date on which the employees render the service that gives rise to the benefit (that is, the identification, due diligence and origination of the assets), we concluded that the arrangement does not meet the definition of a short-term benefit under

IAS 19 and assessed it as a long-term benefit.

IAS 19 requires the recognition of an estimated liability for the present value of the expected benefit at each reporting date with the change in that liability recognized as a compensation expense in the income statement for that period.

For prior financial reporting periods management were not sufficiently confident in their ability to estimate the crystallization on the carry to the level required under IAS 19 to include amounts relating to unrealized gains in the calculation of the liability. The estimate for the liability was therefore determined as what management considered to be a reasonable estimate which was the amount to be paid following the end of the current financial year based on its best judgment of the facts and circumstances at that time.

· Tell us your consideration of the guidance in IAS 19.24.

As set out above, the executive carry arrangement is assessed as a long-term employee benefit in accordance with IAS 19.24.

· Tell us how your current accounting complies with the guidance in IAS 19.

In determining the amount to accrue as of June 30, 2021, management has considered the full extent of the data available at that date in making a reliable estimate of the liability. These data points include consideration of the Company’s continued growth in track record of actual performance of its concluded capital provision asset portfolio and historical assessment of fair values for its ongoing portfolio and is informed by significant maturation of the Company’s asset modeling methodologies.

New

York

London

Chicago

Washington

Singapore

Sydney

In consideration of these inputs, management has determined that for the first time there is sufficient basis to conclude that a reliable estimate of the amount to be recorded as the liability for the executive carry arrangement at June 30, 2021 should include an accrual based on the net unrealized gain position associated with the qualifying capital provision assets within the scope of the carry arrangements.

Management has considered a wide range of data in its analysis including the following:

· Asset returns o Burford was founded in late 2009 driving the development of a new market and type of asset in providing financing to the litigation related market.

o The Company’s portfolio has grown significantly since that time and at June 30, 2021 has matured into a $2.4 billion diversified set of assets.

o A significant challenge with a new and developing asset class is establishing a track record of proven returns associated with the investments – this is especially true for litigation-based assets where the outcomes are often binary (which can result in a complete loss of the financing provided) and the timing of the legal process is inherently uncertain and can often span many years; for example, some investments made in 2010 are still ongoing.

o While the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic during 2020 led to some uncertainties, with new business activity significantly lower than prior periods that year, activity in 1H 2021 rebounded and exceeded pre-pandemic levels.

o Burford’s track record now includes 167 asset realizations at 30 June 2021, 23 of which occurred in H1 2021. These incremental realizations, which spanned different asset and litigation types, provided increased confidence in the Company’s fair value assessments while at the same time 2021 saw significant advances in the Company’s modeling and data analytics.

o The most recent track record for ROIC shows increasing returns over the past few years from 75% in 2017 to 95% in H1 2021. During that same period the IRR achieved for that same population of assets has remained very stable in the range of 30-31%.

· Fair values o Burford has consistently applied an event-driven approach to assessing fair value for the litigation-based assets.

o The core principle of applying event-driven changes based on the relative stage of the underlying litigation has remained the same but management’s experience in assessing the events and their impact on the application of the guidance has grown exponentially as a result of the portfolio growth and the passage of time.

o In more recent years, starting with the year ended December 31, 2018, management has produced and tracked a historical track record of the timing and amount of fair value changes applied to the concluded asset portfolio.

o This analysis has been possible given a sufficiently diversified set of concluded assets (both favorable and unfavorable) becoming available, including the significant asset realization in H1 2021.

o Management is now in its fourth year of tracking this data across all concluded assets, significantly increasing the confidence in the fair value assessment process and the utilization of that data in the estimate of the liability for the compensation arrangement.

In management’s view the collective critical mass of the items and data cited above, combined with consistent performance across both large and small asset realizations with respect to the metrics based on the June 30, 2021 results, provided sufficiently reliable evidence for management to consider for the first time in H1 2021 a revision in the estimate in compensation accruals that are tied to the fair value assessments of the Company’s assets.

As a result of this revision, the expected benefit under IAS 19 for the executive carry arrangement is now estimated each reporting period by applying the applicable percentage allocation to the net unrealized gains assessed on the qualifying investments.

· Explain why your change is not a change in accounting policy that should be reflected retrospectively under IAS 8.19(b).

As part of this reassessment, management considered the guidance in

IAS 8 Accounting policies, changes in accounting estimates and errors. The standard defines a change in accounting estimate as “[a] change in accounting estimate is an adjustment of the carrying amount of an asset or a liability, or the amount of the periodic consumption of an asset, that results from the assessment of the present status of, and expected future benefits and obligations associated with, assets and liabilities. Changes in accounting estimates result from new information or new developments and, accordingly, are not corrections of errors.”

The Company’s accounting policy is to recognize a liability for a long-term employee benefit under IAS 19 and nothing has changed in that respect. What has changed is how the Company arrives at its estimate of the amount of the liability, namely, by incorporating new information and new developments (the continuing performance track record, historical experience of the fair value assessment process and probabilistic modeling) that provide better information regarding the amount of unrealized gains that will eventually be crystallized into realized gains to be paid out to the executives. As a result, management has concluded that the change meets the definition of, and represents, a change in accounting estimate under IAS 8.

· Explain why your change is not the correction of an error that should be reflected retrospectively under IAS 8.42(b).

As noted above, the change is based on a reassessment of the estimate for the liability based on new information and new developments that is consistent with the change in accounting estimate guidance in

IAS 8.

Read in the reply
Consolidated operating results · Six months ended June 30, 2021, compared to six months ended June 30, 2020 Operating Expenses, page 17
SEC asked (2)
In the first full paragraph on page 18 you discuss a $34 million additional accrual related to the grandfathering of a small number of cases following the termination of a profitsharing arrangement in your asset recovery business.
Rest of the question

Please tell us why it is appropriate to record this accrual in 2021 given that it appears to relate to compensation arrangements dating back to 2015 and reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your accounting. In your response, address the following: • Describe for us the profit-sharing arrangement that was terminated and explain why it was terminated. • Tell us what cases or types of cases were grandfathered.

BUR answered
, address the following:

· Describe for us the profit-sharing arrangement that was terminated and explain why it was terminated.

The prior arrangement with the asset recovery business was established when Burford acquired that business in 2015. It was an annual bonus plan to compensate the principals and other employees directly supporting that business area for services provided for each discrete financial year.
Rest of the answer

The arrangement contained a formulaic approach to defining a total bonus pool amount payable based on the realized net operating income for the entire business area for the financial year and was designed to incentivize the principals to maximize operating profits for the business area.

This prior arrangement expired at the end of 2020 per the original terms of the contractual arrangement and a new arrangement was executed and implemented in 2021. The expiration of the prior arrangement coincided with a broader integration of the asset recovery activity into Burford’s core capital provision asset business, including its compensation practices.

The new arrangement, effective January 1, 2021, is a profit-sharing arrangement similar to the executive carry arrangement described in response 1 above. The new arrangement has no set expiration and provides a benefit based on a portion of realized cash profits following a predefined formula (based on a percentage of realized gains less certain contractually predetermined costs) relating to three specific asset recovery capital provision assets.

· Tell us what cases or types of cases were grandfathered.

As noted above, the three assets included in the new arrangement are existing, ongoing asset recovery capital provision assets that relate to Burford’s financing of the cost of the pursuit of enforcement of unpaid legal judgments. The new arrangement does not ‘grandfather’ any assets in the sense that the prior arrangement was continued as to those assets, but rather that an exception has been made to the new arrangement with respect to three existing assets but under newly executed terms in 2021.

The amount payable under the prior arrangement is compensation for services provided in a discrete financial year based on the financial performance of the entire asset recovery business, net of operating expenses, for each discrete financial year. The amount payable is wholly settled within 12 months of the annual reporting period when the employees provided the services. Accordingly, it was assessed as a short-term benefit under IAS 19. The applicable amount to accrue for this prior arrangement was therefore based on the amounts expected to be payable with respect to each historical financial year only.

As noted above, the prior arrangement was assessed as meeting the definition of a short-term benefit under IAS 19. The new arrangement is a multi-year profit-sharing arrangement tied to the performance of three specific assets that is not expected to be wholly settled within 12 months of the annual reporting period when the employees provided the services, similar to the executive carry arrangement described in response 1 above. Accordingly, the new arrangement is assessed as a long-term benefit under IAS 19.24.

Management has assessed the amount to be recorded as a reliable estimate of the liability at June 30, 2021 following a consistent approach to that set out in the response to comment 1 above. For the reasons set out in that response, management’s assessment is that the accrual should be based on the net unrealized gain position associated with the qualifying capital provision assets within the scope of the asset recovery arrangement.

· Explain why your change is not a change in accounting policy that should be reflected retrospectively under IAS 8.19(b).

This is not considered applicable as the asset recovery arrangement was a newly executed contractual arrangement in 2021.

Read in the reply
Consolidated operating results · Six months ended June 30, 2021, compared to six months ended June 30, 2020 Operating Expenses, page 17
SEC asked
We acknowledge your response to prior comment 1. Please address the following additional comments related to your accounting prior to recording the additional $45 million accrual in the first half of 2021: • Elaborate on how you were unable to estimate with sufficient certainty the compensation under your "carry plans" when you record your capital provision assets at fair value.
Rest of the question

In your response, specifically address the impact of the time value of money on your asset valuation and why apparently timing estimates for asset valuation could not be used in estimating long-term carry plan compensation. • We note from your response that the carry plans should be assessed as a long-term employee benefit pursuant to paragraph 24 of IAS 19. As this paragraph requires other long-term employee benefit accounting, tell us how you considered the guidance in paragraphs 155 and 156 of IAS 19, which requires recognition and measurement of surplus or deficit in a plan (paragraphs 56 to 60) and recognition of service cost, net interest on the net defined benefit liability, and remeasurments of the net defined benefit liability.

BUR answered
Despite extensive analysis of the issue at the time the carry plans were adopted, including consultation with our independent registered public accounting firm, Ernst & Young LLP (“EY”), in connection with the preparation of our financial statements as of and for the six months ended June 30, 2021, we have performed additional analysis and conducted additional consultations with EY and concluded that the legal finance one-time, non-cash accrual previously recognized in the six months ended June 30, 2021 as reported in our half-year report should have been applied to 2019 and 2020 as well as
Rest of the answer

2021.

On December 22, 2021, we furnished on Form 6-K a press release announcing our determination and providing corrected amounts for the affected reporting periods.

Read in the reply
Exhibit 99.1: Release issued by the Company, dated December 22, 2021 · Burford Capital Statement Concerning Non-Cash Accrual
SEC asked (1)
We acknowledge your response to our prior comment and note that the pre-tax and aftertax impact of your error correcting entries are the same in each period to be corrected. Please tell us why there is no apparent income tax impact of your error correction entries in each period to be restated.
Rest of the question

In this regard, although you may not be able to claim a current tax deduction for accrued long-term compensation expenses until paid, it appears that a deferred income tax benefit and associated deferred tax asset would be appropriate for the related deductible temporary differences under IAS 12.24.

BUR answered
New York, NY 10017

+1 (212) 235-6820 [email protected] www.burfordcapital.com

The non-cash accrual for the executive carry arrangement relates to employees who are assessed as ‘covered employees’ under the Internal Revenue Code Section 162(m) limitation. This limitation which became applicable to the Company following its SEC registration and NYSE listing in 2020 generally prohibits tax deductions by publicly traded companies on the portion of pay for covered employees that exceeds $1 million per year.
Rest of the answer

The Company has assessed and concluded that other sources of compensation, salary and other annual bonus awards (excluding the executive carry arrangement) paid in 2019, 2020 and 2021, and to be paid to the relevant employees in future years is expected to exceed the $1 million Section 162(m) limitation in each tax year. Accordingly, it is probable that none of the potential amounts to be paid under the executive carry arrangements are expected to be tax deductible and the Company has not recognized any deferred income tax benefit for the correcting entries for the year ended December 31, 2020 or for the six-month periods ended June 30, 2021 and 2020.

The recognition of a deferred tax asset for the year ended December 31, 2019 was already restricted based on the Company’s supporting recoverability projections. The correcting entry to recognize an additional accrual is therefore not accretive to that already restricted deferred tax asset position.

Read in the reply
Exhibit 99.1: Release issued by the Company, dated December 22, 2021 · Burford Capital Statement Concerning Non-Cash Accrual
SEC asked (2)
We note your disclosure on the third page of your release that the audited consolidated financial statements as of and for the years ended December 31, 2020 and 2019 and unaudited condensed consolidated financial statements for the six-month periods ended June 30, 2021 and 2020 should not be relied upon.
Rest of the question

Please amend your Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2020 and Form 6-K filed on September 9, 2021 that are incorporated by reference into your Form S-8 to file restated financial statements that reflect the correction of the error.

BUR answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and intend to file amendments to the Company’s Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2020 and Form 6-K filed on September 9,

2021 that include restated financial statements for the relevant periods.
Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2022-04-29

Form 20-F

2020-07-31 to 2020-09-28 · 35 questions · 5 letters from the SEC, 3 from the company
No closing letter
Risk factorsLegal and contingenciesLeasesResults discussion (MD&A)RevenueSegmentsNon-GAAP measuresCritical estimatesGoodwill and impairment
SEC letter of Jul 31, 2020 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR
D. Risk Factors · Our portfolio may be concentrated in cases likely to have correlated results, page 9
SEC asked (1)
We note your disclosure here that your legal finance assets with a single law firm represented approximately 13% of your group-wide commitments. Please disclose the name of the law firm or advise. A significant portion of our fund assets under management are attributable to a fund with a single investor, page 11
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

D. Risk Factors · Our portfolio may be concentrated in cases likely to have correlated results, page 9
SEC asked (2)
Please disclose the single investor of BOF-C that represents approximately 23% of your fund assets under management or advise why this information is not material to investors. The laws, regulations and rules relating to legal finance are evolving and may be uncertain, page
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

D. Risk Factors · Our portfolio may be concentrated in cases likely to have correlated results, page 9
SEC asked (3)
Please expand the risk factor to address proposed bills as they relate to legal finance in the United States. For example, please discuss briefly the "Litigation Funding Transparency Act" recently introduced in Congress.
Rest of the question

Also please briefly expand your risk factor disclosure to discuss the prohibitions or restrictions in connection with funding claims that you reference in this risk factor, as applicable to the jurisdictions in which you operate, or advise. Please also expand your disclosure related to these prohibitions or restrictions under "Regulations," at page 32, or elsewhere under Business Overview, as applicable, or advise. Please discuss any risks and regulations or restrictions with owning Burford Law as a standalone law firm along with your legal finance businesses, if applicable, or advise. We are subject to the risk of being deemed an investment company, page 13

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

D. Risk Factors · Our portfolio may be concentrated in cases likely to have correlated results, page 9
SEC asked (4)
Please provide us additional analysis as to why you are not an investment company as defined in the Investment Company Act of 1940, as it pertains to the funds described under "Complex Strategies," at page 28 and "Asset Management," at page 29.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Item 4. Information on the Company, page 23
SEC asked (5)
We note that some important information about your general mode of business operations does not appear to be disclosed in this section, but instead described in the financial or other sections. Please include here a brief description of the following: • resale of a portion of your legal assets, including specific percentages of your largest claims (page 40); • state that your undrawn commitments are divided into two
Rest of the question

categories: discretionary and definitive and describe major characteristics of each category (page 52); • your commitments by region, for example, 42% in North America, and 30% Europe (page 55); • types of claims you invest in, such as antitrust 15%, intellectual property - 12%, arbitration - 10% (page 58); • the biggest industries for your legal claims, for example, insurance and utilities (page 59); • the fact that corporate clients account for 52% of your commitments, law firms for 44%, other clients for 4% (page 61); and • the fact that you issue legal expenses insurance policies through your wholly owned subsidiary and Guernsey based insurer, Burford Worldwide Insurance Limited (page F-12).

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Item 4. Information on the Company, page 23
SEC asked (6)
Please disclose in this section your pricing model, such as percentage or fixed fee, a range or a combination of the two you charge for legal finance claims. In addition, based on the risk factor on page 10 it appears that you charge asset management performance fees. Please disclose the average fee or a range of such fees, or advise.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Item 4. Information on the Company, page 23
SEC asked (7)
We note your disclosure on page 27 that you have also launched Burford Law. Please add this company to your organizational chart on page 23 and list it in the table on page 24 or advise.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Complex strategies, page 28
SEC asked (8)
Please expand your disclosure in this section to describe your "complex strategies" business in more detail: • Clarify what you mean when you state that you "acquire assets that [you] believe are mispriced." For instance, please clarify if you acquire these assets from another legal finance company.
Rest of the question

• Explain what you mean by your statement that you "are the owner of the asset subject to the claim, and therefore retain that decision-making authority." Please clarify what decision-making authority are you referring to. Do you make any decisions directly related to the litigation strategies, ability to make decisions to settle or go to trial, or any other decisions traditionally reserved only for litigation parties and their counsel? • Please explain the statement that "there are significant risk management benefits with complex strategies investments because, if we lose the litigation, we still own the underlying asset, as opposed to the core litigation finance business where a loss of the case will generally cause us to lose our entire funded cost."

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Asset Management, page 29
SEC asked (9)
Please clarify what you mean by "sidecar" funds and how those pertain to the specific assets.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

D. Property, Plant and Equipment, page 33
SEC asked (10)
Please describe general details of your office leases, including the size of each lease. Refer to Item 4.D of Form 20-F.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Item 5. Operating and Financial Review and Prospects · A. Operating Results, page 34
SEC asked (11)
Please revise your operating results discussions throughout to quantify and explain the underlying cause(s) for the variation in the financial statement captions period over period. By means of example, the following list is not exhaustive: • Revise your capital provision income disclosure on page 35 to quantify the amount of the decline attributed to lower realized gains and lower fair value adjustments on capital
Rest of the question

provision assets and explain why both these amounts were lower in 2019. • Revise your service income disclosure on page 35 to explain why your fee-forservice income from your asset recovery business increased despite your transition to a contingent risk model. • Revise your asset management income disclosure on page 37 to explain why management fees are lower on older funds. • Revise your insurance income disclosure on page 37 to explain why the settlement of two large cases results in an increase in income.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Segments, page 38
SEC asked (12)
Please revise your segment disclosure to include a discussion about segment profit or loss.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

D. Trend Information · Non-IFRS Supplemental Financial Measures, page 44
SEC asked (13)
Please revise your disclosures to clearly state the reasons why you believe that the presentation of each of your group-wide measures provides useful information to investor's regarding your financial condition and results of operations as required by Item 10(e)(1)(i)(C) of Regulation S-K.
Rest of the question

In your response, at a minimum, explain why: • Group-wide portfolio information on capital provision assets is meaningful to investors when not all the value is expected to inure to you and your shareholders; and • Group-wide undrawn commitments is meaningful to investors when not all commitments will be funded by you.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Item 6. Directors, Senior Management and Employees · Carry Pools Plan, page 78
SEC asked (14)
Please clarify what employees or groups of employees fall in the category of "certain employees" who may be invited to participate in the carry pool plans. Please also expand to explain the assets that are included in the "certain pools of assets." Item 19. Exhibits, page 109
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Item 6. Directors, Senior Management and Employees · Carry Pools Plan, page 78
SEC asked (15)
We note several references in the registration statement to your long-term incentive plan. Please file the plan as an exhibit to the registration statement and describe its material terms. In the alternative, please advise.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Note 2: Basis of preparation and principal accounting policies · Asset management income, page F-13
SEC asked (16)
Please tell us, and revise your policy as appropriate, how you account for the clawback provision in some of your asset management agreements identified in the risk factor at the bottom of page 10. In your response letter, reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your accounting. Financial instruments 7) Third-party interests in consolidated entities, page F-16
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Note 2: Basis of preparation and principal accounting policies · Asset management income, page F-13
SEC asked (17)
We note your classification of third-party interest in consolidated entities as financial liabilities at fair value through profit and loss. As these amounts appear to be akin to noncontrolling interests, please tell us: • Why you do not classify them as a component of equity as required by paragraph 54(q) of IAS 1 and paragraph 22 of IFRS 10; • Why you classify the change in this item as a component of income
Rest of the question

instead of as an allocation of profit for the period as required by paragraph 81B of IAS 1; and • Why you do not provide a rollforward of the balance as a component of equity as required by paragraph 106(a) of IAS 1. In your response, reference of us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your classification and accounting.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Taxation, page F-18
SEC asked (18)
We note your risk factor on page 17 regarding significant uncertainty for the tax treatment of your financing agreements. Please revise your policy note to disclose how you account for this uncertainty. In addition, revise Note 4 to provide the disclosures required by paragraphs A4 and A5 of IFRIC 23 or tell us why this disclosure is not warranted. Note 13: Cash management assets, page F-35
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Taxation, page F-18
SEC asked (19)
You disclose that your cash management assets at December 31, 2019 were invested primarily in a listed investment fund and fixed income securities. Please tell us your consideration for disclosing more granular information about the composition of this portfolio under the requirements in paragraphs 25 and 6 of IFRS 7 to disclose fair value information about financial assets by class.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Note 21: Fair value of assets and liabilities, page F-42
SEC asked (20)
We acknowledge your methodology disclosure regarding your capital provision assets here and in critical accounting estimates on page 40 and in Note 2 on page F-17. We also acknowledge your sensitivity disclosure and reasonably possible alternative assumptions disclosure on page F-45.
Rest of the question

Please address the following: • Revise your disclosure to provide some meaningful quantitative information about the significant unobservable inputs utilized in your fair value estimates as required by paragraph 93(d) of IFRS 13. Notwithstanding your confidentially argument regarding individual assets/matters presented on page 67 and elsewhere in your filing, disclosure of aggregate portfolio ranges and weighted averages appears appropriate. If you continue to believe it inappropriate to provide this required quantitative information, provide us your analysis support your assessment of fair value and the various inputs and explain why you cannot provide relevant quantitative information. • Tell us why your sensitivity analysis required by paragraph 93(h) of IFRS and presented on page F-45 is limited to a simple 10% of the current balance and why you cannot provide other reasonably possible alternatives. In your response, tell us why the amounts disclosed are not 10% of the capital provision assets balances reported on your balance. In this regard, it appears that the impact on income should be a pre-tax amount while the impact on net assets should be an after-tax amount. Note 22: Risk management

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Credit risk, page F-49
SEC asked (21)
In the penultimate paragraph of this section you disclose that you apply the simplified approach to recognize impairment on settlement and receivable balances based on the lifetime expected credit loss. Please tell us why it is appropriate to use the simplified approach for your settlement receivables when paragraph 5.5.15 of IFRS 9 indicates that it applies only to trade receivables and contract assets under IFRS
Rest of the question

15 or lease receivables under IFRS 16. Your settlement receivables appear to be generated from your capital provision assets accounted for as financial instruments under IFRS 9. Reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your accounting.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

General
SEC asked (22)
We note that your forum selection provision identifies the Courts of Guernsey as the exclusive forum for litigation asserting a cause of action arising under the Companies Law or your articles of incorporation. Please disclose whether this provision applies to actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act.
Rest of the question

If so, please also state that there is uncertainty as to whether a court would enforce such provision. If the provision applies to Securities Act claims, please also state that investors cannot waive compliance with the federal securities laws and the rules and regulations thereunder. In that regard, we note that Section 22 of the Securities Act creates concurrent jurisdiction for federal and state courts over all suits brought to enforce any duty or liability created by the Securities Act or the rules and regulations thereunder. If this provision does not apply to actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act, please also ensure that the exclusive forum provision in the governing documents states this clearly, or tell us how you will inform investors in future filings that the provision does not apply to any actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act. Please also describe the exclusive forum provision in your registration statement.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

General
SEC asked (23)
We note that article 40 of your Articles of Incorporation indicates that the Company shall be entitled to security for costs in connection with any proceeding brought against it, which appears to be a fee shifting provision.
Rest of the question

Please disclose the following information in your registration statement: • the types of actions subject to this provision, including whether you intend to apply the provision to claims under the federal securities laws; • the level of recovery required by the plaintiff to avoid payment; and • who is subject to the provision (for example, former and current shareholders, legal counsel, expert witnesses) and who would be allowed to recover (e.g., company, directors, officers, affiliates).

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

SEC letter of Aug 28, 2020 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR
Risk Factors · Our portfolio may be concentrated in cases likely to have correlated results, page 9
SEC asked (1)
We note your response to our prior comment 1 and reissue. Please expand your materiality analysis in your response to us by telling us what percentage of your revenues are derived from the law firm described in this risk factor. A significant portion of our fund assets under management are attributable to a fund with a single investors, page 11
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Risk Factors · Our portfolio may be concentrated in cases likely to have correlated results, page 9
SEC asked (2)
We note your response to our prior comment 2 and reissue. Please provide us with an analysis of why you believe the identity of the investor mentioned in this risk factor is not material to investors. We note, for instance, the disclosure at page 29 that the SWF contributes two-thirds of the capital to the BOF-C fund. Please file the agreement with the SWF or advise.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

We are subject to the risk of being deemed an investment company, page 13
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to our prior comment 4. Please expand on your response to our prior comment asking about your “investment company” status under the Investment Company Act of 1940 (“1940 Act”) as follows: • Please explain whether you currently meet, or expect to meet, the definition of “investment company” under (i) Section 3(a)(1)(A) or (ii) Section 3(a)(1)(C) of the 1940 Act.
Rest of the question

In your response, please provide detailed analysis, including your views as to whether each category of holdings described in your registration statement (in Item 4(B) – Business Overview) will constitute “investment securities” for purposes of the 1940 Act. • If the answer to either (i) or (ii) in the bulleted sentence above is yes, please explain whether you believe any exemption from the definition of “investment company” would apply to you. In your response, please provide detailed analysis, including discussion of any SEC staff no-action letters that you believe may be applicable.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Exclusive Forum; Fees, page 95
SEC asked (4)
We note your response to our prior comment 23 and reissue in part. Please revise to state who would be allowed to recover under the fee shifting provision, such as only the company, or also directors, officers, or affiliates. In addition, please include a risk factor stating that the provision could discourage shareholder lawsuits that might otherwise benefit the company and its shareholders.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Note 2: Basis of preparation and principal accounting policies · Asset management income, page F-13
SEC asked (5)
We acknowledge your response to prior comment 16. Please tell us how your stated policy associated with the variable consideration constraint complies with the guidance in paragraph 56 of IFRS 15. In this regard, you indicate, in part, that performance fees are recognized when it is highly unlikely that a significant revenue reversal will occur when the referenced guidance indicates that the threshold to apply is
Rest of the question

when it is highly probable that a significant revenue reversal will not occur. Paragraph BC211 of IFRS 15 indicates essentially that "highly probable" connotes a future event or events that are likely to occur; therefore, it appears that the likelihood of the event not occurring would be "unlikely" not "highly unlikely" and, by inference, that your variable consideration constraint is too restrictive. In your response, tell us whether you constrained variable consideration at December 31, 2019 and 2018 under the "highly unlikely" threshold that would have been recognized under the "likely" threshold.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Note 21: Fair value of assets and liabilities, page F-42
SEC asked (6)
We acknowledge your response to prior comment 20 and continue to believe that, as capital provision assets are your most significant asset, are Level 3 in the fair value hierarchy and result from your ordinary business activities, you must provide some incremental quantitative information underlying your significant unobservable inputs used to fair value these assets.
Rest of the question

As previously requested, please revise your filing to provide meaningful quantitative information about the significant unobservable inputs used in the fair value measurement of your capital provisions assets as required by paragraph 93(d) of IFRS 13. Otherwise, provide us a detailed analysis of your valuation process and your assessment of how your current disclosures meet the disclosure objectives of paragraph 91 of IFRS 13, considering that paragraph 92 requires additional disclosures if the required disclosures do not meet the disclosure objectives. In your response, at a minimum, tell us your consideration for disclosing quantitative information for each of the following potential inputs: • the number of assets in each of the stages identified in the bullets on page F-17; • the weighted-average probability of success assigned to assets in each of the stages in the preceding bullet; • the weighted-average maximum estimated recovery amount for each of the stages in the first bullet above; • ranges and weighted-averages of risk-adjusted probability factors; and • ranges and weighted-averages of discount rates or risk-adjusted discount rates used to reflect the time value of money.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

SEC letter of Sep 9, 2020 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR
Risk Factors · We are subject to the risk of being deemed an investment company, page 13
SEC asked (1)
We note your response to our prior comment 3. Please expand on your response as follows: 1. Please provide additional detail to support your statement that you are “primarily engaged” in the businesses referenced in Section 3(c)(5)(A) and Section 3(c)(5)(B).
Rest of the question

In particular, please provide information about the specific categories of assets that are included and excluded from your calculations, including a description of which categories of assets are included in the calculation to show that you are “primarily engaged” under Section 3(c)(5)(A) and which categories are included under 3(c)(5)(B), and your reasoning for such inclusions and exclusions, as applicable. Please be sure to provide enough detail to allow the staff to independently verify your calculations.

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Risk Factors · We are subject to the risk of being deemed an investment company, page 13
SEC asked (2)
Please provide additional information about the CPAs as follows: a. Please provide additional detail about how Qualifying CPAs are tied to “one or more specific cases of litigation, arbitration, or regulatory process.” In your response, please address the specific rationale you use for distinguishing between CPAs and Qualifying CPAs. b. Please explain the contractual structure of a typical CPA.
Rest of the question

Are these agreements typically bilateral agreements between you and law firms or companies? Or are they triparty agreements among all parties?

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Risk Factors · We are subject to the risk of being deemed an investment company, page 13
SEC asked (3)
Please provide additional analysis and support for your statement that the notes you acquire pursuant to a CPA represent “part or all of the sales price of merchandise, insurance, and services.” In particular, please explain how you believe this requirement is met with regard to Qualifying CPAs with law firm counterparties.
Rest of the question

Include in your analysis an explanation of whether the compensation arrangement for the law firm being 100% contingent on the outcome of the matter or based on hourly billing rates impacts whether the CPA represents the “sales price.”

BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Risk Factors · We are subject to the risk of being deemed an investment company, page 13
SEC asked (4)
In the case of Qualifying CPAs with law firm counterparties, please provide additional analysis and support for your statement that, under Section 3(c)(5)(B), a law firm may be considered a manufacturer, wholesaler or retailer of services.
BUR answered

No reply letter found.

Risk Factors · We are subject to the risk of being deemed an investment company, page 13
SEC asked
We note your response to our prior comment 1. When discussing why you believe that you are “primarily engaged” in the businesses referenced in Section 3(c)(5)(A) and Section 3(c)(5)(B) of the Investment Company Act of 1940 (“1940 Act”), you excluded “third party interests” from your calculations.
Rest of the question

Please: (i) provide a definition of “third party interests” and (ii) provide your rationale, under the 1940 Act, for excluding such interests from your calculations.

BUR answered
(i) As disclosed in the Registration Statement, the Company prepares its financial statements in accordance with International Financial Reporting

Standards, as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (“IFRS”). IFRS requires the Company to consolidate fund entities that it both manages (and, therefore, controls) and also has a meaningful investment in. These consolidated entities include the Strategic Value Fund, the BOF-C fund and certain special purpose vehicles through which the Company holds capital provision assets jointly with minority partners.
Rest of the answer

As disclosed in the Registration Statement, the Company refers to this presentation as “consolidated” or “IFRS”. In order to provide clarity on the Company as a stand-alone business excluding the impact of third-party interests in these consolidated entities, the Company also furnishes financial information on a “Burford-only” basis, which refers to assets, liabilities and activities that pertain only to the Company itself and excludes third-party interests (such third-party interests being the portions of non-wholly owned entities owned by others). The net assets attributable to the third-party ownership in these funds is subtracted from the Company’s statement of financial position in the line item titled “Third-party interests in consolidated entities” and the share of gains or losses attributable to the third-party ownership in these funds is subtracted from the Company’s statement of comprehensive income in the line item titled “Third-party share of gains relating to interests in consolidated entities”. See Note 2 to the consolidated financial statements beginning on page F-8 of the Registration Statement. Note 23 to the consolidated financial statements beginning on page F-54 of the Registration Statement provides a reconciliation of the line-by-line impact of consolidating the results of those entities with the stand-alone results for Burford (i.e., if Burford-only accounted for its investment in the entities) to arrive at the totals reported in the consolidated statement of comprehensive income and consolidated statement of financial position.

(ii) The Company respectfully submits that the 1940 Act is unambiguous in its requirement that the financial statements of an issuer be considered on an unconsolidated basis for purposes of determining whether the issuer is an investment company. See 15 U.S.C. 80a-3(a)(1). Indeed, the SEC acknowledged this to be the case when it adopted Rule 3a-1 under the 1940 Act, a rule exempting certain issuers that might otherwise be subject to the 1940 Act. Investment Company Act Rel. No. 10937 (Nov. 13, 1979) (“The Act requires unconsolidated financial statements presumably because consolidation of an issuer with a subsidiary which is majority-owned, but not wholly-owned, will distort the relative value of the issuer’s investment securities to its other assets.”). Citing the legislative history of the 1940 Act, the SEC determined to require that an issuer consolidate its financial statements only with those of any wholly-owned subsidiaries. See Rule 3a-1(c) under the 1940 Act; Securities and Exchange Commission, Investment

Trusts and Investment Companies at 19 n.11 (1939). In the absence of any specific guidance from the Staff with respect to the application of the “primarily engaged” requirement for purposes of Section 3(c)(5), and in light of the 1940 Act’s clear preference for financial statements to be considered on an unconsolidated basis, the Company believes the exclusion of third party interests from its calculations is appropriate.

Notwithstanding the foregoing, as of December 31, 2019, qualifying capital provision agreements (“Qualifying Capital Provision Agreements” or “QCPAs”) held by the Company make up at least 55% of the value of the assets on the Company’s consolidated balance sheet and there have been no changes that would result in a meaningfully lower percentage of the value of the Company’s total consolidated assets represented by QCPAs from December 31, 2019 to the date hereof. As such, the Company respectfully submits that—whether assessed on a consolidated basis or after excluding third party interests—it is “primarily engaged” in the businesses referenced in Section 3(c)(5)(A) and Section 3(c)(5)(B) of the 1940 Act.

The Company is supplementally providing a schedule of all of the assets on its consolidated balance sheet as of December 31, 2019, identifying each legal finance asset by category.

As noted in the Company’s response letter dated September 10, 2020, because the Company more than satisfies the 55% test, it has not tested the assets in some of its smaller lines of business, such as its asset recovery business, and has instead assumed that all of those assets are

“bad” assets for the purposes of this analysis; if tested, the Company believes that some of those assets would be

“good” assets.

Read in the reply
Risk Factors · We are subject to the risk of being deemed an investment company, page 13
SEC asked
We note your prior response, dated September 10, 2020, relating to whether you are “primarily engaged” in the businesses referenced in Section 3(c)(5)(A) and Section 3(c)(5)(B) (the “9/10 Response”). Please advise as to what percentage of your assets is currently comprised of QCPAs (as defined in the 9/10 Response) with corporate counterparties.
Rest of the question

In providing this information, please exclude (i) QCPAs with law firms and (ii) cash proceeds of all QCPAs, regardless of the type of counterparty.

BUR answered
The Company hereby confirms that it has separately made available to the Staff on September 23, 2020, via electronic fileshare, the information requested in the Staff’s comment (the “Supplemental Information”). As noted in the cover letter that accompanied the Supplemental Information, the Company respectfully requests that, pursuant to Rule 12b-4 of the Securities Exchange Act of

1934, as amended, the Staff return, destroy or terminate access to the Supplemental Information of the Company following its review.
Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Sep 28, 2020

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 31 letters filed since 2020-07-31. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/BUR/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.