Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2021
Your Critical Accounting Estimates appear to repeat your accounting policy disclosures in Note 2. Please revise to explain why each critical accounting estimate is subject to uncertainty and, to the extent the information is material and reasonably available, how much each estimate and/or assumption has changed over a relevant period, and the sensitivity of the reported amounts to the material methods, assumptionsRest of the question
and estimates underlying its calculation. Refer to Item 303(b)(3) of Regulation S-K.
The Company acknowledges the Staff's comment and respectfully advises the Staff that it will revise future periodic filings with the SEC in response to the Staff's comment. Utilizing the disclosure from the 2021 Form 10-K, the following reflects the Company’s proposed updated draft disclosures to be included in future filings, including its Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2022.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Capitalized terms set forth in the response below that are not otherwise defined shall have the meanings ascribed to such terms in the Q2 2022 Form 10-Q.
The Company notes that since the filing of the 2021 Form 10-K there have been no changes to the selection and application of the
Company’s critical accounting policies and estimates, other than as described below under “Inventory” and “Stock-Based
Compensation.” The Company will continue to evaluate any changes that could reasonably likely impact its critical accounting estimates and will provide updated disclosures in future filings as necessary.
Critical Accounting Estimates
The preparation of the consolidated financial statements in conformity with GAAP requires us to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities, and the disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements, and the reported amounts of revenue and expenses during the reporting period.
Although we regularly assess these estimates, actual results could differ materially from these estimates. We base our estimates on historical experience and various other assumptions that we believe to be reasonable under the circumstances. Actual results may differ from our estimates if these results differ from historical experience, or other assumptions do not turn out to be substantially accurate, even if such assumptions are reasonable when made. Changes in estimates are recognized in the period in which they become known.
Critical estimates relied upon in preparing the consolidated financial statements include the determination of sales allowance and variable consideration in our revenue recognition, allowance for doubtful accounts, the impairment of long-lived assets, the capitalization of product, technology, and development costs for website development, internal-use software and hosting arrangements, the valuation of acquired assets and liabilities, the valuation and recoverability of intangible assets and goodwill, the valuation of redeemable noncontrolling interest, the recoverability of our net deferred tax assets and related valuation allowance, the valuation of inventory, and the valuation of equity and liability-classified compensation awards under ASC Topic 718, Stock-based Compensation, or ASC 718. Accordingly, we consider these to be our critical accounting estimates and believe that of our significant accounting policies, these policies involve the greatest degree of judgment and complexity.
Revenue Recognition
– Sales Allowance and Variable Consideration
The Company’s accounting policy relating to revenue recognition reflects the impact of the adoption of Accounting Standards Codification (“ASC”)
606, Revenue from Contracts with Customers (“ASC 606”), which is discussed further in the Notes to Consolidated Financial
Statements. As prescribed by ASC 606, the Company recognizes revenue based on a five-step approach. We derive revenue from three sources:
(i) marketplace revenue, which consists primarily of dealer subscriptions to our Listings packages and RPM digital advertising suite, advertising revenue from auto manufacturers and other auto-related brand advertisers, and revenue from partnerships with financing services companies; (ii) wholesale revenue, which consists primarily of transaction fees earned by CarOffer from facilitating the purchase and sale of vehicles between dealers; and (iii) product revenue, which consists primarily of aggregate proceeds received on the sale of vehicles. Critical accounting estimates associated with each of the three revenue sources are outlined below.
Total consideration for marketplace revenue is stated within the contracts. There are no contractual cash refund rights, but credits may be issued to a customer at our sole discretion. At the portfolio level, there is also variable consideration, that needs to be included in the transaction price.
Variable consideration consists of sales allowances, usage-based fees, and concessions that change the transaction price of the unsatisfied or partially unsatisfied performance obligation. We recognize that there are times when there is a customer satisfaction issue or other circumstance that will lead to a credit. Due to the known possibility of future credits, a monthly sales allowance review is performed to defer revenue at a portfolio level for such future adjustments in the period of occurrence. We establish the sales allowances at the time of revenue recognition based on our history of adjustments and credits provided to our customers. In assessing the adequacy of the sales allowance, we evaluate our history of adjustments and credits made through the date of the issuance of the financial statements.
Estimated sales adjustments, credits and losses may vary from actual results which could lead to material adjustments to the financial statements. Sales allowances are recognized as a reduction to revenue in the consolidated income statements.
Advertising contracts state the transaction price within the agreement with payment generally being based on the number of clicks or impressions delivered on our websites. Total consideration is based on output and deemed variable consideration constrained by an agreed upon delivery schedule.
Additionally, there are generally no contractual cash refund rights. Certain contracts do contain the right for credits in situations in which impressions are not displayed in compliance with contractual specifications. At an individual contract level, we may give a credit for a customer satisfaction issue or other circumstance. Due to the known possibility of future credits, a monthly review is performed to defer revenue at an individual contract level for such future adjustments in the period of incurrence. Although these credits have not been material and have not changed significantly over the historical period, estimated sales adjustments, credits and losses may vary from actual results which could lead to material adjustments to the financial statements.
Other marketplace revenue includes revenue from contracts for which the performance obligation is a series of distinct services with the same level of effort daily. For these contracts, we estimate the value of the variable consideration in determining the transaction price and allocate it to the performance obligation. Revenue is estimated and recognized on a ratable basis over the contractual term. We reassess the estimate of variable consideration at each reporting period.
Within wholesale and product transactions, there are no contractual cash refund rights, but credits may be issued to a customer at our sole discretion.
At the portfolio level, there is also variable consideration, that needs to be included in the transaction price. Variable consideration consists of sales allowances and concessions that change the transaction price of the unsatisfied or partially unsatisfied performance obligation. We recognize that there are times when there is a customer satisfaction issue or other circumstance that will lead to a credit or arbitration. Due to the known possibility of future credits, a monthly sales allowance review is performed to defer revenue at a portfolio level for such future adjustments in the period of incurrence. We establish sales allowances at the time of revenue recognition based on our history of adjustments and credits provided to our customers. In assessing the adequacy of the sales allowance, we evaluate our history of adjustments and credits made through the date of the issuance of the financial statements. Estimated sales adjustments, credits and losses may vary from actual results which could lead to material adjustments to the financial statements. Sales allowances are recognized as a reduction to revenue in the consolidated income statements.
Accounts Receivable – Allowance for Doubtful Accounts
The allowance for doubtful accounts is our best estimate of the amount of probable credit losses in our existing accounts receivable and is based upon historical loss trends, the number of days that billings are past due, an evaluation of the potential risk of loss associated with specific accounts, current conditions, and reasonable and supportable forecasts of economic conditions. We also consider current economic trends when evaluating the adequacy of the allowance for doubtful accounts. If circumstances relating to specific customers change, or unanticipated changes occur in the general business environment, particularly as it affects auto dealers, our estimates of the recoverability of receivables could be further adjusted.
Long-Lived Assets – Impairment
We evaluate the recoverability of long-lived assets, such as property and equipment and intangible assets, for impairment at least annually and whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying value of an asset may not be recoverable. During this review, we re-evaluate the significant assumptions used in determining the original cost and estimated lives of long-lived assets. Although the assumptions may vary from asset to asset, they generally include operating results, changes in the use of the asset, cash flows, and other indicators of value. Management then determines whether the remaining useful life continues to be appropriate, or whether there has been an impairment of long-lived assets based primarily upon whether expected future undiscounted cash flows are sufficient to support the assets’ recovery.
Website Development and Internal-Use
Software Costs – Capitalization
Capitalized website development and capitalized internal-use software costs are amortized on a straight-line basis over their estimated useful life of three years beginning with the time when the product is ready for intended use.
We evaluate the useful lives of these assets when each asset is ready for its intended use, and at least annually thereafter to ensure three years remains appropriate.
We also test for impairment at least annually and whenever events or changes in circumstances occur that could impact the recoverability of these assets. Impairment is evaluated as discussed in the “Long-Lived Assets – Impairment” section above.
Hosting Arrangements
– Capitalization
Hosting arrangement capitalized implementation costs are amortized on a straight-line basis over an estimated useful life of the term of the hosting arrangement, taking into consideration several other factors such as, but not limited to, options to extend the hosting arrangement or options to terminate the hosting arrangement, beginning with the time when the software is ready for intended use.
lives of these assets when each asset is ready for its intended use, and at least annually thereafter to ensure the selected useful life remains appropriate. We also test for impairment at least annually and whenever events or changes in circumstances occur that could impact the recoverability of these assets. Impairment is evaluated as discussed in the “Long-Lived Assets – Impairment” section above.
Business
Combinations
Valuation of
Acquired Assets and Liabilities
We measure all consideration transferred in a business combination at its acquisition-date fair value. Consideration transferred is determined by the acquisition-date fair value of assets transferred, liabilities assumed, including contingent consideration obligations, as applicable. We measure goodwill as the excess of the consideration transferred over the net of the acquisition-date amounts of assets acquired less liabilities assumed.
We make significant assumptions and estimates in determining the fair value of the acquired assets and liabilities as of the acquisition date, especially the valuation of intangible assets.
Intangible Assets
– Valuation and Recoverability
Intangible assets are recognized at their estimated fair value at the date of acquisition. Fair value is determined based on inputs and assumptions, such as discount rates, rates of return on assets, and long-term sales growth rates.
We amortize intangible assets over their estimated useful lives on a straight-line basis. Useful lives are established based on analysis of all pertinent factors such as: the expected use of the asset, expected useful lives of related assets, provisions that may limit the useful life, historical experience with similar arrangements, effects of economic factors, demand, competition, obsolescence, and maintenance required to maintain the future cash flows.
lives of these assets as of the acquisition date and at least annually thereafter to ensure the selected useful life remains appropriate.
We monitor our long-lived assets for impairment indicators on an ongoing basis in accordance with GAAP, and test for impairment at least annually and whenever events or changes in circumstances occur that could impact the recoverability of these assets. Impairment is evaluated as discussed in the “Long-Lived Assets – Impairment” section above.
Goodwill – Valuation and Recoverability
Goodwill is recognized when consideration paid in a purchase acquisition exceeds the fair value of the net assets acquired. Goodwill is not amortized, but rather is tested for impairment annually or more frequently if facts and circumstances warrant a review. Conditions that could trigger a more frequent impairment assessment include, but are not limited to, a significant adverse change in certain agreements, significant underperformance relative to historical or projected future operating results, an economic downturn affecting automotive marketplaces, increased competition, a significant reduction in our stock price for a sustained period or a reduction of our market capitalization relative to net book value.
We evaluate impairment annually on October 1 by comparing the estimated fair value of each reporting unit to its carrying value. We estimate fair value using a market approach, based on market multiples derived from public companies that we identify as peers. In 2021, we calculated the fair value of our reporting units using the market approach, which required us to estimate the forecasted revenue and estimate revenue market multiples using publicly available information for each of our reporting units. Developing these assumptions required the use of significant judgment and estimates. Actual results may differ from these forecasts.
Redeemable Noncontrolling Interest
– Valuation
As of January 14,
2021, the closing date of our acquisition of a 51% interest in CarOffer, or the Closing Date, redeemable noncontrolling interest was recognized at fair value computed using the Least Square Monte Carlo Simulation approach. Significant inputs to the model included market price of risk, volatility, correlation and risk-free rate.
Income Taxes – Recoverability of Deferred Tax Assets and related Valuation Allowance
In accordance with
ASC 740, “Income Taxes” (“ASC 740”), we account for income taxes under the asset and liability method. Under this method, deferred tax assets and liabilities are recognized based on temporary differences between the financial reporting and income tax bases of assets and liabilities. Deferred tax assets and liabilities are measured using enacted tax rates expected to apply to taxable income in the years in which those temporary differences are expected to be recovered or settled. A valuation allowance against net deferred tax assets is recorded when, based upon the available evidence, it is more likely than not that some or all of the deferred tax assets will not be realized. In performing this analysis, we consider future taxable income and ongoing prudent and feasible tax planning strategies to assess realizability. Actual results may differ from these forecasts. The Company continually evaluates its deferred tax assets to determine if an adjustment to the valuation allowance is required.
Judgment is required in determining our worldwide income tax provision. In the ordinary course of a global business, there are many transactions and calculations where the ultimate outcome is uncertain. Although we believe our estimates are reasonable, there is no assurance that the final outcome of these matters will not be different from that which is reflected in our historical income tax provisions and accruals. Such differences could have a material impact on our income tax provision and net income in the period in which such determination is made.
Significant judgment is involved regarding the application of income tax laws and regulations to estimate the effective income tax rates. As a result, our actual annual effective income tax rates and related income tax liabilities may differ materially from our interim estimated effective tax rates and related income tax liabilities. Any resulting differences are recorded in the period they become known.
Inventory – Valuation
Inventory is valued at the lower of cost or net realizable value. In recording inventory at the lower of cost or net realizable value, we estimate potential future losses on inventory on hand based on historical losses and market trends.
Stock-Based
Compensation – Valuation
For RSUs granted subject to market-based vesting conditions, the fair value is determined on the date of grant using the Monte Carlo simulation lattice model. The determination of the fair value using this model is affected by our stock price performance relative to the companies listed on the S&P 500, and a number of assumptions including volatility, correlation coefficient, risk-free interest rate and dividend yield.
RSUs previously granted subject to market-based vesting conditions vested upon achievement of specified levels of market conditions.
No such RSUs are currently outstanding.
For stock options, the fair value is determined on the date of grant using the Black-Scholes option-pricing model. The determination of the fair value is affected by our stock price and a number of assumptions including volatility, expected term, risk-free interest rate and dividend yield.
Stock options granted generally have a term of ten years from the date of grant and generally vest over a four-year requisite service period.
For liability-classified awards, the fair value is determined on the date of issuance using a Least Square Monte Carlo simulation model. The determination of the fair value is affected by CarOffer’s equity value, EBITDA, Excess Parent Capital (as defined in the CarOffer Operating Agreement), and revenue forecasts that drive the exercise price of future call/put rights, as well as a number of assumptions including market price of risk, volatility, correlation, and risk-free interest rate. Liability-classified awards are remeasured to fair value each period until settlement.
Prior to the three months ended June 30, 2022, a Least Square Monte Carlo simulation model was used as there were multiple potential exit valuations tied to the CarOffer purchase agreement. During the three months ended June 30, 2022, the Monte Carlo simulation model was used instead of the previous Least Square Monte Carlo simulation model as a result of obtaining gross profit actuals through the trailing twelve-month ended June 30, 2022 measuring period. During the three months ended September 30, 2022, the Company determined not to exercise the Company’s call right to acquire up to an additional 25% of the fully diluted capitalization of CarOffer. The valuation of these liability awards is now solely tied to the Company’s 2024 call right and CarOffer’s 2024 put right.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 21, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You state that credit risk with respect to accounts receivable is dispersed due to the large number of customers. However, you also state that at December 31, 2021, two customers together accounted for 65% of net accounts receivable. Please explain this apparent inconsistency or revise as necessary in future filings.
the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that although 65% of net accounts receivable as of December 31, 2021 was attributable to two customers, the remainder of the accounts receivable as of December 31, 2021 was dispersed among more thanRead in the reply
1,000 customers.
At December 31, 2021, two customers in the population of accounts receivable had greater than 10% accounts receivable balances and were disclosed as such in the 2021 Form 10-K.Rest of the answer
By way of background, the majority of the Company’s customers prepay their invoices and of the minority who do not, most of those are customers of CarOffer, LLC (“CarOffer”). Following the Company’s acquisition of a majority interest in CarOffer, the Company has seen a significant increase in its accounts receivable. To further provide context regarding the credit risk of accounts receivable, specifically as it relates to CarOffer, the Company noted on page 77 of the 2021 Form 10-K that, “The Company has had no material losses related to CarOffer receivables, as it does not release the title until successfully collecting funds from the buying dealer.” Because the Company does not release title on vehicles until funds are successfully collected as disclosed in the document, there is no significant credit risk associated with the two customers. Furthermore, the Company’s overall credit risk disclosure is intended to cover both Balance Sheet periods for the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020.
Additionally, the Company intends to clarify in future filings with the Commission that although it may have customers that have greater than 10% of accounts receivable at an applicable balance sheet date, the remainder of the accounts receivable balance is dispersed over a large number of customers and it is not exposed to credit risk.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 21, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You state that the company offsets gross trade accounts receivable with payments received in advance from a third-party processor, which appears to imply that the advance payments are netted against your accounts receivable asset account.Rest of the question
However, you also state that trade accounts related to receivables in transit from the third-party payment processor were offset by payments received in advance and resulted in a net liability. Please explain this apparent inconsistency and revise as necessary to clarify in future filings.
the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the Company leverages a third-party payment processor (the “Processor”) to collect fees from dealers for its wholesale and product offerings. Pursuant to the terms of the arrangement between the Company and the Processor, the Processor pays the Company in advance of cash collections from certain end customers.Read in the replyRest of the answer
At any point in time, the Company could have amounts due from the Processor for funds the Processor has collected from end customers but for which has not yet been remitted to the Company, as well as amounts paid by the Processor to the Company in advance of collecting payments from the end customer(s). The
Company has concluded that pursuant to ASC 210-20-45-1 it has the right and the ability to offset gross trade accounts receivable with these payments received in advance from the Processor. Therefore, on the Company’s balance sheet the Company can either have a net receivable balance due from the Processor, which is included within accounts receivable, or can have a net liability which is recorded in accrued expenses if the advance payments exceed the receivable position from the Processor as of the balance sheet date. On December 31,
2021, the Company was in a net liability position of $28,075 because advance payments from the Processor of $46,822 exceeded receivables collected by the Processor but not yet paid to the Company of $18,747. Furthermore, please refer to what the Company believes is enhanced disclosure under “Concentration of Credit Risk” on pages 7-8 in the Q2 2022 Form 10-Q.
confirms that in future filings it will revise its disclosure as necessary to clarify when the arrangement will result in a net asset versus net liability.
Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period
Ended June 30, 2022
Note 11 Segment and Geographic Information,
First report after the company's reply of Oct 21, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note that during the first quarter of fiscal 2022, you changed from two reportable segments to one as your chief operating decision maker (CODM) now assesses the company’s performance on a consolidated basis. However, you refer to the “CarOffer business” throughout your filings and state that it is evaluated separately.Rest of the question
Further, during your August 2, 2022 earnings call and in the Second Quarter 2022 Financial Results Presentation (Q2 Investor Presentation), you provide financial results that includes GAAP revenue, GAAP gross profit, non-GAAP gross profit and non-GAAP profit margin for total CarOffer, Dealer-to-Dealer and Instant Max Cash Offer (IMCO), as well as Adjusted EBITDA for CarOffer. Considering these disclosures and the financial information presented and discussed, please provide us with a detailed analysis of how you considered the guidance ASC 280-10-50 in determining that you have one reportable segment. As part of your response: • Provide us with an organization chart together with a narrative that describes your management structure. • Describe the role of each of the individuals who report to the CODM. • Tell us how often the CODM meets with his direct reports, the financial information he reviews in conjunction with those meetings, the financial information discussed and who else attends such meetings. • Describe the various forms of discrete financial information regularly reviewed by your CODM, if any, that is at a disaggregated or lower level than your consolidated results. • Explain how budgets are prepared, who approves the budget at each step of the process, the level of detail discussed at each step, and the level at which the CODM makes changes to the budget. • Describe the basis for determining the compensation for each individual that reports to the CODM. • To the extent you have aggregated certain operating segments into a single reportable segment, explain how you determined that aggregation is appropriate.
the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the Company has considered the guidance within ASC 280-10-50 in determining that it has one reportable segment. According to ASC 280-10-50-1, an operating segment is a component of a public entity that has all of the following characteristics:Read in the reply
a. It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expenses (including revenues and expenses relating to transactions with other components of the same public entity);
b.Rest of the answer
Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity's chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance; and c. Its discrete financial information is available.
The Company has six different components that consolidate into the Company’s consolidated financial statements. These multiple components consist of the Company’s
CarGurus U.S., CarGurus UK, CarGurus Canada, CarOffer, Autolist and PistonHeads websites. Each of these components meet the criteria of (a) engagement in business activities and (c) having discrete financial information; however, in evaluating criteria (b) the
Company has concluded that the Company has one reporting segment as the operating results of these six components are not regularly reviewed by the Chief Operating Decision Maker (“CODM”) to make decisions about resources to be allocated and to assess their performance, and therefore are not deemed separate operating segments.
In evaluating criteria (b), the Company respectfully advises the staff that the CODM is the Company’s Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”), Jason Trevisan.
The Company concluded that Mr. Trevisan is the CODM as he is responsible for assessing the Company’s performance and making key operating decisions. The CODM currently makes such decisions based on financial information at the consolidated Company level. The key financial information provided to the CODM is on the same basis as that presented in our filings with the Commission, and includes
Revenue (comprised of Marketplace, Wholesale and Product), Gross Profit (disaggregated by Marketplace, Wholesale and Product), Total
Income (Loss) from Operations, Consolidated Adjusted EBITDA, Consolidated Net Income, Net Income Attributable to Non-Controlling Interest and Net Income Attributable to CarGurus, Inc. These metrics are provided monthly to Mr. Trevisan on both a GAAP and a non-GAAP basis, as applicable.
· Provide us with an organization chart together with a narrative that describes your management structure.
Concurrently herewith, the Company is supplementally providing to the Staff an organizational chart on a confidential basis pursuant to Rule 83 of the
Commission’s Rules on Information and Requests (17 C.F.R. § 200.83) reflecting the Company’s management structure.
The Company’s management is led by an executive leadership team, which is comprised of the CODM and other individuals identified on page 1 of the chart (the “Executive Team”), including certain of the CODM’s direct reports. The
CODM’s direct reporting structure is set forth on page 2 in the chart. Employees at the level of Vice President and above, including divisional leaders, comprise the Company’s senior management team, which is set forth on page 3 therein.
· Describe the role of each of the individuals who report to the CODM.
The Company respectfully advises the Staff that each of the CODM’s direct reports, as identified on page 2 of the organizational chart, and their respective primary roles are as follows:
- President and Chief Operating Officer – Oversees Company-wide sales, marketing, and business operations.
- Chief
Financial Officer – Company-wide financial management and oversight over financial planning and analysis, accounting and investor relations functions. Effective October 3,
2022, Scot Fredo, the Company’s former Chief Financial Officer, separated from the
Company and Mr. Trevisan was appointed as Principal Financial Officer until such time that the Company appoints a successor Chief Financial Officer.
People Officer – Oversees Company-wide human resources including talent acquisition, learning and development, payroll, benefits and facilities.
Product Officer – Oversees Company-wide product management and development, and data integrity.
Technology Officer – Oversees Company-wide engineering, information technology, data analytics, enterprise applications and cyber security.
- General
Counsel and Corporate Secretary – Oversees all Company legal matters.
- Vice
President, Corporate Strategy – Oversees Company-wide corporate development, planning and strategy and strategic partnerships. While this individual is a direct report of the
CODM, they are not a member of the Executive Team.
· Tell us how often the CODM meets with his direct reports, the financial information he reviews in conjunction with those meetings, the financial information discussed and who else attends such meetings.
The CODM meets with the Executive
Team on a weekly basis. In addition to the Executive Team members noted above that report directly to the CODM, the Chief Marketing Officer and Executive Vice President, North American Revenue, each of whom reports to the President and Chief Operating Officer, are members of the Executive Team and attend these meetings. These meetings are strategic in nature and not intended for the review of financial information. Only Executive Team members attend these weekly meetings on a regular basis. Other attendees may join if invited by the
Executive Team for a portion of a single meeting in connection with the presentation of a specific topic, which in the past have included review of major strategic initiatives, such as forthcoming product launches, employee return-to-office plans, and the migration of data center operations.
Additionally, the CODM holds weekly one-on-one meetings with each of his direct reports. These individual meetings are not held for the purpose of reviewing financial information, but financial information is discussed from time to time as appropriate in the CODM’s meetings with each of the Chief
Operating Officer and, prior to departure, the Chief Financial Officer, for the purpose of the CODM’s assessment of the Company’s operating performance. The CODM may also review financial information at such meetings in connection with the preparation of financial and other materials for quarterly meetings of the Company’s Board of Directors (the “Board”).
the various forms of discrete financial information regularly reviewed by your CODM, if any, that is at a disaggregated or lower level than your consolidated results.
On a monthly basis, the prior month’s financial results are distributed to the CODM, as well as to certain members of the Executive Team and the Finance department.
These financial results focus on the summarized consolidated financial information discussed above that the CODM uses to assess the operating performance of the entire Company. Additional backup is provided, which includes: a GAAP and non-GAAP income statement for budget versus actual performance, which is further disaggregated by the Company’s U.S. (which includes CarGurus U.S. and Autolist), CarOffer,
UK (which includes CarGurus UK and PistonHeads) and Canada websites; a consolidated balance sheet; a consolidated cash flow statement;
and a consolidated income statement and balance sheet fluctuation analysis. Also included in the monthly financial results backup are funding metrics tied to the CarOffer Excess Parent Capital (as defined in the Third Amended and Restated Limited Liability Company Agreement of CarOffer, dated November 23, 2021, which is filed as Exhibit 10.27 to the 2021 Form 10-K, as amended by the Corrective
Amendment, dated May 6, 2022, which is filed as Exhibit 10.5 to the Company’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31, 2022 (the “CarOffer Operating Agreement”)). These funding metrics are included as part of monitoring the estimated purchase price of the Company’s 2022 and 2024 call rights related to potentially acquiring additional equity interests in CarOffer in which CarOffer Excess Parent Capital is a defined reduction to purchase proceeds. Such funding to CarOffer is made subject to the Company’s approval and is payable to the Company with interest upon the settlement of call and/or put rights set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement. This supplemental backup file is prepared for a broader distribution group, including appropriate members of the senior management team, and is not used by the CODM to make resource allocation decisions.
notes that in evaluating criteria (b) above, it considered the financial information that is provided to the CODM and how the CODM uses that financial information. In doing so, the Company considered that the financial information must be sufficiently detailed to allow the CODM to make decisions. From a decision-making perspective, the CODM does not make resource allocation decisions between any of the Company’s components. To make such allocation decisions, the CODM would require disaggregated balance sheets and cash flows at the component level to know current cash needs and projections by entity to support where such funds and resources should be allocated on a forward-looking basis. This information is not provided to the CODM. Prior to January 2022 the CODM was provided more granular financial information, including GAAP and Non-GAAP gross profit and operating margin, on a U.S. versus international basis because historically the Company’s international entities’ growth and cash burn rate was a key focus of management and investors. Non-GAAP operating margin for international closely approximated cash burn for that segment given the nature of the digital subscription products being provided. Starting in the first quarter of 2022, the financial information provided to the CODM emphasized the financials on a consolidated basis due to the de-emphasis of the Company’s international growth over the trailing two years, as the Company’s international business is now a smaller portion of the consolidated business and long-term strategy. Based on the factors above, the Company concluded that for fiscal year 2022 it had one reportable segment.
acknowledges the specific CarOffer financial information discussed during the Company’s August 2, 2022 earnings call and in its Second Quarter 2022 Financial Results Presentation (the “Q2 Investor Presentation”). In January 2021, the Company acquired a 51% interest in CarOffer pursuant to the Membership Interest Purchase Agreement dated as of December 9, 2020, as amended, by and among the Company, CarOffer and the other parties thereto, which is filed as Exhibit 2.1 to the 2021 Form 10-K, with the option to acquire portions of the remaining equity in the future. In connection with this acquisition, the Company became party to the CarOffer Operating Agreement, pursuant to which the Company has the ability to acquire the remaining 49% interest in CarOffer through the exercise of call and/or put rights set forth therein. Given CarOffer represents the Company’s most significant acquisition to date and has significant potential liquidity events (or dilution events to the extent shares are used as consideration), the Company has noticed additional attention from investors on the CarOffer business and operations. The Company respectfully advises the Staff that it believes that this focus is reasonable for a recent acquisition, especially considering the relative transaction size as well as future call and put arrangements that could have significant liquidity and/or dilution implications for the consolidated Company. The Company has provided certain supplemental information in the Q2 Investor Presentation to highlight CarOffer’s directional performance and financial metrics that could impact valuation and purchase price considerations for the Company’s potential acquisition of additional interests in CarOffer. As disclosed in the Company’s Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC on September 29, 2022
(the “September 2022 Form 8-K”), the Company determined not to exercise its call right to purchase up to an additional
25% interest in CarOffer, for which the valuation would have been based at an implied value equal to seven (7) times CarOffer’s trailing twelve months gross profit as of June 30, 2022 (as calculated in accordance with the defined terms and subject to the adjustments set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement). As discussed further below in response to the Staff’s comment number 5, the Company intends to remove several CarOffer-related disclosures and revise other CarOffer-related disclosures within its future investor presentations and supplementary earnings materials.
· To the extent you have aggregated certain operating segments into a single reportable segment, explain how you determined that aggregation is appropriate.
Aggregation of multiple operating segments was not evaluated as the Company concluded that the CODM only regularly uses consolidated financial information to make financial decisions and assess the performance of the Company’s business on a consolidated basis.
· Explain how budgets are prepared, who approves the budget at each step of the process, the level of detail discussed at each step, and the level at which the CODM makes changes to the budget.
The Company’s budgeting process is a combination of top-down and bottom-up processes. The bottom-up portion of the budget is set by the Financial Planning &
Analysis (“FP&A”) team with input from various stakeholders across the Company, including department leaders. For example, the FP&A team meets with the Company’s Chief Technology Officer to understand key upcoming development efforts, Chief Product
Officer to understand product roadmap updates, Chief Marketing Officer to determine appropriate marketing spend, as well as various other department leaders in compiling the overall budget. The CODM is not deeply involved in this portion of the budgeting process but instead focuses primarily on providing input on the consolidated top-down targets. Annual consolidated budget targets are based on input from the Executive Team, including the CODM, as well as recent business trends, then presented to the Board for consideration. Revenue and margin targets in the annual budget are set on a consolidated basis. The CODM has the ultimate decision on the overall resource allocation for the Company and exercises this decision on a consolidated basis.
the basis for determining the compensation for each individual that reports to the CODM.
advises the Staff that the determination of compensation for the Company’s Executive Team is described in detail in its Definitive
Proxy Statement, filed with the SEC on April 27, 2022. The guidelines and principles described therein are applied to each of the
CODM’s direct reports. The Company further notes that review of performance on financial targets and corporate strategic and organizational goals underlying such compensation determinations for the CODM’s direct reports is considered on a consolidated basis for the overall
Company as opposed to a component, subsidiary or division basis. For example, each fiscal year the CODM’s direct reports are eligible to earn annual cash incentive awards based on the Company’s level of achievement of one or more pre-established business and financial performance goals and the individual’s achievement of individual performance goals. For 2021 compensation decisions, the Compensation
Committee of the Board (the “Compensation Committee”) selected annual revenue and adjusted earnings before interest and taxes, a non-GAAP metric, as the financial performance measurements for such fiscal year, each of which were set on a consolidated Company basis.
In selecting these measures, the Compensation Committee determined that they were the most appropriate performance measures to use in determining cash incentive awards because, in its view, they were the best indicators of the Company’s successful execution of its annual operating plan. The financial performance goals underlying annual cash incentive award opportunities for the 2022 fiscal year have also been set on a consolidated basis for the overall Company.
Based on the factors outlined above and consideration of the guidance included within ASC 280-10-50, the Company believes that it has one reportable segment for its
2022 fiscal year.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 21, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
In addition, we refer to your measures of Dealer-to-Dealer, IMCO, and CarOffer non- GAAP gross profit and non-GAAP gross profit margin, as well as CarOffer non-GAAP net income and adjusted EBITDA included in the Q2 2022 Investor Presentation. Please tell us how each of these measures are reconciled to the most directly comparable GAAP amounts, particularly considering you have only one reportable segment.Rest of the question
Refer to Item 100(a)(1) of Regulation G.
the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the measures are reconciled to the most directly comparable GAAP amounts in the following manner:Read in the reply
· Dealer-to-Dealer, IMCO, and
CarOffer non-GAAP gross profit and non-GAAP gross profit margin:
o CarOffer,
Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO non-GAAP gross profit margin is calculated as non-GAAP gross profit for each divided by GAAP revenue for each.
Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO non-GAAP gross profit is the difference between GAAP revenue for each and GAAP cost of revenue for each, adjusted for the impacts of amortization of intangible assetsRest of the answer
and stock-based compensation expense in GAAP cost of revenue for each.
o The summation of Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO GAAP revenue and cost of revenue is CarOffer GAAP revenue and cost of revenue. CarOffer GAAP revenue and cost of revenue, including those for
Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO, are included within the Wholesale and Product revenue and cost of revenue streams in the Income Statement.
advises the Staff that it does not intend to disclose CarOffer non-GAAP gross profit and non-GAAP gross profit margins, including those for Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO, in future investor presentations or other earnings materials. The Company intends to present non-GAAP gross profit and gross profit margin for Wholesale and Product (combined), as the Company respectfully notes that the GAAP basis for these measures is presented with the disaggregation of revenue and cost of revenue on the Company’s Income Statement. The Company will provide a reconciliation for any of these non-GAAP measures in its earnings materials to the most directly comparable GAAP amounts.
The Company respectfully believes that while the CODM does not use such non-GAAP measures to assess the Company’s performance and make resource allocation decisions for the Company’s consolidated business, the disclosure of such non-GAAP measures, which reflects the exclusion of significant acquired intangible amortization as well as stock-based compensation, helps investors and analysts more accurately model the Company’s new CarOffer business.
Additionally, the
Company notes that in future SEC filings, beginning with the Company’s Q3 2022 Form 10-Q, it will further disaggregate GAAP revenue by Marketplace, Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO in the Notes to the Company’s consolidated financial statements. Please refer to additional discussion in the Company’s response to the Staff’s comment number 6 below.
· CarOffer non-GAAP net income and
Adjusted EBITDA:
o Non-GAAP
CarOffer net income (loss) is GAAP CarOffer net income (loss) adjusted for the impacts of
CarOffer amortization of intangible assets and CarOffer stock-based compensation expense.
CarOffer adjusted EBITDA is GAAP CarOffer net income (loss), adjusted to exclude: CarOffer depreciation & amortization, CarOffer stock-based compensation expense, CarOffer other expense (income), net; and CarOffer provision for income taxes.
o CarOffer
GAAP net income (loss) multiplied by the noncontrolling interest percentage agrees to the
GAAP net loss attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest in the Income Statement.
The Company notes that it does not intend to disclose CarOffer non-GAAP net income in future investor presentations or other earnings materials. While the CODM does not use an adjusted EBITDA measure to assess the Company’s performance and make resource allocation decisions for the Company’s consolidated business, the Company intends to present Adjusted EBITDA for Wholesale and Product (combined) because of the possibly significant liquidity or dilution implications of the Company’s potential acquisition of the remaining 49% interest in CarOffer in 2024. Such non-GAAP metric is highly correlated to the associated valuation and potential purchase price, which includes consideration of twelve (12) times CarOffer’s trailing twelve (12) months EBITDA as of June 30, 2024 (as calculated in accordance with the defined terms and subject to the adjustments set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement). The Company will provide a reconciliation for any such non-GAAP measures in its earnings materials to the most directly comparable GAAP amounts.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 21, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your reference to Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO throughout your August 2, 2022 earnings call and in the Q2 2022 Investor Presentation. Please tell us how these offerings relate to the three revenue sources discussed in your Form 10-Q and 10-K filings.Rest of the question
Also, explain to us why you use different terminology and alternative financial information in your investor presentations and tell us your consideration to incorporate such information in your filings to the extent it provides a better understanding of how you organize your offerings and analyze your business.
the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the Company presents Product revenue separately from Wholesale revenue as Product revenues are sales of tangible products and Wholesale revenues are revenues from services, each of which comprise greater than 10% of total revenue, as required by S-X Rule 5-03(b). Dealer-to-Dealer revenue and IMCO revenue are both included within Wholesale and Product revenue sources in the Income Statement.Read in the reply
Dealer-to-Dealer revenue is primarily included within Wholesale revenue, with vehicles acquired via arbitration included within Product revenue.Rest of the answer
As described on pages 22-23 of the Q2 2022 Form 10-Q, “Wholesale revenue includes transaction fees earned by CarOffer from facilitating the purchase and sale of vehicles between dealers, where CarOffer collects fees from both the buyer and seller.” Further, “Wholesale revenue also includes fees earned by CarOffer from performing inspection and transportation services, where CarOffer collects fees from the buyer. Inspection and transportation service revenue is inclusive of dealer-to-dealer transactions, other marketplace to dealer transactions, and customer to dealer transactions.” Additionally, with respect to the arbitration portion of Dealer-to-Dealer revenue, the Company described that “Product revenue includes the aggregate proceeds received on the sale of vehicles. This revenue relates to vehicles sold to dealers that CarOffer acquires directly from customers, inclusive of transaction fees collected from the buyer, and in limited situations across all CarOffer transactions, vehicles CarOffer resells after acquiring a vehicle via arbitration.”
IMCO revenue is primarily included within Product revenue, with the inspection and transportation portion of IMCO revenue included within Wholesale revenue. As described on pages 22-23 of the Q2 2022 Form 10-Q, “Product revenue includes the aggregate proceeds received on the sale of vehicles. This revenue relates to vehicles sold to dealers that CarOffer acquires directly from customers, inclusive of transaction fees collected from the buyer.” Additionally, with respect to the inspection and transportation portion of IMCO revenue, the Company described that “Wholesale revenue also includes fees earned by CarOffer from performing inspection and transportation services, where CarOffer collects fees from the buyer. Inspection and transportation service revenue is inclusive of dealer-to-dealer transactions, other marketplace to dealer transactions, and customer to dealer transactions.”
The Q2 2022 Investor Presentation includes disclosure of the Company’s revenue by Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO because IMCO is accounted for on a gross basis, unlike the Company’s other offerings within Product revenue, for which disclosures are prescribed under S-X Rule 5-03(b). As such, the Company believes that presenting IMCO separately from the Product line of the Income Statement helps analysts and investors better understand this product and its growth potential.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Company intends to modify its SEC disclosures to incorporate references to Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO revenue within Wholesale and
Product revenue sources in an effort to provide investors with a better understanding of how the Company organizes its offerings and analyzes its business. Additionally, the Company intends to further disaggregate revenue by Marketplace, Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO in the Notes to the Company’s consolidated financial statements in future SEC filings, beginning with the Company’s Q3 2022
Form 10-Q.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 21, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You disclose that the metrics presented exclude CarOffer because you believe such measures are not applicable for the CarOffer business or do not provide a meaningful way to evaluate the CarOffer business. Please clarify what revenue sources are considered part of the “CarOffer business” and tell us what metrics management uses to evaluate the CarOffer business.Rest of the question
In this regard, we note that you present CarOffer enrolled dealers, CarOffer total transactions and CarOffer Gross Merchandise Sales in the Q2 2022 Investor Presentation. Please revise to include these and/or any other key performance indicators that are necessary for an understanding and evaluation the CarOffer business. Refer to SEC Release 33-10751.
the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the Wholesale and Product revenues in the Income Statement are comprised of the “CarOffer business” revenues.Read in the reply
Since acquiring a 51% interest in CarOffer in January 2021, the Company has continued to evaluate the metrics management uses to evaluate the CarOffer business, including those that would potentially qualify as a key performance indicator (“KPI”).Rest of the answer
Although the Company disclosed CarOffer enrolled dealers, CarOffer total transactions and CarOffer Gross Merchandise Sales (“GMS”) in the Q2 2022 Investor Presentation, management did not consider any of these metrics to be KPIs in Q2 2022 or prior periods. As disclosed by the Company in its September 2022
Form 8-K, during September 2022 the Company determined not to exercise its call right to purchase up to an additional 25% interest in CarOffer. In connection with this determination, the Company’s management is currently assessing CarOffer’s business in light of the company’s recent financial and operating performance, which has seen significant volatility in part caused by the global semiconductor chip shortage and other compounding macroeconomic conditions. As part of this assessment, management is considering potentially relevant metrics that may be applicable for the purposes of evaluating the CarOffer business, measuring its performance, and making operational and strategic decisions. The Company endeavors to include any such metric(s) in its future SEC disclosures that are identified by management at such time(s), in accordance with SEC Release 33-10751.
Furthermore, the Company respectfully advises the Staff that it discloses GMS primarily for the convenience of analysts and investors to provide them with financial modeling support, including for purposes of providing comparative alignment with peer disclosures. Accordingly, the Company does not consider GMS as a KPI. Additionally, following further evaluation, the Company respectfully advises the Staff that it intends to revise its earnings materials beginning with reporting its Q3 2022 results to discontinue disclosure of CarOffer enrolled dealers and CarOffer total transactions, subject to management’s ongoing evaluation of such metrics, as may be applicable for subsequent periods.
advises the Staff that it will revise its future disclosures to include any of these metrics or other KPI(s) that management considers necessary for an understanding and evaluation of the CarOffer business, in accordance with SEC Release 33-10751.
Form 8-K Furnished on August 8,
First report after the company's reply of Oct 21, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your reconciliation of GAAP expense to non-GAAP expense includes a "total expenses" line item, which excludes certain GAAP expenses such as other expenses and income taxes. Please revise to exclude such total from your reconciliation or rename this line item to better describe what it represents (e.g. total cost of revenue and operating expenses).
the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that it will rename the “Total expense” line item to “Total cost of revenue and operating expenses” to better describe what it represents in future SEC filings.Read in the reply
On behalf of CarGurus, Inc., I thank you for your consideration of our response.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 21, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You state in response to prior comment 2 that you do not release the title to vehicles until successfully collecting funds from the buying dealer. Clarify whether this is when funds are received by the payment processor or the company.Rest of the question
Also, regarding your product offerings, tell us whether revenue is recognized before title is transferred to the buying dealer and, if so, how you determined transfer of control of the vehicle has occurred.
The Company acknowledges theRead in the reply
Staff's comment and respectfully advises the Staff that it will clarify in its future filings that title is released when funds are received by the payment processor. The Company notes that its payment processor also handles titling. The payment processor holds the title in escrow until it collects funds from the buying dealer (i.e., title is legally transferred from the selling party to the buying party upon signing of bill of sale, but title is held in escrow by the payment processor until payment is received).Rest of the answer
The transfer of title is administrative in nature and does not correspond to the satisfaction of the Company’s performance obligation or transfer of control of the asset.
The transfer of title process begins immediately upon signing of bill of sale and is generally completed within two to three weeks.
The Company respectfully advises the staff that it recognizes revenue related to the vehicle sale upon the signing of a bill of sale. The Company notes that a bill of sale transfers ownership from the selling party to the buying party and is the triggering event for revenue recognition. Upon signing the bill of sale, the Company and the selling party have a present right to payment and the buying party has legal rights to (can direct the use of and derive benefits from) the asset and has significant risks and rewards of ownership of the asset.
First report after the company's reply of Dec 9, 2022: 10-K filed Mar 1, 2023 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 25, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please explain the following as it relates to the information provided in your response to prior comment 4: • Describe further the strategic discussions in the weekly meetings with the Executive Team. While you state that these meetings are not intended for the review of financial information, tell us whether financial information is ever received by the CODM and discussed in the weekly Executive meetings and if so,Rest of the question
provide us a detailed description of such information. • Tell us the purpose of the weekly one-on-one meetings with the CODM’s direct reports, including whether goals and objectives are discussed. If so, tell us whether these are financial or performance goals and explain how you evaluate the progress towards meeting such goals. • Describe in detail the financial information discussed in the weekly one-on-one meetings between the CODM and the COO and CFO and how such information is used and evaluated. • Tell us whether you discuss resource allocations in these weekly meetings and/or how these meetings inform the CODM’s consideration for making resource allocation decisions, even at a consolidated level. • Tell us how the disaggregated GAAP and non-GAAP income statement information for budget versus actual performance, which you distribute each month to the CODM, Executive Team and Finance department, is used in assessing performance. Also, explain how this information impacts any decisions related to potentially acquiring additional equity interests in CarOffer and why allocation of resources for this potential future investment is not considered in your assessment of such information. • Describe the financial information this is provided to the Board of Directors for the quarterly meeting. Tell us whether the Board receives any financial information between the quarterly meetings and if so, describe such information and how often it is provided. • Explain how the top-down and bottoms-up budgeting processes are aligned. Tell us whether adjustments are made at the component level in order to meet top-down targets or whether targets are adjusted to meet component budgets, and who makes such adjustments. • Explain how you manage the budget to actual performance for the components throughout the year. Specifically address the actions taken should one of the components fail to meet their revenue or operating income budget goals in a particular period.
The Company’s weeklyRead in the reply
Executive Team meetings are almost exclusively on topics that pertain to the entire Executive Team and the Company. Most topics are people-related, followed by product decisions and updates on major go-to-market initiatives. Financial information is not a recurring or regularly discussed topic.Rest of the answer
On an ad hoc basis (e.g., less than a quarterly occurrence) Company-wide financial performance is discussed, which may include a presentation of the consolidated P&L, including product level itemization, or a draft of the subsequent year’s preliminary operating plan.
· Tell us the purpose of the weekly one-on-one meetings with the CODM’s direct reports, including whether goals and objectives are discussed. If so, tell us whether these are financial or performance goals and explain how you evaluate the progress towards meeting such goals.
Response:
All people managers at the
Company are encouraged to have periodic one-on-one meetings with their direct reports. These meetings are a two-way dialogue intended to mutually benefit both the manager and their report. The CODM’s weekly one-on-one meetings with his direct reports are focused on operational issues. The CODM discusses his direct reports’ objectives and ways he can help them better achieve them. During select one-on-one meetings twice per year, aligned with the Company-wide mid-year and year-end performance review cycles, the CODM will discuss with his direct reports their progress against their mid-year or annual objectives. These objectives involve build, launch or hiring goals in line with the Company’s Strategic Initiatives (“SIs”) for the year.
Overall achievement of SIs is one component of the Executive Team members’ annual cash incentive award. SI’s are established each year by major functional area with corresponding operational objectives; none of the SIs relates to component level financial metrics. Every employee, including members of the Executive Team is compensated based on the achievement percentage of the SIs as a whole. There are no employees who have their compensation directly tied to any subset or specific SIs. The Company has consolidated financial goals underlying each employee’s, including each Executive Team member’s, annual cash incentive award opportunities. These consolidated financial goals may vary from year to year but are all on a consolidated basis as disclosed in the annual Proxy Statement.
· Describe in detail the financial information discussed in the weekly one-on-one meetings between the
CODM and the COO and CFO and how such information is used and evaluated.
Response:
The CODM’s conversations with the COO are always focused on the entire business, the COO’s teams, and Company operations. Occasionally with the COO, and more often with the CFO, financial performance is discussed. While financials are not formally presented in these meetings, consolidated results are sometimes discussed relating to trends in the Company’s business in its entirety, specifically for consolidated revenue, gross profit and operating income. The CODM and CFO may further discuss certain areas of the business that are identified as significantly ahead of or behind plan, are in launch phases where trends are still being discerned, or which have become strategically more important.
Components of the business, such as CarGurus United Kingdom and Canada, are rarely discussed individually given their relatively small size compared to the consolidated business, the businesses are mature and operations are typically consistent with operating plans. When the CODM has discussions with the
COO regarding any specific components of the business (including CarOffer), such discussions are focused on management, strategy, operations and, more recently, operational metrics, such as inspection pass/fail rates and vehicle return rates. To the extent financial results are discussed for a specific component of the business, it is in the context of understanding consolidated revenues, gross profits and operating income. Any discussions between the CODM and COO regarding a specific component of the business, including CarOffer are to understand the current state of that business and are not intended for the purpose of resource allocation decisions.
CarOffer is not a wholly-owned subsidiary, and its CEO is responsible for running day-to-day operations as agreed to in the CarOffer Operating
Agreement. There are two instances in which resources have been moved from CarGurus to CarOffer historically. The first instance is with respect to excess Company capital funding in accordance with the terms of the CarOffer Operating Agreement. This occurs when
CarOffer has a working capital need and makes a request to the Company for funding. This funding incurs interest and is payable by
CarOffer to the Company in the form of a reduction to the purchase price upon any future exercise of the Company's call rights or
CarOffer's put rights. No such funding occurred during fiscal 2022. The only other situation in which the Company may provide financial resources to CarOffer relates to a joint product offering in which marketing spend is shared between the two entities. For this marketing spend, the Company pays the expense directly and is then reimbursed by CarOffer for its share of the spend. This is not an allocation of resources between entities but instead a reimbursement of funds. The CarOffer CEO is responsible for directing this type of spending decision along with the Company’s Vice President of Wholesale.
We note that CarOffer remains a relatively immature component of the business, which has experienced rapid growth and volatile operating results in response to changes in business operations and macroeconomic conditions. Because some revenues generated by CarOffer are generated gross, and others are generated on a net basis, the composition of the revenues generated by CarOffer’s business has a direct and significant impact on the results of the consolidated business and can vary significantly each period depending on the composition of activity. Due to its immaturity and varied results, it is sometimes necessary for the CODM to discuss with the CFO or COO the results of the CarOffer operations to better understand the consolidated results of the Company. However, as outlined above and discussed further in this letter, this component of the business is operated autonomously by the CarOffer CEO, and decisions made by the CarOffer CEO are made to allocate resources only within this specific component of the business. These resource allocation decisions are made within the parameters of the annual operating plan, which is approved by the CODM, with management towards that plan being the responsibility of the CarOffer CEO. The CEO of CarOffer is not a direct report to the CODM and does not meet with the CODM on a regular basis.
To the extent CarOffer’s results of operations are discussed between the COO and CODM, it is to understand the results in the context of a rapidly growing business with often volatile results and the impact to consolidated results. These discussions are not with the intent to and do not result in the allocation of resources to or between any component of the business, including CarOffer. We note that while CarOffer revenue is 64% of consolidated revenue for the nine months ended September 30, 2022, and gross margin percentage is highly volatile due to the aforementioned product mix with varying revenue recognition methods, overall CarOffer operating expenses through the nine months ended September 30,
2022, are not nearly as significant, representing less than 20% of consolidated operating expenses. The majority of these operating expenses for CarOffer pertain to personnel-related costs and marketing spend with all other operating expenses for CarOffer reflecting less than
5% of the Company’s consolidated operating expenses for the year-to-date period. Because CarOffer is not a fully owned subsidiary, its CEO is in charge of managing personnel related decisions and costs after their budget is set at the beginning of the year. Marketing spend relates primarily to the IMCO joint product offering and is a small proportion of the Company’s consolidated marketing budget for the year. The remainder of CarOffer’s operating expenses are very small in the context of the entire business. As a result of these factors, while the CODM reviews CarOffer results from time to time due to the nature of the business as described above, it does not warrant separate review from a resource allocation perspective.
· Tell us whether you discuss resource allocations in these weekly meetings and/or how these meetings inform the CODM’s consideration for making resource allocation decisions, even at a consolidated level.
Response:
The primary topic of discussion during these weekly meetings is the Company’s operational performance. The CODM may use information from these meetings to make company-wide allocation decisions. An example would be a company-wide request to reduce discretionary spend or slow new headcount additions in a period of economic downturn. On occasion, functional department leaders will discuss the need to allocate resources (e.g., headcount or spend) between departments. For example, a functional department leader (e.g., a Company product team lead) may recommend a resource change in a department along with the rationale and merits of doing so. The functional department leader will propose a plan of action to implement the suggested change, which may include adding or reducing resources
(e.g., headcount or spend) or if other business leaders can help fill the resource gap. If a product leader sees a product underperforming, the product leader might suggest slowing marketing spend, which would be raised and considered in these meetings.
Functional department and product leads make all allocation proposals versus being directed by the CODM. These allocation decisions are made among legacy Company products and departments and do not involve CarOffer. As outlined above and discussed in more detail below, the CarOffer CEO runs the day-to-day operations of the CarOffer business within the parameters of the approved annual operating plan and, as a result, the Company does not allocate headcount between any legacy Company products or departments and
CarOffer.
· Tell us how the disaggregated GAAP and non-GAAP income statement information for budget versus actual performance, which you distribute each month to the CODM, Executive Team and Finance department, is used in assessing performance. Also, explain how this information impacts any decisions related to potentially acquiring additional equity interests in CarOffer and why allocation of resources for this potential future investment is not considered in your assessment of such information.
Response:
The disaggregated GAAP and
Non-GAAP income statement information for budget versus actual performance is used to provide further context into the Company’s consolidated results as well as to assess the accuracy of the Company’s overall financial statements.
As discussed in the Company’s prior response to the Staff, the focus of the financial reporting package is on the consolidated financial statements, which is what the
CODM uses to assess the operating performance of the entire Company. The prior month GAAP and non-GAAP income statement for budget versus actual performance, disaggregated by the Company’s U.S. (which includes CarGurus U.S. and Autolist), CarOffer, UK (which includes
CarGurus UK and PistonHeads) and Canada websites serves to provide further context to the CODM, Executive Team and Finance department on the drivers of the Company’s consolidated results, akin to how disclosure in “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations” in the Company’s periodic SEC filings provides further context regarding drivers of changes in the Company’s consolidated income statement results. Although the backup within the financial reporting package includes a GAAP and non-GAAP income statement for budget versus actual performance on a disaggregated basis, the CODM would need further detailed information such as disaggregated balance sheets and cash flows at the component level to know current cash needs and projections by business in order to make resource allocation decisions. This information is not provided to the CODM.
With respect to accuracy of the Company’s financial statements, the disaggregated income statement information is included for and used by the broader distribution group (e.g., Finance department) as part of the Company’s internal control over financial reporting controls to compare budget versus actual and to investigate fluctuations to ensure they are not indicative of an error in the financial statements.
The Company notes that the future contractual opportunity to acquire an additional equity interest in CarOffer, or obligation to purchase the remaining interest in CarOffer, is tied to the Company’s 2024 call right, and CarOffer’s 2024 put right and based on consideration of twelve
(12) times CarOffer’s trailing twelve (12) months EBITDA as of June 30, 2024 (as calculated in accordance with the defined terms and subject to the adjustments set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement). Because of CarOffer’s put right, the decision to acquire the remaining equity stake in CarOffer is out of the Company’s control if CarOffer chooses to exercise its put option.
The financial information provided in the disaggregated GAAP and non-GAAP income statements shows directionally CarOffer’s performance but is not used to influence decisions related to potentially acquiring additional equity interests since those decisions are based on a future measurement period, which do not begin until July 1, 2023.
Within Schedule II to the CarOffer Operating Agreement, there are provisions binding the Company and CarOffer from taking or failing to take any action in bad faith for the primary purpose of reducing or minimizing EBITDA. The transaction was structured to enable CarOffer to continue operating autonomously in terms of day-to-day management, with high level oversight by the Company. While the Company has control over CarOffer and the CODM has the ultimate ability to set the CarOffer budget, the CarOffer CEO is responsible for the operation of the business to achieve budgeted results and the allocation of resources supporting those operations. While the disaggregated GAAP and non-GAAP income statement information provides directional indicators of the eventual June 30, 2024, put or call right value which is a helpful monitoring tool, the CODM does not utilize it to direct resources which could ultimately impact the value of that put or call right, or the likelihood at this time of the exercise by the Company.
Further, the Company notes that it can settle CarOffer’s remaining equity stake in cash or stock, or a combination thereof, which provides the Company with flexibility on how it would pay for such a potential future investment. Additionally, as presented in the Company’s Q3 Form 10-Q, the Company had approximately $404 million of cash equivalents as of September 30, 2022, as well as an undrawn revolving credit facility of $400 million with the ability to increase the facility an additional $250 million under certain conditions. With this significant liquidity available, the option to pay partially or entirely in stock, and the fact that the put right is ultimately out of the Company’s control, the CODM does not direct resource allocations between components to prepare for the potential future acquisition of the remaining stake in CarOffer. There are no ongoing plans or discussions related to cash availability for potential future purchases of the remaining equity stake, and projections of the future potential call or put price have no bearing on how current day Company cash or resources are allocated, particularly in light of such significant liquidity.
· Describe the financial information this is provided to the Board of Directors for the quarterly meeting.
Tell us whether the Board receives any financial information between the quarterly meetings and if so, describe such information and how often it is provided.
Response:
On a quarterly basis, the
Company regularly holds both an Audit Committee meeting and a full Board of Directors (“Board”) meeting. For these meetings, financial information is circulated to the directors in advance and then presented at the meetings. At the Audit Committee meeting, the
Company’s consolidated financial statements, including income statement (GAAP and non-GAAP), balance sheet and statements of cash flows are distributed in advance and presented each quarter.
Quarterly, the Board materials and meeting presentation deck includes financial information. Historically the focus of the financial information is the consolidated results versus plan and forecast, supplemented by breakouts such as revenue, margin, and operating profit by product line. Occasionally, when there are focus area meetings, acquisitions, and other significant impacts to the business that merit further discussion, further deep dive slides may be presented on a subset of the business.
For example, during Q3 2022, there was additional focus on CarOffer financial results and operations due to significant changes in the automotive industry and broader macroeconomic environment, including rising interest rates, which significantly decreased demand for automotive purchases. Outside of fiscal year 2020 guidance with the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, this was the first time the Company missed guidance resulting in the need for a deeper analysis to review and revise expectations for fiscal year 2022 and beyond in response to the shifting market dynamics.
Specifically, CarOffer actual financial information for Q3 2022 against forecast and prior year results was distributed in advance and presented to the Board to assist in its review and understanding of CarOffer’s recent performance decline. During Q3 2022, both revenue and margin forecasts were missed primarily due to the macroeconomic decline in wholesale prices coupled with CarOffer’s operational challenges that exacerbated arbitration, or vehicle return, losses. Because of the significant impact to the Company’s overall Q3 2022 performance, CarOffer specific financial information was provided to the Board to assist in its understanding of the underlying causes and to help the Board evaluate Company operational remedies on a go-forward basis, including CarOffer initiatives to enhance inspections and decrease arbitrations. The operational improvement initiatives discussed with the Board did not result in changes to resource allocations within the Company. These types of operational improvements are not driven by or cause any resource allocation but are rather focused on operational efficiency and formalization of processes to reduce risks in the overall consolidated operations of the Company. No funding decisions or allocation between components of the business changed as a result. Rather, these discussions highlighted the focus shift on the part of CarOffer management to tackle the operational issues that came to light in Q3. While the CODM did receive and review this information, the level of detail provided in Q3 was atypical due to the significant industry-wide changes negatively impacting the CarOffer business.
The Board does not regularly receive financial information between quarterly meetings; however, the Board or a subset of directors may receive financial and non-financial information in between meetings on an ad hoc basis for items outside of the ordinary course of business that may ultimately require the
Board’s consideration and formal approval, such as in connection with a potentially significant new strategic M&A opportunity.
The financial information provided in any such instance would be limited to the information the directors would need for evaluating the specific item in discussion.
· Explain how the top-down and bottoms-up budgeting processes are aligned. Tell us whether adjustments are made at the component level in order to meet top-down targets or whether targets are adjusted to meet component budgets, and who makes such adjustments.
Response:
Often there is alignment between the top-down targets, which the CODM provides input on, and the bottom-up budgeting process. If a target was set at the consolidated level but could not be achieved at the component level, then ultimately the top-down target may be reduced if it is not achievable. Alternatively, if there was a situation in which there was a discrepancy that could be addressed, the CODM may provide direction to the Company’s
Financial Planning & Analysis department (“FP&A”) on a consolidated basis. For example, if the bottoms-up budget resulted in lower operating margin than the top-down target set by the CODM at the consolidated level, the CODM may direct FP&A to reevaluate discretionary spend or reduce headcount growth across the Company. The CODM does not make resource allocation decisions between components but instead focuses on achievement of the Company’s overall consolidated financial results.
In its budgeting process, there are situations in which the CODM may need to look at product offerings individually since they have significantly different financial profiles. For example, the Product and Wholesale product offerings are transactional in nature, which can result in variability as volumes rise and fall, whereas Marketplace products are typically more stable and driven by recurring customer subscriptions. Additionally, it is important to understand top line revenue by product line as the product offerings have different gross versus net recognition treatment which then drives consolidated gross profit margins. As a result, the CODM considers these individual components of the business in order to understand the composition of the Company’s consolidated budget. However, in performing this review there is never a decision made to allocate any resources away from one component to affect the financial results of another. Any adjustments to strategy are made holistically and on a consolidated basis. The CODM ultimately reviews the Company’s budget holistically to ensure that the consolidated view is moving the entire business in the desired direction. If the CODM determines that the consolidated budget is inappropriate from a top-down perspective, he will direct the team to make further changes on a consolidated basis to achieve those top-down targets. Refer to the next question for further discussion of changes made to the budget or forecast at a component level by FP&A and functional leaders.
· Explain how you manage the budget to actual performance for the components throughout the year. Specifically address the actions taken should one of the components fail to meet their revenue or operating income budget goals in a particular period.
Response:
Within the disaggregated income statements, the budget versus actual for the CarGurus US, UK, Canada and CarOffer components is intended to support the Company’s consolidated budget versus actual. At the beginning of each year the Company establishes its operating plan. This is a defined target and is monitored against actual performance throughout the year. The Company additionally tracks forecasts throughout the year, which provide revised estimates based on how the entire business is performing. If a component is failing to achieve against the operating plan, the Company’s forecast would be reduced to take into account revised expectations for that component by FP&A in coordination with the functional leaders. The CODM obtains the latest consolidated forecast information with supplemental backup as part of quarterly
Board meeting preparation and may receive one additional forecast update within the quarter. Although the forecast updates often include supporting detail, the CODM will focus his review on the consolidated updates, and analyze disaggregated backup as needed to understand the changes.
Forecast adjustment decisions are made at the functional department leader level and not by the CODM. For example, CarOffer’s CEO leads the day-to-day operations of the CarOffer business and therefore makes decisions within its business, such as product pricing, marketing spend and headcount targets.
These decisions are made by the CarOffer CEO within the broader context of the budget compiled in the consolidated process. For example, as of September 30, 2022, the Company had excess inventory related to its Instant Max Cash
Offer (“IMCO”) product, driven by weakening macroeconomic demand for vehicle purchases. As a result, the CarOffer CEO determined to reduce its IMCO-related marketing to save expenses and slow vehicle acquisition. This decision was made by CarOffer in alignment with appropriate members of the Company’s senior management team (e.g., VP level). Similarly, in the past and particularly during the
COVID-19 pandemic, the Company has reduced its search engine marketing expenditures due to declining dealer demand for its Marketplace products. Given the differing nature of these products, functional leaders strategically target spend reductions instead of enacting blanket marketing spend reductions across the Company. As such, while there are times in which component spend is adjusted given market conditions, these are infrequent, but necessary because the market conditions impact some components differently.
The Company further notes that the CODM does not make resource allocations between components if one component is outperforming against another. For example, CarOffer had a strong first half of 2022 followed by a challenging third quarter. If the CODM were making resource decisions based on component performance, this would have been evident during these swings; however, the funding by the Company to CarOffer pursuant to the applicable terms of the CarOffer Operating Agreement as discussed in the Company’s prior response to the Staff has not changed at any point as a result of performance and has not exceeded the initial funding amount from fiscal year 2021. Further, at no point during these changes in performance did the company make any changes to headcount between components or allocate spending between any components in the business.
Despite occasional occurrences in which a more granular review and adjustment may be warranted by functional team leaders, the CODM’s focus is on the Company’s consolidated performance, and this aligns with how management is compensated as the financial performance goals underlying annual cash incentive award opportunities for fiscal year 2022 are set on a consolidated basis for the overall Company, the details of which are disclosed in the annual Proxy Statement.
First report after the company's reply of Dec 9, 2022: 10-K filed Mar 1, 2023 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 25, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to prior comment 5 regarding the non-GAAP measure of Adjusted EBTIDA for Wholesale and Product (combined). We also note the Adjusted EBTIDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest measure and related disclosures included in the September 30, 2022 Form 10-Q. Please address the following regarding these measures: • Further explain the usefulness and relevance of these measures.Rest of the question
With regard to Adjusted EBTIDA for Wholesale and Product (combined), explain how this performance measure addresses possible liquidity or dilution implications for your potential acquisition of the remaining 49% interest in CarOffer. In this regard, it is unclear how this current measure is correlated to the potential purchase price to be determined in 2024 and why it is useful or relevant information at this time. • You refer to CarOffer's trailing 12 months EBITDA as of June 30, 2024 as calculated in accordance with defined terms and subject to the adjustments set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement. Tell us where such calculation is defined in the CarOffer Operating Agreement and clarify whether the measure presented is calculated as defined in the Operating Agreement. • You state on page 22 that you use Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest to evaluate your operating performance and trends and make planning decisions. Explain why you evaluate a portion of CarOffer that you do not own and how that information is useful to investors. • Further explain how you determine and calculate the adjustments in the measures. In this regard, you appear to exclude portions of certain expenses and disclose that they are adjusted to reflect the noncontrolling shareholder's 38% share of earnings and losses in CarOffer. Since the company owns 51% of CarOffer, explain why the noncontrolling interest “share” is not 49% and provide any supporting documentation.
Staff's comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the measure of Adjusted EBTIDA for Wholesale and Product (combined) materially consists of CarOffer’s Adjusted EBITDA. The Company’s 2024 call right and CarOffer’s 2024 put right tied to the remainingRead in the reply
49% equity stake in CarOffer is based on an enterprise value of twelve (12) times CarOffer’s trailing twelve (12) months EBITDA as of June 30, 2024 (as calculated in accordance with the defined terms and subject to the adjustments set forth in the CarOffer
Operating Agreement).Rest of the answer
Adjusted EBITDA for Wholesale and Product (combined) approximates the Second Determination Date trailing twelve
(12) months EBITDA per the CarOffer Operating Agreement.
The Company believes that providing this measure enables investors to model CarOffer’s EBITDA trends, which may be meaningful for forecasting the potential
2024 purchase price, and could have material liquidity and/or dilution implications for the Company if either party exercises its respective option. While this measure provides investors with directional levels to model future liquidity needs, the 2024 put/call right is based on a future measurement period and subject to other adjustments such as excess parent capital. The Company does not intend to provide forward-looking data for CarOffer, and as such providing the measure of Adjusted EBITDA for Wholesale and Product (combined) is the best proxy investors have for modeling purposes. The Company notes that this metric is currently meaningful as the Company is within one year of the measurement period and that it will be increasingly meaningful moving into the second half of fiscal year 2023 when the twelve-month measurement period for CarOffer’s EBITDA commences.
Additionally, although the
Company presents a metric that materially consists of CarOffer’s Adjusted EBITDA, the CODM does not use this information to perform resource allocations and does not manage the business separately as discussed in the responses above. This measure is only indicative of directional financial performance and does not impact decisions by the CODM related to potentially acquiring additional equity interests in CarOffer since those decisions are based on a future measurement period and subject to other adjustments such as excess parent capital.
This measure is presented for investors modeling purposes as there is large put/call right that will eventually expire in 2024. After such potential additional investment in CarOffer in 2024, the Company intends to cease disclosure of this Adjusted EBITDA for Wholesale and Product (combined) metric, as there would no longer be material liquidity and/or dilution implications for the Company related to the initial CarOffer acquisition arrangement.
Please see the following excerpt from page 94 of the 2021 Form 10-K regarding the calculation of this potential future purchase price:
In the second half of 2024, (a) the
Company will have a call right (the “2024 Call Right”), exercisable in its sole discretion, to acquire all, and not less than all, of the Remaining Equity that it has not acquired pursuant to the 2022 Call Right and the Closing, at the greater of (i) (x) one hundred million dollars ($100,000,000), and (y) the 2022 Call Right Value, whichever is less, and (ii) an implied CarOffer value of twelve (12) times CarOffer’s trailing twelve months EBITDA as of June 30, 2024 (in each case calculated in accordance with the defined terms and subject to the adjustments set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement), and (b) the representative of the holders of the Remaining Equity will have a put right (the “2024 Put Right”), exercisable in his, her or their sole discretion, to have the holders of the Remaining Equity sell to the Company, all, and not less than all, of the Remaining Equity at an implied CarOffer value of twelve (12) times CarOffer’s trailing twelve months EBITDA as of June 30, 2024 (calculated in accordance with the defined terms and subject to the adjustments set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement). The determination of whether the 2024 Call
Right or the 2024 Put Right is ultimately exercised is as set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement. The consideration to be paid by the Company in connection with the exercise of either the 2024 Call Right or the 2024 Put Right, as applicable, will be in the form of cash and/or shares of Company Class A Common Stock, as determined by the Company in its sole discretion.
· You refer to CarOffer's trailing 12 months EBITDA as of June 30, 2024 as calculated in accordance with defined terms and subject to the adjustments set forth in the CarOffer Operating Agreement. Tell us where such calculation is defined in the CarOffer Operating Agreement and clarify whether the measure presented is calculated as defined in the Operating Agreement.
Response:
Staff's comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the calculation is defined in the Annex I, Call and Put Provisions, to the CarOffer
Operating Agreement, which is filed as Exhibit 10.27 to the 2021 Form 10-K, as amended by the Corrective Amendment, dated May 6,
2022, which is filed as Exhibit 10.5 to the Company’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31,
2022.
The measure of Adjusted EBITDA for Wholesale and Product (combined) is not calculated exactly as defined in the CarOffer Operating Agreement but is directionally in line with such definition. As noted in the above response, the Company believes that disclosure of this directional measure assists analysts and investors with financial modeling support.
· You state on page 22 that you use Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest to evaluate your operating performance and trends and make planning decisions. Explain why you evaluate a portion of CarOffer that you do not own and how that information is useful to investors.
Response:
Staff's comment and respectfully advises the Staff that Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest is used by management for the purpose of understanding the adjustment from the Company’s definitions of Consolidated Adjusted EBITDA to Adjusted
EBITDA. It enables an investor to gain a clearer understanding of the portion of Consolidated Adjusted EBITDA that is not attributable to the Company.
The Company’s presentation for Adjusted EBITDA metrics is intended to mirror the Company’s unaudited condensed consolidated income statements included in the
Q3 2022 Form 10-Q, which presents consolidated net income, net (loss) income attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest and net income attributable to the Company.
Furthermore, because the Company’s reconciliations of Consolidated Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDA include a non-GAAP measure within, Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest, the Company believes it is appropriate to provide a separate reconciliation of this non-GAAP measure to a GAAP measure. Therefore, the Company’s reconciliation of Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest reconciles from the GAAP measure of net (loss) income attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest to Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest.
The Company will further clarify in future filings with the SEC that the Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest is presented and used by management to help reconcile these two aforementioned non-GAAP metrics and is not intended to be used on its own.
· Further explain how you determine and calculate the adjustments in the measures. In this regard, you appear to exclude portions of certain expenses and disclose that they are adjusted to reflect the noncontrolling shareholder's 38% share of earnings and losses in CarOffer. Since the company owns 51% of CarOffer, explain why the noncontrolling interest “share” is not 49% and provide any supporting documentation.
Response:
The
Company acknowledges the Staff's comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the Company’s definition of Adjusted EBITDA is intended to reflect Adjusted EBITDA attributable to the Company. For the reconciliation of Adjusted EBITDA, the Company begins with consolidated net income, adds back the non-GAAP items as defined by the Company in the Q3 2022 Form 10-Q, and arrives at a Consolidated Adjusted EBITDA subtotal. This subtotal reflects what the Company’s Adjusted EBITDA would be if the
Company owned 100% of CarOffer. Since the Company does not own 100% of CarOffer, the Company makes an adjustment to remove Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest in deriving Adjusted EBITDA attributable to the Company.
The Company notes that Adjusted
EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest is calculated and presented separately to provide clarity to the reader with a reconciliation from GAAP net (loss) income attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest. For this calculation, the Company begins with net (loss) income attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest, adds back non-GAAP items as defined by the Company in the Q3
2022 Form 10-Q, and arrives at Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest. These amounts and add-backs specific to the redeemable noncontrolling interest are calculated by taking CarOffer’s full financial results and multiplying each line item in the reconciliation by 38%.
As previously discussed, the measure of Adjusted EBTIDA for Wholesale and Product (combined) materially consists of CarOffer’s Adjusted EBITDA. The Company notes that Adjusted EBITDA for Wholesale & Product (combined) is calculated as Adjusted EBITDA attributable to redeemable noncontrolling interest divided by 38%.
The Company notes that it uses 38%, versus 49%, to allocate the share of income (loss) because it reflects the percentage shared between the Company and the redeemable noncontrolling interest. The 38% is exclusive of CO Incentive Units, Subject Units, and 2021 Incentive Units liability-classified awards which do not participate in the share of income/(loss).
First report after the company's reply of Dec 9, 2022: 10-K filed Mar 1, 2023 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 25, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note from your response to prior comment 7 that you intend to discontinue providing information regarding enrolled dealers and total transactions for the CarOffer business from your earnings materials. It remains unclear how you determined that metrics such as CarOffer enrolled dealers, total transactions and gross merchandise value are not applicable for purposes of evaluating the CarOffer business.Rest of the question
In this regard, you refer to such measures qualitatively when explaining changes in revenue and cost of revenue for your wholesale and product revenue streams. For example, in the June 30, 2022 Form 10- Q, you indicate that the increase in wholesale revenue and cost of revenue was primarily due to an increase in transactions. In the current Form 10-Q, you attribute the increase in product revenue and cost of revenue to an increases in IMCO transactions and an increase in proceeds and buy fees received through IMCO transactions and the sale of vehicles acquired in arbitration. As such it would seem that providing quantitative information regarding the number of transactions, gross merchandise value, etc. would be necessary to enhance a reader's understanding of your results of operations discussion. Please explain further or provide us with the specific quantitative measures that you intend to provide as it relates to the portion of your business that comprises approximately 64% of total revenue to date in fiscal 2022.
Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that, following further evaluation, management intends to revise its future SEC disclosures, to include a new transactions-based key performance indicator (“KPI”) in accordance with the Commission’s interpretive guidance on MD&A published in 2020.1 The Company currently expects that this new KPI will primarily reflectRead in the reply
Dealer-to-Dealer and IMCO transactions that are included within the Company’s Wholesale and Product revenues.
First report after the company's reply of Dec 9, 2022: 10-K filed Mar 1, 2023 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 25, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note from your disclosures on page 50 that your Chief Financial Officer resigned on October 3, 2022. You also state in Note 13 that Mr. Yann Gellot, the Principal Accounting Officer, announced his intent to resign. It does not appear that you have filed any Item 5.02 Forms 8-K to disclose these resignations. Please advise or revise.
Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that disclosures of such resignations of the Company’s former Chief FinancialRead in the reply
Officer and Principal Accounting Officer were made in the Company’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30,
2022 (the “Q2 2022 Form 10-Q”) and the Q3 2022 Form 10-Q, respectively, in accordance with Item 5(a) of Form 10-Q.
The Company respectfully draws the Staff’s attention to page 53 of the Q2 2022 Form 10-Q and page 59 of the Q3 2022
Form 10-Q.Rest of the answer
As requisite disclosures of such resignations were made under Item 5 of Form 10-Q, the Company respectfully does not believe that they need to be repeated in reports on Form 8-K.
Commission Guidance on Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, Release
33-10751 (Jan. 30, 2020).
On behalf of CarGurus, Inc., I thank you for your consideration of our response. If you have any questions regarding any of the responses in this letter, please contact the undersigned at (617) 354-0068.
First report after the company's reply of Dec 9, 2022: 10-K filed Mar 1, 2023 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 25, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: request for more time, Oct 11, 2022, request for more time, Nov 16, 2022, company letter, Feb 17, 2023, closing letter, 2023-02-23