to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant notes the following regarding the roles and responsibilities of each of the Chief
Executive Officer (“CEO”), President-Waterworks and President-Fire Protection, consistent with the Registrant’s conclusion of a single operating segment in accordance with ASC 280:
The CEO develops and drives the strategic direction and allocation of resources of the Registrant and maintains responsibility for interaction between the Registrant and the Registrant’s board of directors (the “Board”).
Rest of the answer
The CEO’s specific significant responsibilities include:
•
Serve on the Board and maintain relationships with the Registrant’s private-equity ownership, including the
Chairman of the Board as well as its independent directors;
Review and approve the Registrant’s long-term strategic plan that is developed by the Vice President,
Corporate Development;
Evaluate and recommend to the Board specific acquisition transactions that he believes are consistent with the long-term strategic plan;
Determine what strategic initiatives (including expansion to new geographic areas or expansion to adjacent product categories) the Registrant will pursue through either organic growth or acquisition;
Evaluate and approve capital structure financing proposals put forth by the Chief Financial Officer
(“CFO”);
Review and approve the Registrant’s consolidated operating and capital budgets, which are prepared by the
CFO;
Approve the hiring and compensation model associated with all equity eligible associates, generally Director
(i.e., internal employees generally reporting to Vice Presidents) level and above;
Review and approve annual compensation programs, including annual merit awards, incentive compensation programs
– including specific compensation of senior leadership team members – and employee benefit programs (i.e., health insurance, retirement plans, etc.);
Approve company-wide health, safety, compliance and employment policies and programs;
Evaluate the overall financial performance of the Registrant against formal goals and objectives; and
Communicate with investors and the Board regarding the operating performance of the Registrant.
President – Waterworks
The President-Waterworks manages various direct reports who support the distribution of infrastructure products (including pipes, valves & fittings and storm drainage product lines) and the vendor relations/sourcing function. In this role, the President-Waterworks manages the Registrant’s vendor relationships that account for approximately 99% of the products the
Registrant procures across all product lines (including the fire protection product line) and is responsible for negotiating purchasing incentive programs that are a significant profit driver for the Registrant. In addition, he is responsible for the national customer accounts group across all product lines. Further the President-Waterworks collaborates with and supports the President-Fire Protection in driving growth in meter products (which represents approximately 10% of total company sales) and private label products, which span across all branches and geographies. The Registrant notes that many of these responsibilities extend beyond just managing specific product lines and branches.
President – Fire Protection
The President-Fire Protection manages various direct reports who support the distribution of fire protection products and the distribution of the meter product line primarily through waterworks-centric branches, which meter products represent approximately 10% of total company sales. Further, he manages the Registrant’s growing private label initiative, as described in the
Registration Statement under “Prospectus Summary—Our Strategies—Execute on Gross Margin Initiatives”, for waterworks infrastructure and fire protection products.
Both Presidents also have certain shared or common responsibilities, which include the following:
Drive communication and adoption of strategic initiatives of the CEO through the Registrant’s nationwide network of branches;
Manage various direct reports, some of whom are divided by geography to facilitate an efficient organizational structure, and provide operational support as needed to assist in resolving customer relationship, contractual and employee matters;
Approve the hiring and compensation structure of lower-level positions including branch and district managers;
Partner with various company-wide shared service resources, including, but not limited to, legal, human resources, credit, cash application and accounts payable;
Partner with the company-wide integration team (that reports through the CFO) to support the integration of acquisitions; and
Support the acquisition diligence process, led by the centralized team under the Vice President, Corporate
Development reporting to the CEO, regarding potential acquisition targets, including evaluating vendor relationships and interacting with the target’s management;
To further the Staff’s understanding of the leadership and their roles and responsibilities in the Registrant’s conclusion of a single operating segment, the Registrant presents the following evaluation regarding the determination of the chief operating decision maker (“CODM”), whom the Registrant identified in its letter dated May 21, 2021 to be CEO
Stephen O. LeClair. In determining the CODM, the Registrant considered decisions that it believes represent some of the most significant decisions related to the allocation of resources that the CODM makes:
Key Resource
Allocation
Decisions
Responsible Party
Personnel decisions, including compensation structure
Personnel decisions at or above the Director level are made by the CEO. Mr. LeClair is the ultimate decision maker with regards to the hiring and firing of key personnel (including Executive Leadership Team (“ELT”) members), incentive compensation structure, and the issuing of equity grants. Within the Registrant’s delegation of authority, the CEO must approve the hiring or promotion of any employee that is equity eligible. This generally relates to any individual with a “Director” level title or higher (which approximates 50 employees across the total company). This demonstrates the CEO’s engagement in the allocation of key resources across the total company. In addition, variable compensation plans for all members of the ELT, including the President-Waterworks and President-Fire Protection are determined by the CEO and based on total company financial performance, not an aggregation of branches or product lines.
By contrast, the President-Waterworks and the President-Fire Protection only have independent autonomy to approve hiring, firing and compensation decisions below the Director level.
Review and approval of the annual operating budget
The annual total company budget process is a critical tool in managing the allocation of resources of the organization. The CEO is engaged with the CFO in the budget process, including setting the key metrics to be used for building the budget. Further, as discussed in the Registrant’s prior letter, the CEO reviews and approves the total company annual budget and recommends it to the Board for final review and approval.
Neither of the Presidents is responsible for the approval of the annual operating budget, as this responsibility rests with the CEO.
Recommendation of proposed mergers and acquisitions
All potential transactions are initially identified, evaluated and led by the Vice President, Corporate Development and the various functional department leaders. Each target is summarized and reviewed with the ELT throughout the diligence process. Upon completion of diligence and financial modeling, the Vice President, Corporate Development and the ELT present to the CEO the final summary of the business opportunity, financial terms and findings/risks from the diligence process. Based on this information, the CEO makes a final determination whether to approve the project and proceed with a recommendation to the Board for approval.
Each President provides input on the product lines (i.e., pipes, valves & fittings, meters, fire protection and storm drainage) and initiatives they are responsible for, but they do not make decisions related to acquisition activity regardless of size. Based on the product line, initiative or geographic opportunities, this may require close coordination between the Presidents.
Treasury decisions regarding capital structure
The day-to-day operations of the treasury function are overseen by the CFO. However, the CEO is responsible for approving and recommending to the Board key decisions surrounding this function, most notably decisions regarding matters such as debt issuances and retirements, increases in borrowing availability and execution of interest rate hedging instruments.
Neither of the
Presidents is involved in decisions regarding the capital structure of the Registrant at any level.
Annual merit compensation
As employee compensation costs and benefits represent the largest expense category after cost of goods sold, the annual merit and benefits process represents a significant allocation of resources. The CEO receives input from the CFO and Chief Human Resources Officer (“CHRO”) regarding a recommended company-wide merit percentage increase; however, the CEO makes the final determination regarding the overall merit percentage increase. The CEO further reviews and approves recommendations from the CHRO and CFO regarding potential benefit program changes that impact employees across the total company.
Each President is only allowed to make changes within their allocated merit pool, which is based upon application of the CEO approved company-wide merit percentage to existing compensation costs.
Organization of administrative functions
The CEO has established a structure whereby the various administrative support functions (e.g., legal, human resources, finance, corporate development, IT, etc.) report via members of the ELT to the CEO. These functions all serve to support the total company.
Neither of the Presidents has these administrative support functions built into his respective product lines.