The Company performed an analysis of all of its arrangements that the Company i) holds an economic interest, voting right or similar rights in the entity, or obligations to that entity; ii) has issued a guarantee with respect to that entity;
iii) transferred assets to the entity; iv) manages the assets of the entity; and/or v) leases assets from the entity or provides it with financing to determine whether the arrangements would qualify as variable-interest entities (“VIEs”) and the appropriate accounting for such arrangements (i.e. consolidation, equity method of accounting).
Rest of the answer
The Company identified four joint venture entities which were VIEs.
Three of the four joint ventures, collectively referred to as the “Three Joint
Ventures,” have partnership and management agreements with the same joint venture partner and purposes that are nearly identical. The Three Joint Ventures were formed as limited liability companies with the sole purpose to invest in, own, develop, redevelop and hold for long term capital appreciation in industrial real estate. Since the main objective for each of the Three Joint Ventures is to buy and develop real estate assets, each would require significant contributions from its partners to sustain itself for the initial years of the venture. Accordingly, it was determined that the equity investment at risk was not sufficient to finance their respective activities without additional financial support. The fourth joint venture (the “Fourth Joint Venture”) was formed to invest in, own, operate and hold for long term capital appreciation interests in certain single tenant, net leased properties, with a majority of the business activities to be financed by third-party debt. At inception of this venture it was determined that the entity was not a VIE;
however, subsequently it was determined that the entity was a VIE because during 2009 certain third party mortgage lenders were granted the ability to make substantive decisions.
For the joint venture entities considered VIEs, the Company performed an assessment of which partner would be considered the primary beneficiary. This assessment is based upon which partner (a) had the power to direct matters that most significantly impact the activities of the VIEs, and (b) had the obligation to absorb losses or the right to receive benefits of the VIEs that could potentially be significant to the VIE based upon the terms of their respective partnership and management agreements.
Primary Beneficiary Review — the Three Joint Ventures
The Company reviewed the governing agreements for the Three Joint Ventures to determine the powers given to the respective parties to the agreements. The following documents were reviewed in detail for each joint venture:
o
Operating Agreement
Development Agreement
Management Agreement
Leasing Agreement
Credit Agreements
Based on the review it was determined that the following power/decision rights over activities which significantly impact the economic performance of the Three Joint
Ventures are equally shared by the Company and our partner:
Acquiring projects;
Selling, assigning or transferring projects;
Initiating member capital calls;
Approving operating budgets, development plans and leasing plans;
Approving material variances from approved budgets or plans, including changes in development scope and lease negotiations;
Executing new financing and modifications to existing financing;
Engaging alternate service providers, including project contractors associated with development plans;
Revising any existing asset or property development, management or leasing agreement or any service agreement;
Approving or rejecting proposed tax elections or settlements;
Withdrawing the Company from its role as manager;
Transferring of Member interest in the entity;
Final dissolution of the entity.
However, it was determined that our partner in the Three Joint Ventures has the power/decision right associated with securing all of the entity’s third party debt.
At our partner’s sole discretion, its portion of capital contributions serves as collateral for the financing. Failure by our partner to so collateralize would preclude the Three Joint Ventures from obtaining financing because even in a normalized market, the Three Joint Ventures would not be able to secure conventional financing without this collateral, making this a key power over which only our partner presides.
Primary Beneficiary Review — the Fourth Joint Venture
The Company carried out a similar review related to the Fourth Joint Venture. The following documents were reviewed in detail:
Amended and Restated Master Agreement
Amended and Restated Operating Agreement
Mortgage Agreements activities which significantly impact the economic performance of the Fourth Joint
Venture are equally shared by the Company and our partner:
Amending or revising the existing agreements;
Approving operating budgets for the majority of the buildings;
Approving leasing plans for the majority of the buildings;
Approving development plans;
Transferring of Member interest in the entity.
However, based on the review it was determined that the following key power/decision rights are held solely by our partner in the Fourth Joint Venture:
Majority of members of Board;
Approving material variances from approved budgets or plans on a majority of the properties;
Approving material changes in lease provisions; and
Approval of any agreement or investment which would cause the venture to earn interest income.
Additionally, based on our review of the Fourth Joint Venture’s mortgage agreements the following key power/decision rights are granted to the mortgage lenders for some of the properties:
Approving leases or amendments to existing leases;
Approval of operating budgets; and
Approval of expenditures not already included in an approved budget.
Based on the detailed analysis the Company performed, the Company concluded that it did not hold the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact economic performance for any of the Three Joint Ventures or the Fourth Joint
Venture. ASC 810 dictates that the primary beneficiary must have both of the characteristics (a) and (b) above. As the Company concluded that it did not meet characteristic (a) for either the Three Joint Ventures or the Fourth Joint Venture, the Company was and is not the primary beneficiary of any of its joint ventures.
Accordingly, the Company continued to account for the joint ventures under the equity method of accounting. Additionally, since the Company was able to conclude that it did not meet characteristic (a), it did not analyze the fees it earns related to the joint ventures, which would have been analyzed under characteristic
(b).