As stated in the Company's response herein to comment 5, the loan classes for financial statement purposes are based on the purpose of the loan and not the type of collateral reported for bank regulatory classification purposes on Page 44 of the Company's Form
for the fiscal quarter ended September 30, 2012.
At December 31, 2012, the Company's home equity loans totaled $403.9 million or 11.89% of the Company's total loans of $3.397 billion, compared to $406.9 million or 11.94% of the Company's total loans of $3.408 billion at September 30, 2012.
Rest of the answer
allowance as a percentage of the Company's home equity loan portfolio was 2.64% compared to 2.45% as of September 30, 2012.
At December 31, 2012, the total allowance as a percentage of the Company's residential real estate loan portfolio class was 3.00% compared to 3.27% as of September 30, 2012. The Company does not believe that the Company's total allowance for its residential real estate portfolio loan class is indicative, i.e., predictive of the probable credit losses in the Company's home equity loan portfolio class.
In originating home equity loans, the Company has not engaged in programmatic subprime home equity lending or originated higher risk home equity products.
As of September 30, 2012, the Company's $406.9 million of home equity loans consist of 1-4 family junior lien mortgages and first and junior lien lines of credit ("HELOC") secured by residential real estate. Approximately 20% of the home equity loans are closed-end, amortizing loans and 80% are open-end, revolving HELOCs. The home equity loan portfolio consists of 64% variable interest rate and 36% fixed interest rate loans. Approximately 50%, or $203.5 million of the home equity loans, are in a first lien status with the remaining 50%, or $203.5 million, in junior lien status.
HELOCs are generally originated with maturity terms from 10 to 15 years. At origination, borrowers can choose a variable interest rate or fixed interest rate for the full term of the line of credit, or a fixed interest rate for the first 3 or 5 years from origination which then converts to a variable interest rate for the remaining term of the HELOC. The draw period usually exists from origination to the maturity of the HELOC. During the draw period, a borrower with a variable interest rate term has the option of converting to a fixed interest rate for all or a portion of the remaining term to maturity. During the draw period, the Company has home equity lines of credit where the borrowers pay interest only and home equity lines of credit where borrowers pay principal and interest.
For home equity loans originated by the Company in a subordinated lien position where the Company does not also hold the first lien, the Company is not typically notified about the status of the first lien position subsequent to origination. Information about the first lien status is limited to that which can be obtained from external sources. The Company has not contracted with a third-party service provider to provide updated loan, lien, and collateral data in recognition that the Company's volume of junior lien loans and HELOCs, i.e., $203.5 million at September 30, 2012 is (1) insignificant compared to the Company's entire loan portfolio of $3.4 billion, and (2) is expected to continue to decline in terms of both the outstanding balance and as a percentage of the Company's total loan portfolio (as noted later in this response).
Therefore, the Company does not track whether the default and delinquency statistics for its home equity loan class where it holds the first lien position shows a different trend than situations where the Company does not hold the first lien position. The Company monitors the delinquency and default status of the first lien position when a foreclosure or bankruptcy notice is filed with respect to the first lien loan or the Company obtains a credit report (e.g., due to the delinquency status of the Company's junior lien loan or HELOC) that details the status of the first lien position.
The allowance methodology and analysis applied to each of the Company's loan classes, including the home equity loan class, consists of a specific allocation for loans identified as impaired and a general allocation component for probable credit losses inherent in the balance of each loan class. When available information confirms that specific junior lien mortgages and junior lien HELOCs or portions thereof are uncollectible, such amounts are promptly charged-off against the allowance. The Company places junior lien mortgages and junior lien HELOCs on non-accrual status when it has evidence that the associated senior lien is 90 days past due or in the process of foreclosure, regardless of the junior lien delinquency status.
Where the Company is in the junior lien position, the Company addresses the lack of available information about the performance of the first lien loans through the general allocation component of the allowance for the home equity loan class. The adequacy of the general component of the allowance for home equity lending is evaluated by the Company based on the home equity loan class' previous 12 consecutive calendar quarters, i.e., a rolling 3 year historical loss experience adjusted for trends and changes in 9 environmental factors applicable to the Company's unimpaired home equity lending portfolio. More specifically, the adequacy of the general component of the allowance for home equity lending is determined by the Company based on the historical loss experience adjusted by the combination of the 9 environmental factors rather than isolation of any one environmental factor. The 9 environmental factors are identified in the Allowance for Loan and Lease Losses discussion in Footnote 1 to the Company's audited financial statements included in the Company's Form 10-K for fiscal year ended December 31, 2012.
On a quarterly basis, the Company updates the environmental factors considering the economic and housing market conditions that affect the Company's home equity loan class. Provided below are the more significant economic and housing market conditions that were specifically considered for the September 30, 2012 allowance for the Company's home equity loan class. A similar analysis was also performed as of December 31, 2012 the results of which were not materially different than the analysis as of September 31, 2012.
As of September 30, 2012, the Company's home equity loan portfolio had experienced a 0.89% loss percentage over the previous 12 consecutive calendar quarters, such loss experience the lowest among the Company's 5 loan classes each of which are evaluated for allowance purposes. The Company has determined that such low loss experience is attributable to the fact that approximately 50% of the home equity loan class is in the first lien position. Additionally, the Company attributes the historical 0.89% loss experience for home equity lending to the Company's strong underwriting criteria at origination whereby the first and junior lien positions, with isolated exceptions, did not exceed 80% of the then current appraised value of the residential property.
With respect to the Economic and Business Conditions qualitative environmental factor applied to the home equity loan class, the Company took into account the economic and housing market conditions, including the increased strains in the economy (and related consumer impact) attributable to the European sovereign debt crisis, highly polarized and divisive November 2012 U.S. Congressional and Presidential elections, and the higher unemployment statistic for the US nationally (8.1%) in relation to the lower Montana (6.3%), Idaho (7.3%) and Wyoming (5.6%) unemployment statistics. (Over 90% of the Company's home equity loans are in Montana, Idaho and Wyoming). The Company also evaluated the Total Housing Permit Growth, Housing Starts, and Housing Completions for new privately owned units, taking note that in the first nine months of 2012, Montana, Idaho, Colorado and Utah have each fared positively in relation to the US national statistic. Further, the Company took note of the improvement in single family residential real estate building and sales reports for all of the Company's market areas. Collectively, these considerations bode well to limit the probable credit losses within the Company's home equity loan class.
With respect to the Loan Volume qualitative environmental factor and the Loan Concentrations qualitative environmental factor each applied to the home equity loan class, the Company took into account the trend where the home equity loan class has decreased steadily in balances outstanding as a percentage of the total loan portfolio year over year since December 2010 and for each quarter-end in the first nine months of 2012. At year end 2010, the home equity loan class was 12.88% of the Company's total loan portfolio, declining to 12.71% at year end 2011, and declining further to 12.49%, 12.26% and 11.94% at the end of the first, second and third calendar quarters of 2012, respectively. The decline is due to payments, including outstanding balances paid-off as borrowers with home equity loans have included such balances in refinancing their first lien loans. Lower outstanding balances bode well to limit the probable credit losses within the Company's home equity loan class.
With respect to the Past Due, Non-Performing, and Problem Loans qualitative environmental factor applied to the home equity loan class, the Company took into account the improvement in the past due and non-accrual home equity loans which improved from 3.59% of total home equity loans at year end 2011 to 3.42%, 3.19%, and 3.01% of total home equity loans at the end of the first, second and third calendar quarters of 2012, respectively. In addition, the Company evaluated the steady decline since 2009 in both the Personal Bankruptcy Filings Rate as well as the number of Foreclosures Started in Montana, Idaho, and Wyoming. Such improvements bode well to limit the probable credit losses within the Company's home equity loan class.
With respect to the Value of Underlying Collateral qualitative environmental factor applied to the home equity loan class, the Company took into account that single family residential collateral values in Idaho, Wyoming and Montana have hit bottom, i.e., stabilized (with some improvement in isolated markets in which the Company operates) compared to the prior year and prior 5 year historical trends. Stabilized home prices bode well for first lien loans and junior lien loans, especially where the Company has the junior lien without the associated first lien.
Based on the Company's methodology and process as detailed above in application to the Company's home equity loan class, the Company believes that its home equity loan class allowance incorporates sufficient information that adequately addresses the risks in the portfolio, including the lack of available information on the first lien loans, where the Company is in the junior lien position.
When the Company's home equity loan class becomes significant to its total loan portfolio, the Company will consider revising future filings to include a risk factor or other disclosure addressing the risks in the portfolio, including how the lack of available information on the performance of the first lien position could impact the accuracy of the Company's loan loss estimates and the steps the Company is taking to address the risks.
The Company will provide the following information regarding home equity loans in its Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2012 and in future filings on an updated basis:
The Company's $403.9 million of home equity loans as of December 31, 2012 consist of 1-4 family junior lien mortgages and first and junior lien lines of credit ("HELOC") secured by residential real estate. The home equity loan portfolio consists of 64 percent variable interest rate and 36 percent fixed interest rate loans. Approximately 50 percent of the home equity loans are in a first lien status with the remaining 50 percent in junior lien status. Approximately 20 percent of the home equity loans are closed-end amortizing loans and 80 percent are open-end, revolving HELOCs.
HELOCs are generally originated with maturity terms from 10 to 15 years. At origination, borrowers can choose a variable interest rate or fixed interest rate for the full term of the line of credit, or a fixed interest rate for the first 3 or 5 years from origination which then converts to a variable interest rate for the remaining term of the HELOC. The draw period usually exists from origination to the maturity of the HELOC. During the draw period, a borrower with a variable interest rate term has the option of converting to a fixed interest rate for all or a portion of the remaining term to maturity. During the draw period, the Company has home equity lines of credit where the borrowers pay interest only and home equity lines of credit where borrowers pay principal and interest.
Monitoring of the junior lien and HELOC portfolio includes evaluating payment delinquency, collateral values, bankruptcy notices and foreclosure filings. Additionally, the Company places junior lien mortgages and junior lien HELOCs on non-accrual status when the bank has evidence that the associated senior lien is 90 days past due or in the process of foreclosure, regardless of the junior lien delinquency status.