First, the Company respectfully advises the Staff that the actual REIT election was not made in 2012. The Company began to organize its operations in order to be eligible to elect REIT status and made the decision to convert to REIT status in 2012, but the Company did not begin operating as a REIT until the year ended December 31, 2013.
In response to the Staff’s request that GEO provide the background on the nature of its 2013 REIT election related adjustment as well as elaborate on how it determined that this adjustment relates to 2013, GEO would like to begin by directing the Staff to
Rest of the answer
Note 17 of the notes to the financials in the Form 10-K beginning on page 143.
GEO’s footnote disclosure on page 144 includes the following relevant disclosure:
“In 2013 and 2012, the Company had a tax benefit related to the REIT conversion of $14.9 million and $79.0 million respectively, which was primarily related to the revaluation of certain deferred tax assets and liabilities upon conversion to the effective tax rate of the REIT at a zero tax rate.”
The 2013 adjustment referenced in the above footnote disclosure consists of the following components that are further discussed below.
Worthless stock deduction
$
6.9 million
Impact of acceleration of tax depreciation on certain assets
6.5 million
Tax return to tax accrual items
1.5 million
Total temporary differences (revalued at zero tax rate)
14.9 million
GEO believes it is important to note that the $14.9 million adjustment for the impact of the REIT election consisting of the components listed above would not ordinarily have an effective income tax rate impact since they consist of a change from what was recorded, estimated or accrued to reflect tax basis differences. However, since these underlying assets and liabilities belong to legal entities that form part of the REIT which is essentially not subject to tax, the related gross deferred tax items needed to be revalued at a zero tax rate – and thus impacted the effective tax rate. The zero income tax rate is a result of the REIT receiving a deduction for dividends paid, which as a practical matter is generally larger than taxable income and therefore leaves no income subject to tax.
The impact of the REIT election amounts reported in 2013 related to items that were not reasonably knowable or readily accessible as of the date the December 31, 2012 balance sheet was prepared. Therefore, this $14.9 million adjustment reflects changes in estimates from the date the December 31, 2012 balance sheet was prepared and the adjustment was recorded at the time when information necessary to determine the impact was available and accessible in accordance with ASC 250-10-45-17. Each item described below was grouped under the caption “Impact of REIT election” because, if not for the REIT election, these items would only give rise to a timing difference and not a permanent difference, and therefore would not impact the Company’s effective tax rate disclosed in the rate reconciliation of the tax footnote.
Worthless stock deduction:
Legal entities that form part of the REIT are deemed liquidated into the REIT parent at the end of the day preceding the effective date of the
REIT election, which was January 1, 2013. General U.S. tax rules apply in the case of a liquidation as a result of a REIT conversion. In most situations, these rules provide for a tax-free liquidation with a carry-over tax basis of assets and liabilities that formed part of the liquidated subsidiary. These rules are inapplicable if the liquidating corporation is over-indebted (or insolvent). Such a situation occurs when the debts of the company are in excess of its fair market value and as a result there are no assets available in return for capital stock. The Company has many legal entities which were deemed liquidated into the REIT parent as a result of the REIT election. As such, this required a subsidiary by subsidiary analysis to determine if the liquidation was tax free or not.
In order to completely document a taxable liquidation which results in a worthless stock deduction, there were a number of complex evaluations that needed to be undertaken. These evaluations include, but are not limited to, the following:
Debt
An evaluation of whether GEO could fully support the debts of its subsidiaries or to what extent it could support the debts of its subsidiaries needed to be performed. This evaluation needed to be comprehensive in order to sustain Internal Revenue
Service (“IRS”) scrutiny. If the total debt of each subsidiary being analyzed was less than its fair market value, then the subsidiary was not deemed insolvent. The analysis of debt included intercompany advances.
Fair Market Value
Another evaluation focused on the fair market value of each entity. The evaluation of fair market value of each entity needed to be substantiated and fully supported in order to sustain IRS scrutiny. If the fair market value of the subsidiary was in excess of its debt then the subsidiary would not be insolvent.
Outside Tax Basis in Subsidiary Stock
Another evaluation required GEO to calculate and support the outside tax basis in its subsidiary stock in order to sustain IRS scrutiny and compute the amount of any applicable stock loss.
Subsidiary debt, fair market value and outside tax basis are not information items that are generally maintained up to date unless a company is in the process of divesting subsidiaries or has intentions of divesting subsidiaries. GEO had not completed divestitures or liquidations since 2005 when it undertook two dispositions and GEO did not intend to undertake divestitures or liquidations until it was required to do so in order to be eligible for REIT status. As a result, this information was not readily available.
For subsidiaries that participate in the filing of a U.S. federal consolidated tax return, the outside basis is essentially adjusted each year for income items, expense items and other tax attributes. In the case of subsidiaries that formed part of a consolidated group that was previously acquired by the Company, the analysis included tax years that preceded our acquisition. As such, these values were not readily available at the time of the filing of GEO’s Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2012.
GEO hired a national accounting firm to assist with the gathering of financial and tax information to determine debt, fair market value and outside basis in over a dozen subsidiaries. Three of these subsidiaries were found to be insolvent.
The identified aggregate worthless stock deduction was a change to GEO’s 2012 tax provision estimate. The change in accounting estimate was made in the second quarter of 2013 and reported in GEO’s Form 10-Q for the second quarter ended June 30, 2013. As of the date the
December 31, 2012 balance sheet was prepared, the financial and tax information necessary in order to determine the actual tax impact of the worthless stock deduction was not reasonably known nor readily accessible with a reasonable level of accuracy. As of this date, GEO was not in a position to confirm the solvency of these entities. Under ASC 740-10-25-14 and ASC 740-10-35-2, GEO’s management made its best judgment given the facts, circumstances, and information available at the reporting date and decided to record the financial statement impact of these liquidations when a reasonable estimate could be made with accurate and reliable data. The transactions in question and the required tax analyses were complex in nature and infrequent in occurrence. Therefore, GEO believes it was appropriate to reflect it as a change in accounting estimate made in 2013. ASC 250-10-45-17 states that “A change in accounting estimate shall be accounted for in the period of change if the change affects that period only or in the period of change and future periods if the change affects both. A change in accounting estimate shall not be accounted for by restating or retrospectively adjusting amounts reported in financial statements of prior periods or by reporting pro forma amounts for prior periods.” Therefore, the change in accounting estimate was accounted for in 2013 since that was the period of change.
Since GEO is a participant in the IRS Compliance Assurance Process or CAP program for 2012, the worthless stock deduction has been audited by the IRS and the IRS agreed with the Company’s treatment. The IRS review of the worthless stock deduction was finalized during the fourth quarter of 2013 with the issuance of a Notice of Proposed Adjustment in December of 2013.
Impact of acceleration of tax depreciation on certain assets:
With the filing of the 2012 tax return on September 14, 2013, GEO requested a catch up tax depreciation deduction from the IRS principally with respect to certain security related assets specific to our business that had been classified with a more conservative tax life when originally placed in service.
At the end of 2012, the Company was undergoing an audit by the IRS. The IRS was challenging the tax recovery periods of certain security related assets placed in service during 2010 and 2011. As of the date the December 31, 2012 balance sheet was prepared, the Company and the IRS were not in agreement as to the challenged tax recovery periods used for these fixed assets. In the second quarter of 2013 after the filing of the annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2012, the Company settled its differences with the IRS as to the allowable tax lives of these fixed assets. The settled tax recovery periods were also applied in preparing a method change for similar assets. In 2013, the Company filed for an Automatic Change in Accounting Method with the IRS to retroactively change the tax recovery periods of these fixed assets, which resulted in an acceleration of tax depreciation on GEO’s 2012 income tax return and which was different from the tax depreciation used for the 2012 income tax provision.
In addition, deductions for repairs and maintenance for previously capitalized asset costs were made under newly issued Treasury regulations.
These new regulations prompted the Company to change its method regarding the deductibility of certain repair costs which were previously capitalized. In 2013, the Company filed for an Automatic Change in Accounting Method with the IRS to retroactively deduct certain repair costs, the impact of which was included in the 2012 income tax return but different from what was recorded in the 2012 tax provision.
ASC 250-10-20, “Changes in Accounting estimates result from new information.” In this case, new information was obtained upon the settlement of the issues with the IRS relating to the tax recovery periods of certain fixed assets specific to the Company’s corrections and detention business as well as newly issued Treasury regulations. Therefore, the change in judgment was related to new information and thus a change in accounting estimate. Based on ASC 250-10-45-17 as described above, the change in accounting estimate was accounted for in 2013 since that was the period of change.
The automatic accounting method changes were audited by the IRS as part of the 2012 CAP audit and were accepted with no change during the fourth quarter of 2013.
This adjustment reflects differences between items that were estimated as of the date the December 31, 2012 balance sheet was prepared and the actual amounts of these items reflected on the Company’s tax return. The tax return to tax accrual items reported under the caption “Impact of REIT election” in the rate reconciliation only included temporary differences which would ordinarily not give rise to an effective tax rate impact if it was not for the REIT conversion. No permanent tax return to tax accrual items are included under this caption.
Due to the fact that ASC 250-10-45-17 applies, the change in accounting estimate was accounted for in 2013 since that was the period of change.
GEO believes it is important to note that the $14.9 million adjustment reported under the caption “Impact of REIT election” consisting of the worthless stock deduction, impact of acceleration of tax depreciation on certain assets and tax return to tax accrual items as discussed above would not ordinarily have an effective income tax rate impact since they consist of a change from what was recorded, estimated or accrued to reflect tax basis differences. However, since the underlying assets and liabilities belong to legal entities that form part of the REIT which is essentially not subject to tax, the related gross deferred tax items needed to also be revalued at a zero tax rate – and thus impacted the effective tax rate. The zero income tax rate is a result of the REIT receiving a deduction for dividends paid, which as a practical matter is generally larger than taxable income and therefore leaves no income subject to tax.
The impact of the REIT election amounts reported in 2013 related to items that were not reasonably knowable or readily accessible as of the date the December 31, 2012 balance sheet was prepared. Therefore, this $14.9 million adjustment reflects changes in estimates from the date the December 31, 2012 balance sheet was prepared and the adjustment was recorded at the time in which information necessary to determine the impact was available and accessible in accordance with ASC
250-10-45-17. Each item described above was grouped under the caption “Impact of REIT election” because, if not for the REIT election, these items would only give rise to a timing difference and not a permanent difference, and therefore would not impact the Company’s effective tax rate disclosed in the rate reconciliation of the tax footnote.
We believe the responses provided above fully address the Staff’s comments. If you have any questions, please call the undersigned at 305-982-5519.
In connection with responding to the Staff’s comments, GEO has acknowledged in Exhibit A to this letter the following:
•
GEO is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;
Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and
GEO may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.