Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0001289419 /10-K filed Feb 13, 2026, compared with Feb 28, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
Nasdaq Financials · Asset Management

Morningstar, Inc. MORN

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

2 reviews of MORN's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 2 latest letter Apr 24, 2023
Questions asked 6 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 0 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 6 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 6 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 7 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 2 of 2 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 310 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2022

2023-04-24 to 2024-02-28 · 5 questions · 5 letters from the SEC, 6 from the company
Review closed 2024-02-28
SegmentsRevenueGoodwill and impairment
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
SEC asked
Segment and Geographical Area Information, page 93 1. We note your previous response to comment 1 in your letter dated June 10, 2020 regarding your determination that the Company has a single operating and reportable segment, and that you continue to identify a single reportable segment.
Rest of the question

We also note your current disclosure on page 11 regarding your license-based, asset-based, and transactionbased product areas, which each still represent more than 10% of your total revenues, and your continued discussion of these product areas, including on a relative margin and directional basis, in your investor questions and answers provided on Forms 8-K, such as those filed on July 22, 2022, September 23, 2022 and March 23, 2023. Given your continued and ongoing discussion of these product areas, please provide us with an updated ASC 280 segment identification analysis, including information on the following: • Provide us with details on your current management structure and how your Company is organized, including an organizational chart. • Describe the role of your CODM and each of the individuals reporting to the CODM. • Identify and describe the role of each of your product area managers and leadership team. • Describe the key operating decisions, who makes these decisions, how performance is assessed and how resources are allocated within your business. • Tell us how often the CODM meets with his direct reports and product area managers, the financial information the CODM reviews in conjunction with those meetings and the other participants at those meetings. • Explain how budgets are prepared, who approves the budget at each step of the process, the level of detail discussed at each step, and the level at which the CODM makes changes to the budget. • Describe the basis for determining the compensation for each individual that reports to the CODM. 2. As part of your updated segment identification analysis, describe the financial information reviewed by the CODM for the purpose of allocating resources and assessing performance. In this regard, your previous response indicated that a variety of financial information, including by product area, is provided to and reviewed by the CODM, and that the CODM meets with product area leaders on a regular basis to review performance in order to track progress across key business objectives. We also note certain disaggregated financial information, including relative margin and directional margin impacts, is available based on your responses to investor questions and answers. Please tell us whether the CODM continues to receive disaggregated financial information, such as by product or product area, and, if so, describe it in detail, how frequently it is provided, and how it is used by the CODM. In addition, describe the key business objectives that are tracked and discussed with the product area leaders, as referenced in your previous response letter. Finally, describe the financial information provided to the Board of Directors and how frequently that information is reviewed. In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.

MORN answered
Summary

In determining and continuing to support its conclusion on its reportable segments, the Company referred to the guidance provided in FASB ASC 280, Segment Reporting (ASC 280), which employs a management approach in determining a company’s operating and reportable segments and, in turn, the presentation of disaggregated information by segment.
Rest of the answer

The Company acknowledges that additional financial information, including relative and directional margins by revenue type and product area, is available and was made available due to requests from its shareholders given the Company’s interest in providing transparency when possible, and was provided with appropriate considerations and caveats as to the nature of its preparation.

The Company concluded that its business activities and products covered by the Company’s reporting of revenue by type or product area may meet the definitions of a component and business activity. However, the Company does not believe this information constitutes discrete financial information in the context of ASC 280. The Company further discusses its rationale for this conclusion later in this letter. In addition, none of this financial information at the revenue by type or product area level is used by its chief operating decision maker (CODM), Kunal Kapoor, Chief Executive Officer (CEO), in making decisions about resource allocation or strategic initiatives. Therefore, the Company concludes that a single reportable segment continues to be appropriate. The Company’s analysis is provided below.

Segment Identification Analysis

Identify the CODM1

Following the steps outlined in ASC 280, the Company continues to conclude that its CODM is Kunal Kapoor, who is the Company’s CEO. The CODM focuses on total Company strategy and delivery of its suite of products to drive long-term revenue and operating income growth. The

CODM is the only member of the management team with the authority to make or approve significant operating or strategic decisions (subject to oversight by the Company’s Board of Directors) related to resource allocation, capital allocation, operating expense spending levels, and merger and acquisition activity.

1 This section is responsive to the request in the Comment Letter to “Describe the role of your CODM” in the second bulleted item of Question 1.

Identify Components and Operating Segments of the Company’s Operations

The FASB Master Glossary defines a component as follows:

“A component of an entity comprises operations and cash flows that can be clearly distinguished, operationally and for financial reporting purposes, from the rest of the entity. A component of an entity may be a reportable segment or an operating segment, a reporting unit, a subsidiary or an asset group.”

In determining its operating segments(s), the

Company considered the definition of operating segments in ASC 280-10-50-1 as follows:

“An operating segment is component of a public entity that has all of the following characteristics:

a. It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expenses (including revenues and expenses relating to transactions with other components of the same public entity).

b. Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity’s chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance.

c. Its discrete financial information is available.” and cash flows that can be clearly distinguished, operationally and for financial reporting purposes, from the rest of the entity. A component of an entity may be a reportable segment or an operating segment, a reporting unit, a subsidiary or an asset group.”

Management’s assessment of each criterion in relation to its Company-specific circumstances follows.

A. Business Activities

Management views the Company as a portfolio of product areas that utilize a core set of data, research, and other shared or central functions. To achieve its overall strategic and financial objectives and best serve its clients, the Company’s operating model is organized by product or product groupings (product areas) and corporate or central functions (central functions). Within this structure, thee product areas engage in business activities that generate revenues and incur certain expenses, while the central functions primarily generate expenses, some of which are direct expenses of the product areas and others are allocated.

In its reports on Forms 8-K, 10-Q, and 10-K filed or furnished, as applicable, with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the Company reports revenue in two ways: by type and for its largest product areas. Revenue by type consists of License-Based, Asset-Based, and Transaction-Based categories and is used to provide better clarity to investors on business activities and how revenue is recognized under the different revenue recognition models in accordance with the applicable accounting guidance. Additionally, the Company reports revenue for certain key product areas (PitchBook, Morningstar Data, DBRS Morningstar, Morningstar Direct, Investment Management, Morningstar

Sustainalytics, Workplace Solutions, and Morningstar Advisor Workstation) to provide additional information to help investors track revenue trends and understand contributors to total Company revenue performance. In the product development, maintenance, and delivery of its products, the Company incurs various direct and indirect expenses, including, but not limited to, compensation, data purchases, and information technology infrastructure. As a result, the Company concludes that its product areas and groupings of revenue by type meet criterion a., “It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expenses (including revenues and expenses relating to transactions with other components of the same public entity)”. The central functions do not meet this criterion since they primarily generate expenses.

B. Operating Results Regularly Reviewed by CODM

The

Company has several leaders who report to the CODM that are accountable for product areas or central functions based on its management structure. For purposes of individual performance management of these leader and to track the status and achievement of Company-wide goals and cross-Company initiatives that require collaboration across product areas and central functions, the CODM periodically receives financial information on a product or product area level; however, the CODM does not utilize this information for making decisions regarding resource allocation.

Organization Structure2

There are 16 members of the Executive Leadership team at the Company and the CODM has 13 direct reports. Leaders of central functions are responsible for managing areas such as research, information technology systems and infrastructure, sales, customer service, marketing, design, legal, finance, facilities and real estate, and human resources, which are leveraged and shared across the Company. Product area leaders are responsible for managing specific products or product groupings. Some leaders have responsibilities for both central functions and product areas. Product area leaders’ responsibilities are reorganized from time to time to reflect strategic priorities, address market trends, provide professional development opportunities for the Executive Leadership team, or for other reasons. Currently, the product area leaders are organized into the following seven areas of responsibility:

· DBRS

Morningstar

· Enterprise

2 This section is responsive to the request in the Comment

Letter to “Provide us with details on your current management structure and how your Company is organized…” in the first bulleted item of Question 1.

· Morningstar

Indexes

Sustainalytics

Wealth

· PitchBook

· Workplace

Solutions

The primary rationale for the current product groupings is to:

· Align products and services under common leadership to better serve customers and end markets;

· Maximize the value of the core data and research assets;

· Move certain operations into the direct control of product area leadership to facilitate increased accountability; and

· Provide an ability to structure and track more specific internal metrics to monitor individual performance.

By comparison, for purposes of its key product area revenue disclosures in its most recent Forms 8-K, 10-Q, and 10-K, the Company defines its key product areas as follows:

Data3

Direct3

· Investment

Management4

Advisor Workstation3

The primary rationale for this key product area disclosure is to provide shareholders’ information on the Company’s largest and flagship products that customers recognize as part of the Morningstar brand and suite of offerings. In aggregate, these product areas comprised 80.4% of total revenue as of December 31,

2022.

3 Morningstar Data, Morningstar Direct, and Advisor Workstation are part of the Enterprise product area.

4 Investment Management is part of the Morningstar Wealth product area.

In addition to the CEO, the Executive Leadership team consists of the following individuals:5

Name

Title

Reports to

CODM

Responsibility

[***]*

Chief

Marketing Officer

Central

Function

[***] of Staff

X

[***]**

President,

Morningstar Indexes

Product

Area

Financial Officer

Revenue Officer

Founder and Chief Executive Officer, PitchBook Data, Inc.

Strategy Officer & Head of Investment Research

Function and Product Area

President, Retirement & Workplace Solutions

Morningstar Sustainalytics

Morningstar Wealth

Legal Officer

Enterprise & Chief Technology Officer

DBRS Morningstar Credit Ratings

Chief People Officer

Design Officer

*[***], Chief Marketing Officer, reports to [***],

Chief Revenue Officer.

**[***], President of Morningstar Indexes, reports to [***], Chief Strategy Officer & Head of Investment Research.

5 This table is responsive to the request in the Comment

Letter to “Describe … each of the individuals reporting to the CODM” in the second bulleted item of Question 1 and request to “Identify and describe the role of each of your product area managers and leadership team” in the third bulleted item of Question 1.

Refer to Exhibit A for the Executive Leadership team organization chart.6

Under this management structure, the Company not only evaluates the performance of the single consolidated Morningstar view, but also reviews the contributions of product areas and central functions to achieve Company-wide strategic and financial objectives as defined in its annual Objectives and Key Results (OKRs). Over time, product areas have shifted and been combined in different ways to achieve these objectives. For example, Morningstar Data and Morningstar Direct were managed separately until 2022 and are now included within the Enterprise product grouping. Additionally, Morningstar Wealth was created in 2022 to incorporate Investment Management, Morningstar

Office, Ballcourts, and Morningstar.com, which were previously managed within other product groupings. In addition, as noted in statements made by the CODM at the annual shareholder’s meeting on May 12, 2023, the Company evaluates opportunities to shift resources across product areas in response to customer and business needs. For example, earlier this year, the Company shifted resources between

Wealth, Enterprise, and its Central Sales function to better serve the Australian market. Additionally, the Company recently announced plans to bring together its Research and Investment teams currently sitting in the Morningstar Wealth, Workplace Solutions, and Investment

Research groups. This new central function will be called Research, Investments, & Analytics. These decisions were made directly by the CODM.

The CODM’s 13 direct reports meet periodically throughout the year. Given the size of this group and cross-functional reliance to achieve objectives for total Company performance, there are bi-weekly Executive Leadership team meetings and quarterly offsite sessions. In these meetings, leaders discuss Company-wide updates and events, as well as the status and achievement of Company-wide goals and cross-Company initiatives that require collaboration across product areas and central functions. Examples of recent discussions include long-term strategy for the Customer Relationship Management solution, return to office, brand architecture, and Company-wide bonus and forecast updates. In addition to group meetings, the CODM meets one-on-one, formally and informally, with his direct reports on a periodic basis.7

6 This Exhibit is responsive to the request in the Comment

Letter to “Provide us with …an organizational chart.” in the first bulleted item of Question 1.

7 The preceding paragraph is responsive to the request in the Comment Letter to “Tell us how often the CODM meets with his direct reports and product area managers …” in the fifth bulleted item of Question 1.

Key Business Objectives8

On an annual basis, the Company performs its strategic planning process and defines the annual OKRs for the upcoming year. Then all product area and central function leaders develop OKRs, which are reviewed and approved by the CODM to ensure alignment across the entire organization to achieve its shared strategic, operational, and financial objectives. These OKRs complement the annual budget process and inform the individual performance management framework for the Executive Leadership team.

The Company’s 2022 OKRs were the following:

· Exceed companywide financial goals.

· Deliver differentiated insights across asset classes to public and private market investors.

· Establish leading ESG position across each business.

· Drive operational excellence and scalability to support growth targets.

· Build an inclusive culture that delivers exceptional talent engagement and development.

Budget Process9

The Company’s budget process begins and ends with the consolidated Company view. With reference to the annual OKRs, the CODM and Chief Financial Officer (CFO) set consolidated

Company targets and then work across product areas and central functions to allocate resources in support of the desired Company result.

The budget planning process is iterative, beginning in August and ending with final Board of Directors approval around December.

Key steps in the budget process include:

August

· Define consolidated Company financial targets.

guidance on revenue and controllable costs to product areas.

guidance on costs to central functions.

October

· Review the consolidated budget after initial budget submissions from product area and central functional leaders.

· Meet with product area and central function leaders to review the initial budget submissions.

· CODM and CFO provide feedback and further guidance if consolidated objectives are not achieved.

November

· Meetings to revise the initial submission and coordinate with product areas or central functions to provide additional submissions as needed to finalize the budget.

8 This section is responsive to the request in the Comment

Letter to “Describe the key operating decisions, who makes these decisions …” in the fourth bulleted item of Question

1. 9 This section is responsive to the request in the Comment

Letter to “Describe … how performance is assessed and how resources are allocated within your business” in the fourth bulleted item of Question 1 and to the request to “Explain how budgets are prepared, who approves the budget at each step of the process, the level of detail discussed at each step, and the level at which the CODM makes changes to the budget” in the sixth bulleted item of Question 1.

December / January

· Finalize the consolidated Company budget and present to Board of Directors for review; revise as necessary to incorporate feedback from the Board of Directors; receive approval from the Board of Directors.

Given the complexity of the Company’s product portfolio and significant reliance of the various product areas on central capabilities, the Company employs a variety of cost allocation methodologies in the budget process to directionally attribute certain pools of centralized expenses to the product areas, which contribute approximately 40% of the Company’s total operating expenses. These central expense pools include the Company’s core data and research assets that are critical components to the delivery, ongoing maintenance, and development of the Company’s suite of product offerings. As examples, the Company allocates the costs of the central research team based on proportion of revenue by product area. Information technology infrastructure costs are allocated by product area headcount. Allocated central data costs are based on estimated usage. Sales and support costs are allocated by annual sales goals across product areas. Other central costs, such as finance, legal, and human resources, vary based on product area revenue and salary expense. These cost pools and cost allocation methodologies are often changed and refined, which results in comparability issues across periods. This also results in potentially incomplete views of profitability of any given product area on a stand-alone basis.

Resource allocation decisions are made at the total Company level and allocated across product areas and central functions as part of the annual budget process with final determinations made by the CODM. Within a fiscal year, product area and central function leaders make operational decisions based on their OKRs and budget. Any material changes to the budget or pursuit of initiatives not contemplated in the budget require approval from the CODM or

Board of Directors, as applicable, after consideration of the impact on the total Company results.

Performance Management10 goals of the Company’s compensation plans are to attract and retain talented executives, motivate and reward executives for their individual and collective contributions to the Company, and align executives’ interests with the long-term interests of its shareholders.

The Company’s annual compensation plans align itsexecutives’ pay with performance against OKRs. As part of its compensation philosophy, the Company provides pay that is externally competitive, internally equitable, and that considers an employee’s specific role and recognizes their contributions to Morningstar. Compensation targets are informed by an assessment of the individual’s competencies and performance against OKRs. The primary components of the Company’s compensation packages are salary, annual bonus, and stock-based long-term incentives (equity). Compensation changes for the Company’s Named Executive Officers (NEOs) are reviewed and approved by the Compensation Committee. The CODM’s compensation target is reviewed and approved each year by the Compensation

Committee.

10 This section is responsive to the request in the Comment

Letter to “Describe the basis for determining the compensation for each individual that reports to the CODM” in the seventh

The Company’s 2023 and 2022 annual bonus incentive targets for its NEOs are based 100% on consolidated total Company results, and central function leaders are also incentivized on this basis. Product area leader bonus targets are structured with 25% of the payout tied to total Company results and 75% driven primarily by results for the leader’s specific product area.

The financial performance metrics utilized in the annual bonus incentive plan are consolidated adjusted revenue and consolidated adjusted EBITDA. For NEOs and central function leaders, the Company weights the adjusted revenue measure at 50% and the adjusted EBITDA measure at 50%. However, for its product area leaders, the mix of adjusted revenue and adjusted EBITDA varies by product area depending on its stage of growth – either 50%/50% or 67%/33%.

For the purpose of calculating the annual bonus, the Company uses a non-GAAP adjusted calculation of revenue and EBITDA, so its incentive plan is tied more closely to what is controllable by management. The Company adjusts these measures for the effects of currency exchange rates and any mergers, acquisitions, or divestitures. The Company also adjusts EBITDA to include cost allocations to product areas and exclude costs associated with the bonus itself, stock-based compensation, infrequent expenses, and certain accounting methods related to the development of internal software systems (i.e., capitalized internal software development). This calculation of adjusted EBITDA differs from the non-GAAP adjusted metrics reported in the Company’s financial reports on Forms 8-K, 10-Q, and 10-K. The definition of adjusted operating margin for these filings excludes intangible amortization expense, all mergers and acquisition-related expenses

(including M&A-related earn-outs), and recently, items related to the significant reduction and shift of the Company's operations in China. The Company does not report an adjusted revenue metric in its reports on Forms 8-K, 10-Q, and 10-K filed or furnished, as applicable, with the SEC.

Each of the CODM’s direct reports receives stock-based equity awards – comprised 75% of Market Stock Units (MSUs) and 25% of Restricted Stock Units (RSUs). Typically, RSUs vest in four equal annual installments commencing on the first anniversary of the grant date. MSUs vest three years from the grant date and the number of shares received upon vesting depends primarily on the Company’s total shareholder return (TSR) over that three-year period. The MSUs granted to a majority of the Executive Leadership team also have a feature that will provide an increased number of shares that can be earned at the vesting date, if certain revenue metrics are exceeded or other performance goals are met as determined at the discretion of the Board of Directors. The revenue metrics applicable to these MSU awards are either the consolidated Company results or, for certain product area leaders, the applicable product area revenue with similar adjustments described above with respect to the annual bonus incentive plan.

Review of Financial Information11

CODM attends monthly or quarterly business review meetings primarily to support the individual performance management of its direct reports, which is based on financial performance against budget and the achievement of their respective OKRs. In addition, the CODM uses these meetings to help drive overall accountability across the leadership team and advance cross-functional collaboration on shared initiatives.

The attendees of these business reviews may vary, but typically include:

· CFO

· Product area leader

· Other product area team members, as needed

· Chief

People Officer

Strategy Officer

A key topic at these meetings is the financial performance of the product area against budget and progress toward that teams’ OKRs. The agenda for the monthly or quarterly business reviews also includes a wide range of other topics, including updates on key business initiatives, key milestones with customers, vendors, and other stakeholders, and employee engagement results. There is no standard template for these business review meetings; the format and nature of other information presented will vary depending on the metrics relevant to any given product area. For example, reviews of Morningstar.com will focus on web traffic and reviews of Investment Management will focus on investment flows.

While the nature of the financial information shared during these business reviews may vary by product area due to unique characteristics of that product area, typically the following financial information is included:

· Revenue by product

KPI’s (assets under management, annual contract values, and revenue renewal rates vs.

goals, as applicable)

· Certain operating expenses in direct control of the product area leader

11 This section is responsive to the request in the Comment

Letter to “Tell us how often the CODM meets with his direct reports and product area managers, the financial information the CODM reviews in conjunction with those meetings and the other participants at those meetings” in the fifth bulleted item of Question

1. This section is also responsive to the requests in Question 2 of the Comment Letter and describes a process that is generally consistent with the meetings among the CODM and product area leaders referenced in the Company’s previous response to the SEC on June 10,

2020.

· Measurements of product area profitability, including operating income before central cost allocations and EBITDA both including and excluding central cost allocations

· Salary target tracking, headcount summaries, and people metrics

· OKR summary and status

In addition to business reviews, the CODM and

Executive Leadership team receive a monthly financial results package primarily focused on total Company results, which approximates

30 pages. The contents of this package include:

· Performance highlights

· Consolidated company results, including revenue, expenses, profitability, headcount, and salary tracking company financial performance variances vs. budget, forecast and prior year by product area and region

· Operating income, margin, and expense performance across product areas and central functions

The primary focus of the monthly financial results package is consolidated Company results, with an emphasis on revenue reporting. The reporting of operating income, margin, and expense performance across product areas and central functions (noted in the 5th bullet above) is presented in a single page, around page 10 of the reporting package. The allocations used for this purpose are the same allocations used for the Company’s budget process.

Board Oversight12

The Board of Directors oversees high-level strategy and spends its time during meetings discussing and advising the Company through a variety of lenses. Many Board meetings include a review of a product area (e.g., Enterprise or PitchBook), but agendas also include Company-wide topics, such as cybersecurity, sales pipelines, and talent management. The Board of Directors receives a variety of periodic and annual information. Aside from revenue by product area, all other key financial information is presented to the Board of Directors at the consolidated Company level. On a monthly basis, the

Board of Directors receives a financial results package (consisting of a slide deck and cover memo with narrative explanation) including the following:

key financial metrics (revenue, operating income, EBITDA, cash flow) explaining performance drivers vs. budget, forecast, and prior year actual results performance by product area compared to prior year actual results free cash flow compared to prior year information, to explain performance (e.g., sales pipeline and performance)

12 This section is responsive to the request in the Comment

Letter to “describe the financial information provided to the Board of Directors and how frequently that information is reviewed” in Question 2.

It should be noted that this reporting is different from the monthly financial results package referenced in the section above. The Board of Directors does not regularly receive financial information at the product area level, other than revenue.

On an annual basis, the CODM’s performance is evaluated holistically, considering the Company’s consolidated financial performance, shareholder return, and progress toward strategic initiatives in support of the Company’s OKRs among other factors. As part of this process, the CODM prepares a qualitative self-evaluation for the Board of Directors, not organized by product area or specific OKR, reflecting on successes and challenges of the recently completed fiscal year. As a result, the Board of Directors does not receive any financial information related to the profitability of the product areas as this information is determined to not be needed to evaluate the performance of the CODM in context of the Company’s overall strategy or otherwise oversee consolidated Company performance.

Criterion B Conclusion

The budget process starts and ends with total

Company strategic and financial goals, which drives the Company’s annual OKRs. It is on this basis that the CODM makes decisions about resource allocation and strategic initiatives in support of the annual OKRs. The Company then incentivizes the performance of its

NEOs on total Company results, while incentive compensation measures for product area leaders are determined based on a mix of total

Company results and product area performance, with a heavier weighting on product area results. While a variety of financial information for the product areas or central functions is routinely provided to the CODM to monitor performance at these levels and drive accountability across the Executive Leadership team, this is not the information used to run the business and allocate resources in order to achieve the Company-wide OKRs. It is for this reason that the Company concludes that criterion b., “Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity’s chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance” is not met.

C. Discrete Financial Information

The final characteristic in determining whether a component meets the definition of an operating segment is whether “discrete financial information” is available. As described above, a variety of financial information relating to the Company’s revenue types, product areas, and central functions is prepared on a periodic basis and provided to the CODM. However, the Company does not believe this information represents sufficiently complete and consistent “discrete financial information” within the meaning of ASC 280. Further, while the CODM may receive this information and may discuss it in the context of the periodic business review and performance management meetings, the Company notes that he does not regularly utilize this type of financial information when making decisions to allocate resources or as the basis to determine the most effective way to monetize the Company’s core data and research assets and other capabilities. Instead, the CODM primarily uses this information to evaluate progress against total Company goals and evaluate the individual performance of his direct reports on the Executive Leadership team in support of the Company’s annual performance management and compensation process.

As the Company noted in the budget process section, given the complexity of its product portfolio and significant reliance on central functions for the various product areas, the Company employs a variety of cost allocation methodologies to directionally attribute certain pools of centralized expenses to the product areas.

As a result, many of these allocation methods are inherently incomplete or based on high-level assumptions that may not represent the true costs of a product area if it were to operate on a stand-alone basis. For example, given the significance of central costs and numerous product areas in the Company’s portfolio, most allocations are based on revenue, salary expense, or headcount, which often fluctuate and are only a rough estimation of the usage of a specific service. Additionally, these allocation methods fluctuate as product areas are often reorganized under different product area leaders (for example the Morningstar Data, Morningstar Direct, and Morningstar Wealth organizational changes mentioned above). These reorganizations impact allocations due to changes in revenue, salary expense, and headcount.

Approximately 40% of the Company’s operating expense categories are not direct costs and are allocated to the product areas. These expenses include Company-wide capabilities and those managed by central functions, including data collection, research, sales, and marketing, customer service, information technology, corporate functions (finance, human resources, legal), and equity compensation, among other areas.

The Company does not perform allocations by revenue type. In addition, product areas may fall into more than one revenue type based on the revenue recognition model that applies to the performance obligation of the product. As noted in the Company’s earnings release for the quarter ended March 31, 2023, the

Company updated its revenue-type classifications to account for product areas with more than one revenue type. Revenue from Morningstar

Sustainalytics' second-party opinions product was reclassified from License-Based to Transaction-Based. Revenue from Morningstar Indexes data and services products was reclassified from Asset-Based to License-Based. Revenue from DBRS Morningstar's data products was reclassified from Transaction-Based to License-Based. As a result, financial information at the revenue by type level is not considered discrete financial information that is suitable for decision-making by the CODM.

Given the expense fluctuations that occur due to changing allocations of central costs, the expense profile by revenue type or product area is incomplete and varying assumptions are made to derive estimated, directional margins. The Company notes that there has been increasing demand from its shareholders for financial information at the product area level. It is the Company’s current policy to respond to questions submitted by shareholders. The

Company understands that shareholders are likely submitting questions requesting this information to help enable comparisons of Company performance to peers, as well as to evaluate Company performance against an investor’s investment horizon, which may be short, medium, or long-term. While the CODM is not held accountable at the product area level and is not focused on short-term results, the

Company is responding to shareholder questions by providing estimated, directional or relative margin information in an effort to be transparent to stakeholders. However, while this information is available, it does not constitute discrete financial information under

ASC 280 and is not used by the CODM to make resource allocation decisions.

When discussing relative margins or margins across its product portfolio for investors, the Company’s message is that these are “directional” given the incompleteness and lack of consistency over time. Through the recent Form 8-K filings addressing a large volume of shareholder questions and the annual shareholder meeting on May 12, 2023, the Company’s intention was to provide directional observations on margin estimates for certain product areas to assist investors in understanding certain trends in the business.

While certain financial information by revenue type or product area derived from these cost allocations is available, it is inherently incomplete, and, therefore, not utilized by the

CODM to make decisions about the allocation of resources in support of the Company’s primary financial goals of achieving long-term consolidated organic revenue and operating income growth. Complete, consistent, and meaningful discrete financial information to help the CODM make informed judgments on these matters is only available at the consolidated Company level; therefore, the Company concludes that criterion c., “Its discrete financial information is available” is not met.

Conclusion

Based on the evaluation of the three criteria to determine whether components of a business qualify as operating segments, the Company determined that the only criteria that was met is “a. engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expenses”. The Company considers the following in reaching this conclusion:

· The management of the business is focused on leveraging the Company’s core data and research assets that are critical centralized components to the delivery, ongoing maintenance, and development of the

Company’s suite of product offerings in support of the achievement of long-term strategic growth objectives for the consolidated Company.

CODM focuses on long term strategy and product delivery by setting the annual Company-wide

OKRs. Throughout the year, the status of the individual product area and central function

OKRs are reviewed through various touch points with the CODM and select OKRs are reviewed with the Board of Directors on a quarterly basis.

· Substantially all of the financial information that is prepared and used by the Company for decision-making focuses on consolidated results and top-line revenue and operating income growth.

· While other financial information is available, the Company does not believe it meets the definition of the discrete financial information criteria in ASC 280. When the Company addresses relative margins in its responses to shareholder questions, by type of revenue or product area, the

Company employs a variety of cost allocation methodologies to directly attribute certain expenses to the product areas. These methodologies are not complete and, like the product areas, change from time to time. As a result, the discussions of relative margins are directional and based on estimates. The Company has provided this information, with caveats, in an effort to be transparent to shareholders.

financial information that is available at the revenue by type or product area level is inherently incomplete and does not constitute “discrete financial information”; therefore, it is not used by the CODM to allocate resources.

Therefore, the Company continues to conclude that it has one operating segment since all three criteria are not met.

Aggregation and Materiality Determination of

Reportable Segments

The provisions of ASC 280 detail two additional steps in this analysis, (i) aggregate operating segments that have similar economic characteristics and that meet certain qualitative aggregation criteria and (ii) apply quantitative materiality thresholds to each operating segment to determine which operating segments are required to be separately reported in the notes to the financial statements. As the Company determined that it has one operating segment, these two steps are not applicable.

Read in the reply
SEC asked
Segment and Geographical Area Information, page 93 1. In your response to our comments, you outlined that your monthly financial results packages include operating income, margin, and expense performance across product areas and central functions.
Rest of the question

Additionally, your monthly or quarterly business review meetings include sharing measurements of product area profitability, including operating income before central cost allocations and EBITDA, both including and excluding central cost allocations. Please tell us why you believe that this information does not represent discrete financial information. Refer to ASC 280-10-50-1(c). 2. We note from your response that your product area managers are responsible for making product area operational decisions based on their Objectives and Key Results (“OKRs”) and budget, report directly to your CODM, and meet periodically with your CODM. Additionally, we note that 75% of your product area managers’ bonuses are driven primarily by their specific area’s financial results. Please provide us with your analysis of whether product area managers are segment managers based on ASC 280-10-50-7. 3. You state in your response that “[r]esource allocation decisions are made at the total Company level and allocated across product areas and central functions as part of the annual budget process with final determinations made by the CODM.” Please describe in detail the product area-level information the CODM receives as part of the budgeting process and how he uses it. Please also describe in detail the CODM’s participation in meetings that discuss the product area budget submissions, any feedback and further guidance that the CODM provides at the product area-level during the budgeting process, and whether the CODM makes or requests changes to product area budgets. 4. In your response, you state that product area leaders “develop OKRs, which are reviewed and approved by the CODM to ensure alignment across the entire organization to achieve its shared strategic, operational, and financial objectives.” Describe for us in detail the process by which product area OKRs are developed, including the CODM’s involvement in reviewing and approving OKRs. As part of this, tell us what your 2022 OKRs were for each product area and the financial measure(s) which were used to evaluate progress towards the achievement of each OKR, as applicable. Finally, you state that your annual compensation plans align your executives’ pay with performance against OKRs. Please tell us if product area leaders’ pay is based on Company-wide OKRs or product area OKRs. 5. You state in your response that a key topic at the monthly or quarterly business review meetings that the CODM and product area leaders attend “is the financial performance of the product area against budget and progress toward that teams’ OKRs.” Your response also indicates that the CODM attends these meetings “to support the individual performance management of its direct reports, which is based on financial performance against budget and the achievement of their respective OKRs.” As noted in the comments above, the information shared at these meetings typically includes measurements of product area profitability, product area OKRs are reviewed and approved by the CODM and budgeting takes place at the product area level. We also note your reference to the CODM’s statements that the “Company evaluates opportunities to shift resources across product areas in response to customer and business needs.” Explain to us how you concluded that your CODM does not regularly utilize product area financial information when making decisions to allocate resources. Refer to ASC 280-10-50-1(b).

MORN answered

No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗

SEC asked
Segment and Geographical Area Information, page 93, page 93 1. We have considered your May 31, 2023 and July 21, 2023 responses to our segment comments and the information provided on our August 23, 2023 call with you. Based upon the information provided, we object to your conclusion that you have only one operating segment.
Rest of the question

Please provide us with a revised analysis of your operating and reportable segments in accordance with ASC 280 and your proposed segment footnote disclosure. Ensure that your revised analysis addresses, but is not limited to, the following: • Your consideration of which measure you would identify as the reported measure of profit or loss for each reportable segment. • A detailed discussion explaining whether and the extent to which the change to your identified operating segments has, or had, an impact on the Company’s prior annual goodwill impairment testing analysis.

MORN answered
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comments from letters dated April 24, 2023, June 15, 2023, and September 27, 2023, and following ongoing engagement with the Staff, the Company will revise its segment footnote (and other impacted disclosures, including goodwill-related items) beginning with its Quarterly

Report on Form 10-Q for the period ended September 30, 2023 to reflect its revised conclusions with respect to the identification of multiple operating and reportable segments.
Rest of the answer

As a result of its revised analysis pursuant to ASC 280, the Company also assessed whether the revised conclusions with respect to components and reporting units (as defined in ASC 350) would have impacted the prior year goodwill impairment testing analysis and concluded that the revised segment analysis would not have resulted in an impairment to goodwill. See below for a more detailed discussion on the analyses performed in each of these regards.

ASC 280 Segment Reporting Analysis

Our analysis of operating and reportable segments in accordance with

ASC 280 is as follows:

ASC 280-10-50-1 states that “an operating segment is component of a public entity that has all of the following characteristics:

a. It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expenses (including revenues and expenses relating to transactions with other components of the same public entity).

b. Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity’s chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance.

c. Its discrete financial information is available.”

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

A. Business Activities

Management views the Company as a portfolio of product areas that utilize a core set of data, research, and other shared or central functions.

The Company’s product offerings and services are organized into the following seven product areas:

License–based Product Areas:

· Enterprise

· PitchBook

· Morningstar Sustainalytics

Asset-based Product Areas:

· Morningstar Indexes

· Morningstar Wealth

· Morningstar Retirement

Transaction-based Product Areas:

· DBRS Morningstar

Each product area engages in business activities, generates revenue, and incurs expenses and is managed by a product area manager (previously defined in the Company’s response to the SEC comment letter dated June 15, 2023 as “Segment Managers”) who directly reports to the chief operating decision maker (“CODM”). Management noted that while there are central function leaders that report to the CODM, they do not meet the requirements of ASC 280-10-50-1(a).

B. Information regularly reviewed by the CODM

The

Company continues to conclude that its CODM is Kunal Kapoor, Chief Executive Officer. The CODM’s direct reports meet periodically throughout the year and prepare Quarterly Business Review (“QBR”) reports to present to the CODM. In addition, a Monthly Financial

Book is prepared by the Finance team that focuses on the performance of the Company at the consolidated level, with some detail on the financial performance of the seven product areas and new segments outlined above. The QBR reports contain revenue, expense, operating profit, and comparisons to budget, forecast, and prior periods for each of the product areas. The CODM reviews the Monthly Financial Book and meets quarterly with Segment Managers to discuss the QBR. On an annual basis, the Company performs its strategic planning process and defines the annual Objectives and Key Results (“OKRs”) for the upcoming year. All Segment Managers develop OKRs, which are reviewed and approved by the CODM to ensure alignment across the entire organization to achieve its shared strategic, operational, and financial objectives.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

As part of the reassessment of ASC 280, the Company selected Adjusted Operating Income1 as the segment measure of profit or loss for each reportable segment because the CODM will use this measure for purposes of making decisions to allocate resources and assess performance of the segments, in addition to monitoring consolidated Company results. Adjusted Operating Income is a metric that the Company has historically used to monitor consolidated financial performance and is defined as operating income excluding intangible amortization,

M&A-related expenses (including M&A-related earn-outs), and items related to the reduction and shift of the Company’s operations in China, which include severance and personnel expenses, transformation costs, and asset impairment costs. The Board of Directors also holds the CODM and management accountable to this metric as they believe it is the most important metric to monitor financial performance.

In addition to Adjusted Operating Income, the financial reporting packages also include revenues, adjusted EBITDA, and adjusted EBITDA margins at the consolidated level but do not include any GAAP profitability metrics at the product area level. As the Company presents more than one segment measure of profit or loss within its financial reporting packages, another reason that Adjusted Operating Income was selected as the reported measure of profitability for its segments is that this measure is most levered2 (as it includes depreciation), and therefore, most consistent with the corresponding amounts and principles used in Morningstar’s consolidated financial statements and most quantitatively similar to net income as reported on a consolidated financial statement basis. Adjusted Operating Income has also been presented historically as part of the Company’s consolidated earnings releases and Management’s Discussion and Analysis included in the Company’s periodic reports under the Securities Exchange Act. Total Segment Adjusted Operating Income will reconcile to these previously presented consolidated amounts.

C. Discrete financial information

The final characteristic in determining whether a component meets the definition of an operating segment is whether “discrete financial information” is available. A variety of financial information relating to the Company’s product areas and central functions is prepared on a periodic basis through the

Monthly Financial Book and QBR reports, which are provided to the CODM. Following discussions with the Staff, management concluded that discrete financial information within the meaning of ASC 280-10-50-1(c) is available at the product area level of the Company.

Based on the analysis above, the Company identified seven operating segments (prior to applying aggregation criteria): Enterprise, PitchBook, Morningstar Sustainalytics, Morningstar Indexes,

Morningstar Wealth, Morningstar Retirement, and DBRS Morningstar, given that each product area engages in business activities, has operating results regularly reviewed by the CODM, and has discrete financial information available, and, therefore, satisfies the three characteristics required under ASC 280-10-50-1 for a component to be an operating segment.

Morningstar’s consolidated statement of income presents operating income, which includes the following operating expenses:

cost of revenue, sales and marketing, general and administrative, and depreciation and amortization. The only incremental costs to arrive at net income are interest expense, realized gains and losses on sale of investments or equity method investments, other, equity in net income (loss) of unconsolidated entities, and income tax expense.

2 [***]

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

Aggregation of Operating Segments and Reportable Segment Analysis

We considered the aggregation criteria for operating segments below.

ASC 280-10-50-11 states “two or more operating segments may be aggregated into a single operating segment if aggregation is consistent with the objective and basic principles of this Subtopic, if the segments have similar economic characteristics, and if the segments are similar in all of the following areas:

a. The nature of the products and services b. The nature of the production processes c. The type or class of customer for their products and services d. The methods used to distribute their products and provide their services e. If applicable, the nature of the regulatory environment, for example, banking, insurance or public utilities”

Based on the assessment of the above criteria, the Company has aggregated its seven operating segments into two aggregated operating segments and one standalone operating segment for a total of three reportable segments, which are discussed in further detail below.

Aggregated Operating Segment: Data and Analytics

The Company reviewed the Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics businesses against the ASC 280 aggregation criteria for potential aggregation. These are all data businesses that serve investors and advisors. Each one uses a combination of human and technological processes to acquire investment data from various sources. The data is enriched with analytics and research, generating proprietary intellectual property, and customers pay predominantly license-based subscription fees to access the data and analytics. These businesses provide investors with comprehensive market data, research and insights, and investment analysis to inform investment decisions.

The Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics businesses are all centered on providing financial data and proprietary research and analysis that builds on such data and serves investors.

· Data is collected from multiple third-party sources using a range of similar techniques. Often, there is overlap in sources, such as company reports, which provide data to each of the aggregated products.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

· Raw data is processed and analyzed, and then used to create additional, proprietary intellectual property and research insights.

· Technology platforms/interfaces enable users to further customize the data and create their own insights and analysis.

· Clients gain access to the enriched data products via subscription-based platforms (typically via web portal or application programming interface/file transfer protocol) and pay license fees at a fixed price for a defined term of one to three years.

After the data is processed, analyzed, and sold to customers, the need to regularly refresh and update the data is also consistent across these license-based products. The license-based revenue recognition model is a key similarity as 100% of Enterprise and PitchBook’s revenues, and 93% of Morningstar Sustainalytics’ revenues were derived from license-based sources for the nine months ended September 30, 2023.

Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics gather data, analyze data, and sell data via access to software interfaces. The common characteristics of the production processes are as follows:

· An initial build of data and research is needed, requiring sizable upfront investment.

· Raw data is typically identified and extracted from similar sources, including public disclosures, regulatory filings, and direct communication with issuers and companies. In some cases, these are the same reports/data sources.

· Similar technology is used to partially or fully automate the extraction process (data scraping) and for extensive validation. A regular cadence of updates to this data ensures timely insights are provided.

· The data is always enriched with Morningstar intellectual property, resulting in proprietary statistics, and additional research, interpretation, and insight is provided by Company analysts. The analysts involved in all three businesses have similar skill sets.

· Primary costs are headcount and facilities, and all three businesses benefit similarly from central functions.

· There is significant overlap in data access. For example, Morningstar’s equity data and research supports both PitchBook and Enterprise, and users have full access to this content through both products.

all support a large, overlapping network and ecosystem of business-to-business companies that provide services and solutions to financial institutions and investors seeking information to empower investment decisions. Asset managers and advisors made up over two-thirds of revenue for all three businesses (85% for Enterprise, 72% for Sustainalytics, and 69% for PitchBook) for the nine months ended September 30,

2023. Redistributors make up a portion of the remainder for Enterprise and Morningstar Sustainalytics, as do corporate clients for PitchBook and Morningstar Sustainalytics.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

There are numerous examples of significant client crossover with clients using products from each of the components. For example, among the top 100 current Enterprise clients, 45 clients account for at least $100,000 in annual contract revenue and 32 clients account for at least $250,000 in annual contract revenue for each of Pitchbook and Sustainalytics.

all distribute data and analytics directly to the customer, primarily via two mechanisms:

· Software platforms are the most common option for customers. These are typically all-in-one web portals, with login credentials for licensed customers.

· Data, research, and ratings from all three businesses can also be plugged directly into existing client workflows and updated automatically whenever a data feed update becomes available.

Enterprise,

PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics leverage multiple go-to-market “GTM” strategies and a variety of distribution channels. However, the primary route to market is via direct sales, with each business leveraging its own embedded sales specialist teams focused on connecting specific buyer needs to specific product capabilities. In direct sales, the product areas also leverage central sales resources and coordination through Strategic Account Executives (SAEs), who develop, implement, and coordinate distribution strategies across key customers within Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics (the same SAEs sell product lines across all three businesses).

Other areas of shared competencies include demand generation, inside sales, strategic accounts sales, and cross product solution sales capabilities. From a marketing perspective, the businesses leverage a mix of central marketing capabilities, such as brand, public relations, communications, and website, to more granular dedicated marketing services within the product area, including product marketing, events, and campaign management. All GTM teams follow a standard sales process, methodology, and systems as set forth by the central GTM team.

are not directly regulated, apart from certain isolated geographic regulation covering the Morningstar Sustainalytics ESG product.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated f. Economic similarity

ASC

280 notes that economically similar operating segments often exhibit similar long-term financial characteristics. The Company’s license-based businesses of Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics are viewed as having very similar economic characteristics.

When assessing economic similarity and the ability to achieve similar long-term margins, the Company considered the following:

· As noted in the production processes above, the Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics businesses require a large upfront investment to build initial data sets, analytics, and research. Once established, these businesses are similar in that they each follow a “build once, sell many times” model. There is inherent leverage in each business because once the initial data is assembled and the platform/software has been built, the marginal cost of adding other licensed users and updating data is low. The Company’s own historic experience supports this low marginal cost of user assertion. In terms of investment cycle,

Morningstar Sustainalytics is currently at an early-stage relative to Enterprise and PitchBook, which are more mature and already experiencing greater economies of scale; therefore, Morningstar Sustainalytics’ current margin is below that of Enterprise and PitchBook.

Margin convergence can be achieved more quickly by reducing investment; however, management determined lack of investment would not be optimal for long-term value creation, and ultimately, long-term financial performance. The Company projects it will achieve similar long-term margins with Morningstar Sustainalytics relative to its historical experience with Enterprise and PitchBook products given the similar license-based nature of its products, offerings, customers, and distribution channels.

· Further, Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics each operate in a similar competitive landscape and have consistent sources of competitive advantage that enable these businesses to sustain full-scale margins once mature: 1) data sets are difficult to replicate, given the complexity of the data scraping process, 2) proprietary analytics and contextual data adds unique, intangible value for customers, and 3) products become embedded in customer workflows, creating very high switching costs. These factors allow these businesses to benefit from low customer acquisition costs and consistently high renewal rates (97%+ across each of the three businesses in 2022).

· Regarding expected convergence of margins across Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics, Company history and peer analysis demonstrate the potential for long-term margin convergence through its own extensive history with scaling data platforms. The exact timing of this convergence is not known by the Company given the ongoing investment cycle decisions that have currently been made or may be made in the future. Specifically, the Company will decide to invest in data and research at different points in time, and these investment decisions impact margins negatively in the short-term (as most cost is headcount/employee or M&A-related and is expensed as incurred) but will support long-term results by expanding addressable market through enhanced offerings of data and research, thus providing greater returns. In addition, the Company notes that the peers it tracks that have comparable, but currently more developed, business models also exhibit comparable financial performance over the full business cycle.

Conclusion for Data and Analytics - Based on the qualitative and quantitative discussions above, the Company believes that Enterprise,

PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics are both qualitatively and economically similar and meet the criteria to aggregate into a single operating segment, which is also a reportable segment.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

Aggregated Operating Segment: Asset and Index Solutions

Morningstar Indexes, Morningstar Retirement, and

Morningstar Wealth serve investors by building investable solutions and strategies that seek to build wealth for the end investor. The

Company’s strategy and historical approach has been to build investable solutions, investment strategies, or investment portfolios at scale. These strategies create vehicles for managing or advising large pools of client assets. A critical commonality is that each is principally an asset under management platform charging basis points on assets under management (AUM) and advisement (AUMA). Accordingly, long-term economies of scale are driven by growth in AUM across each of the three businesses.

Morningstar

Indexes, Morningstar Retirement, and Morningstar Wealth offer strategies that attract large pools of client assets, generating revenue by charging fees on AUMA. Specifically, 75% of Morningstar Indexes, 98% of Morningstar Retirement and 54% of Morningstar Wealth revenues for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 is from AUM and AUMA, while the other four businesses have no revenue from

AUMA. Even though Morningstar Indexes and Morningstar Wealth support their core products with secondary offerings that earn other revenue types, the Company views the success of these businesses through the level of assets in the strategies that each area produces.

Since asset-based products account for the majority of revenue for the Morningstar Indexes, Morningstar Retirement, and Morningstar Wealth businesses, the nature of the production processes for each of these businesses are similar, specifically:

· There are coordinated processes across portfolio management, product teams, and investment operations teams to construct, and implement investable portfolios and strategies.

· Each of these businesses are based on leveraging Morningstar’s core data assets and related intellectual property (research, ratings, and data), which are used to build other value add products (i.e., investment portfolios and strategies) and then attract assets into these portfolios and models.

· Each of these businesses use central functions to build investable solutions, investment strategies, or investment portfolios. Specifically, the teams that produce Morningstar’s core, proprietary research have been moved out of the business areas and into a central team to provide greater leverage of these capabilities. The central team includes research (manager research, equity research, and quantitative research), portfolio construction and management, and wealth forecasting.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

Morningstar Indexes, Morningstar Retirement, and Morningstar Wealth products cater to a subset of investors and advisors looking to invest assets with the aim of increasing wealth over time. More specifically, Morningstar Wealth and Morningstar Retirement both have extensive focus and overlap in targeting financial advisors. The Company notes that the target clients for the products offered by Morningstar Indexes differ slightly in that they are offered further up the value chain, meaning indexes are available to asset managers whereas the portfolios offered by Morningstar Retirement and Morningstar Wealth are directly available to the end investor. However, customers across all businesses include firms that share an important characteristic – they are involved in the development and distribution of investment products.

Indexes, Morningstar Retirement, and Morningstar Wealth leverage multiple GTM strategies and a variety of distribution channels. However, the primary route to market is via direct sales, with each business leveraging its own embedded sales specialist teams focused on connecting specific buyer needs to specific product capabilities. In direct sales, the product areas also leverage central sales resources and coordination through Strategic Account Executives (SAEs), who develop, implement, and coordinate distribution strategies across key customers within

Morningstar Retirement, Morningstar Indexes, and Morningstar Wealth (there are SAEs covering all three businesses). Other areas of shared competencies include demand generation, inside sales, strategic accounts sales, and cross product solution sales capabilities. From a marketing perspective, the businesses leverage a mix of central marketing capabilities, such as brand, public relations, communications, and website, to more granular dedicated marketing services within the product area, including product marketing, events, and campaign management. All GTM teams follow a standard sales process, methodology, and systems as set forth by the central GTM team.

Morningstar Wealth all operate in regulated environments in each jurisdiction in which they do business. As a result of the regulations, each business has significant compliance responsibilities and costs, including, but not limited to, sales practices, specified governance and oversight arrangements, outsourcing limitations, specified items in a code of conduct, key information disclosures, required systems and controls governing data, complaints, recordkeeping, and general anti-fraud prohibitions.

Given the numerous regulatory agencies in various jurisdictions, the Company believes the regulatory presence/environment is similar across these businesses.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

280 notes that economically similar operating segments often exhibit similar long-term financial performance. As the Company’s asset-based businesses, Morningstar Indexes, Morningstar Retirement, and Morningstar Wealth have very similar economic characteristics.

When assessing economic similarity and the ability to achieve similar long-term margins, the Company considered that the economics (revenue/profit) and asset flows of these businesses are highly correlated with market performance:

· Revenue in all three businesses is primarily generated from fees (basis points) charged on AUMA, resulting in revenue for all three businesses trending similarly with the market over time. Asset gains and losses related to ebbs and flows in the markets will cause revenue to fluctuate, exhibiting stronger financial performance (revenue and profit) as markets rise and weaker performance as they fall.

· As noted above, the changes in AUMA over time is driven by market performance and can be explained by

1) the direct impact of market impact gains and losses on AUMA, and 2) the market impact on customer behavior changing the inflows and outflows from customers. For example, when the markets decline, the Company observes lower net inflows because investors typically reduce their equity exposure. This results in less capital in exchange-traded funds, and, therefore, reduced fees paid by Morningstar’s

Indexes, Wealth, or Retirement clients.

Another consideration when assessing economics and ability to achieve long-term margins that are similar is the maturity of these businesses, and the ability for asset-based businesses to benefit from large economics of scale. These businesses sell products that are an infinitely replicable collection of securities in the form of investment strategies, portfolios, and portfolio construction methodology. Once created, they can be sold or applied repetitively with minimal incremental costs. Morningstar Indexes and Morningstar Wealth are currently at an earlier stage of the investment cycle relative to Morningstar Retirement, which is more mature. This is supported by the Company’s analysis of several peers that generate asset-based revenue via investment products and services, which demonstrated a clear link between

AUMA and long-term profitability. The financial performance of these competitors also aligns with the long-term expectations for the three operating segments in Asset and Index Solutions, and supports Management’s projections for margin convergence within these businesses.

Morningstar Retirement’s margins reflect the maturity of this business (having been established in 2000) along with a strong market presence over many years after building proprietary managed account capabilities and relationships. The Company’s history has shown that upfront investments to build and enhance managed account offerings/platforms as well as create an industry network has led to a profitable model that scales as AUM grow. The Company is applying the same strategy with Morningstar Indexes and Morningstar Wealth - building operating models to significantly grow AUM over time. Upfront incremental investment in both businesses has reduced margins temporarily, but is expected to support significant future growth, resulting in margin expansion over time that will converge and achieve similarity with Morningstar Retirement.

for Asset and Index Solutions - Based on the qualitative and quantitative discussions above, management believes that Morningstar

Wealth, Morningstar Indexes, and Morningstar Retirement are both qualitatively and economically similar and support aggregation into a single operating segment, which is also a reportable segment.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

Operating Segment: Credit and Ratings Solutions

DBRS Morningstar generates revenue by providing independent credit rating services on financial institutions, corporates, and sovereigns, as well as on securitizations and other structured finance instruments. These credit ratings are formed based on established methodologies, models, and criteria that apply to the entities and securities that DBRS Morningstar rates, using a rating scale to assign and monitor credit ratings. Credit ratings are issued in response to request from issuers, intermediaries, or investors, and rating reports are distributed electronically to clients with public ratings posted on the DBRS Morningstar website. As a credit rating entity, DBRS Morningstar operates in a highly regulated environment in every jurisdiction in which it does business.

Given the unique aspects of the credit ratings business noted above, DBRS Morningstar was not deemed to be economically similar to other operating segments and will not be aggregated with other operating segments.

Reportable Segment Conclusion

Finally, the Company considered the quantitative thresholds outlined in ASC 280-10-50-12, noting the two aggregated operating segments: Data and Analytics, Asset and Index Solutions, and the Credit and Ratings Solutions operating segment, individually represent over 10 percent of the Company’s current and projected consolidated revenues for the next three years. Their combined total revenues represent 100 percent of the Company’s consolidated revenues; therefore, the 75 percent revenue threshold is met. Based on this analysis, we determined the following will be the Company’s reportable segments:

· Data and Analytics – aggregated Enterprise, PitchBook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics

· Asset and Index Solutions – aggregated Morningstar Indexes, Morningstar Retirement, and Morningstar

Wealth

· Credit and Ratings Solutions

Our segment footnote disclosure is included within Note 7 to our Unaudited Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements included in the Quarterly

Report on Form 10-Q for the period ended September 30, 2023 filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on November 9,

2023.

Goodwill Impairment Testing Analysis Under Revised Segment

Analysis

As noted above, the Company identified seven operating segments prior to applying the aggregation criteria that align to the Company’s product areas. The Company assessed the seven operating segments under ASC 350 to determine its components. ASC 350-20-35-34 states that “A component of an operating segment is a reporting unit if the component constitutes a business for which discrete financial information is available and segment management, as that term is defined in paragraph 280-10-50-7, regularly reviews the operating results of that component.” Following the guidance from

ASC 350, the Company’s seven operating segments, prior to applying the aggregation criteria, were determined to be the Company’s seven reporting units.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

To determine whether the change to our identified operating segments and reporting units has, or had, an impact on our prior annual goodwill impairment testing analysis, the Company engaged a third-party valuation specialist to perform a valuation of our reporting units as of January 1, 2021. The start of 2021 was selected based on the Company’s intention to ensure that the change in identified operating segments, and associated reporting units, would not have any impact to comparative periods on file with the SEC, notably the Company’s comparative Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the period ended September 30, 2022, and the Company’s annual goodwill impairment testing for both the 2022 and 2021 years.

ASC 820-10-20 defines fair value as “the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date.” The calculation of value for each of the identified reporting units as of January 1,

2021, was based on a market approach, specifically the guideline company method, which analyzed (i) market multiples of revenue and

EBITDA for a group of comparable public companies and (ii) the relative growth, profitability, potential for cash flow conversion, and risk of each reporting unit relative to the peers and Morningstar overall. Management believes the market approach is reasonable given

(i) the availability of publicly traded market values for the Company which the valuation can reconcile to, (ii) the availability of public information regarding a number of comparable companies, and (iii) the availability of historical and forecasted financial information at the reporting unit level. Management does not believe that other methods would result in a materially different outcome, and as noted, the Company reconciled its market approach to the market capitalization as of the valuation date. As a result of the analysis performed, management concluded there was no impairment as of January 1, 2021, as each of the reporting units had an excess of fair value over carrying value ranging from [***] of their respective carrying values as shown below:

Reporting Unit

Excess of Fair Value over

Carrying Value (in millions)

Percentage of

Carrying Value

Enterprise3

[***]

Retail Investing Products & Services3

Morningstar Wealth3

Morningstar Managed Portfolios

Morningstar Index

Morningstar Credit Ratings

PitchBook

Sustainalytics

Note the reporting unit structure in place as of January 1, 2021 was comprised of eight reporting units; the incremental reporting unit was Retail Investing Products & Services. On January 1, 2022, this Retail Investing Products & Services reporting unit largely became Enterprise, apart from an insignificant product that became a part of Morningstar Wealth (approximately 90% became

Enterprise and 10% Morningstar Wealth).

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

After determination of value for each reporting unit at January 1, 2021, the Company re-performed a goodwill impairment analysis as of the subsequent annual goodwill impairment testing dates (i.e., October 1, 2021 and October 1, 2022).

Specifically, the Company performed a qualitative assessment for the relevant events and circumstances consistent with the criteria in ASC 350-20-35-3C to determine if it is more likely than not that a reporting unit is impaired. Based on the analysis of the macroeconomic conditions, industry and market conditions, cost factors, cash flows, changes in key Company personnel, and our share price, the Company did not identify any significant qualitative factors that would suggest the need to perform a quantitative goodwill impairment test at any of the three testing dates subsequent to January 1, 2021. A summary of our qualitative assessment is included in the table below:

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

[***]4

The Company did not observe any events or changes in circumstances that would require an additional impairment review outside of the annual tests in 2021 and 2022, nor in the interim periods of 2023. The Company will complete its annual impairment review in the fourth quarter of 2023, consistent with its goodwill impairment policy.

In conclusion, the analyses performed validates the revised analysis pursuant to ASC 280 did not result in an impairment to goodwill for any of the Company’s revised reporting units under ASC 350.

Read in the reply
SEC asked
Segment and Geographical Area Information, page 93 1. We note from your response that you have chosen Adjusted Operating Income as the reported measure of profit or loss for your segments. Please (i) provide us with a list of all measures of profit or loss at the product area level that are provided to the CODM; (ii) describe each of these measures; (iii) tell us the frequency with which they are provided; and (iv)
Rest of the question

tell us how you concluded that Adjusted Operating Income was the measure required to be disclosed under ASC 280-10-50-28. As examples only, your most recent response references operating profit (page 3), and page 13 of your response dated May 31, 2023 references operating income before central cost allocations, EBITDA including central cost allocations, EBITDA excluding central cost allocations, operating income, and operating margin. 2. We note that page 4 of your response says the CODM will use Adjusted Operating Income to make decisions to allocate resources and assess performance of segments. Please clarify whether Adjusted Operating Income at the product area level was used by the CODM during the quarter ended September 30, 2023 and in prior periods, or whether this is a measure that has not historically been used but will be used going forward. 3. We continue to evaluate your response, including the qualitative factors considered in your aggregation analysis, and may have further comments. However, in consideration of your aggregation conclusion, please provide us with the underlying historical financial and other data you considered in concluding that the aggregated segments have similar economic characteristics under ASC 280-10-50-11. As part of your response, please provide quantitative data for revenues and the measures of segment profitability you considered, by year, for each operating segment. 4. We note from your response that you project that Morningstar Sustainalytics’ current margin is below that of Enterprise and PitchBook, however, you project it will achieve similar long-term margins. Similarly, you project margin convergence for the three operating segments in Asset and Index Solutions. Please clarify whether and how you considered and determined actual margins achieved, in addition to the ability to achieve similar long-term margins, when evaluating your segments for aggregation. Please also provide us with quantitative details regarding (i) actual historical individual (not aggregated) segment revenues and margins; (ii) assumptions underlying your projections for margin convergence among different businesses, as well as when you expect such convergence to actually occur, and (iii) whether the segments you aggregated are expected to have similar long-term sales trends and the assumptions underlying your sales projections. 5. Please provide us with your analysis of how aggregation of your operating segments is consistent with the objective and basic principles of ASC 280. Refer to ASC 280-10-5011.

MORN answered
The

Chief Operating Decision Maker (“CODM”), Kunal Kapoor (Morningstar Chief Executive Officer), assesses business performance primarily through review of the Monthly Financial Book. The Monthly Financial Book is prepared by the Finance team and focuses on the performance of the Company at the consolidated level as well as revenue by its seven business components. Additionally, the Monthly Financial

Book details various financial performance metrics of the Company’s operating segments (described below).
Rest of the answer

Supplemental to the Monthly

Financial Book, Quarterly Business Review (“QBR”) reports are prepared by the product area managers (previously defined in the Company’s response to the SEC comment letter dated June 15, 2023 as “Segment Managers”) with support from the Finance team and presented to the CODM on a periodic basis, which varies by business component. Additional discussion of the Monthly

Financial Book and QBR reports follows:

Monthly

Financial Book

Monthly Financial Book is provided to the CODM and the Executive Leadership team on a monthly basis and presents information for the

CODM to assess performance and make resource allocation decisions for the Company. While the majority of the Monthly Financial Book focuses on consolidated Company results and revenue reporting on a consolidated and disaggregated basis, the Company also presents various profitability measures at the segment level. Specifically, for the months prior to September 2023, the Monthly Financial Books included the following profitability measures for each of the Company’s seven business components, shown as an amount favorable/(unfavorable) compared to budget:

· Operating

Income1 before allocations2

Income after allocations

Income margin (after allocations)

· EBITDA3 margin (after allocations)

The Company defines Operating Income as revenue less the following operating expenses: cost of revenue, sales and marketing, general and administrative, and depreciation and amortization. The only incremental costs to arrive at net income are interest expense, realized gains and losses on sale of investments or equity method investments, other income (loss), equity in investments of unconsolidated entities, and income tax amounts.

[***]

The Company defines EBITDA as consolidated earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. For the presentation of this metric at the product area level, this metric would be consistent with operating income except for the exclusion of depreciation and amortization.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

As part of the reassessment of ASC 280, Segment Reporting (“ASC 280”), the Company revised its Monthly Financial Book in September of 2023. In response to the change to reporting under multiple segments, the Company was thoughtful as to which metrics would best allow the CODM to assess business performance and make resource allocation decisions across the segments. The Company has historically presented Adjusted Operating Income as a non-GAAP measure of financial performance on a consolidated basis within its earnings releases and Management’s Discussion and Analysis included in the Company’s periodic reports under the Securities Exchange

Act. Adjusted Operating Income is defined as operating income4, excluding intangible amortization expense, all mergers and acquisitions (M&A)-related expenses (including M&A-related earn-outs), and items related to the significant reduction and shift of the Company’s operations in China. As Morningstar has made certain large-scale acquisitions in recent years, the Company is of the view that it needs to understand and assess the monthly performance of the business excluding acquired intangible amortization and other M&A-related costs, which can be substantial and may range from pre-acquisition due diligence costs to post-closing system and process integration activities, which are not reflective of the core business operations. In addition, the reduction and shift of operations out of China resulted in significant costs that the Company determined were not representative of ongoing business activities and had the potential to cloud the true expense profile of the Company for investors.

At the segment level, this is operating income after allocations.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

Management notes that Adjusted Operating Income (as currently defined) for each of the Company’s seven business components as well as on a consolidated basis was not historically included in the Monthly Financial Book. Instead, the profitability measures bulleted above were included, shown as an amount favorable/(unfavorable) compared to budget.

To align with our segment reporting reassessment and highlight Adjusted Operating Income as the chosen segment profitability measure, the

September 2023 Monthly Financial Book was updated to present only the following profitability measures at the segment level:

· Adjusted

Segment Operating Income5 and respective Segment Adjusted Operating Income Margin

Segment EBITDA6 and respective Adjusted Segment EBITDA Margin above two measures are the only measures presented consistently at the segment level within the Monthly Financial Book from and after

September 2023. [***]. As the Company settles into its new segment reporting structure, additional changes to the Monthly Financial

Book may be considered, as needed, to support enhanced management and monitoring of the business.

QBR

Reports

QBR reports are presented by the Segment Managers to the CODM on a monthly or quarterly basis. There is variability in the meeting and reporting frequency. In addition, the content, both financial and non-financial, of each QBR report varies by business component based on the specific items the Segment Managers deem important for a given meeting. Given the varying frequency and content of the information presented in the QBR reports, they are not regularly reviewed by the CODM and are considered supplemental to the Monthly Financial Book.

The Company defines Adjusted Segment Operating Income as Operating

Income plus: intangible amortization expense, M&A-related expenses (including M&A-related earnouts), and costs associated with the significant reduction and shift of the Company's operations in Shenzhen, China (including severance and personnel expenses, transformation costs, and asset impairment costs).

Adjusted Segment EBITDA presented by the Company at the segment level is calculated as Adjusted Operating Income, excluding depreciation expense.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

list below includes the types of profitability metrics (including margins) that may be included within individual business component

QBR reports from quarter to quarter:

income pre-allocations income after-allocations operating income

· EBITDA before corporate allocation after corporate allocation

Similar to the Monthly Financial Book, the Company is updating the QBR reports to consistently present Adjusted Operating Income on a prospective basis, and notes that, despite this update, the variability of the information provided and frequency of preparation will continue. In contrast to the QBR reports, the Monthly Financial Book is regularly reviewed, consistent month-to-month, and is the main source of data used by the CODM to measure business performance and allocate resources.

Conclusion on measure of profit or loss for segments

In deciding which measure of segment profit or loss to disclose, the Company considered the guidance in ASC 280-10-50-28, which states:

“If the chief operating decision maker uses only one measure of a segment’s profit or loss and only one measure of a segment’s assets in assessing segment performance and deciding how to allocate resources, segment profit or loss and assets shall be reported at those measures. If the chief operating decision maker uses more than one measure of a segment’s profit or loss and more than one measure of a segment’s assets, the reported measures shall be those that management believes are determined in accordance with the measurement principles most consistent with those used in measuring the corresponding amounts in the public entity’s consolidated financial statements.” considering the guidance above, the Company reviewed the metrics presented in both the Monthly Financial Book to determine the appropriate measure to disclose as the segment measure of profit or loss.

Company has deemed the appropriate measure of segment profit or loss to disclose should be driven by the Monthly Financial Book since it is (1) regularly reviewed, (2) consistent and comparable from month-to-month, and (3) is the primary source of data used by the CODM to measure business performance and allocate resources. As such, this financial data is directly consistent with the guidance in ASC 280-10-50-1(b), “operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity’s chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance”.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

more than one segment measure of profit or loss was historically presented within the Monthly Financial Book (i.e., Adjusted Operating

Income and Adjusted EBITDA), the Company considered various factors in deciding which metric was most in line with ASC 280. As a starting point, the Company notes Adjusted Operating Income has been the metric historically presented as part of the Company’s consolidated earnings releases and Management’s Discussion and Analysis included in the Company’s periodic reports under the Securities

Exchange Act. Since the Company began presenting Adjusted Operating Income in 2018, its investors and shareholders have come to rely on and track this metric in their evaluation of the Company’s performance. The Company also notes that several of its peer group present “adjusted” metrics, so its presentation of Adjusted Operating Income supports greater comparability across its competitors.

Importantly,

Adjusted Operating Income is more levered than Adjusted EBITDA as it includes all allocated costs, inclusive of depreciation expense, and therefore, most consistent with the corresponding amounts and principles used in the Company’s consolidated financial statements, and is most quantitatively similar to net income as reported on a consolidated financial statement basis. To illustrate this point, the

Company’s total segment Adjusted Operating Income and total segment Adjusted EBITDA for the three months ended September 30,

2023 was [***] and [***], respectively. Similarly, total segment Adjusted Operating Income and total segment Adjusted EBITDA for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 was [***] and [***], respectively. Adjusted EBITDA excludes depreciation and is therefore further from net income than Adjusted Operating Income.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

Therefore, the Company concluded that Adjusted Operating Income is the segment measure of profit or loss required to be disclosed under ASC 280-10-50-28.

Refer to the table below for a summary of conclusions reached:

Segment

Profitability

Metric Presented beginning with

September 30, 2023

CODM

Package

Frequency of

CODM review

Three months ended

(in millions)

Nine

Evaluation consistency with consolidated financial statements

(net income)

Adjusted

Segment Operating Income

Financial

Book & QBR

– Financial Book

Quarterly - QBRs

Segment Operating Income is the most consistent with net income of the consolidated financial statements, which was $39.1 million and $67.7 million for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023, respectively. Adjusted Operating Income is most levered as it includes all allocated costs, inclusive of depreciation expense.

Segment EBITDA

Book

Operating

Quarterly

– QBR

Periodically

- QBR

Various performance metrics reviewed periodically by the CODM. More specifically the presentation within the QBR is at the discretion of the Segment Manager. Historically, only certain Segment Managers have included these metrics and not consistently each quarter. Accordingly, they were not evaluated for consistency with the consolidated financial statements for purposes of presenting as the presented measure of profit or loss for segments.

EBITDA

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

2. We note that page 4 of your response says the CODM will use Adjusted Operating Income to make decisions to allocate resources and assess performance of segments. Please clarify whether

Adjusted Operating Income at the product area level was used by the CODM during the quarter ended September 30, 2023 and in prior periods, or whether this is a measure that has not historically been used but will be used going forward.

Response:

discussed in the response to Question 1 above, Adjusted Operating Income was not presented to the CODM at the product area level in prior periods. Adjusted Operating Income was added to the September 30, 2023 Monthly Financial Book at the reportable segment level and will be included prospectively.

3. We continue to evaluate your response, including the qualitative factors considered in your aggregation analysis, and may have further comments. However, in consideration of your aggregation conclusion, please provide us with the underlying historical financial and other data you considered in concluding that the aggregated segments have similar economic characteristics under ASC 280-10-50-11. As part of your response, please provide quantitative data for revenues and the measures of segment profitability you considered, by year, for each operating segment.

4. We note from your response that you project that Morningstar Sustainalytics’ current margin is below that of Enterprise and PitchBook, however, you project it will achieve similar long-term margins. Similarly, you project margin convergence for the three operating segments in Asset and Index Solutions. Please clarify whether and how you considered and determined actual margins achieved, in addition to the ability to achieve similar long-term margins, when evaluating your segments for aggregation. Please also provide us with quantitative details regarding

(i) actual historical individual (not aggregated) segment revenues and margins; (ii) assumptions underlying your projections for margin convergence among different businesses, as well as when you expect such convergence to actually occur, and (iii) whether the segments you aggregated are expected to have similar long-term sales trends and the assumptions underlying your sales projections.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

Response:

following response applies to Questions 3 and 4 in the Comment Letter. [***]7

Data and Analytics Segment

Based on its strategy, current operating plans, and forecasts, the Company expects the business components in Data and Analytics to exhibit margin convergence over time. As described in prior responses, all three business components within this reportable segment are qualitatively similar and economically similar as the operating model is highly leverageable as scale is achieved. Data and Analytics business components are all centered around software platforms giving access to investor data and, once upfront investments to build data sets and platforms are made, incremental licenses can be sold with minimal marginal costs. [***].

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

Data &

Analytics

[***] [***]

[***]8

[***].

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

Upon its founding in 2007, PitchBook invested heavily in data sets, product development, and customer acquisition, which continues today.

For example, in 2022, PitchBook acquired Leveraged Commentary and Data for $650 million, enabling PitchBook to expand its platform offering to include private debt market news and data, attract new users, and expand existing customer relationships, all driving revenue growth.

In addition to this acquisition, the Company has also been investing organically to enhance the product offering and expand its subscriber base. As shared in its presentation at its annual shareholders’ meeting on May 12, 2023, the Company has made organic investments exceeding $40 million over 2021 and 2022. [***].

Compared to the other business components in the Data and Analytics segment, Sustainalytics is at the earliest stage in its life cycle, as its core ESG Risk Rating product was not launched until 2018. As a result, it has not yet enjoyed the same economies of scale and has not yet reached target profitability. Shortly after its acquisition in 2020, the Company began making investments to develop new data sets and platforms, as well as sales and marketing capabilities. As shared in its presentation at its annual shareholders’ meeting on

May 12, 2023, the Company has made organic investments in the range of $30-40 million over 2021 and 2022, primarily to develop its proprietary climate and impact data sets and build sales and marketing teams. In 2022, the Company also made an acquisition of approximately

$7 million to support its climate data initiative. As expected, Sustainalytics’ revenue is growing rapidly as revenues more than doubled in 2021 and grew by over 30% in 2022. [***].

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

Asset and Index Solutions Segment

Company also expects margin convergence in the Asset and Index Solutions segment. As the Company has addressed in prior responses, Morningstar

Retirement (Retirement), Morningstar Indexes (Indexes), and Morningstar Wealth (Wealth) are qualitatively similar for several reasons and economically similar, centered around the business model of generating revenue by charging basis points on assets under management and advisement (AUMA). [***].

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

close correlation between market performance and revenue growth for these asset-based business components is relevant for economic similarity and emphasizes that revenue trends tend to follow market cycles as the AUMA upon which basis points are charged for fees go up or down.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

shown in the tables and charts below, the profitability of these business components was more consistent in previous years (e.g., 2017-2019), even while Indexes and Wealth were not operating with optimum scale. Indexes and Wealth were pursuing different strategies at that time, which did not support paths to maximize their full revenue and profit potentials. [***].

This contrasts with Retirement, which was launched in 2000 and is the most mature business component in the Asset and Index Solutions segment.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

shared in its presentation at its annual shareholders’ meeting on May 12, 2023, the Company made organic investments in the range of $30-40 million for Wealth over 2021 and 2022. These investments have refocused the business from customized investment solutions with an emphasis on larger institutional clients to a platform model that serves as a conduit to client assets and channels these assets into Morningstar managed portfolios [***]. Meanwhile, the 2022 acquisition of Praemium’s international business for $44.9 million brought similar platform capabilities outside the U.S., [***].

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

Analyzing

Wealth competitors with similar platform models reveals a clear link between AUMA and profitability. For example, AssetMark’s Adjusted

EBITDA margin was 24% in 2018, based on AUMA of $44 billion, and 32% by 2022, as AUMA had risen to $84 billion. [***].

Indexes, the situation is similar. As shared in its presentation at its annual shareholder meeting on May 12, 2023, the Company made organic investments in the range of $10-20 million for Indexes over 2021 and 2022. The Company has been building teams and capabilities to create new investible products. In addition, the Company invested heavily in a proprietary index calculation engine for its products to reduce reliance on outside providers and acquired Moorgate Benchmarks (a European-based provider of index design, calculation, and administration) [***] in 2022 to enhance these capabilities. The Company also increased the size and scale of the global sales team to serve market needs. [***]9

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

5. Please provide us with your analysis of how aggregation of your operating segments is consistent with the objective and basic principles of ASC 280. Refer to ASC 280-10-50-11.

Response:

ASC

280-10-50-11 requires the aggregation of operating segments to be consistent with the objectives and basic principles of segment reporting outlined in ASC 280-10-10-1, which are intended to assist financial statement users better understand an entity’s different types of business activities, the different economic environments in which it operates, its performance, its prospects for future net cash flows, and to make more informed judgments about the entity as a whole.

Company respectfully refers you to additional information provided in this letter response and its comment letter response dated November 9,

2023 for discussion related to the qualitative similarity of its operating segments as it pertains to the nature of products and services, production processes, customers, distribution methods, and regulatory environments. The Company believes an investor would obtain the same level of information relating to its business activities and economic environments in which it operates by understanding the operating segments – as aggregated into Data and Analytics, Asset and Index Solutions, and Credit Ratings and Solutions – as the aggregated operating segments are similar in each of these factors. Additional information to facilitate a user’s understanding of the business and its performance would not be obtained from a disaggregated view of the operating segments.

Given that for the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the Data and Analytics reportable segment was comprised of [***] and the Credit

Ratings and Solutions segment was almost entirely comprised of transaction-based revenue, the Company believes any movements in the financial performance of the underlying business components to be similar. For example, the Data and Analytics components exhibit consistent movement and trends in revenues and profitability based on their leverage models, because once the initial data sets are assembled and the platform/software has been built, the marginal cost of adding other licensed users and updating data is low. Additionally, as it relates to the Asset and

Index Solutions reportable segment, the financial performance for all three components of this reportable segment moves in line with the overall market. Asset gains and losses are correlated directly to market movements, which will cause revenue to fluctuate, exhibiting stronger financial performance (revenue and profit) as markets rise and weaker performance as they fall.

FOIA Confidential Treatment Request by Morningstar, Inc. Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

[***]. Therefore, the Company does not believe disaggregation of the reportable segments would provide additional useful information to investors. Increasing the prominence of the individual operating segments would detract from an understanding of the Company’s view of the material drivers of its business, which is aligned with the three reportable segments and the way the Company drives strategy for each segment.

Finally, as part of its revised ASC 280 assessment, the Company made changes to the way it provides information to investors through its presentation materials, and respectfully refer you to the Current Report on Form 8-K dated November 9, 2023, which furnished a Supplemental

Presentation Update. This investor presentation presents information to investors under the new reportable segments and describes product areas and representative products of those reportable segments. The Company believes sharing information with investors in this manner, along with the financial information disclosed by segment in its financial statements, allows financial statement users to make informed judgments about the Company as a whole.

conclusion, the Company believes the aggregation of our operating segments is consistent with the objective and basic principles of ASC

280.

Read in the reply
SEC asked
Segment and Geographical Area Information, page 93 1. We have considered your November 9, 2023 and December 15, 2023 responses to our comments. Based upon the information provided, we do not believe the aggregation criteria in ASC 280-10-50-11 have been met and therefore object to your aggregation of the Enterprise, Pitchbook, and Morningstar Sustainalytics operating segments and the Morningstar Indexes, Wealth, and
Rest of the question

Retirement operating segments. Please revise your disclosures accordingly.

MORN answered
In response to your objection, and as described in more detail below, we have revised our segment disclosure and concluded upon the following five reportable segments, which are also individual operating segments as shared in our comment letter response dated November 9, 2023:

● Morningstar Data &

Analytics (Enterprise)

● PitchBook

● Morningstar Wealth (Wealth)

● Morningstar Credit (Morningstar DBRS)

● Morningstar Retirement

(Retirement)

Our remaining operating segments, Morningstar Indexes (Indexes) and

Morningstar Sustainalytics (Sustainalytics), will not be presented as reportable
Rest of the answer

segments as they do not meet the quantitative thresholds outlined in ASC 280-50-10-12, nor will they be aggregated into a reportable segment per ASC 280-50-10-13, and will instead be reported as “Corporate and All Other” in accordance with ASC 280-10-50-15.

Please see Appendix A for our revised segment footnote disclosure that will be included within the Notes of our Audited Consolidated Financial Statements included in the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2023, that we plan to file with the Securities and Exchange Commission on February 29,

2024.

ASC 280 Analysis

In order to address your concerns, we have reassessed the aggregation criteria in ASC 280-10-50-11 and concluded that the Company will not be aggregating any of our seven operating segments.

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated

We applied the 10% quantitative thresholds outlined in ASC 280-10-50-12

(the “10% tests”) to our seven operating segments. Based on final 2021, 2022, and 2023 revenue and profit/loss for our operating segments, we determined that Enterprise, PitchBook, Wealth, Morningstar DBRS, and Retirement should each be a separate reportable segment as their revenue and/or profit/loss exceeded 10% in at least one of the periods presented1.

Once we applied the 10% tests under ASC 280-10-50-12 and determined which operating segments are required to be shown as reportable segments, we applied the guidance under ASC 280-10-50-14, which further requires that reportable segment external revenues aggregate to at least 75% of an entity’s consolidated revenue (the “75% of Revenue Test”). The five reportable segments determined under the 10% tests represent over 91% of Morningstar’s consolidated revenue in each of 2021, 2022, and 2023, thus satisfying the 75% of Revenue Test. These reportable segments also represent 92% of reported profit/loss in each of the years presented.

Therefore, after satisfying the 75% of Revenue Test, our two remaining operating segments, Indexes and Sustainalytics, which are both below 10% of Morningstar’s consolidated revenue and profit/loss will be presented as “Corporate and All Other”. We considered the guidance in ASC 280-10-50-13, but concluded these operating segments should not be aggregated and combined as a reportable segment, given they do not meet the criteria established in ASC 280-10-50-13 and ASC 280-10-50-11. By applying ASC 280-10-50-15, operating segments that are not reportable are required to be combined and disclosed in an “all other” category. Accordingly, we included Indexes and

Sustainalytics in “Corporate and All Other” and not as a reportable segment. Rather, “Corporate and All

Other” provides a reconciliation between revenue from our reportable segments and consolidated revenue amounts. In addition to

Indexes and Sustainalytics revenue and profit/loss, the “Corporate and All Other” category includes unallocated corporate expenses, such as finance, human resources, legal, and other management-related costs that are not considered when segment performance is evaluated.

ASC 280 Objectives

The Company notes the general objectives of segment reporting outlined in ASC 280-10-10-1, which are intended to assist financial statement users in better understanding an entity’s performance, its prospects for future net cash flows, and to make more informed judgments about the entity as a whole. The Company believes that its updated segment reporting outlined in this response letter is consistent with these objectives given the significant percentage of both revenues and profit/loss included as reportable segments and separate disclosure of sources of revenue included in the “Corporate and All Other” category consistent with the disclosure requirements of ASC 280-10-50-15.

1 [***]

Pursuant to Rule 83 (17 C.F.R. 200.83). This letter requests confidential treatment of the bracketed portions of this letter (designated by “[***]”).

Read in the reply

Also in this review: request for more time, Apr 28, 2023, company letter, Nov 2, 2023, request for more time, Nov 28, 2023, closing letter, 2024-02-28

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2019

2020-05-27 to 2020-07-09 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2020-07-09
RevenueSegments
Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data · Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
SEC asked
Segment and Geographical Area Information, page 86 1. We note from your disclosure on page 11 that your current business model consists of selling products and services within following three major categories: Licensed-based, Asset-based, and Transaction-based (each of which represent more than 10% of total revenues).
Rest of the question

We also note from Question 3 in the 8-K dated March 13, 2020 that you discuss operating margins for these categories. Provide us with your analysis supporting your conclusion that a single reportable segment is appropriate pursuant to the requirements of ASC 280. Please address the following in your response: • We understand that certain of your major products and services have separate chief executive officers, heads, and presidents, etc. Tell us how you define your Chief Operating Decision Maker (“CODM”), for example, an individual or group. • Explain to us the key measures the CODM uses in assessment of performance and allocation of resources. Tell us if you provide detailed operating margin information, other than at the consolidated level, (e.g., at the major category level, as referenced above or for your major products and services) to the CODM.

MORN answered
Summary

In determining its reportable segments, the Company looked to the specific guidance included in FASB ASC 280, Segment Reporting (“ASC 280”), which employs a management approach in determining a company’s operating and reportable segments and, in turn, the presentation of disaggregated information by segment. Following the steps outlined in ASC 280, we concluded that our chief operating decision maker (“CODM”) is Kunal Kapoor, our Chief Executive Officer.
Rest of the answer

While the business activities and product lines covered by the Company’s reporting of revenue by type or product area may meet the definitions of a component and business activity, they are not appropriate operating segments because complete and consistent “discrete financial information” is not available. As a result, such information is unsuitable for use by our CODM in making decisions about resource allocation or strategic initiatives, and accordingly is not used for this purpose. Therefore, we conclude that a single reportable segment is appropriate.

Chief Operating Decision Maker

We determined our CODM based on the guidance in ASC 280-10-50-5 as follows:

“The term chief operating decision maker identifies a function, not necessarily a manager with a specific title. That function is to allocate resources to and assess the performance of the segments of a public entity.”

Our CODM is the Company’s Chief Executive Officer, Kunal Kapoor. Mr. Kapoor is the only member of the management team with the authority to make or approve significant operating or strategic decisions (subject to oversight by the Company’s Board of Directors) related to capital allocation, operating expense spending levels, resource management, and merger and acquisition activity. As noted in your comment, we have leaders within our Company who all report to the CODM that are accountable for product areas, functional areas or geographies based on our matrix management reporting structure. This structure was designed to put select groups of products and related direct expenses under the influence of specific leaders to facilitate increased accountability and collaboration, as well as to enable the structuring and tracking of specific metrics for performance management and incentive plans. While these leaders have discretion over certain levels of decision-making for their areas of responsibility, such as hiring and other resource and business decisions within consolidated budgeted guidelines, our CODM is solely responsible for decisions related to the allocation of resources that have impact on the consolidated Company business and operations.

Components of the Company’s Operations

The FASB Master Glossary defines a component as follows:

“A component of an entity comprises operations and cash flows that can be clearly distinguished, operationally and for financial reporting purposes, from the rest of the entity. A component of an entity may be a reportable segment or an operating segment, a reporting unit, a subsidiary or an asset group.”

As described in Item 1. Business of the Company’s Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2019, we sell products and services that generate revenue in three major categories (revenue by type): Licensed-based, Asset-based, and Transaction-based. Each of our three major categories of products and services are delivered using the Company’s primary set of core data, which is managed centrally on a Company-wide basis. Our core data consists, among other things, of historical and wide-ranging financial information and data concerning pooled investment vehicles, such as mutual funds and exchange traded funds, data on publicly traded equity issuers and securities, data on fixed income issuers and securities, and data on private companies and investors, such as private equity and venture capital funds. Decisions about resources and resource allocation are made at the Company-wide level based on how this core data can be most effectively utilized and monetized across revenue types and products in pursuit of the Company’s goal of empowering investor success. Our core data flows into and populates our licensed products, such as Morningstar Direct, Advisor Workstation, Office, Morningstar.com and PitchBook, and is used by our research, asset management and retirement products in developing fund and equity ratings, investment recommendations and model portfolios. In addition, it is sold directly to clients in various forms through Morningstar Data, and has been recently expanded and enhanced by the trove of fixed income data and research available from our principal transaction-based product offering, credit ratings from our rating agency, DBRS Morningstar.

We began disclosing revenue by type in the third quarter of 2016 to give investors better clarity on our business model and how revenue is being recognized under the applicable accounting guidance. Additionally, we report revenue by certain key product areas (Morningstar Data, Morningstar Direct, PitchBook, DBRS Morningstar, Morningstar Investment Management, Morningstar Advisor Workstation, and Workplace Solutions) to provide more useful information to investors. For the year ended December 31, 2019, our reported key product area revenue represented approximately 77% of consolidated revenue. Although we choose to disclose revenue by type and, in some cases, product area, we do not run our business or make resource allocation decisions under this framework. Instead, we consider the Company as a portfolio of product lines that share a core set of data and contribute to our consolidated results.

Operating Segments

With respect to the Company’s assessment of operating segments, the Company considered the definition of operating segments in ASC 280-10-50-1 as follows:

“…a component of a public entity that has all of the following characteristics:

a. It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expenses (including revenues and expenses relating to transactions with other components of the same public entity).

b. Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity’s chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance.

c. Its discrete financial information is available.”

A. Business Activities

Our portfolio of products and services engages in business activities that generate revenues and expenses. For external and certain internal management reporting purposes, we sometimes group the revenues we earn into the three categories mentioned above — Licensed-based, Asset-based and Transaction-based. However, more frequently, these business activities are organized by product or product area.

B. Operating Results Regularly Reviewed by CODM

The information described below is provided to our CODM monthly, quarterly, and/or annually:

· Consolidated financial performance;

· Revenue by product area and geography;

· Key performance indicators, including sales pipeline activities tied to revenue generation and business objectives;

· Product area financial summaries, including certain direct costs and allocated expenses; and

· Progress reporting against strategic objectives.

Our CODM meets with the product area leaders on a regular basis to review performance, primarily for purposes of driving accountability across the leadership team and to track progress against key business objectives. Performance is tied to our annual compensation plans. Our 2020 incentive compensation plans for product area leaders are structured with 75% of the payout tied to the total Company’s results with the other 25% driven primarily by revenue results for the leader’s specific product area. In addition, the Company’s named executive officers are compensated based on consolidated Company results.

A variety of financial information exists and is available from our global financial systems, including by product area, and this information is provided to and reviewed by our CODM; however, it does not represent the primary tool he uses in evaluating and deciding upon significant operating or strategic decisions. Instead, our CODM considers the impact on consolidated Company performance, margins, cash flow, and, most importantly, how our long-term organic revenue growth is driven by investment decisions. While the impact on specific product areas may help inform these decisions, it is not the primary driver of our CODM’s strategic decision-making framework, nor are such results viewed in isolation. The annual budget that our CODM presents for approval to the Board of Directors is prepared at the consolidated Company level, and decisions are evaluated in this context.

Accordingly, for our CODM, our consolidated results are the most important input into his strategic decision-making framework.

C. Discrete Financial Information

A variety of financial information relating to our revenue types and key product areas is prepared on a periodic basis and reviewed by our CODM and leadership team. However, our CODM does not believe this information represents sufficiently complete and consistent “discrete financial information” within the meaning of ASC 280. Further, he does not regularly utilize this type of financial information when making decisions to allocate resources or as the basis to determine the most effective way to monetize the Company’s core data assets. This is principally attributable to the changing nature of the Company’s product areas and the manner in which costs are allocated over time. Management employs a variety of cost allocation methodologies to directionally attribute certain expenses to the product areas. Nearly half of operating expense categories is not direct costs to the product areas. For the year ended December 31, 2019, 54% of our costs were direct and these were primarily related to compensation. Therefore, the expense profile by revenue type or product area is incomplete and varying assumptions are made to derive estimated, directional margins.

These issues explain why, in our 8-K response dated March 13, 2020 referenced above and at our recent shareholder meeting, we did not disclose License-based, Asset-based or Transaction-based operating margins. Instead, our intention was to provide “directional” observations on margin to assist investors because investors have asked for that information, not because it is used as a means for our CODM to allocate resources. This information was intended to provide relative margins between these categories at a point in time given the lack of data and consistency with historical comparisons. During our annual shareholder meeting, which was held on May 15, 2020, we also noted these metrics were “directional” and should be viewed as such.

In addition, our product areas have not been consistent over time as products are regrouped to maximize the value of the core data assets, to reflect operational improvements or for other reasons. For instance, the Company’s index products were treated as part of the Company’s data product area until 2020. In connection either with such changes or as a result of refinements to the analysis, the underlying cost allocation methodologies have been from time to time refined, added to, and replaced, which results in internal comparability issues. Also, certain pools of operating expenses, such as those for data, research, information technology systems and infrastructure, sales, marketing, facilities and other corporate functions, are managed by centralized teams. Similar to our core data set, these functions are shared extensively across the Company for business purposes and it is difficult to fully estimate utilization and attribution to any given area.

While certain directional and discrete financial information by revenue type or product area derived from these cost allocations is available, it is inherently incomplete, and, therefore, not utilized by our CODM to make decisions about the allocation of resources in support of our primary strategic financial goals of achieving long-term consolidated organic revenue growth, operating income growth and cash flow generation. Complete, consistent, and meaningful discrete financial information to help our CODM make informed judgments on these matters is only available at the consolidated Company level.

Aggregation and Materiality Determination

The provisions of ASC 280 detail two additional steps in this analysis, (i) aggregate operating segments that have similar economic characteristics and that meet certain qualitative aggregation criteria and (ii) apply quantitative materiality thresholds to each operating segment to determine which operating segments are required to be separately reported in the notes to the financial statements. As the Company determined that we have one operating segment, these two steps are not applicable.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 10, 2020: 10-Q filed Jul 31, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 1, 2020 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2020-07-09

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 17 letters filed since 2020-05-28. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/MORN/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.