We determined that the losses associated with the sales referenced above were not incurred until closing, based upon our application of the guidance in Statement of Financial
Accounting Standards No. 144, “Accounting for the
(“SFAS 144”). As discussed in more detail below, we did not consider either of these sales of operations to be “more-likely-than-not” until shortly prior to closing, and the Board of
Directors (the “Board”) did not approve either sale until such time.
Rest of the answer
As also discussed in more detail below, we conducted periodic impairment tests in accordance with SFAS 144 and recorded impairments of specific manufacturing lines when appropriate.
The first timeline below pertains to strategic alternative actions relating to the sale of the various operating assets of our Automotive Segment, including our Des Moines, Iowa automotive accessory operations and our automotive accessory operations in Coshocton, Ohio and LaGrange,
Georgia. This timeline is followed by analysis of the timing of the losses. We also provide below a second timeline relating to our Glassware and Candles Segment, which was part of our strategic alternative review.
Timeline #1 – Automotive Segment:
•
November 2004 – The Board authorized management to engage an investment banking firm to understand the alternatives available with respect to our automotive operations.
January 2005 – We formally engaged an investment banking firm to explore strategic alternatives involving all or a part of our automotive operations, including their potential sale.
Summer of 2005 through fall of 2006 – In conjunction with assessing various alternatives, we undertook marketing efforts for this segment’s operations but this proved challenging due to a number of factors, including deteriorating credit conditions for automotive-related transactions. We were unable to find an acceptable buyer with significant and satisfactory interest in the automotive operations as a whole. Discussions then ensued with various potential buyers regarding purchases of various product lines.
March 2007 – Pursuant to specific Board authorization granted on March 22, 2007, we sold our heavy truck splashguard and pickup truck bedmat lines manufactured in Wapakoneta,
Ohio for a gain of approximately $1.2 million.
May 23, 2007 – Board granted authorization to sell our automotive floor mat lines manufactured in Coshocton, Ohio and LaGrange, Georgia pursuant to the material terms presented to the Board by management.
June 2007 – In accordance with the foregoing authorization, we sold our automotive floor mat lines manufactured in Coshocton, Ohio and LaGrange, Georgia resulting in a pretax loss of approximately $24.3 million. We retained the Coshocton real estate, but very little of the Coshocton-related machinery and equipment.
May 28, 2008 – Board granted authorization to sell our truck accessory lines manufactured in Des Moines, Iowa pursuant to the material terms presented to the Board by management.
June 2008 – In accordance with the foregoing authorization, we sold our truck accessory lines manufactured in Des Moines, Iowa resulting in a pretax loss of approximately $20.4 million.
The primary driver for divestiture of the various operations was our strategic direction towards becoming a more food-focused company. The Board did not authorize, however, any sale of nonfood operations prior to finalization of the material terms, and initial Board directives were limited to authorizing management to explore strategic alternatives. Accordingly, no sale was considered probable until specific Board approval. The Board retained the ultimate authority to determine when these operational assets could be sold, to whom and at what price. Each sale transaction involved a purchase agreement not executed until closing after Board approval of all material terms. Financing for the buyers in the latter two transactions remained in question until the date of closing. While the Board and management discussed various alternatives during this extended time period, the challenges identified early regarding marketing efforts, the evolving nature of the discussions with potential buyers and generally deteriorating sectoral market conditions precluded a commitment to the divestitures until the actual time of sale.
As apparent from the discussion above, we did not consider our automotive operations as “assets held for sale” prior to closing under the guidance of paragraph 30 of SFAS 144. We did not meet all of the criteria of paragraph 30, including “management having the authority to approve the action, commit[ting] to a plan to sell the asset (disposal group);...[and] the sale of the asset (disposal group) [being] probable (i.e. likely to occur).” In addition, except for impairment of certain manufacturing lines specifically described below, we did not consider our automotive operations to be subject to impairment under SFAS 144. None of the asset sales met the “more-likely-than-not” threshold consideration under paragraph 8 of SFAS 144 until shortly prior to closing; and except as described below, our automotive operations had consistent, historic and projected positive cash flows that obviated further consideration for an impairment analysis under paragraph 8 of SFAS 144.
In conjunction with SFAS 144, we monitor long-lived assets for impairment and test such for recoverability whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that carrying amounts may not be recoverable. As defined in paragraph 4 of SFAS 144, “an asset group represents the lowest level for which identifiable cash flows are largely independent of the cash flows of the other groups of assets and liabilities.”
Of the above asset groups sold, only our automotive floor mat operation demonstrated adverse operating conditions, beginning in the latter half of fiscal 2006 that required consideration of impairment testing in accordance with SFAS 144. As such, with the input and assistance of outside valuation firms, we conducted and documented tests of impairment for our fiscal year ended June 30,
2006. We assumed 3% sales growth over a five-year projection period with an EBITDA margin between
4% and 5% each year. We utilized a discount rate of 12% for the analysis, which represented the estimated weighted average cost of capital calculated for the reporting unit. It should also be noted that we actually began reviewing and evaluating the goodwill (approximately $1 million) associated with this reporting unit in accordance with Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
No. 142 “Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets” beginning July 1, 2002 (the beginning of our 2003 fiscal year) and conducted annual reviews through June 30, 2006. In addition, we also conducted impairment reviews of certain specific long-lived assets relating to the floor mat products whenever events or changes in circumstances indicated that the carrying value may not have been recoverable and recorded impairments for specific manufacturing lines as considered necessary. As a result, asset impairments relating to two of our specific manufacturing lines within our floor mat operations occurred, and we recorded and disclosed these in our Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q for the periods ended March 31, 2005 and 2006, respectively.
The fiscal 2006 evaluations of the automotive floor mat operation resulted in a) a fair value of this reporting unit of $25.5 million as compared to a carrying value of $24.4 million and b) a fair value more specifically for property, plant and equipment of $22.6 million as compared to a net book value of $8.5 million. We continued to update our impairment review of this reporting unit quarterly during fiscal 2007 until it was ultimately sold. The probability of a sales transaction was not given weight due to the substantial uncertainties of successfully concluding a sale considering the prior lack of significant transactional progress, open issues regarding the negotiation of material terms and obtaining financing and the late timing (i.e., end of June 2007) of the sale itself.
Given such factors as our strategic direction to become a more food-focused company, certain management issues and the perception of increasing sectoral risks, the Board eventually determined to forego further marketing efforts and approve the proposed transactions as soon as practicable after management finalized the material terms. In each case, Board approval occurred shortly before closing, and we did not enter into the sale agreements until closing. In the meantime, our ongoing review under SFAS 144 did not result in an impairment in our Automotive Segment except for the product lines discussed above. For these reasons, we determined that the losses did not occur until closing.
Timeline #2 – Glassware and Candles Segment (relevant to responses 9 and 10 below):
November 2005 – We engaged an investment banking firm to assist in exploring alternatives with respect to our consumer and floral glassware operations. This effort was deemed prudent given higher input costs, growing competition and the planning horizon necessary to accommodate large capital expenditures forecast several years in the future.
Spring and Summer of 2006 – We explored the possible sale of our glassware operations.
We determined that market interest did not meet our expectations.
March 2007 – We announced the closure of our industrial glass operations, largely due to a declining customer base.
Spring 2007 – An inquiry from a potential strategic buyer sparked a renewed sales effort of the consumer and floral glass operations.
November 2007 – After lengthy negotiations and specific Board approval of all material terms, we completed the sale of the consumer and floral glass business.
August 2008 – We reported in our Form 10-K that we do not expect further progress on our strategic evaluation of our candle operations under current market conditions.