Staff’s comment, Ernst & Young LLP (“EY”) has furnished the Company with the following response:
In evaluating its ability to act as the principal auditor for the Company and issue an audit report on the combined financial statements of the Company for the two years ended December 31, 2016, in accordance with AS 1205.02, EY considered:
the relative materiality and importance of the portion of the consolidated financial statements audited by EY compared to the portions audited by other auditors; and the extent of EY’s knowledge of the Company’s business and its financial
Rest of the answer
statements and EY’s involvement and contact with management of the Company.
EY’s analysis of these two considerations is as follows:
In determining if EY may serve as the principal auditor of the Company, EY assessed the relative materiality and importance of the portion of the consolidated financial statements (i.e., the legacy business of Newmark
Knight Frank) audited by EY compared to the portions of the consolidated financial statements (i.e., the legacy business of Berkeley Point) audited by other auditors, which included an analysis of the percentages of total assets, total equity, total revenue and total pre-tax income in the tables below as of and for the years ended December 31, 2015, and 2016:
Accounting
Metric
EY
Other Auditors
Audit
Coverage
2015
Total Assets
857,052,000
800,875,000
%
Total Equity
449,433,000
354,601,000
Revenue
997,267,000
201,812,000
Pre-tax Income
67,535,000
57,258,000
2016
995,491,000
1,539,199,000
503,981,000
479,802,000
1,055,964,000
293,077,000
45,295,000
125,281,000
There is no definitive metric that should be used when determining principal auditor, and EY allocated greater weight to total equity and total revenue for this analysis. EY’s determination of the metrics (total equity and total revenue) that were most important was based on the following analysis:
Pre-tax income is not a comparable measure because due to its compensation structure, Newmark Knight Frank generally has operated with lower US GAAP pre-tax income than Berkeley Point. Berkeley Point has a different compensation structure that results in higher US GAAP pre-tax income. As a result, EY determined revenue is more reflective than pre-tax net income with respect to the relative size of the operations audited by EY as compared to other auditors.
EY’s belief that revenue is the most important metric focused on by readers of the financial statements of the Company, since this metric has been the focus of BGC Partners’ earnings press releases and within the Company’s MD&A.
Berkeley Point’s total assets are primarily comprised of loans held for sale and therefore fluctuate significantly with the timing of loan sales, as evidenced in the tables above. Loans held for sale by Berkeley
Point are typically sold within 45 days from the date that the loans are funded. As a result, EY determined other measures including total equity are more reflective than the total assets with respect to the relative size of the operations audited by EY as compared to those audited by other auditors.
Since the Company has significant debt financing, EY believes total equity to be a more important key metric that is reflective of the relative size of the operations audited by EY as compared to those audited by other auditors, as total equity is a focus of lenders.
In further assessing the relative size of the operations audited by EY as compared to those audited by other auditors, EY considered the portion of combined expenses generated by, and the number of combined brokers supporting, Newmark Knight Frank. For both of these metrics in 2016, Newmark Knight Frank comprised the large majority, as it accounted for 86% of combined expenses and 96% of combined brokers. EY determined this disparity in expenses and brokers was also relevant in determining the relative size of the operations audited by EY as compared to those audited by other auditors.
EY also considered that all of the executive officers of the Company are from Newmark Knight Frank and that one of the key drivers of performance for investors is Newmark Knight Frank’s revenue growth. The executive officers spend the majority of their time focusing on the Newmark Knight Frank businesses. Berkeley Point was acquired as a complementary product offering viewed by the executive management team as an enhancement to future Newmark Knight Frank growth.
EY assessed the extent of its knowledge of the Company’s business and the financial statements and its involvement and contact with management of Newmark Knight Frank and Berkeley Point. For the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2016, EY was the auditor for Newmark Knight Frank, while KPMG was the auditor for Berkeley Point. In June 2017, EY was appointed as the auditor for Berkeley Point for the year ended December 31, 2017. As a result, with respect to the unaudited interim financial information for the six-month period ended June 30, 2017 included in the Public Filing, EY performed PCAOB AS 4105 reviews on the results of Newmark Knight Frank, Berkeley Point, and the Company as a whole. EY has been appointed, and will act as sole auditor for, the Company for the year ended
December 31, 2017. Additionally, for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2016, EY issued audit reports for BGC Partners as principal auditor which also references the work of other auditors for Berkeley Point. As the Company is presently one of two reporting segments of BGC Partners, the percentage of assets covered by other auditors with respect to BGC Partners is significantly less than 50%. EY also considered that it has been Cantor’s auditor since 2008, and Cantor was and continues to be the controlling shareholder of BGC Partners (and thus indirectly controls both Berkeley Point and Newmark Knight Frank). EY has developed extensive knowledge of Cantor’s businesses and overall financial statements through the performance of its previous audits of Cantor. Further, Berkeley Point has been included in Cantor’s consolidated financial statements since the year ended December 31, 2014, during which period EY has issued audit reports while referencing
KPMG as other auditors with respect to
Berkeley Point. Additionally, EY has extensive involvement with the management of Cantor, meeting throughout the course of the audit and with executive management on a quarterly basis. Those meetings have historically included discussions of the Berkeley Point business, results, risks and accounting.
Based on the foregoing, EY concluded that it possesses the appropriate knowledge of the Company’s business and financial statements to serve as principal auditor of the Company.