Pilgrim’s Pride Corporation · Preliminary Proxy Statement · Filed October 25, 2024 · File No. 001-09273
We note your disclosure that, "[T]he amendment will specifically provide that, at any time when JBS is an 80 Percent Holder, there shall be 10 directors on the Board consisting of eight JBS Directors and two Equity Directors." However, this appears inconsistent with the table in Annex A, which indicates that when the JBS Stockholder holds between 80-90%, there shall be seven JBS Directors, one Equity Director, andRest of the question
one Founder Director. Please revise Annex A to reconcile this apparent inconsistency, as well as the inconsistency between the table and the proposed proviso in the paragraph thereafter. Your revisions should clearly indicate, if true, that in this ownership scenario, the number of directors will be increased from nine to ten, and the board will be comprised of eight JBS Directors, two Equity Directors, and no Founder Director. We note your disclosure that, "[T]he amendment provides that at least two of the JBS Directors will be financially literate and be independent under Rule 5605(a)(2) of the listing rules of the Nasdaq Stock Market LLC and under Rule 10A-3 of the Exchange 2. Act." However, we are unable to locate this requirement within the proposed amendments, though we note the last sentence of the proposed amendment in Annex A, which is qualified by an ownership threshold. Please revise your disclosure and/or proposed amendments to Article 5.2 accordingly, or advise. 3. We note the rationale for the amendment is to enable your consolidation with JBS USA Food Company Holdings ("JBS USA") for U.S. federal income tax purposes. Your disclosure indicates that the second requirement for consolidation, that JBS USA own at least 80% of the total stock voting power, "is generally determined by the ability to elect directors" and is not currently satisfied because the JBS Stockholder only has seven of nine directors, or 77.8%. Please provide your legal analysis, including references to applicable tax code, regulations, and/or caselaw, to support your view that the JBS Stockholder must have the right to elect 80% of the board and the certificate must be amended, as proposed. Explain why, in light of the ownership it currently has, JBS does not already have the "ability to elect directors" in excess of the amount required. Discuss whether alternative actions could achieve the same result, whether those actions were considered, and why those actions were rejected. 4. Considering the length of time JBS has owned a substantial number of your shares, please expand the disclosure about your rationale for this amendment to explain why you are proposing this amendment now as opposed to any other time. 5. Please revise to disclose the number and percentage of shares held by non-JBS shareholders that is required to establish a quorum and approve the proposal, clearly stating if none are required. If approval of the proposal is assured, state so clearly and directly. 6. Please revise your disclosure to describe material provisions of the stockholders agreement with JBS USA Holding Lux, S.à.r.l. and tax sharing agreement with JBS USA, and file these agreements as exhibits to your proxy statement. We note your disclosure that the consolidation "will benefit all of the Company’s shareholders." Please address the following items in this regard: • The tax sharing agreement will require you to make payments to JBS USA in an amount equal to your tax liability determined as if you had filed a separate tax return. Revise your disclosure to clarify whether the payments from JBS USA for the utilization of your tax assets will effectively transfer any tax-saving benefits of consolidation to you, in whole or in part, or whether JBS USA will realize all such benefits. • You disclose that JBS USA will make payments to you for the incremental tax cost savings with respect to any dividends (up to $725,000,000) you pay prior to December 30, 2026, and estimate these potential payments as $50,000,000; yet it appears you have not paid dividends in recent years, and your Form 10-K indicates you have no current intention to pay dividends and are subject to certain restrictions on dividends. Revise your disclosure to provide balance, including that no payment from JBS USA will be forthcoming unless your dividend policy changes, and assess the likelihood thereof in light of related restrictions. You disclose that the consolidation is expected to result in "administrative and cost efficiencies, including from filing a single consolidated tax return for U.S. • 7. federal income tax purposes." Revise to clarify whether and how this benefits you, as opposed to JBS USA. • Revise your disclosure to discuss any negative factors that will or may result from the proposed amendment and ancillary agreements, and assess the material related risks to your minority shareholders. 8. We note that Article 5.2 continues to refer to one Founder Director at each ownership level, yet according to your Form 8-K filed on May 2, 2024, your current board consists of six JBS Directors and three Equity Directors. Please revise your disclosure and/or proposed amendments to Article 5.2 as appropriate to update and clarify the ongoing role, if any, of Founder Directors. 9. Please define all capitalized terms used in the proxy statement or, alternatively, file as an exhibit the certificate of incorporation or other document where such terms are defined.
to the Staff’s comment, the Company has revised, in Annex A to the Revised Proxy Statement, the Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation (“Certificate”) reflecting the proposed amendment to the Certificate, as well as the accompanying disclosure in Proposal 1 under “Description of the Amendment” describing the proposed amendment to the Certificate. The revisions in Annex A reflect the removal of theRead in the reply
“Founder Director” concept throughout the entire Certificate.
Please expand your revisions in response to prior comment 4 to clarify the reasons for proposing this amendment. For example, explain what about "the current financial condition of the Company, economic conditions, and other strategic business and financial priorities of the Company" led to proposing this amendment now?
to the Staff’s comment, as shown in the Appendix, the Company proposes to revise the disclosure in Proposal 1 under “Board Recommendation” to include more detail as to the rationale for seeking this amendment now.Read in the reply
We note your response to the first element of prior comment 7. However, it seems any tax savings that may result from consolidation benefit your parent by default, as the tax sharing agreement does not appear to have a mechanism to share such benefits with you.Rest of the question
Accordingly, please further revise your disclosure to clearly state that your tax liability is not expected to be reduced following consolidation, and any tax savings that may result from consolidation will benefit JBS USA rather than you or your subsidiaries.
to the Staff’s comment, as shown in the Appendix, the Company proposes to revise the disclosure in Proposal 1 under “Rationale for the Amendment and Summary of the Tax Sharing Agreement” to clearly state that the Company Group Stand-Alone Tax Liability is not expected to be reduced following consolidation, and to clarify the circumstances in which the Company would be expected to benefit from the tax savings arising from the utilization of the Company Group’s Tax Assets.Read in the reply
We reissue the second element of prior comment 7 in part. Please further revise your disclosure to clearly state, as in your Form 10-K, that you have no present intention to pay dividends and to discuss the contractual limitations on the payment of dividends.Rest of the question
Further disclose that no payment from JBS USA will be forthcoming unless your dividend policy changes, and assess the likelihood thereof in light of related restrictions.
to the Staff’s comment, to clarify the Company’s dividend policy, discuss the applicable contractual limitations on the payment of dividends and the likelihood of the payment in light thereof, and disclose that no payment from JBS USA will be forthcoming unless theRead in the reply
Company’s dividend policy changes.
Disclosure revised in response to the third element of prior comment 7 states that the filing of a consolidated return is expected to result in administrative and cost efficiencies, to benefit you, and reduce your tax compliance costs. Please further revise to specifically identify the benefits that you expect to realize.Rest of the question
Additionally revise your disclosure to discuss how your administrative and tax compliance costs are expected to be reduced notwithstanding that you will be required to prepare pro forma returns to determine your individual tax liability (for purposes of making payments to JBS USA in such amount) and also assist JBS USA in preparing consolidated returns. If the consolidated benefits and reduced costs will accrue to JBS USA rather than to you, then clearly so state.
to the Staff’s comment, the Company has further considered the discussion in Amendment No. 1 under “Rationale for the Amendment and Summary of the TaxRead in the reply
Sharing Agreement” regarding the administrative and cost efficiencies to the Company from filing a consolidated return for the
JBS USA Group and the Company Group, and, as shown in the Appendix, the Company has determined to remove that discussion.Rest of the answer
While the filing of such a consolidated return would be expected to create certain efficiencies for the Company, the Company does not believe they are sufficiently material to merit disclosure in the Definitive Proxy Statement.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2024-12-09