The Company conducted an analysis under Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99, Materiality (“SAB 99”) and Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 108, Considering the Effects of Prior Year Misstatements When Quantifying Misstatements in Current Year Financial Statements (“SAB 108”), relating to the identified misstatements resulting from the previous accounting policy not to consolidate the Papa John’s Marketing Fund (“PJMF” or the “Fund”) and its wholly owned subsidiary, Papa Card Inc. (“PCI”).
Rest of the answer
This analysis resulted in the conclusion that the previous accounting policy to not consolidate PJMF, which had been previously disclosed in the Significant Accounting Policies footnote, was not material for the periods ended December 30, 2018, December 31, 2017, or December 25, 2016. The analysis was reviewed by our external SEC counsel and reviewed by the Audit Committee of our Board of Directors on May 2, 2019, each of whom agreed with management’s conclusions. Our analysis is set forth below.
Materiality Analysis
In order to determine materiality of the error, we utilized guidance in SAB 99 and SAB 108. Our SAB 108 analysis includes a materiality assessment based on both the “rollover” and “iron curtain” approach. The “rollover” approach requires an assessment of the error based on the current year income statement. The “iron curtain” approach requires the Company to assess the impact of the error based on correcting the balance sheet at the end of the current period, regardless of the year when the error originated (sometimes referred to as the “balance sheet” approach).
Under SAB 99, “one rule of thumb in particular suggests that misstatements or omission of an item that falls under a 5% threshold is not material in the absence of particularly egregious circumstances.” The SEC stated in SAB 99 that it has no objection to use such a “rule of thumb,” but noted that quantifying in percentage terms the magnitude of the misstatement is only the beginning of an analysis of materiality. Per SAB 99, “A matter is ‘material’ if there is a substantial likelihood that a reasonable person would consider it important.” As detailed in the Financial Accounting Standards Board’s (“FASB”) Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 2, Qualitative Characteristics of Accounting Information, “the omission or misstatement of an item in a financial report is material if, in the light of surrounding circumstances, the magnitude of the item is such that it is probable that the judgment of a reasonable person relying on the report would have been changed or influenced by the inclusion of a correction of the item.” In other words, both quantitative and qualitative factors must be considered.
Set forth herein are the quantitative and qualitative considerations based on SAB 99 and SAB 108 related to the error.
Quantitative analysis (2016, 2017 and 2018)
2017 and 2016 (Periods Prior to Adoption of ASC 606)
Prior to the required adoption of ASC 606, Revenue From Contracts With Customers (“ASC 606”), on January 1, 2018, the accounting under ASC 605, Revenue Recognition, permitted the Company to present revenues and expenses for advertising funds it controlled on a net basis. This conclusion is consistent with ASC 952-605 as the Company has engaged in these transactions which are in substance acting as an agent for franchisees by entering into purchases at no profit and such monies are explicitly designated and segregated. Under this historical accounting treatment, the annual operations for PJMF would have qualified for reporting on a net basis, except for PCI which would have to report transactions on a gross basis. If the Company had previously consolidated PJMF on a net basis and PCI on a gross basis, the impact for 2017 and 2016, including the impact of other previously identified errors which were immaterial at the time of issuance of each year’s respective financial statements, would have been as follows (in thousands):
2017 Full Year
2016 Full Year
$ Change
% Change
Balance Sheet:
Total Assets (1)
$
22,872
4.1
%
36,406
7.1
Total Liabilities (2)
20,860
3.2
34,622
7.0
Total Equity
2,012
-2.0
1,785
9.8
Statement of Operations:
Total Revenues
2,255
0.1
3,945
0.2
Total Expenses
2,116
1,836
Income before income taxes
139
2,109
1.3
Income tax expense
173
0.5
286
0.6
Net Income before attribution to noncontrolling interests
(34)
0.0
1,823
1.7
Income attributable to noncontrolling interests
-
Net income attributable to the Company ("Net Income")
1.8
Diluted EPS
(0.00)
0.05
Iron Curtain (Balance Sheet) Method:
Change in Net Income
491
525
Change in Diluted EPS
0.01
(1)
– Consists principally of cash and accounts receivable.
(2)
– Consists principally of accounts payable, accrued expenses, deferred revenue and debt.
The Company concluded that all changes in 2016 and 2017 are immaterial based on the following:
·
The dollar and percentage changes are de minimis and well below the 5% “rule of thumb” we use for making an initial “first step” evaluation of the magnitude of potential errors, except for 2016 total assets, liabilities and equity amounts. In general, the Company believes that income statement items, particularly Income before income taxes, Net Income and Diluted Earnings per Share (“Diluted EPS”), are viewed by our investors as more important measures of materiality for the Company than balance sheet items, which we do not believe are key metrics for investors in our industry. In particular, we do not believe total stockholders’ equity changes, including the 9.8% impact in 2016, would represent a material impact for investors, given our total stockholders’ equity is a deficit attributable to the significant level of share repurchases recorded in treasury stock. Additionally, the total stockholders’ equity changes would have been approximately 0.1% of the Company’s 2016 and 2017 market capitalization. As noted in our periodic reports, PJMF is designed to operate at or near “break even” results on an annual basis as it is required by its bylaws to spend all revenues for advertising and marketing activities. Therefore, the net impact of the errors in 2017 and 2016, which were primarily associated with the activities of PCI, on both GAAP and non-GAAP adjusted financial results, are not material, as further discussed below:
Ø
The decrease in consolidated Net Income in 2017 of $34,000 was immaterial to reported consolidated Net Income of $102.3 million, with no impact on Diluted Earnings Per Share (“Diluted EPS”) reported of $2.83 based on the rollover approach and was also immaterial based on the iron curtain approach impact of 0.5% of both Net Income and of Diluted EPS. In comparison to non-GAAP adjusted net income (“adjusted net income”) reported of $90.8 million and reported non-GAAP adjusted Diluted EPS of $2.51 (“adjusted Diluted EPS”), the impact under the rollover method was also immaterial to adjusted Net Income with no impact on adjusted Diluted EPS. Under the iron curtain method, the impact was approximately 0.5% of both adjusted net income and adjusted Diluted EPS.
The increase in consolidated Net Income in 2016 of $1.8 million was 1.8% of reported net income of $102.8 million and 1.8% of Diluted EPS reported of $2.74 based on the rollover approach and was not deemed material; the 2016 impact was also immaterial based on the iron curtain approach impact of 0.5% of both Net Income and Diluted EPS. In comparison to adjusted net income reported of $95.8 million and reported adjusted Diluted EPS of $2.55, the impact was also immaterial. Under the rollover method, the $1.8 million impact would represent 1.9% of both adjusted net income and adjusted Diluted EPS. Under the iron curtain method, the $525,000 impact was approximately 0.5% of both adjusted net income and adjusted Diluted EPS.
The impact on related cash flows was also immaterial, as the change in related Net cash provided by operating activities would have been less than 2.5% and Net cash used in financing activities would have been less than 2.0% for both 2017 and 2016.
The non-GAAP results detailed above, which exclude Special items, should not be construed as a substitute for or a better indicator of the Company’s performance than the Company’s GAAP results. However, management believes presenting certain financial information without the Special items is important for purposes of comparison to prior year results. In addition, management uses these metrics to evaluate the Company’s underlying operating performance and to analyze trends.
In 2016, the only amounts above the 5% initial “rule of thumb” threshold were total assets, total liabilities and total equity. We concluded that the balance sheet misstatements are immaterial as further discussed below:
While the balance sheet misstatements exceed 5%, they all fall below the 10% standard determined by the Company to be an important metric in assessing the significance of any error as material.
As detailed in SAB 99, “the FASB noted in certain limited circumstances, the Commission and other authoritative bodies had issued quantitative materiality guidance citing as examples guidelines ranging from one to ten percent with respect to a variety of disclosures. And it took account of contradictory studies, one showing lack of uniformity among auditors on materiality judgments, and another suggesting widespread use of a ‘rule of thumb’ of five to ten percent of Net Income.” The FASB rejected a purely quantitative approach to determining materiality decisions and noted, “by itself, without regard to the nature of the item and the circumstances in which the judgement has to be made, a purely quantitative approach will not generally be a sufficient basis for a materiality judgment.” This guidance demonstrates the amount of judgment involved in the materiality assessment, as various qualitative variables are also very important. As detailed below, the Company believes these qualitative variables support the position that the impact of not consolidating PJMF was not material. Most significantly, the Fund is designed to break even on an annual basis and not provide any meaningful Net Income or cash flow contribution to the Company’s consolidated financial statements. Therefore, the Company believes that not consolidating did not have a significant impact on investors’ view of the Company or the related stock price of the Company’s common stock.
Like most companies in the restaurant industry, we believe that total assets and liabilities are not key metrics used by our investors to assess the Company’s business. PJMF’s assets consist principally of cash and accounts receivable to be used to fund future advertising, as required by the bylaws. Additionally, as previously noted, we do not believe the total stockholders’ equity changes, including the impact of 9.8% for 2016, would represent a material measure for investors, given our total stockholders’ equity is a deficit due to the material level of share repurchases recorded in treasury stock as well as the immaterial impact relative to the Company’s market capitalization.
2018 Financial Statement Assessment (After Adoption of ASC 606)
Effective January 1, 2018, the Company adopted ASC 606 and, therefore, grossed up all the related revenues and expenses for the marketing funds that the Company controlled and consolidated, as required. If the Company had previously consolidated PJMF on a gross basis with PCI, the full year 2018 financial impact, including previously identified errors which were immaterial at the time of issuance of the 2018 financial statements, would have been as follows (in thousands):
2018 Full Year
26,724
4.7
28,497
3.3
(1,772)
89,500
5.7
87,837
5.6
1,663
28.2
210
7.9
1,453
44.8
88.3
0.04
90.0
-107.7
(0.05)
-109.7
The Company concluded that all corrections in 2018 are immaterial as follows:
Rollover Approach: The impact of the correction on Net Income is approximately $1.5 million, or $0.04 on Diluted EPS.
Iron Curtain Approach: The impact of the correction on Net Income is approximately ($1.8) million or a ($0.05) decrease in Diluted EPS.
Even though the related percentage changes for the rollover and iron curtain approach are higher than 10%, they are individually not material in absolute dollar amount. SAB 99 states that “[i]n the context of a misstatement of a financial statement item . . . the ‘total mix’ [of information made available] includes the size in numerical or percentage terms of the misstatement . . . ” (emphasis added), indicating that absolute numerical amounts should also be considered when percentages may be misleading. Here, these figures are only significant as a percentage of Net Income given the low earnings of the Company in 2018 as a result of the extraordinary events the Company experienced in 2018 and the resulting special charges. When the special charges of $41 million, after tax, are excluded (as reported in the Company’s non-GAAP presentation in the Form 10-K for the year ended December 30, 2018) the Company reported adjusted net income of $43.2 million and adjusted Diluted EPS of $1.34. Thus, the impact of this error would be greatly reduced, as a percentage, if viewed on a non-GAAP basis as follows:
Rollover Impact: The Net Income impact from the consolidation of PJMF of approximately $1.5 million would represent 3.4% of adjusted Net Income, or 3.0% of adjusted Diluted EPS, which is immaterial to operating results and cash flows.
Iron Curtain Impact: The Net Income impact from the consolidation of PJMF of approximately ($1.8) million would represent (4.1%) of adjusted Net Income or (3.7%) of adjusted Diluted EPS, which is immaterial to operating results and cash flows.
The Company believes its investors and financial analysts view these non-GAAP financial measures as important indicators of the Company’s core operating performance in addition to GAAP Net Income and GAAP Diluted EPS. Therefore, the Company believes that its investors and financial analysts would view these changes as immaterial.
The impact on total assets, liabilities and equity is below 5%.
The impact of the consolidation of PJMF on revenues and expenses is just slightly over 5%, at 5.7% and 5.6%, respectively. Additionally, given that expenditures approximate revenues, no significant impact in Net Income trends will occur, regardless of the revenue levels.
As discussed above, the Company concluded the annual impact of the consolidation of PJMF for 2016, 2017 and 2018 is not material. A quarterly review for 2018 was also prepared as follows, which confirmed our conclusion on a quarterly basis.
Q1 2018
Q2 2018
Q3 2018
Q4 2018
35,349
6.1
20,513
3.7
22,818
27,534
4.8
37,832
4.6
23,237
2.9
26,892
28,336
(2,483)
1.0
(2,723)
1.1
(4,074)
1.5
(801)
0.3
22,251
5.2
21,511
5.3
20,772
24,966
6.7
21,583
21,754
20,058
24,443
6.3
668
3.0
(242)
-1.2
714
-3.6
523
-3.2
Income tax expense/ (benefit)
267
(139)
6.9
665
3.8
(320)
-2.5
447
-3.5
661
-4.7
Net income attributable to the Company("Net Income")
4.0
-2.7
-3.4
-4.8
0.02
(0.01)
-2.8
3.5
Based on our review of the 2018 quarterly impact of the consolidation of PJMF, there are no significant changes in trends in comparison to the full year 2018 trends.
The quarterly impact of the consolidation of PJMF on revenues and expenses is just slightly over 5% each quarter, consistent with the annual trends. Given that expenditures approximate revenues, no significant impact in Net Income trends will occur, regardless of the revenue levels.
While first quarter’s impact on total assets was 6.1%, it falls below the 10% measure used by the Company as an important metric in assessing the significance of any error as material.
In evaluating whether this error was material overall to the balance sheet in 2019 when the error was detected, as required by the application of the “Iron Curtain” approach, we performed the following assessment:
The cumulative error as of the beginning of 2019 would be ($1.8) million, equaling the impact to retained earnings. To correct this error in our 2019 consolidated financial statements, the Company would have to record this 2018 error as additional expense in the first quarter of 2019. This amount would not be considered material to the 2019 forecasted results.
If corrected prospectively in 2019, and not corrected in 2018, the revenue recognition “gross up” that would be presented in the first quarter of 2019 of approximately $23.5 million would not be comparable to the related first quarter of 2018 revenues ($22.3 million) and expenses ($21.6 million). On a full year basis, the 2018 total related revenues and expenses were $89.5 million and $87.8 million, respectively. As previously concluded, these numbers are not material to 2018 consolidated revenue and expenses. However, for comparability purposes for 2019 Other revenues and Other expenses, we determined that the 2018 periods should be corrected, even though there would be no significant impact on 2018 consolidated Net Income or
Diluted EPS. As discussed in SAB 108, “Correcting prior year financial statements for immaterial errors would not require previously filed reports to be amended. Such correction may be made the next time the registrant files the prior year financial statements.” Therefore, the Company determined that the 2018 financial statements would be restated, for comparability purposes, in the periodic reports for the respective quarters of 2019, with the Form 10-Q for the first quarter of 2019 including a restated 2018 Balance Sheet and Statement of Stockholders’ Equity. The full year 2018 Statement of Operations, Statement of Comprehensive Income and Statement of Cash Flows will be presented, as restated, in the Form 10-K for the year ended December 29, 2019. The Company concluded given the insignificant impact of 2017 on the financial statements ($34,000 Net Income change), when revenues and expenses would have been reported on a net basis prior to the adoption of ASC 606, that the restatement of 2017 is not required or meaningful in the Form 10-K for the year ending December 29, 2019 as the impact is clearly immaterial.
Quantitative Conclusion
Based on SAB 99 and SAB 108 guidance, the Company concluded that the consolidation of PJMF is not quantitatively material to the reported financial statements in any of the three years in the period ended December 30, 2018.