The Company reconsidered the adequacy of its previous conclusion regarding the effectiveness of its
(“ICFR”) and disclosure controls and procedures (“DC&P”) as a result of the accounting errors described in Note 1 of the Form
for quarterly period ended May 4, 2019 in the year ending February 1, 2020 (fiscal 2019).
Rest of the answer
Set forth below is a summary of the considerations undertaken by management to assess the severity of the control deficiencies and management’s conclusions regarding the effectiveness of the
Company’s ICFR and DC&P.
As disclosed in Note 1 of the Form 10-Q for quarterly period ended May 4, 2019, the Company revised its accompanying unaudited interim financial statements due to the identification of the following errors:
Equity reclassification related to the Company’s retirement of treasury stock which impacted the quarterly and year-end reporting periods of the fiscal year ended February 3, 2018 (fiscal 2017) and the first and second quarterly reporting periods of the fiscal year ended February 2, 2019 (fiscal 2018), as first reported in the third quarter of fiscal 2018 Form 10-Q;
Misstatements related to an exited lease which impacted the fourth quarter of fiscal 2017 and the first quarter of fiscal 2018 ended May 5, 2018, as first reported in the first quarter of fiscal 2019 Form 10-Q; and
Cash flow reclassification related to the Company’s unpaid capital expenditures which impacted the quarterly and year-end reporting periods of fiscal 2018, as first reported in the first quarter of fiscal 2019 Form 10-Q.
In connection with the identification of these errors, management performed an assessment of the materiality of these misstatements in accordance with ASC 250-10-S99. Based on the results of this assessment, these errors were not considered to be material to any of the previously issued financial statements either individually or in the aggregate.
The Company also performed an analysis to determine the impact of the errors on management’s assessment of the effectiveness of its ICFR and DC&P as of February 2, 2019 (fiscal 2018) and as of May 4, 2019 (first quarter of fiscal 2019). This analysis included consideration of the nature and cause of the deficiency, the impact to the consolidated financial statements and the potential aggregation of the deficiencies to determine whether these deficiencies constitute a material weakness in internal control over financial reporting.
Such assessments considered both qualitative and quantitative factors in accordance with SEC Release
No. 33-8810, Section II, B1 to determine whether there was a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement would not be prevented or detected on a timely basis, including consideration of how the applicable internal controls or compensating controls would have identified each such misstatement if the amounts involved were material.
The Company evaluated the severity of the deficiencies and concluded that the deficiencies did not indicate a material weakness in internal controls and were not indicative of a broader or systemic issue with the Company’s ICFR or DC&P. As a result, the Company reconsidered and reaffirmed its previous conclusions that it maintained effective internal control over financial reporting and disclosure controls and procedures.
The following presents a summary of the above mentioned errors and the Company’s assessment of controls:
Treasury stock
The Company retired treasury stock in the first quarter of fiscal 2017 for the first time since inception. The
Company identified in the third quarter of fiscal 2018 that, due to a lack of precision in the design of the related control activity to review the presentation requirements over the cost of treasury stock upon retirement, the Company did not correctly reclassify the cost associated with the share repurchases of $19.5 million from the treasury share line item to either (1) retained earnings or (2) an allocation between retained earnings and additional paid-in capital. The Company disclosed this revision upon identification of the error in Note 1 of the Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended November 3, 2018. The
Company also disclosed this revision in the fiscal 2018 Form 10-K and the Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended May 4, 2019 and plans to continue to disclose this revision in the Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended August 3, 2019 in order to effect the revision for all comparative periods.
At the time that the deficiency was identified in the third quarter of fiscal 2018, the Company evaluated the magnitude of the potential misstatement that could have resulted from the deficiency based on quantitative and qualitative factors. As a result of this assessment, the Company concluded the magnitude of the potential misstatement was not material based on consideration of the following:
This deficiency would only result in reclassification between two line items within equity;
There would be no impact on key performance metrics; and
There would be no impact on any other compliance requirement, including: state laws, Company corporate by-laws, debt covenants, and the ability to pay dividends.
Based on the analysis above, management concluded that the deficiency represents a significant deficiency in internal control over financial reporting and maintained its conclusion that internal controls and disclosure controls and procedures were effective.
The Company completed a second treasury stock retirement in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2018 and increased the precision of its control activity to include accounting for the retirement of treasury stock. Upon retirement, management correctly recorded the cost of the treasury stock and also concluded the design and operation of the revised control activity was effective. Therefore, management concluded that this control deficiency was remediated by the end of its fiscal year 2018.
Distribution center closure
The Company ceased operations at one of its distribution center facilities in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2017.
The Company identified in the first quarter of fiscal 2019 that, due to a deficiency in the related control over the identification of the unit of account in accounting for exited location, in connection with the computation of the transaction the
Company understated its exit and disposal costs by $2.1 million. While the previous conclusions and interpretations of exit and disposal obligations were based on accounting literature research, after additional research and consideration of the relevant facts, management identified that the conclusions were not in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America (“US GAAP”) and therefore the understatement was an error.
The Company evaluated the magnitude of the potential misstatement that could have resulted from the deficiency based on quantitative and qualitative factors. As a result of this assessment, the Company concluded the magnitude of the potential misstatement was not material based on consideration of the following:
The magnitude of the potential misstatement is below management’s quantitative materiality thresholds for the impacted periods; and
There would be no material impact on any key performance metrics.
While the error was not material and therefore is considered to not warrant revision individually, the Company reported the revision in Note 1 of the Form 10-Q for quarterly period ended May 4, 2019 in connection with the modified retrospective application of ASC 842 Leases as further discussed in Note 2 of the Form 10-Q.
Based on the analysis above, management concluded that the deficiency represents a deficiency in internal controls and maintains its conclusion that internal controls and disclosure controls and procedures were effective.
Cash flow: Unpaid capital expenditures
In connection with the preparation of the consolidated statement of cash flows for the first quarter of fiscal
2018, the Company incorrectly computed the change in accrued capital expenditures for the period. The Company identified in the first quarter of fiscal 2019 that this error was carried forward to each of the subsequent reporting periods in fiscal
2018 resulting in a misclassification between operating and investing cash flows. The miscalculation was due to a deficiency in the design of controls over the review of hard-coded inputs within the cash flow calculations which resulted in an incorrect classification between operating and investing cash flows of $9.2 million.
The Company evaluated the magnitude of the potential misstatement that could have resulted from the deficiency to the interim and annual financial statements and evaluated the materiality based on quantitative and qualitative factors. As a result of this assessment, the Company concluded the magnitude of the potential misstatement was not material based on consideration of the following:
This deficiency would only result in reclassification between two line items within the cash flow statement and would not change total cash flows;
The magnitude of the potential misstatement does not flip any cash flow activities between “provided by” or “used in” and does not affect any trends;
The deficiency would not impact earnings or debt covenants; and
There would be no impact on key performance metrics or the Company’s guidance.
internal controls and maintains its conclusion that internal controls and disclosure controls and procedures were effective.
As noted above, the Company concluded that none of the control deficiencies discussed above constitute a material weakness. In addition to the individual assessment of deficiencies in controls, the Company assessed the aggregation of all known deficiencies that were unremediated as of February 2, 2019 and May 4, 2019. In light of the multiple errors identified within a relatively short period of time, the Company reconsidered the adequacy of its previous conclusion regarding the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting and disclosure controls and procedures, as described below.
The Company aggregated all known unremediated deficiencies by significant accounts or disclosures, relevant assertion, business unit or component, business process, and component of internal control. The deficiencies described above occurred in different business processes and do not affect the same accounts or disclosures. Additionally, of the deficiencies that resulted in an error requiring revision, only the cash flow control deficiency noted above was not remediated as of February 2, 2019 and May 4, 2019, and there were no other unremediated control deficiencies impacting the cash flow statement or presentation and disclosure assertion to aggregate with this deficiency at fiscal year end 2018 or the end of the first quarter of fiscal 2019. These deficiencies do not have similar root causes with each other, nor with any of the other control deficiencies that were not remediated at the time. Accordingly, the Company maintains its conclusion that the combination of all deficiencies does not indicate ineffective internal control over financial reporting or disclosure controls and procedures.
The Company assessed whether situations existed that might indicate a material weakness in internal control over financial reporting. Such assessment included, without limitation, that there was no identification of fraud on the part of senior management, there was no restatement of previously issued financial statements for a material misstatement nor could the errors have risen to a level such that there was a material misstatement, and there was not ineffective oversight by the Company’s Audit Committee. The Company further considered whether any of these deficiencies might prevent prudent officials in the conduct of their owns affairs from concluding that they have reasonable assurance that transactions are recorded as necessary to permit the preparation of financial statements in conformity with US GAAP.
Based on the considerations outlined above, the Company concluded that the deficiencies, or combination of deficiencies, did not indicate a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement would not be prevented or detected on a timely basis in the Company’s consolidated financial statements.
In evaluating our disclosure controls and procedures following the identification of the matters noted above, management, including our Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, concluded that despite these deficiencies, our system of internal control was designed and operating effectively, for all relevant periods, to provide reasonable assurance that information required to be disclosed by us were recorded, processed, summarized and reported within the time periods specified in the SEC’s rules and forms.
Management also assessed the related control enhancements made to internal control over financial reporting since the identification of the deficiencies discussed above and concluded that none of these enhancements resulted in a material change to the Company’s internal control over financial reporting during fiscal 2018 or the first quarter of fiscal 2019.
The conclusions reached above with respect to the errors and control deficiencies were discussed with the Company’s Audit Committee of the
Board of Directors prior to the filing of the Company’s Form 10-K for the year ended February 2, 2019 and prior to the filing of the Company’s Form 10-Q for the period ended May 4, 2019. In weighing all of the factors explained above, and the reconsideration of the adequacy of the Company’s previous conclusions, management continues to believe that the Company’s ICFR and DC&P were effective as of February 2, 2019 and as of May 4, 2019.
If you require additional information or have any questions about this letter, please call me at (917) 882-5454.