Combination”). Our analyses are discussed below, including the specific factors raised by the Staff.
When determining the appropriate accounting acquirer, the Company considered ASC 805-10-25-5 which establishes that the existence of a controlling financial interest, as defined in ASC 810-10 related to consolidation, is indicative of an accounting acquirer.
ASC 810-10-15-8 defines the usual condition for a controlling financial interest as “ownership by one reporting entity, directly or indirectly, of more than 50 percent of the outstanding voting shares of another entity.”
Rest of the answer
It is currently expected that the current shareholders of Thunder Bridge will retain approximately 56.7% of the voting power in the combined post-merger Company (the “Combined
Company”) (based on the assumptions described in the section entitled “Frequently Used Terms—Share Calculations and Ownership Percentages” on page 4 of Amendment No. 1), resulting in the current shareholders of Thunder Bridge retaining controlling financial interest in the Combined Company.
Furthermore, ASC 805-10-25-5 provides that if the acquiring entity is not clearly indicated by the existence of a controlling financial interest in accordance with the guidance therein, the factors in ASC 805-10-55-11 through 55-15 must be considered in order to determine the accounting acquirer. The guidance does not provide a hierarchy for assessing the various factors that influence the identification of the accounting acquirer in a business combination, and we believe that no single criterion is more significant than any other.
The Company submits that an analysis of the totality of factors in ASC 805-10-55-11, 55-12 and 55-13 supports our ASC 805-10-25-5 analysis, under which we concluded that the current expectation of the current shareholders of Thunder Bridge retaining the controlling financial interest in the Combined Company is indicative of Thunder Bridge as an accounting acquirer. We note that the guidance under ASC 805-10-55-14 and 55-15 are not relevant to the Business Combination and present below our analysis of the totality of factors in ASC 805-10-55-11,
55-12 and 55-13:
● Transfer of Cash. ASC 805-1055-11 states that in a business combination effected primarily by transferring cash or other assets or by incurring liabilities, the accounting acquirer is usually the entity that transfers the cash or other assets or incurs the liabilities. In connection with the Business Combination, the Company will transfer a minimum of $290 million of cash consideration to the current equity holders of Repay. We believe the payment of such cash consideration by the Company is a strong indicator that the Company is the accounting acquirer.
● Exchange of Equity Interest. ASC
805-10-55-12 provides that in a business combination involving the exchange of equity interests, all pertinent facts and circumstances should be considered. In particular, consideration should be given to which company’s shareholders obtain, in the aggregate, a controlling interest in the combined company. In the Business Combination, the Combined Company will issue Class V common stock and its subsidiary (of which the Combined Company will be the sole managing member) will issue Post-Merger Repay Units to the current equity holders of Repay, all of which in the aggregate constitute the equity component of the merger consideration. In addition, the pre-Business Combination shareholders of the Company are expected to retain a controlling interest in the Combined Company.
Both of these facts are indicative of the Company being the accounting acquirer.
o Relative Voting Rights of the Combined Entity. Under ASC 805-10-55-12(a), the accounting acquirer is usually the entity whose owners as a group retain or receive the largest portion of the voting rights in the combined entity. As discussed above, the pre-Business Combination shareholders of the Company are expected to retain 56.7% of the voting interests of the Combined Company at closing (based on the assumptions described in the section entitled “Frequently Used
Terms—Share Calculations and Ownership Percentages” on page 4 of Amendment No. 1). We believe the fact that the Company’s current shareholder group will retain the largest portion of the voting rights indicates that the Company is the accounting acquirer.
o Existence of a Large Minority Voting Interest. Under ASC 805-10-55-12(b), if no other group has a significant interest in the combined entity, then the existence of a large minority interest may be indicative of the accounting acquirer. The Company believes that this guidance is not applicable to the significant minority ownership by Corsair of approximately
29% of the Combined Company because the pre-Business Combination shareholders of the Company are expected to retain 56.7% of the voting interests of the Combined Company (in each case based on the assumptions described in the section entitled “Frequently
Used Terms—Share Calculations and Ownership Percentages” on page 4 of Amendment No. 1), which is significantly greater than the voting interest that Corsair expects to hold at closing.
o Composition of the Governing Body of the Combined Entity. In accordance with ASC 805-10-55-12(c), we analyzed the composition of the board of directors of the Combined Company (the “Board”). After the Business
Combination, the initial Board will consist of nine members who were mutually agreed upon by Thunder Bridge and Repay and identified in the Merger Agreement. Of those nine individuals:
■ Each of Gary Simanson, Peter J. Kight,
Robert A. Hartheimer and Maryann Goebel are subject to replacement by the sponsor of Thunder Bridge in the event such individual becomes unwilling or unable to serve prior to the completion of the Business Combination;
■ Each of Jeremy Schein and James Kirk are subject to replacement by Corsair in the event such individual becomes unwilling or unable to serve prior to the completion of the Business Combination;
■ Each of John Morris and Shaler Alias are subject to replacement by the founders of Repay in the event such individual becomes unwilling or unable to serve prior to the completion of the Business Combination; and
■ In the event William Jacobs becomes unwilling or unable to serve prior to the completion of the Business Combination, his replacement would need to be mutually approved by Thunder
Bridge and Repay.
As a result of this arrangement,
Thunder Bridge and its sponsor have the ability to control or veto a majority of the Board (5 of 9 directors) in the event such nominees become unwilling or unable to serve prior to the completion of the Business Combination. In addition, following the completion of the initial term for each class of directors, the election of such class of directors will be subject to approval by the Company’s shareholders, and shareholders of Thunder Bridge are expected to hold a majority of the Company’s equity following the completion of the Business Combination. These two factors combined indicate that the Company is the accounting acquirer.
o Composition of the Senior Management of the Combined Entity. With respect to ASC 805-10-55-12(d), the executive officers of Repay prior to the consummation of the Business Combination will become the executive officers of the
Combined Company and serve under the direction of the Board. Because the factors we describe other than ASC 805-10-55-12(d) favor
Thunder Bridge as the accounting acquirer, this factor is not determinative for the identification of the accounting acquirer.
o Terms of the Exchange of Equity Interests. Under ASC 805-10-55-12(e), the accounting acquirer is usually the entity that pays a premium over the pre-Business Combination fair value of the equity interests of the other entity.
The Business Combination consideration to be paid by the Company in the Business Combination represents a premium above fair value of Repay’s net assets. Such premium relates to Repay’s intangible assets including non-competition agreements, trade names, developed technology, merchant relationships, and goodwill which totals approximately $394 million and supports the conclusion that the Company is the accounting acquirer.
● Relative Size. Under ASC 805-10-55-13, the accounting acquirer is usually the entity whose relative size is significantly larger than the other entity. While Repay, as the operating entity, is significantly larger than Thunder Bridge, the current equity holders of Repay will not own a majority of the voting rights or control the Board. Therefore, we believe the relative size of the entities should not be the determinative factor and that all the other factors need to be considered.
After considering all the various factors set forth above, the Company concluded that Thunder Bridge is considered the accounting acquirer based upon the following determinations: (1) the majority voting interest of the Combined Company will be held by current shareholders of
Thunder Bridge, (2) the voting interest and ownership of Thunder Bridge’s current shareholders in the Combined Company will be greater than those of Repay’s current equity holders, and (3) there is no mechanism for Repay’s current equity holders to control the Board of the Combined Company. The Company notes that, as disclosed in Amendment No. 1, under the Merger Agreement,
Thunder Bridge has the ability to raise additional equity financing of up to an amount equal to $30 million plus the amount of the aggregate redemption price of all redemptions. If Thunder Bridge seeks any additional equity financing prior to the completion of the Business Combination, the analyses described herein may need to be revised to reflect any anticipated changes to the capital structure of the Combined Company.