Form S-1
Please provide an identification of the nature of the underwriting arrangement. See Item 501(b)(8) of Regulation S-K.
No reply letter found.
We note that on page 4 and 88, you present the non-GAAP measure, Adjusted EBITDA, but do not present the most directly comparable GAAP measure, Net loss, with equal or greater prominence. For each non-GAAP financial measure you present, please present the most directly comparable GAAP measure with equal or greater prominence as required by Item 10(e)(1)(i)(A) of Regulation S-K and Question 102.10 of the Division ofRest of the question
Corporation Finance’s Compliance & Disclosure Interpretations on Non-GAAP Financial Measures.
No reply letter found.
Please balance the disclosure in your summary by prominently disclosing your level of indebtedness, history of losses and challenges you face.
No reply letter found.
Footnote (2) on page 18 indicates that management uses EBITDA to evaluate your performance, allocate resources and measure leverage, as such, it appears you are using EBITDA as both a performance and liquidity measure.Rest of the question
Please clarify whether the measure is used for liquidity purposes and if so, please revise future filings to reconcile the measure to the most directly comparable GAAP measure, cash flows from operating activities.
No reply letter found.
We note your risk factors indicating that inflation has affected your operations that there is significant inflationary on wages. Please expand to identify the principal factors contributing to the inflationary pressures the company has experienced and clarify the resulting impact to the company.
No reply letter found.
We note that you "intend to use the net proceeds from this offering to repay certain indebtedness." Please revise to set forth the interest rate and maturity of such indebtedness. If the indebtedness to be discharged was incurred within one year, describe the use of the proceeds of such indebtedness other than short-term borrowings used for working capital. See Item 504 of Regulation S-K.
No reply letter found.
We note your disclosure stating the principal purposes for which the net proceeds to you from the securities to be offered are intended to be used. Revise your disclosure to include the approximate amount intended to be used for each such purpose. See Item 504 of Regulation S-K.
No reply letter found.
We note that you include disclosure of Adjusted EBITDA Margin. Please revise to include disclosure of the most comparable GAAP measure, presumably net income/loss margin, whenever you disclose this non-GAAP measure. See Item 10(e)(1)(i)(A) of
No reply letter found.
Your disclosure indicates that revenue increased as a result of both volume and price growth. In future filings, please quantify the impact of the individual factors impacting your results of operations. Additionally, we note the volume increases were partially offset by ongoing supply chain delays that impacted the availability of parts and ultimately engine throughput across all of our end markets.Rest of the question
To the extent there have been material impacts to your results of operations, revise future results of operations discussions to quantify such impacts.
No reply letter found.
We note your risk factor on page 50 where you indicate that your ability to pay dividends will rely on cash flow generated by your subsidiaries and there may be restrictions on your subsidiaries limiting their ability to pay dividends to you.Rest of the question
Given the holding company structure noted, please revise your disclosures to discuss any material restrictions on your ability to transfer funds from your operating subsidiaries and the potential impact on your liquidity. Additionally, given you are a holding company, please tell us what consideration you gave to the need for parent only financial statements under Rules 5-04 and 12-04 of Regulation S-X.
No reply letter found.
Please provide a list of any patents, trademarks, or licenses you own including their period of validity and issuing country. Notes to the Audited Financial Statements Note 2. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies (f) Revenue Recognition, page F-11
No reply letter found.
We note that you recognize revenues under fixed price and time and materials contracts, which recognize revenue over time proportionately to costs incurred relative to total expected costs to satisfy the performance obligation.Rest of the question
We also note that this type of percentage of completion accounting depends on your ability to make reasonably dependable cost estimates, costs may be incurred over a period of several years, and estimation of these costs requires the use of judgment. Since it appears a significant portion of your revenues are recognized using this method, a significant change in one or more of these estimates could affect your results. Please revise the notes to your financial statements to disclose the impact of changes in contract estimates on your results during each period presented, including an analysis of the underlying reasons for the changes in estimates. Please refer to ASC 250-10-50-4. Additionally, please revise your Critical Accounting Estimates section of MD&A to provide the gross amount of favorable and unfavorable adjustments to contract estimates to complete for each period presented. To the extent material, please revise your disclosure to address such circumstances, accompanied by an appropriate level of analysis of the underlying reasons for the significant changes. We believe such disclosure will give investors more insight to the estimation process associated with your contracts, as discussed in “Critical Accounting Estimates,” and the separate potential impacts on your results.
No reply letter found.
We note from your disclosure in Note 4 that you present disaggregated revenue information only by segment. However, it appears from your discussion in the results of operations section of MD&A, that you discuss revenue trends in your end markets of commercial aerospace, military and business aviation.Rest of the question
Please tell us the consideration given to presenting additional disaggregated revenue by categories such as end market or contract type, as set forth in the guidance in ASC 606-10-50-5 and 606-10-55-89 through 55-91.
No reply letter found.
Please revise to provide disclosure of Commission's position on indemnification for Securities Act liabilities in the prospectus instead of in Part II. See Item 510 of Regulation S-K.
No reply letter found.
Please disclose on the cover page that this offering is a firm commitment underwritten offering. Partnership Agreement and Stockholders Agreement, page 133 We note your disclosure regarding the Partnership Agreement and Stockholders Agreement and that such agreements include or will include provisions relating to, among other things, the election of directors, participation rights in equity and debt offerings,Rest of the question
registration rights, information rights, indemnification rights, expense reimbursement and 2. corporate governance provisions. Please revise to disclose the material features of these provisions, and add risk factors that address the risks associated with these provisions.
No reply letter found.
Given your response to comment 4 of our letter dated July 5, 2024, please remove your reference to liquidity in the first paragraph on page 70 or explain to us why this disclosure is appropriate. We note that within your MD&A discussion, you disclose Total Segment Adjusted EBITDA.Rest of the question
We also note your reconciliation of Total Segment Adjusted EBITDA to net income on page 71 and your disclosure that the adjustment for Unallocated Corporate Expenses primarily consists of costs related to executive and staff functions, including information technology, human resources, legal, finance, marketing, corporate supply 2. chain and corporate engineering services finance, which benefit the enterprise as a whole. These costs are primarily related to the general management of these functions on a corporate level and the design and development of programs, policies, and procedures that are then implemented in the individual segments, with each segment bearing its own cost of implementation. This measure must comply with the Non-GAAP guidance when it is presented outside the ASC 280 required disclosures in the notes to the financial statements. In this regard, because the adjustment appears to represent normal recurring operating costs of your business, they would not be an appropriate adjustment from the Total Segment Adjusted EBITDA measure when that measure is disclosed within MD&A. See Question 100.01 of the SEC Staff’s Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations. Please advise or revise to remove this measure from your MD&A section. Notes to the Audited Financial Statements Note 24. Segment Information, page F-50 3. We note your disclosure in Note 24, that effective May 2024, the Company’s CODM reevaluated how the Company measures performance and allocates resources, and modified the Company’s internal reporting, budgeting and forecasting and the responsibilities of his direct reports. As a result, the Company’s previous Airlines and Fleets, Military, Helicopters and Energy and Business Aviation reportable segments are now combined into a new Engine Services reportable segment. The Company’s Component Repair Services segment remains unchanged. Please provide us more explanation of why you believe it was appropriate to change from 4 reportable segments to 2 reportable segments. As part of your response, please indicate how many operating segments you currently have. In this regard, we note from your disclosure on page 111 that you continue to have a President responsible for each of the three previous segments that have been combined into the Engine Services. Please describe the role of each of these Presidents including who they report to. Also, please describe the nature of any financial information that is created by each of these three businesses, the identity of the person(s) who review this financial information and describe the nature of the financial information that is regularly reviewed by the CODM.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on pages 18 and 70.Read in the reply
We note from your response to our prior comment 3 that you have concluded that the CEO, and not the COO, is the CODM. Please compare and contrast the roles of the CEO and COO as they relate to the key operating decisions of the consolidated business and to each of the business units.Rest of the question
As part of your response, please describe the budgeting process, including the roles of both the CEO and COO, and identify approval authority for each position. Also, we note that the COO meets regularly, at a minimum monthly, with the Engine Services Division Presidents and the Component Repair Services Division President to review the performance of the divisions, including financial information at the business unit level comparing revenue, profitability, and financial position against the prior year and forecasted results, as well as operational data. Please tell us more about the nature of the decisions made during these monthly meetings and if the COO has any authority to allocate resources between the Engine Services business units and the 1. Component Repair Services segment.
The Company respectfully notes the Staff’s comment regarding the Company’s determination of its Chief Operating Decision Maker (CODM) and confirms that its CEO, Russell Ford, functions as the CODM as defined by Accounting Standards Codification 280-10-50-5. Mr. Ford is the individual who is responsible for allocating resources to the different segments of the business and assessing their performance. Mr.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Ford is the only executive who holds the authority to make or approve material decisions and allocate material resources within the Company.
Roles of the CEO and
COO:
The CEO serves as the CODM and primarily focuses on strategic, company-wide objectives. These objectives include strategic leadership, operational oversight, including strategic allocation of resources, assessment of performance of Engine Services and Component Repair Services segment results reported to him by the COO, customer management, board relations, stakeholder management, culture, and talent leadership.
The COO, on the other hand, is responsible for the operational management at a site level. The
COO’s role entails regular and detailed performance reviews of the division’s financial and operational results, including direct interaction with the Division Presidents to assess and manage day-to-day operations. As an example, the COO’s responsibilities include monitoring and managing the timely delivery of services and attrition at specific service locations. In performing these responsibilities, the COO will make tactical decisions for the business, including adjustments to capacity, supply of materials and labor, negotiations with vendors and customers, use of capital within the divisions, enhancements to operating systems for health, quality and safety, decisions regarding the workforce, and control of expenses. The COO reports monthly or more regularly to the CEO (see further below).
Budgeting Process:
During the annual budgeting process, the CEO sets annual targets, including financial and operating targets and related capital expenditure spend for the business by determining deliberate goals together with the CFO according to the strategic business plan. The COO then works closely with the sites and Division Presidents and finance teams to prepare detailed budgets for each site on these overall strategic goals which roll up into the Divisional and Segment budgets. These proposed budgets for
Engine Services and Component Repair Services segments are then reviewed and refined in consultation with the CEO. Based on the CEO’s review and input, the detailed budgets may be refined with additional actions. Final budget approval authority rests solely with the CEO, who takes into consideration the recommendations and analysis provided by the COO. The COO has the authority to manage and adjust the budget within the divisions, but adjusting the budget between segments would require CEO approval. The COO is responsible to the CEO for operating within the established budgets. The CEO reviews the Company’s performance against the budget on a monthly, quarterly and annual basis at both the consolidated and segment levels.
Monthly Meetings of the COO and Division Presidents and Decision Making:
The COO’s monthly meetings with the Division Presidents are designed to closely monitor and manage the performance of each division. In these meetings, the COO reviews financial information at the division level, including revenue, profitability, and financial position against prior year and forecasted results, as well as operational data. These meetings are not attended by the CEO.
The nature of the decisions made during these meetings includes operational adjustments, resource allocation within divisions, and implementation of strategies to improve performance. While the COO has the authority to make decisions regarding resource allocation within the Engine Services divisions and the Component Repair Services segment, resource shifts or strategic changes between the Engine Services and Component Repair Services segments are subject to review and approval by the CEO, ensuring alignment with the Company’s broader strategic direction.
Monthly Meetings of the CEO and COO (as described in our previous letter and presented here for your convenience):
The CODM meets with the COO on a regular (typically monthly) and as-needed basis to discuss operational issues as well as periodic results of the Company’s two segments in order for the CEO to assess the Company’s performance and determine the allocation of the Company’s resources. The CODM receives monthly financial information relevant to monitoring the Company’s business, which includes data related to actual and projected operating results, cash flows, and liquidity, in addition to non-financial business information. The CODM reviews financial information about the business at both the consolidated and disaggregated level, namely for Engine Services and Component Repair Services. The financial information reviewed by the CODM includes the Company’s consolidated financial statements for annual and interim periods. Additionally, the CODM receives financial information on a monthly basis that includes:
•
A monthly and year-to-date comparison of our consolidated income statement with forecasted results and the actual prior period results.
comparison of revenue, segment adjusted EBITDA, and segment adjusted EBITDA as a percentage of revenue, disaggregated for Engine Services and Component Repair Services.
comparison of consolidated cash flows.
A monthly summary of the consolidated financial position, including financial leverage levels and ratios.
Revenue results for the month and year-to-date periods for the sites, without any measure of profitability.
Other:
As stated in our previous correspondence, the divisions within the Engine Services segment perform similar Maintenance, Repair and Overhaul,
(MRO) services across multiple end markets. These commonalities include the nature of the work, the resultant form and substance of capital required to fund the growth and maintenance of the business, similarity in commercial pursuits, similarity of market factors driving revenue, earnings and cash flow, the limited number of supported Original Equipment Manufacturers, (OEMs) and the key operational metrics used to monitor, target and drive performance. The end markets have unique customers with distinct profiles. The Division President focus on the individual customer subset, thereby enhancing the relationship and service delivery to the customers and strengthening the Company’s position within different customer industries.
Given the earlier-noted similarities in MRO services, the CEO is able to make key operating decisions and allocate resources at the Engine Services segment level and leverage the COO for the day-to-day management of the divisions.
Meetings of the CEO and Divisional Presidents occur periodically at the CEO’s discretion, approximately quarterly. The purpose of these meetings is to review customer relationships and any new developments in significant customers contracts that could lead to potential revenue changes in future periods. The Divisional Presidents also provide a high-level update on operational matters to apprise the CEO of any existing trends in operational performance. The information gathered from these discussions informs the CEO of the needs of the business and customers to make strategic decisions for growth and performance.
Please find the following table that compares the roles of our CEO and COO as they relate to key operating decisions of our business and to our business divisions.
Key Operating
Processes / Decisions
CEO responsibilities
COO responsibilities
Summary description of role and responsibilities
The CEO is responsible for setting strategic, company-wide objectives and all key financial and resource allocation decisions of the business, such as acquisitions, expansion for new market opportunities, significant capital expenditures and hiring decisions on key personnel and executives.
The COO is responsible for the operational performance of individual sites and effective execution of services. The COO reports monthly or more often to the CEO.
Budgeting process
The CEO has approval authority over final periodic and annual budgets on a consolidated basis and for the Engine Services and Component Repair Services segments, but not at a level below the segments. The CEO sets and actively monitors financial, operational targets and capital expenditure spend at the Company and at the segment level which are deployed by the COO.
The COO is responsible for deploying and proposing the operating budget on an annual basis. In the budgeting process the COO may work with Division Presidents to establish and review these site-level budgets. Performance against the budget is monitored throughout the year and reviewed with the Division Presidents and reported monthly at a segment level to the CEO.
Approval authority and limits
The CEO has authority to make business decisions, with significant decisions requiring approval of Board of Directors.
The COO has approval authority with a limit of $250,000, with amounts over this threshold requiring additional approvals by CEO and the Board of Directors, considering the separate thresholds of the CEO.
Frequency of meeting between CEO and COO and topics covered
The CEO meets regularly with the COO (typically at least monthly if not more regularly) and on an as-needed basis, which has generally been weekly, and at each monthly and quarterly cycle. The purpose of these meetings is to understand the performance of the Company’s Engine Services and Component Repair Services segments. During the meetings the COO provides periodic financial information on revenue / profitability and financial position against the prior year and budget for the Engine Services Segment and Component Repair Segment. Additionally, these meetings include progress updates on key initiatives, such as the integration of newly acquired businesses into the Company’s operations.
Frequency of meeting with Engine Services Division Presidents and topics covered
The CEO meets with Engine Services Division Presidents, periodically at the CEO’s discretion, approximately quarterly, to review customer relationships and potential revenue changes with customers based on current and anticipated service levels.
The information gathered from these discussions informs the CEO of the needs of the business and customers to make strategic decisions for growth and performance.
The COO meets with the Engine Services Division Presidents at least monthly to review performance and operating metrics compared to the annual operating plan, forecast, and prior year, and to oversee the quarterly and long-range performance of the Engine Services Divisions. These meetings cover updates to customer relationships, operational performance of the MRO facilities as well as any challenges in effectively providing services and the potential revenue impacts with customers.
Examples of decisions made during these meetings include adjustments to capacity, supply of materials and labor, negotiations with vendors and customers, use of capital within the Engine Services segment, enhancements to operating systems for health, quality and safety, decisions regarding the workforce, and control of expenses.
Frequency of meeting with Component Repair Service Division President and topics covered
The CEO meets with Component Repair Services Division President periodically at the CEO’s discretion, approximately quarterly, to review
The information gathered from these discussions informs the CEO of the needs of the business and customers to make strategic decisions for growth and
The COO meets with the Component Repair Services Division President at least monthly to review performance and operating metrics compared to the annual operating plan, forecast, and prior year, and to oversee the quarterly and long-range performance of the Component Repair Services Division. These meetings cover updates to customer relationships, any challenges in effectively providing services and the potential revenue impacts with customers.
Examples of decisions made during these meetings include adjustments to capacity, supply of materials and labor, negotiations with vendors and customers, the use of capital within the Component Repair Services segment, enhancements to operating systems for health, quality and safety, decisions regarding the workforce, and control of expenses.
In summary, the CEO, as the CODM, retains primary and ultimate responsibility for key operating and financial decisions at the consolidated level and segment level, including reviewing results of segment operations, allocation of resources, setting budgets and targets, mergers and acquisitions, and expansion of markets, while the COO has been empowered with responsibilities for day-to-day operational management and performance review of the divisions. The Company believes that this organizational structure enhances its ability to execute its strategic plan effectively and respond to operational challenges efficiently.
* * * *
We hope that the foregoing has been responsive to the Staff’s comments and look forward to resolving any outstanding issues as quickly as possible. Please direct any questions or comments regarding the foregoing to me at (202) 637-2258 or my colleague, Patrick H. Shannon, at (202) 637-1028.
Also in this review: company letter, Sep 27, 2024