Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0000077543 /10-K filed Feb 26, 2026, compared with Feb 27, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
NYSE Industrials · General Bldg Contractors - Nonresidential Bldgs

Tutor Perini Corp TPC

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

8 reviews of TPC's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 8 latest letter Apr 12, 2021
Questions asked 44 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 1 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 17 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 44 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 17 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 7 of 8 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 34 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2020

2021-04-12 to 2021-05-05 · 2 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2021-05-05
Income taxesDebt
Note 7. Financial Commitments, page F-27
SEC asked
We note the repayment of a portion of the Company's convertible notes that occurred on August 19, 2020. In order to better understand the Company's accounting for this transaction, please tell us the following: • the amount of consideration attributable to the fair value of the liability component immediately before extinguishment and how you accounted for the difference between the fair value and the carrying value
Rest of the question

of the liability component that may have resulted in a gain or loss on debt extinguishment. Refer to ASC 470-20-4020(b); • whether the deferred taxes presented on your table on page F-30 represent the basis difference associated with the liability component that was initially recognized as an adjustment to APIC consistent with the guidance in ASC 470-20-25-27 and when the Company is expecting such temporary difference to reverse; and • what consideration you gave to reversing a portion of the $18.8 million deferred tax liability due to the previous amortization of the debt discount and whether an additional amount should be reversed due the partial redemption of the convertible notes on August 19, 2020. Refer to the example in ASC 470-20-55-71 through 5582.

TPC answered
In accordance with the requirements of ASC 470-20-40-20(b), upon the repayment of a portion of the Company’s outstanding convertible notes in August 2020, the Company allocated the consideration transferred to the holders between the liability and equity components of the instruments. The amount of the consideration allocated to the fair value of the liability component immediately before extinguishment was $130.5 million with $0.9 million allocated to the equity component.
Rest of the answer

The $7.1 million difference between 1) the consideration allocated to the liability component, and 2) the $123.4 million net carrying amount of the liability component (including $6.7 million of remaining unamortized discount and debt issuance costs) was recognized as part of the loss on extinguishment of debt.

•whether the deferred taxes presented on your table on page F-30 represent the basis difference associated with the liability component that was initially recognized as an adjustment to APIC consistent with the guidance in ASC 470-20-25-27 and when the Company is expecting such temporary difference to reverse; and

Response:

We confirm that the deferred taxes presented on the table on page F-30 represent the basis difference associated with the liability component that was initially recognized as an adjustment to additional paid in capital consistent with the guidance in ASC 470-20-25-27. The related $18.8 million initially recognized as deferred tax liability (“DTL”) for the basis difference has been reduced on a monthly basis (since the issuance of the convertible notes) in conjunction with the amortization of the debt discount. As non-cash interest expense has been recognized each period related to the amortization of the debt discount, a deferred tax benefit has been recognized in earnings as a result of the reduction of the DTL. In addition, as a result of the repurchase of $130.1 million aggregate principal amount of the convertible notes in August 2020, a portion of the remaining unamortized debt discount was written off and, accordingly, $1.6 million of the remaining DTL balance was also reversed and was primarily recognized as deferred tax benefit in earnings with the remainder related to the change in equity component recognized in additional paid in capital. As of December 31, 2020 the remaining DTL associated with the basis difference was $0.6 million.

•what consideration you gave to reversing a portion of the $18.8 million deferred tax liability due to the previous amortization of the debt discount and whether an additional amount should be reversed due the partial redemption of the convertible notes on August 19, 2020. Refer to the example in ASC 470-20-55-71 through 55-82.

Response:

As described in our response to the previous bullet point, the $18.8 million of DTL has been reduced on a monthly basis (since the issuance of the convertible notes) in conjunction with the amortization of the debt discount, and a portion of the DTL was also reduced due to the partial redemption of the convertible notes in August 2020.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 20, 2021: 10-Q filed May 5, 2021 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 4, 2020 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 7. Financial Commitments, page F-27
SEC asked
We note your response to comment 1. In future filings, please ensure your disclosures clearly disclose any gains or losses that may have resulted from the extinguishment, including where the gains or losses are presented in your financial statements.
TPC answered
In future filings, the Company will ensure that our disclosures clearly disclose any gains or losses that may have resulted from the extinguishment of debt, including where the gains or losses are presented in our financial statements.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 4, 2021: 10-Q filed May 5, 2021 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 4, 2020 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2021-05-05

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2017

2018-09-17 to 2018-10-12 · 3 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2018-10-12
Goodwill and impairmentCritical estimatesSegmentsResults discussion (MD&A)
Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations · Specialty Contractors Segment, page 23
SEC asked (1)
Your disclosure states that “income from construction operations decreased 50% in 2017 compared to 2016, principally due to the impact of unfavorable project adjustments on certain mechanical projects in New York and California, none of which were individually material.” To the extent that the unfavorable project adjustments were material in the aggregate, please revise future filings to also quantify the total of
Rest of the question

such adjustments. Please refer to Item 303(A)(3)(i) of Regulation S-K for guidance.

TPC answered
In future filings, to the extent that identified unfavorable project adjustments are material in the aggregate, the Company will quantify the total of such adjustments.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 28, 2018: 10-Q filed Nov 7, 2018 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2018 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Critical Accounting Policies – Recoverability of Goodwill, page 28
SEC asked (2)
We note that your market capitalization is significantly below your equity value at both December 31, 2017 and June 30, 2018. Please explain to us how you have considered this significant difference in your goodwill impairment analysis as of December 31, 2017.
Rest of the question

Additionally, please tell us if you have performed an interim impairment analysis subsequent to December 31, 2017, and if so, please tell us the results of such analysis. In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.

TPC answered
The Company performs its goodwill impairment test as of October 1st each year and the test is completed during the fourth quarter. As part of the Company’s 2017 annual goodwill impairment testing, multiple factors were considered and various analyses were performed in determining whether the difference between the carrying value of equity and market capitalization was indicative of a goodwill impairment. As discussed in ASC 350-20-35-22 and 35-23, market capitalization may not be representative of fair value.
Rest of the answer

For many publicly traded companies, including Tutor Perini, a control premium exists because market capitalization reflects trading prices on a minority interest basis. In accordance with the aforementioned guidance, an entity’s fair value reflects the premium a market participant may pay to gain control of the entity to affect future strategy, introduce synergies or otherwise increase value to a market participant. Therefore, in consideration of the accounting guidance and as part of the Company’s annual goodwill impairment test, the Company performed a market capitalization reconciliation. The market capitalization reconciliation began by estimating the fair values of each reporting unit. The aggregate fair value of the reporting units was then compared to the Company’s market capitalization to calculate the implied control premium. The Company analyzed whether the implied control premium was consistent with or within a reasonable range of actual premiums paid in industry-specific merger and acquisition transactions observed over a sustained period of time. The Company’s analysis indicated that its implied control premium was well within the range of yearly average premiums paid in the marketplace from 2007 to 2016. In 2017, the Company also noted a premium paid in excess of the observed range in an acquisition made by a company in its peer group.

In addition to the calculation and assessment of the implied control premium, the Company considered what it believes to be an inherent marketability discount embedded in the Tutor Perini stock price as a result of a significant portion (approximately 18%) of the Company’s total shares outstanding being owned by one individual, its Chairman and CEO. After considering all insiders, the Company’s public float is below 80%, which represents the percentage of total outstanding shares of common stock that are freely traded by public investors. This public float percentage is significantly lower than the public float of the Company’s peers, which averaged 98% (with a range of 90% to 100%) for the two-year period ended October 1, 2017. Because investors in the Company’s stock are faced with a lower supply of stock available to be traded, the trading volume and liquidity of its shares may be more limited when compared to its peers, which further contributes to the inherent marketability discount in the Company’s stock price as compared to an estimated fair value.

In conducting its goodwill impairment analysis, the Company considered various quantitative and qualitative factors as required in the impairment analysis process, including its implied control premium and the difference between its equity value and market capitalization, as of October 1, 2017. Based on the Company’s calculation and assessment of its implied control premium and qualitative factors, including its inherent marketability discount described above, the Company concluded that the difference between its market capitalization and equity value did not indicate an impairment of goodwill when it conducted its 2017 annual goodwill impairment test.

During interim periods, including those subsequent to the Company’s October 1, 2017 annual test date, in accordance with ASC 350-20-35-30, the Company performed assessments to determine whether there were any triggering events or changes in circumstances that would warrant an interim ASC 350 Step 1 impairment analysis. Specifically, the Company performed a comprehensive evaluation, for each assessment, of relevant events and circumstances since the annual goodwill impairment test, including but not limited to, an examination of macroeconomic conditions, industry and market conditions, cost factors, overall financial performance by each reporting unit, other relevant entity-specific events, and trends in the stock prices of the Company and its peers. In its evaluations, the Company considered each reporting unit’s current financial performance and forecast as well as the performance against previous forecasts. Additionally, since the Company’s October 1, 2017 annual test date, the Company has continued to observe significant opportunities in a robust marketplace which have led to sizable awards and notable growth in backlog at each of the Company’s reporting units. In considering the totality of the aforementioned factors together with the significant excess of fair value over carrying value calculated on all of the reporting units in the previous annual impairment test, the Company concluded it was not more likely than not that the fair value of any reporting unit had been reduced below its carrying value for any period subsequent to its 2017 annual impairment test. As a result, the Company concluded that an interim Step 1 impairment test was not required.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 28, 2018: 10-Q filed Nov 7, 2018 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2018 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Critical Accounting Policies – Recoverability of Goodwill, page 28
SEC asked
We note your response to our prior comment two. Please expand your disclosure in future annual filings: • To address how you consider market capitalization as part of your annual goodwill impairment test, similar to the information you provided in your response letter; and • To state, if true, that the fair values of your reporting units substantially exceed their respective carrying values.
TPC answered
In future annual filings, the Company will address how it considers market capitalization as part of its annual goodwill impairment test, similar to the information provided in the Company’s response letter dated September 28, 2018. In addition, the Company will state, if true, that the fair values of its reporting units substantially exceed their respective carrying values.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 9, 2018: 10-Q filed Nov 7, 2018 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2018 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2018-10-12

Form 10-K for the Year Ended December 31, 2016

2017-07-06 to 2017-08-09 · 6 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2017-08-09
Executive payLegal and contingencies
Consolidated Financial Statements · Note 1 – Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, Page F-8
SEC asked (1)
You disclose that you classify construction-related receivables and payables that may be settled in periods exceeding one year from the balance sheet date as current. Please disclose the portion expected to be settled after one year. Refer to ASC 910-310-50 and 910-405-50.
TPC answered
The Company classifies construction-related receivables and payables that may be settled in periods exceeding one year from the balance sheet date as current, consistent with the length of time of its project operating cycle. These amounts include costs and estimated earnings in excess of billings, as well as retainage receivables and payables. ASC 910-310-50 and 910-405-50 require the portion of construction-related receivables and payables expected to be settled after one year to be disclosed.
Rest of the answer

In the Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2016, the Company provided disclosure regarding the amount of costs and estimated earnings in excess of billings estimated by management to be collected beyond one year (Page F-9). In response to the Staff’s comment and to more fully comply with ASC 910-310-50 and 910-405-50, the Company will expand its disclosures to include the portion of retainage receivables and retainage payables expected to be settled after one year, beginning with its Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2017. Further, to the extent there is a material change during the interim periods, the Company will provide an update in its future quarterly filings. As of December 31, 2016, the Company estimated that approximately 26% and 28% of retainage receivables and retainage payables, respectively, were to be settled after one year (but within the length of time of its project operating cycle).

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2017: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 3, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 7 – Contingencies and Commitments, Page F-22
SEC asked (2)
You state that a material adverse financial impact due to the insurers’ denial of coverage and WSDOT’s legal actions related to the Alaskan Way Viaduct matter is neither probable nor remote. If it is at least a reasonable possibility, please disclose an estimate of the possible loss or range of loss or a statement that such an estimate cannot be made. Refer to ASC 450-20-50-4.
TPC answered
If a loss contingency is reasonably possible, ASC 450-20-50-4 requires the disclosure of the nature of the contingency and an estimate of the possible loss or range of loss or a statement that such an estimate cannot be made. As of February 23, 2017, the filing date of our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2016, the related legal proceedings were still in the early stages, and while the Company concluded a loss was reasonably possible, we could not estimate the possible loss or range of loss.
Rest of the answer

In response to the Staff’s comment and to more fully comply with ASC 450-20-50-4, beginning with Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended June 30, 2017, the Company will expand the disclosure to include either a statement that such an estimate cannot reasonably be made or, if reasonably estimable, an estimate of the possible loss or range of loss.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2017: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 3, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Compensation Discussion and Analysis, page 26 · General
SEC asked (3)
Please tell us whether the $3.75 million payment was pursuant to a further agreement or understanding with Mr. Tutor, as it appears that the employment agreement you have filed as exhibit 10.1 to Form 8-K filed December 24, 2014 provides for $5 million succession planning bonus upon the finalization of a board approved succession plan including the naming of a successor for the role of the Chief Executive Officer.
Rest of the question

We note your disclosure on page 31 that the Compensation Committee has no current plans to consider significant future bonuses to your CEO that could be considered discretionary. It is unclear from your disclosure if the remaining $1.25 million will no longer be paid to Mr. Tutor. Please tell us whether the Compensation Committee has terminated the remaining bonus under the employment agreement or whether Mr. Tutor has elected to forgo the remaining amounts due. In future filings, to the extent that any of the remaining succession plan bonus is paid, please disclose the basis of the award.

TPC answered
The $3.75 million payment made to Mr. Tutor in 2015 was a partial payment towards the $5 million succession planning bonus that is payable to Mr. Tutor pursuant to the terms of his December 2014 amended and restated employment agreement and is not part of any further agreement or understanding with Mr. Tutor. The remaining $1.25 million of the $5 million succession planning bonus will be paid to Mr. Tutor as the succession plan is finalized and the basis for any related payment will be disclosed accordingly.
Read in the reply
Annual Incentive Compensation, page 37
SEC asked (4)
We note that you disclose the Pre-Tax Income target performance metric for your annual incentive compensation. However, you do not disclose the threshold and maximum level of achievement. In future filings please disclose the threshold, target and maximum level of achievement required for each performance metric and payouts for each level of achievement. Please provide the staff with proposed revised disclosure.
TPC answered
In future filings, the Company will disclose the threshold, target and maximum level of achievement required for each performance metric and payouts for each level of achievement.

Below is an example of how the Company expects to disclose this information in future filings:

The following table presents the 20XX threshold, target and maximum bonus opportunities as a percentage of each executive's base salary and the payouts associated with each level of achievement.

Threshold

Target

Maximum

Named Executive Officer

Base Salary

(%)

Payout

($)

XX

For each performance metric (e.g.,
Rest of the answer

pre-tax income, cash flow from operations, safety and individual performance), the applicable targets set by the Compensation Committee, the performance ranges and the actual performance achieved, as calculated based on the plan formula for 20XX, were as follows:

(Dollars in thousands)

Performance Ranges

Metric

20XX

Results

Achievement

(e.g., pre-tax income, etc.)

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2017: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 3, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Long-Term Incentives, page 38
SEC asked (5)
In future filings please disclose threshold, target and maximum level of achievement required for each metric and payouts for each level of achievement. Please provide the staff with proposed revised disclosure.
TPC answered
In future filings, the Company will disclose the threshold, target and maximum levels of achievement required for each long-term incentive metric and the payouts for each level of achievement. Below is an example of how the Company expects to disclose this information in future filings:

During 20XX, the following NEOs received equity grants with potential payouts as specified below:
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2017: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 3, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Compensation Discussion and Analysis, page 26 · General
SEC asked
Your response to comment 3 of our letter dated July 6, 2017 appears to be inconsistent with your disclosure on page 31of your proxy statement. In future filings, please clarify that you intend to pay the remaining $1.25 million of $5 million succession planning bonus.
TPC answered
In future filings, the Company will clarify that it intends to pay the remaining $1.25 million of Mr. Tutor’s $5 million succession planning bonus when earned, unless the remaining payment has already been made prior to such filing, in which case the Company will disclose the payment and the basis for the payment.
Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2017-08-09

Form 10-K for the Year Ended December 31, 2014

2015-09-18 to 2015-10-30 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2015-10-30
SegmentsGoodwill and impairment
Financial Statements · [3] Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 65
SEC asked
You disclose that during the first quarter of 2014 you completed a reorganization which resulted in the elimination of the Management Services reporting unit and reportable segment. Please address the following:  You state that the reorganization was completed due to the unit no longer meeting the criteria set forth in FASB ASC Topic 280.
Rest of the question

Please provide us with a robust explanation of the criteria that your Management Services unit no longer meets. Please cite the specific literature that you are relying on to support your conclusion;  You disclosed that you reallocated goodwill between reorganized reporting units based on a relative fair value assessment. Please tell us how you determined how to reallocate goodwill. Please tell us what consideration you gave to ASC 35020-35-45 through 35-46 and 35-51 through 35-57; and  Please tell us the date you decided to reorganize your Management Services reporting unit and reportable segment. Please also tell us whether you also performed a goodwill impairment analysis immediately before and after the reorganization of your reporting structure. If not, please explain why.

TPC answered
Prior to the reorganization, the Company’s Chief Executive Officer, who is the Company’s chief operating decision maker (“CODM”), regularly reviewed the operating results of the Company’s operating segments: Civil, Building, Specialty Contractors and Management Services. The Management Services operating segment consisted of two business units: Black Construction (“Black”) and Perini Management Services (“PMSI”).
Rest of the answer

Because of changes in management responsibilities and changes in the operating and economic characteristics of the Management Services operating segment, the CODM concluded that the Management Services operating segment was no longer material to the management of the Company as a whole, and that financial information related to the Management Services operating segment no longer provided useful information for strategic and operating decision making. As a result, Management Services no longer met the qualitative criteria of ASC 280-10-50-1 (see excerpt below) and therefore was no longer considered an operating segment. Accordingly, the Company reorganized the Black and PMSI business units into the Civil and Building segments, respectively, as each had operating and economic characteristics, including contract type and profit margins, consistent with the respective segments.

Subsequent to the reorganization, the CODM has regularly reviewed the operating results of the Civil, Building and Specialty Contractors operating segments of the Company and has used those operating results to assess performance and to make decisions about the allocation of the Company’s resources.

Excerpt from ASC 280-10-50-1:

An operating segment is a component of a public entity that has all of the following characteristics:

a. It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expenses (including revenues and expenses relating to transactions with other components of the same public entity).

b. Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity's chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance.

c. Its discrete financial information is available.

Lastly, although the Company was not required under ASC 280 to consider quantitative factors, the Company, based on the historical and projected financial information available at the time, noted the following, which reinforced the Company’s qualitative assessment:

Management Services’ revenues represented approximately 4% of the Company’s consolidated revenues.

Management Services’ pre-tax income represented approximately 3% of the Company’s consolidated pre-tax income.

Management Services’ assets represented approximately 6% of the Company’s consolidated assets.

You disclosed that you reallocated goodwill between reorganized reporting units based on a relative fair value assessment. Please tell us how you determined how to reallocate goodwill. Please tell us what considerations you gave to ASC 350-20-35-45 through 35-46 and 35-51 through 35-57.

Response:

The Company reallocated the goodwill associated with the Management Services reporting unit to the Building and Civil reporting units using a relative fair value allocation method as prescribed by ASC 350-20-35-45 through 35-46 and 35-51 through 35-57 (as superseded by ASC 350-20-40-1 through 40-7 and Accounting Standards Update 2012-04).

In the application of the relative fair value allocation method, the Company utilized various commonly accepted valuation modeling techniques and other qualitative market factors to determine the fair value allocation of goodwill to the Civil and Building reporting units. The commonly accepted valuation modeling techniques included valuations as determined by the income, market and asset approaches. The income and market approaches followed the historical valuation methodologies used by the Company in its annual goodwill impairment evaluations, as disclosed in the Company’s annual financial statements reported in its Form 10-K. The asset approach was based on the carrying value of equity for each of the business units, which was reflective of the fair value of their underlying net assets. The qualitative market factors incorporated the Company’s assessment of the expected differential in value to a market participant between Black and PMSI, which was reflective of the long-term prospects of each entity at March 31, 2014.

The Company evaluated the results of all the above techniques in determining the final relative fair value assessment used to allocate goodwill.

Please tell us the date you decided to reorganize your Management Services reporting unit and reportable segment. Please also tell us whether you also performed a goodwill impairment analysis immediately before and after the reorganization of your reporting structure. If not, please explain why.

Response:

On March 12, 2014, after the Company filed its Form 10-K for the 2013 year, the Company reorganized its reporting units and operating segments. As required by ASC 350, the Company, with the assistance of external fair value specialists, analyzed goodwill for impairment immediately prior to and immediately subsequent to the reorganization. As a result of these analyses, it was determined that goodwill was not impaired either prior to or subsequent to the reorganization.

In connection with our responses to the Staff’s comments, the Company acknowledges that:

The Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and,

The Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 2, 2015: 10-Q filed Nov 16, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2015-10-30

Form 10-K for the Year Ended December 31, 2013

2014-09-17 to 2014-09-30 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2014-09-30
Executive pay
Compensation Discussion and Analysis, page 16 · Peer Group, page 25
SEC asked
We note disclosure that you undertook a peer group review with the aim of optimizing your peer group for benchmarking and determining executive compensation in 2013. In future filings, please clarify whether and how you benchmark compensation against the compensation of other companies.
Rest of the question

Please identify which elements of compensation you benchmark, and disclose where actual compensation payments fall within targeted parameters for each of your named executive officers. Please see Item 402(b)(2)(xiv) of Regulation S-K.

TPC answered
Starting with its Definitive Proxy Statement on Schedule 14A which is expected to be filed in April 2015 related to our regular Annual Shareholders Meeting, when and to the extent the Compensation Committee utilizes benchmarking of the Company’s compensation programs, the Company will identify the benchmark and, if applicable, its components and component companies, as well as where actual compensation payments fall within targeted parameters for each named executive officer, to the extent required by Item 402(b)(2)(xiv) of Regulation S-K.

In connection with our responses to your letter,
Rest of the answer

Tutor Perini Corporation acknowledges that:

·

We are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and,

We may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 19, 2014: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 5, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2014-09-30

Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2011

2012-08-20 to 2012-12-10 · 11 questions · 3 letters from the SEC, 3 from the company
Review closed 2012-12-10
Critical estimatesResults discussion (MD&A)Goodwill and impairmentRevenueLiquidity and cashSegmentsDebt
Critical Accounting Policies, page 34 · Method of Accounting for Contracts, page 35
SEC asked (1)
We note that you recognize revenues from long-term contracts under the percentage of completion method. We also note the percentage-of-completion method of accounting depends on your ability to make reasonably dependable cost estimates, costs may be incurred over a period of several years, and estimation of these costs requires the use of judgment.
Rest of the question

Since a significant portion of your revenues are recognized using the percentage of completion method, a significant change in one or more of these estimates could affect your results. It appears to us that changes in estimates may include a number of significant items, such as (i) unusual and infrequent contract price adjustments; (ii) material changes in contract estimates, including provisions for losses; (iii) substantial incentive income or claims revenues; (iv) significant problems encountered in the performance of contracts that materially affect operations; and (v) other material amounts. Please provide us, and revise the notes to your financial statements in future filings to disclose, the impact of changes in contract estimates on your results during each period presented, including an analysis of the underlying reasons for the changes in estimates. Please refer to ASC 250-10-50-4.

TPC answered
We have evaluated the disclosure requirements surrounding changes in accounting estimates in light of FASB Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 250-10-50-4. In addition, we have evaluated ASC 605-35-50-9, Revenue Recognition, Construction-Type and Production-Type Contracts, which references ASC 250-10-50-4 and requires that contractors disclose the effects of a change in contract estimate if that change is material.
Rest of the answer

Based on our evaluation of this guidance, disclosure is required for changes in estimates at the individual contract level (our profit center and unit of account) if the changes in estimates are material. We do not believe the guidance requires the disclosure of the aggregate impact of all individual contract changes in estimates based on our review of (i) ASC 250-10-50-4 ; (ii) ASC 605-35-50-9; (iii) the requirements of ASC 275, Risks and Uncertainties; (iv) the preparation of financial statements and footnotes in accordance with Regulations S-K and S-X; (v) other SEC interpretive literature provided in Financial Reporting Policies, Staff Accounting Bulletins, etc.; and (vi) the AICPA Audit and Accounting Guide for construction contractors.

We recognize revenues from our contracts under the percentage of completion method. In the ordinary course of business, and at a minimum on a quarterly basis, we update projected total contract revenue, cost and profit or loss for each of our contracts based on changes in facts, such as an approved scope change, and changes in estimates. Normal, recurring changes in estimates include, but are not limited to: (i) changes in estimated scope as a result of unapproved or unpriced customer change orders; (ii) changes in estimated productivity assumptions based on experience to date; (iii) changes in estimated materials costs based on experience to date; (iv) changes in estimated subcontractor costs based on subcontractor buyout experience; (v) changes in the timing of scheduled work that may impact future costs; (vi) achievement of incentive income; and (vii) changes in estimated recoveries through the settlement of litigation. We capture these ordinary course changes in estimates at the contract level and note that over the life cycle of a typical contract, there are hundreds, if not thousands, of favorable and unfavorable changes in estimates.

In our evaluation of this disclosure requirement we considered the unit of account at which changes in contract estimates are required to be evaluated and disclosed. Consistent with ASC 605-35-25-4, we have evaluated the substantial majority of our contracts to be separate profit centers. Generally, each contract we enter into possesses a unique set of facts and circumstances that must be separately considered each period when concluding on accounting estimates. The same change in fact or circumstance in a period can have differing impacts on individual contracts based on a number of factors, including the type of contract and specific terms agreed to with the customer.

The example below shows the differing impacts that a significant increase in the estimated cost of materials would have on two of the most common types of contracts we enter into and illustrates the value of providing the disclosure of changes in estimates at the contract level and not on an aggregate basis (dollars in thousands):

Contract A

Contract B

Contract Type

Fixed Price

Cost Plus

Before Change in Estimate

Estimated Revenue at Completion

$

500,000

Estimated Costs at Completion

(450,000

)

Estimated Profit at Completion

50,000

Costs incurred to date

225,000

Percentage Complete

%

Change in estimated cost of materials

25,000

After Change in Estimate

527,500

(475,000

52,500

Impact

Current Period Profit Impact

(13,158

(132

Future Period Profit Impact

(11,842

2,632

Net Impact

(25,000

2,500

As illustrated in the example above, a material increase in costs can have a significant negative impact on one contract and a positive impact on another contract. Given the diverse nature of contracts in our backlog, meaningful disclosure of changes in contract estimates, including an analysis of the underlying reasons for those changes, can only be made at the contract level.

In conjunction with this response, we specifically analyzed individual contracts with changes in forecasted profit over $1 million during 2011 to determine if the impact of any individual contract change in estimate was material to our results of operations in 2011 and/or several future reporting periods. As a result of this analysis, we confirmed that there were no material individual contract changes in estimate recorded during 2011.

We will continue to evaluate changes in estimates at the individual contract level as required by ASC 250-10-50-4 and ASC 605-35-50-9. In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, to the extent that there is a change in an individual contract estimate that materially impacts the current reporting period and/or will materially impact several future reporting periods, we will provide the required disclosures and analysis.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 4, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 34 · Method of Accounting for Contracts, page 35
SEC asked (2)
Please provide us, and revise your revenue recognition critical accounting policy disclosure in MD&A in future annual and quarterly filings to quantify the gross amounts of favorable and unfavorable adjustments to contract estimates during each period presented and to provide an analysis of the underlying reasons for the changes in estimates.
TPC answered
As indicated in our response to the Staff’s first comment above, changes in contract estimates are captured within each contract. As of December 31, 2011 we had more than 1,000 active contracts, each of which contains hundreds, if not thousands, of favorable and unfavorable changes in contract estimates which are tracked on a net basis. While we monitor the effect of these changes in estimates for individual contracts, our systems do not allow us to collect aggregated information regarding individual changes in estimates that occur within each contract.
Rest of the answer

We believe our systems are adequate to evaluate and disclose material changes in contract estimates at the contract level; however, we cannot provide a complete aggregate gross favorable and unfavorable impact for the Company as a whole.

Management currently reviews changes in contract estimates by individual contract, and not at the gross favorable and unfavorable change level. We believe that management’s current review process is more than sufficient in assessing our operating results and providing informative and transparent disclosure to our investors. We do not believe the disclosure of gross favorable and unfavorable contract changes would provide our investors with an accurate view of the Company through the eyes of management, consistent with the Staff’s guidance on MD&A disclosures in Item 303(a)(3) of Regulation S-K and Staff Releases 33-8350 and 33-6835. We also evaluated, and believe we are in compliance with, the Staff’s guidance on Critical Accounting Estimate disclosures in FRC 501.14 which states that companies should provide quantitative as well as qualitative disclosure when quantitative information is reasonably available and will provide material information for investors. As discussed above, the disclosure of aggregate gross favorable and unfavorable changes in contract estimates requested by the Staff is not reasonably available and would not provide material information to our investors.

In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings we will enhance our critical accounting policy disclosures in MD&A to include the changes in estimate at the individual contract level and the nature of the changes to the extent that the changes materially impact our results of operations during the current reporting period and/or several future reporting periods. We believe this level of disclosure will provide our investors the opportunity to view our business consistently with how management analyzes the Company.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 4, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Results of Operations, page 39
SEC asked (3)
Please expand your MD&A in future annual and quarterly filings to separately quantify and discuss the factors responsible for changes in cost of operations, at both the consolidated and segment level, during each period presented as required by Item 303 of Regulation S-K.
Rest of the question

It appears to us that your future annual and quarterly filings should discuss consolidated cost of operations, including the impact of each significant cost component in cost of operations that caused cost of operations to materially vary (or not vary when expected to). Your disclosures should be presented in a manner that allows investors to discern the relative contribution of each of multiple components cited to the total change in cost of operations and resultant operating income. Additionally, please note that even when total cost of operations do not materially vary from period to period, the impact of material variances in the components of cost of operations that offset one another should be separately disclosed, quantified, and discussed (not netted). Please also ensure that your revised disclosures provide appropriate explanations of the underlying reasons for the changes. Given the potential for differing or offsetting results in your segments, we encourage you to also provide the above disclosures at the segment level. In any event, you should provide a discussion and analysis of cost of operations at the segment level when a change in a segment’s cost of operation materially impacts the segment’s measure of operating income.

TPC answered
We have evaluated the Staff’s comment above in light of the guidance provided in Item 303 of Regulation S-K. We note that MD&A is specifically required to: (i) describe any significant components of revenues or expenses that, in the judgment of the management of the company, should be disclosed in order to understand its results of operations; and (ii) disclose known events that will cause a material change in the relationship between costs and revenues.
Rest of the answer

In accordance with Release 33-8350 and Release 33-6835, we note that MD&A should provide discussion and analysis of a company’s business as seen through the eyes of those who manage the business.

We recognize revenues from our contracts under the percentage of completion method. In accordance with ASC 605-35, we utilize the cost-to-cost method to measure progress toward completion each period. The application of this accounting treatment inseparably links the recognition of revenue to the recognition of operating costs based on the progress achieved and the estimated final cost. With the exception of changes to the gross profit margins, the factors responsible for changes in costs of operations between periods are identical to the factors responsible for changes in revenue between periods, currently discussed in our MD&A. Changes in the gross profit margins can relate to the change in mix of work between periods, or changes in contract estimates (i.e. favorable or unfavorable performance, etc.), currently discussed as changes in operating profit in our MD&A and addressed in our response to the Staff’s first comment above.

To illustrate the link between changes in costs and revenues period to period, consider an example of an increase in labor costs on an individual contract compared to a previous period. The increase in labor costs on that individual contract could be driven by various factors including: (i) a ramp-up of activity on the contract; (ii) an increase in self-performed work versus subcontracted work; or (iii) an increase in labor costs per hour over original estimates. These factors can have varying implications on the profitability of an individual contract and on our results of operations. Disclosure of these changes in costs would not meaningfully address the impact on our operations for the period, which we respectfully submit is achieved through our current approach of analyzing revenue variances, income from operations variances and operating margin variances.

With regards to our segment level disclosures, management’s review of each segment’s income from construction operations currently includes an analysis of changes in revenue and operating profit. We do not separately analyze the variance of costs of operations between periods. These costs are maintained on a contract by contract basis and are reviewed at the individual contract level by project management but are not currently aggregated for review at the segment level.

For these reasons, we have focused our results of operations disclosures in MD&A around changes in revenue, income from operations and operating margin from period to period. In these disclosures, we discuss the types of active contracts we have, changes in mix of contracts during the period, favorable and unfavorable contract performance during the period, as well as management’s strategies to increase operating margins through a continued focus on obtaining large, complex public works projects and to increase the volume of self-performed work. We respectfully submit that this discussion of management’s strategies, contract mix and performance provides meaningful disclosure to investors and is consistent with management’s view of the business, both in the short and long-term. In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we will revise our results of operations disclosures to include a discussion of how changes in revenues and income from operations are inseparably linked to changes in costs consistent with our response to this comment.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 4, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 43
SEC asked (4)
We note your disclosure on page 32 that each joint venture participant is fully liable for the obligations of the joint venture. With a view towards future disclosure, please tell us what consideration you have given to the financial stability of your other joint venture participants and whether you may be obligated to contribute additional capital to any of your joint venture arrangements.
TPC answered
Joint ventures in which we participate require each partner to accept joint and several responsibility for all obligations of the joint venture. As a result, we are very selective as to the companies with which we will enter into a joint venture partnership. Prior to forming a joint venture, we conduct a thorough analysis of the prospective partner to determine its capabilities, specifically relating to construction expertise, track record for delivering a quality product on time, reputation in the industry, as well as financial strength and available liquidity.
Rest of the answer

We utilize a number of resources to verify a potential joint venture partner’s financial condition, including credit rating reports and financial information contained in its audited financial statements. We specifically review a potential partner’s available liquidity and bonding capacity. Before entering into a joint venture, we interview the principals of the firm, check references in their local community, confirm their ability to bond their interest in the project, and consider their ability to absorb insurance deductibles. Initial capital contributions to the project are negotiated based in part on the assessed financial stability of our joint venture partners. In the event we are concerned with the financial viability of a potential partner, we will require substantial initial cash contributions upon inception of the joint venture to mitigate the risk that we would be required to cover a disproportionate share of the joint venture’s future cash needs. We regularly enter into joint venture arrangements with partners we have worked with in the past, giving us further insight into their financial stability as well as their operating style and quality of work.

The majority of our joint venture contracts are for various government agencies that typically require the joint venture and/or our partners to complete a thorough pre-qualification process. This pre-qualification process typically includes the verification of each partner’s financial condition and capacity to perform the work, as well as the issuance of performance bonds by surety companies who also independently verify each partner’s financial condition.

If one or more of our partners in a joint venture fail to perform or become financially distressed, the remaining partner(s) would be responsible to complete the performance of the outstanding work and assume any financial obligations of the defaulting and/or nonperforming partner(s). In order to mitigate the need for future capital calls, our joint ventures typically retain a substantial majority of the cash flow generated during the course of the project. Approximately 18% or $1.1 billion of our current backlog relates to joint venture contracts and 59% or $110 million of our cash balance as of June 30, 2012 was held in our joint ventures. The relatively large joint venture-related cash balance compared to backlog of future joint venture-related work provides reasonable assurance that significant future capital calls are not likely.

Because of our due diligence process and the significant amount of cash retained in our joint ventures, we do not believe that it is likely we will be called upon to contribute significant additional capital in the event of default by any of our partners.

In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we will expand our disclosure on joint venture arrangements in MD&A to include a description of our due diligence process in assessing the financial stability of potential joint venture partners and clarify our potential liability in the event of a default by one or more of our joint venture partners as joint and several in nature.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 4, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 3. Fair Value Measurements, page 80
SEC asked (5)
With a view towards future disclosure, please provide us with a more specific and comprehensive discussion of how the impairment charge for your auction rate securities was determined and how you concluded that the remaining balance was recoverable. Please discuss your consideration of the current repayment status of student loans.
Rest of the question

In addition, please clarify if your settlements of auction rate securities during fiscal 2011 or the six month period ended June 30, 2012 resulted in any losses.

TPC answered
We perform a fair market value assessment of our auction rate securities (ARS) on a quarterly basis. To estimate the fair value, we utilized an income approach valuation model, with consideration given to a market-based valuation approach, in accordance with ASC 820. With the general failure of the auction process used to market these securities, we have specifically considered the factors in ASC 820-10-35-51A, Determining Fair Value When the Volume and Level of Activity for the Asset or Liability Have Significantly Decreased.
Rest of the answer

We classify our ARS as Level 3 investments, where fair value inputs are unobservable inputs in which little or no market data exists, therefore requiring us to develop our own assumptions based on the best information available in the circumstances.

Our valuation model considered, among other items, the following inputs: (i) the underlying structure of each security; (ii) the present value of future principal and interest payments discounted at rates considered to reflect current market conditions (discount rates range from 3% to 7% for investment grade securities); (iii) consideration of the probabilities of default or repurchase at par for each period (term periods range from 6 to 8 years); (iv) prices from recent comparable transactions; and (v) other third party pricing information without adjustment.

We utilize a third party specialist to assist in evaluating the inputs noted above. The inputs and analysis consider: (i) contractual terms of the ARS instruments; (ii) government-backed guarantees, if any; (iii) credit ratings on our ARS; (iv) current interest rates on our ARS and other market interest rate data; (v) trade data available, including trade data from secondary markets, for our ARS or similar ARS; (vi) recovery rates for any non-government guaranteed assets; (vii) historical transactions of our ARS being called at par; (viii) refunding initiatives of ARS; and (ix) risk of downgrade and default.

Current market conditions, including repayment status of student loans, credit market risk, market liquidity and macro-economic influences are reflected in the inputs noted above.

We assess the recoverability of the remaining ARS balance by reviewing, on a quarterly basis, several factors including: (i) the regularity and timely payment of interest on the securities; (ii) the probabilities of default or repurchase at par; (iii) the risk of loss of principal from government backed versus non-government-backed securities; and (iv) the prioritization of the Company’s tranche of securities within the investment in case of default. Potential impact of any principal loss is included in the valuation model and discussed with our third party valuation specialist.

On a quarterly basis, we also analyze the appropriateness of the classification of our investment in ARS and related impairment charges recorded in the period, if any. At December 31, 2011 and June 30, 2012, we had neither the intent to sell the securities in the near term, nor the intent to hold the securities to maturity. As such, we determined the securities to be classified as available-for-sale securities based on our intent.

When our analysis indicates an impairment of a security, we consider several factors in accordance with ASC 320-10-35 to determine the proper classification of the charge. Those factors include, but are not limited to: (i) any requirement or intent to sell the security; (ii) failure of the issuer to pay interest or principal; (iii) volatility of fair value; (iv) changes to the ratings of the security; (v) adverse conditions specific to the security or market; (vi) expected defaults; and (vii) length of time and extent that fair value has been less than the cost basis. We use the accumulation of this data to conclude if a credit loss exists for the specific security, and then determine the classification of the impairment charge as temporary or other-than-temporary.

As a result of our analysis at December 31, 2011, we determined the fair value of our investment in ARS was less than book value and recorded an impairment charge of $4.8 million. We deemed the impairment to be other-than-temporary and recorded the charge against income. Of the total impairment charge, $4.1 million was for the impairment of two ARS which were not government-guaranteed.

In 2011, two of our ARS were redeemed at their full par values, totaling $21.2 million. These redemptions resulted in a reversal of $132 thousand of impairment charges recorded in earnings in a prior year. In the first six months of 2012, we sold one ARS at auction for its full par value of $8.1 million, and two ARS in a secondary market for $8.5 million. Our decision to sell the two ARS in the secondary market was reached subsequent to the balance sheet date of the previous reporting period. The settlement of the three securities resulted in a pre-tax impairment charge of $2.7 million.

In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we will expand our disclosure on the determination of impairment charges for ARS and our assessment of recoverability of remaining ARS balances.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 4, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 6. Goodwill and Intangible Assets, page 17
SEC asked (6)
With a view towards future disclosure, please help us better understand how you determined the amount of your goodwill impairment charge. In this regard, please tell us how the significant assumptions in your impairment testing used to calculate your charge differed from the assumptions used in your testing during the fourth quarter of fiscal 2011.
Rest of the question

Please ensure that you provide us with the implied control premium used during each test and discuss any differences in amounts. In addition, please discuss how you have considered the continuing difference between your market capitalization and carrying value.

TPC answered
Based on the facts and circumstances that were concluded to be triggering events as described in our Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended June 30, 2012, we performed an interim goodwill impairment test as of June 30, 2012. As a result, we recorded a pre-tax goodwill impairment charge of $321.1 million during the second quarter of 2012.

Determination of the amount of Goodwill Impairment

Our first step in the impairment analysis was to determine the fair value of the Company and each of its reporting units and compare the fair value of each reporting unit to its carrying value.
Rest of the answer

To determine the fair value of the Company and each of its reporting units, we utilized both an income-based valuation approach as well as a market-based valuation approach. The income-based valuation approach is based on the cash flows that the reporting unit expects to generate in the future and requires us to project revenues, operating expenses, working capital investment, capital spending and cash flows for each reporting unit in a discrete period, as well as to determine the weighted-average cost of capital to be used as a discount rate and a terminal value growth rate for the non-discrete period. The market-based valuation approach to estimate the fair value of the Company’s reporting units utilizes industry multiples of revenues and operating earnings. We equally weight the fair values calculated under the income-based and market-based valuation approaches in arriving at the concluded fair values of our reporting units.

We utilized a third party specialist in our determination of the fair value of each reporting unit.

The following table summarizes the results of our ASC 350 Step 1 analysis as of June 30, 2012 (dollars in thousands):

Reporting Unit

Fair Value

Carrying

Value

Excess/

(Shortfall)

Pass/Fail

Building

90,000

360,629

(270,629

(75.0

%)

Fail

Civil

440,000

456,973

(16,973

(3.7

Management Services

85,000

100,754

(15,754

(15.6

Specialty Contractors

135,000

86,849

48,151

55.4

Pass

Based on the results of our ASC 350 Step 1 analysis, we proceeded to the Step 2 analysis to calculate the goodwill impairment. In this second step, we determined the fair value of the individual assets and liabilities of the reporting units that failed Step 1 and calculated the implied fair value of goodwill for those reporting units. In this calculation we included the valuation of assets and liabilities that would occur in a theoretical purchase price allocation of the reporting unit under ASC 805, including the value of backlog, trade name, and customer relationships as well as the impact of deferred tax liabilities and assets arising from the fair valuation of these assets and liabilities.

The following table summarizes the results of our ASC 350 Step 2 analysis as of June 30, 2012 (dollars in thousands):

Total Fair

Fair Value of Individual

Assets & Liabilities

Residual Fair

Goodwill Prior to Impairment

Goodwill

Impairment

79,498

10,502

273,420

(262,918

65,847

374,153

429,893

(55,740

40,842

44,158

46,587

(2,429

Changes in significant assumptions

Changes in significant assumptions from those used in the impairment test during the fourth quarter of 2011 included an increase in the weighted average cost of capital by up to 150 basis points in certain reporting units caused primarily by deterioration in broader market conditions, particularly in the construction industry, that led to greater stock price volatility in the guideline companies, and lower profit expectations resulting in declines in market multiples from the guideline companies used in deriving the fair values of our reporting units. We also experienced a degradation in the timing of projected cash flows used to derive the fair values of the Building, Civil and Management Services reporting units, caused primarily by delays in the timing of awards and start of new work that we anticipated would enter into backlog in the first half of 2012, and a general decrease in profit margins on new work awards that were factored into our forecast assumptions.

In the Building reporting unit, the most significant decrease in estimated new work cash flow for 2012 was the result of political decisions that negatively impacted the advance of a large project for an existing customer that was entering its second phase of construction. This project was expected to produce significant cash flows during 2012 and beyond. In addition, we observed an unfavorable change in the margin mix of new work obtained in the first half of 2012 compared with prior years. The majority of our new work awards in the first half of 2012 as well as our near term new work prospects are comprised of lower margin private client work and not the higher margin public works Building reporting unit work that we have previously enjoyed. As a result of the delay in new work awards and the deterioration in new work margins, the Building reporting unit experienced operating results significantly below those forecasted in the fourth quarter of 2011. The projected cash flows for the Building reporting unit as of June 30, 2012 took into consideration the delay in new work awards and unfavorable change in margin mix, consistent with our actual results in the first half of 2012.

In the Civil reporting unit, the fourth quarter 2011 valuation anticipated the start and/or ramp-up of a number of projects during the first half of 2012. Many of these projects were ultimately delayed for several reasons including political pressures, timing of funding, and general economic concerns. The delay in timing of recent awards as well as the slower ramp-up of production for certain projects resulted in deterioration in anticipated future cash flows from our fourth quarter of 2011 expectations. This was further compounded by delays in the release of expected new contracts which will ultimately be bid and awarded later in the current year. While the earnings of the Civil reporting unit through June 30, 2012 have tracked to the projections utilized in the fourth quarter 2011 valuation, we had reason to believe that the delays being experienced could have an adverse impact on future cash flows of the Civil reporting unit. Given the sensitivity of the model and lack of substantial head room from the concluded fourth quarter valuation as compared to the carrying value, as disclosed in our Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2011, the change in timing of cash flows led to a reduction of the Civil reporting unit’s fair value below its carrying value.

Within the Management Services reporting unit valuation for the fourth quarter of 2011, cash flow projections included the anticipated ramp-up of the “Design – Build Multiple Award Construction Contract (MACC) for U.S. Military Construction Projects for Sites in Guam and Other Areas Under the Cognizance of the Naval Facilities Engineering Command, Pacific” Contract associated with the movement of Pacific Marine Corps operations from the island of Okinawa to the island of Guam. It should be noted that we are a pre-qualified participant in the program. During April 2012, United States bipartisan legislators were unable to come to agreement on government spending cuts and certain government projects were suspended indefinitely. This called into question the amount of work that would be necessary on Guam in the foreseeable future and left significant doubt around the timing and magnitude of the proposed move. This doubt was magnified by the initial disagreement between the governments of the United States and Japan in the first half of 2012 regarding the plans for troop realignment. These uncertainties led to the removal of these projected cash flows, used in the fourth quarter of 2011 valuation, as we are currently uncertain of the scope and timing of this work.

Control Premium Assessment as of the periods ended December 31, 2011 and June 30, 2012

As part of our valuation process, we compared the aggregate fair value of the Company to our market capitalization at the valuation date in order to determine the implied control premium. We then compared the implied control premium to the control premiums paid in recent transactions within our industry. As of the fourth quarter 2011 valuation, our implied market control premium of 78.1% was determined to be in an acceptable range of market transactions observed in the construction and engineering industry in the past seven years.

The table below from the Mergerstat Review summarizes the control premiums paid in these market transactions:

Observed Control Premiums

Construction Contractors & Engineering Services Average

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

Average Control Premiums Observed

27.9

49.5

40.0

18.5

44.5

67.1

54.6

High

62.9

71.1

50.5

31.1

89.5

176.9

141.3

Low

0.7

29.8

7.5

16.5

23.3

7.8

The implied control premium as of the fourth quarter 2011 valuation was considered to be at the higher end of an acceptable range of observable market transactions, which averaged 59.1% over the past seven years. We concluded that the control premium was appropriate based on our low public float, low trading volume, and the impact of insider trading near the valuation date that artificially created a drag on the price of our stock.

As of June 30, 2012, our implied control premium was 42.5%. Similar to the fourth quarter 2011 valuation, this control premium falls within the range of observed market transactions and we concluded that the valuation is appropriate and in line with the market data. While our stock price undoubtedly continues to be encumbered by the low trading volumes and low public float, we would expect the decline in insider trading activity during the second quarter of 2012 to be a natural cause for a reduction in the implied control premium.

Difference between market capitalization and carrying value

As part of our interim 2012 impairment analysis, we considered the implied market control premium as a benchmark for determining the reasonableness of the ongoing difference between our market capitalization and carrying value. As discussed above, the implied control premium, calculated with the assistance of a third party specialist, fell within an acceptable range of transactions being observed in the market place. However, we noted a continued drag on the stock price causing a material difference between the carrying value of our equity and market capitalization as of June 30, 2012.

Our stock price has long experienced the impacts of low public float. A significant portion of our stock, approximately 20.6% as of the date of our June 30, 2012 interim impairment test, is owned by our Chairman and CEO. As a result, our public float, calculated as the percentage of shares of common stock freely traded by public investors divided by our total shares outstanding, is significantly lower than the public float of our peers. Currently, our public float is approximately 76.5% compared to a range between 97.5% and 99.5% for our peers. As a result, investors in our stock are faced with a lower supply of stock available to be traded, thereby limiting the trading volume and liquidity of our stock as compared to the stock of our peers.

In addition to having a low float percentage, the average daily volume of our stock has been very low, averaging 0.7% for the past two years as compared to the trading volume of the stock of our publicly traded peers currently ranging from 1.2% to 1.4%. The trading volume of these companies has consistently been approximately two times our volume over the past two years. Low volume combined with low float implies that our stock is not very liquid as compared to the stock of our peers.

Insider trading activities have also had a significant impact on our stock price during the past year. Our Chairman and CEO needed to divest a significant portion of his holdings for personal reasons unrelated to the Company, which also resulted in the subsequent amendment of Tutor Perini’s Shareholder’s agreement to provide our Chairman and CEO additional flexibility with respect to the remaining shares he owns.

We believe the circumstances surrounding our stock, described above, led to an inherent marketability discount embedded in our stock price, which is the primary reason for the continued difference between the carrying value of our equity and market capitalization.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 4, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 54 · Long-term Debt, page 55
SEC asked (7)
We note that had you not obtained a waiver you would have been out of compliance with the covenants of your Credit Agreement for the period ended June 30, 2012 due, in part, to your debt levels and lower than expected income from operations.
Rest of the question

Although these covenants have since been modified it appears additional information regarding your status of compliance with your debt covenants will provide an investor with a better understanding of your potential borrowing availability. Therefore please revise future filings to disclose actual amounts versus required amounts for your significant debt covenants for each period presented.

TPC answered
We have evaluated the request above in light of SEC Interpretive Release No. 33-8350 which requires a company that is, or is reasonably likely to be, in breach of its debt covenants to disclose material information about the breach and analyze the impact or reasonably likely impact of the breach on financial condition or operating performance, if material.

We disclosed in our June 30, 2012 Form 10-Q that we obtained a waiver from compliance with certain of the most restrictive debt covenants for the quarterly period ended June 30, 2012.
Rest of the answer

Before the waiver, we would have been out of compliance with the required minimum consolidated fixed charge coverage ratio, and the permitted maximum consolidated leverage ratio, primarily due to the pre-tax goodwill and intangible asset impairment charge of $376.6 million, as well as increased debt levels and lower than expected income from operations during the second quarter of 2012. We also disclosed that our revolving credit facility was amended to require lower minimum consolidated fixed charge coverage ratios and to increase the permitted maximum consolidated leverage ratio effective beginning with the quarterly period ended September 30, 2012.

The table below presents our consolidated fixed charge coverage ratio, consolidated leverage ratio, consolidated net worth and consolidated liquidity for the June 30, 2012 quarter period:

Actual

Pro Forma

Required

For the quarter ended June 30, 2012

Including impact of impairment change

Excluding impact

Before amendment of credit agreement

After amendment

Fixed charge coverage ratio

(1.60) : 1.00

1.65 : 1.00

> or = 1.50 : 1.00

> or = 1.00 : 1.00

Leverage ratio

(7.97) : 1.00

3.08 : 1.00

< or = 3.00 : 1.00

< or = 4.25 : 1.00

Net worth

$1.056 billion

$1.412 billion

> $1.040 billion

> $837.0 million

Liquidity

$343.7 million

N/A

> or = $100.0 million

We expect to be in compliance with the modified debt covenants in the foreseeable future. We will continue to evaluate our current and anticipated future compliance with debt covenants as well as the potential impact of covenants restricting our ability to undertake additional debt or equity financing. In the event that we are, or are reasonably likely to be, in breach of any of our debt covenants, in future filings, we will provide actual amounts versus required amounts for those debt covenants and disclosures, as appropriate, required by SEC Interpretive Release No. 33-8350.

In connection with our responses to your letter, Tutor Perini Corporation acknowledges that:

·

We are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and,

We may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 4, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 34 · Method of Accounting for Contracts, page 35
SEC asked (1)
We note your response to our prior comments one and two. However, it continues to be unclear to us why you believe you are not required to disclosure the aggregate impact of changes in your contract estimates as well as the gross amounts of favorable and unfavorable adjustments and why such information would not provide material information to your investors.
Rest of the question

Please explain further and tell us more specifically what consideration you have given to Release No. 33-8350 and ASC 250-10-50-4. While we note that you have diverse contracts including fixed price and cost plus contracts, it appears that disclosure could be made based on the contract type. In addition, please further explain why it may not be practicable for you to obtain this information.

TPC answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, we specifically analyzed ASC 250-10-50-4. We note that ASC 250-10-50-4 requires disclosure of the quantitative effect on the Company’s results of operations in the current period for changes in estimates that affect several future periods or those that materially affect the current period. ASC 250-10-50-4 and the glossary in ASC 250-10-20 provide examples of changes in estimates to be considered for disclosure, including uncollectible receivables, inventory obsolescence, service lives and salvage values of depreciable assets, and warranty obligations.
Rest of the answer

We believe that the disclosure requirements for the effect of changes in estimates on construction contracts are more specifically defined in ASC 605-35, Revenue Recognition, Construction-Type and Production-Type Contracts, which addresses revisions of contract estimates, referring to the underlying disclosure in ASC 250-10-50-4, and provides interpretive examples specific to the construction industry.

ASC 605-35 is entirely focused on the accounting considerations and disclosure requirements for individual construction contracts. We note that no reference is made to an aggregated disclosure or analysis of the effect of changes in contract estimates. ASC 605-35-25 requires the revenue measurement and recognition principles to be applied to individual profit centers. According to ASC 605-35-20, a profit center is defined as “the unit for the accumulation of revenues and costs and the measurement of income. For business entities engaged in the performance of contracts, the profit center for accounting purposes is usually a single contract.” Consistent with this definition, we have evaluated the substantial majority of our contracts to be separate profit centers with each generally possessing a unique set of facts and circumstances that must be separately considered each period when concluding on measurements of projected revenue, cost, profit and progress toward completion.

Within the context of a single contract being synonymous with the profit center at which the revenue measurement and recognition principles are to be applied, ASC 605-35-25-85 describes revisions of estimates at the individual contract level rather than groups of contracts. We note that ASC 605-35-25-86 states that revisions in estimates discussed in ASC 605-35-25-85 are changes in accounting estimates, as defined in ASC 250. Disclosure requirements for revised estimates are defined in ASC 605-35-50-9 to be limited to the effect of revisions that are material.

The implementation guidance contained in ASC 605-35-55-2 through paragraph 10 provides an example of the appropriate level of disclosure for the effects of changes in contract estimates. We note that the example refers to a company with multiple projects however the evaluation and disclosure of the change in estimate was made at the individual contract level. Paragraph 9 of this implementation guidance reaffirms that ASC 250-10-50-4 requires disclosure of the effect of significant revisions of estimates if the effect is material.

Based on the examples cited in ASC 250-10-50-4, we interpret this topic to require aggregate disclosure of the quantitative impact of a change in estimate that affects a homogeneous population (e.g. useful lives and salvage values for depreciable assets), which would provide meaningful information for investors based on the relative comparability of activities within those populations. In contrast, we believe ASC 250-10-50-4 and ASC 605-35 require material changes in contract estimates to be disclosed at the unit of account level, the individual contract, due to the unique facts and circumstances that drive changes on each contract. We believe that ASC 605-35 provides valuable interpretive guidance for the application of ASC 250-10-50-4 by companies with contracts subject to ASC 605-35. The implementation guidance referred to above illustrates that a clear, meaningful disclosure of the impact of changes in contract estimates and their potential future impact on results of operations should be made at the contract level, enabling registrants to provide project specific discussion of the factors that drove the change in estimate.

Given the frequency of changes in contract estimates, most of which are immaterial at the individual contract level, an aggregated disclosure of the impact on our results of operations or of total gross favorable and unfavorable changes in contract estimates, whether provided by contract type, by type of change in estimate, or otherwise, would inevitably lead to a summarization of facts and circumstances that we believe would overshadow a clear, meaningful disclosure of the impact of material changes in estimates on our current or future results of operations. Disclosure of material changes in estimates at the individual contract level, as illustrated in ASC 605-35-55, enables us to provide investors with a clear discussion of the circumstances leading to the material change in estimate such as the status of the project (i.e. ramp up or nearing substantial completion) as well as a more clear discussion of the potential future impact of the change on our results of operations.

We also analyzed Release 33-8350, specifically section V which considers disclosure of critical accounting estimates. We note that in preparation of the disclosures, companies should consider whether the nature of estimates or assumptions is material due to the levels of subjectivity and judgment necessary to account for highly uncertain matters or the susceptibility of such matters to change and whether the impact of the estimates on financial condition of operating performance is material. The disclosure should address factors in arriving at an estimate, how accurate the estimate has been in the past and whether the estimate is reasonably likely to change in the future. The Release provides suggestions on the overall approach to MD&A disclosures and advises that MD&A should i) be a discussion and analysis of a company’s business as seen through the eyes of those who manage the business; ii) eliminate information that does not promote understanding of a company’s results of operations; and iii) focus on materiality and known trends and uncertainties impacting future results of operations and financial condition. Finally, this section also states that companies should provide quantitative and qualitative disclosure when quantitative information is reasonably available and will provide material information for investors.

We believe that Release 33-8350 requires us to evaluate the appropriate level of disclosure based on the nature and materiality of the changes in estimate, the process by which management evaluates these changes and the ultimate insight provided to investors in the disclosure. Consistent with our analysis of ASC 250-10-50-4 above, we believe that the requirement to disclose to investors the key factors that drove the change in estimate and whether the estimate is reasonably likely to change in the future is most meaningfully provided at the individual contract level. We believe that a quantitative disclosure of total gross favorable and unfavorable changes in contract estimates would not provide meaningful insight to the impact of those changes on the current or future results of operations. To illustrate this point, please consider the following example which shows the results of a potential gross favorable and unfavorable quantitative disclosure vs. the impact on the current or future results of operations for 4 contracts that experienced changes in estimates and contract scope at different stages of progress (dollars in thousands):

Contract A

Contract B

Contract C

Contract D

Total

Before Change in Estimate

Estimated Revenue at Completion

$

500,000

Estimated Costs at Completion

(450,000

)

Estimated Profit at Completion

50,000

Costs incurred to date

135,000

315,000

382,500

427,500

Percentage Complete

%

Changes in estimated profit at completion

Decrease in est. cost for labor efficiencies

-

12,500

Deductive change in scope @ 10% profit

(7,000

Increase in est. cost for sequencing delays

( 1,500

(2,000

(3,500

Increase in est. cost of materials

(3,000

Net changes in estimates and scope

5,500

(1,000

After Change in Estimate

430,000

(451,500

(374,500

(452,000

(453,000

48,500

55,500

48,000

47,000

Impact

Current Period Profit Impact

(498

11,682

(1,881

(3,146

6,157

Future Period Profit Impact

(1,002

(6,182

(119

146

(7,157

Net Impact

(1,500

As illustrated in the example above, the relationship between the aggregate gross favorable and unfavorable changes in estimates and the aggregate impact of those changes on current and future period results is dependent upon the status of each individual contract. In the example above, we would have visibility to gross favorable and unfavorable changes in estimates of $5.5 million and $6.5 million, respectively, however the aggregate impact of the changes in estimates on current and future period results varies significantly with the stage of project completion. The only contract where the changes in estimate would potentially be considered significant to our current or future period results and disclosures is Contract B, based on the magnitude of the change and the status of the project’s percentage of completion before and after the change in estimate is recorded, yet an aggregated disclosure of gross favorable and unfavorable changes in estimates and the aggregate impact of these changes would not provide a clear and meaningful understanding of the impact of this change.

We believe the following complexities should be considered in evaluating our ability to provide accurate aggregate disclosure and how meaningful aggregate gross disclosure would be:

·

Accessibility of data – We have summarized changes in estimated profit at completion by type of change for illustrative purposes. In practice, specific changes are not separately tracked in our systems and management is only able to readily access the “net change in estimate and scope” for each contract.

Changes in contract estimates – The impact of a change in contract estimate on the period operating results is a function of the (a) magnitude of the change and (b) stage of project completion. The correlation of the gross change in estimate to the current period impact increases as the contract is more complete, as is illustrated by comparing the impact of Contract A (30% complete) and Contract D (95% complete). As a result, the disclosure of gross changes in estimate may mislead investors to conclude that the change has a greater impact on the period than is actually experienced.

Changes in contract scope - Given the nature of how construction contracts progress, we experience a significant volume of gross favorable and unfavorable changes in contract scope. The impact of these changes on the current period is a function of (a) how much progress has been previously completed on the change order and (b) whether the change impacts revenue at completion, cost at completion or both. The correlation of gross profit changes associated with contract scope and the impact on the current period increases as production of work associated with the change is more complete. In addition, contract scope changes that impact estimated costs at completion have an immediate impact on the contract percentage of completion, therefore resulting in a retrospective adjustment of earned profit in the period. For example, an increase in estimated final costs at completion that has no impact on the estimated final contract profit will generate a decrease in the contract percentage of completion, resulting in a retrospective adjustment to decrease profit recognized.

Netting changes in estimate with changes in scope - As noted above, management is only able to readily access the total contract change, which includes both changes in estimates and scope. These changes can have offsetting impacts, as illustrated in Contract B, resulting in a clear disconnect between the gross favorable change of $5.5 million and the current period impact of $11.7 million. In this case, the disclosure of gross favorable and unfavorable changes would not highlight the potentially material impact of the change in estimate on the period.

Complexity of calculation – In the illustration above, the aggregate impact of all changes in contract estimates and scope on current and future periods for all 4 contracts is $1 million. Determining the impact of these changes requires a company to track all estimates by period, which we do not currently maintain in our system. Using the information readily available to the company to estimate the impact of the change may result in inaccurate results. To illustrate this point, consider the impact of changes on Contract B. Information readily available to management includes the total change in estimate of $5.5 million and current estimated revenue at completion, cost at completion and costs incurred to date. With this limited information our best estimate of the impact of the changes for the period would be calculated by multiplying the total change in estimate of $5.5 million by the percent complete of 84%. The result of this calculation, which is $4.6 million, significantly understates the current period impact of $11.7 million.

We believe that the variable relationship between the aggregate gross favorable and unfavorable changes in estimates and the aggregate impact of those changes on current and future period results of operations would be confusing and potentially misleading to our investors. The example above demonstrates the complexity involved in aggregating this data on a small set of contracts. The volume of contracts in our backlog (over 1,000 active contracts) would significantly add to the difficultly in providing meaningful aggregated disclosure. We believe that this example illustrates that the most meaningful disclosure of the impact of changes in contract estimates, and the context for whether the estimate may change in the future, is at the individual contract level.

As discussed above, our accounting systems are not currently designed to capture and aggregate information regarding individual changes in estimates that occur within each contract. In the ordinary course of business, and at a minimum on a quarterly basis, we update projected total contract revenue, cost and profit or loss for each of our contracts based on changes in facts, such as an approved scope change, and changes in estimates. We also review current period results by contract versus historical and forecasted periods and investigate significant deviations to determine the key driver of the deviation (i.e. change in production volume vs. change in estimate). Management uses this contract specific analysis to evaluate operating results and make timely business decisions. We specifically evaluate the significant changes in estimate, over a certain dollar threshold, to determine the nature of the change and the impact on the current and future periods. This is a time consuming process that involves discussion with project management on the contract and comparison of detailed job cost reports between periods. In any given reporting period, this analysis is typically performed on less than 5% of our total active contracts. Changes on the remaining contracts are clearly immaterial and not subjected to further analysis. Providing meaningful and accurate aggregate reporting of the impact of changes in contract estimates, given our current system constraints, would require us to implement this process across each of our active contracts (over 1,000 currently) and result in substantial manual effort.

While it is possible to evaluate the impact and potential disclosure for significant changes in estimates at the individual contract level, as these are specifically reviewed by management, in order to provide an accurate and meaningful disclosure of aggregated gross favorable and unfavorable changes in estimate and the aggregate impact of those changes with reasonably available quantitative information, we would need to modify our accounting systems to specifically track and aggregate all changes in estimates on each project by the period and type of change. This would significantly impact the configuration of our accounting systems. Our systems are not currently designed to separately calculate the impact of changes in contract estimates on results of operations from period to period. The accurate accumulation of this information, including the stage of completion of each project at the time of the change in estimate, would require substantial manual effort and judgment based on our current system capabilities, as well as the implementation of new processes that will have a significant impact on our financial close and reporting cycle.

We have reviewed both the footnote and MD&A disclosures of our peers in the engineering and construction industry group and note that the majority of these registrants provide disclosure of material changes in estimate at the individual contract level but do not provide these disclosures in the aggregate or at the gross favorable and unfavorable change level. We believe that the level of disclosure made by the majority of our peers further demonstrates a consistent application of GAAP disclosure requirements and industry view that discussion of the impact of changes in estimates at the contract level provides a more meaningful disclosure than an aggregate disclosure of gross favorable and unfavorable changes in contract estimates. We also considered the questions we receive regularly from analysts and investors, including those asked during our quarterly earnings conference calls. We note that analysts and investors have never asked for an aggregated change in estimate analysis and that their questions are more frequently focused on the specific status or facts and circumstances around key projects in our backlog.

If the Staff determines that the aggregate disclosure is necessary, we respectfully request that this matter be subjected to the formal SEC rule-making process or the Financial Accounting Standards Board (“FASB”) standard-setting process to enable all registrants an opportunity to comment on the proposal, establish the appropriate internal control framework to allow for accurate reporting, and provide the disclosure at the same time.

In response to the Staff’s comment, we will continue to evaluate changes in estimates and will provide enhanced disclosure of material changes in estimates in the Critical Accounting Policies section of our MD&A, as well as in the discussion of our results of operations. To the extent that there are no material changes in contract estimates during a reporting period, we will affirmatively state this in our Critical Accounting Policies disclosures in future filings.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 11, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Results of Operations, page 39
SEC asked (2)
We note your response to our prior comment three. It is unclear to us why you believe disclosure of changes in your cost of operations would not meaningfully address the impact on your operations. Please explain further. It continues to appear to us that such disclosure is necessary to more fully understand your results.
Rest of the question

For example, an increase in labor rates per hour may have varying impacts on your overall results based on your types of contracts. Therefore, disclosure of the impact of labor rates would allow an improved understanding of your results at a more granular level.

TPC answered
We believe that disclosure of changes in our costs of operations would be duplicative in nature, which Release 33-8350 encourages companies to avoid. Specifically, Release 33-8350 instructs companies to “avoid unnecessary duplicative disclosure that can tend to overwhelm readers and act as an obstacle to identifying and understanding material matters”.
Rest of the answer

Currently, the reasons for the change in our costs of operations are covered in our discussion of revenues and operating income variances in MD&A.

Aside from changes in the volume of revenue, factors that significantly impact our results, in particular income from operations and operating margins, primarily relate to changes in the mix of work between segments (e.g. our Civil segment typically generates higher margins than our Building segment); changes in the mix of work type (e.g. shift from higher margin public work to more competitive and lower margin private work); changes in our estimated revenue and costs at completion for specific projects, which produces a retrospective true-up of operating profit in the period based on the percentage of completion at that time; and current period activity associated with pending change orders and claims, for which operating profit is not recognized. Other operating cost related factors that can have an impact on our results, typically to a much lesser extent, include a change in the absorption of general and administrative expenses, acquisition and integration related expenses. All of these changes are currently explained in our discussion of income from operations and operating margins in MD&A.

The majority of our costs of operations relate to subcontractor costs and material costs, both of which are typically fixed at the start of a construction contract. To the extent that our construction costs are not fixed, cost escalation is generally either passed onto our client, through cost reimbursable type contract arrangements or commodity price escalation provisions in the contract. When cost escalation does not contractually pass through to our clients, we specifically include anticipated cost escalation into our estimated costs at completion at the start of the contract, resulting in little to no impact on the results of operations in the period which we experience the cost escalation.

As revenues from contracts in each of our business segments are predominantly recognized using the percentage of completion method, there is a direct link between the recognition of revenue and the recognition of operating costs during the relevant reporting period. The substantial majority of variance in our costs of operations between periods is the result of changes in our volume of revenues, as illustrated in the chart below. The change in volume between periods is primarily due to the timing of award and execution of large construction contracts. The strong correlation between changes in revenue and changes in costs of operations is illustrated in the chart below, which presents our consolidated revenues and costs of operations by quarter for the past two years. Please note that the graph is presented in three dimensional format as the correlation is so strong that a simple line graph does not display both lines. A similar correlation between revenues and costs of operations is also evident at the segment level.

In evaluating whether a separate discussion of changes in our cost of operations is meaningful to investors, we considered the questions we receive from analysts and investors on a regular basis, including those asked during our quarterly earnings conference calls. We note that analyst and investor questions primarily focus on new work volume and new work margins, not on what is driving changes in our cost of operations between periods.

We will continue to evaluate changes in our cost of operations between periods in light of Release 33-8350 to determine whether the nature of changes is adequately disclosed in our discussion of changes in revenue and operating profit. If in the future there is a change in our cost of operations that is not naturally covered under the current disclosure format, we will provide the appropriate additional disclosures at that time.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 11, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 6. Goodwill and Intangible Assets, page 17
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to our prior comment six and have the following additional comments:  Please provide us with a more specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you determined the fair value of your Civil reporting unit at June 30, 2012. In this regard, please discuss the impact of contracts that have already been awarded as well as contracts that you hope to bid on in the future.
Rest of the question

Please further address the impact of cancellations and delays in your estimates as well as decreases in your backlog and new business awards. In addition, please tell us what consideration you gave to a sensitivity analysis of the significant assumptions used in developing this fair value.  Please provide us with copies of the valuation reports utilized at December 31, 2011 and June 30, 2012.  We note your statement that your implied control premium as of the fourth quarter 2011 valuation was based on low public float, low trading volume and the impact of insider trading near the valuation date that artificially created a drag on our stock price. Please tell us what consideration you gave to the impact of your results and overall market conditions on your stock price at that time.  Please further explain your belief that an inherent marketability discount embedded in your stock price is the primary reason for the continued difference between the carrying value of your equity and market capitalization. Please tell us what consideration you gave to your results and market conditions during the six months ended June 30, 2012. As appropriate, please respond to these comments within 10 business days or tell us when you will provide us with a response. Please furnish a letter that keys your responses to our comments and provides any requested supplemental information. Detailed response letters greatly facilitate our review. Please file your response letter on EDGAR. Please understand that we may have additional comments after reviewing your responses to our comments.

TPC answered
In order to determine the fair value of the Civil reporting unit as of June 30, 2012, we performed an income-based valuation approach as well as a market-based valuation approach with the assistance of external fair value specialists. The income-based valuation approach was based on the cash flows that the reporting unit expects to generate in the future. In order to estimate future cash flows we projected revenues, operating expenses, working capital investment, and capital spending for the reporting unit during a discrete period.
Rest of the answer

In addition, we calculated the weighted-average cost of capital to be used as a discount rate and a terminal value growth rate for the non-discrete period. The market-based valuation approach used to estimate the fair value of the Civil reporting unit utilized industry multiples of revenues and operating earnings. We equally weighted the fair values calculated under the income-based and market-based valuation approaches in arriving at the concluded fair values of our Civil reporting unit.

Specific and comprehensive discussion around the determination of the fair value of the Civil reporting unit as of June 30, 2012:

The valuation process began with the collection of revenue, operating expense, working capital investment, and capital spending data for a discrete three year period. The forecast was compiled by reviewing work in backlog as of the valuation date and projecting the burn of such work through completion for each active job. The expected backlog burn was determined with the input of project managers on each job and benchmarked against recent results. Next, we estimated the volume of new work that is expected to enter into backlog, the timing of when such work is expected to begin, and the expected rate of production for the new work. We evaluated the reasonableness of the projections for the Civil reporting unit, for both existing and expected future contracts, by benchmarking against historical results, including volume, gross margin percentage, pre-tax income percentage, production rates by quarter, and against data specific to the Civil construction market.

The discrete projections were provided to our external fair value specialists who in turn helped develop an income-based approach valuation model to determine an expected fair value. The income-based valuation approach begins with the conversion of the projected results into expected cash flows over a discrete projection period. The estimated cash flows for each of the years in the discrete projection period are then converted to their present value equivalent using a discount rate appropriate for the risk of achieving the projected cash flows. The present value of the estimated cash flows are then added to the present value equivalent of the residual value of the Civil reporting unit at the end of the discrete projection period to arrive at an estimate of fair value. The discount rate utilized in the June 30, 2012 valuation was based on the weighted average cost of capital (“WACC”) which is derived using general market inputs, competitor data, adjustments for the size of the reporting unit, and non-systemic risk. The concluded discount rate was consistent with those used in prior valuations and in line with standard valuation practices.

The second step to determining the fair value of the Civil reporting unit as of June 30, 2012 was performing an independent market-based valuation. The market-based valuation technique provides an estimation of fair value for the company based on observed market prices for similar businesses. Under the market-based valuation method the Civil reporting unit was valued by comparing it to publicly traded firms in similar lines of business. In determining the comparability of publicly traded companies, several factors were analyzed, including, markets, growth patterns, relative size, earnings trends and risk characteristics.

In order to determine the market-based valuation of the Civil reporting unit, we provided the external fair value specialist a list of competitors and comparable companies all of which are actively traded public companies. From this listing our specialist utilized externally published data to determine the presumed value of the comparable entities compared to expected fiscal year 2012 revenues and earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization (“EBITDA”). This developed a range of “multiples” observable in the market space that we operate in and allowed us to determine an expected fair value independent of the income-based approach. We utilized our projected fiscal year 2012 results multiplied against the multiples observed in the market place within our peer group to determine our Civil reporting unit valuation. In doing so, the concluded market-based value was within 5% of our concluded income-based value.

Discuss the impact of contracts already awarded and work to be bid on in the future:

Our analyses of projected results specifically considered work in backlog as of the valuation date and new work we expect to bid on in the future. The projected production of contracts in backlog was prepared with input from project management on each existing job by utilizing the estimated costs to complete and forecasted contract value, and by incorporating the most recent construction schedule benchmarked against a typical construction curve to refine our estimate of the timing of production. The projected results for the completion of our backlog were compared to actual results for recent periods and forecasts used in prior valuations to assess for reasonableness.

With the assistance of segment leadership, we developed expectations for future work by reviewing current bids and prospective projects. In developing our new work estimate, we specifically considered our relationship with the prospective client, political or legal circumstances that may impact the prospective project award, financing constraints for the project and our historical success in acquiring similar contracts we have bid on in the past. Once compiled, we compared the percentage of new work revenue needed to achieve the projected results for each discrete year of the forecast to actual results from prior years and against previous period forecasts to assess the level of inherent risks of achieving the forecasted results. In addition, we benchmarked our expected annual revenue growth rates against published third party industry growth expectations specific to the Civil construction market, and growth rate expectations for our competitors, to the extent available. We also calculated the compounded annual growth rate of our revenue projections through fiscal year 2017 and compared them against the industry publications and competitor data noted above. To the extent our expected future results deviated from industry expectations, additional analyses were performed to understand the variance and the projections were adjusted as appropriate. Projections used in our valuation were in line with external industry expectations.

Address the impact of cancellations and delays in your estimates as well as decreases in your backlog and new business awards:

As discussed above, we performed extensive analyses testing projected results, many of which were focused on assessing the risk of achieving our expectations in light of potential delays and cancellations. To this regard, growth in expected production on existing work and additions of new work were challenged through multiple benchmarking exercises and a review of verifiable evidence supporting management’s assumptions such as letters of intent, identification as low bidders on an open bid, shortlist approvals, and outstanding bids. Our projections were adjusted to reflect the observed industry trends relating to delays in timing and potential future cancellations.

As part of the income-based valuation approach, a present value factor is applied to the cash flows in order to determine the present value of the free cash flow. The present value factor is a derivative of the WACC adjusted for the expected cash flow period. When determining the present value factor for the June 30, 2012 valuation, we allowed for approximately 3 months of slippage in the timing of expected cash flows. This factor was determined by comparing the timing of expected cash flows from previous projections to actual results in subsequent periods, as we have experienced recent delays in the rate of production on certain work in backlog as well as start dates for new work due to political pressures, timing of funding, and general economic concerns.

Consideration given to a sensitivity analysis of the significant assumptions used in developing the fair value of the Civil reporting unit:

As part of our review process for the Civil reporting unit valuation, we created multiple income-based and market-based valuation models to understand the sensitivity of the variables used in determining the fair value. These models were reviewed with our external fair value specialists who assisted in the process by providing insight into acceptable ranges on various valuation assumptions as well as preferred valuation techniques. Similar to previous valuations, we noted that small changes to valuation assumptions could have a significant impact on the concluded value; however, we gained comfort over the assumptions selected for our valuation through comparison to historical transaction benchmarks, third party industry expectations, and our previous models.

Please provide us with copies of the valuation reports utilized at December 31, 2011 and June 30, 2012.

Response:

We are providing a copy of the requested valuation reports utilized at December 31, 2011 and June 30, 2012 under a separate cover via hand delivery. This information is submitted in paper pursuant to Rule 101(c)(2) of Regulation S-T. We request that these reports be returned to the undersigned after the Staff review is completed.

We note your statement that your implied control premium as of the fourth quarter 2011 valuation was based on low public float, low trading volume and the impact of insider trading near the valuation date that artificially created a drag on our stock price. Please tell us what consideration you gave to the impact of your results and overall market conditions on your stock price at that time.

Response:

One primary difference between the market capitalization of any publicly traded company, such as Tutor Perini, and the fair value of the equity of that entity is the fact that the market capitalization reflects trading prices on a minority interest basis and the fair value of equity is on a controlling interest basis. The difference commonly referred to as the control premium can be impacted by the various explicit and implicit factors common to a publicly traded company. Our operating results and overall market conditions have a significant impact on our stock price and resulting control premium. With the assistance of our external fair value specialists, we conducted research surrounding control premiums paid in the construction and engineering industry over the past seven years to determine whether our implied control premium was within the industry range of control premiums paid and how close our implied control premium was to the industry average control premium paid.

In the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2011, we determined that our implied control premium of 78.1% was within the range of control premiums paid in the construction and engineering industry during the past seven years; however, our implied control premium exceeded the industry average control premium paid of 59.1% by 19%. In order to understand this difference, we first compared our stock price to the stock prices of our peer group from the beginning of fiscal year 2011 up to the date of our valuation to identify whether there were observable trends in the market. A downward trend in stock prices on an average of approximately 36% was observed within our peer group, compared to our change of approximately 53.5% for the same period as illustrated in the graph below. We attributed the downward cycle trend to general market conditions as well to the concerns about the economic and political pressures facing the construction and engineering industry as a whole, an observation that we believe impacted our stock price consistent with our peers. Additional analysis was performed around the 17.5% difference between us and our peers including the release of our recent results and the revision of our forward looking results at or around the valuation date, a factor that we believe negatively impacted our stock price during that time. We also determined it necessary to consider other factors that may have an impact on our stock price in conjunction with our evaluation of the control premium. We researched differences between our company and the others within our peer group to further understand factors that may have an impact on our control premium. The largest observable differences were the impact of insider sales, low public float, and low trading volume.

The impact of insider sales on the stock price has been a specific topic of discussion with investors since the second quarter of fiscal year 2011. In June 2011 the Company held a special call with analysts and investors to specifically address recent and anticipated future insider sales activity. We continue to receive regular inquiries as to whether and to what extent we expect additional insider sales activity.

The “Insider Sales” activity, including press around the need for insider sales, amendment of Tutor Perini’s Shareholder’s agreement, and the ultimate insider sales of shares through several transactions from May 16, 2011 to the valuation date, is illustrated in the graph below.

Based on a comparison of our share price to comparable company share prices, it appears that our stock price has traded at an unusually depressed price compared to our competitors. Within the last six months prior to the valuation date, we, as well as some of our competitors, had revised 2011 earnings guidance. These downward revisions negatively impacted their respective share prices. Given the analysis of trailing share prices, however, it appears that the market has also negatively reacted to our insider sales activity, which has been exacerbated by low public float and low trading volume.

As discussed previously, our stock price has long experienced the impacts of low public float in comparison to our peers. As of the valuation date, our public float was approximately 65.4% compared to a range between 97.5% and 99.5% for our peers. As a result, investors in our stock are faced with a lower supply of stock available to be traded, thereby limiting the trading volume and liquidity of our stock as compared to our peers.

In addition to having a low float percentage, the average daily volume of our stock has been very low, averaging 0.7% for the past two years as compared to the trading volume of the stock of our publicly traded peers currently ranging from 1.2% to 1.4%. The trading volume of these companies has consistently been approximately two times our volume over the past two years. Low volume combined with low float implies that our stock is not very liquid as compared to the stock of our peers.

Based on the analyses above, we concluded that, while our stock price was impacted by overall market conditions and release of our operating results, the difference between our implied control premium and the observed market average premium was appropriate and supportable, given the pressure of insider sales, low public float and low trading volume, and within range of the transactions observed in the market place.

Please further explain your belief that an inherent marketability discount embedded in your stock price is the primary reason for the continued difference between the carrying value of your equity and market capitalization. Please tell us what consideration you gave to your results and market conditions during the six months ended June 30, 2012.

Response:

As of June 30, 2012 and prior to the recorded impairment, we noted that the ongoing difference between the book value of our equity and the market capitalization had reached excessive levels. As part of the valuation process we discussed this gap in values and examined the reasons for such a material difference. Through the accumulation of projections supporting the valuation process we observed that our future cash flows had deteriorated from previous valuations as a result of discrete events observed in fiscal year 2012 and the continued impact of depressed market conditions. As a result of this observation, we recorded a non-cash impairment charge reducing the carrying values of certain definite lived intangible assets and indefinite lived intangible assets including goodwill, reducing the carrying value to a level supported by our fair value determination.

In order to understand the remaining difference between our market capitalization and the carrying value of our equity, we first compared our stock price to those in our peer group from the beginning of the second quarter of fiscal year 2011 up to June 30, 2012, noting a continued downward trend in stock prices within our peer group of approximately 20% on average, compared to our decrease of 48.7% for the same period. We maintain that the overall downturn continues to be a function of general market conditions and pressures surrounding the construction and engineering industry as a whole, a factor that we believe impacts our stock price consistent with our peers. Further, we believe the negative impact of our results and the revision of our forward looking results were reflected in the impairment charge taken as of June 30, 2012. Additional analysis was performed around the 28.7% difference between our decline and the decline of our peers. We specifically focused on other facts and circumstances that impact our stock price which are not present at other companies within our peer group. Consistent with prior periods, we noted the largest difference continued to be the negative impacts that insider sales, low public float, and low trading volume has on our stock price.

To understand the factors we believe negatively impact our stock price, we compared our observable metrics to other engineering and construction companies. As of June 30, 2012, our Chairman and CEO owned approximately 20.6% of our outstanding stock, resulting in a public float of approximately 76.5% compared to a range between 97.5% and 99.5% for comparable companies. Further, the average daily trading volume of our stock continued to be approximately 50% less than that of our publicly traded peers. Lastly, the impact of insider sales on the stock price continues to draw inquiries from investors and analysts. While the volume of insider sales activity has dropped during the six months ended June 30, 2012, we believe there continues to be an impact on our stock price due to the uncertainty around potential future insider sales. We believe these three factors continue to depress our stock price and its perceived liquidity as compared to our publicly traded peer group.

To determine whether our fair value was appropriate as of June 30, 2012, we benchmarked our valuation and implied control premium of 42.5% against the historical average control premium observed in the construction and engineering industry of 59.1% as well as recent transactions in the industry most notably Chicago Bridge and Iron Company’s (“CB&I”) ongoing purchase of Shaw Group (“Shaw) and URS Corporation’s acquisition of Flint Energy Services (“Flint”). In reviewing these transactions, we noted that CB&I will likely pay a premium of approximately 72% over Shaw’s closing share price prior to the deal announcement and that URS paid a 68% premium to the closing price of Flint shares on the day prior to the announcement. In analyzing the historical averages and the recent deal metrics, it was determined that our implied control premium was in line with observable market data.

After considering observable market metrics, including recent transactions, we concluded that the fair value was supportable and appropriately considers recent results and market conditions, the book value reflects adjustments based on the current fair value of the reporting units and our market capitalization continues to reflect the impact of insider sales, low public float and low trading volume.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 11, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of · Operations, page 32
SEC asked
We have reviewed your response to our prior comment one. While we note it is currently not practicable for you to obtain information regarding the gross favorable and unfavorable adjustments to your contract estimates, we continue to believe that your MD&A should more fully address how changes in your contracts, including changes in estimates and changes in scope, impact your results.
Rest of the question

Therefore, please ensure future annual and quarterly filings include a more specific and comprehensive discussion of the underlying nature of changes in your contracts and include quantified information where available. * * * * As appropriate, please respond to these comments within 10 business days or tell us when you will provide us with a response. Please furnish a letter that keys your responses to our comments and provides any requested supplemental information. Detailed response letters greatly facilitate our review. Please file your response letter on EDGAR. Please understand that we may have additional comments after reviewing your responses to our comments.

TPC answered
The Company will ensure future annual and quarterly filings include a more specific and comprehensive discussion of the underlying nature of changes in our contracts and include quantified information where available.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 5, 2012: 10-K filed Feb 25, 2013 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: request for more time, Oct 3, 2012, closing letter, 2012-12-10

Form S-4

2011-04-07 to 2011-04-27 · 6 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
No closing letter
Legal and contingencies
SEC letter of Apr 7, 2011 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
General · Supplemental Letter
SEC asked (1)
We note that you are registering the notes in reliance on our position enunciated in Exxon Capital Holdings Corp., SEC No-Action Letter (April 13, 1988). See also Morgan Stanley & Co. Inc., SEC No-Action Letter (June 5, 1991) and Shearman & Sterling, SEC No-Action Letter (July 2, 1993).
Rest of the question

Accordingly, with the next amendment, please provide us with a supplemental letter stating that you are registering the exchange offer in reliance on our position contained in these letters and include the representations contained in the Morgan Stanley and Shearman & Sterling no-action letters.

TPC answered

No reply letter found.

General · Supplemental Letter
SEC asked (2)
Please note that you will need to file counsel’s legal opinion before you can request the acceleration of the effective date of your registration statement. Please allow sufficient time for staff review of the opinion and note that we may have comments on the opinion.
TPC answered

No reply letter found.

Cautionary Disclosure Regarding Forward – Looking Statements, page iii · Forward-Looking Statements
SEC asked (3)
The safe harbor for forward-looking statements provided in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 does not apply to statements made in connection with a tender offer. See Section 27A (b)(2)(C) of the Securities Act and Section 21E(b)(2)(C) of the Exchange Act.
Rest of the question

Therefore, please delete the reference to the safe harbor or state explicitly that the safe harbor protections it provides do not apply to statements made in connection with the offer.

TPC answered

No reply letter found.

Incorporation of certain information by reference, page 74
SEC asked (4)
We note that you incorporation your 2010 Form 10-K by reference, but that you have not yet filed your proxy material from which Part III information in the Form 10-K is incorporated by reference. Please note that you may not request acceleration of the registration statement until you file your proxy materials or an amendment to your Form 10-K to include this Part III information.
Rest of the question

Please see paragraph 123.01 of the Securities Act Forms C&DIs, available on our website.

TPC answered

No reply letter found.

Item 22 Undertakings, page II-13
SEC asked (5)
Please revise your undertakings to include the undertaking required by Item 512(b) of Regulation S-K, as it appears to apply to your transaction.
TPC answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.1 – Opinion of Kirkland & Ellis
SEC asked
We note the assumption in the penultimate paragraph of the opinion letter. Please revise this assumption to clarify that it relates only to agreements and instruments which are not filed as exhibits to the company’s filings with the Commission.
TPC answered
The Company has refiled Exhibit 5.1 and the assumption has been deleted.

We hope that the foregoing has been responsive to the Staff’s comment.
Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Apr 27, 2011

Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2009

2010-07-06 to 2010-10-28 · 14 questions · 4 letters from the SEC, 4 from the company
Review closed 2010-10-28
Goodwill and impairmentCritical estimatesSegmentsRevenueLiquidity and cashAcquisitionsResults discussion (MD&A)Executive payLeasesDebt
Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked (1)
Please address the following items related to your change in reporting units. Reference ASC 350-20. • Please provide us with a specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you initially allocated your goodwill to reporting units following your merger with Tutor- Saliba.
Rest of the question

In this regard, we note your disclosure on page 75 of your Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2008 that one of the reasons for the acquisition was Tutor-Saliba’s expertise in civil projects. Therefore, it is unclear to us why you initially did not allocate more goodwill to your Civil reporting segment. • Please provide us with a specific and comprehensive discussion regarding the nature of the reorganization you completed during 2009. In this regard, please tell us if there were any changes in your reporting structure. Please also discuss how you determined that greater operating efficiencies could be achieved. • Please provide us with a detailed listing of your reporting units and the goodwill assigned to each unit upon completion of your merger with Tutor-Saliba, at December 31, 2008 and at December 31, 2009. • Please tell us if and how there would be any changes to the impairment charge you recognized during fiscal 2008 had the analysis been performed using the reporting units that existed after your 2009 reorganization.

TPC answered
The merger of Perini and Tutor-Saliba closed in September 2008. The primary strategic reasons for the merger, as indicated on page 1 of our 2008 proxy filed on August 6, 2008, include the following:

Increased scale and greater diversification of our business

Entry into additional high-growth and high-margin markets and projects

Consolidation of Ronald N.
Rest of the answer

Tutor’s, our chief executive officer and chairman, management activities on the growth and development of the combined company, and elimination of risk that he might leave Perini to focus on Tutor-Saliba

Additional management depth and enhanced management capabilities

Enhanced commercial building and civil business operations, due to the complementary and synergistic strengths of the two companies in these market segments

Greater opportunities to win new, substantial contracts to drive accelerated revenue growth

Ability to use the strength of Perini’s balance sheet to win additional large civil and public works projects that require surety capacity in excess of what Tutor-Saliba was able to obtain

Opportunities to realize significant synergies

In September 2008, we evaluated the operations of Tutor-Saliba and concluded there to be three operating segments, each of which we determined to be a reporting unit. Tutor-Saliba reporting units consisted of Tutor-Saliba Building (“TSC Building”), Tutor-Saliba Civil (“TSC Civil”) and Black Construction (Tutor-Saliba’s international operations). At the time of the merger, Tutor-Saliba had identified significant new work opportunities in its TSC Building reporting unit, including new work opportunities in Dubai and letters of intent on other significant private, non-residential building opportunities. Conversely, at the time of the merger the Company did not have the same level of pre-identified new work opportunities at TSC Civil, which was primarily focused on work in California at that time, and visibility into future opportunities was limited. At the time of the merger, the Company was not predicting the melt-down in financial markets, which ultimately sparked a deterioration in the private, non-residential building market. The level of TSC Building backlog was approximately five times larger than the backlog at TSC Civil at the time of the merger.

The purchase price allocation, including allocation of goodwill between reporting units, was made based on Tutor-Saliba’s operating structure at the time of the merger and the relative fair value of each reporting unit, summarized above. We utilized a third party specialist in our determination of the fair value of each reporting unit and considered three separate valuation methodologies, including the income approach, based on the Company’s estimate of future cash flows by reporting unit, the market approach, based on a peer group of publically traded companies, and the cost approach. The estimated fair value of each reporting unit was ultimately calculated under the income approach, utilizing a discounted cash flow, and corroborated by the estimated fair value calculated under the market approach. The purchase price for each reporting unit was allocated to tangible and identifiable intangible assets, based on their fair value, and the excess purchase price was determined to be goodwill. The resulting allocation of goodwill between reporting units was weighted more heavily to TSC Building than TSC Civil based on our assessment of their relative fair values at the time of the merger.

Please provide us with a specific and comprehensive discussion regarding the nature of the reorganization you completed during 2009. In this regard, please tell us if there were any changes in your reporting structure. Please also discuss how you determined that greater operating efficiencies could be achieved.

Response:

The 2009 reorganization, which was initiated in the first quarter of 2009 and finalized in the fourth quarter of 2009, was designed to allow the Company to best respond over the long-term to a dynamic economic climate. Benefits realized as a result of the reorganization include an improved ability to leverage the unique capabilities of each business unit, an increased level of resource sharing across business units and geographies, an increased emphasis on work performed for public agencies (building and civil), an increase in common operating procedures and a decrease in overhead due to centralization of certain functions. Through this reorganization the Company has achieved a single company operating mentality in which specialized resources are readily deployed across all markets served, allowing the Company to readily adapt to market changes, increasing our operating efficiencies and taking full advantage of the public works expertise acquired through the Tutor-Saliba merger.

The reorganized company is structured around the following three operating segments (collectively “Groups”), each of which is focused on different customers and types of construction.

Building Group – Focused on constructing buildings for public agencies and private industry customers across a diverse array of end markets (i.e. hospitality & gaming, healthcare, municipal offices, sports & entertainment, education, transportation terminals, corrections, etc.).

Civil Group – Focused on constructing infrastructure for public agencies (i.e. highways, bridges, mass transit, energy, water treatment, etc.).

Management Services Group – Focused on diversified construction and design-build services to the U.S. military and other federal government agencies.

Each of the operating segments has a group manager (“Group CEO”) who is directly accountable to the Company’s Chairman and CEO, who is the Chief Operating Decision Maker (“CODM”). Group CEOs were appointed on March 23, 2009. Components of each operating segment consist of separately managed business units (“BU”). BU Presidents report directly to the Group CEOs. Group CEOs meet regularly with BU Presidents to review operating performance as well as new work opportunities. When evaluating new work opportunities within each Group, the Group CEO makes the final determination on which BU will bid the job (or joint venture between BUs) and what resources need to be allocated between BUs in order to bid and perform the work. This is a significant change from historical practice, where each of the BU Presidents had reported directly to the CODM and BUs would independently bid work, rarely sharing resources (except through a joint venture arrangement). The establishment of Group leadership has facilitated teamwork across BU lines and we expect it will ultimately result in additional work for the Groups.

In connection with the reorganization we made a strategic decision to increase our emphasis on civil operations, which we believe will maximize the Company’s long term growth. Given the opportunities in the civil infrastructure arena, fueled in part by federal government stimulus funding, it was determined that our Tutor-Saliba subsidiary would focus completely on Civil Group work going forward. Tutor-Saliba personnel that have specific expertise relevant to the Building Group, including project managers, risk management, estimators, project labor and administrative support, have either transferred to one of the Company’s remaining Building Group BUs or been designated to support public works building opportunities nationally. TSC Building backlog, operating segment components and equipment have also been subsumed into the Building Group.

Group level leadership has enabled us to leverage the unique strengths of each BU within its group and streamline elements of our operations, including our business development, estimating and job cost management. The impact of this reorganization has been extremely positive, evidenced in part by a 90% increase in Civil Group backlog during 2009 and the award of several large public works building jobs in the Building Group. At the same time, our improved ability to share resources across BUs and geographies and the increase in common operating procedures, some of which have been centralized, has allowed us to reduce our overhead and improve operating efficiencies on existing and future projects.

The 2009 reorganization resulted in a reduction in the number of operating segments and reporting units for the Company from eleven to three. The change in reporting structure includes dissolution of the legacy TSC Building reporting unit and aggregation of certain operating segment components. We considered ASC 350-20-55-6 and 55-7 in evaluation of operating segment components for aggregation, noting similar economic characteristics among aggregated operating segment components, including the nature of products and services provided, types of customer, regulatory environment, manner of operations and operating margins. See summary below:

We noted the following changes to the composition of legacy reporting units as a result of the 2009 reorganization.

Pre-Reorganization

Post-Reorganization

Perini Building Company

PBC East was managed as a separate

BU and evaluated to be a separate reporting unit.

PBC East management has been terminated or transferred to other BUs. All management functions, including accounting and reporting, have been assumed by PBC West. PBC is now managed as one BU.

TSC Building

TSC Building was managed as a separate BU and evaluated to be a separate reporting unit. Operational focus was primarily on general contracting services for large building projects for both private owners and public agencies. A small portion of the business focused on subcontracted mechanical services through the DPH and PowerCo subsidiaries.

TSC Building no longer has a BU President and does not operate as a stand-alone BU. Revenue generating resources have been reallocated, primarily to the Civil Group, in accordance with our long-term strategic focus. Legacy TSC Building resources remaining in the Building Group include DPH, PowerCo and a remnant of legacy TSC Building employees who have assumed a Building Group support function, focused on assisting public works building bids at other Building Group BUs.

Civil Group

TSC Civil, Perini Civil and CHC have historically operated as three separate BUs.

The Civil Group is now managed as a single BU, sharing resources seamlessly. Centralized functions result in certain BU within the group bearing costs for the entire Civil Group (i.e. estimating, procurement, etc.). Post-reorganization, the Civil Group has experienced an influx of resources from TSC Building (personnel and equipment). These resources have enabled the Civil Group to pursue and win significant new work opportunities.

As a result of this reorganization, the composition of the legacy reporting units has changed as it relates to assets, liabilities and other revenue producing resources such as key personnel (which has a direct correlation to new work and future cash flow streams).

Please provide us with a detailed listing of your reporting units and the goodwill assigned to each unit upon completion of your merger with Tutor-Saliba, at December 31, 2008 and at December 31, 2009.

Response:

As of December 31, 2008 and 2009, the Company had $588.1 and $602.5 million of goodwill recorded, respectively, including $14.4 million associated with the 2009 acquisition of Keating Building Company. The change in reporting structure and composition of certain reporting units as a result of the 2009 reorganization required the reallocation of goodwill and certain indefinite lived intangible assets and deferred tax liabilities between impacted reporting units. Reallocation of goodwill was based on the relative fair value of legacy reporting unit components, determined with the assistance of a third party specialist in accordance with ASC 350-20-35-45, and distributed to new reporting units as of the date the reorganization was completed. See summary below (in thousands):

Please tell us if and how there would be any changes to the impairment charge you recognized during fiscal 2008 had the analysis been performed using the reporting units that existed after your 2009 reorganization.

Response:

Subsequent to closing the merger with Tutor-Saliba, the financial markets collapsed, significantly impacting the Company’s new work prospects in the building segment, including certain new work opportunities identified in TSC Building at the time of the merger. We deemed these events to be an impairment indicator, which triggered an evaluation and ultimately an impairment charge of $224.5 million ($166.9 million of goodwill, $56.9 million of trade name and $0.7 million of contractor license). Estimated future cash flows used for purposes of this impairment charge were based on the operating structure in place at the time of the assessment, consisting of eleven reporting units.

The 2009 reorganization resulted in a reduction in the number of reporting units for the Company from eleven to three. As summarized above, the change in reporting structure included the aggregation of certain operating segment components which were previously reporting units as well as dissolution of the legacy TSC Building reporting unit. If the goodwill impairment analysis had been performed using the post-reorganization reporting units, we estimate that excess fair value of certain operating segment components would offset the deficiencies in fair value for the remaining operating segment components aggregated into post-reorganization reporting units, resulting in no assessed impairment of goodwill. We are unable to quantify the impact of the reorganization on the valuation of trade name and contractor license as of the testing date; however due to the positive impact the reorganization has had on current and expected future cash flows, we believe there would have been less assessed impairment of these intangible assets.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked (2)
We note that your market capitalization is significantly below your book value. With a view towards future disclosure, please provide us with a specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you have considered this in your impairment analysis.
TPC answered
Historically, the market capitalization of the Company has served as a reasonable proxy for its fair value. Given the recent decline in our stock price, which management attributes primarily to the limited trading activity of our common stock and the current economic recessionary environment, the market capitalization is less than the stockholders’ equity of the Company as reflected in our consolidated balance sheet.
Rest of the answer

As a result, the Company’s 2009 annual impairment analysis determined the fair value of the Company and each of its reporting units, utilizing third party specialists, based on a weighting of market-based and income-based valuation approaches. In conjunction with this analysis, we reconciled the assessed fair value of the Company to its market capitalization and concluded that the implied control premium associated with the fair value estimate was reasonable based in part on current comparable market data. In addition, in conjunction with our impairment analysis, we performed sensitivity analysis around our fair value estimate, noting that in all cases fair value exceeded the book value of the Company.

On a quarterly basis the Company considers whether events or changes in circumstances indicate that assets, including goodwill and other intangible assets not subject to amortization, might be impaired. In conjunction with this analysis, we evaluate whether our current market capitalization, if less than our stockholders’ equity, is an impairment indicator warranting further evaluation. We specifically consider the following factors in this evaluation:

Duration and severity of a decline in market capitalization

Reconciliation of the implied control premium to the current market control premium

Actual operating results compared to forecasted results used in the most recent annual impairment assessment in determining the fair value of the Company and its reporting units

Current target share price assessments by third party analysts who follow the Company

In future filings, when the Company’s market capitalization is significantly below its book value, we will provide additional disclosure of how we considered current market conditions in our impairment analysis.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked (3)
Please revise future filings to include a more specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you consider current events and circumstances in determining whether it is necessary to test your goodwill and intangible assets for recoverability. If an analysis is conducted in a given period, please include a specific and comprehensive discussion regarding the results of that analysis.
Rest of the question

In addition, please provide us with a specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you have considered decreases in your backlog during fiscal 2009 and the first quarter of fiscal 2010 as well as decreases in your revenues during the fourth quarter of fiscal 2009 and the first quarter of fiscal 2010 in your impairment analysis. In this regard, please specifically discuss what consideration you gave to whether the decreases in the first quarter of fiscal 2010 constituted a triggering event requiring further testing.

TPC answered
On a quarterly basis the Company considers whether events or changes in circumstances indicate that assets, including goodwill and other intangible assets not subject to amortization, might be impaired. In conjunction with this analysis, we evaluate whether our current market capitalization, if less than our stockholders’ equity, is an impairment indicator warranting further evaluation, as discussed in response to comment #2 above.

We have also considered the recent decline in our backlog and the decline in our quarterly revenues between the fourth quarter of 2009 and first quarter of 2010.
Rest of the answer

As indicated on page 22 of our Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31, 2010 filed with the SEC on May 10, 2010, the recent decline in revenues and backlog is primarily due to the completion of Project CityCenter, a $6.2 billion contract that was completed in December 2009. The completion of this contract, and associated decline in backlog and quarterly revenues to a more normalized level, was anticipated and factored into our assessment of the fair value of the Company during our annual impairment analysis in 2009 and 2008. In our first quarter 2010 assessment of potential impairment indicators, we noted that the Company’s operating results and backlog were in line with the forecast we used in our most recent annual impairment assessment.

In future filings we will evaluate the need for further disclosures around our consideration of current events and circumstances in determining whether it is necessary to test goodwill and intangible assets for recoverability.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked (4)
To the extent that any of your reporting units have estimated fair values that are not substantially in excess of their carrying values and goodwill for such reporting units, in the aggregate or individually, if impaired, could materially impact your results or total shareholders’ equity, please identify and provide the following disclosures for each such reporting unit in future filings: • The percentage by which
Rest of the question

fair value exceeds carrying value as of the most-recent stepone test. • The amount of goodwill allocated to the unit. • A description of the material assumptions that drive estimated fair value. • A discussion of any uncertainties associated with each key assumption. • A discussion of any potential events, trends and/or circumstances that could have a negative effect on estimated fair value. If you have determined that estimated fair values substantially exceed the carrying values of your reporting units, please disclose that determination in future filings. Reference Item 303 of Regulation S-K. Please provide us with a specific and comprehensive discussion regarding your analysis of these items for the periods ended December 31, 2009, March 31, 2010 and June 30, 2010.

TPC answered
As of the valuation date for our most recent step-one impairment analysis, performed during the fourth quarter of 2009, the fair value of each of the Company’s reporting units exceeded the carrying value by more than 40%. We have updated our assessment of the fair value of each reporting unit at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2010, noting that actual cash flows were in line with those used in our annual impairment assessment and that there were no significant changes in trends or any other material assumption used.
Rest of the answer

As of each of these dates, we have concluded that the estimated fair value substantially exceeded the carrying value of each reporting unit. We are currently updating our assessment as of June 30, 2010 and will provide appropriate disclosure in our 10-Q filing for the quarter ended June 30, 2010.

In future filings we will evaluate the need for further disclosure of our assessment of the relationship between the fair value and the carrying value of our reporting units and, if necessary, provide additional disclosure of material assumptions and potential events, trends or circumstances that may have an impact on our estimate of fair value. If we determine that the estimated fair value of each reporting unit substantially exceeds the carrying value, we will disclose that determination.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Exhibits 31.1 and 31.2
SEC asked (5)
Please amend your Form 10-K to file as exhibits corrected copies of the certifications required by Rules 13a-14(a) and 15d-14(a) of the Exchange Act. As currently filed, paragraph 1 refers to “this quarterly report on Form 10-K” and should be revised to refer to your “annual report on Form 10-K”.
TPC answered
The Company will amend the certifications required to be filed as exhibits to its Form 10-K, in accordance with Rules 13a-14(a) and 15d-14(a), such that paragraph 1 will read “annual report on Form 10-K” and will file the corrected, executed certifications as exhibits to a Form 10-K/A that the Company will file with the Securities and Exchange Commission as soon as practicable. The Company is currently in the process of obtaining an updated consent from its auditor and completing work related to that consent process.
Rest of the answer

The Company expects to be able to file the Form 10-K/A in conjunction with the filing of our Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended June 30, 2010.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Definitive Proxy Material on Schedule 14A
SEC asked (6)
We note you have not included any disclosure in response to 402(s) of Regulation S-K. Please advise us of the basis for your conclusion that disclosure is not necessary and describe the process you undertook to reach that conclusion.
TPC answered
In evaluating our disclosure requirements under section 402(s) of Regulation S-K, we considered the nature and administration of each of the Company’s compensation programs to determine whether any risks exist that are reasonably likely to have a material adverse effect on the Company. Compensation programs utilized by the Company, which are periodically reviewed by third party compensation consultants and evaluated using a market comparison with our peer group, include the following:

Short-term Compensation Programs

Base salaries – Payments of base salary, which are based on a fixed hourly
Rest of the answer

rate or a fixed annualized salary, are paid for current performance received by the Company. Base salaries are set based on current market rates and none of the employees have an employment agreement fixing their base salary, with the exception of Mr. Tutor (see summary on page 23 of our 2010 proxy, filed on April 28, 2010).

Corporate incentives – Payments of corporate incentives are made in cash and are variable based on the performance of the Company. In order for corporate employees to be eligible to receive an incentive, a minimum level of pre-tax income, which is established in the first quarter of each fiscal year by the Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors, must have been achieved by the Company.

Business unit incentives – Payments of business unit incentives are made in cash and are variable based on the performance of each business unit. In order for business unit employees to be eligible to receive an incentive, a minimum level of pre-tax income, which is established in the first quarter of each fiscal year by senior management of the Company, must have been achieved by the business unit. Business unit employees are not eligible to receive an incentive unless a minimum level of pre-tax income, which is established in the first quarter of each fiscal year by the Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors, is also achieved by the total Company.

Project incentives – Payments of project incentives are made in cash and are variable based on the performance of each project. In order to be eligible to receive a project incentive, a minimum level of pre-tax income must be achieved by the project, which is established prior to the start of the project.

Long-term Compensation Programs

Restricted stock units – Grants of restricted stock units are made from time to time upon approval by the Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors. Substantially all of the restricted stock grants awarded vest over a period of five years subject to achievement of a minimum level of predetermined pre-tax income performance targets by the Company or one of its reporting segments.

Stock options - Grants of stock options are made from time to time upon approval by the Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors. Substantially all of the stock options awarded vest over a period of five years subject to achievement of a minimum level of predetermined pre-tax income performance targets by the Company or one of its reporting segments.

Each of the Company’s compensation programs summarized above links compensation with employee or Company performance during the period in which the compensation is paid. The Company’s approach to compensation is a balance between base salaries and performance based incentive compensation. The Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors has direct oversight of our performance based compensation programs for senior management and is involved in approving senior management participants, setting pre-tax income targets, evaluating achievement of pre-tax income targets based on our audited financial statements, and approving payouts. Senior management has direct oversight of our performance based compensation programs for all other employees and is involved in approving all other participants, setting pre-tax income targets, evaluating achievement of pre-tax income targets based on our audited financial statements, and approving payouts for all other participants. None of the Company’s compensation programs fix future payments through employment agreements, with the exception of Mr. Tutor’s compensation (see summary on page 23 of our 2010 proxy, filed on April 28, 2010). Based on our evaluation of the nature and administration of our compensation programs, we determined that disclosure in response to 402(s) of Regulation S-K was not required for the 2010 Proxy Statement as none of these programs are reasonably likely to have a material adverse effect on the Company.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Definitive Proxy Material on Schedule 14A
SEC asked (7)
We note that you have historically aimed to have the target annual cash and stock based compensation for your named executive officers fall within the 50th to 75th percentile for comparable executives of your relevant competitors. In future filings, please disclose where payments actually fell within targeted parameters.
TPC answered
In future filings we will include the requested disclosure based on the then most recent compensation survey completed.

Certain Relationships and Related Party Transactions, page 27.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Certain Relationships and Related Party Transactions, page 27
SEC asked (8)
Please file copies of the company’s lease agreements with Mr. Tutor.
TPC answered
The Company will file the lease agreements with Mr. Tutor as exhibits to its next quarterly filing on Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended June 30, 2010.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 24
SEC asked (9)
We note that your credit agreement contains financial covenants. Given the importance of available funding to your business, please revise future annual and quarterly filings to present, for your most significant and restrictive covenants, your actual ratios and other actual amounts versus the minimum/maximum ratios/amounts required as of each reporting date.
Rest of the question

Such a presentation may allow investors to more easily assess and understand your current status and ability to meet your covenants. See Sections I.D and IV.C of the SEC Interpretive Release No. 33-8350.

TPC answered
We evaluated our level of disclosure surrounding financial covenants in light of SEC Interpretive Release No. 33-8350 and specifically considered whether the Company was in breach of, or was reasonably likely to be in breach of, its covenants in conjunction with the filing of our Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended March 31, 2010.
Rest of the answer

The Company was in compliance with all of its restrictive covenants as of that date, remains in compliance as of the date of this letter, and anticipates continued compliance for the foreseeable future.

We also evaluated the potential impact that current covenants restricting our ability to undertake additional debt or equity financing may have on our financial condition or ongoing operations. As of March 31, 2010 the Company had no outstanding borrowings under its existing revolving credit facility, which provided for total availability in excess of $300 million, nor has the Company drawn on its credit facility in the past three years, with the exception of a four month period in 2009 during which an amount was drawn in conjunction with an anticipated acquisition. Based on the level of available funding and the level of cash reserves maintained by the Company, which were in excess of $250 million at March 31, 2010, we do not believe that current covenants restricting our ability to undertake additional debt or equity financing are likely to have a material affect our financial condition or ongoing operations.

Based on our assessment summarized above, we have concluded that our filings are in compliance with SEC Interpretive Release No. 33-8350. We will continue to evaluate our current and anticipated future compliance with debt covenants as well as the potential impact of covenants restricting our ability to undertake additional debt or equity financing, and in future filings we will provide additional disclosure, as appropriate, based on SEC Interpretive Release No. 33-8350.

In connection with our responses to your letter, Tutor Perini Corporation acknowledges that:

the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filings;

staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and the Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 19, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked (1)
We note your response to our prior comment one. Please provide us with a more specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you determined it was appropriate to aggregate all of the business units in your Building Group into a single reporting unit.
TPC answered
In accordance with ASC 350-20-35-33, a reporting unit is defined as “an operating segment or one level below an operating segment (referred to as a component)”. We determined each of the following business units to be components of the Building Group operating segment as each constitutes a business, in accordance with the definition contained in ASC 805-10-55-4, and each maintains discrete financial information that is regularly reviewed by the Building Group CEO.

General Contractors: Specialty Contractors:

Perini Building Company (“PBC”) Desert Plumbing & Heating (“DPH”)

Rudolph & Sletten
Rest of the answer

(“R&S”) PowerCo Electric (“PowerCo”)

James A. Cummings (“JAC”)

Keating Building Company (“Keating”)

We evaluated these components of the Building Group operating segment for aggregation in accordance with ASC 280-10-50-11 and ASC 350-20-55. Our assessment considered each of the following areas in determining whether two or more of the components of the Building Group operating segment have similar economic characteristics such that they should be aggregated into a single reporting unit.

·

Integrated approach to operations –

Ø

New work procurement – When evaluating new work opportunities within the Building Group, the Building Group CEO considers several factors in determining which component business unit or joint venture between component business units will pursue the project. Factors considered include existing relationships with the prospective client, relevant project experience and location of the component business unit. New work opportunities are often bid as joint ventures between component business units as one business unit may bring a relationship or locally recognized brand name and the other brings a resume of relevant project experience. For example, we were recently selected to construct a casino project in New York that was bid as a joint venture between Keating (local presence and brand name) and Perini Building Company (nationally recognized leader in casino construction).

Project execution – The Building Group CEO oversees all operations within the group, including the allocation of resources between component business units. Business unit resources, including personnel and equipment, are frequently shared between each of the component business units in the Building Group operating segment. Examples of our integrated approach to project execution include the following:

-

Estimating – When pursuing new work opportunities, the team of estimators assembled frequently draws from personnel in more than one component business unit (general and specialty contractors) in order to ensure the appropriate mix of experience and specialized expertise is applied to the estimating process.

Equipment – Construction equipment owned by component business units is centrally managed and frequently utilized by other component business units.

Project management and construction activities – Based on the specific requirements of a project and availability of personnel, component business units share project management and construction personnel in completion of project work.

Specialty contractors – Services performed by our specialty contractors allow the Company to enhance our profit by increasing the portion of work we self-perform on Building Group projects. Our specialty contractors, which were acquired by the Company in Q3 2008, obtain the substantial majority of their revenue and profit from work performed for general contractors within the Building Group (PBC, R&S, JAC and Keating). In 2009 and YTD 2010, more than 80% of specialty contractor revenues have been generated from work performed for the Company’s general contractors. The primary function for our specialty contractors is to support our integrated service approach to Building Group general contractor clients.

Nature of products / services – General contractors are engaged by a customer to deliver finished buildings, built to the customer’s specifications. The nature of services performed by each of the general contractor component business units are the same and include project management, procurement and construction performance. Each of the component business units construct non-residential buildings in a variety of end markets including but not limited to hotels, casinos, schools, hospitals, transportation facilities, correctional facilities, sports and entertainment facilities, office buildings and parking garages. Although each building project is unique in design and scope, the nature of services and skills required to perform services are consistent. Specialty contractors are utilized by general contractors to perform specific portions of the construction activities including electrical, mechanical, plumbing and HVAC. Services performed by our specialty contractors fall within the scope of services the general contractor is obligated to provide a project owner. As indicated above, our specialty contractors obtain the substantial majority of their revenue and profit from work performed for general building contractors within the Building Group.

Nature of production process – The Company’s approach to the construction process is consistent across all components of the Building Group operating segment (general and specialty contractors). Despite the unique design of each building we are engaged to construct, the Company’s process for development and project management includes the same basic steps including estimating (materials, labor, schedule, etc.), procurement, construction based performance and project management.

Type or class of customer – General contractors all perform services for the owner of a project. Owners include companies in private industry as well as public agencies. Each of our component business units perform work for a mix of private industry and public agency owners. Specialty contractors are engaged by general contractors to perform services to the specification of the owner of a project. We utilize an integrated approach for services performed on projects in which one of the Company’s general contractors is also engaged and as such we view the project owner as a shared customer between our general contractor and specialty contractors. All services provided must be accepted by the owner of the project.

Method of distribution – Not applicable.

Nature of regulatory environment – Each component of the Building Group operating segment (general and specialty contractors) performs construction subject to local and regional building codes. All business units utilize union labor and abide by regional and national union regulations.

Financial Performance – General contractors in the Building Group all consistently achieve similar gross margins and each component business unit has an average forecasted gross margin between 4% and 5%. Specialty contractors have higher average gross margins than general contractors, due to a greater volume of work that is self-performed rather than subcontracted. We note that our specialty contractors obtain the substantial majority of their revenue and profit from work performed for general contractors within the Building Group. In our assessment of the financial performance of a project we take a total project view, based on an integrated service approach, in which the average gross margin for a project is enhanced by the degree of work we are able to self-perform.

Recoverability of goodwill from component operations – As indicated above, we utilize an integrated service approach between our general contractors and specialty contractors on our Building Group projects. Services performed by our specialty contractors allow the Company to enhance our profit by increasing the portion of work we self-perform on Building Group projects. Our specialty contractors, which were acquired by the Company in Q3 2008, obtain the substantial majority of their revenue and profit from work performed for general contractors within the Building Group (PBC, R&S, JAC and Keating). In 2009 and YTD 2010, more than 80% of our specialty contractor revenues have been generated from work performed for the Company’s general contractors. Due to the interdependency of the operations of our specialty contractors with those of our general contractors, we determined that goodwill associated with the specialty contractors is recoverable through the integrated operations of specialty and general contractor component business units.

Based on our analysis of the qualitative and quantitative factors summarized above, including the interdependence between general and specialty contractors, we have concluded that each of the components of the Building Group operating segment have similar economic characteristics and are appropriately aggregated into a single Building Group reporting unit.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 10, 2010: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked (2)
We note your response to our prior comment two. Please provide us with a more specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you have assessed the control premium in comparing the difference between your market capitalization and book value. In addition, please further explain how you have considered the duration and severity of your decline in market capitalization.
TPC answered
The Company’s 2009 annual impairment analysis determined the fair value of the Company and each of its reporting units, utilizing third party specialists, based on a weighting of income-based and market-based valuation approaches. The implied control premium was calculated to be 77%, determined based on the fair value and the market capitalization at the date of our fair value assessment.
Rest of the answer

We considered the following factors in determining that the implied control premium was reasonable and that there was no impairment as of the date of our analysis:

Market control premium: In order to assess whether the implied control premium is in line with the market, we utilize a third party specialist to assist in determining the market control premium. During 2009, we noted that the average control premium paid in transactions of companies in the construction industry was 48.4% and the median control premium was 35.7%. The range of control premiums paid, excluding the highest and lowest, were between 16.8% and 89.6%.

Impact of low public float and limited trading activity: A significant portion of our stock, approximately 43% as of the date of our 2009 annual impairment test, is owned by the Company’s Chairman and CEO. As a result, the public float of our stock, calculated as the percentage of shares of common stock freely traded by public investors divided by the Company’s total shares outstanding, is significantly lower than our publically traded peers. Currently, our public float is approximately 51% compared to a range between 88% and 100% for other publically traded companies comparable to Tutor Perini. As a result, investors in Tutor Perini stock are faced with a lower supply of stock available to be traded, thereby limiting the trading volume and liquidity of our stock as compared to our peers.

We believe the circumstances surrounding our stock, described above, lead to an inherent marketability discount impacting our stock price. We estimate the impact of our low public float and limited trading activity to be a discount on our stock price ranging between 8% and 21%, based on third party market based studies of less liquid investments and the volume of less liquid shares outstanding. For purposes of our sensitivity analysis, summarized below, we used the midpoint of this range.

Third party analyst target price estimates: Given the continued volatility in the market for corporate securities, including Tutor Perini stock, we also consider the implied control premium calculated based on an average of stock price estimates by third party analysts who follow our company. During Q4 2010 the Company’s stock price fluctuated between $16.50 per share and $22.12 per share. As of the date of our 2009 annual impairment analysis, the stock price was $20.49 per share and the average analyst price estimate for Tutor Perini stock was $23.00.

Sensitivity analysis: Taking the forgoing items into consideration, we performed a sensitivity analysis to determine the minimum control premium required to recover the book value of the Company at the testing date. In each scenario we noted that the implied control premium fell within the range of market control premiums summarized above. We further noted the minimum control premium required to be well below the average control premium paid in transactions of companies in the construction industry during 2009. See summary of our analysis below (in thousands):

Scenario A

Scenario B

Scenario C

Book value

1,250,500

Fair value

1,760,000

Market capitalization

994,400

1,138,588

1,278,064

Implied control premium

77%

55%

38%

Minimum control premium required

26%

10%

-2%

Scenario A:

Market capitalization calculated based on the closing share price on the testing date.

Scenario B:

Market capitalization adjusted to eliminate the impact of a discount for low float and limited trading volume, estimated to be 14.5% at the testing date.

Scenario C:

Market capitalization calculated based on the average analyst stock price estimate, adjusted to eliminate the discount for low float and limited trading volume, estimated to be 14.5% at the testing date.

Subsequent to the 2009 annual impairment analysis testing date, we have observed significant fluctuations in our market capitalization. Temporary declines in our market capitalization have been followed by a recovery within a relatively short period of time (typically less than three months). The chart below summarizes the fluctuations in our market capitalization calculated (a) at the end of each quarter subsequent to the 2009 annual impairment testing date, (b) based on the average share price during each period and (c) based on the average third party analyst stock price estimate at the end of each period.

Market Capitalization

Qtr End

% Var

Qtr Average

Analyst

Q4 2009

877,585

-12%

902,509

-9%

1,189,205

20%

Q1 2010

1,066,795

7%

995,146

0%

1,196,772

Q2 2010

800,857

-19%

1,029,280

4%

1,255,226

% Var: Represents the % change from the market capitalization on the date of our 2009 annual impairment test.

During the period summarized above, we noted the magnitude and duration of fluctuation in our market capitalization to be generally representative of fluctuations in the broader equity markets. We further noted that the average market capitalization during Q1 and Q2 2010 approximated or exceeded the market capitalization as of the date of our 2009 annual impairment analysis. Moreover, analyst estimates of our stock price have increased each quarter since our 2009 impairment analysis. In conjunction with our quarterly impairment indicator assessment, we compared actual operating results to the forecasted results used in our 2009 annual impairment analysis. Through Q2 2010, actual revenues approximated forecasted revenues and actual pre-tax earnings exceeded forecasted pre-tax earnings. Based on these facts, we concluded that the fluctuation in market capitalization during the quarters following our 2009 annual impairment analysis did not constitute an impairment indicator.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 10, 2010: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to our prior comments three and four. Please provide us with a more specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you concluded that the fair value of each of your reporting units exceeded the carrying value. In this regard, we note that the revenues and backlog in your Building segment have decreased substantially.
Rest of the question

At December 31, 2008, you disclosed that the backlog in the Building segment was $5.7 billion while you disclosed that it was $3.0 billion at June 30, 2010. While we understand that part of the decrease is driven by certain projects as well as a focus on opportunities in the Civil segment, please discuss further how you determined that the projected future cash flows of your Building segment support the current value. In addition, while we note you have identified more opportunities in your Civil segment, please discuss further how you have concluded that the future cash flows from this segment support the current value. It appears that some of the projects driven by stimulus funding may only have a short term impact. * * * * As appropriate, please respond to these comments within 10 business days or tell us when you will provide us with a response. Please furnish a letter that keys your responses to our comments and provides any requested supplemental information. Detailed response letters greatly facilitate our review. Please file your response letter on EDGAR. Please understand that we may have additional comments after reviewing your responses to our comments.

TPC answered
The Company’s 2009 annual impairment analysis determined the fair value of the Company and each of its reporting units, utilizing third party specialists, based on a weighting of income-based and market-based valuation approaches. The results of this analysis yielded a fair value substantially in excess of the carrying value of each of our reporting units. On a quarterly basis we update our forecast based on current market information, as part of our budgeting process.
Rest of the answer

At that time we evaluate whether our current forecast of revenues and pre-tax profits are in line with the forecast used in our annual impairment assessment. We also consider whether there are any changes in trends or any other material assumptions used in our annual impairment valuation. In conjunction with this quarterly evaluation during 2010, we have concluded that the fair value of each of our reporting units continues to approximate the fair value calculated at the date of our 2009 annual impairment assessment, and exceeds the carrying value of each reporting unit. The following paragraphs summarize our valuation methodology, including our development of the key valuation assumptions, and additional factors considered in our conclusion that the fair value of each reporting unit exceeds its carrying value.

Income-based valuation – We calculate the fair value of each reporting unit using a discounted cash flow analysis. Key valuation assumptions utilized include the following:

Estimate future cash flows – We estimate future cash flows by reporting unit for a period of three years. These estimates are developed based on our forecast of (a) the completion of existing backlog, (b) the revenue stream for pending awards and (c) the revenue stream for new work. New work revenue estimates are derived based on our evaluation of a list of specifically identified prospective projects that have been pre-identified as opportunities within our target market that we plan to pursue. In our forecast of new work revenue we consider our probability of success in winning new work based on our relationship with the project owner, the strength of our qualifications and our historical rate of success in winning similar new work opportunities.

Estimate the residual value – We estimate the residual value associated with cash flows beyond a discrete forecast period after normalizing revenues to reflect long term projections and to eliminate the effect of business cycles during the discrete forecast period. In this regard, revenues and related cash flow in the year following our discrete forecast, capitalized into value using a long term growth rate, may be less than the revenues and cash flows forecast for the prior year. The capitalization rate utilized to calculate the residual value is determined based on our consideration of long term market factors, such as projected demand, available funding, and our historical long-term growth rates for the reporting unit.

Discount future cash flows to the present value – The discount rate used to calculate the present value of future cash flows is a risk adjusted rate that approximates the Company’s weighted average cost of capital.

Market-based valuation – In addition to the income-based valuation, we also calculate the fair value of each reporting unit using a market approach based on an analysis of market multiples for companies engaged in similar businesses. After identifying and selecting the comparable publically traded companies, their business and financial profiles are analyzed for similarities and differences to the Company. Based on this assessment, adjustments are made and the market multiples are calculated for utilization in our valuation. A market based control premium, determined to be 30% in our 2009 annual impairment analysis, is then applied to determine the fair value of a marketable and controlling interest in the business.

As indicated above, the fair value of the Company and each of its reporting units in our 2009 annual impairment analysis was based on consideration of income-based and market-based valuation approaches. Prior to determining that the fair value exceeds the carrying value for each reporting unit, we considered the following additional factors:

Congruence of fair value between valuation methods – We compared the fair value of the Company calculated under each valuation methodology, noting the fair value calculated under the income-based method to be within +/-5% of the fair value calculated under the market-based method.

Stress test based on valuation method: We compared the carrying value of each reporting unit to the lower of the two fair value calculations, noting that in each case the fair value substantially exceeded the carrying value.

Stress test of the income-based valuation method: We reduced our estimate of future cash flows for each reporting unit by 20%, noting that in each case the resulting income-based value still exceeded the carrying value by a significant amount. Furthermore, we calculated the percentage of estimated future cash flows required to support the book value of each reporting unit at the testing date to be 65% for the Building Group, 71% for the Civil Group and 44% for the Management Services Group.

Building segment considerations – In late September 2008 the financial markets collapsed, which sparked a deep downturn in global economic conditions generally that ultimately had a significant impact on the Company’s new work prospects in the Building segment. We determined that these events were an impairment indicator at that time, which triggered an impairment evaluation and ultimately a goodwill impairment charge of $166.9 million in Q4 2008.

Anticipated decline in Building segment revenues: The forecast utilized in our Q4 2008 impairment analysis projected a decrease in Building segment revenues of approximately 34% between 2009 and 2010 due to the projected completion of certain large hospitality and gaming projects in 2009 and an anticipated slower pace of new work procurement in the Building segment. In the forecast utilized for our 2009 annual impairment analysis, we projected a similar decrease in Building segment revenues between 2009 and 2010 of approximately 35%. Through Q2 2010, actual revenues and pre-tax earnings for the Building segment approximated revenues and pre-tax earnings forecasted in our 2009 annual impairment analysis (within 3%).

Anticipated decline in Building segment backlog: In light of the global economic challenges facing our hospitality and gaming clients, our 2008 and 2009 annual impairment analysis anticipated a significant decline in the level of Building segment backlog. At December 31, 2008 our Building segment backlog was $5.7 billion. Approximately $2.5 billion of the backlog at that time related to large hospitality and gaming work in Las Vegas which we anticipated would be substantially complete by the end of 2009. We specifically excluded hospitality and gaming projects of similar size and scale from our forecast of new work in cash flows at each of these testing dates. Since the completion of this large hospitality and gaming work in Q4 2009, the level of our Building segment backlog has stabilized, as anticipated, at approximately $3 billion ($3.13 billion at December 31, 2009 and $3.05 billion at June 30, 2010).

Civil segment considerations – Prior to our 2009 reorganization and increase in emphasis on Civil segment operations, we noted a significant volume of infrastructure related work on the horizon. Annual revenues generated by the U.S. Civil Construction industry exceed $200 billion and the demand for public works construction is anticipated to be strong for the foreseeable future due to the substantial need for the repair and replacement of aging vital infrastructure. It is estimated that over $2.2 trillion of improvements are needed over the next five years in order to bring the nation’s infrastructure into a state of good repair. Many of the key drivers for civil infrastructure spending, such as population growth and urbanization, are long-term trends. In addition, Civil infrastructure spending has strong political support because of the powerful job creation capability and the high return on investment to gross domestic product over the life of the asset. Based on our market analysis, we have assessed the civil infrastructure opportunity to be long-term in nature and, while positively impacted by recent stimulus spending, we believe the tremendous need for infrastructure improvements and repair in the United States will continue to drive growth in this sector for years to come.

Based on the results of our valuation, stress tests performed, assessment of actual results versus our forecast on a quarterly basis and other market considerations, we have concluded that the fair value of each reporting unit exceeded the carrying value at December 31, 2009, March 31, 2010 and June 30, 2010.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 10, 2010: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked
We have received your letter dated September 10, 2010. In order for us to fully consider your responses, please provide us with the following additional information: • The specific comparable company transactions you considered in your analysis of the market control premium. In this regard, please tell us the names of the parties involved and the control premium paid in each individual transaction.
Rest of the question

• The names of the comparable public companies you considered in your analysis of public float. • A copy of the valuation reports used in your 2009 impairment analysis. * * * * As appropriate, please respond to these comments within 10 business days or tell us when you will provide us with a response. Please furnish a letter that keys your responses to our comments and provides any requested supplemental information. Detailed response letters greatly facilitate our review. Please file your response letter on EDGAR. Please understand that we may have additional comments after reviewing your responses to our comments.

TPC answered
Our assessment of the market control premium in our 2009 annual impairment analysis considered transactions within the Construction Contractors and Engineering Services industry announced in 2008, as published by Mergerstat. Specific transactions considered consist of the following:

BUYER NAME

SELLER NAME

% PREMIUM

Citigroup, Inc.

Sacyr Vallehermoso S.A.

16.5%

Dominion Homes, Inc. / Private Group

Dominion Homes, Inc.
Rest of the answer

- REM

35.4%

Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.

Fujita Corp.

61.4%

Insight Equity

Meadow Valley Corp.

19.7%

Subsequent to our annual impairment analysis, Mergerstat published 2009 transactions within the Construction Contractors and Engineering Services industry, which we considered in conjunction with our quarterly impairment indicator analysis. Specific transactions considered consist of the following:

Absa Capital Private Equity

(Proprietary) Limited , Vantage

Capital Kwikspace Investments

(Proprietary) Limited

Kwikspace Modular Buildings Limited

44.9%

Aecon Group Inc.

Lockerbie & Hole Inc.

30.1%

AMEC plc

GRD Limited

35.8%

Ausdrill Ltd.

Brandrill Limited

89.6%

CLSA Capital Partners , CLSA

Sunrise Capital LP

Nihon Integround Holdings, Inc.

171.4%

Energy Conversion Devices, Inc.

Solar Integrated Technologies, Inc.

16.8%

Fuji Furukawa Engineering &

Construction Co., Ltd.

Furukawa Engineering & Construction, Inc.

45.9%

Grupo Dragados, S.A.

PRI Pol-Aqua S.A.

8.0%

IHI Corporation

Matsuo Bridge Co., Ltd.

35.6%

Pulte Homes Inc.

Centex Corporation

57.6%

Southern Energy Homes, Inc.

Cavalier Homes, Inc.

23.3%

The names of the comparable public companies you considered in your analysis of public float.

Response:

Comparable publically traded companies considered in our analysis of public float consist of Flour Corporation, Granite Construction Incorporated, Jacobs Engineering Group Incorporated, and KBR Incorporated.

A copy of the valuation reports used in your 2009 impairment analysis.

Response:

We are providing a copy of the supplemental information requested under separate cover via hand delivery. This information is submitted only in paper pursuant to Rule 101(c)(2) of Regulation S-T. We request that such supplemental information be returned to the undersigned after Staff review.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 30, 2010: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Critical Accounting Policies, page 32 · Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 34
SEC asked
We have reviewed your letters dated September 10, 2010 and September 30, 2010 as well as the supplemental information you provided. Please revise your disclosures in future filings, beginning with your Form 10-Q for the period ended September 30, 2010, to include a more specific and comprehensive discussion regarding how you have considered your market capitalization compared to your book value in your impairment
Rest of the question

analysis. Your disclosures should include the significant items you discussed in your previous responses such as your implied control premium, the impact of your low public float and the sensitivity analysis of your fair value estimate. * * * * As appropriate, please respond to these comments within 10 business days or tell us when you will provide us with a response. Please furnish a letter that keys your responses to our comments and provides any requested supplemental information. Detailed response letters greatly facilitate our review. Please file your response letter on EDGAR. Please understand that we may have additional comments after reviewing your responses to our comments.

TPC answered
In future filings, beginning with our Form 10-Q for the period ended September 30, 2010, we will include the following disclosure under Critical Accounting Policies in Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations.

The Company’s annual impairment analysis determines the fair value of the Company and each of its reporting units based primarily on an income-based valuation approach with consideration also given to a market-based valuation approach.
Rest of the answer

The implied control premium is calculated based on the fair value and the market capitalization at the date of our fair value assessment. In evaluating whether our implied control premium is reasonable, we consider a number of factors including the following more significant factors.

·

Market control premium: We compare our implied control premium to the average control premium paid in transactions of companies in the construction industry during the year of evaluation.

Sensitivity analysis: We perform a sensitivity analysis to determine the minimum control premium required to recover the book value of the Company at the testing date. We then compare the minimum control premium required to the average control premium paid in transactions of companies in the construction industry during the year of evaluation.

Impact of low public float and limited trading activity: A significant portion of our stock is owned by the Company’s Chairman and CEO. As a result, the public float of our stock, calculated as the percentage of shares of common stock freely traded by public investors divided by the Company’s total shares outstanding, is significantly lower than our publically traded peers. This circumstance does not impact the fair value of the Company, however based on our evaluation of third party market data we believe it does lead to an inherent marketability discount impacting our stock price.

As of the date of our most recent annual impairment analysis, our implied control premium was within the range of market control premiums paid in transactions of companies in the construction industry during the year of evaluation. Based on our sensitivity analysis at that date, the minimum control premium required to recover the book value of the Company was substantially less than the average control premium paid in transactions of companies in the construction industry during the year of evaluation.

On a quarterly basis we consider whether events or changes in circumstances indicate that assets, including goodwill and intangible assets not subject to amortization, might be impaired. In conjunction with this analysis, we evaluate whether our current market capitalization is less than our stockholders’ equity and specifically consider (1) the duration and severity of any decline in market capitalization, (2) a reconciliation of the implied control premium to a current market control premium, (3) target price assessments by third party analysts and (4) how current market conditions impact our forecast of future cash flows. We also update our assessment of the fair value of each of our reporting units, considering whether our current forecast of future cash flows are in line with those used in our most recent annual impairment assessment and whether there are any significant changes in trends or any other material assumption used. As of September 30, 2010 we have concluded that we do not have an impairment indicator and that the estimated fair value of each reporting unit substantially exceeds its carrying value.

In the event we determine in a future period that the estimated fair value of one or more of our reporting units does not substantially exceed the carrying value, we will provide additional disclosure of material assumptions and potential events, trends or circumstances that may have an impact on our estimate of fair value.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 27, 2010: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2010 ↗.

No earlier 10-Q before the SEC's letter is in Tickdelta, so there is nothing to compare with.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2010-10-28

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 42 letters filed since 2010-07-06. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/TPC/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.