Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended July 1, 2023
It appears there are inconsistencies between the notes to the summary resource table and certain individual property resource tables. For example, note 4 to Table 2.5 indicates a long-term uranium price of $40 per pound for ISR projects and $65 per pound for conventional projects, however Table 2.41 on page 87 discloses pricing of $56 per pound.Rest of the question
Additionally, note 5 to Table 2.5 states that resources are 100% attributable to the company, however Table 2.42 on page 93 states that the resources in the table are based on UEC's 49.0975% equity in the project. We also note that you have included two tables identified as Table 2.42, including Table 2.42 on page 93 and Table 2.42 on page 90. Please revise to ensure the pricing and attributable resource disclosures are consistent between individual property resource tables and the summary resource table, and correct the table numbers listed with each table.
In this respect the Company notes and confirms that:Read in the reply
●
The Company has now updated each of mineral resource estimate information contained in the footnotes to each of the following Tables for the following Company Projects in the filed Form 10-K/A as follows: Table 2.5 (Mineral Resources); Table 2.6 (Year over Year Changes); Table 2.8 (Irigaray Project); Table 2.10 (Christensen Ranch Project); Table 2.12 (Moore Ranch Project); Table 2.14 (Reno Creek Project); Table 2.16 (Ludeman Project); Table 2.18 (Allemand Ross Project); Table 2.20 (Barge Project); Table 2.22 (Jab/West Project); TableRest of the answer
2.24 (Charlie Project); Table 2.26 (Nine Mile Lake Project); Table 2.28 (Red Rim Project); Table 2.30 (Clarkson Hill Project); Table 2.33 (Palangana Project); Table 2.35 (Burke Hollow Project); Table 2.37 (Goliad Project); Table 2.39 (Salvo Project); Table 2.40 (Anderson Project); Table 2.42 (Horseshoe-Raven Project); and Table 2.43 (Shea Creek Project); in order to clearly set forth:
● the long-term uranium price utilized for each Project;
● the point of reference utilized for each Project;
● the cut-grade utilized for each Project; and the metallurgical recovery factor utilized for each Project.
In this respect the Company notes, for example, that footnotes 3. and 4. in Table 2.5 (Mineral Resources) of the filed Form 10-K/A now provide as follows:
3. The point of reference for mineral resources is in-situ at the Project.
4. Mineral Resources are estimated using a long-term uranium price of $40 per pound for ISR projects and $65 per pound for conventional projects, except for the Canadian projects where a price of $56 per pound was used for the Roughrider Project, a price of $75 per pound was used for the Horseshoe-Raven Project, a price of $50 per pound was used for the Shea Creek Project, a price of $50 per pound was used for the Christie Lake Project and a price of $62 per pound was used for the Millennium Project.”;
The Company has now clarified that the mineral resources in each of Tables 2.5 and 2.42 are 100% attributable to the Company, and in this respect the Company notes that footnote 5. in Table 2.5 (Mineral Resources) of the filed Form 10-K/A now provides as follows:
5. Mineral Resources in the table above are 100% attributable to the Company. Where JV projects have resources that are attributable to other companies, these resources are not listed in this table.”;
The Company has now re-labelled the second Table 2.42 in the filed Form 10-K/A to be “Table 2.43” and, in addition, has now re-labelled Tables 2.43 as “Table 2.44” as well; and
The Company confirms that it has ensured that the pricing and attributable resource disclosures are consistent between individual property resource tables and the summary resource table in the filed Form 10-K/A;
and we hope and trust that this is now clear and satisfactory in this regard.
“2.
We note that several of the properties that have been included in Table 2.6, Year over Year Changes in Mineral Resources, were acquired during the fiscal year ending 2023, however resource estimates related to these properties are reflected in the fiscal year ending 2022. Please revise as necessary.”
Company Response:
In this respect the Company notes and confirms that Table 2.6 (Year over Year Changes) in the filed Form 10-K/A has now been revised to indicate that the Company did NOT have any resource estimates for its Canadian Projects for its fiscal year ending 2022, such that the year over year (fiscal 2022 to fiscal 2023) change in mineral resource updates for the Company’s material properties in Canada only changed by 100% for Indicated pounds; and we hope and trust that this is now clear and satisfactory in this regard.
As necessary please revise all individual property mineral resource tables to include the point of reference, the price, the cut-off grade, and the metallurgical recovery factor as required by Item 1304(d)(1) of Regulation S-K.”
Company Response:
In this respect the Company notes and confirms, as indicated above, that the Company has now updated each of mineral resource estimate information contained in the footnotes to each of the following Tables for the following Company Projects in the filed Form 10-K/A as follows: Table 2.5 (Mineral Resources); Table 2.6 (Year over Year Changes); Table 2.8 (Irigaray Project); Table 2.10 (Christensen Ranch Project); Table 2.12 (Moore Ranch Project); Table 2.14 (Reno Creek Project); Table 2.16 (Ludeman Project); Table 2.18 (Allemand Ross Project); Table 2.20 (Barge Project); Table 2.22 (Jab/West Project); Table 2.24 (Charlie Project); Table 2.26 (Nine Mile Lake Project); Table 2.28 (Red Rim Project); Table 2.30 (Clarkson Hill Project); Table 2.33 (Palangana Project); Table 2.35 (Burke Hollow Project); Table 2.37 (Goliad Project); Table 2.39 (Salvo Project); Table 2.40 (Anderson Project); Table 2.42 (Horseshoe-Raven Project); and Table 2.43 (Shea Creek Project); in order to clearly set forth:
the long-term uranium price utilized for each Project;
the point of reference utilized for each Project;
the cut-grade utilized for each Project; and the metallurgical recovery factor utilized for each Project;
“Item 15. Exhibits, Financial Statement Schedules
96.4 page 151
We note that you have assumed a cut-off grade of 0.05% U308 for your Horseshoe-Raven mineral resource, however you have not included underground mining costs in the cut-off grade calculation. Mining costs must be included in the cut-off calculation in order to establish a reasonable prospect of economic extraction; similar to mining costs that were included in the Roughrider Uranium technical report summary, provided as Exhibit 96.10.
Please revise the technical report summary to include mining costs in the cut-off grade calculation, and revise the resource disclosure as necessary.
Please review your other technical report summaries to ensure that mining costs have been included in the cut-off grade, as necessary.”
Company Response:
In this respect the Company notes and confirms that, in accordance with the now updated and filed TRS respecting the Horseshoe-Raven Project, and as now set forth in the filed Form 10-K/A:
The filed TRS now includes mining costs in its cut-off grade calculation;
The filed TRS and related Form 10-K/A resource disclosure uses a cut-off grade of 0.05% U3O8, and that the cut-off grade was determined utilizing a current uranium price of $75 per pound a metallurgical recovery rate of 95%; and
The Company has reviewed its other technical report summaries to ensure that mining costs had been utilized in their respective cut-off grade calculations;
“5.
We note that disclosures under Reliance on Other Experts, on page 134 of the Technical Report Summary, include categories of information beyond those that are permissible under Item 1302(f)(1) of Regulation S-K.
For example, in one paragraph of this section, the qualified person indicates that there has been reliance with regard to content in Section 10, exclusively on information and data supplied by UEX.
Please discuss this observation with the qualified person and arrange to obtain and file a revised technical Report Summary that is consistent with the requirements in Item 1302(f)(2) of Regulation S-K.
We generally anticipate that qualified persons would validate and discuss information utilized in preparing the report that is not within categories listed in the guidance referenced above, in an alternate and corresponding section of the report.”
Company Response:
In this respect the Company notes and confirms that, in accordance with the now updated and filed TRS respecting the Horseshoe-Raven Project, Section 25 of the TRS has now been revised to remove the two (last) paragraphs incorporated therein wherein references to reliance by the TRS QPs on both prior metallurgical testing and recovery and processing/water treatment and general and administrative costs were previously provided for and which were previously beyond those categories that are permissible under Item 1302(f)(1) of Regulation S-K; and we hope and trust that this is now clear and satisfactory in this regard.
We hope and trust that each of the foregoing responses and the Company’s now filed Form 10-K/A and updated TRS are clear, satisfactory and fully responsive to the Comment Letter; however, should the SEC have any further questions or concerns respecting any of the same please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned, at 604.691.7445, at the SEC’s convenience at any time.
We thank the SEC in advance for its prompt attention to and its continued cooperation in this matter and, in the interim, we remain,
Yours very truly,
First report after the company's reply of Apr 2, 2024: 10-Q filed Jun 10, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Dec 11, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note that several of the properties that have been included in Table 2.6, Year over Year Changes in Mineral Resources, were acquired during the fiscal year ending 2023, however resource estimates related to these properties are reflected in the fiscal year ending 2022. Please revise as necessary.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Apr 2, 2024: 10-Q filed Jun 10, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Dec 11, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
As necessary please revise all individual property mineral resource tables to include the point of reference, the price, the cut-off grade, and the metallurgical recovery factor as required by Item 1304(d)(1) of Regulation S-K.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Apr 2, 2024: 10-Q filed Jun 10, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Dec 11, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note that you have assumed a cut-off grade of 0.05% U3O8 for your Horseshoe-Raven mineral resource, however you have not included underground mining costs in the cut-off grade calculation. Mining costs must be included in the cut-off calculation in order to establish a reasonable prospect of economic extraction; similar to mining costs that were included in the Roughrider Uranium technical report summary,Rest of the question
provided at Exhibit 96.10. Please revise the technical report summary to include mining costs in the cut-off grade calculation, and revise the resource disclosure as necessary. Please review your other technical report summaries to ensure that mining costs have been included in the cut-off grade, as necessary.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Apr 2, 2024: 10-Q filed Jun 10, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Dec 11, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note that disclosures under Reliance on Other Experts, on page 134 of the Technical Report Summary, include categories of information beyond those that are permissible under Item 1302(f)(1) of Regulation S-K. For example, in one paragraph of this section, the qualified person indicates there has been reliance with regard to content in Section 10, exclusively on information and data supplied by UEX.Rest of the question
Please discuss this observation with the qualified person and arrange to obtain and file a revised technical Report Summary that is consistent with the requirements in Item 1302(f)(2) of Regulation S-K. We generally anticipate that qualified persons would validate and discuss information utilized in preparing the report that is not within the categories listed in the guidance referenced above, in an alternate and corresponding section of the report. We remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Apr 2, 2024: 10-Q filed Jun 10, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Dec 11, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your revisions to the technical report summary in response to prior comment 4, pertaining to disclosures of the cut-off grade and the inclusion of underground mining costs in the cut-off grade calculation. For example we note that the cut-off grade has stayed the same with the inclusion of underground mining costs, however you have increased the commodity pricing and decreased the processing costs.Rest of the question
The types of changes proposed in your response may be considered in an updated or new technical report summary, to support disclosures that may be made in a future periodic report, though would generally not be appropriate as revisions to a prior technical report summary. Please revise the technical report summary to include the underground mining cost and the original assumptions reported with your July 31, 2023 annual report. We would expect the revised calculations to increase the cut-off grade resulting in a reduction in mineral resources. Please coordinate with the qualified persons involved in preparing the technical report summary to ensure that content throughout the report is revised as necessary. Please similarly revise all corresponding information in your annual report. You may provide us with draft disclosures for review in advance of filing the amendments. The content of any updated or new technical report summary that you obtain to support future disclosures should provide clear explanations for any changes in assumptions that materially correlate with project economics, as this may include the cut-off grade, prices, costs and quantification of resources, relative to those requirements. In your response, and not in your filing, please explain to us the difference in the processing and underground mining cut-off grade cost profile with respect to the Horseshoe-Raven project and the Roughrider Uranium project. In this regard we note the cost assumptions used in the Roughrider Uranium cut-off calculation are significantly greater that the Horseshoe-Raven cut-off grade cost assumptions.
In this respect the Company notes and confirms that:Read in the reply
●
The noted underground mining costs of $47.83/tonne were provided for in accordance with a 2022 Canadian Mining Journal article on cut and fill mining (the “Article”). The Updated TRS QPs believe this to be an accurate representation of the anticipated mining costs at the Horseshoe-Raven Project;
The noted uranium commodity price has increased since the filing by the Company of its Original TRS Report respecting the Horseshoe-Raven Project.Rest of the answer
The commodity price in the Updated TRS is now reasonably current and represents the present five-year projected commodity pricing;
The now Updated TRS notes that the processing costs were inflated from the 2016 scoping study originally supplied by the Company, and that this escalated the processing costs to $32.75/tonne in 2024. In this respect it appears that the number of $48.89/tonne in the Original TRS Report was an improper escalation of that cost and that the correction now to $32.75/tonne is believed to be more accurate by the QPs of the newly filed and Updated TRS; and
It believes that the recently filed and Updated TRS respecting the Horseshoe-Raven Project is fully accurate and that no revisions need to be made to the same or the Original TRS Report in this instance.
“Please revise the technical report summary to include the underground mining cost and the original assumptions reported with your July 31, 2023 annual report. We would expect the revised calculations to increase the cut-off grade resulting in a reduction in mineral resources. Please coordinate with the qualified persons involved in preparing the technical report summary to ensure that content throughout the report is revised as necessary. Please similarly revise all corresponding information in your annual report. You may provide us with draft disclosures for review in advance of filing the amendments.”.
Company Response:
In this respect the Company notes and confirms that it believes that its recently filed and Updated TRS respecting the Horseshoe-Raven Project is fully accurate and that no revisions need to be made to the same or the Original TRS Report in this instance.
“The content of any updated or new technical report summary that you obtain to support future disclosures should provide clear explanations for any changes in assumptions that materially correlate with project economics, as this may include the cut-off grade, prices, costs and quantification of resources, relative to those requirements.
In your response, and not in your filing, please explain to us the difference in the processing and underground mining cut-off grade cost profile with respect to the Horseshoe-Raven project and the Roughrider Uranium project. In this regard we note the cost assumptions used in the Roughrider Uranium cut-off calculation are significantly greater that the Horseshoe-Raven cut-off grade cost assumptions.”.
Company Response:
The Canadian Mining Journal Article of 2022 (provided in the references of the 2024 report) shows the cost of cut and fill mining can be expected at $47.83/tonne. This mining method, when combined with the savings associated with heap leach processing, provides for considerable cost savings when compared to conventional long hole stoping underground;
In the Athabasca Basin it is not uncommon for underground mining costs to approach $1,000/tonne for the most expensive underground mining operations that require unique or exotic mining methods. The Horseshoe-Raven Project is uniquely suited by its geological setting in competent quartzite to be considered for mining by cut and fill, whereas this cannot be considered for most Athabasca deposits due to the lack of ground stability by being hosted at the sub-Athabasca unconformity or within faulted rocks in the basement. These factors lend the Horseshoe-Raven Project to be considered for access by decline into basement rocks without any Athabasca sandstone cover rocks and mining by the cut and fill method with heap leach recovery; and
In contrast the Roughrider Project will require the development of a vertical shaft from surface to 300 metres or more at the Far East Zone, through unconsolidated overburden water-saturated sandstone which will require ground freezing to mitigate flooding from the water contained in the Athabasca sandstone. This will contribute to expensive and ongoing operation of ground freezing and water treatment far in excess of the costs required at the Horseshoe-Raven Project. While cut and fill mining is proposed for the very top of the West Deposit at the Roughrider Project, the majority of the deposit is not amenable to recovery by this method and long hole stoping is proposed for the rest of the Roughrider Project. Another cost mitigating factor at the Horseshoe-Raven Project is the shallow depth to mineralization, that tops at ~ 50 metres below the surface, whereas the Roughrider Project is quite deep necessitating the costly shaft. Milling/processing is another advantage for the Horseshoe-Raven Project, with a relatively uniform low-grade monometallic deposit that is amenable to heap-leach processing whereas the processing required at the Roughrider Project is conventional milling with more costly reagents and vastly more power consumption.
SEC Comment:
We are now responding, on behalf of the Company, to the SEC Staff’s recent comment respecting the timing of the now Updated TRS filing that accompanied its prior Form 10-K/A filing.
Company Response:
In this respect we note, on behalf of the Company, that the Company is the view that, in light of the foregoing responses to the recent SEC Comment Letter, no further revisions or updates are required going forward respecting its recent (and April 2, 2024 dated) Form 10-K/A filing and, in addition, that the recent and updated costing and pricing information provided for in the Updated TRS (which was also filed on April 2, 2024 and is now dated as updated to and effective as at March 1, 2024) is accurate such that no further revisions or updates are also required going forward for the same.
The Company is also of the view that, in light of the SEC’s initial comment letter in this instance; whereby the Company then determined that it was necessary to update and file its subject Form 10-K/A with certain resource estimate table footnotes updated for a large number of its material projects located in Item 2 of the same; and, furthermore, in light of the fact that the Company then also determined that it was necessary to update its Original TRS Report respecting its Horseshoe-Raven Project in order to update certain mining and processing costs and the pricing of uranium associated with an updated cut-off grade then calculated with the same; such filings by the Company were truly updated to incorporate both existing TRS information and the new information now provided for in the Updated TRS for the Horseshoe-Raven Project. As with the updated Form 10-K/A, Item 2 and the Updated TRS are current and it would be confusing to update the Original TRS Report with current information on costing and pricing and indicate that the effective date of the Original Report was somehow continuing. In this respect the Company notes that it filed several revised TRSs (but with current dated QP certification pages) in connection with its Form 10-K/A filing for fiscal 2022; at which point it was never suggested that the then revised TRSs were only effective for that fiscal year end. If that were the case, what would an issuer do if it had an updated resource estimate for a material property interest but was caused to revise a prior TRS and file the same under a prior Form 10-K filing when it knows that the information is no longer accurate. The Company is of the view the within and updated Form 10-K/A, which amends the information as set forth in the explanatory note as of the date of the filing of the Form 10-K/A, and related and Updated TRS are consistent in their approach to filing as is.
In this respect the Company also notes the current explanatory note as set forth on page 1 of its recent Form 10-K/A filing which, it believes, clearly explains the updates provided for relative to the same:
“Uranium Energy Corp… is filing this Form 10-K/A… for the fiscal year ended July 31, 2023, as originally filed with the… SEC… on September 29, 2023 (the “Original Report”) to amend the disclosure contained in Items 2 and 15 of the Original Report pursuant to correspondence with… the Staff of the SEC in connection with the Staff’s review of the Original Report, including the Staff’s review of the property disclosure requirements for registrants engaged in mining operations and reflected in the Original Report.
Item 15 of the Original Report has been amended to contain:… the S-K 1300 Technical Report Summary 2024 Technical Report on the Horseshoe-Raven Project, Saskatchewan, dated March 1, 2024, attached as Exhibit 96.4 to this Form 10-K/A.
Except as expressly set forth herein, this Form 10-K/A does not reflect events occurring after the date that the Original Report was filed or modifies or updates any other of the other disclosures contained therein in any way other than as required to reflect the amendments discussed above. The remainder of the Original Report filed with the SEC on September 29, 2023, remains unchanged….”. (emphasis added)
We hope and trust that each of the foregoing responses are clear, satisfactory and fully responsive to the SEC’s recent Comment Letter; however, should the SEC have any further questions or concerns respecting any of the same please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned, at 604.691.7445, at the SEC’s convenience at any time.
We thank the SEC in advance for its prompt attention to and its continued cooperation in this matter and, in the interim, we remain,
Yours very truly,
/s/ Thomas J. Deutsch
Thomas Deutsch* for McMillan LLP
* Law Corporation ec.
First report after the company's reply of Apr 29, 2024: 10-Q filed Jun 10, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Dec 11, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: company letter, Mar 18, 2024, closing letter, 2024-05-02