Form 10-K
We note there were various references in your fourth quarter earnings call on August 6, 2015 to specific products found in your product categories, describing increases in revenue for some of these products and decreases in revenue for others.Rest of the question
Please consider disclosures that improve transparency for investors about the specific products and services that had the most significant impact on your results for the periods presented. For example, you should separately discuss and quantify, as applicable, the volume and price changes for your service provider (broadband) products such as airMAX, EdgeMAX and airFiber platforms, as well as embedded radio products and other 802.11 standard products; and your enterprise technology products such as UniFi and mFi platforms, including UAP products, Unifi Video products, Unifi VOIP phones and Unifi switches. Please also provide a detailed discussion of cost of goods sold in order to help explain the change in gross profit. For example, you should quantify and explain what and why changes in product mix increased your cost of goods sold. Provide insight into the underlying business drivers or conditions that contributed to these changes. For example, you should describe material conditions in your Asian, European, South American and U.S. markets and how they effected changes in revenues and cost of goods sold. This is not meant to represent an all-inclusive list of where your MD&A should be improved. We encourage you to provide quantification of amounts and further clarification throughout your discussion. See Item 303(a)(3) of Regulation S-K.
As the Staff notes, we discuss in our earnings calls specific products that may have performed better than others for a given period. On such calls, our CEO typically discusses the overall changes to our two main product categories—Service Provider Technology and Enterprise Technology—and may, on occasion, discuss specific increases or decreases in revenue attributable to specific products within those categories.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Our financial statements and management prepared remarks describe the actual operating results in terms of overall revenues for these product categories and not for individual products. We thus believe that any specifics discussed in the CEO’s remarks is supplemental in nature, providing additional color as to the demand or “business momentum” for our products.
Additionally, the Company respectfully advises the Staff that when preparing the discussion and analysis of results of operations in Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations (“MD&A”) it analyzes its results of operations based on the instructions and guidance in Item 303(a)(3) of Regulation S-K and specifically, clause (ii) of such Item, which states that “To the extent that the financial statements disclose material increases in net sales or revenues, provide a narrative discussion of the extent to which such increases are attributable to increases in prices or to increase in the volume or amount of goods or services being sold or to the introduction of new products or services.” Furthermore, in considering the materiality to investors of separate discussion of the specific products within each product category, we evaluate this information not only in terms of whether it is material to an understanding of the current period operating results, but also as to whether the financial statements disclose material increases in net sales or revenues, as contemplated by Item 303(a)(3)(iii) of Regulation S-K. Gross profit as a percentage of revenue remained flat at 44% in both fiscal 2015 and fiscal 2014, while gross profit increased 3.44% between 2014 and 2015. We do not view this year over year increase in gross profit as material and therefore do not believe that quantification of volume and price changes for our service provider (broadband) products such as airMAX, EdgeMAX and airFiber platforms, embedded radio products and other 802.11 standard products and our enterprise technology products such as UniFi and mFi platforms, including UAP products, Unifi Video products, Unifi VOIP phones and Unifi switches would provide material information to readers of these periodic reports beyond the information already provided to assist them in projecting our future operating results.
Furthermore, with regard to the impact on revenue from changes in prices or changes in volume, we respectfully advise the Staff that there are many interrelated factors that contribute to changes in our total product sales between periods, and these factors are typically interdependent such that quantification of individual factors would not be meaningful. For example, aggregate pricing is affected by factors such as the launch of new products and new and improved versions of existing products. The prices of our products do not change materially, if at all, from period to period. Furthermore, due to the varying mix of products and the various selling prices of those products, we do not view per unit selling price as an important predictor of changes in revenues. Similarly, the changes in prices cannot readily be isolated to individual units because our products often incorporate new features from year to year, and a substantial portion of revenue comes from the introduction of new products and/or further adoption of our existing product lines as was especially the case with respect to our UniFi technology platform within our Enterprise Technology product category. The Company does not believe further quantification of the impact of volume and price changes would be meaningful.
With respect to the second and third bullet points of this Comment 1, the Company notes that it does not report Cost of Goods Sold, but rather reports Cost of Revenues, which we believe to be a more accurate reflection of the costs of selling our products. Additionally, as described in Note 2 to our consolidated financial statements, the Company does not organize or report its costs on a segment basis. The Company further notes in particular Instruction 4 to Item 303(a), which states “Where the consolidated financial statements reveal material changes from year to year in one or more line items, the causes for the changes shall be described to the extent necessary to an understanding of the registrant’s businesses as a whole; Provided, however, That if the causes for a change in one line item also relate to other line items, no repetition is required and a line-by-line analysis of the financial statements as a whole is not required or generally appropriate. Registrants need not recite the amounts of changes from year to year which are readily computable from the financial statements”.
In summary, the Company’s MD&A analysis determined the revenues financial statement line item was the most important information for investors to understand its operating performance and, accordingly, the Company provided in its MD&A revenue by product category and geography. Furthermore, the Company noted the geographical distribution of our product revenues based on our customers’ ship-to destinations, and how the revenue changes in particular regions were driven by increased or decreased demand for certain product categories. For example, we noted that the decrease in demand in South America was due to decreased demand for our Service Provider Technologies. The Company then evaluated whether there had been material changes in the cost of revenue and gross profit financial statement line items and whether those changes diverged from the change in revenues. The changes in cost of revenue and gross profit were consistent with the change in revenue. Similarly, given the balance involved, the Company did not consider details about how specific factors in various geographical regions may have affected cost of revenues and gross profit as material components to understanding the overall financial results of the Company. As previously discussed, the Company noted changes in revenue by product category and region, which the Company believes is the most relevant in helping readers of our financial statements understand our results of operations.
For the foregoing reasons, we respectfully submit that we do not believe that a detailed discussion of cost of revenues and gross profit would provide material information to readers of these periodic reports beyond the information already provided to assist them in projecting our future operating results.
First report after the company's reply of Nov 9, 2015: 10-Q filed Feb 4, 2016 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 7, 2015 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please explain to us, in detail, the facts and circumstances concerning the fraudulent transfer of funds aggregating $46.7 million and why it is not necessary for you to correct previously filed financial statements. In this regard, identify the period over which the transfers occurred and quantify the amounts transferred by quarter. Also, explain to us the status of your investigation into this matter.Rest of the question
In responding to our comments, please provide a written statement from the company acknowledging that: the company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing; staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
We will respond to this Comment #2 in three parts, consisting of (i) the facts and circumstances concerning the fraudulent transfer of funds aggregating $46.7 million, including an identification of the period over which the transfers occurred, (ii) an explanation of why it is not necessary to correct previously filed financial statements, and (iii) the status of our investigation into this matter.Read in the reply
Facts and circumstances concerning the fraudulent transfer of funds aggregating $46.7 million, including an identification of the period over which the transfers occurred
On June 5, 2015, Mr.Rest of the answer
Robert Pera, the CEO of the Company and a director of Ubiquiti Networks International Limited, an indirect wholly-owned Hong Kong-incorporated subsidiary of the Company (“Ubiquiti Hong Kong”), received a message by e-mail from Scott Hellman, an officer of the San Francisco office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, advising that a large amount of money may have been fraudulently taken from a bank account of Ubiquiti Hong Kong. Mr. Robert Pera launched an internal investigation, from which it was discovered that Rohit Chakravarthy, the then Principal Financial Officer and Controller of the Company, having the authority to transfer funds from the accounts of the Company and Ubiquiti Hong Kong, had authorized fourteen (14) wire transfers from Ubiquiti Hong Kong’s account at HSBC Hong Kong, totaling USD $46,703,232, to the accounts of several entities in several jurisdictions (including Russia, Hong Kong, the People’s Republic of China, Hungary and Poland), pursuant to instructions given by fraudsters who purported to be Robert Pera and Tom Evans of the London office of Latham & Watkins, an international law firm.
Chronology of Events
On May 19, 2015, [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] received an e-mail message ostensibly from [***INFORMATION REDACTED***], sent from what appeared to be the corporate e-mail address, [***INFORMATION REDACTED***], which [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] uses for his business correspondence.
The email of May 19, 2015 advised that the Company was conducting a transaction (an acquisition), and instructed [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] to make several payments under the transaction. The letter advised that a certain Tom Evans would give [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] instructions and details for making such payments, that [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] was to obey his instructions, and that the transaction was confidential. Later that day, May 19, 2015, [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] received another e-mail message ostensibly from [***INFORMATION REDACTED***], instructing him to make the first payment on the same day, May 19, 2015.
In reality, [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] had never written or sent [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] any e-mails on May 19, 2015, and Ubiquiti was neither transacting nor preparing to transact any business at the time.
Wire transfers from Ubiquiti Hong Kong’s account at [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] in Hong Kong is Ubiquiti’s normal business practice; therefore [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] took the e-mail message as his senior officer’s binding instruction. [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] learned that the emails had not been sent by [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] but fraudsters impersonating [***INFORMATION REDACTED***], only in the course of the internal investigation launched at the US FBI’s notice to the Company.
Rohit Chakravarthy received subsequently several emails in the name of Tom Evans (sent in fact by a fraudster impersonating Latham & Watkins’ attorney Tom Evans), including details for the first payment. The emails, ostensibly sent by Tom Evans, bore Tom Evans’ signature and Latham & Watkins’ details, but it was sent not from a Latham & Watkins e-mail address, but from an e-mail account, @consultant.com.
[***INFORMATION REDACTED***] received subsequently by email several instructions containing banking details for further payments, ostensibly sent by Tom Evans, and authorized the payments.
In reality, neither the Company nor Ubiquiti Hong Kong has ever had any business whatsoever with the firms to whose accounts the money was wired, nor do they even know such firms, which substantiates the fraudulent nature of the wires.
The following chart illustrates the relevant transactions, which were initiated and subsequently realized by [***INFORMATION REDACTED***] based on the fraudulent instructions:
[***INFORMATION REDACTED***]
An explanation of why it is not necessary to correct previously filed financial statements
As illustrated above, all of the fraudulent wire transfers occurred between May 20, 2015 and June 5, 2015. The Company’s audit committee independently engaged counsel and conducted an extensive internal investigation into the facts and circumstances of the fraudulent wire transfers, including forensic examinations of key personnel’s computers, mobile phones, personal and corporate email accounts and social media accounts. The investigation revealed no evidence of complicity or awareness of the fraudulent scheme by anyone working for the Company and did not identify any evidence of external penetration into our email accounts or IT systems. One hundred percent of the fraudulent wire transfers occurred during the Company’s fiscal fourth quarter of 2015 (April 1 through June 30, 2015). Our internal investigation did not reveal any improper or unaccounted for similar transactions at any other time. There is no need to correct any previously filed financial statements because they did not contain any errors or misstatements related to this matter.
The status of our investigation into this matter
As discussed above, the Company’s audit committee independently engaged counsel and conducted an investigation into the facts and circumstances of the fraudulent wire transfers. The investigation revealed no evidence of any complicity or knowledge by any employee of the Company in the fraudulent wire transfers or any unauthorized access by any third parties into the Company’s IT systems. The Company continues to work with law enforcement agencies in a variety of jurisdictions as it pursues recovery of its funds.
* * * *
In connection with these responses, we acknowledge the following:
the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;
Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
First report after the company's reply of Nov 9, 2015: 10-Q filed Feb 4, 2016 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 7, 2015 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to prior comment 1. Please note that MD&A should give investors the opportunity to look through the eyes of management by providing a historical and prospective analysis of the registrant's financial condition and results of operations.Rest of the question
The results of operations discussion in MD&A should help investors understand the variables and factors (quantitative and qualitative) that management uses to evaluate the company’s performance. It is apparent from earnings calls that the company’s Chief Operating Officer and investors place importance on the volume and price of principal products that you sell in your various markets under the service provider (broadband) and enterprise headings. While line item changes that state the obvious are unnecessary, the MD&A should explain “what happened” by providing an analysis for investors of the underlying changes in material product lines, even if the results of the overall category headings appear stable. Therefore, if there is a slowing in the volume of principal products sold when compared to a prior period, MD&A should not only identify the weakening in sales volume, but also should analyze the reasons underlying the flagging sales of specific principal products. The analysis should reveal underlying material causes, including for example, if applicable, difficulties in the manufacturing process, a decline in the quality of a product, loss in competitive position and market share, or a combination of conditions. We refer you to Section III.B of SEC Release No. 33-8350.
The Company respectfully advises the Staff that it considered Section III.B of SEC Interpretive Release No. 33-8350 prior to filing the Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2015 (the “Annual Report”) and believes that “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations” contained therein provides investors and other users with the material information necessary to provide an understanding of the Company’s financial condition and operating performance.Read in the reply
We discuss and quantify factors and events impacting our results of operations, as well as knownRest of the answer
material trends. We also discuss and quantify factors and events that explain material changes in our consolidated results for the quarter. For example, our Annual Report presents revenues by both our Service Provider Technology and Enterprise Technology product lines and also by geography. When we believe specific information about the reasons for the changes in revenue by product line or geography from period to period is material to investors, we include it in the Company’s disclosure with the SEC. For example, in the Annual Report, we explained that the 7% decline in Service Provider Technology revenues during fiscal year 2015 compared to fiscal year 2014 was primarily due to lower demand outside of North America, including political and economic instability in those regions and the strength of the U.S. Dollar during fiscal year 2015. For our Enterprise Technology line, we attributed the 46% increase in revenues during fiscal year 2015 compared to fiscal year 2014 to further adoption of our UniFi technology platform. We provided similar explanations for the changes in revenue during fiscal year 2015 compared to fiscal year 2014 for each of the North America, South America, EMEA and Asia Pacific geographic regions. We did not include an analysis of how per unit selling price or volume of principal products contributed to revenues because we did not deem it to be material information to investors for the reasons described in our response letter to the Staff dated November 9, 2015.
On earnings calls, the Company does its best to answer questions by analysts and investors, but this does not necessarily mean the questions, or the answers we may provide, are material to understanding our financial condition, changes in financial condition or results of operations. The commentary provided by our Chief Executive Officer during our earnings call related to volume and price of our products largely consisted of forward looking statements. These statements did not identify a known trend or uncertainty and are immaterial to our actual results of operations for fiscal year 2015.
First report after the company's reply of Dec 21, 2015: 10-Q filed Feb 4, 2016 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 7, 2015 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: request for more time, Oct 16, 2015, closing letter, 2015-12-29