Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0001319161 /10-K filed Nov 20, 2025, compared with Nov 21, 2024 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
Nasdaq Consumer discretionary · Entertainment

Warner Music Group Corp. WMG

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

8 reviews of WMG's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 8 latest letter Mar 2, 2026
Questions asked 82 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 2 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 14 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 82 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 16 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 6 of 8 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 73 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 10-K

2026-03-02 to 2026-03-12 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2026-03-12
SegmentsResults discussion (MD&A)Non-GAAP measures
Item 7. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations · Business Segment Results, page 57
SEC asked (1)
We note that you have presented adjusted OIBDA on a segment basis. This measure appears to be an additional profit/(loss) measure that is not calculated in accordance with GAAP. Please reconcile this measure to the most directly comparable GAAP measure in accordance with Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K and Regulation G. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements 17. Segment Information, page 115
WMG answered
The Company will provide the requested reconciliations for adjusted OIBDA on a segment basis in its periodic reports on Form 10-K and Form 10-Q in future filings. The reconciliations for each of the Recorded Music and Music Publishing segments and Corporate for the fiscal years ended

September 30, 2025, 2024 and 2023 and for the three months ended December 31, 2025 and 2024 are presented in the table below.

Three Months Ended

December 31,

Fiscal Year Ended

September 30,

2025

2024

2023

Recorded Music

Recorded Music operating income

329

238

850

916

875

Depreciation and
Rest of the answer

amortization expense

189

179

205

Restructuring and impairments

198

166

Executive transition costs

—

Net gain on divestitures

(17

)

(41

Non-cash stock-based compensation and other related costs

Recorded Music Adjusted OIBDA

403

323

1,269

1,282

1,094

Music Publishing

Music Publishing operating income

224

200

Depreciation and amortization

127

102

(14

Music Publishing Adjusted OIBDA

361

330

296

Corporate

Corporate operating loss

(106

(79

(380

(331

(285

(1

Transformation initiatives and other related costs

Corporate Adjusted OIBDA

(42

(43

(187

(180

(155

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements

17. Segment Information, page 115

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Mar 11, 2026: 10-Q filed May 7, 2026 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2026 ↗.

Business Segment Results: 86 paragraphs changed; the 3 closest in words to the question are below.

Gone

Adjusted EBITDA as presented below should not be used by investors as an indicator of performance for any future period. Further, our debt instruments require that it be calculated for the most recent four fiscal quarters. As a result, the measure can be disproportionately affected by a particularly strong or weak quarter. Further, it may not be comparable to the measure for any subsequent four-quarter period or any complete fiscal year. In addition, our debt instruments require that the leverage ratio be calculated on a pro forma basis for certain transactions including acquisitions as if such transactions had occurred on the first date of the measurement period and may include expected cost savings and synergies resulting from or related to any such transaction. There can be no assurances that any such cost savings or synergies will be achieved in full.

140 words cut, 0 added sec.gov
Gone

In addition, Adjusted EBITDA is a key measure used by our management to understand and evaluate our operating performance, generate future operating plans and make strategic decisions regarding the allocation of capital. Adjusted EBITDA has limitations as an analytical tool, and you should not consider it in isolation or as a substitute for analysis of our results as reported under U.S. GAAP. Some of those limitations include: (1) it does not reflect the periodic costs of certain capitalized tangible and intangible assets used in generating revenue for our business; (2) it does not reflect the significant interest expense or cash requirements necessary to service interest or principal payments on our indebtedness; and (3) it does not reflect every cash expenditure, future requirements for capital expenditures or contractual commitments. In particular, this measure adds back certain non-cash, extraordinary, unusual or non-recurring charges that are deducted in calculating net income; however, these are expenses that may recur, vary greatly and are difficult to predict. In addition, Adjusted EBITDA is not the same as net income or cash flow provided by operating activities as those terms are defined by U.S. GAAP and does not necessarily indicate whether cash flows will be sufficient to fund cash needs. Accordingly, Adjusted EBITDA should be considered in addition to, not as a substitute for, net income (loss) and other measures of financial performance reported in accordance with U.S. GAAP.

232 words cut, 0 added sec.gov
Gone

The Revolving Credit Facility contains a springing leverage ratio that is tied to a ratio based on EBITDA, which is defined under the Revolving Credit Agreement. Our ability to borrow funds under the Revolving Credit Facility may depend upon our ability to meet the leverage ratio test at the end of a fiscal quarter to the extent we have drawn a certain amount of revolving loans. On May 4, 2021, certain covenants set forth in our Revolving Credit Facility were suspended, including the restriction on incurring certain additional indebtedness, based on the determination that the total indebtedness to EBITDA ratio is below the required threshold specified therein. EBITDA as defined in the Revolving Credit Facility is based on Consolidated Net Income (as defined in the Revolving Credit Facility), both of which terms differ from the terms “EBITDA” and “net income” as they are commonly used. For example, the calculation of EBITDA under the Revolving Credit Facility, in addition to adjusting net income to exclude interest expense, income taxes and depreciation and amortization, also adjusts net income by excluding items or expenses such as, among other items, (1) the amount of any restructuring charges or reserves; (2) any non-cash charges (including any impairment charges); (3) any net loss resulting from hedging currency exchange risks; (4) the amount of management, monitoring, consulting and advisory fees paid to Access; (5) business optimization expenses (including consolidation initiatives, severance costs and other costs relating to initiatives aimed at profitability improvement); (6) transaction expenses; (7) equity-based compensation expense; and (8) certain extraordinary, unusual or non-recurring items. The definition of EBITDA under the Revolving Credit Facility also includes adjustments for the pro forma impact of certain projected cost savings, operating expense reductions and synergies and any quality of earnings analysis prepared by independent certified public accountants in connection with an acquisition, merger, consolidation or other investment. The Senior Term Loan Facility and the Secured Notes Indenture use financial measures called “Consolidated EBITDA” or “EBITDA” and “Consolidated Net Income” that have substantially the same definitions to EBITDA and Consolidated Net Income, each as defined under the Revolving Credit Agreement.

351 words cut, 0 added sec.gov

Paragraphs where only numbers, dates or period words changed are not shown. Cut words struck through, new words highlighted.

Item 7. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations · Business Segment Results, page 57
SEC asked (2)
Please revise your disclosure to provide a reconciliation of your total segment profit/(loss) measure to your consolidated income before taxes for each reporting period presented as required by ASC 280-10-50-30.
WMG answered
The Company will revise its segment footnote disclosure in future periodic reports on Form 10-K and

Form 10-Q as set forth below.

Recorded

Music expenses and

Publishing eliminations

Total

(in millions)

Revenues

5,408

1,306

(7

6,707

Cost of revenue

2,818

821

3,632

Selling and marketing expense

615

642

Distribution expense

112

General and administrative expense

679

131

325

1,135

Restructuring & Impairment

234

Amortization expense

136

122

258

Operating income (loss)

694

Interest expense, net

162

Other expense, net

Income before income taxes

490

Total
Rest of the answer

assets

5,328

3,463

1,038

9,829

Capital expenditures

114

139

Depreciation expense

118

September 30, 2024

5,223

1,210

6,426

2,599

763

3,355

663

685

105

664

123

302

1,089

177

(32

823

161

601

4,945

3,017

1,193

9,155

116

103

September 30, 2023

4,955

1,088

(6

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Mar 11, 2026: 10-Q filed May 7, 2026 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2026 ↗.

Business Segment Results: 86 paragraphs changed; the 3 closest in words to the question are below.

Gone

The Revolving Credit Facility contains a springing leverage ratio that is tied to a ratio based on EBITDA, which is defined under the Revolving Credit Agreement. Our ability to borrow funds under the Revolving Credit Facility may depend upon our ability to meet the leverage ratio test at the end of a fiscal quarter to the extent we have drawn a certain amount of revolving loans. On May 4, 2021, certain covenants set forth in our Revolving Credit Facility were suspended, including the restriction on incurring certain additional indebtedness, based on the determination that the total indebtedness to EBITDA ratio is below the required threshold specified therein. EBITDA as defined in the Revolving Credit Facility is based on Consolidated Net Income (as defined in the Revolving Credit Facility), both of which terms differ from the terms “EBITDA” and “net income” as they are commonly used. For example, the calculation of EBITDA under the Revolving Credit Facility, in addition to adjusting net income to exclude interest expense, income taxes and depreciation and amortization, also adjusts net income by excluding items or expenses such as, among other items, (1) the amount of any restructuring charges or reserves; (2) any non-cash charges (including any impairment charges); (3) any net loss resulting from hedging currency exchange risks; (4) the amount of management, monitoring, consulting and advisory fees paid to Access; (5) business optimization expenses (including consolidation initiatives, severance costs and other costs relating to initiatives aimed at profitability improvement); (6) transaction expenses; (7) equity-based compensation expense; and (8) certain extraordinary, unusual or non-recurring items. The definition of EBITDA under the Revolving Credit Facility also includes adjustments for the pro forma impact of certain projected cost savings, operating expense reductions and synergies and any quality of earnings analysis prepared by independent certified public accountants in connection with an acquisition, merger, consolidation or other investment. The Senior Term Loan Facility and the Secured Notes Indenture use financial measures called “Consolidated EBITDA” or “EBITDA” and “Consolidated Net Income” that have substantially the same definitions to EBITDA and Consolidated Net Income, each as defined under the Revolving Credit Agreement.

351 words cut, 0 added sec.gov
Gone

The following is a reconciliation of net income (loss), which is a U.S. GAAP measure of our operating results, to Adjusted EBITDA as defined, for the most recently ended four fiscal quarters, or the twelve months ended December 31, 2025, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2024 and for the three months ended December 31, 2025 and December 31, 2024. In addition, the reconciliation includes the calculation of the Senior Secured Indebtedness to Adjusted EBITDA ratio, which we refer to as the Leverage Ratio, under the Revolving Credit Agreement for the most recently ended four fiscal quarters, or the twelve months ended December 31, 2025. The terms and related calculations are defined in the Revolving Credit Agreement. All amounts in the reconciliation below reflect Acquisition Corp. (in millions, except ratios):

131 words cut, 0 added sec.gov
New paragraph

Reconciliation of Net Income Attributable to Warner Music Group Corp. and Operating Income to Consolidated Adjusted OIBDA

0 words cut, 17 added sec.gov

Paragraphs where only numbers, dates or period words changed are not shown. Cut words struck through, new words highlighted.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2026-03-12

Form S-1

2019-10-30 to 2020-05-29 · 10 questions · 3 letters from the SEC, 5 from the company
No closing letter
Liquidity and cashResults discussion (MD&A)RevenueCritical estimatesRisk factors
SEC letter of Oct 30, 2019 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
Draft Registration Statement Submitted October 1, 2019 · Dividend Policy, page 47
SEC asked (1)
Please revise your disclosures to clarify whether you intend to continue paying a variable dividend in the fourth quarter of each fiscal year as discussed on page F-87. Also, please revise your disclosure to disclose the dividends per share paid to date to put your disclosure in context. Refer to Item 201(c) of Regulation S-K.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Draft Registration Statement Submitted October 1, 2019 · Dividend Policy, page 47
SEC asked (2)
Please demonstrate to us that you have a reasonable basis for concluding that you expect to have earnings and cash flows sufficient to cover the projected dividend.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Draft Registration Statement Submitted October 1, 2019 · Dividend Policy, page 47
SEC asked (3)
We note your disclosure regarding your dividend policy and contractual restrictions with respect to the payment of dividends. Please describe the most significant restrictions on the payment of dividends, indicating their sources, their pertinent provisions and the amount of retained earnings or net income restricted or free of restrictions. Please refer to Rule 4-08(e) of Regulation S-X.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked (4)
Please revise your discussion to describe material commitments for capital expenditures and indicate the general purpose of such commitments and the anticipated source of funds needed to fulfill such commitments. Refer to Item 303(a)(2) of Regulation S-K and the Commission’s Guidance Regarding Management Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, Release No. 33-8350.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Critical Accounting Policies · Revenue and Cost Recognition, page 98
SEC asked (5)
Please provide disclosure about your critical accounting estimates and assumptions under ASC 606. Additionally, please disclose the impact of such estimates and assumptions on your financial condition and operating performance. Refer to SEC Release No. 33-8350.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Relationship with Access Following this Offering · Shareholder Agreement, page 151
SEC asked (6)
We note that your Shareholder Agreement with Access will govern your relationship with Access following the offering, including matters related to corporate governance, board nomination rights and information rights. Please revise your disclosure to discuss the material terms of the Shareholders Agreement, and include any material risk factors as applicable.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Consolidated Financial Statements · Consolidated Statements of Operations, page F-4
SEC asked (7)
Please present basic and diluted earnings per share for each period presented pursuant to ASC 260-10-45. Also, provide the disclosures required by ASC 260-10-50.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Consolidated Statements of (Deficit) Equity, page F-7
SEC asked (8)
Please disclose your dividends per share for each period presented here and in the selected financial data section. Refer to Rule 3-04 of Regulation S-X and Instruction 2 to Item 301 of Regulation S-K.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

SEC letter of Nov 18, 2019 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
Dividend Policy, page 47
SEC asked
We note your response to comment 2, and that the Secured Notes Indenture, the Senior Notes Indenture, the Revolving Credit Agreement and the Senior Term Loan Credit Agreement each contain certain provisions that restrict the payment of dividends, subject to certain exceptions. Please revise to describe in further detail the most significant contractual provisions that restrict the payment of dividends.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Consolidated Financial Statements · Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm, page F-2
SEC asked
Please make arrangements with your auditors to revise their report to refer to the correct location where financial statement schedule II is listed.
WMG answered
The Registrant’s auditors have revised their report to refer to the correct location where financial statement schedule II is listed. Please see page F-2 of Amendment No. 3.
Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Feb 21, 2020, company letter, Feb 25, 2020, company letter, May 29, 2020, company letter, May 29, 2020

Form 10-K

2014-03-14 to 2014-03-25 · 3 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2014-03-25
Non-GAAP measures
Signatures
SEC asked (1)
Please confirm that in future filings you will revise the second half of the signature block so that it is signed by someone with the indicated capacity of principal financial officer and either principal accounting officer or controller.
WMG answered
We confirm that in future filings we will review and revise, if necessary, the second half of the signature block so that it is signed by someone with the indicated capacity of principal financial officer and either principal accounting officer or controller.
Read in the reply
Form 8-K furnished February 6, 2014 · Exhibit 99.1
SEC asked (2)
Please present with equal or greater prominence, net income calculated in accordance with GAAP, in the headlines on page 1 of your results for the fiscal first quarter ended December 31, 2013 in accordance with Item 10(e)(1)(i)(A) of Regulation S-K.
WMG answered
We confirm that we will add an additional line in the headlines of our earnings releases to present net income calculated in accordance with

GAAP, with equal or greater prominence, in future applicable filings.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Mar 21, 2014: 10-Q filed May 8, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 6, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Other
SEC asked (3)
Data about your company included in the SEC’s EDGAR system includes the company’s current fiscal year end. However, it appears that the fiscal year end listed for your company does not agree with the actual fiscal year end of your most recent annual periodic report.
Rest of the question

Please correct the fiscal year end listed in EDGAR as follows:  log onto your account at https://www.edgarfiling.sec.gov  select “retrieve/edit data” from the left-side menu  select “retrieve company information”  select “edit company information” at the bottom of the screen  enter the month and day of your fiscal year end (e.g., “1231” or “0630”) in the “fiscal year end” field  and finally select “submit change” at the bottom of the screen. If your fiscal year end is not a fixed date and instead varies by a few days each year pursuant to your articles of incorporation (e.g., the first Tuesday following May 31st), please list your fiscal year end for this purpose as the fixed date on which your fiscal year end is based (e.g., May 31st, or “0531”). In your case, this appears to be September 30th, or “0930.”

WMG answered
We confirm that we have updated the EDGAR system to reflect our fiscal year end as September 30th, or “0930,” as requested.

In addition to the aforementioned responses to the

Staff’s comments, the Company acknowledges that:

the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the
Rest of the answer

federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2014-03-25

Form 10-K

2013-03-18 to 2013-05-30 · 13 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2013-05-30
Liquidity and cashDebtGoodwill and impairmentResults discussion (MD&A)Legal and contingenciesRevenueIncome taxesControlsCritical estimates
Management’s Discussion and Analysis · Results of Operations, page 52
SEC asked (1)
Throughout your discussion, please quantify each factor cited that contributed to the changes in revenues and expenses. For example, on page 54 you disclose that the increase in digital revenue was driven by continued success of streaming services, growth of digital downloads in the U.S.
Rest of the question

and emerging digital markets in Latin America and certain European territories, partially offset by the continued decline in global ringtone revenue, but you do not quantify any of these factors. Please revise your disclosure and ensure that your revised disclosure is sufficiently detailed in explaining the factors cited and analyzing the underlying reasons for the factors. Refer to section 501.04 of the Codification of Financial Reporting Releases for guidance.

WMG answered
We note for the Staff that digital revenue is a component of the Company’s total revenue, and thus, the

Company’s disclosure of the amount of its digital revenue itself reflects a quantification of a significant factor that contributed to the change in the Company’s revenue line item. Similar quantitative disclosure is provided for other components of the Company’s revenue and for the Company’s cost of revenues.
Rest of the answer

See pages 53 – 59 of the Form 10-K.

Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Company recognizes its obligations under section 501.04 of the Codification of Financial Reporting

Releases and therefore in future applicable filings will disclose the magnitude and relative impact of each material factor when two or more factors are cited as contributing to a variation of a line item, consistent with the requirements of section

501.04 of the Codification of Financial Reporting Releases.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Liquidity · Contractual and Other Obligations, page 89
SEC asked (2)
Please include the scheduled annual fees due Access pursuant to the management agreement you entered into with Access, which is noted on page 52 of your filing. According to your disclosure on page 124, it appears the minimum fee is $6 million per year. Please revise accordingly.
Rest of the question

Since the fee to Access may be higher, consider providing additional information below the table to enable investors to readily understand how the fee may vary.

WMG answered
Under its management agreement with Access, the Company is obligated to pay Access an aggregate annual fee equal to the greater of

(i) the sum of (x) $6,000,000 and (y) 1.5% of the aggregate amount of Acquired EBITDA (as defined in the management agreement) as at such time and (ii) 1.5% of the EBITDA (as defined in the WMG Holdings Corp. 13.75% Senior Notes due 2019 as required by the management agreement) of the Company for the applicable fiscal year. Thus, as the Staff correctly notes, the minimum annual fee to be paid by the Company to Access is $6,000,000.
Rest of the answer

In future applicable filings, the Company will include this $6,000,000 plus 1.5% of any Acquired EBITDA annual base amount obligation in the “Contractual and Other Obligations” table, and will include as a footnote to such table a discussion of the circumstances under which the amount payable under its management agreement with Access may be in excess of such annual base amount.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 6: Goodwill and Intangible Assets · Other Intangible Assets, page 118
SEC asked (3)
We note the expected useful life of your music publishing copyrights increased to 28 years after the July 20, 2011 merger from 10 to 15 years prior to the merger. Given your disclosure, both before and after the merger, that the useful lives of definite-lived intangible assets are evaluated based on expected future cash flows associated with the assets, and given that the useful life of this asset was presumably
Rest of the question

partially consumed prior to the merger, please explain to us why the post-merger useful life is significantly longer than the remaining useful life immediately prior to the merger, how you determined the post-merger useful life, and why you believe it is reasonable and appropriate. As part of your response, please also address other categories of definite-lived intangibles whose post-merger useful lives exceeded their pre-merger remaining useful lives.

WMG answered
We note that in 2003, a private equity consortium of investors formed the Company to acquire Warner Music Group from Time Warner Inc. In conjunction with the acquisition by the Company of Warner Music

Group from Time Warner Inc. effective March 1, 2004, management identified and valued the tangible and intangible assets acquired and liabilities assumed. The amortizable intangible assets identified were then assigned useful lives based upon the information available at that time, which included management’s projections of estimated future cash flows.
Rest of the answer

Subsequent to the establishment of the intangible assets and their useful lives, management evaluated at each reporting period

“…whether events and circumstances warrant a revision to the remaining period of amortization…” in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 350-30-35-9 of Accounting Standards Codification (“ASC”) topic 350,

Intangibles-Goodwill and Other. No such events or changes in circumstances had occurred; therefore management determined that a detailed analysis of the remaining useful lives was not necessary.

On July 20, 2011, the Company was acquired by AI Entertainment Holdings LLC, an affiliate of Access Industries, Inc. Similar to

2004, in conjunction with the acquisition, management identified and valued the tangible and intangible assets acquired and liabilities assumed and the amortizable intangible assets identified were assigned useful lives.

The amortizable intangible assets identified were assigned useful lives using the “Least Squared Errors” method. This method assigns a useful life based on the pattern of amortization that best matches the cash flows expected to be derived by the asset. The Least Squared Errors method considers both the timing and magnitude of the underlying cash flows for each asset.

As a result of applying the Least Squared Errors method management noted that, with the exception of Music Publishing copyrights, the useful lives assigned to the amortizable intangible assets identified were commensurate with the fiscal 2004 assessment. Management believes that comparing the initial useful lives is more meaningful than comparing the remaining useful lives of the fiscal 2004 assets to the newly established lives of the fiscal 2011 assets. This is due to the fact that, while the nature of the intangible assets identified is consistent with fiscal 2004, the make-up of the underlying assets is different. For example, the Recorded Music catalog valued in fiscal 2004 would have consisted of sound recordings the Company owned the rights to at that time. The fiscal 2011 Recorded Music catalog included the sound recordings from fiscal 2004, less any rights that reverted back to recording artists or were sold, plus all new sound recordings that had been created by the Company from fiscal 2004 to fiscal 2011. Accordingly, the remaining useful lives of the fiscal 2004 assets immediately prior to the acquisition and the newly established lives of the fiscal 2011 assets would not be comparable.

A key driver in the determination of the value and useful lives of the intangible assets was the underlying financial (cashflow) projections. Specifically in the case of Music Publishing copyrights, a key driver in determining the useful life was the “decay rate” which is the assumption about how the financial contribution of the musical compositions acquired will behave over time. In preparing the financial projections and evaluating the reasonableness of the useful lives calculated for Music Publishing copyrights and the related decay rates, management considered the following:

•

Music Publishing has an extensive and highly diversified catalog with no individual songwriter or musical composition making up more than 1% of total revenue;

Management evaluated the contribution by musical composition for the top 245 musical compositions by annual contribution by fiscal year for the period from fiscal 2008 to 2010. It was noted that each musical composition individually had relatively consistent performance over the period;

Management also evaluated the behavior of the top 15,000 musical compositions grouped by annual contribution (e.g., all compositions with contributions greater than $250,000, greater than $100,000, etc.) from fiscal 2008 to 2010. Excluding the new compositions added subsequent to fiscal 2008, it was noted that the contribution generated by these musical compositions was relatively consistent over the period. This analysis further evidenced a slow decay rate for the catalog as a whole, not just the top 245 compositions analyzed previously; and

The new owner of the Company, Access Industries, Inc., appeared to be more focused on the Music Publishing copyrights and the related exploitation of those rights than the previous owners. The underlying financial projections used to determine the value/life of these rights reflect this greater focus, which has been further evidenced since the acquisition by Access’ actions including, but not limited to, certain management changes, taking a global view of Music Publishing catalog exploitation strategy, making Music Publishing catalog acquisitions and making IT investments to the systems used for tracking owned copyrights and the related exploitation.

As previously noted, the useful lives of Music Publishing assets increased in the fiscal 2011 assessment when compared to the lives determined in the fiscal 2004 assessment. This is a result of management’s projections, the new owner’s focus on the exploitation of Music Publishing copyrights and the decay rates utilized based on the analysis of the behavior of the copyrights.

Based on the aforementioned factors management believes the useful lives established in conjunction with the fiscal 2011 acquisition are appropriate. On an annual basis the Company will continue to analyze whether events and circumstances warrant a revision to the remaining period of amortization in accordance with the ASC topic 350.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 9: Income Taxes, page 120
SEC asked (4)
In the table on page 121 that presents the differences between the U.S. Federal statutory income tax rate and income taxes provided, you report the line item “Loss without benefit/(release of valuation allowance), net.” It appears this line represents two different effects, which may be opposite from one another (that is, the “loss without benefit” increases tax expense, whereas the “release of valuation allowance”
Rest of the question

reduces tax expense). Please present a line item for each respective effect represented in this line for transparency, or advise why your presentation is meaningful.

WMG answered
In future applicable filings, the Company will no longer present the Company’s “loss without benefit” and “release of valuation allowance” on a net basis and will present a separate line item for each such amount to the extent such separate disclosure is required from a materiality perspective.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Item 9A. Controls and Procedures · Evaluation of Disclosure Controls and Procedures, page 151
SEC asked (5)
Please note that Item 307 of Regulation S-K requires a conclusion as to the effectiveness of “disclosure controls and procedures” as defined in the Exchange Act rules. Please represent to us whether or not these controls were effective at September 30, 2012, and revise your filing accordingly.
WMG answered
As requested, the Company hereby represents to the Staff that as of September 30, 2012, based on management’s evaluation (with the participation of the Company’s principal executive officer and principal financial officer), the Company’s principal executive officer and principal financial officer have concluded that the Company’s Disclosure Controls are effective to provide reasonable assurance that information required to be disclosed in reports that the Company files or submits under the Exchange Act will be recorded, processed, summarized and reported within the time periods specified in
Rest of the answer

SEC rules and forms, including that such information is accumulated and communicated to management, including the principal executive officer and principal financial officer, as appropriate to allow timely decisions regarding required disclosure. The Company will include a similar conclusion as to the effectiveness of its disclosure controls and procedures in its future applicable filings with respect to the period covered by such reports.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Notes to Consolidated Interim Financial Statements · Note 6: Commitments and Contingencies, page 13
SEC asked (6)
It appears that the ongoing lawsuits in regard to “Pricing of Digital Music Downloads” and “Music Download Putative Class Action Suits” may be material to investors. In this regard, please disclose for either an estimate of the loss or range of loss (or, if true, state that the estimate is immaterial in lieu of providing quantified amounts) or state that such an estimate cannot be made, pursuant to ASC
Rest of the question

450-20-50-4.b. You may provide your disclosures on an aggregated basis. Please include your proposed disclosure in your response. If you conclude that you cannot estimate the reasonably possible loss or range of loss, please explain to us (1) the procedures you undertake on a quarterly basis to attempt to develop a range of reasonably possible loss for disclosure and (2) what specific factors are causing the inability to estimate a loss and when you expect those factors to be alleviated. We recognize that there are a number of uncertainties and potential outcomes associated with loss contingencies. Nonetheless, an effort should be made to develop estimates for purposes of disclosure, including determining which of the potential outcomes are reasonably possible and what the reasonably possible range of losses would be for those reasonably possible outcomes.

WMG answered
In determining whether there is a reasonable possibility that a loss or an additional loss has been incurred with respect to any claims, members of the Legal and Finance functions in conjunction with the Company’s outside counsel review the status of claims made against the Company on at least a quarterly basis. Such review includes the assessment of the status of asserted and unasserted claims, including the facts and circumstances of the claims, the theories of asserted liability, the stage of the proceedings, the Company’s defenses and its past experiences with respect to similar claims.
Rest of the answer

Based upon such analysis, the Company determines the probability of liability with respect to such claims and whether an estimate of reasonably possible loss or range of loss can be made with respect to such claims. If a loss is determined to be probable and reasonably estimable, an accrual for such estimate will be recorded. With respect to disclosed matters for which a loss is reasonably possible and the possible loss or range of loss is reasonably estimable, the Company will disclose the possible losses or range of losses on an aggregate basis. With respect to each disclosed matter for which the Company cannot reasonably estimate the possible loss or range of loss, the Company will conclude that the possible loss or range of loss cannot be reasonably estimated.

Based upon this review, the Company determined that it was not possible at December 31, 2012 to estimate the ultimate loss to resolve the proceedings described under the heading “Pricing of Digital Music Downloads” and “Music Download Putative Class Action Suits” (each a “Specified Lawsuit”) or even a range of losses due to the uncertainties inherent with such claims. These uncertainties include but are not limited to the results of ongoing discovery, a less than complete factual record, damage theories and demands, legal theories and their resolution by judges, juries or regulators and the unpredictable nature of opposing parties and their demands. We note for the Staff that page 14 of the notes to the financial statements in the Form 10-Q provides the following disclosure:

“An estimate of the reasonably possible loss or range of loss in excess of the amounts already accrued cannot be made at this time due to various factors typical in contested proceedings, including (1) uncertain damage theories and demands; (2) a less than complete factual record; (3) uncertainty concerning legal theories and their resolution by courts or regulators; and (4) the unpredictable nature of the opposing party and its demands. However, we cannot predict with certainty the outcome of any litigation or the potential for future litigation. As such, we continuously monitor these proceedings as they develop and adjust any accrual or disclosure as needed.”

The Company will continue to include such disclosure in its future applicable filings and will also include in such filings either an estimate of the loss or range of loss where such amount is estimable, or the following disclosure under the heading for each Specified Lawsuit and any additional claims that may be material to investors:

“The outcome of the claims to which the Company is a party cannot be determined and an estimate of the reasonably possible loss or range of loss cannot presently be made.”

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Financial Condition and Liquidity · Covenant Compliance, page 51
SEC asked (7)
Please specifically state whether or not you are in compliance with all covenants in effect. If any covenants are close to being noncompliant, identify which ones and the degree to which the covenant is in compliance.
WMG answered
The Company confirms to the Staff that it was in compliance with its covenants under its outstanding notes, term loan credit agreement and revolving credit facility as of December 31, 2012. The Company will include disclosure in its future applicable filings, if accurate, that the Company was in compliance with its covenants under its outstanding financing arrangements as of the end of the period covered by such filing and will describe whether any covenants are close to being noncompliant.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Financial Condition and Liquidity · Covenant Compliance, page 51
SEC asked (8)
You present the measure “consolidated EBITDA” as calculated pursuant to your new revolving credit facility. You state that your notes and term loan credit agreement also use similar measures called “consolidated EBITDA” or “EBITDA.” Please explain to us and disclose why you chose to present the measure as calculated pursuant to the new revolving credit facility instead of or in addition to the measures associated
Rest of the question

with your other debt arrangements. In so doing, tell us which measure of each arrangement is the most restrictive, or limiting, to you. Also, please advise if there are material financial measures associated with your notes and term loan credit agreement of which investors should be aware.

WMG answered
As disclosed in the Form 10-Q, the Company’s revolving credit facility does not include any financial maintenance covenants other than a springing leverage ratio, which will be tested only when there are loans outstanding under the revolving credit facility in excess of $30,000,000 (excluding (i) letters of credit that have been cash collateralized and (ii) undrawn outstanding letters of credit that have not been cash collateralized not exceeding $20,000,000).
Rest of the answer

The financial maintenance covenant provides that if the outstanding aggregate principal amount of borrowings under the new revolving credit facility is greater than $30,000,000 at the end of a fiscal quarter, the maximum leverage ratio permitted under the new revolving credit facility is 6.00x as of the end of any fiscal quarter in fiscal 2013. The Company has therefore provided disclosure in the Form 10-Q setting forth the Company’s calculation of

“Consolidated EBITDA” pursuant to the Company’s new revolving credit facility and the corresponding leverage ratio.

We supplementally advise the Staff that the references in the Form 10-Q to “Consolidated EBITDA” and “EBITDA” with respect to the notes and term loan credit agreement will not be included in future filings. Such disclosure had previously been included in the Form 10-Q in connection with the Company’s financing arrangements that were outstanding prior to the Company’s refinancing of its previously existing indebtedness.

The currently outstanding notes, the term loan agreement and the revolving credit facility do not contain any additional financial maintenance covenants. As mentioned above, the only financial maintenance covenant to which the Company is subject under its debt instruments is the springing leverage ratio under its revolving credit facility. The Company is also subject to certain negative covenants under its debt instruments that restrict the Company’s ability to take certain actions including, among other things, the incurrence of indebtedness or the making of restricted payments. Qualitative disclosure with respect to these covenants is included in the Form 10-Q. Under these covenants, there are customary “baskets” that permit the Company to incur indebtedness and make restricted payments up to certain specified amounts. As disclosed on page 54 of the Form 10-Q, management believes that funds generated from the Company’s operations and borrowings under its revolving credit facility will be sufficient to fund its debt service requirements, working capital requirements and capital expenditure requirements for the foreseeable future.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Financial Condition and Liquidity · Covenant Compliance, page 51
SEC asked (9)
Please clarify the computation indicated in footnote (h) in regard to the “consolidated funded indebtedness, less cash” ratio presented on page 52. It is not clear which items are additive or subtractive in arriving at the amount presented.
WMG answered
We supplementally advise the Staff that the “Consolidated Funded Indebtedness, less cash” set forth in footnote

(h) to the table on page 52 of the Form 10-Q reflects (a) the principal balance of external debt at WMG Acquisition Corp. of approximately $2,100,000,000, plus (b) the annualized daily revolver borrowings of approximately

$3,000,000, plus (c) contractual obligations of deferred purchase price of approximately $2,000,000, plus (d) contingent consideration related to acquisitions of approximately $16,000,000 as of December 31, 2012, minus (e) the amount of cash and cash equivalents
Rest of the answer

of the Company as of December 31, 2012 not exceeding $150,000,000. The Company will revise its future applicable filings to clarify whether the amounts are additive or subtractive in arriving at this figure.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Financial Condition and Liquidity · Covenant Compliance, page 51
SEC asked (10)
In footnote (i) to the “leverage ratio” in the table on page 52 you disclose the maximum ratio permitted under the new revolving credit facility when the outstanding aggregate principal amount of borrowings under the facility is greater than $30 million. Please disclose the permitted ratio when the outstanding aggregate principal amount of borrowings under the facility is less than $30 million.
WMG answered
We supplementally advise the Staff that the Company’s revolving credit facility does not impose any “leverage ratio” restrictions on the Company when the aggregate principal amount of borrowings under the revolving credit facility is less than $30,000,000 at the end of a fiscal quarter. The Company will revise its future applicable filings to clarify this description.

In addition to the aforementioned responses to the Staff’s comments, the Company acknowledges that:

the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to
Rest of the answer

disclosure in response to comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 5, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 6: Goodwill and Intangible Assets · Other Intangible Assets, page 118
SEC asked (1)
Refer to your response to our prior comment 3. Please tell us how you concluded that the useful life of music publishing copyrights was 28 years and why you believe this life is reasonable and appropriate relative to another period of time.
WMG answered
Management’s conclusion that the appropriate useful life of the music publishing copyrights is 28 years was based on both quantitative and qualitative factors. The Company owns or administers over one million music publishing copyrights from over 65,000 songwriters and composers. These copyrights span multiple generations and music genres, including an extensive collection of owned evergreen standards, holiday classics and theatrical pieces.
Rest of the answer

The Company’s music publishing copyright catalog has a deep foundation including older classics that have stood the test of time and continue to generate consistent revenues. Examples of music publishing copyrights owned or administered by the Company include: Happy Birthday to You, Winter Wonderland, Frosty the Snowman, The Lady is a Tramp, When a Man Loves a

Woman, I Got You Babe, Staying Alive, Star Wars Theme, Eye of the Tiger, Celebration, Livin’ La Vida Loca, etc. Due to the Company’s extensive and highly diversified music publishing catalog, no individual songwriter or musical composition makes up more than 1% of total revenue in any given period. As noted in our previous response, in developing the decay rates to be applied to the music publishing copyright revenue streams, management prepared a detailed analysis of the behavior of the copyrights over a three-year period (2008 – 2010). This analysis supported the qualitative factors cited above and helped to illustrate the consistency of the individual music publishing copyright contribution (i.e., slow decay rates).

As an example, when analyzing the top 25 songs by total revenue management noted that in the three-year period analyzed, only two of the songs were brand new, i.e., copyrighted in that three-year period. Six of the top 25 songs were holiday-related and are therefore very consistent earners as evidenced by the fact that five of those songs appear in the top 25 for each of the three years examined. Of the songs from the 1950’s and prior, two appear in the top 5 in each of the three years examined and seven appear in the top 25 for each of the three years examined. In addition, 76% of the top 25 songs were from the 1980’s and prior.

The decay rates developed by management for the music publishing copyrights were based on the observed behavior as a result of this analysis. These decay rates were then applied to the underlying music publishing copyright revenue streams. The adjusted revenue streams were the basis for determining the appropriate useful life of the music publishing copyright intangible asset by utilizing the “Least Squared Errors” method. This method assigns a useful life based on the pattern of amortization that best matches the cash flows expected to be derived by the asset. The Least Squared Errors method considers both the timing and magnitude of the underlying cash flows for each asset and is calculated as follows:

•

Start with the forecasted cash flows for each year associated with the asset;

Project the annual amortization that would result from the assignment of a specific useful life to the asset;

Compute the difference between the cash flow and the amortization in each year;

Square the difference computed above for each year;

Add all of the squared differences to arrive at a measure of how closely the assigned amortization pattern matches the forecasted cash flows; and

Determine which useful life provides the smallest sum of squared differences (i.e. the best match of amortization with cash flows)

As a result of the Least Squared Errors calculation, the useful life for the music publishing copyright intangible asset was determined to be 28 years as that was the period that resulted in the best match of amortization to cash flows.

Based on management’s industry experience, the focus on music publishing copyrights by the new owners and all of the quantitative and qualitative factors noted above and in our previous response, management believes that the 28 year useful life assigned to the music publishing copyrights at the date of acquisition is most appropriate relative to any other period of time. Management also noted through the review of filings by competitors with music publishing copyrights, that the lives assigned to those intangible assets were materially consistent with its own analysis.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 6: Goodwill and Intangible Assets · Other Intangible Assets, page 118
SEC asked (2)
Please expand your disclosure in “critical accounting policies” to discuss the significant factors, assumptions, judgments and uncertainties considered in your determination and ongoing assessment of the useful life of your music publishing copyrights. Include an analysis of the sensitivity of how your results may differ under different factors, assumptions and judgments you consider in assessing the useful life.
Rest of the question

Refer to Section V of “Interpretation: Commission Guidance Regarding Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations” available on our website at http://www.sec.gov/rules/interp/33-8350.htm for further guidance.

WMG answered
In our discussion of critical accounting policies we currently include the following for Business Combinations and the related process for determining fair value:

Business Combinations

We account for our business acquisitions under the Financial Accounting Standards Board (“FASB”) authoritative guidance for business combinations. The total cost of acquisitions is allocated to the underlying identifiable net assets based on their respective estimated fair values. The excess of the purchase price over the estimated fair values of the net assets acquired is recorded as goodwill.
Rest of the answer

Determining the fair value of assets acquired and liabilities assumed requires management’s judgment and often involves the use of significant estimates and assumptions, including assumptions with respect to future cash inflows and outflows, discount rates, asset lives and market multiples, among other items.

To the extent a significant acquisition is made during a fiscal year, we will expand the discussion similar to that provided for the goodwill impairment analysis to discuss specific assumptions and inputs to the model used to determine the fair value of acquired assets and assumption of liabilities, including a sensitivity analysis.

We also currently include a discussion of the Valuation of Long-Lived Assets in Note 3

– Summary of Significant Accounting Policies in the notes to our consolidated audited financial statements. In future filings of our Form 10-K we will also include this discussion in the Critical Accounting Policies, and we will update to specifically discuss amortizable intangibles as follows:

Valuation of Long-Lived Assets

The Company periodically reviews the carrying value of its long-lived assets, including property, plant and equipment and amortizable intangible assets, whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying value may not be recoverable or that the lives assigned may no longer be appropriate. To the extent the estimated future cash inflows attributable to the asset, less estimated future cash outflows, are less than the carrying amount, an impairment loss is recognized in an amount equal to the difference between the carrying value of such asset and its fair value. Assets to be disposed of and for which there is a committed plan to dispose of the assets, whether through sale or abandonment, are reported at the lower of carrying value or fair value less costs to sell. If it is determined that events and circumstances warrant a revision to the remaining period of amortization, an asset’s remaining useful life shall be changed, and the remaining carrying amount of the asset shall be amortized prospectively over that revised remaining useful life.

To the extent that during a fiscal year a review was warranted based on events or changes in circumstances, management will include a discussion of the analysis, including the key assumptions and inputs to the model as well as a sensitivity discussion surrounding those assumptions and inputs. The discussion will be similar in content to the discussion of our annual goodwill and indefinite lived intangibles impairment and sensitivity analysis as currently included in our Critical Accounting Policies.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Notes to Consolidated Interim Financial Statements · Note 6: Commitments and Contingencies, page 13
SEC asked (3)
Refer to your response to our prior comment 6. We note that the reference in your response to the disclosure on page 14 of the notes to the financial statements in the Form 10-Q is in regard to “other matters” and not the specific matters disclosed.
Rest of the question

In regard to the specific matters disclosed, your response indicates that you will disclose “The outcome of the claims to which the Company is a party cannot be determined and an estimate of the reasonably possible loss or range of loss cannot presently be made.” To comply with the disclosure requirement of ASC 450-20-50-4.b, your determination of the amount of the reasonably possible loss or range of loss to disclose for these proceedings should be based on your determination of all of the potential outcomes that are reasonably possible and not just a determination of “the” outcome. For example, if an unfavorable decision is a potential reasonably possible outcome for the specific matters disclosed, disclose the associated amount of the reasonably possible loss or range of loss, or state, if true, that such is not material or that it cannot be estimated. Please advise, and revise your disclosure as appropriate.

WMG answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company will include under the heading for each lawsuit specified in any applicable filing, an estimate of the reasonably possible loss or range of loss where such amount is estimable with respect to a potential outcome that is reasonably possible, or the following disclosure:

“The potential outcomes of these claims that are reasonably possible cannot be determined at this time and an estimate of the reasonably possible loss or range of loss cannot presently be made.”

In addition to the aforementioned responses to the Staff’s comments, the Company
Rest of the answer

acknowledges that:

the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2013: 10-Q filed May 14, 2013 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 14, 2013 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2013-05-30

Form S-4

2012-02-15 to 2012-03-06 · 14 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
No closing letter
SEC letter of Feb 15, 2012 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
General
SEC asked (1)
We note that you are registering the exchange offer in reliance on our position enunciated in Exxon Capital Holdings Corp., SEC No-Action Letter (April 13, 1988). See also Morgan Stanley & Co. Inc., SEC No-Action Letter (June 5, 1991) and Shearman & Sterling, SEC No-Action Letter (July 2, 1993).
Rest of the question

Accordingly, with the next amendment, please provide us with a supplemental letter stating that you are registering the exchange offer in reliance on our position contained in these letters and include the representations contained in the Morgan Stanley and Shearman & Sterling no-action letters.

WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Summary, page 1 · Our Company, page 1
SEC asked (2)
Please revise the first paragraph of this section and specifically the last sentence to add balancing language regarding your net loss for the twelve months ended September 30, 2011.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.2
SEC asked (3)
Please refer to the last paragraph on page F-2. Please delete the qualification contained in the second sentence.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.2
SEC asked (4)
Please refer to the second paragraph on page F-3. Please delete the assumptions contained in clauses (vii) and (viii). Please also delete the phrase “and that the execution, delivery and performance by each of the Corporations of the Transaction Documents to which it is a party are necessary and convenient to the conduct, promotion or attainment of the business of such Corporation” from clause (ix).
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.2
SEC asked (5)
Please delete the assumptions contained in clause (C) on page F-5.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.4
SEC asked (6)
Please refer to the Assumptions section. Please delete the assumptions contained in the first paragraph on page 4.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.4
SEC asked (7)
Please refer to the Qualifications and Exceptions section. Please delete the qualifications contained in the second to last paragraph on page 4.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.4
SEC asked (8)
Please refer to the Reliance section. Please delete the last sentence of the last paragraph on page 5.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.5
SEC asked (9)
Please delete the assumptions contained in clauses (e), (g), (h), (i), (k) and (l) on pages 3 and 4.
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.6
SEC asked (10)
Please refer to the assumptions beginning on page 2. Please delete the assumption contained in clause (2).
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.6
SEC asked (11)
Please refer to the assumptions beginning on page 2. Please delete the last sentence of the assumption contained in clause (3).
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.8
SEC asked (12)
Please refer to the first paragraph on page 4. Please delete the qualification added to the second sentence beginning with the phrase “provided, however.”
WMG answered

No reply letter found.

General
SEC asked (1)
We note that you are registering the exchange offer in reliance on our position enunciated in Exxon Capital Holdings Corp., SEC No-Action Letter (April 13, 1988). See also Morgan Stanley & Co. Inc., SEC No-Action Letter (June 5, 1991) and Shearman & Sterling, SEC No-Action Letter (July 2, 1993).
Rest of the question

Accordingly, with the next amendment, please provide us with a supplemental letter stating that you are registering the exchange offer in reliance on our position contained in these letters and include the representations contained in the Morgan Stanley and Shearman & Sterling no-action letters.

WMG answered
to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant has provided the supplemental letter with

Amendment No. 1.
Read in the reply
Summary, page 1 · Our Company, page 1
SEC asked (2)
Please revise the first paragraph of this section and specifically the last sentence to add balancing language regarding your net loss for the twelve months ended September 30, 2011.
WMG answered
to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant has revised its disclosure on page 1.
Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Mar 6, 2012

Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2009

2010-03-31 to 2010-07-14 · 10 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2010-07-14
RevenueResults discussion (MD&A)Executive payGoodwill and impairmentCritical estimatesRisk factors
Factors Affecting Results of Operations and Financial Condition, page 48
SEC asked (1)
Please expand your discussion to provide more information on how a shift from the CD format to digital music can impact your business. For example, discuss the differences in costs associated with digital formats as well as the differences in contribution margin from digital sales and physical sales.
WMG answered
Increasing digital revenue in our Recorded Music business is a key part of our strategy to offset declines in physical sales. We note that in our current filings we do include general discussions surrounding our strategy to focus on digital distribution.

See, for example, the discussion in “Our Strategy” on page 4 of the 10-K under “Capitalize on Digital Distribution.” As requested, we intend to add additional disclosure to our MD&A in future filings beginning with the Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31, 2010 (the “Q2 10-Q”) which, absent changes in facts and circumstances, we would
Rest of the answer

expect to be substantially similar to that set forth below:

Expanding Business Models to Offset Declines in Physical Sales

A key part of our strategy to offset declines in physical sales is to expand digital sales. New digital models have enabled us to find additional ways to generate revenues from our music content. In the early stages of the transition from physical to digital sales, overall sales have decreased as the increases in digital sales have not yet met or exceeded the decrease in physical sales. Part of the reason for this gap is the shift in consumer purchasing patterns made possible from new digital models. In the digital space, consumers are now presented with the opportunity to not only purchase entire albums, but to

“unbundle” albums and purchase only favorite tracks as single-track downloads. While to date, sales of online and mobile downloads have constituted the majority of our digital Recorded Music revenue, that may change over time as new digital models, such as access models (models that typically bundle the purchase of a mobile device with access to music) and streaming subscription services, continue to develop. In the aggregate, we believe that growth in revenue from new digital models has the potential to offset physical declines and drive overall future revenue growth. In the digital space, certain costs associated with physical products, such as manufacturing, distribution, inventory and return costs, do not apply.

Partially eroding that benefit are increases in mechanical copyright royalties payable to music publishers which apply in the digital space. While there are some digital-specific variable costs and infrastructure investments necessary to produce, market and sell music in digital formats, we believe it is reasonable to expect that digital margins will generally be higher than physical margins as a result of the elimination of certain costs associated with physical products. As consumer purchasing patterns change over time and new digital models are launched, we may see fluctuations in contribution margin depending on the overall sales mix.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 26, 2010: 10-Q filed May 6, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Factors Affecting Results of Operations and Financial Condition, page 48
SEC asked (2)
Please also consider adding a discussion under this section explaining your shift in strategy to enter into expanded-rights deals with artists to capitalize on the growth areas of the industry and how expanding these areas has and is expected to impact revenue and margins over time.
WMG answered
We note that in our current filings we do include general discussions surrounding our strategy to enter into expanded-rights deals with recording artists, as well as the expected benefits from such deals. See, for example, the discussion in “Our Strategy” on page 4 of the 10-K under “Enter into Expanded-Rights Deals to Form Closer Relationships with Recording Artists and Capitalize on Growth Areas of the Music Industry.” To the extent the non-traditional recorded music revenue generated by these expanded-rights deals begins to be material to our results, we will add additional discussion of
Rest of the answer

our strategy as it relates to our expanded-rights deals. In addition, as requested, in future filings we intend to add additional disclosure in our MD&A beginning with the Q2 10-Q noting that entering into expanded-rights deals are another strategy to offset declines in physical revenues in our recorded music business. We will include this as part of the disclosures discussed in our response to comment 1 above under “Expanding Business Models to Offset Declines in Physical Sales”, which absent changes in facts and circumstances, we would expect to be substantially similar to that set forth below:

We have also been seeking to expand our relationships with recording artists as another means to offset declines in physical revenues in Recorded Music. For example, we have been signing recording artists to expanded-rights deals for the last several years. Under these expanded-rights deals, we participate in the recording artist’s revenue streams, other than from recorded music sales, such as live performances, merchandising and sponsorships. We believe that additional revenue from these revenue streams will help to offset declines in physical revenue over time. As we have generally signed newer artists to these deals, increased non-traditional revenue from these deals is expected to come several years after these deals have been signed as the artists become more successful and are able to generate revenue other than from recorded music sales. While non-traditional Recorded Music revenue, which includes revenue from expanded-rights deals as well as revenue from our artist services business, was less than 10% of our total revenue in fiscal 2009, we believe this revenue should continue to grow and represent a larger proportion of our revenue over time. We also believe that the strategy of entering into expanded-rights deals and continuing to develop our artist services business will contribute to Recorded Music growth over time. Margins for the various non-traditional Recorded Music revenue streams can vary significantly. The overall impact on margins will, therefore, depend on the composition of the various revenue streams in any particular period.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 26, 2010: 10-Q filed May 6, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Results of Operations, page 50 · Revenues
SEC asked (3)
In your discussion regarding the changes in revenue between periods you attribute the changes between periods in all of the revenue items (recorded music, music publishing, geographical location) to ‘economic pressures.” Please provide a more robust discussion to specifically explain what is meant by ‘economic pressures’ as well as to provide investors with a clearer understanding of any specific factors driving the
Rest of the question

changes in your results of operations. Include in your discussion the effects changes in price and volume have on your results.

WMG answered
To the extent that in future periods ‘economic pressures’ are a significant contributor to the changes in our results of operations, we will include more specific disclosure in our filings to further discuss what is meant by ‘economic pressures’ as well as any additional factors driving the changes to our results of operations.
Rest of the answer

In general, ‘economic pressures’ refers to the impact of the global recession on both consumers’ buying patterns, which has resulted in decreased discretionary spending, and a reduction by retailers in the amount of floor and shelf space dedicated to music.

Retailers still account for the majority of sales of our physical product. However, as the number of physical music retailers has declined significantly, there is increased competition for available display space. This has led to a decrease in the amount and variety of product on display. As noted in “Factors Affecting Results of Operations and Financial Condition” on page 48 of the 10-K, these economic pressures have resulted in significant recessionary pressures, lower consumer confidence and lower retail sales in general. Of particular note for fiscal 2009 was the impact of the recession in Japan on our overall results, which was specifically noted in the discussion of “Revenue by Geographical Location” on page

52 of the 10-K.

In addition, our future disclosures will include expanded discussion about the transition from physical to digital and our strategy to enter into expanded-rights deals with recording artists as noted in our responses to comments 1 and 2 above. This will include a discussion of the impact on the volume of sales resulting to date from the shift from physical to digital. The overall decline in revenue is an industry-wide recorded music issue. We do not believe that pricing is the primary driver of this decline. Rather the majority of the revenue decline is attributable to the ability of consumers in the digital space to purchase individual tracks from an album rather than purchase the entire album (as described in our response to comment 1 above), the economic pressures described above, the growing competition for consumer discretionary spending and the ongoing issue of piracy (physical and digital theft).

Read in the reply
Critical Accounting Policies · Accounting for Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, page 74
SEC asked (4)
We note that you have incurred net losses for the last three years and have negative stockholders’ equity. Please expand your critical accounting policy for goodwill to include the following: • the percentage by which fair value of the reporting unit exceeded the carrying value as of the date of the most recent test; • a description of the methods and key assumptions used and how the key assumptions were determined;
Rest of the question

• a discussion of the degree of uncertainty associated with the key assumptions including specifics to the extent possible (e.g., the valuation model assumes recovery from a business downturn within a defined period of time); and • a description of potential events and/or changes in circumstances that could reasonably be expected to negatively affect the key assumptions.

WMG answered
We will include expanded disclosure in our future annual reports on Form 10-K in the “Management’s Discussion &

Analysis – Critical Accounting Policies” section under the subheading “Accounting for Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets.” In addition, we will disclose our revised Goodwill accounting policy or, if we so choose, our Critical

Accounting Policies in their entirety, which will reflect our expanded disclosures, in our Q2 10-Q and in our Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2010 (the “Q3 10-Q”).
Rest of the answer

Absent changes in facts and circumstances, we would expect the disclosure in the Goodwill accounting policy to be substantially similar to that set forth below:

Accounting for Goodwill and Other

Intangible Assets

We account for our goodwill and other indefinite-lived intangible assets as required by FASB Accounting

Standards Codification (“ASC”) Topic 350, Intangibles—Goodwill and other (“ASC 350”). Under ASC 350, we no longer amortize goodwill, including the goodwill included in the carrying value of investments accounted for using the equity method of accounting, and certain other intangible assets deemed to have an indefinite useful life. ASC 350 requires that goodwill and certain intangible assets be assessed for impairment using fair value measurement techniques on an annual basis and when events occur that may suggest that the fair value of such assets cannot support the carrying value. Goodwill impairment is tested using a two-step process. The first step of the goodwill impairment test is used to identify potential impairment by comparing the fair value of a reporting unit with its net book value (or carrying amount), including goodwill.

In performing the first step, management determines the fair value of its reporting units using a combination of a discounted cash flow (“DCF”) analysis and a market-based approach. Determining fair value requires significant judgment concerning the assumptions used in the valuation model, including discount rates, the amount and timing of expected future cash flows and, growth rates, as well as relevant comparable company earnings multiples for the market-based approach including the determination of whether a premium or discount should be applied to those comparables. The cash flows employed in the DCF analyses are based on management’s most recent budgets and business plans and when applicable, various growth rates have been assumed for years beyond the current business plan periods. Any forecast contains a degree of uncertainly and modifications to these cash flows could significantly increase or decrease the fair value of a reporting unit. For example, if revenue from sales of physical products continues to decline and the revenue from sales of digital products does not continue to grow as expected and we are unable to adjust costs accordingly, it could have a negative impact on future impairment tests. In determining which discount rate to utilize, management determines the appropriate weighted average cost of capital (“WACC”) for each reporting unit. Management considers many factors in selecting a WACC, including the market view of risk for each individual reporting unit, the appropriate capital structure and the appropriate borrowing rates for each reporting unit. The selection of a WACC is subjective and modification to this rate could significantly increase or decrease the fair value of a reporting unit.

If the fair value of a reporting unit exceeds its carrying amount, goodwill of the reporting unit is considered not impaired and the second step of the impairment test is unnecessary. If the carrying amount of a reporting unit exceeds its fair value, the second step of the goodwill impairment test is performed to measure the amount of impairment loss, if any. The second step of the goodwill impairment test compares the implied fair value of the reporting unit’s goodwill with the carrying amount of that goodwill. If the carrying amount of the reporting unit’s goodwill exceeds the implied fair value of that goodwill, an impairment loss is recognized in an amount equal to that excess. The implied fair value of goodwill is determined in the same manner as the amount of goodwill recognized in a business combination. That is, the fair value of the reporting unit is allocated to all of the assets and liabilities of that unit (including any unrecognized intangible assets) as if the reporting unit had been acquired in a business combination and the fair value of the reporting unit was the purchase price paid to acquire the reporting unit.

As of September 30, 2009, we had recorded goodwill in the amount of

$1.04 billion, primarily related to the Acquisition (as defined). We test our goodwill and other indefinite-lived intangible assets for impairment on an annual basis in the fourth quarter of each fiscal year. The performance of our fiscal 2009 impairment analyses did not result in any impairments of the Company’s goodwill. The discount rates utilized in the fiscal 2009 analysis ranged from 9% to 10% while the terminal growth rates used in the DCF analysis ranged from 2% to 3%. To illustrate the magnitude of a potential impairment relative to future changes in estimated fair values, had the fair values of each of the reporting units been hypothetically lower by 50% at September 30, 2009, no reporting unit’s book value would have exceeded its fair value. The percentage by which the fair value of each reporting unit exceeded the respective carrying value was as follows:

Reporting Unit

Percentage by which Fair

Value Exceeded

Carrying Value

U.S. Recorded Music

%

International Recorded Music

205

Publishing

The impairment test for other intangible assets not subject to amortization involves a comparison of the estimated fair value of the intangible asset with its carrying value. If the carrying value of the intangible asset exceeds its fair value, an impairment loss is recognized in an amount equal to that excess. The estimates of fair value of intangible assets not subject to amortization are determined using a DCF valuation analysis. Common among such approaches is the “relief from royalty” methodology, which is used in estimating the fair value of the Company’s trademarks. Discount rate assumptions are based on an assessment of the risk inherent in the projected future cash flows generated by the respective intangible assets. Also subject to judgment are assumptions about royalty rates, which are based on the estimated rates at which similar trademarks are being licensed in the marketplace.

See Note 9 to our audited consolidated financial statements for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2009 for a further discussion of our goodwill and other intangible assets.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 26, 2010: 10-Q filed May 6, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Accounting for Royalty Advances, page 77
SEC asked (5)
We note that management’s decision to capitalize an advance to an artist or songwriter as an asset requires significant judgment as to the recoverability of these advances. In light of the judgment in determining whether and how much to capitalize, please expand your disclosure to discuss (i) the average age of the outstanding advances expected to be recouped, (ii) the percentage of advances that are typically
Rest of the question

recouped, (iii) the average time period that most advances are collected, and (iv) the percentage of advances that are expensed immediately.

WMG answered
While we make a large number of advances each year, we evaluate the recoverability of an advance both at the onset, and over its respective life, on an advance-by-advance basis. As we are continually evaluating the recoverability of advances on an individual basis, we do not utilize overall metrics similar to those requested by the Staff to evaluate the amount to capitalize or the recoverability of advances. As we noted in the 10-K, we follow the guidance under FASB ASC Topic 928, which establishes the criteria to be used when initially determining if a royalty advance can be capitalized.
Rest of the answer

We will include expanded disclosure in our future annual reports on Form 10-K in the “Management’s Discussion & Analysis – Critical Accounting Policies” section under the subheading “Accounting for Royalty Advances.” In addition, we will disclose our revised Royalty Advances accounting policy or, if we so choose, our Critical Accounting Policies in their entirety, which will reflect our expanded disclosures, in our Q2 10-Q and Q3 10-Q. Absent changes in facts and circumstances, we would expect the disclosure in the Royalty Advances accounting policy to be substantially similar to that set forth below:

Accounting for Royalty Advances

We regularly commit to and pay royalty advances to our recording artists and songwriters in respect of future sales. We account for these advances under the related guidance in FASB ASC Topic 928, Entertainment—Music (“ASC 928”). Under ASC 928, we capitalize as assets certain advances that we believe are recoverable from future royalties to be earned by the recording artist or songwriter. Advances vary in both amount and expected life based on the underlying recording artist or songwriter. Advances to recording artists or songwriters with a history of successful commercial acceptability will typically be larger than advances to a newer or unproven recording artist or songwriter. In addition, in most cases these advances represent a multi-album release or multi-song obligation and the number of albums releases and songs will vary by recording artist or songwriter.

Management’s decision to capitalize an advance to a recording artist or songwriter as an asset requires significant judgment as to the recoverability of the advance. The recoverability is assessed upon initial commitment of the advance based upon management’s forecast of anticipated revenue from future and existing albums or songs. In determining whether the advance is recoverable, management evaluates the current and past popularity of the recording artist or songwriter, the sales history of the recording artist or songwriter, the initial or expected commercial acceptability of the product, the current and past popularity of the genre of music that the product is designed to appeal to, and other relevant factors. Based upon this information, management expenses the portion of any advance that it believes is not recoverable. In most cases, advances to recording artists or songwriters without a history of success and evidence of current or past popularity will be expensed immediately. Advances are individually assessed for recoverability continuously and at minimum on a quarterly basis. As part of the ongoing assessment of recoverability, we monitor the projection of future sales based on the current environment, the recording artist’s or songwriter’s ability to meet their contractual obligations as well as our intent to support future album releases or songs from the recording artist or songwriter. To the extent that a portion of an outstanding advance is no longer deemed recoverable, that amount will be expensed in the period the determination is made.

We had $380 million and $386 million of advances in its balance sheet at September 30, 2009 and 2008, respectively. We believe such advances are recoverable through future royalties to be earned by the applicable recording artists and songwriters.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 26, 2010: 10-Q filed May 6, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 3: Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, page 92 · Music Publishing
SEC asked (6)
We note that music publishing royalties are recognized as revenue when cash is received and that an agreement was reached with the U.S. recorded music and music publishing industries which will result in a $25 million payment of royalties that were accrued in prior years.
Rest of the question

Please explain this to us in greater detail and tell us the period to which this amount relates and the length of time between accrual of amounts and collection.

WMG answered
The $25 million payment discussed in the 10-K relates to our music publishing business’ share of a settlement paid by record companies (including our recorded music business) as a result of an agreement reached in September of 2009 between the National Music Publishers’ Association and the Recording Industry Association of America to distribute a pool of unpaid music publishing royalties primarily related to sales of physical and digital recorded music products from 2000 through 2008.
Rest of the answer

These royalties had not been previously paid for a variety of reasons including instances where record companies did not have the information necessary to make royalty payments to the proper parties.

Music publishing revenue is generally recorded on a cash basis because the ultimate amount of royalties earned is typically not known until cash is received. Prior to the settlement, our music publishing business had not recognized any revenue relating to the royalties covered by the settlement as it was not clear what royalties had been earned. Once the settlement was reached, we knew the amount of royalty income we were to receive and had therefore met the revenue recognition criteria. Accordingly, we recognized $25 million of royalty revenue in fiscal 2009 as disclosed in our 10-K.

We received the majority of the proceeds due under this settlement in March of 2010.

The statement regarding “royalties that were accrued in prior years” refers to the accrual of royalty expense by

U.S. record companies (including our U.S. recorded music business). Our U.S. recorded music business was able to accurately calculate the royalty expense based upon established statutory rates. Our U.S. recorded music business accrued the appropriate royalty expense when the underlying sale was recognized; however, as the proper payee was not known, no payments were made until the settlement was reached. Once the settlement was reached, our U.S. recorded music business contributed its share of the settlement payment to the pool that was eventually distributed to music publishers (including our music publishing business). This treatment is consistent with our accounting policies as disclosed in our filings.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 26, 2010: 10-Q filed May 6, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Royalty Advances and Royalty Costs, page 92
SEC asked (7)
Please expand your policy to disclose how credits to the royalty advances balance are calculated each reporting period. For example, explain what portion of revenue earned on a specific song is credited towards an artist’s outstanding balance. Also in this regard, please tell us and disclose how you account for revenue received for artists whose advances have been deemed unrecoupable and therefore expensed.
WMG answered
As noted in our response to comment 5 above, we will include expanded disclosure regarding our accounting for royalty advances in our

Critical Accounting Policies in our Q2 10-Q and Q3 10-Q. We will also include expanded disclosure in our next annual report on Form 10-K in the Notes to the Consolidated Audited Financial Statements under the subheading “Royalty Advances and

Royalty Costs.” Absent changes in facts and circumstances, we would expect the disclosure to be substantially similar to that set forth below, which is based upon the disclosure on “Royalty Advances and Royalty Costs” on
Rest of the answer

pages 92 and

93 of the 10-K:

Royalty Advances and Royalty Costs

The Company regularly commits to and pays royalty advances to its recording artists and songwriters in respect of future sales. The

Company accounts for these advances under the related guidance in FASB ASC Topic 928, Entertainment—Music (“ASC 928”). Under ASC 928, the Company capitalizes as assets certain advances that it believes are recoverable from future royalties to be earned by the recording artist or songwriter. Advances vary in both amount and expected life based on the underlying recording artist or songwriter. Advances to recording artists or songwriters with a history of successful commercial acceptability will typically be larger than advances to a newer or unproven recording artist or songwriter. In addition, in most cases these advances represent a multi-album release or multi-song obligation and the number of albums releases and

The Company’s decision to capitalize an advance to a recording artist or songwriter as an asset requires significant judgment as to the recoverability of the advance. The recoverability is assessed upon initial commitment of the advance based upon the Company’s forecast of anticipated revenue from future and existing albums or songs. In determining whether the advance is recoverable, the Company evaluates the current and past popularity of the recording artist or songwriter, the sales history of the recording artist or songwriter, the initial or expected commercial acceptability of the product, the current and past popularity of the genre of music that the product is designed to appeal to, and other relevant factors. Based upon this information, the Company expenses the portion of any advance that it believes is not recoverable. In most cases, advances to recording artists or songwriters without a history of success and evidence of current or past popularity will be expensed immediately. Advances are individually assessed for recoverability continuously and at minimum on a quarterly basis. As part of the ongoing assessment of recoverability, the Company monitors the projection of future sales based on the current environment, the recording artist’s or songwriter’s ability to meet their contractual obligations as well as the Company’s intent to support future album releases or songs from the recording artist or songwriter. To the extent that a portion of an outstanding advance is no longer deemed recoverable, that amount will be expensed in the period the determination is made.

Royalties earned by recording artists, songwriters, co-publishers, other copyright holders and trade unions are recognized as an expense in the period in which the sale of the product takes place, less an adjustment for future estimated returns, and are included in cost of revenue. The royalty earned varies by recording artist or songwriter based on separately negotiated royalty rates. In addition, the royalty rate can vary based on the underlying album or song. However, when a sale of product is recognized and the underlying advance had been expensed as a result of it being deemed unrecoverable, no corresponding royalty expense is recognized until such time that the cumulative royalty earned exceeds the advance that was paid to the recording artist or songwriter.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 26, 2010: 10-Q filed May 6, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Royalty Advances and Royalty Costs, page 92
SEC asked (8)
We note per a risk factor on page 29 that as new distribution channels continue to develop, you have to implement systems to process royalties on these new revenue streams. Please tell us how your system for processing royalties for digital distribution differs from your existing system including any differences in the process for determining and paying royalty amounts due.
WMG answered
To date, the system for processing royalties related to the distribution of digital product is consistent with how royalties are processed on physical product. We receive reports from the respective digital distributors (e.g., iTunes, Verizon, etc.), which detail the sales by artist/title/product type. That information is entered into our existing royalty IT system and the system applies the appropriate royalty rates (based on artist and product type).
Rest of the answer

All royalty information is aggregated by artist to determine the related expense to be recognized and amounts to be paid based on the recoupment status of the artist’s advance, if any. The language in the risk factor was intended to highlight that as the number of new digital models expand, there may continue to be new types of transactions to be processed, i.e., the risk factor is addressing potential future distribution channels that are not currently known. There may also be corresponding increases in the volume of transactions to be processed. In each case, we will have to ensure that our systems will continue to be able to adequately identify the proper royalty rates applicable to the new types of transactions and process an increased number of new types of transactions in an accurate and timely manner.

We will update the disclosure within this risk factor in our Q2 10-Q to make clear we are addressing potential future digital distribution channels that are not currently known. Absent changes in facts and circumstances, we would expect the disclosure to be substantially similar to that set forth below. For the Staff’s convenience, the language we intend to add to our disclosure in the Q2 10-Q is set forth in bold.

Legitimate channels for digital distribution of our creative content are a recent development, and their impact on our business is unclear and may be adverse.

We have positioned ourselves to take advantage of online and mobile technology as a sales distribution channel and believe that the development of legitimate channels for digital music distribution holds promise for us in the future. Digital revenue streams of all kinds are important to offset continued declining revenue from physical CD sales industry-wide over time. However, legitimate channels for digital distribution are a recent development and we cannot predict their impact on our business. In digital formats, certain costs associated with physical products such as manufacturing, distribution, inventory and return costs do not apply. While there are some digital-specific variable costs and infrastructure investments necessary to produce, market and sell music in digital formats, we believe it is reasonable to expect that we will generally derive a higher contribution margin from digital sales than physical sales. However, we cannot be sure that we will generally continue to achieve higher margins from digital sales. Any legitimate digital distribution channel that does develop may result in lower or less profitable sales for us than comparable physical sales. In addition, the transition to greater sales through digital channels introduces uncertainty regarding the potential impact of the “unbundling” of the album on our business. It remains unclear how consumer behavior will continue to change when customers are faced with more opportunities to purchase only favorite tracks from a given album rather than the entire album. In addition, if piracy continues unabated and legitimate digital distribution channels fail to gain consumer acceptance, our results of operations could be harmed. Furthermore, as new distribution channels continue to develop, we may have to implement systems to process royalties on new revenue streams for potential future distribution channels that are not currently known. These new distribution channels could also result in increases in the number of transactions that we need to process. If we are not able to successfully expand our processing capability or introduce technology to allow us to determine and pay royalty amounts due on these new types of transactions in a timely manner, we may experience processing delays or reduced accuracy as we increase the volume of our digital sales, which could have a negative effect on our relationships with artists and brand identity.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 26, 2010: 10-Q filed May 6, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Definitive Proxy Statement on Schedule 14A · Annual Cash Bonus, page 27
SEC asked (9)
In future filings, please disclose all performance targets, including budgeted levels of net revenue and OIBDA, which must be achieved in order for your named executive officers to earn their annual cash bonuses.
Rest of the question

To the extent you believe that disclosure of the targets is not required because it would result in competitive harm such that the targets could be excluded under Instruction 4 to Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K, please provide us with a detailed explanation for such conclusion. Please also note that to the extent that you have an appropriate basis for omitting the specific targets, you must discuss how difficult it would be for the named executive officers or how likely it will be for you to achieve the undisclosed target levels or other factors. General statements regarding the level of difficulty, or ease, associated with achieving performance goals either corporately or individually are not sufficient. Please provide insight into the factors considered by the committee prior to the awarding of performance-based compensation such as historical analyses prior to the granting of these awards or correlations between historical bonus practice and the incentive parameters set for the relevant fiscal period.

WMG answered
In its Compensation Discussion and Analysis, a registrant is required to provide to investors material information that is necessary to an understanding of the registrant’s compensation policies and decisions regarding the named executive officers. Instruction 1 to Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K and Section II.B.1. of Securities Act Release No. 8732A (Aug.
Rest of the answer

29, 2006).

As described in detail under the caption “Annual Cash Bonus” on page 27 of the Proxy Statement, the purpose of the performance goals related to the achievement of budgeted amounts of net revenue and OIBDA set by the Compensation Committee for fiscal 2009 and the committee’s measurement of our actual performance after the end of the year was to determine, together with any other relevant accomplishments, the overall funding for our company-wide bonus pool. As described in the Proxy Statement, the actual individual bonus amounts are fully discretionary, taking into account the target bonuses set forth in each named executive officer’s employment agreement, our corporate performance and other discretionary factors. Because of the discretionary nature of the annual bonuses awarded to the named executive officers, which are individually unrelated to the established performance goals (other than the fact that all bonuses are awarded out of our company-wide bonus pool which is determined after measuring actual performance against the performance goals), the annual bonuses have been appropriately reflected in the summary compensation table on page 32 of the Proxy Statement as “Bonus” and not “Non-Equity Incentive Plan Compensation.”

In this regard, the performance goals established by the Compensation Committee for the determination of our company-wide bonus pool are not material to an understanding of either the amounts of the annual bonus for named executive officers or why the Compensation Committee determined to pay those amounts. The establishment of the performance goals is described in the our

Compensation Discussion and Analysis merely to inform investors of the process by which the Compensation Committee determines the bonus pool, from which bonuses to all employees are awarded. The Compensation Committee has full discretion to award bonuses to named executive officers out of this overall pool, using whatever factors the committee deems relevant at the time that the amounts of the bonuses are determined. The discretionary factors that the Compensation Committee took into account in determining the actual amounts of the fiscal 2009 bonuses for the named executive officers include the six factors listed on pages 28 and 29 of the Proxy Statement and the other qualitative factors listed in the first full paragraph on page 29 of the Proxy Statement. We believe that it is these listed accomplishments that are the material performance measures on which the annual bonuses were actually determined and, accordingly, the material information necessary to an understanding of the registrant’s compensation policies and decisions regarding the named executive officers.

We do not believe that the performance targets established to set our company-wide bonus pool are material to an understanding of the annual bonuses awarded to the named executive officers and have therefore omitted the performance targets in reliance on Instruction 1 to

402(b) of Regulation S-K and not a competitive harm analysis pursuant to Instruction 4 to Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K. Since it is Instruction 4 to Item 402(b) that requires level of difficulty disclosure if a registrant determines that disclosure of target levels would cause competitive harm, we do believe it is required to discuss how difficult it would be for the named executive officers or how likely it will be for our company to achieve the targets which, in any event, have no direct bearing on the amount of the annual bonus awarded to individual named executive officers.

* * * * * *

In addition, we acknowledge that:

We are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and

We may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under any federal securities laws of the

United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 26, 2010: 10-Q filed May 6, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Definitive Proxy Statement on Schedule 14A · Annual Cash Bonus, page 27
SEC asked
We note your response to our prior comment 9; however, please provide us with additional analysis supporting your belief that the performance targets, including budgeted levels of net revenue and OIBDA, are not material information that is necessary to an understanding of your compensation policies.
Rest of the question

For example, we note that the overall funding for your company-wide bonus pool is determined by the achievement of these performance goals and, as a result, directly affects the amount of funds available to your named executive officers in the form of annual cash bonuses. Alternatively, confirm to us that, in future filings, you will disclose these performance targets.

WMG answered
In its Compensation Discussion and Analysis, a registrant is required to provide to investors material information that is necessary to an understanding of the registrant’s compensation policies and decisions regarding the named executive officers. Instruction 1 to Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K and Section II.B.1. of Securities Act Release No. 8732A (Aug. 29, 2006).

As described under the caption “Annual Cash Bonus” on page 27 of the Proxy Statement, the Company establishes performance targets to establish a target amount for the Company-wide bonus pool.
Rest of the answer

If the performance targets set by the Compensation Committee are met, the Company-wide bonus pool is initially set at the target amount in the Company’s annual operating budget. If the Company’s performance exceeds the performance targets, the bonus pool is generally initially increased above the targeted amount based on the pre-established scale. If the performance targets are not met, the bonus pool is generally initially decreased below the targeted amount based on the pre-established scale. However, in all cases, the Compensation Committee has the discretion to adjust the initial bonus pool amount determined by reference to the performance targets either upwards or downwards taking into consideration management’s recommendations, the achievement of pre-established qualitative factors and other considerations the Compensation Committee deems appropriate, and, as we have previously disclosed in our proxy statements, the Compensation Committee has used this discretion in the past to adjust final bonus pool amounts.

Given the large number of participants in, and size of, the Company-wide bonus pool, the overall funding amount of the bonus pool has had no direct effect on the amount of funds available to pay the annual discretionary cash bonuses of our named executive officers. Since our initial public offering in 2005, the aggregate of the discretionary annual cash bonuses awarded to our named executive officers has ranged from $2.8 million to $13.7 million, which has always been a small portion of the Company-wide bonus pool. Therefore, the overall funding amount of the Company-wide bonus pool has not been a limiting factor with respect to the Compensation Committee’s annual bonus determinations for our named executive officers. In addition, the aggregate of the annual cash bonuses paid to our named executive officers as a percentage of the total Company-wide bonus pool during such years has varied widely, which indicates that there has been no direct correlation between the size of the Company-wide bonus pool and the aggregate of the annual cash bonuses paid to our named executive officers. As described in our prior response and in our Proxy Statement, the actual individual bonus amounts awarded to our named executive officers are fully discretionary, taking into account the target bonuses set forth in each named executive officer’s employment agreement, our corporate performance and other discretionary factors. Therefore, we do not believe that the performance targets established by the Compensation Committee for the determination of the

Company-wide overall bonus pool are material to an understanding of either the amounts of the annual bonuses for our named executive officers or why the Compensation Committee determined to pay those amounts.

To the extent that in a future fiscal year the size of the Company-wide bonus pool does have a direct effect on the funds available to pay annual cash bonuses for our named executive officers or the amounts of their bonuses, we will either (1) disclose the relevant performance targets for the Company-wide bonus pool or (2) if we believe that the disclosure would result in competitive harm, explain how likely it would be for us to achieve the undisclosed performance targets for the Company-wide bonus pool.

We are providing the Staff on a confidential and supplemental basis in a separate letter dated today additional detail supporting our conclusion that the performance targets established by the Compensation Committee for the determination of the Company-wide overall bonus pool were not required to be disclosed under the requirements of Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K.

* * * * * *

In addition, the Company acknowledges that:

• the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under any federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 12, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 5, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 9, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2010-07-14

Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2007

2008-04-29 to 2008-05-29 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2008-05-29
Results discussion (MD&A)Executive pay
Director Compensation, page 23
SEC asked (1)
In future filings, please disclose all assumptions made in the valuation of awards in the stock awards column of the table by reference to a discussion of those assumptions in your financial statements, footnotes to the financial statements, or discussion in Management’s Discussion and Analysis. See Instruction to Regulation S-K Item 402(k), which refers to Instruction 1 to Item 402(c)(2)(v) and (vi).
WMG answered
In accordance with the Instruction to Item 402(k) of Regulation S-K, in future filings the Company will disclose all assumptions made in the valuation of awards in the stock awards column of the Director

Compensation table by reference to a discussion of those assumptions in the Company’s financial statements, footnotes to the financial statements or discussion in Management’s Discussion and Analysis.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 27, 2008: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2008 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 6, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Executive Compensation Objectives and Philosophy, page 30
SEC asked (2)
We note that your Compensation Committee considers ranges of compensation paid by a comparative group of companies of similar size and stature as well as your direct competitors in making its compensation decisions. In any future filing, please identify the benchmark companies and specify how each element of compensation relates to the information you reviewed.
Rest of the question

Discuss where actual payments fall within targeted parameters. To the extent actual compensation was outside a targeted percentile range, please explain why. Refer to Item 402(b)(2)(xiv) of Regulation S-K.

WMG answered
As noted on page 30 of the Proxy Statement, our Compensation Committee did not use information with respect to our peer companies and other comparable public companies to establish targets for total compensation, or any element of compensation, or otherwise numerically benchmark its compensation decisions.
Rest of the answer

Rather, the Compensation

Committee used the compensation information of our peer companies and other comparable public companies (and, more particularly, our direct competitors, which were identified on page 30 of the Proxy Statement) as one source for market or competitive data, which data were then used as a guideline for the exercise of its discretion in determining the compensation for our named executive officers. This comparison to our peer companies and other comparable public companies is simply one data point used by the Compensation Committee to judge, in the exercise of the Committee’s discretion in making decisions regarding the total compensation, or particular elements of compensation, whether those decisions resulted in compensation for our named executive officers that is competitive in the marketplace for senior executive talent.

Since our Compensation Committee does not engage in any benchmarking of our named executive officers’ compensation, we do not believe it is appropriate to include disclosure regarding percentiles of our peer companies and other comparable public companies. In future filings, however, to the extent it remains relevant and material, the Company will provide additional details regarding how the Compensation Committee considered information from the competitive market for executives and compensation levels provided by our peer companies and other comparable public companies in determining the elements of compensation for each of the named executive officers.

We acknowledge that to the extent the Compensation Committee does in the future engage in benchmarking of total compensation, or any element of compensation, in future filings we will (i) identify the benchmark companies and specify how each element of compensation relates to the information used and (ii) disclose the actual compensation as a percentile of the benchmark that is used, and, where the actual percentile differs from the target, we will explain why.

* * * * * *

In addition, the Company acknowledges that:

• the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under any federal securities laws of the United

States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 27, 2008: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2008 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 6, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2008-05-29

Form 10-K

2007-08-15 to 2007-12-03 · 28 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2007-12-03
RevenueDebtLiquidity and cashResults discussion (MD&A)SegmentsGoodwill and impairmentDerivatives and hedgingIncome taxesControlsAcquisitions
Our Business Strengths, page 1 · Flexible Cost Structure With Low Capital Expenditure Requirements, page 2
SEC asked (1)
Please explain to us and disclose what you mean when you state that you “have contractual flexibility with regard to the timing and amounts of advances paid” and how your accounting for the related advances is affected.
WMG answered
The statement cited refers to the fact that in the vast majority of contracts between the Company and its artists (whether recording artists or songwriters), such contracts cover multiple deliverables (whether albums or songs), many of which are only deliverable at the Company’s option. With respect to optional albums or songs, the advance attributable to those albums or songs is only payable if the Company exercises its option to require delivery of those albums or songs and if those albums or songs are actually delivered.
Rest of the answer

Advances with respect to albums deliverable under recording agreements are generally payable in installments tied to certain steps in the recording process such as commencement of recording, delivery of “basic tracks” and delivery of a completed album. Since the Company plays an important role in the recording process, it controls in part when those installments will be paid. Many of the Company’s recording agreements contain a so-called “pay or play” provision, which permit the Company to stop delivery of an album that was otherwise required to be delivered in exchange for a payment to the artist that is significantly less than the full album advance. It is typical in the Company’s recording agreements and music publishing agreements that advances for future albums or songs are calculated by a formula which takes into account the success of prior albums or songs, subject to a pre-negotiated minimum or maximum advance. These are some of the many reasons that the Company has contractual flexibility with regard to the timing and amount of advances paid. This flexibility, however, does not affect the Company’s accounting for any advances that are paid. Once an advance is paid, it is accounted for as described in the response to Comment #14 below.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Twelve Months Ended September 30, 2006 Compared to Twelve Months Ended · September 30, 2005, page 45
SEC asked (2)
A significant portion of your results of operations disclosure is dedicated to stating, in narrative text form, dollar and percentage changes in accounts, some of which is already included in tables. In addition, while you discuss certain factors to which changes are attributable, you do not quantify a large number of these factors nor analyze the underlying business reasons for the changes.
Rest of the question

For example, you state that costs of revenues decreased in 2006 due, in part, to fewer unrecoverable advances, but you do not quantify this factor nor analyze the underlying reason for the change. We believe your disclosures could be improved and made much more user-friendly and clearer by: a) increasing the use of tables to present dollar and percentage changes in accounts, rather than including such information in narrative text form; b) using tables to list, quantify, and sum all of the material individual factors to which changes in accounts are attributable; c) refocusing the narrative text portion of the disclosure on analysis of the underlying business reasons for the individual factors in the tables above; d) ensuring that all material factors are quantified and analyzed; and e) quantifying the effects of changes in both price and volume on revenues and expense categories, where appropriate (for example, quantifying the change in digital sales that was related to volume changes as opposed to price increases).

WMG answered
The Company notes that within the specific cost categories of

Cost of Revenues and SG&A, there are only a small number of contributing factors. Typically, the Company focuses on quantifying only the material contributing factors, while providing narrative text for both material factors and immaterial factors that when combined are material.
Rest of the answer

Where appropriate and when it feels the tables are necessary to summarize a number of material contributing factors, the Company will use tables to list, quantify and sum the material factors that contribute to Cost of Revenues, SG&A and other categories of expenses discussed in its results of operations disclosure in future filings. In addition, the Company will, while endeavoring to increase the use of tables to quantify the contributing factors in its future filings where appropriate, also refocus the narrative text portion of the disclosure on the underlying business reason for each of the individual material factors. The Company will continue to ensure that all material factors are quantified and analyzed in future filings.

The Company notes that the effects of changes in price are not material to the Company’s changes in revenue categories and as such, the narrative text discussion is focused on the volume changes that occur period over period. Should the effects of changes in price become material to the Company’s revenue and expense categories, the

Company will ensure that appropriate disclosure is provided to quantify such effects.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Twelve Months Ended September 30, 2006 Compared to Twelve Months Ended · September 30, 2005, page 45
SEC asked (3)
Please revise to include a table or tables detailing revenues both by geography (U.S., international, total) and by segment (recorded music, music publishing) and subcategory (such as digital sales, physical sales, licensing for recorded music, and mechanical, synchronization, performance, and other for music publishing) for each period discussed.
Rest of the question

Please include columns for dollar and percentage changes and common size percentages to the extent you believe useful. We believe such a table or tables will significantly improve the ease of use of this information to your investors and allow you to focus the narrative text on discussion and analysis of these figures as seen through the eyes of management, which we believe should be the focus of these disclosures.

WMG answered
The Company will include tables detailing revenue by geography and subcategory for each period discussed in its Form 10-K to be filed for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2007 and for future years. The Company currently includes a table detailing revenue and OIBDA by segment. The Company will expand this table to include columns for dollar and percentage changes and common size percentages where it determines such information to be useful to investors.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Twelve Months Ended September 30, 2006 Compared to Twelve Months Ended · September 30, 2005, page 45
SEC asked (4)
We note your discussion and analysis of costs of revenues is limited to a single paragraph on a consolidated basis, while your segment discussion of expenses is limited to the context of OIBDA, which does not address your expenses directly.
Rest of the question

We believe your segment OIBDA disclosures should be supplemented with or, preferably, replaced by a discussion and analysis of costs on a stand-alone basis (not in the context of OIBDA) for each segment (including corporate). Further, we believe such disclosure should be more comprehensive than that currently presented and should include separate quantification and discussion of changes in significant components of costs of revenues and SG&A, such as A&R, licensing, distribution, manufacturing, marketing costs, and other components, as appropriate. In addition, where discussing changes in these significant components, please provide total amounts in addition to the changes to provide context to readers. For example, you state that selling and marketing costs increased by $33 million in 2006, but do not disclose total selling and marketing costs. As noted above, tables will help in this regard.

WMG answered
The Company will disclose in future filings the amounts of SG&A and Cost of Revenues for each segment as well as the subcategories comprising each category of costs. The Company will expand its discussion of segment OIBDA to include a paragraph for each of SG&A and Cost of Revenues and will quantify the changes to each subcategory that contribute to the total category change along with a discussion of the underlying business reason for each change. The Company will consider tables to the extent it determines they are helpful to its investors.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Selling, general and administrative expenses, page 46
SEC asked (5)
You refer to the effect of bad debt expense in partial explanation of the increase in S,G&A expenses, however such effect is not evident in Schedule II in regard to the allowance for doubtful accounts. Please tell us the amount of bad debt expense recorded in fiscal 2006 and 2005 and how these amounts are reflected in Schedule II.
WMG answered
The amount of bad debt expense recorded in fiscal 2006 and 2005 was $11 million and $1 million, respectively.

The Company notes that upon further investigation of this matter, the amount of bad debt expense in fiscal 2006 in Schedule II was netted with deductions to the allowance for doubtful accounts rather than separately set forth in the column “Additions Charged to Costs and Expenses.” The financial statement schedule should have read as follows, with the bad debt expense separately reflected in the “Additions Charged to Costs and Expenses” column (in millions):

As Reported

Balance
Rest of the answer

at

Beginning of

Period

Additions

Charged to

Costs and

Expenses

Deductions

End

Year ended September 30, 2006

Allowance for Doubtful Accounts

$

(12

)

Revised

(23

Given the disclosures provided in the MD&A, the Company does not believe that this revision to

Schedule II is material to an investor’s reading of the Company’s annual report. The Company will make this revision in its Form 10-K to be filed for its fiscal year ending September 30, 2007.

The Company notes that the $1 million of bad debt expense in fiscal 2005 was separately reflected in the “Additions Charged to Costs and Expenses” column in Schedule II.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Other income, net, page 47
SEC asked (6)
Please tell us the estimated gross amounts of what you expected to receive and the payments to artists related to the KaZaA copyright infringement lawsuit settlement and the basis for these estimates. Also, explain to us why you believe it was appropriate to recognize net income for this settlement in fiscal 2006 prior to receipt of the settlement, as well as the basis for recording estimates of net receipts for
Rest of the question

other settlements recorded in other income, net in fiscal 2005. Further, tell us and disclose when you expect to receive the proceeds of the settlements recorded in each year and the factors that may affect amounts received and paid to be materially different from the amounts you estimated and recorded.

WMG answered
During the fourth quarter of the Company’s fiscal 2006, a settlement agreement was entered into between the record company plaintiffs including the Company (“the plaintiffs”) and the defendants in an Australian proceeding (Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd & Ors v. Sharman License

Holdings Ltd & Ors) and a U.S. proceeding (Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios Inc., et al. v. Grokster, Ltd., et al.), pursuant to which $100 million became due and owing to the plaintiffs. The $100 million in settlement proceeds was wired to the

Recording Industry Association of America, the U.S.
Rest of the answer

recording industry trade association, to be held in escrow until the plaintiffs agreed on how the proceeds would be allocated among them. Commencing in the fourth quarter of the Company’s fiscal 2006, the plaintiffs engaged in allocation discussions. As of September 30, 2006, as a result of the allocation discussions among the plaintiffs, the Company estimated its allocation of the settlement proceeds at $19 million. In June of

2007, the plaintiffs agreed on the allocation and the Company’s portion of the settlement proceeds, including interest then accrued, was determined to be approximately $19.4 million, which the Company expects to receive in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2007. The Company will disclose receipt of the payment for the KaZaA settlement amount (or, if it has not yet received the payment, when it expects to receive the proceeds of settlement) in its future filings.

As of September 30, 2006, the Company calculated the amount to be credited to the royalty accounts of its recording artists by reducing its estimated settlement by the Company’s contribution to litigation expenses and then applying an estimated royalty rate to the net settlement amount. The Company recorded income equal to the settlement less the amount payable to recording artists.

Under FASB Statement No. 5, Accounting for Contingencies, the Company believes it is appropriate to recognize a gain when a settlement is entered into and the settlement proceeds are paid and the Company knows with certainty the minimum amount of money that will be received.

During the fourth quarter of the Company’s fiscal 2005, a settlement agreement was entered into between ABC and several recorded music and music publishing companies including the Company, for the unauthorized use of music in various ABC programming, which included a cash settlement of $65 million. As of September 30, 2005, the four major music companies had determined an allocation among them for the recorded music portion of the settlement and were in discussions to appropriately allocate the music publishing portion. Based upon discussions among the four major music companies, the Company estimated that its combined recorded music and music publishing settlement proceeds would be $10 million. The Company then determined the portion owing to its recording artists and songwriters using estimated royalty rates. The Company recorded income equal to the settlement less the amount payable to recording artists and songwriters.

During the fourth quarter of the Company’s fiscal 2006, the Company received its portion of the settlement proceeds ($11.1 million) and as a result recorded an additional $880,000 of income after applying the amount payable to recording artists and songwriters.

The Company will disclose in future filings when it expects to receive the proceeds of material settlements recorded in each year and the factors that may affect amounts received.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Loss on termination of management agreement, page 47
SEC asked (7)
Please explain to us why you were required to pay a termination fee in the termination of the management agreement when it was the other party that terminated the agreement and how the amount of the termination fee was determined. Reconciliation of Consolidated Historical OIBDA to Operating Income and Net Income (Loss), page 48
WMG answered
The payment of the termination fee and the amount payable were governed by the management agreement (Exhibit 10.18 of AcquisitionCo’s Amendment No. 2 to its Registration Statement on Form S-4) and in particular Section 3 of the management agreement which reads as follows:

“This Agreement shall continue in full force and effect until December 30, 2014; provided, however, that the Managers may cause this Agreement to terminate at any time upon the agreement of (i) Managers affiliated with a majority of the Investor Shares then outstanding and (ii) two out of three of THL, Bain and Providence,
Rest of the answer

including the Manager that, at any such time as between these three

Managers, is affiliated with the greatest number of Investor Shares. In the event of the termination of this Agreement, Parent, Holdings and the Company, jointly and severally, shall pay each of THL, Bain, Providence and Music (i) all unpaid Periodic Fees (pursuant to Section 2(b) above), Subsequent Fees (pursuant to Section 2(c) above) and expenses (pursuant to Section 4(a) below) due with respect to periods prior to the date of termination plus (ii) the net present value (using a discount rate equal to the then yield on U.S. Treasury Securities of like maturity) of the Periodic Fees that would have been payable with respect to the period from the date of termination until December 30, 2014.”

In connection with Corp’s initial public offering, the Managers exercised their right to terminate the management agreement and, as a result, the Company was obligated to make the payment required in the event of such termination. The amount of the fee was determined as set forth in the management agreement, including the net present value of the Periodic Fees that would have been payable under the management agreement as noted above.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Depreciation expense, page 48
SEC asked (8)
It is not clear to us why lower capital expenditures necessarily translates into less depreciation, particularly when no disclosure was noted of dispositions, impairments, and/or fully depreciated assets, and gross property, plant and equipment (exclusive of construction in progress) has increased. Please advise.
WMG answered
While the Company’s overall gross property, plant and equipment balance had increased from September 30, 2005 to September 30, 2006, 15% of the increase related to construction in progress with no related depreciation expense. In addition, a significant portion of the balance was fully depreciated as of each of September 30, 2006 and 2005, including 70% and 58% of computer hardware and software as of September 30, 2006 and 2005, respectively. In addition, computer hardware and software comprise approximately 40% of the Company’s gross property, plant and equipment balance.
Rest of the answer

No disclosure has been made with regard to such fully depreciated assets as the balance and the change in fully depreciated assets are not material to the Company’s total assets as they are significantly less than 5% of total assets.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Income tax expense, page 49
SEC asked (9)
Please explain to us and disclose the basis for a higher percentage of shared service operating expenses being allocated to foreign income in fiscal 2006 that had the effect of reducing foreign income taxes and the overall tax provision.
Rest of the question

Please advise and disclose if this represents a trend in the way domestic and international operations are to be conducted, and if so, the basis for such change and anticipated impacts of such.

WMG answered
The Company recharges centralized support costs (e.g., information technology support and professional fees) that originate at its shared service centers in London, New York and Burbank to its affiliates under its management service fee agreements. The centralized costs are recharged in accordance with the applicable tax rules and regulations (e.g. OECD guidelines, IRS and local tax regulations).
Rest of the answer

The amount of the costs recharged have varied in each year for a number of reasons, including the fact that fiscal 2004 (the Company’s first year of operation as a stand-alone company) was a partial fiscal year and because the Company completed a study in 2006 related to the recharged costs which resulted in adjustments in 2006. The Company believes that going forward the recharge process will result in an allocation of costs that is consistent on a year-over-year basis.

As requested, the Company will expand its disclosure related to the impact of shared services operating expenses in future filings to note the reasons the costs have varied between years and that this is not expected to represent a trend or change in the way domestic and international operations are conducted.

Business Segment Results, page 50

Recorded Music,

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Business Segment Results, page 50 · Recorded Music, page 50
SEC asked (10)
Please explain to us how a comparatively larger number of releases sold in excess of 1 million units contributes to an increase in selling and marketing costs in fiscal 2006 and the associated amount of the increase in these costs.
WMG answered
For album releases that are expected to sell a significant number of units (i.e., in excess of one million units), the Company will typically launch a major marketing and promotional campaign. The Company will incur significantly higher costs to promote a major album release, including costs relating to the production of music videos. For album releases that are expected to sell a lower number of units, the Company will launch a smaller scale marketing campaign, with much lower associated costs.
Rest of the answer

On a foreign currency adjusted basis, the Company’s selling and marketing costs increased by $29 million in fiscal 2006.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Music Publishing, page 51
SEC asked (11)
Please explain to us the basis for and associated amount of the favorable royalty adjustments in fiscal 2006 to accurately state your royalty payable balances as indicated in the first full paragraph of page 52.
WMG answered
The Company’s music publishing processes include periodic reconciliations of royalty payable balances. The Company estimates the amounts payable to its songwriters and music publishers in respect of payments received from so-called collection societies. Please refer to the Company’s answer to Comment #15 for details of the sales reporting process.
Rest of the answer

Once the Company receives cash and the accompanying sales reporting from a collection society, it records revenue and an estimate of the amounts owed to its songwriters and music publishers in respect of the related sales based on its best estimate of the appropriate royalty rate using historical data and royalty payout rates. Subsequently, the Company processes the sales reporting data from the collection societies through its royalty processing systems, determines the actual amounts payable and credits the appropriate songwriter or music publisher. The periodic reconciliation process consists of adjusting the estimated royalties payable to songwriters and music publishers to reflect the actual amounts payable once the data from the collection societies is processed through the Company’s royalty processing systems and subsequently settled. Once the reconciliations are complete, the Company adjusts its books and records to record the actual royalty payable balances and royalty expense amounts. Typically, such adjustments are not significant. The amount of the favorable royalty adjustment in fiscal 2006 was $5 million and the Company believes such amount is inconsequential as compared to royalty expense recorded for the twelve months ended September 30, 2006 of $344 million. The adjustment in fiscal 2006 was approximately 1% of the average royalty balance.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Contractual Obligations, page 66
SEC asked (12)
Since interest is material to your operations and cash flow, please include in the table the amount of interest associated with long term debt and the basis for the amount of interest. If it is not practicable to include an amount for interest, please disclose the reason.
WMG answered
The Company will include its fixed interest payments in the Firm Commitments and Outstanding Debt table within the Contractual and Other Obligations section of its Form 10-K in future filings. The Company will continue to exclude the estimated amounts payable in respect of its variable rate debt as the Company is unable to predict with certainty the future amounts payable. The Company will disclose this accordingly in its future filings.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Revenues, page 87 · Recorded Music, page 87
SEC asked (13)
In regard to digital distribution channels, explain to us and disclose your relationship with providers of your recorded music with respect to the timing of when you recognize revenues and determining the amount thereof.
Rest of the question

For example, describe how your recorded music is made available to the digital distributors and how you are notified by the providers of the amount of revenue attributed to you and when it has been earned by you. Also, explain to us and disclose the compensation arrangements, such as in regard to licensing, rights or other arrangements, you have with digital distributors, whether you are the recipient or payor of the compensation, and your accounting for such arrangements. Further, explain to us and disclose the costs associated with generating revenues associated with digital distribution channels and how you determine when such costs are recognized in earnings.

WMG answered
The Company enters into agreements with digital service providers to make its masters available for sale in digital formats (e.g., mobile ringtones, digital downloads, etc.). The Company then provides digital assets for its masters to digital service providers in saleable form. The Company’s agreements with digital service providers establish wholesale prices or license fees which vary based on the type of product being sold or licensed.
Rest of the answer

The Company typically receives sales accounting reports from digital service providers on a monthly basis, detailing the sales or licensing activity, with payments rendered on a monthly or quarterly basis. The Company uses the sales accounting reports as a basis for recording revenue and the associated royalty expense. The Company will record revenue and the associated royalty expense upon receipt of the sales accounting reports as long as payment has been rendered or the collectibility of the payment is reasonably assured. The Company also incurs marketing costs in connection with digital transactions. These costs are expensed as incurred.

The Company will expand its disclosures related to its agreements with digital service providers as included in its prior Form 10-K under

“Business-Sales” to include additional detail regarding its relationships with digital service providers. The Company notes that the policies with regard to the costs associated with its digital business are already provided within the disclosures for recorded music costs as discussed in the Company’s response to Comment #14 below.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Revenues, page 87 · Recorded Music, page 87
SEC asked (14)
Please revise to disclose your accounting policy for recognition of recorded music costs, both acquired and non-acquired.
WMG answered
The Company believes that all relevant disclosures have been provided for the recognition of all significant recorded music costs. Please refer to the following disclosures in Note 3, Summary of Significant Accounting Policies in the Company’s Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2006:

Royalty Advances and Royalty Costs

The Company regularly commits to and pays advance royalties to its artists and songwriters in respect of future sales. The Company accounts for these advance royalty payments under the related guidance in FASB No.
Rest of the answer

50, “Financial Reporting in the Record and Music Industry” (“FAS 50”). Under FAS 50, certain advance royalty payments that are believed to be recoverable from future royalties to be earned by the artist or songwriter are capitalized as assets. The decision to capitalize an advance to an artist or songwriter as an asset requires significant judgment as to the recoverability of these advances. The recoverability of these assets is assessed upon initial commitment of the advance, based upon the Company’s forecast of anticipated revenues from the sale of future and existing music and publishing-related products. In determining whether these amounts are recoverable, the Company evaluates the current and past popularity of the artist or songwriter, the initial or expected commercial acceptability of the product, the current and past popularity of the genre of music that the product is designed to appeal to, and other relevant factors. Based upon this information, the portion of such advances that are believed not to be recoverable is expensed. All advances are assessed for recoverability continuously and at minimum on a quarterly basis.

Royalties earned by artists, songwriters, co-publishers, other copyright holders and trade unions are recognized as an expense in the period in which the sale of the product takes place, less an adjustment for future estimated returns, and are included in cost of revenue.

Inventories

Inventories consist of CDs, cassettes and related music products, as well as published sheet music and songbooks. Inventories are stated at the lower of cost or estimated realizable value. Cost is determined using first-in, first-out (“FIFO”) and average cost methods, which approximate cost under the FIFO method.

Returned goods included in inventory are valued at estimated realizable value, but not in excess of cost.

Advertising

In accordance with American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (“AICPA”) Statement of Position (“SOP”)

No. 93-7, “Reporting on Advertising Costs,” advertising costs, including costs to produce music videos used for promotional purposes, are expensed as incurred. Advertising expense amounted to approximately $202 million for the year ended September 30, 2006, $192 million for the year ended September 30, 2005, $94 million for the seven months ended September 30, 2004, and $53 million for the three months ended February 29, 2004. Deferred advertising costs, which principally relate to advertisements that have not been exhibited or services that have not been received, were approximately $2 million and $3 million at September 30, 2006 and 2005, respectively.

The above disclosures describe the policies related to the Company’s significant recorded music costs including Royalty Expense and other Artist and Repertoire Costs, Product Costs and Sales and Marketing Costs. The Company notes that Royalty Expense and other Artist and Repertoire Costs comprise 64% of Cost of Revenues and Product Costs comprise 32% of Cost of Revenues, in total representing 96% of Cost of Revenues. The remaining 4% relates to other costs of licensing products. In future filings, the Company will ensure that explanations for all significant Cost of Revenues categories are provided.

The Company notes that Sales and Marketing Costs comprise 50% of the Company’s SG&A expenses. In future filings, the Company will ensure that explanations are provided with regard to the impact Sales and Marketing Costs have on total SG&A expenses.

The Company also notes that it has fully disclosed its accounting for record masters acquired in a business combination in its Critical Accounting Policies in the Company’s Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2006:

Purchase Accounting

We account for our business acquisitions under the purchase method of accounting. The total cost of acquisitions is allocated to the underlying identifiable net assets based on their respective estimated fair values. The excess of the purchase price over the estimated fair values of the net assets acquired is recorded as goodwill. Determining the fair value of assets acquired and liabilities assumed requires management’s judgment and often involves the use of significant estimates and assumptions, including assumptions with respect to future cash inflows and outflows, discount rates, asset lives and market multiples, among other items. In addition, reserves have been established on our balance sheet related to acquired liabilities and qualifying restructuring costs based on assumptions made at the time of acquisition. We evaluate these reserves on a regular basis to determine the adequacy or accuracy of the amounts estimated.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Music Publishing, page 87
SEC asked (15)
Please explain to us why it is proper to recognize music publishing royalties when received. Tell us the uncertainties involved in determining when this revenue has been earned such that it can only be recorded upon receipt.
Rest of the question

Further, describe for us the process by which you obtain information from third parties from which you record these revenues, how such revenue is attributed to you by these parties, and how the information provided affects the timing of when you recognize and record such revenue

WMG answered
The Company’s main music publishing revenue sources are royalties earned when a song is publicly performed on the radio, television, via the internet or at venues including stadiums, bars and nightclubs (i.e., performance revenue), when a song is included on a physical product (i.e., mechanical revenue) and when a song is licensed for use with a moving picture such as an advertisement, film or television show (i.e., synchronization revenue).

The Company registers its owned or managed compositions with so-called collection societies that collect royalty income on its behalf from a variety of
Rest of the answer

sources and issue licenses for performance and mechanical rights. These societies include, but are not limited to, the Performing

Right Society (PRS) and the Mechanical Copyright Protection Society (MCPS) in the U.K. and ASCAP, BMI, SESAC and The Harry Fox Agency in the U.S. Most territories in which the Company operates have a collection society for performance and mechanical rights. The Company collects the income from the collection societies as well as directly from other sources and passes the relevant percentage on to the songwriters and music publishers. The Company also sub-publishes its rights in certain overseas territories in order that there is someone in the territory with an active interest in tracking all of the royalties and ensuring their timely receipt.

Until a report from a collection society is received, the Company does not know the quantity sold or amount earned and has no evidence that goods have been sold or services provided. Further, the Company relies on these collection societies for collecting and reporting the revenue earned during each reporting period. Accordingly, the Company does not have sufficient information to record revenue until reports are received from the societies.

The Company follows the revenue recognition criteria in Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 104 (SAB 104) “Revenue Recognition” (an amendment of

Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 101 “Revenue Recognition”) and recognizes revenue when a report for a rights society or recorded music company is received. These reports generally include royalty income earned by songwriter on a song-by-song basis. Until such report is received, the revenue is not fixed and determinable and collectibility is not reasonably assured. The Company believes that this is consistent with Example 1 in Part II of SAB 104.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Royalty Advances and Royalty Costs, page 88
SEC asked (16)
Please disclose for each year presented the amount written-off for advances deemed unrecoverable.
WMG answered
As disclosed by the Company in its summary of significant accounting policies in the notes to its financial statements and in accordance with FASB Statement No. 50, the Company records advance royalties paid to its recording artists or songwriters as assets when management believes that such advances are recoverable from future royalties to be earned by the recording artist or songwriter.
Rest of the answer

Management evaluates the recoverability of these assets based on a number of factors including the current and past popularity of the recording artist or songwriter and the initial or expected commercial acceptability of the product. The Company expenses these assets as royalties are earned by the recording artist or songwriter. The Company regularly evaluates the recoverability of the advances and expenses any portion determined to be unrecoverable. In many cases, royalty advances paid to recording artists or songwriters without a history of commercial success will be expensed immediately. As such, the Company considers the expensing of these amounts deemed to be part of its overall Artist and Repertoire Costs. Therefore, the Company respectfully requests that it not be required to separately disclose the amount written-off for advances deemed unrecoverable. However, if a large or unusual advance write-off occurs in relation to a recording artist or songwriter that the Company considers to have a proven track record of sales, the Company will disclose such item if it materially impacts the Company’s results of operations.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 9. Goodwill and Intangible Assets, page 96
SEC asked (17)
Please explain to us why it is proper to record the purchase accounting adjustments against goodwill rather than in earnings. Tell us whether any of the adjustments were made beyond one year of the associated purchase.
WMG answered
The purchase price accounting adjustments recorded during fiscal 2006 to reduce goodwill by $20 million consisted of $11 million of tax adjustments and $9 million of opening balance sheet adjustments. Such adjustments related to the opening balance sheet recorded on March 1, 2004, the date of the Company’s acquisition of substantially all of the recorded music and music publishing businesses of Time Warner Inc. (the “Acquisition”).
Rest of the answer

The majority of the $11 million of tax adjustments related to the release of valuation allowances against deferred tax balances that were recorded in the opening balance sheet on March 1, 2004. In accordance with FASB Statement No. 109, Accounting for Income Taxes, such releases of valuation allowances must be recorded as changes to the opening balance sheet and not recorded in the Company’s current tax provision.

The $9 million of opening balance sheet adjustments represented final adjustments to correct the fair value of the Company’s assets and liabilities recorded on the date of the Acquisition (the “Acquisition date”). An adjustment of $3.5 million related to an overstated royalty accrual that existed as of the Acquisition date. Another adjustment of $5 million was recorded to properly reflect the fair value of the inventory balance that existed as of the Acquisition date. As these excess accruals and asset balances existed as of the

Acquisition date, the Company recorded their reversal as an adjustment to the purchase price of the Acquisition. The Company believes this approach is consistent with the concepts outlined in EITF No. 95-3, Recognition of Liabilities in

Connection with a Purchase Business Combination, which states “when the ultimate amount of a cost expended is less than the amount recorded as a liability assumed in a purchase business combination ….the excess should reduce the cost of the acquired company. The amount of a cost exceeding the amount recorded as a liability assumed in a purchase business combination should result in an additional element of cost of the acquired company if an adjustment to an original estimate is determined within one year of the acquisition date and, thereafter, should be included in the determination of net income in the period in which the adjustment is determined”. While EITF 95-3 states that additional costs should be included in the determination of net income in the period in which the adjustment in determined, it does not provide a specific time frame for the reversal of excess costs. While the Company believes that typically all purchase accounting is finalized within one year of the acquisition date, the adjustments were recorded to properly value assets and liabilities as of the Acquisition date. The adjustments would have resulted in the Company recording a benefit to earnings in the period of adjustment.

Given the nature of the adjustments, the Company determined that it was more appropriate to adjust the opening balance sheet rather than inflating earnings in the period of the adjustment.

The Company also notes that these adjustments related to a number of pre-Acquisition periods and that the adjustments were not material to any pre-Acquisition period.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 9. Goodwill and Intangible Assets, page 96
SEC asked (18)
We note that you amortize your recorded music catalog over a period of ten years. Based on the amounts presented in your table of expected amortization for each of the next five years, it appears that you amortize this intangible on a straight-line basis. Please tell us whether our understanding is correct and, if so, why you believe the straight-line method is appropriate.
Rest of the question

In this regard, please tell us the actual historical and expected future pattern of economic benefits generated by the catalog asset.

WMG answered
The Company amortizes its recorded music catalog over a period of ten years on a straight-line basis. The Company believes such basis is appropriate for a number of reasons. The Company obtained a third-party valuation expert to value the catalog at the Acquisition date from Time Warner and to provide an estimated useful life.
Rest of the answer

The valuation from the third-party valuation expert indicated that primarily all of the cash flows related to the catalog would be realized over a twenty-year period, however, the Company’s estimated projections utilized to prepare such valuation indicated that a greater amount of the cash flows would be realized over a ten-year period.

The Company’s recorded music catalog includes music from all major music genres, including pop, rock, jazz, country, R&B, hip-hop, Latin, alternative and many others. In addition, the catalog includes some of the best-selling albums and artists of all time (e.g., Eagles, Led Zeppelin, etc.) and the Company’s catalog sales generate approximately 30%—40% of total recorded music sales in any given year. The Company owns the majority of the record masters in its catalog. The catalog is an accumulation of masters recorded over many decades and as such, it does not experience a significant decline in cash flows as would the Company’s newer releases. The financial analysis of the catalog prepared by the third-party valuation expert confirms that the Company’s cash flows associated with the catalog do not vary significantly year over year. The recorded music industry and its recorded music catalogs have a long history of benefiting from new technologies such as cassette tapes, 8-track, vinyl and the compact disc. Currently, the Company’s growth in digital distribution has increased the availability of and therefore, the revenue generated from its recorded music catalog. Due to changes in technology and the long history of recorded music catalogs, the Company believes there is no pattern that can be reliably determined to amortize the intangible asset related to its recorded music catalog. Therefore, the Company believes the straight-line method over the estimated useful life is appropriate. In addition, the estimated life of the intangible asset was estimated at ten years to assure that recognition of the cost of the revenues, represented by amortization of the intangible asset, better corresponds with the distribution of the Company’s expected revenues from the catalog.

At this time, the Company anticipates that its expected future pattern of economic benefits will be consistent with the analysis performed in 2004 in connection with the Acquisition. The Company will continue to reevaluate this on an annual basis in connection with its overall review of intangible assets performed in connection with its impairment testing. Should the Company determine that the future pattern of economic benefits has changed, the Company will disclose this in the relevant filing for the period that a change takes place.

Note

12. Debt, page 100

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 12. Debt, page 100
SEC asked (19)
We note your December 2004 issuance of senior discount notes and PIK notes, which were repaid, in whole or in part, in June 2005. You state that interest accrued on the discount notes in the form of an increase in the accreted value of the notes and that interest accrued on the PIK notes in the form of additional PIK notes.
Rest of the question

You state that you were required to pay all accrued interest as of the redemption date relating to the notes that were redeemed, and that this included $4 million in accreted value of the discount notes and $9 million related to the PIK notes. It appears that the repayment of this $13 million in accrued interest was recognized as a financing cash outflow in the debt repayments line in the financing activities section of your statement of cash flows for the year ended September 30, 2005. Paragraph 23(d) of SFAS 95 requires cash payments to lenders and creditors for interest to be classified as operating cash flows. Therefore, it appears that you should amend your filing to restate your financial statements for this repayment of interest, which appears material to 2005 operating cash flows.

WMG answered
The Company agrees that the accrued interest paid on the floating rate notes ($5 million) should have been classified as an operating cash outflow. However the Company believes that the repayment of the additional PIK notes and discount related to the PIK notes ($8 million) was properly classified as a financing activity in the Company’s statement of cash flows.

There was no intent on the part of the Company to pay cash interest with respect to this debt instrument.
Rest of the answer

The Company believes that “principal” was being added to the initial amount of the borrowing to be repaid at maturity or at an interim period if the debt were retired prior to maturity. Further, the Company believes this treatment is consistent with the financial statements of other reporting registrants.

The Company does acknowledge that there has been diversity in practice in how these repayments are classified, and that the SEC’s view is to treat these repayments as operating activities. Regardless of the classification of the repayment, the historical impact of the classification has not been material to the Company’s statement of cash flows. In addition to presenting in future filings any amount in excess of the original principal of the Company’s senior discount notes as an operating activity in the statement of cash flows, the Company will disclose in future filings in the basis of presentation in the notes to the consolidated financial statements that the repayment of any amount in excess of the original principal of the Company’s senior discount notes will be classified as an operating activity in the statement of cash flows.

As stated above, the Company does not believe such changes are material to the Company’s Statement of Cash Flows from a quantitative or qualitative perspective. The Company has considered the relevant guidance in Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 108 and Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99 with respect to materiality and believes that such a change would not have had an impact on an investor’s ability to make decisions with regard to the Company’s cash flows.

The Company notes that such adjustment would result in a decrease in net cash provided by operating activities of $13 million from $205 million to $192 million and an increase to net cash used in financing activities of $13 million from $(416) million to $(403) million. The following table reflects the year-over-year comparisons of each cash flow category as reported and revised for the items discussed above (in millions):

$ Change

06 v 05

% Change

05 v 04

2006

2005

2004

Operating

307

205

102

%

119

138

Investing

(153

(54

(2,663

(99

183

2,609

Financing

(81

(416

2,661

335

(3,077

-116

192

115

106

123

(403

322

(3,064

-115

The following table reflects the comparisons of the nine-month periods ended June 30, 2006,

2005 and 2004 of each cash flow category as reported and revised for the items discussed above (in millions):

223

172

135

365

(142

(2,648

(88

163

2,594

(68

(407

2,669

339

(3,076

159

122

330

(394

326

(3,063

The notes repaid were issued in December of 2004 and redeemed in June of 2005, in connection with

Corp’s initial public offering. The debt was outstanding for less than one year. The Company also notes that its capital structures in 2004, 2005 and 2006 are not comparable.

The Company notes that a reclassification between net cash provided by operations and net cash used in financing would not materially impact the figures presented in the Company’s statement of cash flows or the comparisons with either the prior year or subsequent year amounts. In addition, the Company discloses the cash payments related to interest that occurred in connection with the debt redemption in Note 13 of the Company’s Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2006 under the heading ‘The Holdings Redemption’. The Company believes this disclosure clearly sets forth the components of the cash payments made in connection with the redemption of the notes in 2005.

The Company notes that this comment is not applicable to AcquisitionCo as the debt redeemed was issued by WMG Holdings Corp., the immediate parent company of AcquisitionCo.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 15. Stock-Based Compensation Plans, page 106
SEC asked (20)
Please explain to us the basis for a term of 6 years for stock options when the aggregate of the amounts disclosed as exercised and forfeited suggests a shorter term.
WMG answered
All of the Company’s stock option awards vest over a four-year period and expire after ten years. While there were a significant number of options cancelled in 2006, 85% of such options were granted to two senior management employees whose employment was terminated in 2006. In addition, 96% of options cancelled in 2005 were granted to one senior management employee whose employment was terminated in 2005. In 2004 and 2005, the Company made several large grants of stock options to management in association with the establishment of Corp as a stand-alone company.
Rest of the answer

These awards were intended to provide a significant incentive compensation opportunity for employees who were instrumental in the development and growth of Corp as a stand-alone company. The size of these awards as a percentage of total compensation are atypical and the Company’s current stock award plans are designed to represent a much smaller portion of an employee’s total compensation. Such grants typically range from 10,000 to 250,000 options as compared to prior grants of 120,000 to 1.2 million options.

Accordingly, the Company has determined that the cancellation of options for three senior management employees in 2005 and 2006 is not specifically applicable in determining the appropriate term for future awards. Excluding these anomalous cancellations, 3% of options outstanding as of September 30, 2005 were cancelled in 2006 and less than 1% of options outstanding as of September 30, 2004 were cancelled in 2005. In addition, there were no exercises in 2005 and 13% of the options outstanding as of September 30, 2005 were exercised in 2006.

As such, the Company believes that a term of six years is appropriate for the Company’s stock options previously granted. The Company evaluates its assumptions on an annual basis or when evidence exists to indicate the assumptions should be evaluated more often than annually. The Company will evaluate in 2007 whether a different term is more appropriate for future option grants.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 15. Stock-Based Compensation Plans, page 106
SEC asked (21)
Please disclose the following information pursuant to the indicated paragraphs of FAS 123R: a) method used to incorporate the indicated factors associated with the term of stock options into the fair value of the options pursuant to paragraph A240(e)(2)(a); b) stock options expected to vest and fully vested options (to the extent fully vested options differ from options that are exercisable) pursuant to paragraph
Rest of the question

A240d; c) the weighted average period over which total compensation cost related to nonvested awards is expected to be recognized pursuant to paragraph A240h; and d) tax benefit associated with stock options exercised pursuant to paragraph A240i.

WMG answered
“The Company calculates the expected term of its stock options by considering employee attrition rates, employee exercise activity, the length of the vesting period for each award and the length of the expiration period for each award.”

The Company will supplement this disclosure in future filings to describe in more detail the approach for estimating the expected life of each option, which includes segmenting the Company’s employees between senior executives and all other employees (as described in the response to Comment #20) and analyzing the expected life for each employee segment using
Rest of the answer

historical and expected exercise behavior.

stock options expected to vest and fully vested options (to the extent fully vested options differ from options that are exercisable) pursuant to paragraph A240d;

The Company notes that there is no difference between its fully vested options and those that are exercisable.

the weighted average period over which total compensation cost related to non-vested awards is expected to be recognized pursuant to paragraph A240h; and

The Company will disclose in future filings that the weighted average period over which total compensation related to non-vested awards is expected to be recognized is 1.5 years.

tax benefit associated with stock options exercised pursuant to paragraph A240i.

The Company notes that the tax benefit associated with stock option exercises was not material for disclosure in prior years. The tax benefit in fiscal 2006 of $2,000 is not material as the majority of stock options were awarded to U.S. employees and the Company has recorded a full valuation allowance on the deferred tax assets related to these employees, given the Company’s significant historical losses in the U.S. Should such amount become material, the

Company will ensure that the required disclosures are made.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Item 9A. Controls and Procedures, page 133 · Evaluation of Disclosure Controls and Procedures, page 134
SEC asked (22)
It appears from your disclosure that the conclusion reached in regard to your disclosure controls and procedures is qualified in that they provided reasonable assurance only with respect to “information required to be disclosed in reports filed or submitted under the Exchange Act were recorded, processed, summarized and reported within time periods specified in SEC rules and forms” and not also in regard to
Rest of the question

“information required to be disclosed is accumulated and communicated to management to allow timely decisions regarding the required disclosure.” Please represent to us whether or not your disclosure controls were qualified in this fashion, and if qualified, the facts and circumstances associated with this qualification. Ensure your future disclosure in each periodic report filed addresses all aspects embodied in the full definition of “disclosure controls and procedures” specified in Exchange Act rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e), as appropriate. Management’s Discussion and Analysis …, page 24 Six Months Ended March 31, 2007 Compared to Six Months Ended March 31, 2006,

WMG answered
The Company hereby represents that it did not intend to qualify and it does not believe that its disclosure controls were qualified as suggested. In the introduction to the Company’s disclosure regarding Disclosure Controls and Procedures it is specifically noted that

“[d]isclosure controls and procedures include, without limitation, controls and procedures designed to ensure that information required to be disclosed by public companies in the reports that they file or submit under the Exchange Act is accumulated and communicated to a company’s management, including its principal executive
Rest of the answer

and principal financial officers, or persons performing similar functions, as appropriate to allow timely decisions regarding required disclosure.”

This disclosure was deemed a further description of some of the aspects of disclosure controls and procedures. Such controls and procedures, including the aspects described, are intended to ensure “information required to be disclosed in reports filed or submitted under the Exchange Act were recorded, processed, summarized and reported within the time periods specified in SEC rules and forms.” If such controls and procedures did not ensure that information required to be disclosed was accumulated and communicated to a company’s management as appropriate to allow timely decisions regarding required disclosure, then it would not be possible to conclude that the controls and procedures had provided reasonable assurance that information required to be disclosed in reports filed or submitted under the Exchange Act were recorded, processed, summarized and reported within the time periods specified in SEC rules and forms. Since we incorporated the definition of Disclosure Controls and Procedures from Rule 13a-15(e) into our disclosure, we believe we have complied with the requirements of Rule 13a-15(e) of the Exchange Act. While the Company believes it is not necessary to include references to all or some of the aspects of the controls and procedures that ensure timely reporting of information as required by SEC rules as part of its evaluation of whether they are working effectively, in order to clarify our disclosure in future filings the Company will change the disclosure to also note that its disclosure controls and procedures provided reasonable assurance that “information required to be disclosed by public companies in the reports that they file or submit under the Exchange Act is accumulated and communicated to a company’s management, including its principal executive and principal financial officers, or persons performing similar functions, as appropriate to allow timely decisions regarding required disclosure.”

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Consolidated Historical Results, page 35 · Cost of revenues, page 36
SEC asked (23)
Please explain to us and disclose in further detail how the change in product mix influences the amount of royalty expense recorded and the circumstances associated with the royalty advance write offs.
WMG answered
The Company pays royalties to its recording artists and songwriters based on agreed-upon royalty rates per their respective contracts. Within the recorded music business, royalty rates may vary by artist, with top-selling artists typically earning higher royalty rates than less popular artists. In addition, CD/DVD products may have different royalty rates than CDs alone or albums in digital form.

With respect to the music publishing business, royalties owed to songwriters and music publishers on mechanical, performance and synchronization revenues vary from deal to deal and also because
Rest of the answer

different rates apply to the different categories of revenue. Accordingly, the mix of music publishing revenues has a direct impact on royalty expense and cost of revenues.

In accordance with FASB Statement No. 50, Financial Reporting in the Record and

Music Industry, the Company expenses royalty advances to recording artists and songwriters without a proven track record of historical sales. During the six months ended March 31, 2007 as compared to the six months ended March 31,

2006, the Company increased its royalty advance spending on new recording artists and songwriters. This increase in spending results in higher Artist and

Repertoire Costs as such advances must be expensed immediately. Royalty advances paid to artists with a proven track record of historical sales are recorded as assets on the Company’s balance sheet and expensed when sales occur unless indicators of impairment exist at which point the Company will expense the portion of the payments made not deemed recoverable.

In future filings, the Company will include additional disclosure to explain in further detail how the changes in product mix and changes in royalty advance spending on new recording artists and songwriters influences the amount of royalty expense recorded.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

General
SEC asked (24)
As applicable and appropriate, please address in the filings of Warner Music Group the comments indicated above for WMG Acquisition Corp.
WMG answered
Our responses to comments numbered 1 through 18 and 20 to 23 apply to Corp and AcquisitionCo. Comment 19 applies only to Corp.
Read in the reply
Consolidated and Combined Statements of Cash Flows, page 89
SEC asked (25)
Within financing activities, please present proceeds of borrowings and related financing costs on a gross basis. Refer to paragraph 11 of FAS 95.
WMG answered
In future filings, the Company will present such amounts on a gross basis, regardless of materiality.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 21. Derivative Financial Instruments, page 127 · Warrants, page 128
SEC asked (26)
Please explain to us how the fair value of the warrants was determined when issued, at September 30, 2004, and when repurchased. Explain to us the reason for the significant increase in the value of the warrants from their value of $35 million at the date when issued of March 1, 2004 to their value of $155 million at September 30, 2004.
WMG answered
The Company issued warrants to Time Warner as part of the purchase price of the Acquisition. One of the warrants gave Time Warner the option to purchase equity in the Company at any time subsequent to the Acquisition date and the other provided Time Warner with the option to purchase equity in the Company upon the occurrence of a merger between the Company and another major music company. The fair value of the warrants on the issuance date of $35 million was agreed upon between the Company and Time Warner as part of the purchase price of the Acquisition.
Rest of the answer

Subsequent to the Acquisition date, the Company engaged a third-party valuation expert to determine the value of the Company’s underlying common and preferred stock and accordingly, the value of the Company’s warrants issued to Time Warner, which was calculated based on the value of the Company’s common and preferred stock. The third-party valuation expert also applied a probability of exercise to the warrants to calculate their value as of September 30, 2004 and December 31, 2004. The Company used such valuations to record a gain on the mark-to-fair-market value of the warrants as of both September 30, 2004 and December 31, 2004. The warrants were repurchased from Time Warner in connection with Corp’s initial public offering in May of 2005. At such time, the fair value of the warrants was determined based on the price of the common stock to be offered to the public in Corp’s initial public offering. This is consistent with the value of the stock that Time Warner would have received upon exercise of the warrants at that time. There was significant accretion in the value of Corp’s common shares over the fifteen-month period from the Acquisition date through the date the warrants were repurchased. Accordingly, the increase in value of the warrants from the Acquisition date through September 30, 2004 is consistent with the increase in the value of Corp’s common shares, as calculated by the third-party valuation expert.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 21. Derivative Financial Instruments, page 127 · Warrants, page 128
SEC asked (27)
We note in exhibit 99 to this filing and other Form 8-Ks in regard to periodic earnings releases that you have described realignment and restructuring costs incurred as “nonrecurring.” Since you have incurred such or similar costs in the last two years and you expect to incur them further in fiscal 2007, please discontinue describing these costs in this manner, or explain to us why you believe such description is
Rest of the question

appropriate.

WMG answered
to the Staff’s comment, the Company will discontinue describing realignment and restructuring costs incurred as “nonrecurring”. The Company, however, respectfully notes that the costs related to the two programs described, while both reported as restructuring charges pursuant to SEC rules, were part of two distinct initiatives implemented for very different purposes. The restructuring plan implemented in connection with the Acquisition of the Company in

March 2004 was intended to realign the Company’s cost structure with industry trends.
Rest of the answer

This was a broad restructuring plan in order to adapt our cost structure to current industry conditions. This plan resulted in significant annual cost savings. The realignment plan announced in the second quarter of fiscal 2007 is intended to shift Company resources from physical sales channels to efforts focused on digital distribution and emerging technologies and other new revenue streams. The

Company expects the majority of any cost savings from the reported “restructuring” and other severance charges related to moving resources out of physical sales channels to be offset by investments in new business initiatives.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 28, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Notes to Consolidated and Combined Financial Statements, page 91 · Note 13. Debt, page 110
SEC asked
We note your response to our prior comment 19. You state that you believe repayment of additional PIK notes and accretion on the discount notes were properly classified as financing activities because you did not intend to pay cash interest.
Rest of the question

However, it is not clear how your intent is relevant either under applicable accounting literature or in the circumstances, considering that you actually paid cash interest in connection with the June 2005 redemption. You also state that you believe principal, rather than interest, was being added to the initial amount of the borrowing. However, in substance the additional PIK notes and accretion on the discount notes were simply obligations for unpaid interest, whether labeled so or not. This fact is made clear in your filing where you state “The Company was also required to pay all accrued interest as of the redemption date …. This amount consisted of $5 million related to the Holdings Floating Rate Notes, $9 million related to the Holdings PIK notes, and $4 million in accreted value of the 35% of Holdings Discount Notes redeemed.” In addition, prior to payment, these amounts were classified as noncash interest expense in your statements of cash flows. Payment of this interest should be reflected as an operating cash outflow, similar to any other interest, as required by paragraph 23.d of FAS 95. Your operating cash flows benefited in periods this interest was deferred and such benefit should be reversed in subsequent repayment periods. The tables in your response appear to address only the purported lack of qualitative impact on the trend in your operating cash flows, but not the quantitative impact on operating cash flows for the applicable periods in 2005. Exclusion of the $13 million of interest payments on the PIK and discount notes resulted in operating cash flows being overstated by 6.8% and 8.2% for the 2005 fiscal year and nine months ended June 30, 2005, respectively. In addition, based on your response it appears $5 million of additional interest paid in connection with the redemption of the floating rate notes was also inappropriately excluded from operating cash flows. If our understanding is correct, operating cash flows were overstated by a total of 9.6% and 11.7% for interest payments on all three instruments for the 2005 fiscal year and nine months ended June 30, 2005, respectively. In either case, we believe these overstatements are material. Accordingly, we believe you should amend your 2006 Form 10-K to restate your 2005 financial statements to correct this error.

WMG answered
The Company recognizes the Staff’s preference for presenting cash paid in association with the discount accretion and the additional principal accretion as operating cash activities. However, the Company respectfully notes that there is diversity in practice in classifying such cash payments as cash payments for interest and that the alternative practice of presenting the cash payments as financing activities is consistent with the presentation on the balance sheet.

The Company notes the Staff’s comment regarding the quantitative impact on 2005 cash flows of the aggregate amount of the above
Rest of the answer

items of $18 million, consisting of the $5 million error and the other changes in classification of $13 million. While the Company does not believe the amounts being discussed here of $18 million are material on a dollar basis (relative to cash and equivalents of $367 million as of September 30, 2006), the Company respectfully notes your reference to the quantitative impact of these changes in the aggregate as a percentage of operating cash flows.

In our previous response, we considered Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99 Materiality and its guidance that quantifying in percentage terms, the magnitude of a misstatement is only the beginning of an analysis of materiality and cannot appropriately be used as a substitute for a full analysis of all relevant considerations. Also, in Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 2, the FASB stated the essence of the concept of materiality is that the omission or misstatement of an item in a financial report is material if, in the light of surrounding circumstances, the magnitude of the item is such that it is probable that the judgment of a reasonable person relying upon the report would have been changed or influenced by the inclusion or correction of the item.

The Company believes that the previously provided qualitative and quantitative assessments of the classification of these items support that a change in presentation would not have been significant to the users of the financial statements. This position is supported by the comparison of 2005 with both 2006 and 2004. The Company specifically notes that the nature of the Company’s business provides a normal variation in operating cash flows and as such, each year-over-year comparison has great variation. For example, the change in operating cash flows for the nine months ended June 30, 2007 as compared to June 30, 2006 was

(12%), the change in operating cash flows for the nine months ended June 30, 2006 as compared to June 30, 2005 was 40%, and the change in operating cash flows for the nine months ended June 30, 2005 as compared to June 30, 2004 was 330%. Because the Company’s business cycle varies considerably based on its schedule of new album releases, comparisons of its operating cash flows typically vary significantly. Therefore, the Company believes that making such a change in presentation would not provide significant value to its investors, as it would not substantially change the comparisons for operating cash flows, which the Company believes is the major factor considered by investors in their decision-making process. In addition, the proposed change relates to its 2005 fiscal year, which will only be presented in the statement of cash flows in the Company’s 2007 annual report and after such filing, will no longer be presented.

The Company further notes each of the items being discussed have been clearly identified to investors in the Company’s previous disclosures within the notes to its consolidated financial statements and within Management’s Discussion and Analysis with the specific amounts attributable to each item disclosed.

The Company recognizes the Staff’s preference for presenting cash paid in association with the discount accretion and the additional principal accretion as operating cash activities, however, the Company respectfully requests that it not be required to file an amendment to the Company’s 2006 Form 10-K to restate the 2005 financial statement to reflect these changes. Given the lack of impact of the changes on investors, the Company believes these items would be more appropriately corrected and adjusted in the Company’s next Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2007 to be filed on or about November 29, 2007. The Company agrees to identify and both correct the error noted and make the change in presentation with respect to cash paid in association with the discount accretion and the additional principal accretion to the Staff’s preferred presentation in its 2007 Form 10-K. The Company has provided as an attachment to this response the revised sections of its Form 10-K to correct and adjust its financial statements for the above items.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 21, 2007: 10-K filed Nov 29, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Dec 1, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2007-12-03

Letters without questions

Other letters

UPLOAD and CORRESP
2 other letters: notices that a filing will not be reviewed, requests to declare a registration effective, and the like

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 38 letters filed since 2007-08-15. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/WMG/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.