The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has provided additional details below. The Company has revised the disclosure on pages 22, 23, 79 and 80 of the Revised Registration Statement to provide additional clarity on the measure, why the Company believes this measure is informative, the timing differences mentioned, and the reason for excluding technology and data analytics from the measure.
measure of the revenues generated by the Company’s platform less those operating costs closely
Rest of the answer
correlated to, and variable with, those revenue generating activities to measure the unit economics of the transactions facilitated by the
Company’s platform in the period. The operating costs that are directly attributable to revenue-generating activities consist of the Company’s provision for credit losses, funding costs, and processing and servicing expenses as they vary with the volume of transactions processed by the Company’s platform and changes in the balance of loans held for investment on the
Company’s consolidated balance sheet. The Company’s remaining operating expenses represent the costs of the design, development, improvement, maintenance, and administration of the Company’s platform as a whole. Such costs are generally fixed or are not closely correlated with revenues. In addition, there are certain timing differences in the recognition of certain revenues and expenses associated with the Company’s relationship with their originating bank partners that do not reflect the unit economics of transactions processed by the Company’s platform in the period presented. The Company believes that adjusting for these timing differences provides investors with useful information about the Company’s unit economics in the period and facilitates comparability of the Company’s financial performance between periods and against other operating metrics such as GMV.
Why technology and data analytics are excluded from the measure considering these costs appear to be directly related to revenue generation?
The Company’s technology and data analytics expenses are largely made up of the personnel costs of the Company’s engineering, product, and risk organizations that are attributable to the delivery of the Company’s platform as a whole. These teams are focused on the design, development, improvement, maintenance, and administration of the Company’s technology platform and proprietary risk scoring model. The related personnel costs, including salaries and stock-based compensation, represented approximately 62% of the Company’s overall technology and data analytics expenses for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2020. The remaining portion of these expenses consists of costs incurred to support the Company’s infrastructure, cloud hosting, and operational data inputs to refine the Company’s risk scoring model. Because most of these expenses are fixed or do not represent an incremental unit of cost on a transaction processed on the Company’s platform, the Company has excluded them from the calculation of contribution profit.
Discussion of timing differences cited above
The Company purchases loans from their originating bank partner that are processed through the Company’s platform and that their bank partner puts back
(i.e., sells) to the Company. Under the terms of the agreement with the Company’s originating bank partner, the Company is generally required to pay the principal amount plus accrued interest for such loans. In certain instances, the Company’s originating bank partner may originate loans with zero or below market interest rates. In these instances, the Company may be required to purchase the loan for a price in excess of the fair market value of such loans, which results in a loss and a discount included in the amortized cost basis of the loan.
When a merchant captures a transaction, the Company recognizes merchant fees as revenue. Simultaneously, because the Company is obligated to purchase the loans that the
Company’s originating bank partner originates and puts to the Company, the Company recognizes a liability in an amount equal to the difference between the purchase price and the loan’s fair value. The corresponding debit is recognized as a loss on loan purchase commitment in the Company’s operating expenses. When the Company purchases the loan from the Company’s originating bank partner, the Company presents the liability that the Company initially recorded as a reduction of the carrying amount of the loan (i.e., discount). The accounting for the discount is dependent on whether the Company retains or sells the loan and is described below.
For loans the Company purchases from the Company’s originating bank partner and then retains on the Company’s balance sheet, the Company recognizes an expense associated with this loss on loan purchase commitment upfront. The Company then amortizes the loan discount into interest income over the loan’s life. Since the recognition of interest income is associated with unwinding the discount created by the initial loss on loan purchase commitment, the cumulative value of the interest income recognized and loss on loan purchase commitment expense incurred equal one another and thus net to zero over the life of the loan. However, the recognition of the amortization into interest income creates a timing difference relative to when the expense associated with the loss on loan purchase is incurred.
The Company believes that this timing difference obscures the unit economics of the transactions facilitated by the Company’s platform and that adjusting for this timing difference provides investors useful information about the unit economics of the transactions facilitated by the Company’s platform in the period.
from the Company’s originating bank partner and then sells to third-party loan buyers, the Company similarly recognizes an expense associated with the loss on loan purchase commitment upfront as well as an amortization of loan discount recognized into interest income for the period of a loan’s life in which it is held on the Company’s consolidated balance sheet, but the Company releases the remaining unamortized discount in full when the loan is sold. The unamortized discount released at the time of sale is recognized as part of the gain or loss on sales of loans. The aggregate value of all three of these mechanisms
(the initial loss, recognized interest income, and the discount released at the time of sale) net to zero over the life of the loan. However, the timing of when the loan is sold and how long the loan is held on the balance sheet prior to being sold creates a timing difference amongst the income statement impacts of loss on loan purchase commitment, interest income, and gain or loss on sales of loans. As with loans the Company retains on the Company’s balance sheet, the Company believes that this timing difference obscures the unit economics of the transactions facilitated by the Company’s platform and that adjusting for this timing difference provides investors with useful information about the unit economics of the transactions facilitated by the Company’s platform in the period.
The basis for the following adjustments made in the reconciliation to operating loss to arrive at contribution profit:
(i) loss on loan purchase commitment: As mentioned above, since the loss on loan purchase commitment that is recognized upfront (at the time the merchant captures a transaction) and the associated amortization of the discount that is recognized over the life of the loan are equal, there exists a timing difference that results in a net expense in the period in which the transaction occurs versus the income that is amortized over the life of the loan. The Company believes that adjusting this net expense out of the calculation of contribution profit provides investors with useful information about the unit economics of the transactions facilitated on the
Company’s platform during the period.
(ii) amortization of discount:
As mentioned above, since the amortization of the discount created by the purchase of a loan at a price above the fair market value of the loan is recognized into interest income over the life of the loan, but the corresponding loss on loan purchase commitment is incurred upfront when the merchant captures the transaction, there exists a timing difference. This difference results in income being recognized in the periods after the transaction is facilitated, while the loan is held for investment, compared with the expense being recognized during the period in which the transaction is facilitated. The Company believes that adjusting this component of interest income out of the calculation of contribution profit provides investors with useful information about the unit economics of the transactions facilitated on the Company’s platform during the period.
(ii) unamortized discount released on loans sold: When a loan is sold to a third-party loan buyer, the unamortized discount is released in full at the time of sale, against the gain or loss recognized on the sale of the loan. Similar to those mentioned above, the timing of this release into income differs from the time in which the loss on loan purchase commitment is incurred and any previous amortization of discount is recognized, though the aggregate amounts net to zero over the life of the loan. The Company believes that adjusting this component of revenues out of the calculation of contribution profit provides investors with useful information about the unit economics of the transactions facilitated on the Company’s platform during the period.
Why only certain components of interest income are excluded from contribution profit, and a description of the remaining components included as part of contribution profit and why.
Interest income consists of interest earned on unpaid principal balances, amortization of discount on loans held for investment, amortization of premiums on loans, and interest receivable charged-off, net of recoveries. Of these components, only the amortization of discount results in a timing difference, as mentioned above. The other components not excluded from the calculation of contribution profit are as follows:
(i) interest income on unpaid principal balance: This reflects the interest that is earned based on the finance charge disclosed to the consumer (consumer’s APR) and recognized under the effective interest method over the life of the loan.
This is the largest component of the Company’s GAAP interest income and does not have an offsetting operating expense that would yield a timing difference.
(ii) amortization of premiums on loans: The Company records certain premiums upon the purchase of a loan from the Company’s originating bank partner related to certain fees charged by the Company’s originating bank partner. These premiums are amortized over the life of the loan as a reduction of interest income and, unlike the discounts, do not have an offsetting operating expense that would yield a timing difference in recognition.
(iii) interest receivable charged-off, net of recoveries: The Company charges-off the accrued interest on a loan directly to interest income when a loan becomes 120 days past due or becomes otherwise uncollectible. This contra-revenue item is unrelated to the mechanics of the loss on loan purchase commitment and does not have an offsetting effect that would yield a timing difference in recognition.
Fiscal Year Ended June 30,
2019
2020
($ in millions)
Interest income on unpaid principal balance (i)
$ 103.7
$ 163.4
Amortization of discount on loans held for investment
21.8
35.3
Amortization of premiums on loans (ii)
(2.5 )
(6.2 )
Interest receivable charged-off, net of recoveries (iii)
(3.7 )
(5.7 )