We acknowledge the Staff’s comment regarding identifying cash production cost per ton, non-production cash cost per ton and cost of goods sold and operating expense rate excluding DDA per ton as
measures. In response to the Staff’s comment and in light of the Staff's general concern with the prominence of non-GAAP financial measures, we will no longer disclose cash production cost per ton and non-production cash cost per ton in future filings.
Rest of the answer
Instead, we will provide simplified disclosures, considering the requirements of Item 10(e)(1)(i) of Regulation S-K, consistent with those below in future public disclosures, to the extent applicable:
U.S. Iron Ore
The following is a summary of U.S. Iron Ore results for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014:
(In Millions)
Changes due to:
Year Ended
December 31,
Revenue and cost rate
Sales volume
Idle cost/production volume variance
Freight and reimburse-ment
Total change
2015
2014
Revenues from product sales and services
$
1,525.4
2,506.5
(401.9
)
(465.4
—
(113.8
(981.1
Cost of goods sold and operating expenses
(1,298.3
(1,796.1
140.2
305.3
(61.5
113.8
497.8
Sales margin
227.1
710.4
(261.7
(160.1
(483.3
Per Sales Ton Information
Difference
Percent change
Realized product revenue rate1
79.12
102.36
(23.24
(22.7
)%
Cash cost of goods sold and operating expense rate1, 2
60.27
64.91
(4.64
(7.1
Depreciation, depletion & amortization rate
5.72
4.92
0.80
16.3
%
Total cost of goods sold and operating expense rate
65.99
69.83
(3.84
(5.5
13.13
32.53
(19.40
(59.6
Sales tons3 (In thousands)
17,292
21,840
Production tons3 (In thousands)
Total
26,138
29,733
Cliffs’ share of total
19,317
22,431
1 Excludes revenues and expenses related to domestic freight, which are offsetting and have no impact on sales margin. Revenues also exclude venture partner cost reimbursements.
2 Cash cost of goods sold and operating expense rate is a non-GAAP financial measure. See "Non-GAAP Reconciliation" for reconciliation in dollars back to our consolidated financial statements.
3 Tons are long tons (2,240 pounds).
Non-GAAP Reconciliation
We present cash cost of goods sold and operating expense rate per long/metric ton, which is a non-GAAP financial measure that management uses in evaluating operating performance. We believe our presentation of non-GAAP cash cost of goods sold and operating expense rate to be a widely-acknowledged and useful measure of productivity and performance by our investors and other users of financial information, particularly in the capital intensive industry in which we operate. The presentation of this measure is not intended to be considered in isolation from, as a substitute for, or as superior to, the financial information prepared and presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP. The presentation of this financial measure may be different from non-GAAP financial measures used by other companies. Below is a reconciliation in dollars of this non-GAAP measure to our consolidated financial statements.
Year Ended December 31,
Asia Pacific Iron Ore
(478.5
(1,776.8
(745.0
(2,541.1
Less:
Freight and reimbursements
(157.3
(23.6
(180.9
(271.1
(6.9
(278.0
Depreciation, depletion & amortization
(98.9
(25.3
(124.2
(107.4
(145.9
(253.3
Elimination with discontinued operations
53.6
Cash cost of goods sold and operating expenses
(1,042.1
(429.6
(1,471.7
(1,417.6
(592.2
(2,009.8
In addition, we will continue to provide disclosure as recommended by the Staff in future public disclosures regarding such forward-looking non-GAAP financial measures, within our Outlook to the extent applicable:
The following table provides a summary of our 2016 guidance for our two business segments:
2016 Outlook Summary
U.S. Iron Ore1
Asia Pacific Iron Ore2
Cash cost of goods sold and operating expense rate3
$55 - $60
$30 - $35
$7
$2
$62 - $67
$32 - $37
Sales volume (million tons)
17.5
11.5
Production volume (million tons)
1 U.S. Iron Ore tons are reported in long tons of pellets.
2 Asia Pacific Iron Ore tons are reported in metric tons of lump and fines.
3 We present cash cost of goods sold and operating expense rate per long/metric ton, which is a non-GAAP financial measure that management uses in evaluating operating performance. We believe our presentation of non-GAAP cash cost of goods sold and operating expenses is useful to investors because it excludes depreciation, depletion and amortization, which are non-cash, thus providing a more accurate view of the cash outflows related to the sale of iron ore. The presentation of this measure is not intended to be considered in isolation from, as a substitute for, or as superior to, the financial information prepared and presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP. The presentation of this measure may be different from non-GAAP financial measures used by other companies.
In response to the Staff’s comment, we have historically discussed period-over-period variances either in full dollars or on a per ton basis, based on what we believe would be most insightful to our investors without duplication of explanations. In future filings, we will expand our disclosure to include both full dollar and per ton variance explanations.