Form 10-K
Expand your disclosure to provide the annual volumes of production by final product sold for each of the last three fiscal years, including the disclosure of natural gas liquids production if sold separately. Refer to the disclosure requirements in Item 1204(a) of Regulation S-K.
The Company reports production and revenues related to its oil and gas production activities on the two-stream method which is commonly used in our industry. Accordingly, natural gas liquids (“NGL”) production is included in natural gas production and revenues. In 2019, total NGL production was 497.2Read in the reply
MBbls, which was sold for $5.8 million. This amounts to 0.9% of total natural gas sales. Most of our wells do not produce any NGLs so the level of NGL volumes is not significant.Rest of the answer
Footnote 1 to the table of proved reserves and production on page
1 discusses how we convert NGL volumes to Mcf.
September 29, 2020
Page
The Company presented fourth quarter 2019 production activity for our primary operating areas due to the significance of the Covey Park acquisition completed in the third quarter of 2019 as we felt that would be more meaningful to investors. Fourth quarter 2019 was the first full quarter that included the acquisition. We disclosed full year average daily production by major operating area for 2019 on an annual basis on page 10 of our annual report. The Company proposes to include annual volumes by product and operating area in a tabular format within its future filings as follows:
Predecessor
Successor
Year Ended
December 31, 2017
Period from
January 1, 2018 through
August 13, 2018
August 14, 2018
December 31, 2018
December 31, 2019
Natural Gas (MMcf):
Haynesville/Bossier Shale
71,550
52,021
39,413
275,832
Bakken Shale
—
3,855
6,106
Other
1,971
3,219
1,763
10,896
Oil (MBbls):
1,364
2,465
898
287
214
Total (MMcfe):
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The third party reserves audit reports filed as Exhibits 99.1 and 99.2, respectively, disclose natural gas liquids reserves; however, such reserves are not disclosed in the filing on Form 10-K as of December 31, 2019. Tell us the reason(s) for this apparent inconsistency in the disclosure of your proved reserves.
As discussed in the Company’s response to comment 1 above, Comstock includes NGL production as part of its natural gas production. Footnote 1 to the table of proved reserves and production on page 1 states that natural gas volumes include NGLs.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The tabular presentation provided on page 11 relating to the proved reserves as of December 31, 2019 indicates that the present worth discounted at 10% (“PV 10 Value”) for your proved developed non-producing reserves is positive. However, both third party reserves audit reports filed as Exhibits 99.1 and 99.2, respectively, disclose that the present worth at 10% relating to such reserves is negative.Rest of the question
Tell us the reason(s) for this apparent inconsistency in the disclosure of information relating to your proved reserves.
The Company reported proved developed shut-in reserves and behind pipe reserves as proved developed non-producing reserves in the table on page 11. Proved developed shut-in reserves represent wells that were formerly producing but are no longer producing due to mechanical issues. Behind pipe reserves represent reserves expected to be recovered from zones in existing wells, which will require additional completion work or future re-completion prior to start of production.Read in the reply
See table below for a reconciliation of proved developed non-producing reserves between the table on page 11 and theRest of the answer
revised Exhibit 99.1 and Exhibit 99.2.
Reserve table on
Revised
Exhibit
99.1
99.2
Total
Difference
(in thousands)
Proved developed non-producing reserve PV 10
Value
$
10,677
10,796
(119
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The third party reserves audit report filed as Exhibit 99.2 indicates that you have included estimates of proved undeveloped reserves for certain locations that generate positive future net revenue but have negative present worth discounted at 10 percent. Tell us if the referenced locations were part of the development plan adopted by your management at December 31, 2019.Rest of the question
Refer to Rule 4-10(a)(31)(ii) of Regulation S-X.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
If you have adopted a plan to drill proved undeveloped locations with negative present worth discounted at 10 percent, disclose the marginal nature of these wells and the economic risk that they pose in your filing. Refer to FASB ASC 932-235-50-10 and your response dated January 19, 2012 to comment 3 in the letter dated December 28, 2011.
s 4 and 5: The referenced proved undeveloped reserves, which have a negative present worth, are comprised of 40.2 net locations with total reserves of 246.1 Bcfe (4.5% of total proved reserves), future net revenues of $79.0 million and a PV10 Value of $(22.6) million. The referenced locations were part of the Company’s development plan at December 31, 2019 and are scheduled to be drilled and completed within five years with the expectation that they will generate adequate returns when they are completed or are being drilled to meet certain drilling obligations in order to retain leaseholdRead in the replyRest of the answer
interest or to properly manage reservoir performance. The inclusion of these reserves in our proved reserves were not significant to our total proved reserves. The Company proposes the following disclosure in future filings with regard to such reserves:
“Our estimates of oil and natural gas reserves include 246.1 Bcfe as of
December 31, 2019 related to undrilled wells that have positive undiscounted future cash flows but which, based upon natural gas prices that we use to prepare reserve estimates in accordance with SEC guidelines, have a rate of return that is less than the 10% discount rate used in the Standardized Measure. We anticipate drilling such wells based on our expectation of future oil and natural gas prices as well as the need to meet certain drilling obligations in order to retain leasehold interests and to properly manage reservoir performance. To the extent that oil or natural gas prices are substantially weaker than our expectations, we may not recover our investment in drilling these wells from future cash flows.”
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Revise the tabular disclosure provided on page 12 relating to the average production cost per unit of production for each of the last three fiscal years to exclude the costs relating to severance and ad valorem taxes and transportation costs. Refer to Item 1204(b)(2) of
The Company proposes to include average production cost per unit of production in a tabular format within its future filings as follows:Read in the reply
Average Production Costs ($ per Mcfe):
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The tabular reconciliation of the changes that occurred in proved undeveloped reserves provided on page 13 indicates that no new reserves were added from extensions and discoveries for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2019.Rest of the question
This disclosure appears to be inconsistent with the level of drilling activity that occurred during the year and the disclosure relating to the change in total proved reserves for new reserves added from extension and discoveries. Tell us the reason(s) for this apparent inconsistency in the disclosure of information relating to your proved undeveloped reserves. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules (b) Exhibits
During the fiscal year ended December 31, 2019, Comstock completed the acquisition of CoveyRead in the reply
Park Energy, which added a large number of proved undeveloped drilling locations. According to Rule 4-10(a)(31) of Regulation S-X, “undrilled locations can be classified as having undeveloped reserves only if a development plan has been adopted indicating that they are scheduled to be drilled within five years, unless specific circumstances, justify a longer time.” Given the magnitude of additional proved undeveloped locations added with the acquisition, the Company elected not to include any newRest of the answer
proved undeveloped locations on its properties owned before the acquisition in order to align the future development of proved undeveloped locations within the five year limitation. Accordingly, there were no proved undeveloped locations added during fiscal year 2019 through extensions and discoveries.
Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules
(b) Exhibits
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Expand the disclosure in Exhibit 99.1 to provide the qualifications of the technical person(s) of the independent petroleum engineering firm primarily responsible for overseeing the firm’s audit of the Company’s proved reserves. Alternatively, expand the disclosure in the filing on Form 10-K to provide this disclosure. Refer to the disclosure requirements pursuant to Item 1202(a)(7) of Regulation S-K.
The Company proposes filing a revised Exhibit 99.1 that provides the qualifications of the technical person(s) of the independent petroleum engineering firm primarily responsible for overseeing the firm’s audit of Comstock’s proved reserves. See attachment to this correspondence of what the Company proposes filing as a revised Exhibit 99.1. The Company points out that Exhibit 99.1 only covers 6.1% of our proved reserves.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The disclosure in Exhibit 99.1 does not appear to address all of the requirements of the report pursuant to Item 1202(a)(8) of Regulation S-K. Obtain and file a revised reserves report to address the following points: • The reserves report should state the purpose for which the report was prepared, e.g. for inclusion as an exhibit in a filing made with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.Rest of the question
See Item 1202(a)(8)(i) of Regulation S-K. • The reserves report should specify the initial benchmark and the average realized prices after adjustments for location and quality differentials, by product type, including natural gas liquids, for the reserves included in the report. See Item 1202(a)(8)(v) of Regulation S-K.
The Company proposes filing a revised Exhibit 99.1 to state the purpose for which the report was prepared and to specify the initial benchmark and the average realized prices after adjustments for location and quality differentials, by product type for the reserves included in the report. See attachment to this correspondence of what the Company proposes filing as a revised Exhibit 99.1.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The reserves report refers to additional supplemental information, e.g. various summaries including Schedule No. 1 through Schedule No. 5 and an Appendix: SEC Petroleum Reserve Definitions that are not included with the report. Obtain and file a revised report to include the referenced supplemental information. Alternatively, remove these references if you do not intend to include this supplemental information.
The Company proposes filing a revised Exhibit 99.1 with the above-mentioned references removed from the report. See attachment to this correspondence of what the Company proposes filing as a revised Exhibit 99.1.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The tabular summary of the estimated remaining net reserves and future net revenue provided on page 1 indicates that the proved developed non-producing reserves have negative future net revenue, both undiscounted and discounted at 10%. Tell us why these reserves meet the requirements to be classified as proved reserves at December 31, 2019.Rest of the question
Refer to the definitions of economically producible, proved reserves, and reserves in Rules 4-10(a)(10), (a)(22) and (a)(26) of Regulation S-X, respectively.
As discussed in the Company’s response to comment 3, proved developed non-producing reserves represent shut-in wells that were formerly producing but are no longer producing due to mechanical issues.Read in the reply
The proved undeveloped non-producing reserves referenced in the table represent a reserve quantity of 1.0 Bcfe, which is 0.0018% of the Company’s total proved reserves.Rest of the answer
These cases are marginally uneconomic using first-day-of-the month average pricing for the previous 12 months (“SEC pricing”) and therefore do not meet the definitions of economically producible, proved reserves and reserves according to Rule 4-10 of Regulation S-X. However, the Company also considers the impact of forward market pricing, drilling obligations and reservoir performance in its evaluation of whether or not to keep marginally uneconomic reserves using SEC pricing.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Expand your disclosure of the changes in the net quantities of total proved reserves for each of the periods presented to include an appropriate narrative explanation of the significant changes related to each line item other than production.Rest of the question
To the extent that two or more separate and unrelated factors are combined to arrive at the line item figure, your disclosure should separately identify and quantify each individual factor that contributed to a significant change so that the change in net reserves between periods is fully explained. In particular, disclosure relating to the revisions in previous estimates of reserves should identify such underlying factors as changes caused by commodity prices, well performance, improved recovery, uneconomic proved undeveloped locations or changes resulting from the removal of proved undeveloped locations due to changes in a previously adopted development plan. Refer to FASB ASC 932-235-50-5 and Instruction 1 to Item 302(b) of Regulation S-K.
The Company provided an explanation of the significant increase in acquisitions of minerals in place during 2019 on page F-36. The Company proposes in future filings to expand its disclosure of significant changes in net quantities of total proved reserves with an appropriate narrative explanation of significant changes related to each line item and disclosure related to revisions in previous estimates as follows:Read in the reply
“Revisions of previous estimates.Rest of the answer
Revisions of previous estimates for 2017, 2018 and 2019 were comprised of 14.6 Bcfe, 41.0 Bcfe and 266.6 Bcfe, respectively, of upward revisions that were primarily attributable to higher production performance from Haynesville Shale wells as compared to expected performance from proved undeveloped locations included in proved reserves in the previous year. Revisions of previous estimates associated with changes in oil and gas prices were 26.5 Bcfe of upward price revisions in 2017, zero price related revisions in 2018 and 231.5 Bcfe of negative price revisions in 2019.
Extensions and discoveries. Extensions and discoveries for 2017, 2018 and 2019 were primarily comprised of proved reserve additions attributable to the Company’s successful drilling program in the Haynesville/Bossier Shale.
Acquisitions of minerals in place.
The significant increase in acquisitions of minerals in place during 2019 is primarily related to the Covey Park Acquisition.”
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The figures relating to the changes that occurred in your total proved reserves due to extensions and discoveries appear to be inconsistent with the corresponding figures relating to such changes that occurred in your proved undeveloped reserves for each of the last three fiscal years presented.Rest of the question
Expand the discussion of the changes in your total proved reserves attributed to extensions and discoveries to explain the reason(s) for this difference. Refer to FASB ASC 932-235-50-5.
The reserve additions related to extensions and discoveries on page F-36 relate to total proved reserves (both developed and undeveloped) while the reserves table on page 13 relates to total proved undeveloped reserves only. The inconsistency between the tables is due to wells successfully drilled and completed that were not classified as proved undeveloped reserves in the prior year.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The Company’s drilling program typically includes certain locations that were not carried as proved undeveloped.
As noted in the Company’s response to comment 12, Comstock proposes in future filings to expand its disclosure of the changes in net quantities of total proved reserves, including an appropriate narrative explanation of significant changes related to each line item and disclosure related to revisions of previous estimates. See the Company’s response to comment 12 for an example of the proposed disclosure language.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Tell us if the costs associated with the abandonment of your proved undeveloped locations, have been included as part of the future development costs used in the calculation of the standardized measure as of December 31, 2019. If such costs have been omitted, explain to us your basis for excluding these costs from your calculation of the standardized measure.
The costs associated with the abandonment of our proved undeveloped locations have not been included as part of the future development costs used in our calculation of standardized measure due to their immateriality. Due to the long economic lives of the Company’s wells, the standardized measure of abandonment costs associated with the Company’s proved undeveloped locations amount to $23.1 million of undiscounted cost and $174 thousand of discounted cost.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The Company proposes to include abandonment costs as part of the future development costs associated with our proved undeveloped locations in the calculation of the standardized measure in future filings despite the immateriality.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your presentation of the non-GAAP measure adjusted net income available to common stockholders. Revise to present a tabular reconciliation of adjusted net income available to common stockholders to net income. Additionally, revise to disclose the reasons why you believe your presentation of this non-GAAP measure provides useful information to investors.Rest of the question
Lastly, revise to disclose the purposes for which management uses this non-GAAP measure. Please refer to Regulation G and Item 10(e)(1)(i) of
The Company believes it provided a quantitative reconciliation of material items that comprised the difference between net income available to common stockholders and adjusted net income available to common stockholders in accordance with Regulation G and ItemRead in the reply
10(e)(1)(i) of Regulation S-K. Although Comstock believes it provided the appropriate information in the reconciliation of its non-GAAP measure, the Company proposes to include in future filings a tabular reconciliation of adjusted net income available to common stockholders to net income available to common stockholders and theRest of the answer
reasons why we believe our presentation of this non-GAAP measure provides useful information to investors and the purposes for which the Company’s management uses this non-GAAP measure as follows:
Three Months
Ended June 30,
Six Months
Net loss available to common stockholders
(60,002
(30,046
Unrealized loss on derivative financial instruments
65,585
49,102
Interest amortization on Senior Notes valuation
5,425
10,680
Loss on early extinguishment of debt
861
Non-cash preferred stock accretion
2,917
5,417
Impairment of unevaluated oil and gas properties
Adjusted provision for income taxes
(13,043
(8,048
Adjusted net income available to common stockholders
1,743
27,993
Diluted shares outstanding
208,904
198,910
Adjusted net income available to common stockholders per share
0.01
0.14
“The Company presents adjusted net income available to common stockholders because of its acceptance by investors and by Comstock management as an indicator of the Company’s profitability excluding non-cash unrealized gains and losses on derivative financial instruments and other unusual items.”
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note certain line items in your tabular reconciliation of net income to EBITDAX that are not traditionally included to arrive at the non-GAAP measure EBITDAX. Tell us whether you considered labeling this measure adjusted EBITDAX.
The Company did not consider labeling EBITDAX as adjusted EBITDAX in its tabular reconciliation of net income to EBITDAX. TheRead in the reply
Company has historically included non-cash items in its calculation of EBITDAX that are non-traditional to the definition of EBITDAX and has noted from its review of other peers in the energy industry that they also include non-traditional items in their calculation of EBITDAX without labeling it adjusted EBITDAX. The Company proposes in future filings to change the label of this measure to adjusted EBITDAX.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 29, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Your response to prior comments 3 and 11 acknowledges that the disclosed proved developed non-producing reserves for certain shut-in wells at December 31, 2019 did not meet the definitions of economically producible, proved reserves or reserves according to Rule 4-10(a)(10), (a)(22) and (a)(26), respectively. The intent to develop these uneconomic quantities in and of itself does not justify recognition of reserves.Rest of the question
Remove any quantities in filings made with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission that do not meet all of the requirements to be classified as reserves.
The Company acknowledges that the disclosed proved developed non-producing reserves included certain shut-in wells at December 31, 2019 that did not meet the definition of economically producible, proved reserves. The Company proposes in future filings to exclude any reserve quantities related to wells that do not meet all of the requirements to be classified as proved reserves under the Commission’s rules.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Oct 28, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Your response to prior comment 12 indicates that will expand your disclosure in future filings to include an appropriate narrative explanation of significant changes related to each line item in the reconciliation other than production for each of the periods presented.Rest of the question
Please confirm that your expanded disclosure relating to the changes from extensions and discoveries will additionally include the narrative explanation provided in your response to prior comment 13.
The Company confirms that in future filings it will include a narrative explanation relating to the changes from extensions and discoveries, if significant, as provided in our response to prior comment 13.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Oct 28, 2020: 10-Q filed Nov 5, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2020 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2020-10-29