Form F-1
2012-12-31 to 2013-05-22 · 193 questions
· 7 letters from the SEC, 1 from the company
No closing letter
Liquidity and cashAcquisitionsSegmentsGoodwill and impairmentNon-GAAP measuresDebtRisk factorsResults discussion (MD&A)RevenueLegal and contingenciesIncome taxesPensionsReserves and insuranceInventoryCybersecurityDerivatives and hedgingChinaClimateLeasesCritical estimates
General
SEC asked (1)
If you intend to respond to these comments with an amended draft registration statement, please submit it and any associated correspondence in accordance with the guidance we provide in the Division’s October 11, 2012 announcement on the SEC website at http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cfannouncements/drsfilingprocedures101512.htm.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (2)
Please keep in mind that we may publicly post filing review correspondence in accordance with our December 1, 2011 policy (http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cfannouncements/edgarcorrespondence.htm). If you intend to use Rule 83 (17 CFR 200.83) to request confidential treatment of information in the correspondence you submit on EDGAR, please properly mark that information in each of your confidential submissionsRest of the question
to us so we do not repeat or refer to that information in our comment letters to you.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (3)
Please be advised that after the confidential draft review process is completed, and at the time of the public filing of your Form F-1, you must file on EDGAR all correspondence submitted in response to our comments regarding the draft submission and other correspondence.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (4)
We will process this filing and your amendments without price ranges. Since the price range triggers a number of disclosure matters, we will need sufficient time to process the amendment when it is included. Please understand that its effect on disclosure throughout the document may cause us to raise issues on areas not previously commented upon.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (5)
As indicated in the comment above, we note that you have omitted certain pricing-related information as well as other information from this filing. If you intend to rely on Rule 430A of Regulation C under the Securities Act of 1933, please note that Rule 430A does not allow for the omission prior to effectiveness of amounts that may be computed based on the maximum number of shares offered and the mid-point of theRest of the question
offering price range, or the number of shares to be offered. In addition, please confirm that you will not circulate copies of the registration statement or the preliminary prospectus until you include an estimated price range, maximum number of shares, dollar amounts dependent upon the offering price that are based on the mid-point of the offering price range, and all other information except information you may exclude in reliance upon Rule 430A.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (6)
Please tell us when you intend to identify the underwriter(s) of the offering. We would anticipate that your next amendment reflects the designation of the underwriter(s).
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (7)
Prior to the effectiveness of your registration statement, please inform us as to whether or not the amount of compensation payable to the underwriters has received clearance by FINRA.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (8)
We encourage you to file all exhibits with your next amendment or otherwise furnish us drafts of your legal opinion and underwriting agreement. Please understand that we will need adequate time to review these materials before effectiveness.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (9)
Please provide us copies of any artwork that you intend to use as soon as possible for our review and comment. Please keep in mind that we may have comments on these materials and you should consider waiting for further comments before printing and circulating artwork.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Prospectus Cover Page
SEC asked (10)
Please revise your disclosure to indicate that this is your first public offering and that prior to the IPO, no public market existed for your shares.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Market and Industry Data, page iii
SEC asked (11)
We note your disclosure in this subsection; however, throughout the prospectus you provide various factual statements without indicating whether the source of the information is management’s belief, industry data, general articles or another source.Rest of the question
Refer to the following examples: “we are one of only two suppliers of aluminum products to the aerospace market with facilities in both the United States and Europe” [page 1]; the chart showing your leading market positions across your segments [page 10]; the new stretcher in the Ravenswood facility “is the most powerful stretcher in our industry” [page 11]; “Singen has improved our reputation in many product areas…” [page 84]; and “aluminum rolled products… constitute almost 50 percent of all aluminum volumes used” [page 87]. Please note that the above list is not meant to be exclusive. Where disclosure requires it, please identify the information source(s) serving as basis for your disclosure. If this information is based upon management’s beliefs, please indicate that this is the case. If the information is based upon other sources, please provide us supplementally copies of these sources marked to highlight the information you are using to support your disclosures.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Market and Industry Data, page iii
SEC asked (12)
If true, please confirm that all market and industry data represents information that is generally available to the public and was not commissioned by your for use in this registration statement. If you funded or were otherwise affiliated with any of the sources that you cite, please disclose this.Rest of the question
Please file necessary consents or explain to us why you are not required to do so under Rule 436 of Regulation C and Section 7 of the Securities Act of 1933. We note, for example, the reference to certain “CRU” data starting on page 5 of the prospectus, statistical information provided by LMC Automotive, and the study done by Frost & Sullivan, both referenced on page 91. We may have additional comments after we review your response.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Market and Industry Data, page iii
SEC asked (13)
At the end of the second paragraph of your disclosure please clarify the intended meaning of your statement that you “have converted historical data using [y]our financial methodology and forecast based on a constant exchange rate in line with the most recent year in the forecast” as it is not readily apparent.Rest of the question
Please consider providing an example to illustrate your disclosure or reference a section in the filing where this disclosure is made.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Basis of Presentation, page iii
SEC asked (14)
Refer to your disclosure in the penultimate paragraph. As you may not assign or disclaim any party’s responsibility under the federal securities laws for information included in a registration statement, please remove disclosure asking investors “to irrevocably acknowledge and agree” that Rio Tinto is not responsible for the 2009 and 2010 financial statements.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Our Competitive Strengths, page 9 · Stable business model that delivers robust free cash flow across the cycle, page 11
SEC asked (15)
Please further explain how your cash flows are countercyclical and how working capital is impacted when cash flow is replaced with inventory purchases. In addition, please consider providing comparative quantitative disclosure of your cash flows, demonstrating their consistency and stability, or include a reference where such information is disclosed in the filing.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Corporate History and Information, page 14
SEC asked (16)
Please revise your disclosure here to indicate the percentage of equity ownership to be held by the public stockholders following the offering.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Corporate History and Information, page 14
SEC asked (17)
In connection with the offering, you will convert into a Dutch public limited liability company. Please disclose whether there will be any impact to your financial statements as a result of this conversion.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary of Consolidated Historical Financial Data, page 17
SEC asked (18)
In regards to your presentation of Segment Adjusted EBITDA and Management Adjusted EBITDA, please address the following: Please expand your disclosures to clarify why you believe both of these Adjusted EBITDA amounts are useful performance measures pursuant to Item 10(e)(1)(i)(C) of Regulation S-K; Your disclosures on page 19 indicate that the primary use for Management Adjusted EBITDA is for debt covenantRest of the question
compliance purposes whereas Segment Adjusted EBITDA is primarily used to measure the performance of your segments. Based on what appears to be the primary purpose for presenting Management Adjusted EBITDA, it is not clear why you would present this amount for each segment beginning on page 4. In a similar manner, it is not clear why you would focus on Management Adjusted EBITDA in your overview section beginning on page 2. Please advise; You present Segment Adjusted EBITDA and Management Adjusted EBITDA per ton amounts. Please present the comparable IFRS amounts pursuant to Item 10(e)(1)(i)(a) of Regulation S-K; Please disclose how you calculate the amount of the metal price lag adjustment to arrive at Management Adjusted EBITDA; The definition of Management Adjusted EBITDA provided on page 19 does not appear to include the impact of cost savings. In this regard, it is not clear how you determined it was appropriate to present alternative Management Adjusted EBITDA amounts in note (j) which further adjusts for this amount. Please advise or remove these amounts; and Given that you incurred exceptional consulting costs in each of the three years ended December 31, 2011, please clarify how you determined it was appropriate to characterize these costs as exceptional. Please see Compliance and Disclosures Interpretation 102.03 which is available on our website at http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/guidance/nongaapinterp.htm.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary of Consolidated Historical Financial Data, page 17
SEC asked (19)
In addition to Segment Adjusted EBITDA and Management Adjusted EBITDA, you present EBITDA in certain places including on page F-18. Please confirm that these EBITDA amounts represent EBITDA as is commonly defined. If not, please retitle these measures. Please also ensure that you are using consistent terminology to describe your EBITDA amounts throughout the filing.Rest of the question
For example, if the EBITDA amounts presented on page F-18 actually represent Management Adjusted EBITDA, you should refer to it as Management Adjusted EBITDA rather than EBITDA.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Risk Factors, page 21 · A portion of our revenues is derived from international operations…, page 24
SEC asked (20)
If there are material risks unique to each country that is material to your operations or expansion, please include them here or as separate risks.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
We may not be able to adequately protect proprietary rights to our technology, page 32
SEC asked (21)
Since you have manufacturing facilities and a growing presence in China, disclose that China has provided less protection to a company’s intellectual property than the United States or the Netherlands. Failure to protect our information against cyber-attacks or information security breaches could have a material adverse effect on our business, page 33
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
We may not be able to adequately protect proprietary rights to our technology, page 32
SEC asked (22)
Please tell us what consideration have you given to including disclosure in accordance with the guidance provided by the Division of Corporation Finance’s Disclosure Guidance Topic No.2 , to address, among other things, (i) the adequacy of preventative actions taken to reduce cybersecurity risks, (ii) to the extent applicable, the risks resulting from outsourcing of any functions that have material cybersecurityRest of the question
risks, (iii) risks related to cyber incidents that may remain undetected for an extended period of time, and (iv) whether you have obtained relevant insurance coverage.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Product liability claims against us could result in significant costs. . ., page 34
SEC asked (23)
Disclose whether you possess product liability insurance that you believe to be adequate given your exposure to product liability lawsuits.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Our operations present significant risk of injury or death, page 34
SEC asked (24)
It is unclear whether hazards associated with your heavy industrial activities have ever resulted in incidents that disrupt your operations or expose you to significant losses or liabilities. Please clarify and, to the extent applicable, quantify the impact of any such incidents.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
We are principally owned by Apollo, Rio Tinto and FSI . . . , page 35
SEC asked (25)
Please be more specific about the “certain board representation rights” that Apollo, Rio Tinto and FSI will have under the Amended and Restated Shareholders Agreement. In particular, we note that Apollo will be entitled to appoint a majority of the directors of the company, provided that certain conditions are met. Clarify the extent to which any board members will be elected by vote of the public shareholders.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
We are a foreign private issuer . . . , page 36
SEC asked (26)
We note that you intend to rely on exemptions from “certain” of the NYSE corporate governance rules. Please clarify which rules you will rely on exemptions from as a foreign private issuer.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
We are a foreign private issuer . . . , page 36
SEC asked (27)
Clarify that foreign private issuers are exempt from certain U.S. securities law requirements applicable to U.S. domestic issuers, including the requirement to distribute a proxy statement pursuant to Exchange Act Section 14 in connection with the solicitation of proxies for shareholders meetings.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
We do not comply with all of the provisions of the Dutch Corporate Governance Code, page 36
SEC asked (28)
In this risk factor, briefly identify the principal Dutch Corporate Governance Code provisions with which you do not intend to comply. Alternatively, provide a reference to where in the registration statement an investor may find a more detailed discussion of this information (i.e. page 132). Provisions of our organizational documents and Dutch corporate law may impede or discourage a takeover…, page 38
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
We do not comply with all of the provisions of the Dutch Corporate Governance Code, page 36
SEC asked (29)
Refer to the disclosure requirements of Item 10.B.7 in Part I of Form 20-F. Please consider expanding your “Description of Capital Stock” disclosure on page 125 to include under a separate descriptive subheading disclosure similar to this risk factor disclosure. In connection with this offering, we will convert from a Dutch private limited company to a Dutch public limited liability company, page 40
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
We do not comply with all of the provisions of the Dutch Corporate Governance Code, page 36
SEC asked (30)
In an appropriate section of the filing, please explain the implications resulting from converting from a private to a public Dutch limited company. In addition, please expand this risk factor by discussing the material differences between the rights of shareholders and responsibilities of the members of the board of directors between an U.S. and a Dutch company.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Use Of Proceeds, page 44
SEC asked (31)
As indicated in Items 3.C.1 and 2 in Part I of Form 20-F, please revise your disclosure to provide a breakdown of each principal intended use of the offering proceeds in order of priority, to the extent that the anticipated proceeds may not be sufficient to fund all of the proposed purposes.Rest of the question
In addition, since you disclose that the anticipated proceeds may be used to fund acquisition opportunities, please discuss, to the extent relevant, the status of any contemplated acquisitions. If you have no specific plans for the proceeds, then please discuss the principal reasons for your offering. Refer to Item 3.C.1 and 3 in Part I of Form 20F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 46
SEC asked (32)
The capitalization table is not supposed to function as a balance sheet. Accordingly, delete the “cash and cash equivalents” item.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 46
SEC asked (33)
Please clearly show in the notes how you computed each pro forma and pro forma as adjusted amount, including a discussion of any significant assumptions and estimates used to arrive at the amounts.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Dilution, page 47
SEC asked (34)
With a view towards disclosure, please explain to us whether your dilution analysis assumes the underwriters’ exercise of the overallotment option.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Our History and Corporate Structure, page 48
SEC asked (35)
If the length of the company’s life is not indefinite, please identify the corporate life term in the filing. Refer to Item 4.A.2. in Part I of Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Our History and Corporate Structure, page 48
SEC asked (36)
Please disclose here or in an appropriate section of the registration statement, the name of agent in the United States, as host country. Please see Item 4.A.3 in Part I of Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Corporate Structure, page 49
SEC asked (37)
Please consider revising your graphical presentation to include your significant subsidiaries by name, identifying also their country of incorporation and proportion of ownership percentage. Refer to Item 4.C in Part I of Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management’s Discussion and Analysis, page 52 · Results of Operations, page 58
SEC asked (38)
For both the consolidated and segment results of operations discussions, please quantify the impact of each factor when multiple factors contribute to material changes in a line item as well as discuss the underlying business reasons for material changes between periods in line items.Rest of the question
For example, in your results of operations discussion for the Aerospace & Transportation segment for the six months ended June 30, 2012 compared to the six months ended June 30, 2011, you state that Segment Adjusted EBITDA increased by 61% or 22 million Euros due to increased prices and higher volumes and the positive effects of the operational turnaround at the Ravenswood facility. These increases were offset by inflation and currency effects. In addition to separately quantifying the impact of each of these factors, you should discuss the underlying business reasons for each of these factors. For example, you should give additional insight as to what caused an increase in sales volumes. Please revise your discussion accordingly. Refer to Items 303(a)(3)(i) and (iii) of Regulation S-K as well as Financial Reporting Codification 501.04.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management’s Discussion and Analysis, page 52 · Results of Operations, page 58
SEC asked (39)
It appears that your results of operations could be materially impacted by metal prices, foreign currency exchange rates and interest rates which you attempt to minimize using financial instruments. Please specifically discuss the impact of these financial instruments on your results of operations for each period presented if material.Rest of the question
Please address the specific underlying reasons such instruments impacted each year by the amounts disclosed. For example, if there are increases in metal prices which have impacted your results of operations, you should discuss why the increase was not offset by your derivative contracts, which may be due to your positions being too small relative to your needs. In addition, please also discuss any cases in which your strategies and assumptions resulted in adverse impacts.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management’s Discussion and Analysis, page 52 · Results of Operations, page 58
SEC asked (40)
Subsequent to your results of operations discussion by segment, please provide a discussion of the business reasons for fluctuations in the Eliminations and Other column presented in your segment note to the financial statements.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Covenant Compliance and Financial Ratios, page 71
SEC asked (41)
Please discuss the terms of all significant covenants that you are subject to in your debt agreements, including any required ratios/amounts. Please also clearly state whether you were in compliance with all covenants.Rest of the question
For example, it appears that you are still subject to the cumulative cash outflow covenant related to your ABL Facility which is disclosed on page F-60 and for which you were not in compliance with for the period January 1, 2011 through December 31, 2011. Please disclose the actual ratios/amounts as of each reporting date for any material debt covenants for which it is reasonably likely that you will not be able to meet, along with the specific computations used to arrive at the actual ratios/amounts with corresponding reconciliations to US GAAP amounts. See Sections I.D
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Interpretation 102.09 which is available on our website at · Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 73
SEC asked (42)
Given your significant foreign operations, please enhance your liquidity disclosure to address the following: Disclose the amount of cash and short-term investments held by foreign subsidiaries as compared to your total amount of cash and short-term investments as of June 30, 2012; Disclose whether or not you would need to accrue and pay taxes if these amounts are repatriated; Disclose, if true, that you doRest of the question
not intend to repatriate these amounts; and Disclose the nature and extent of any legal or economic restrictions on the ability of your subsidiaries to transfer funds to you in the form of cash dividends, loans or advances and the impact such restrictions have had or are expected to have on your ability to meet cash obligations. Refer to Item 5(b) of the Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Interpretation 102.09 which is available on our website at · Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 73
SEC asked (43)
You state that your primary sources of cash have historically been cash flows from operating activities and funding and borrowings from external parties and related parties. You believe your cash on hand, cash flows from operations, and availability under Term Loan and revolving credit facilities will enable you to meet your working capital, capital expenditures, debt service and other funding requirements for theRest of the question
foreseeable future. Given that you have not generated cash flows from operations in each of the two years ended December 31, 2011 or the six months ended June 30, 2012, it is not clear how you determined that this is one of your primary sources of cash. Please further clarify in your disclosures.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Interpretation 102.09 which is available on our website at · Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 73
SEC asked (44)
You had total liquidity of 308 million Euros which is comprised of 113 million Euros of cash and cash equivalents and 195 million Euros of undrawn credit facilities. The term loan facility provided by Apollo and FSI also provides for an additional 96 million of uncommitted loans in the event of your insolvency.Rest of the question
It is not clear if the undrawn credit facilities amount of 113 million Euros includes this additional 96 million Euros. Please clarify in your disclosures. If this amount is included, please explain how you determined this is appropriate given that it only appears to be available in the event of insolvency.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Interpretation 102.09 which is available on our website at · Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 73
SEC asked (45)
Please expand your liquidity and capital resources discussion to address your exposure to margin calls.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financing Arrangements, page 76 · Historical Capital Expenditures, page 76
SEC asked (46)
There appears to be a typographical error in the heading of the third column. It appears that this column relates to the year ended December 31, 2011. Please revise as necessary.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financing Arrangements, page 76 · Historical Capital Expenditures, page 76
SEC asked (47)
Please revise your disclosure to quantify the amount of the capital expenditures required in connection with your currently ongoing projects. See Item 4.A.6. in Part I of Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Contractual Obligations, page 76
SEC asked (48)
Please revise your table of contractual cash obligations to include estimated interest payments on your borrowings. Because the table is aimed at increasing transparency of cash flows, we believe these payments should be included in the table. Please also disclose any assumptions you made to derive these amounts in a footnote to the table.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Business, page 79 · Our Operating Segments, page 81
SEC asked (49)
Please note that the information required to be provided in accordance with Item 4.B.2. in Part I of Form 20-F must be provided for each of the last three financial years for each category of activity as well as each geographic market in which you complete. Please revise your disclosure accordingly.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Aerospace & Transportation Operating Segment, page 82
SEC asked (50)
In the first paragraph, please revise your disclosure to elaborate on the nature of your services “designed to optimize customer operations and reduce costs.”
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Aerospace & Transportation Operating Segment, page 82
SEC asked (51)
You state that the aerospace products are typically subject to long qualification. Please explain whether these products would have to be qualified by your customers or by a designated governmental agency, and provide an objective range of what may be considered a long qualification period.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Aerospace & Transportation Operating Segment, page 82
SEC asked (52)
To the extent possible, please provide an objective measure demonstrating the EBITDA improvements due to your turn-around plan in the Ravenswood facility.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Our Industrial Facilities and Offices, page 98
SEC asked (53)
With respect to each facility discussed, please expand your disclosure to indicate current production capacity and utilization rate. To the extent that you plan to construct, expand or improve any of these facilities, please discuss the nature and reason for these plans, the estimated amount of expenditures and the methods you plan to finance these plans, indicating also estimated dates of start and completion ofRest of the question
these projects. Refer to Item 4.D. in Part I in Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Raw Materials and Supplies, page 100 · Our Customers, page 100
SEC asked (54)
With respect to your multi-year supplier and customer contracts, please tell us what consideration you have given to filing these contracts as exhibits to your registration statement. In this regard, we also note disclosure related to the metal supply agreements on page 119. Please see Item 8 of Form F-1 and Item 601(b)(10) of Regulation S-K.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Trademarks, Patents, License and IT, page 102
SEC asked (55)
With a view towards disclosure, please tell us whether your business is dependent upon any of your patent families. See also Item 4.B.6 in Part I in Form 20-F. We note your disclosure that no single patent or patent application is critical to your business.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Governmental Regulation and Environmental, Health and Safety Matters, page 102
SEC asked (56)
Please expand your disclosure to discuss the effects that REACH may have on your operations. Refer to “Regulations regarding carbon dioxide emissions…” risk factor on page 28. In addition, please identify the regulatory body overseeing environmental compliance in the jurisdictions where a material portion of your business is conducted. See Item 4.B.8 in Part I in Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Litigation and Legal Proceedings, page 103
SEC asked (57)
Please disclose the aspects of your business exposing you to asbestos related claims.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management, page 104 · Executive Officers and Board of Directors, page 104
SEC asked (58)
To the extent that any director or member of senior manager was selected as such pursuant to any arrangement or understanding with Apollo, Rio Tinto or FSI, pursuant to the Shareholders Agreement or otherwise, please ensure that your disclosure makes that clear, as required by Item 6.A.5. of Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Board Structure, page 108
SEC asked (59)
For each director, please indicate the date when their respective current term of office expires. See Item 6.C.1 in Part I in Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Compensation of Non-Employee Directors and Officers, page 110
SEC asked (60)
Refer to Item 6.C.2 in Part I of Form 20-F. If there are no director service contracts providing post-employment termination benefits, please include an appropriate negative statement.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Officer Compensation, page 111
SEC asked (61)
You state that the tabular disclosure sets forth the “approximate” remuneration paid to your executive officers in 2011. With a view towards disclosure, please tell us why you are unable to disclose the actual compensation paid to your executive officers.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Long Term Incentive Cash Plan, page 111
SEC asked (62)
Please tell us why grants of cash awards under the long term incentive cash plan are not disclosed in the compensation table. In this regard, we note that 50 of your senior employees received such grants in 2011.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management Equity Plan, page 113
SEC asked (63)
Please revise to provide brief disclosure of the material terms and conditions of MEP.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management Equity Plan, page 113
SEC asked (64)
Reference to “Constellium Management GmbH” at the end of the third paragraph on page 114 appears in error. Please revise.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management Equity Plan, page 113
SEC asked (65)
Refer to your disclosure in the fourth paragraph on page 114. With a view towards disclosure, please explain to us how the amount of each grant under MEP is determined, and whether any performance-vesting tranches vested at the end of 2011.Rest of the question
In addition, please tell us whether these tranches represent compensation related to performance and as such, whether related disclosure should be included in the Officer Compensation section.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management Equity Plan, page 113
SEC asked (66)
In the third paragraph of your “Our History” discussion on page 48 you state that the Management KG shares are voted “in the same manner as, and in proportion to the respective equity ownership amounts of, Apollo, Rio Tinto and FSI.” Please supplement your disclosure here to explain how this proportional voting is achieved.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Principal and Selling Shareholders, page 115
SEC asked (67)
In light of the disclosure requirements of Item 6.E.1 in Part I of Form 20-F, please tell us what consideration you have given to disclosing here the executive officers’ MEP participation interests.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Principal and Selling Shareholders, page 115
SEC asked (68)
Given the U.S. address disclosed at the end of footnote (1), please state the number of record holders in the United States and the corresponding percentage of the outstanding shares currently held in the United States. See Item 7.A.2 in Part I of Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Description of Capital Stock, page 125
SEC asked (69)
Please include disclosure describing the material differences among, the Class A, Class B1 and Class B2 ordinary shares.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Description of Capital Stock, page 125
SEC asked (70)
Please expand your disclosure to incorporate (i) the requirements of Item 10.B.2. in Part I of Form 20-F, including, but not limited to, a summary of the applicable provisions of your articles of association regarding a director’s power in the absence of an independent quorum to vote compensation to themselves or any members of their body; and (ii) the requirements of paragraph (b) of Item 10.B.3 in Part I of FormRest of the question
20-F if cumulative voting in the election of directors is permitted.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Description of Capital Stock, page 125
SEC asked (71)
Refer to Item 10.B.9 in Part I of Form 20-F. Under a separate descriptive heading, please disclose the material differences between Dutch laws and the laws of United States, explaining also the effect that the applicable law would have on the noted disclosure items.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Liquidation Rights and Dissolution, page 130
SEC asked (72)
Please make clear any limits to the liabilities of shareholders, including whether shareholders may be liable for the debts of the corporation beyond the amount of distributions they receive.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Dutch Corporate Governance Code, page 131
SEC asked (73)
Supplementally advise, with a view to disclosure, how the “nature of your business” justifies your not following the Dutch Corporate Governance Code provision requiring that a majority of board members be non-executive directors who are independent.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Underwriting, page 135
SEC asked (74)
Please revise your disclosure to include each underwriter’s address. See Item 9.B.1. in Part I of Form 20-F.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Ordinary Shares Eligible for Future Sale, page 136 · Regulation S, page 136
SEC asked (75)
Revise your first sentence to state that Regulation S under the Securities Act provides that offers or sales, and reoffers or resales, of securities may occur without registration under Section 5 of the Securities Act provided that the offer or sale is made in an offshore transaction and no directed selling efforts are made in the U.S. (as those terms are defined in Regulation S) subject to certain other conditions.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Material U.S. Federal Income Tax Consequences, page 138
SEC asked (76)
We note your statement that, while you believe that you will not be a passive foreign investment company (“PFIC”) for the current taxable year or in the foreseeable future, because PFIC status is a fact-intensive determination, “it is possible that [you] may become a PFIC due to changes in [your] income or asset composition or a decline in the market value of [your] equity” and “no assurance can be given that [you]Rest of the question
are not, have not been, or will not become, classified as a PFIC.” Accordingly, provide a risk factor that briefly discusses the risks to your U.S. holders should you be classified as a PFIC.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Material U.S. Federal Income Tax Consequences, page 138
SEC asked (77)
Expand upon your PFIC discussion by describing the various elections that a U.S. holder may be able to take to mitigate the adverse consequences of PFIC tax status. Include in this discussion whether, should you be classified as a PFIC, you do not intend to furnish the information necessary for U.S. holders to make qualified electing fund elections that would provide some relief from the PFIC rules.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Enforcement of Judgments, page 154
SEC asked (78)
Please revise your discussion to: consider moving the substance of the risk “United States civil liabilities may not be enforceable against us” on page 40 to this heading; make clear whether shareholders may originate actions in the Netherlands to enforce liabilities against you based upon the U.S. federal securities laws. Refer to Item 101(g)(1) of Regulation S-K.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Where You Can Find Additional Information, page 154
SEC asked (79)
Disclose that your Form 20-F annual report will be due four months from the end of each fiscal year.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financial Statements · Financial Statements for the Period Ended June 30, 2012
SEC asked (80)
Please address the comments below related to the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2011 in your interim financial statements as well to the extent applicable.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Unaudited Condensed Interim Consolidated Financial Statements of Changes in Equity, page F-5
SEC asked (81)
Please disclose the nature of the line item described as allocation of previous year net loss.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to the Financial Statements · Note 22. Related Party Transactions, page F-26
SEC asked (82)
You disclose related party revenues for the year ended December 31, 2011 on page F- 74. Please confirm that you did not have any related party revenues during the six months ended June 30, 2012 or June 30, 2011.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financial Statements for the Year Ended December 31, 2011
SEC asked (83)
It appears that you refer to minority interests instead of noncontrolling interests pursuant to IAS 27.4 in certain places, including page F-32. Please revise as necessary.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Consolidated Income Statement, page F-28
SEC asked (84)
Please present basic and diluted earnings per share amounts from continuing operations on the face of your income statement. Refer to IAS 33.66.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Consolidated Statement of Comprehensive Income (Loss), page F-29
SEC asked (85)
Please disclose the amount of income tax related to each component of other comprehensive income either in the statement or in the notes to the financial statements. Refer to IAS 1.90.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Consolidated Statement of Changes in Equity, page F-31
SEC asked (86)
Please present a reconciliation of each component of other comprehensive income in the statement or in the notes to the financial statements. Refer to IAS 1.106A, 1.106(d)(ii), and paragraph BC74A of IAS 1.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows, page F-32
SEC asked (87)
Please help us understand how you determined it was appropriate to begin your determination of net cash flows from operating activities with net loss before minority interests and discontinued operations pursuant to IAS 7.18.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows, page F-32
SEC asked (88)
You present changes linked to discontinued activity in cash flows from financing activities. Please also present any net cash flows attributable to operating and investing activities of discontinued operations. Refer to IFRS 5.33(c).
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows, page F-32
SEC asked (89)
Please tell us whether any liability amounts as of December 31, 2010, December 31, 2011, or June 30, 2012 include amounts owed related to property, plant and equipment. To the extent that you do have liabilities outstanding as of the end of any of these periods related to property, plant and equipment, please confirm that these amounts are excluded from your determination of cash flows of investing activities untilRest of the question
the period in which a cash payment is made. Refer to IAS 7.16(a).
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows, page F-32
SEC asked (90)
Please tell us how you determined it was appropriate to present cash flows related to factoring, term-loan, and other loans on a net rather than gross basis pursuant to IAS 7.22 through 24.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
F-36 · Goodwill, page F-36
SEC asked (91)
Please clarify what your cash-generating units are and expand your disclosures pursuant to IAS 36.134 and 135 to the extent applicable.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Revenue Recognition, page F-38
SEC asked (92)
Please separately disclose the amount of revenues recognized for services provided related to tolling arrangements. Refer to IAS 18.35(c).
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Deferred Tooling Revenue and Related Costs, page F-39
SEC asked (93)
In a similar manner to the disclosures in the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2010 on page F-99, please expand your disclosures to discuss how you account for tooling revenue and related costs. Please also provide the disclosures called for by IAS 11.39 through 45.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Leases, page F-41 · Constellium as the Lessor, page F-41
SEC asked (94)
Please provide the disclosures required by IAS 17.47 and 48 regarding your finance lease arrangements.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 2.6. Judgments in Applying Accounting Policies and Key Sources of Estimation · Uncertainty, page F-45
SEC asked (95)
We remind you that IAS 1.129 states that the disclosures in IAS 1.125 should help users of the financial statements understand the judgments that you make about the future and other sources of estimation uncertainty. Your current disclosures appear to only provide a general discussion and in some cases appear to only repeat disclosures provided in Note 2.5. Please refer to the examples provided in IAS 1.125.Rest of the question
For example, it would appear that you should provide a more detailed discussion regarding the assumptions used in determining the defined benefit obligation and net pension costs. You should consider disclosing how you derive estimates and related assumptions, how accurate those estimates/assumptions have been in the past, and whether the estimates/assumptions are reasonably likely to change in the future. Please also consider providing quantitative as well as qualitative information when information is reasonably available.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-46
SEC asked (96)
The sum of receivables on your statement of financial position for Engineered Aluminum Products as of December 31, 2010 appears to be approximately 200 million Euros higher than the amounts reflected in the table on page F-47 when taking the sum of long-term loans receivable, trade receivables and other, and short-term loans receivable.Rest of the question
Please help us better understand why there would be such a significant difference.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-46
SEC asked (97)
You disclose on page 66 that an impairment charge was recorded related to property, plant and equipment and intangible assets during 2010 as a result of the pending acquisition. It appears the fair value of property, plant and equipment was further reduced by an additional 123 million Euros in recording the acquisition on January 4, 2011.Rest of the question
Please help us better understand what resulted in the additional reduction in value when recording the acquisition.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-46
SEC asked (98)
Please expand your disclosures regarding acquired receivables, contingent liabilities and goodwill recorded related to the acquisition pursuant to IFRS 3.60. Refer to paragraphs B64(h),(j) and (k) of IFRS 3.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-46
SEC asked (99)
On January 4, 2011, Rio Tinto International Holdings Limited subscribed in class “A” shares to bring their equity holdings into Omega Holdco B.V., which is now referred to as Constellium Holdco B.V., to 39%. On this date, Constellium Holdco B.V. also acquired substantially all of the entities and business of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products from Rio Tinto International Holdings Limited.Rest of the question
Please tell us the form of consideration paid for the acquisition and how you differentiated between the consideration paid for the acquisition versus the consideration paid for the subscription of shares. Note 10. Earnings Per Share, page F-51 100. Please disclose instruments (including contingently issuable shares) that could potentially dilute basic earnings per share in the future but were not included in the calculation of diluted earnings per share because they were antidilutive for the period presented. Refer to IAS 33.70(c). Note 11. Property, Plant and Equipment, page F-52 101. Please disclose the amount of contractual commitments for the acquisition of property, plant and equipment pursuant to IAS 16.71(c). 102. The majority of your property, plant and equipment at December 31, 2011 is construction work in progress and therefore not currently being depreciated. Please disclose the nature of the items that are included in construction work in progress and when you expect to place these assets in service. Note 16. Trade Receivables and Other Factoring Arrangements, page F-56 103. In regards to your factoring arrangements, please address the following: In December 2011, you amended the French factoring agreement to allow the partial derecognition of some receivables. Your disclosures on page F-17 indicate that you also amended the French factoring agreement in June 2012. Please disclose the nature of the amendments made which resulted in the partial derecognition of receivables; Please provide the disclosures required by IFRS 7.13(c) and (d) including the total carrying amount of the original assets, the amount of assets you continue to recognize, and the carrying amount of associated liabilities in factoring arrangements in which you continue to recognize the assets to the extent of continuing involvement; and Please disclose how you present cash flows related to factoring arrangements. Please specifically address any differences between those arrangements in which you derecognize receivables versus those that you do not. 104. Please provide additional clarity in your disclosures regarding the extent to which your arrangements resulted in derecognition of receivables versus those for which the sales of receivables did not qualify for derecognition. The borrowings amount disclosed on page F- 17 as of June 30, 2012 appears to indicate that a significant portion did not qualify for derecognition. Note 19. Pension Liabilities and Other Post-Retirement Healthcare Obligations, page F-61 105. Please provide the following disclosures: The actual return on plan assets pursuant to IAS 19.120A(m); and The estimated expected contributions to be paid to the plan pursuant to IAS 19.120(q). Note 20. Provisions, page F-66 106. Please expand your disclosures pursuant to IAS 37.85 to address the expected timing of outflows related to the provisions recorded. Please also describe any uncertainties about the amount or timing as well as the major assumptions made concerning future events in arriving at the provision amount. 107. In regards to the claims and lawsuits in France that your businesses have been subject to related to occupational diseases, please consider expanding your disclosures pursuant to Question 3 of SAB Topic 5:P, which would include disclosure of the number of claims pending at each balance sheet date, the number of claims filed for each period presented, the number of claims dismissed, settled, or otherwise resolved for each period, and the average settlement amount per claim. The disclosures should address historical and expected trends in these amounts and their reasonably likely effects on operating results and liquidity. Note 21. Share Capital, page F-67 108. Please provide us with an analysis of any equity issuances since January 1, 2012 as well as any planned equity issuances. For each transaction, identify the parties, including any related parties; the purpose of the issuance; how you accounted or will account for the issuance; the nature of any consideration; the fair value and your basis for determining the fair value; and o Indicate whether the fair value was contemporaneous or retrospective. o To the extent applicable, reconcile the fair values you used for equity transactions to the fair value indicated by the anticipated IPO price. For equity transactions in which your Board of Directors estimated the fair value, please provide us with a detailed explanation of the significant factors, assumptions, and methodologies used in determining fair value. We will not be able to complete our evaluation of your response until the IPO range has been disclosed. 109. Class B2 Shares can be converted into Class B1 shares that give the same economic rights as Class A shares upon vesting. Please clarify what economic rights, if any, Class B2 Shares have prior to converting to Class B1 Shares. Please also clarify whether Class B1 and B2 shares have any rights to dividends. Note 23. Financial Instruments, page F-71 110. Please provide the disclosures called for by IFRS 7.9 through 11 regarding changes in the fair value of your derivative assets and liabilities attributable to changes in credit risk. Note 24. Commitments and Contingencies, page F-73 111. For any matter for which there is a possible or present obligation that may, but probably will not, require an outflow of resources, please provide the disclosures called for by IAS 37.86. Note 26. Operating Segment Information, page F-75 112. Please separately present each significant reconciling item in your reconciliations, including amounts related to eliminations or reversal of transactions between segments and head office or regional administrative centers. Refer to IFRS 8.28. 113. Please provide the disclosures required by IFRS 8.34 regarding major customers. 114. Please help us understand why you are presenting a subtotal for EBITDA in the reconciliation between Segment Adjusted EBITDA and Net Loss. Alternatively, please remove this line item from your reconciliation. Note 30. Share Equity Plan, page F-80 115. During 2011, some beneficiaries left and new participants were elected to the plan. Please disclose how you determined the price at which the new beneficiaries acquired shares, including if you determined it was the fair value on the transaction date, as well as the corresponding accounting for the issuance of the shares pursuant to IFRS 2. Note 32. Subsequent Events, page F-82 116. Please provide the disclosures required by IAS 10.17 through 22 as applicable. Your disclosures should include the date when the financial statements were authorized to be issued and who gave that authorization. Waiver in Relation to the Constellium Rolled Products – Ravenswood LLC’s ABL Facility, page F-82 117. In regards to the waiver received related to the ABL Facility, please address the following: Please disclose the terms of the waiver, including when it expires; and Please disclose the potential impact on your liquidity and capital resources of not being able to comply with these covenants and obtain waivers of compliance in the future. Financial Statements for the Years Ended December 31, 2010 and December 31, 2009 118. Please address the above comments as applicable. Note 2. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies Allocations from Owners, page F-97 119. Please clearly disclose, if true, that the financial statement provided reflect all of the costs of doing business related to these operations, including expenses incurred by other entities on your behalf. Please clearly disclose the allocation method used for each material type of cost allocated and your assertion that the methods used are reasonable. Refer to SAB Topic 1:B.1.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Market and Industry Data, page iii
SEC asked (1)
Please refer to comment 11 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. As previously requested, please provide us supplementally with copies of the third party sources referenced in the registration statement, appropriately marked to point out the information you are using to support your disclosures.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary of Consolidated Historical Financial Data, page 17
SEC asked (2)
We note your response to comment 18 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. In regards to your presentation of Segment Adjusted EBITDA and Management Adjusted EBITDA, please address the following: We continue to believe that you should further clarify in your disclosures why both of these Adjusted EBITDA amounts are useful performance measures pursuant to Item 10(e)(1)(i)(C) of Regulation S-K.Rest of the question
Your current disclosures address why you believe an Adjusted EBITDA-related performance measure is useful; however, you do not address why two different Adjusted-EBITDA-related measures are useful. Please also confirm that your determination of Management Adjusted EBITDA as presented is consistent with how this measure is determined pursuant to your financial covenants; As a result of the reconciling items that you have disclosed on pages 72 and F-77, the total of the Segment Management Adjusted EBITDA amounts and Segment Adjusted EBITDA amounts presented starting on page 4 for all segments do not equal the amounts presented on page 19. Please accordingly expand your disclosures subsequent to your discussion of each operating segment on page 7 to discuss these reconciling items; Please expand your disclosures to discuss how you calculate the amount of the metal price lag adjustment to arrive at Management Adjusted EBITDA; and We continue to have difficulty understanding how you determined it was appropriate to present alternative Management Adjusted EBITDA amounts as well as your basis for assuming that you would have had similar cost savings amounts in 2009 and 2010 compared to what you had in 2011. Please either remove your presentation of these alternative Management Adjusted EBITDA amounts in note (k) or further advise.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary of Consolidated Historical Financial Data, page 17
SEC asked (3)
Given that metal price lag appears to have a direct impact on your profitability, it is not clear why your disclosures on pages 19, 101, and elsewhere throughout the filing indicate that it is not an indicator of the performance of your underlying operations. Please revise your disclosures accordingly throughout the filing.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Risk Factors, page 21 · We are principally owned by Apollo, Rio Tinto and FSI…, page 35
SEC asked (4)
We note your revised disclosure in response to comment 25 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Further revise your risk factor disclosure to briefly explain the legal significance of a “binding nomination,” indicating also the number of binding nominations each of your three principal shareholders may put forward.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Use of Proceeds, page 44
SEC asked (5)
Please include here the company’s reasons for conducting the offering as you have stated them in your response to comment 31 in our letter dated December 31, 2012.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Use of Proceeds, page 44
SEC asked (6)
Your disclosures indicate that you intend to use the net proceeds of this offering for general corporate purposes, which may include the repayment of debt. Please make sure your Use of Proceeds discussions on pages 16 and 44 are consistent. Specifically, the disclosures on page 16 do not mention the possibility of using the net proceeds to repay debt.Rest of the question
Please also confirm that there are no specific plans at this time to use the net proceeds to repay debt.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Management’s Discussion and Analysis · Key Factors Influencing Constellium’s Financial Condition and Results from Operations, page
SEC asked (7)
Given that the price of metal can significantly impact your overall profitability, please consider disclosing metal prices or discussing the overall market movements for metal prices during each period as well as any material changes to these prices that have taken place subsequent to the end of the period. Refer to Item 303(a)(3)(ii) of Regulation S-K.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Results of Operations, page 59
SEC asked (8)
We note your response to comment 39 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. In a similar manner to your response, please expand your disclosures to discuss the impact of your use of financial instruments to minimize the risks associated with foreign currency exchange rates and metal prices.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 74
SEC asked (9)
We note your response to comment 45 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Please disclose whether you have held any positions in the past which resulted in margin calls and the extent of these margin calls.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Contractual Obligations, page 78
SEC asked (10)
We note your response to comment 48 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Given that it appears the interest rate under the term loan facility is the greater of 8% or a LIBORbased rate plus a floor, please help us better understand how you determined it would be appropriate to reflect the floor of 1.25% for purposes of estimating interest payments.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Aerospace & Transportation Operating Segment, page 85
SEC asked (11)
Please revise your disclosure to include a summary of your response to comment 51 in our letter dated December 31, 2012.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Principal and Selling Shareholders, page 121
SEC asked (12)
Please ensure that your disclosure here complies with the requirements of Item 9.D in Part I of Form 20-F, and in particular Item 9.D.2 requirements of specifying the amount and percentage of securities held by the selling shareholders immediately after the offering.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Dutch Corporate Governance Code, page 138
SEC asked (13)
Please include here a summary of your response to comment 73 in our letter December 31, 2012.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financial Statements for the Period Ended June 30, 2012 · Note 17. Borrowings, page F-18
SEC asked (14)
We note your response to comment 41 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Please also expand your disclosures in the notes to the financial statements to clearly state whether you were in compliance with all covenants and to discuss the terms of the significant covenants that you are subject to in your debt agreements.Rest of the question
For example, your disclosures on page 72 refer to a financial maintenance covenant under your ABL Facility, which it does not appear is discussed in the notes to the financial statements on page F-20.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
F-37 · Goodwill, page F-37
SEC asked (15)
We note your response to comment 91 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Your response indicates that your cash-generating units generally correspond to an industrial site whereas your disclosures on page F-37 indicate that goodwill is monitored at the operating segment level. It is not clear if your cash-generating units are your operating segments or your industrial sites. Please clarify in your disclosures.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 2.6 Judgments in Applying Accounting Policies and Key Sources of Estimation · Uncertainty, page F-46
SEC asked (16)
We note your response to comment 95 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. It is unclear what additional disclosures were provided pursuant to IAS 1.125 to help users of the financial statements understand the judgments that you make about the future and other sources of estimation uncertainty.Rest of the question
Please consider disclosing how you derive estimates and related assumptions, how accurate those estimates/assumptions have been in the past, and whether the estimates/assumptions are reasonably likely to change in the future. Please also consider providing quantitative as well as qualitative information when information is reasonably available.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-48
SEC asked (17)
We note your response to comment 97 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Please help us further understand how your application of IFRS 3 led to a further reduction in the value of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets after the recording of an impairment charge pursuant to IAS 36.Rest of the question
Please specifically address the following: IAS 36.18 states that the recoverable amount is the higher of an asset’s or cashgenerating unit’s fair value less costs to sell and its value in use. Please tell us what consideration was given to the value in use in your analysis; Please tell us what consideration you gave to IAS 36.23 in determining that you should use the recoverable amount for cash-generating units instead of for individual assets. In this regard, we note that for purposes of applying IFRS 3, you indicate that you were able to perform an asset by asset assessment; You state that the fair value was assigned to each cash-generating unit in a rational and systematic manner. Given that it appears you would have determined the fair value for each cash-generating unit, it is not clear why you would be allocating amounts at the cash-generating unit level. Please advise; Please help us understand how you allocated the impairment loss to the assets of the cash-generating unit pursuant to IAS 36.104 through 107; and Please help us better understand why the fair value determined pursuant to IFRS 3 would be significantly less than the fair value less costs to sell pursuant to IAS 36.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-48
SEC asked (18)
We note your response to comment 98 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Your response indicates that you did not recognize a contingent liability because the fair value could not be measured reliably. In this regard, please provide the disclosures called for by paragraph B64(j)(i) and (ii) of IFRS 3.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 10. Earnings Per Share, page F-52
SEC asked (19)
We note your response to comment 100 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. We continue to believe that you should disclose instruments (including contingently issuable shares) that could potentially dilute basic earnings per share in the future but were not included in the calculation of diluted earnings per share because they were antidilutive for the period presented. Refer to IAS 33.70(c).Rest of the question
Though the additional shares may not be material to current earnings per share amounts, it is not clear how you determined they would not be material to future earnings per share amounts.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 16. Trade Receivables and Other · Factoring Arrangements, page F-56
SEC asked (20)
We note your response to comment 103 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. It is not clear where you provided additional disclosures regarding the cash flow statement presentation of your factoring arrangements. Please advise or revise your disclosures as necessary.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 20. Provisions, page F-67
SEC asked (21)
We note your response to comment 106 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Please provide the disclosures required by IAS 37.85 for the litigation accrual of 8 million Euros at December 31, 2011.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 20. Provisions, page F-67
SEC asked (22)
We note your response to comment 107 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Please also disclose or tell us what consideration you gave to disclosing the average settlement amount per claim as well as historical and expected trends in the liability amounts and their reasonably likely effects on operating results and liquidity.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 21. Share Capital, page F-68
SEC asked (23)
We note your response to comment 109 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. In a similar manner to your response, please clarify the economic rights, including dividend rights of each class of shares in the notes to the financial statements.Rest of the question
Please also clarify in your disclosures how the different classes of shares are treated for purposes of determining earnings per share, including what consideration was given to IAS 33.A13 and A14 in determining whether you have participating equity instruments and two-class ordinary shares.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 26. Operating Segment Information, page F-76
SEC asked (24)
We note your response to comment 112 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. It appears that you have included Holding and Corporate assets as part of the Intersegment and Other line item in your reconciliation from segment assets to total assets. Please separately present Holding and Corporate assets in your reconciliation. Please also disclose the nature of the assets described as Intersegment and Other.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 30. Share Equity Plan, page F-80
SEC asked (25)
We note your response to comment 115 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Please address the following: Please help us better understand how you determined that the April 2011 and July 2011 share issuances fall outside the scope of IFRS 2 given that the purpose of these issuances was to align management’s interests with the interests of shareholders and to enable management to participate in the long-term growthRest of the question
of the company; Please confirm there were no new shares acquired or reissued under the Management Equity Plan during 2012. If so, please tell us the dates and the corresponding fair values of the shares; Please tell us what consideration was given to IFRS 2.19 through 21 in determining how to treat the vesting provisions in terms of determining the fair value of the class B shares as well as determining how and when to record the expense associated with the share issuances; and Please disclose the factors which have caused significant differences between the fair values of the class A and B shares.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financial Statements for the Year Ended December 31, 2010 and December 31, 2009 · Allocations from Owners, page F-98
SEC asked (26)
We note your response to comment 119 in our letter dated December 31, 2012. Please clearly disclose the allocation method used for each material type of cost allocated.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (1)
Please note that any comments regarding your confidential treatment request will be sent under separate cover and we will not consider a request for acceleration of effectiveness of the registration statement until we resolve all issues concerning the confidential treatment request.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Holdings and Corporate, page 7
SEC asked (2)
We note your response to comment two in our letter dated February 27, 2013. Please also disclose the percentage of Management Adjusted EBITDA which is attributable to Holdings and Corporate.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Risk Factors, page 22 · Our indebtedness could materially adversely affect our ability to invest in or fund our operations…, page 30
SEC asked (3)
In light of your ability to negotiate a greater term loan which will be used to fund the €250 million distribution to your equity holders (refer to your “Term Loan” disclosure on page 128), with a view towards disclosure, please tell us what consideration you have given to updating your risk factor disclosure to adequately describe how your indebtedness may impact your operations.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Use of Proceeds, page 45
SEC asked (4)
We note your response to comment six in our letter dated February 27, 2013. You intend to use the net proceeds of this offering for general corporate purposes, which may include the repayment of debt. Please tell us if there are specific plans at this time to use the net proceeds to repay debt.Rest of the question
Please address what consideration you gave as to whether pro forma financial information should be provided for the repayment of debt from the use of offering proceeds as well as the refinancing of the term loan which is discussed on page 128. Refer to Article 11 of Regulation S-X.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Results of Operations · Segment Adjusted EBITDA, page 71
SEC asked (5)
We continue to believe that you should better quantify the impact of each significant factor when multiple factors contribute to material changes in Segment Adjusted EBITDA. For example, for the Aerospace & Transportation segment for the year ended December 31, 2012 compared to the year ended December 31, 2011, Segment Adjusted EBITDA more than tripled.Rest of the question
There appear to be multiple factors which resulted in this net increase, which include increased pricing and spreads on aerospace products, lower overhead and laboring expenses in Sierre, increased R&D costs, and the weakening of the Swiss franc. Please revise your discussion accordingly. Refer to Items 303(a)(3)(i) and (iii) of Regulation S-K as well as Financial Reporting Codification 501.04.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Cash Flows, page 77 · Net Cash from Operating Activities, page 77
SEC asked (6)
Please expand your disclosures to discuss the underlying reasons for changes in working capital components, with specific discussions for trade receivables and inventories. Given the impact that changes in your trade receivables had on your cash flows from operations, please also consider whether a discussion of financial measures such as days sales outstanding would be relevant to a reader of your financialRest of the question
statements. See Section IV.B of the SEC Interpretive Release No. 33-8350.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Contractual Obligations, page 79
SEC asked (7)
We note your response to comment 10 in our letter dated February 27, 2013. In a similar manner to your response, please clarify in your disclosures that the interest rate used for purposes of purposes of estimating interest payments in the table is an assumed 1.25% floor plus 8%.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financial Statements · Consolidated Statement of Financial Position, page F-5
SEC asked (8)
On March 13, 2013, the Board of Directors approved a one-time distribution of approximately 250 million Euros. Please present a pro forma statement of financial position alongside the historical statement of financial position reflecting the distribution with corresponding footnote disclosure. Please also provide the pro forma per share data required by SAB Topic 1:B.3 regarding this distribution.Rest of the question
In this regard, we note that the distribution amount exceeds your earnings for the year ended December 31, 2012.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to the Financial Statements · Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-23
SEC asked (9)
We note your response to comment 17 in our letter dated February 27, 2013. Given the proximity of the your impairment assessment as of December 31, 2010 to the acquisition on January 4, 2011, we continue to have difficulty understanding what caused such a significant further reduction in the value of property, plant and equipment at the time of the acquisition.Rest of the question
If the recoverable amount of an asset is less than its carrying amount, IAS 36.59 requires an impairment charge to be recorded so that the carrying amount of the asset is reduced to its recoverable amount. Pursuant to IAS 36.18, the recoverable amount is defined as the higher of an asset’s or cash-generating unit’s fair value less costs to sell and its value in use. You used the fair value less costs to sell to determine the recoverable amount, which you believe would be essentially the same as the value in use. IFRS 3.18 requires identifiable assets acquired to be measured at their acquisition-date fair values. Given that there does not appear to be any difference in how fair value is defined in IAS 36.25 and Appendix A of IFRS, please help us understand why the fair value less costs to sell would be higher under IAS 36 compared to the fair value pursuant to IFRS 3.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to the Financial Statements · Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-23
SEC asked (10)
The balance sheet as of December 31, 2010 includes 214 million Euros of property, plant and equipment whereas the fair value of property, plant and equipment acquired on January 4, 2011 was 91 million Euros. If there are factors aside from the write-down to fair value pursuant to IFRS 3 which contributed to this decrease, please identify each factor and the corresponding amount.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to the Financial Statements · Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-23
SEC asked (11)
You indicate that the acquisition-date fair value of property, plant and equipment under IFRS 3 was measured primarily using a cost approach adjusted by economic obsolescence determined using the income approach. Please help us understand how this cost-based methodology results in you measuring these assets at acquisition-date fair value pursuant to IFRS 3.18.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to the Financial Statements · Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-23
SEC asked (12)
At April 2012, the 2010 impairment charge was re-assessed and it was determined that the change in fair value as a result of the ultimate settlement did not create a material change in the impairment charge as when it was applied to the cash generating units it was primarily applied to either cash generating units for which assets had already been fully impaired or where the cash generating units did not require anyRest of the question
impairments. Please provide us with a summary of this analysis performed by cash generating units. Your analysis should show each of the cash generating units which was impacted by the write-down of property, plant and equipment upon acquisition pursuant to IFRS 3 and the corresponding amount of the reduction in value. For each of these cash generating units, please explain how you determined that there was no impact to the 2010 impairment charge recorded pursuant to IAS 36.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 12. Earnings Per Share, page F-32
SEC asked (13)
Please help us understand and disclose how you determined Class B2 shares should be treated as ordinary shares for purposes of determining earnings per share given that Class B2 shares are subject to vesting. Refer to IAS 33.6.Rest of the question
Please clarify if you have determined Class B2 shares to be participating pursuant to IAS 33.A13 and A14 as well as whether the rights to dividends held by Class B2 shareholders are nonforfeitable.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 18. Share Capital, page F-39
SEC asked (14)
We note your response to comment 23 in our letter dated February 27, 2013. We continue to believe that you should further clarify the differences between Class B1 and B2 shares in your disclosures. For example, your response to comment 109 in our letter dated December 31, 2012 states that Class B2 shares have a right to a pro rata part of the profits; however, prior to conversion to Class B1 shares, such profitsRest of the question
shall be attributed to the dividend reserve for the Class B2 shares. This amount will be added to the dividend reserve for the Class B1 shares upon conversion to Class B1 shares. Please also disclose what happens to the Class B2 dividend reserve if the shares do not convert to Class B1 shares.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 22. Provisions, page F-49 · Legal Claims and Other Costs, page F-50
SEC asked (15)
In regards to litigation and disease claims, you do not anticipate that the resolution will have a material effect on your future results. Please also disclose the expected impact of the resolution of these matters on your financial position and cash flows.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 29. Subsidiaries and Operating Segments, page F-64
SEC asked (16)
It appears that the cross operating segment represents the packaging and automotive rolled products segment as disclosed on page F-24. Please revise your disclosures as necessary.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 30. Share Equity Plan, page F-65
SEC asked (17)
It appears that the vesting period that you refer to related to the Class B2 shares actually represents the period of time over which the Class B2 shares can be converted into Class B1 shares. Please clarify accordingly in your disclosures as well as disclose how you determined that this period should be treated as the vesting period for purposes of accounting for these shares pursuant to IFRS 2.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 32. Subsequent Events, page F-66
SEC asked (18)
In March 2013, you received a binding offer for the purchase of two plants in France. It does not appear that these assets were classified as held for sale on your statement of financial position as of December 31, 2012. Based on the terms of the offer, please tell us what consideration you gave as to whether the carrying amount of the assets are recoverable.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Recent Developments, page 14
SEC asked (1)
You present Management Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDA for the last twelve months ended March 31, 2013. In a similar manner to your reconciliations for the three months ended March 31, 2013, please reconcile these non-GAAP financial measures to the corresponding GAAP financial measure.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Recent Developments, page 14
SEC asked (2)
You currently anticipate issuing preference shares to your existing Class A and Class B1 shareholders. Please expand your disclosures to explain how you will determine how many preference shares each Class A and B1 shareholder will receive, including if they will receive a pro-rata number of shares based on their current ownership.Rest of the question
Please clarify if any preferential treatment will be given to any of the shareholders in determining the number of preference shares they will receive. Please also clearly disclose the significant terms of these preference shares in your recent developments section.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Recent Developments, page 14
SEC asked (3)
Please clarify, if true, that you anticipate paying a distribution of 147 million Euros to Class A preference shareholders throughout your filing rather than just referring to Class A shareholders. In this regard, we note the disclosures on page 140 which indicate that only preference shareholders will receive the additional distribution of 147 million Euros.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Selling Shareholder Private Sale, page 15
SEC asked (4)
Please tell us the percentage of Class A ordinary shares that you expect will be sold by Apollo and Rio Tinto to FSI as part of the selling shareholder private sale.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Selling Shareholder Private Sale, page 15
SEC asked (5)
Please tell us what consideration you have given to filing the share purchase agreement as an exhibit to the registration statement. In addition, please clarify whether FSI will sell shares in the offering. We note that you have included FSI in the “Principal and Selling Shareholders” table, but since you have not yet disclosed the number of shares being offered in this offering, it is unclear to us whether FSI willRest of the question
offer shares, or whether it is in the table because it is a 10% shareholder prior to the offering.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Dividend Policy, page 47
SEC asked (6)
You disclose on page F-31 that the Class A, B1, and B2 shares have equal rights to profit allocation and dividends. In this regard, please disclose why the distribution of 103 million Euros was only made to holders of Class A and B1 ordinary shares. In addition, your disclosures on page 140 indicate that only Class A preference shareholders will receive the additional planned 147 million Euros distribution.Rest of the question
It appears that only holders of Class A and B1 ordinary shares will receive preference shares and correspondingly the 147 million Euros distribution.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 48
SEC asked (7)
It is not clear why the preference shares in your capitalization table are presented with cash and cash equivalents rather than with your other equity accounts to arrive at total deficit. Please advise or revise as necessary.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 48
SEC asked (8)
Based on the description above your capitalization table, it does not appear that you intend to present the 147 million Euros planned distribution discussed on page 47. Please revise to include this distribution.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 48
SEC asked (9)
Please disclose whether the proceeds of the New Term Loan obtained in the March 25, 2013 financing were used to pay the 103 million Euros distribution.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Dilution, page 50
SEC asked (10)
With a view towards disclosure, please tell us whether the preference shares you intend to distribute to your existing Class A and Class B1 shareholders will have a dilutive impact to the investors’ interest in the IPO. In this regard we note your disclosure on page 15 under “Recent Developments.”
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Selected Financial Information, page 54
SEC asked (11)
There appears to be a typographical error in note (1) to the table presented on page 55. It appears that net trade working capital is determined by subtracting the current portion of trade payables and other rather than trade receivables and other. Please revise as necessary.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Cash Flows, page 80 · Net Cash from Operating Activities, page 80
SEC asked (12)
We note your response to comment six in our letter dated April 8, 2013. Please expand your disclosures to explain how you calculate net working capital days as well as how this measure helps readers evaluate your financial statements.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to the Financial Statements · Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-22
SEC asked (13)
We note your response to comment nine in our letter dated April 8, 2013. The vast majority of the difference in fair value from December 31, 2010 to January 4, 2011 appears to be attributable to the impact of the difference in discount rates used.Rest of the question
You note that a different discount rate was applied by the Successor as part of the purchase price allocation to reflect a greater cost of capital attributable as a stand-alone rather than that which was attributed to the Predecessor as a group of entities managed by a large conglomerate. Please help us better understand how you determined the appropriate discount rate to use as of December 31, 2010 pursuant to IAS 36.55 through 57 and IAS 36.A15 through A21. It appears that this guidance suggests that the discount rate used should reflect the risks specific to the assets or cash-generating units being evaluated. It is not clear why there would be a significant difference in the discount rates used based on whether the company was a stand-alone entity or managed by a large conglomerate. In this regard, IAS 36.A17 indicates that an entity can use their weighted average cost of capital as a starting point; however, IAS 36.A18 indicates that this rate should be adjusted for specific risks related to the asset’s estimated cash flows. Please advise.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to the Financial Statements · Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-22
SEC asked (14)
Please tell us what the amount of the impairment loss would have been for the year ended December 31, 2010 if you had used the same discount rates as were used as part of the purchase price allocation on January 4, 2011.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to the Financial Statements · Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-22
SEC asked (15)
You used discount rates of 17% to 18.5% as of January 4, 2011 whereas such rates in the predecessor period were 11.5% to 14%. It appears that the discount rates of 17% to 18.5% were used in the discounted cash flow analysis performed to determine economic obsolescence when applying the depreciated replacement cost method as of January 4, 2011.Rest of the question
It is not clear how you applied the discount rates of 11.5% to 14% in your December 31, 2011 analysis pursuant to IAS 36. For example, please clarify if these were the rates used to determine the total business enterprise value of 1.2 billion Euros which was assigned to each cash-generating unit and then adjusted for the pension liability, debt facility, and estimated working capital adjustment.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 12. Earnings Per Share, page F-30
SEC asked (16)
We note your response to comment 13 in our letter dated April 8, 2013. We continue to have difficulty understanding how you determined Class B2 shares are ordinary shares versus potential ordinary shares pursuant to IAS 33.5 through 7.Rest of the question
Given that Class B2 shares are subject to vesting, please provide us with a comprehensive explanation as to how you determined these are ordinary shares and are not participating securities pursuant to IAS 33.A13 and A14.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 18. Share Capital, page F-39
SEC asked (17)
We note your response to comment 14 in our letter dated April 8, 2013. Please expand your disclosures to clearly explain the differences between Class B1 and B2 shares in your disclosures. For example, you should clarify if the only difference is the vesting terms associated with Class B2 shares as well as if only Class B2 shares are issued under the share equity plan.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 32. Subsequent Events, page F-63
SEC asked (18)
We note your response to comment 18 in our letter dated April 8, 2013. In the fourth quarter and up to the 2012 financial statement issuance date, you assessed the potential impact of the disposal process on the carrying amount of the assets related to the Ham and Saint-Florentin sites and determined that the recoverable amount was not less than the carrying value.Rest of the question
It is not clear what consideration you gave to the binding offer received in March 2013 and whether this offer was before or after the 2012 financial statement issuance date. Based on the terms of the offer, please tell us what consideration you gave as to whether the carrying amounts of the assets are recoverable. If the recoverable amounts based on this offer were less than the carrying amounts, please tell us the amount of the difference.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 33. Pro Forma Information (Unaudited), page F-63
SEC asked (19)
We note your response to comment eight in our letter dated April 8, 2013. Prior to the completion of this offering, you will issue preference shares. Please also reflect the issuance of the preference shares in your pro forma statement of financial position and in your determination of pro forma per share data.Rest of the question
In this regard, your disclosures on page 140 indicate that these preference shares will be participating securities pursuant to IAS 33.A13 and A14
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (1)
We note that on the prospectus cover page you have reflected the change in the company name and the form of corporate entity. Please reflect this change also with respect to company signature on page II-3 of the registration statement. In addition, please submit with your next amendment drafts of your legal opinion and the form of Amended and Restated Articles of Association of Constellium Holdco B.V.Rest of the question
for our review, as well as explain to us why the amended and restated articles of association are not those of Constellium N.V. In this regard, we note your “Corporate History and Information” on page 17 where you anticipate the conversion of the company into a Dutch public limited liability company renamed Constellium N.V. to occur immediately prior to the consummation of this offering. Please clarify whether you expect that the conversion will take place before or after effectiveness. For further guidance, please refer to Sections II.B.2(e) and (f) of Staff Legal Bulletin No.19 (CF) dated October14, 2011.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Recent Developments, page 14 · New Term Loan, Application of Term Loan Proceeds and Issuance of Preference Shares, page 16
SEC asked (2)
We note your response to comment two in our letter dated April 23, 2013. Once the 147 million Euros distribution has been paid on the preference shares, the rights attached to the preference shares will automatically and immediately become equal to the rights attached to the ordinary shares.Rest of the question
You have agreed with your existing shareholders to repurchase the preference shares for no consideration following the payment of the 147 million Euros. Please expand your disclosures to provide additional clarity as to what will happen after the 147 million Euros distribution is paid. Please further clarify if the repurchase of the preference shares will occur simultaneously with the payment of the distribution. If so, it is not clear why the holders would continue to have rights equal to the holders of ordinary shares.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Provisions of our documents and applicable law may impede or discourage a takeover…, page
SEC asked (3)
We note that you have added disclosure at the end of this risk factor stating that due to some of your products which may have applications in the defense sector, you may be subject to rules and regulations in jurisdictions that could impede or discourage takeovers.Rest of the question
Here or in an appropriate section of the filing, please expand your disclosure to identify this category of products and to better explain the resulting implications of being subject to such rules and regulations.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 50
SEC asked (4)
Please clearly show in the notes how you computed each pro forma and as adjusted pro forma amount, including a discussion of any significant assumptions and estimates used to arrive at the amounts. For example, you should clearly disclose in the note to the table each of the adjustments and corresponding amounts that impacted the as adjusted and as adjusted pro forma cash and cash equivalents as well as retainedRest of the question
deficit amounts.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 50
SEC asked (5)
We note your response to comment seven in our letter dated April 23, 2013. In a similar manner to your response, please clearly disclose why you are not presenting preference shares in your capitalization table.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 50
SEC asked (6)
The as adjusted and as adjusted pro forma column headings refer to notes 11 and 12 but there do not appear to be any corresponding notes 11 and 12. Please revise as necessary.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 50
SEC asked (7)
Please present the historical, as adjusted, and as adjusted pro forma shares authorized, issued and outstanding in your capitalization table.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Issuance of Ordinary Shares, page 146
SEC asked (8)
We note your disclosure that prior to completion of this offering, the shareholders will adopt a resolution in connection with the issuance prior to the conversion of Constellium into a Dutch public limited liability company, of a maximum of 94,289,289 Class A ordinary shares, 915,702 Class B1 ordinary shares and 1,037,493 Class B2 ordinary shares.Rest of the question
With a view towards disclosure please explain to us the transactions pursuant to which these shares will be issued, including the corresponding accounting and who is receiving these shares. In addition, please disclose the transaction(s) throughout the filing, including under the recent development section, and indicate how these issuances are reflected in your capitalization table and whether they will have a dilutive effect.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financial Statements
SEC asked (9)
Page 20 indicates that a stock split will occur prior to this offering. Please revise your financial statements and your disclosures throughout the filing to give retroactive effect to the expected stock split. Doing this in the next amendment will save us substantial review time in future amendments.Rest of the question
If your auditors believe that only a “draft” report can be presented, due to a pending future event such as the stock split, they can include in the filing a signed and dated preface to their “draft” report stating the reason for the “draft” report and that they expect to be in a position to issue the report in the form presented prior to effectiveness. A signed, dated, and unrestricted auditor’s report should be included in the filing prior to effectiveness. See Rule 2-02 of Regulation S-X.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-22
SEC asked (10)
We are continuing to evaluate your responses to comments 13 through 15 in our letter dated April 23, 2013 and may have additional comments.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 12. Earnings Per Share, page F-30
SEC asked (11)
We note your response to comment six in our letter dated April 23, 2013. Your response indicates that each class of shares only has rights to dividends to the extent of their share premium reserves. In addition, your disclosures on page 146 regarding the order in which the holders of Class A ordinary, Class B ordinary shares, and preference shares are entitled to profits indicate that the remaining profits after theRest of the question
147 million Euros distribution is made may not be allocated equally in certain circumstances. Please further clarify in your disclosures the rights to dividends and profits that each class is entitled to in the notes to the financial statements. In light of these potential differences, please tell us what consideration you gave to IAS 33.A13 and A14 for purposes of calculating earnings per share amounts.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 12. Earnings Per Share, page F-30
SEC asked (12)
Please help us understand why the earnings amount you are using to calculate basic and diluted earnings per share appears to include the amount attributable to non-controlling interests. Refer to IAS 33.A1.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 18. Share Capital, page F-37
SEC asked (13)
Please confirm there were no equity issuances since January 1, 2013 as well as any planned future equity issuances. If there were any, please provide the following for each transaction: identify the parties, including any related parties; the purpose of the issuance; how you accounted or will account for the issuance; the nature of any consideration; the fair value and your basis for determining the fairRest of the question
value; and o Indicate whether the fair value was contemporaneous or retrospective. o To the extent applicable, reconcile the fair values you used for equity transactions to the fair value indicated by the anticipated IPO price. For equity transactions in which your Board of Directors estimated the fair value, please provide us with a detailed explanation of the significant factors, assumptions, and methodologies used in determining fair value.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 30. Share Equity Plan, page F-62
SEC asked (14)
We note your response to comment 16 in our letter dated April 23, 2013. Your disclosures on page F-62 do not appear to indicate that any unvested limited partnership interests in the management equity plan have been issued since the plan was implemented in 2011. Please confirm and clarify your disclosures accordingly.Rest of the question
Similarly, your disclosures on page F-31 state that no instruments have been issued that may potentially have a dilutive effect.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 33. Pro Forma Information (Unaudited), page F-63
SEC asked (15)
We note your response to comment 19 in our letter dated April 23, 2013. Please clearly disclose how you are arriving at the amount of earnings for the twelve months preceding the dividend distribution, including the specific months that are being included in your computation.Rest of the question
We also remind you that the number of shares to be added to the denominator for purposes of pro forma per share data should not exceed the total number of shares to be issued in the offering.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Prospectus Cover Page
SEC asked (1)
Please identify the class of ordinary shares being offered by the selling shareholders. Please also ensure that the Principal and Selling Shareholders disclosure on page 136 identifies beneficial ownership for each class of ordinary shares.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
New Term Loan, Application of Term Loan Proceeds and Issuance of Preference Shares, page
SEC asked (2)
We note your revised disclosure in the fourth paragraph relating to the preference shares. Please clarify, if true, that the rights attached to the preference shares that will become equal to the rights attached to the ordinary shares are voting rights and rights to profits, as indicated in your response to our comment 13.Rest of the question
Please also clarify whether it is likely that the preference shareholders will actually have an opportunity to exercise or benefit from those rights, given that the repurchase of the preference shares might not happen simultaneously with the distribution payment.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Pro Rata Share Issuance, page 17
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to comment nine in our letter dated May 3, 2013 in which you reference a stock split of 23.8:1, reflected also on page F-18 under the “Share Capital” discussion. Since your disclosure here refers to a different ratio of 22.8, please revise your disclosures accordingly.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Selling Shareholder Private Sale, page 18
SEC asked (4)
You disclose at the end of the paragraph that Apollo and Rio Tinto may “elect not to sell in this offering.” In light of your Underwriting disclosure on page 183 stating that you and the selling shareholders have agreed to sell to the underwriters the shares subject to the terms of the underwriting agreement, with a view towards disclosure, please explain to us whether the selling shareholders anticipate to makeRest of the question
their election before or after effectiveness of the registration statement, and how and when the information will be reflected in your prospectus.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 51
SEC asked (5)
We note your response to comment four in our letter dated May 3, 2013. Please more clearly show in the notes how you computed the as adjusted pro forma share premium amount. In addition, in arriving at the as adjusted pro forma retained deficit amount, you refer to 15 million Euros of fees and expenses related to this offering.Rest of the question
Please further clarify in your disclosures the nature of these fees and expenses being reflected in retained earnings compared to those offering costs being reflected as a reduction of offering proceeds in share premium.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Capitalization, page 51
SEC asked (6)
We note your response to comment seven in our letter dated May 3, 2013. Your disclosures refer to shares fully paid up. To be consistent with the terminology used in your financial statements, please refer to shares outstanding.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financial Statements · General
SEC asked (7)
We note your response to comment nine in our letter dated May 3, 2013. Your response indicates that 83,945,965 additional Class A ordinary shares, 815,252 additional Class B1 ordinary shares, and 923,683 additional Class B2 ordinary shares will be issued and that the pro rata share issuance is the equivalent of a 23.8:1 stock split.Rest of the question
Please help us better understand how you arrived at the pro rata number of shares to be issued for each class based on the number of shares outstanding as of December 31, 2012 as disclosed on page F-37.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Financial Statements · General
SEC asked (8)
It does not appear that you have consistently given retroactive effect to the expected stock split in your historical amounts, including in note (8) to the capitalization table on page 53 and on page F-37. Please revise your disclosures throughout the filing as necessary to give retroactive effect to the expected stock split.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-22
SEC asked (9)
We are continuing to evaluate your response to comment 10 in our letter dated May 3, 2013 and may have additional comments.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-22
SEC asked (10)
For both the impairment analysis performed as of December 31, 2010 pursuant to IAS 36 and the purchase price allocation performed as of January 4, 2011 pursuant to IFRS 3, the initial purchase price for the acquisition of the Engineered Aluminum Products business from Rio Tinto was used as the basis for determining fair value.Rest of the question
During the call held on May 6, 2013, it was indicated that this transaction was not a bargain purchase. Please help us better understand the positive and negative factors that you considered in reaching the conclusion that it was not a bargain purchase.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 3. Acquisition of Rio Tinto Engineered Aluminum Products Entities, page F-22
SEC asked (11)
We note in your response letter dated April 29, 2013 that the size premiums selected for the impairment and purchase accounting analyses were based on an estimated equity value of $125 million. As you state, the $125 million does fall within the market capitalization ranges for the Micro Cap (9th and 10th deciles) and Decile 10b categories.Rest of the question
We note, however, that a $125 million market capitalization is in the lower third of the Micro Cap distribution and above the upper quartile of the Decile 10b distribution. It is our understanding that the size premium generally selected would be the one that is the most statistically relevant to the market capitalization size as to maximize the number of comparable observations. In other words, the size premium selected should be within the central tendency of the distribution. Such selection is especially important in thin market capitalizations due to the sensitivity of the size premium for small changes in market capitalization. We further note in your response to comment nine in your letter dated April 16, 2013 that the discount rate impact was over 80 percent of the value difference from December 31, 2010 to January 4, 2011 for cashgenerating units one through four. Given the sensitivity of the discount rate to the fair value estimates, please advise why a more selective size premium screening was not performed.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 12. Earnings Per Share, page F-30
SEC asked (12)
We note your response to comment 11 in our letter dated May 3, 2013. If there will be significant changes in the rights that Class A ordinary shareholders will have to profits after completion of this offering, please disclose these changes throughout the filing including in your description of the offering on page 20.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (13)
Please have counsel revise its opinion to include the shares which may be issued pursuant to the underwriters’ overallotment option.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (14)
With respect to the resolutions listed in paragraph 2(h) of the legal opinion, it appears that the date of these resolutions should pre-date May 2013 considering that they relate to the issuance of shares currently held by the Selling Shareholders.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (15)
Please have counsel revise its opinion in paragraphs 5(b) and (c) to remove the “upon payment in full of the Secondary Shares” and “upon valid execution of the Issue Resolution” qualifications as inappropriate. The Secondary Shares are currently outstanding and the valid execution of the Issue Resolution represents facts readily ascertainable by counsel.
CSTM answered
No reply letter found.
Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked
We note your response to comment 15 in our letter dated May 9, 2013 stating that counsel will not be able to ascertain whether payment for the Secondary Shares will be made in full and therefore it is not able to opine as to whether there are sufficient reserves to cover payment for the Secondary Shares.Rest of the question
Since the issuance of the prorata shares to the selling shareholders does not involve payment of consideration by them and the prospectus contemplates the prorata issuance to be completed prior to the commencement of the offering, the sale of shares by the selling shareholders should represent sale of shares outstanding prior to the IPO. As such, please have counsel revise its opinion to remove the assumption in Section 3(b).
CSTM answered
Pursuant to Rule 461 promulgated under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, Constellium N.V. (the “Registrant”) hereby requests that the effective date of the Registrant’s Registration Statement on Form F-1 (File No. 333-188556) be accelerated by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “Commission”) to 5:00 p.m.
Rest of the answer
EST on May 22,
2013, or as soon as possible thereafter.
In connection with the foregoing request for acceleration of effectiveness, the
Registrant hereby acknowledges the following:
• should the Commission or its staff, acting pursuant to delegated authority, declare the filing effective, it does not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing;
the action of the Commission or the staff, acting pursuant to delegated authority, in declaring the filing effective, does not relieve the Registrant from its full responsibility for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing; and the Registrant may not assert staff comments or the declaration of effectiveness as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
Read in the replyopen_in_new