Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0000769520 /10-K filed Mar 4, 2026, compared with Feb 26, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
Nasdaq Industrials · Refrigeration & Service Industry Machinery

MIDDLEBY Corp MIDD

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

10 reviews of MIDD's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 10 latest letter Jul 11, 2024
Questions asked 83 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 1 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 13 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 83 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 10 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 9 of 10 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 35 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 10-K for the Year Ended December 30, 2023

2024-07-11 to 2024-08-06 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2024-08-06
Non-GAAP measuresResults discussion (MD&A)
Fiscal Year Ended December 30, 2023 as Compared to December 31, 2022 · Net Sales, page 32
SEC asked
In light of the material period to period changes in your net sales, describe and quantify the extent to which such changes are attributable to changes in prices or to changes in the volume or amount of goods or services being sold or to the introduction of new products or services, as required by Item 303(b)(2)(ii) of Regulation S-K.
Rest of the question

Selling, General, and Administrative Expenses, page 33 We note that unquantified lower compensation costs, professional fees, and intangible 2. amortization expense partially offset higher but unquantified selling and marketing expenses. Please revise here and elsewhere, as applicable, to quantify the impact of each material factor when your results are impacted by two or more factors. Form 8-K Dated and Filed on May 8, 2024 Exhibite 99.1 The Middleby Corporation Reports First Quarter Results, page 1 3. Please revise in future filings to avoid presenting non-GAAP measures, such as Adjusted EBITDA and Organic adjusted EBITDA margin, in greater prominence than the presentations of the most directly comparable GAAP measures. See the answers to Question 102.10 of the guidance provided by the Division of Corporation Finance's Compliance & Disclosure Interpretations of the rules and regulations on the use of non-GAAP financial measures.

MIDD answered
We have reviewed and acknowledge the Staff’s comment. In the future, if there are changes to pricing, volume or the amount of goods or services sold, or the introduction of new products or services that materially impact our financial results, we will describe those changes in future filings. With respect to quantifying the extent to which any such material changes in net sales from period to period may be attributable to specific changes in prices, however, we do not assess specific pricing impacts at a granular level when analyzing changes in our net sales.

Across our businesses, we offer
Rest of the answer

many products that are sold at varying prices to different customers in several different regions. For example, changes in unit volumes may be driven in part by pricing as a result of promotions or from groups of products sold at a combined price or discount from the prices of the same products sold separately. New product launches and product discontinuations also contribute to changes in product mix that lead to different price and volume outcomes from period to period.

As a result, when assessing changes in net sales, our management considers, among other things, overall pricing actions and how those actions apply to various product lines and customers. They also consider qualitative information about the processes to implement pricing actions and how such pricing actions have or may, on their own, impact demand or volume. If material, we include a description of these factors in our filings.

We believe, based on these considerations and with our commitment in response to the Staff’s comment to describe material changes that are attributable to changes in prices or to changes in the volume or amount of goods or services being sold or the introduction of new products or services, our disclosures will comply with the requirements of Item 303(b)(2)(ii) of Regulation S-K.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 25, 2024: 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 9, 2024 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2024-08-06

Form 10-K

2023-09-22 to 2023-12-05 · 6 questions · 3 letters from the SEC, 3 from the company
Review closed 2023-12-05
ClimateResults discussion (MD&A)Risk factors
Form 10-K Filed March 1, 2023 · General
SEC asked (1)
We note that you provided more expansive disclosure in your 2021 Sustainability Report than you provided in your SEC filings. Please advise us what consideration you gave to providing the same type of climate-related disclosure in your SEC filings as you provided in your 2021 Sustainability Report.
MIDD answered
The Company provides disclosure in our SEC filings that is required pursuant to applicable SEC rules or regulations as well as to satisfy our obligations under the U.S. securities laws to provide material information to our shareholders and the investing public. Separately, the Company provides information on its website, including its 2021 Sustainability Report regarding our environmental, social and governance (“ESG”) initiatives and addresses evolving stakeholder expectations, even when such information is beyond the scope of the information required to be disclosed in filings with the SEC
Rest of the answer

or that a reasonable investor may consider important or that significantly alters the total mix of information about the Company and its operation. This is stated on page 37 of our 2021 Sustainability Report.

When considering whether to include climate-related information in our filings with the SEC, the Company takes into account applicable SEC rules and regulations, including Item 101, Item

103, Item 105 and Item 303 of Regulation S-K, as well as the

SEC’s Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations, available

guidance from the SEC and its Staff (including the SEC’s 2010

Guidance Regarding Disclosure Related to Climate Change) and

applicable standards of materiality. We believe that our SEC filings adequately and appropriately inform investors as to material information about our business, strategy, and financial results, including climate-related information.

With respect to future SEC filings, we will continue to monitor and evaluate whether the inclusion of additional climate-related information is appropriate at such time in response to applicable disclosure requirements.

Read in the reply
Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked (2)
To the extent material, discuss the indirect consequences of climate-related regulation or business trends, such as the following: • decreased demand for goods or services that produce significant greenhouse gas emissions or are related to carbon-based energy sources; • increased demand for goods that result in lower emissions than competing products; • increased competition to develop innovative new products that
Rest of the question

result in lower emissions; • increased demand for generation and transmission of energy from alternative energy sources; and • any anticipated reputational risks resulting from operations or products that produce material greenhouse gas emissions.

MIDD answered
As noted in our 2021 Sustainability Report, product innovation is central to our value proposition to our customers and to our

commitment to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals

around Affordable and Clean Energy, Responsible Consumption and

Production, and Industry Innovation and Infrastructure. As

discussed in our Form 10-K, the Company has established itself as a leader in all three business segments in which we operate by acquiring leading brands and through the introduction of innovative products.
Rest of the answer

However, the Company has not identified any material indirect consequences of climate-related regulation or business trends.

The following is a discussion of why we have not identified any business trends from factors such as:

carbon-based energy sources

• increased demand for goods that result in lower emissions than competing products

During the periods covered by the Form 10-K, the Company did not experience and we did not expect to experience any material change in the demand for our products based on any increase or decrease in demand for our products and services due to their carbon intensity or other climate-related impacts.

The Company regularly evaluates consumer insights, including those relating to sustainability, through participation in industry organizations, securing access to industry research tools, leveraging information gained via our strong customer relationships and analyzing current and historical sales trends. For example, we did not identify a material shift in our product mix or demand for such product mix, such as a shift away from gas and towards electric equipment. For decades, we have developed and promoted energy star products within our diverse portfolio, and we expect additional future opportunities to develop and sell sustainable products. Additionally, industry and customer insights revealed that our customers’ purchasing decisions are driven by various legal and regulatory requirements and customer-specific operational factors such as safety, price/cost, efficiency, ease of use, flexibility and sustainability. We believe our diverse customer base continues to make purchasing decisions by considering sustainability as one of many factors in making purchasing decisions. Given this, we have not experienced a material impact on the demand for our products due to climate-related changes in consumer preferences or regulation, nor a material impact on our liquidity, capital resources or results of operations.

The Company acknowledges that climate-related changes in consumer preferences more broadly may include decreased demand for goods that produce significant greenhouse gas emissions or are related to carbon-based energy sources and increased demand for goods that result in lower emissions, which may lead to increased competition to develop innovative new products that result in lower emissions. We believe that the sustainability aspect of our development, production and distribution of commercial foodservice equipment, food processing equipment and residential kitchen equipment is an important and growing area of focus for our customers and end users, and that action on climate change is an area of focus for our industry.

• increased competition to develop innovative new products that result in lower emissions

As we disclosed in “Item 1A. Risk Factors” (the “risk factors”) of the Form 10-K, within the risk factor titled “The company faces intense competition in the commercial foodservice, food processing, and residential kitchen equipment industries and failure to successfully compete could impact the company’s results of operations and cash flows”, the Company competes based on a variety of factors, including product features and design, brand recognition, reliability, durability, technology, energy efficiency, breadth of product offerings, price, customer relationships, delivery lead-times, serviceability and aftersale service. The Company is not aware of, nor have we experienced, any material increased competition to develop new products that result in lower emissions to address climate change. There continues to be strong competition in all of the markets and geographies we serve and the competition we have typically encountered has not materially changed, nor do we expect it to materially change, as new products are developed or modified to result in lower emissions. Given these competition factors, research and development (“R&D”) is critical to the success of the Company and within each of the highly competitive and fragmented industries in which we operate, driving our annual average R&D spend of approximately 1.5% of Net Sales. Our R&D and product development efforts have and continue to include a focus on delivering products that are designed to reduce energy consumption and that are environmentally safe. Our spend trends and a historical focus on R&D have remained consistent and, in these areas, we concluded that further disclosures on such trends within the MD&A in our Form 10-K was not warranted.

As it relates to the emissions created by the manufacturing of our products, that has not been, nor do we expect it to be, a critical or material consideration by our customers in choosing to purchase and using our products, as there are many other important factors customers evaluate when purchasing equipment for commercial, residential and food processing applications, as noted herein and in our risk factors referenced above. At the same time, the Company continues to aim to reduce the environmental footprint of our products by striving to limit emissions and waste in the manufacturing process.

We have also considered the following factor, as to whether there has been:

• increased demand for generation and transmission of energy from alternative energy sources

As noted in our 2021 Sustainability Report, the Company sources over 17% of our purchased electricity from renewable energy. The Company expects to continue investing in innovative processes, materials and technologies to reduce negative environmental impacts within our sustainability strategy. For the periods covered by our Form 10-K, our operations and related costs did not reflect material changes that resulted in increased demand for generation and transmission of energy from alternative energy sources.

Lastly, we have considered the following factor, as to whether

operations or products that produce material greenhouse gas emissions

Our 2021 Sustainability Report addresses our climate related metrics and strategic direction related to energy, greenhouse gas emissions, waste and water, which we noted will continue to be reported in future reports. We recognize that our brand image and reputation could be harmed if we were perceived to not be progressing on our sustainability strategy. Our Form 10-K addresses the significance of this potential reputational risk within the business competition discussion and within our risk factors, including, “The company faces intense competition in the commercial foodservice, food processing, and residential kitchen equipment industries and failure to successfully compete could impact the company’s results of operations and cash flows.” This and our other risk factors included in our Form 10-K discuss the potential impact of increased competition to evolve with changes in technology and industry standards, development of products and technologies that adhere to certification and regulatory approval schedules, exposure to potential liabilities under environmental laws, and other legal compliance risks, such as potential climate change legislation, regulation and international accord. As noted in the Form 10-K, these risks could result in a material adverse effect on the Company’s reputation, demand for its products, financial condition and results of operations.

The Company will continue to monitor the material indirect consequences of climate-related regulation or business trends, including strategic opportunities, and if they are considered reasonably likely to have a material effect on our business, financial condition, liquidity or results of operations, we will disclose such consequences in future SEC filings as appropriate.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 6, 2023: 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2023 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 10, 2023 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked (3)
We note that your Form 10-K identifies natural disasters, extreme weather and climate change as potential risks to your suppliers and business. Please discuss the physical effects of climate change on your operations and results.
Rest of the question

This disclosure may include the following: • severity of weather, such as floods, hurricanes, sea levels, arability of farmland, extreme fires, and water availability and quality; • quantification of material weather-related damages to your property or operations; • potential for indirect weather-related impacts that have affected or may affect your major customers or suppliers; • decreased agricultural production capacity in areas affected by drought or other weather-related changes; and • the extent to which extreme weather events have reduced the availability of insurance or increased the cost of insurance. Include quantitative information for each of the periods covered by your Form 10-K and explain whether increased amounts are expected in future periods.

MIDD answered
As disclosed in the risk factors included in the Form 10-K, including “Price increases in some materials and disruptions in supply could affect the company’s profitability,” natural disasters, extreme weather patterns and climate change could have a material adverse effect on the Company’s or its customers’ and suppliers’ operations due to the location of certain facilities.

The Company’s physical properties include its corporate headquarters and global manufacturing and distribution facilities.
Rest of the answer

While in the ordinary course of business, individual properties may experience severe weather conditions, such as heavy snow or rainfall, and natural disasters such as hurricanes and wildfires, which may interrupt or disrupt operations, no such conditions have led to physical damages resulting in material loss of business or resulting in material operational disruption, either individually or in the aggregate for the periods covered by our Form 10-K.

While the Company has from time to time experienced certain climate-related disruptions, such as reduced availability of certain products, delivery delays in its supply chain and climate-related impacts to the timing and uncertainty of customer demands, none of these impacts have been material to the Company’s financial condition and results of operations for the periods covered by our Form 10-K. The Company’s broad customer base across three business segments, illustrated by the breadth of our portfolio and diversity and longevity of products and markets we serve, reduces the likelihood that climaterelated disruptions would have a material impact on the Company. Also as noted in our Form 10-K, there is not a single customer within any of our three business segments that accounts for greater than 10% of our net sales. Our diverse customer base combined with the Company’s 75 global manufacturing and 16 distribution locations, reduces the risk that a single weatherrelated event would have a material impact on the Company and our major customers. Additionally, the Company uses large amounts of stainless steel, aluminized steel and other commodities, which are sourced from numerous suppliers around the world, in the manufacturing of our products. The Company has a Global Supply Chain team that regularly assesses risks to our supply chain, our suppliers’ financial health and supplier concentrations to assist in minimizing the likelihood that weather-related impacts to our major suppliers will have a material impact on the Company.

Given our insignificant weather-related claims, the cost or availability of the Company’s property insurance is directly tied to events happening in the broader macroeconomic environment and the impact of such events on the overall insurance market. As such, the Company has experienced increased premiums. However, the Company’s total property insurance costs represented, on average, less than 0.2% of the total cost of sales for each of the periods covered by our Form 10-K. As a result, neither the total premiums paid nor the increase in the premiums were material to the Company’s financial condition or results of operations. The Company has not experienced any weather-related damages to our property or operations in excess of our main insurance carrier deductible of $250,000 for the periods covered by our Form 10-K. To date, extreme weather events have not reduced the availability of insurance or increased the cost of insurance for the Company.

Based on our historical experience and current knowledge, we do not currently believe that the impact of weather-related events on our overall property, operations or cost of insurance is expected to materially change in the foreseeable future.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 6, 2023: 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2023 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 10, 2023 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked (4)
If material, please provide disclosure about your purchase or sale of carbon credits or offsets and any material effects on your business, financial condition, and results of operations. Provide us with quantitative information for each of the periods covered by your most recent Form 10-K and the amounts budgeted for or expected to be incurred in future periods.
MIDD answered
During the periods covered by our Form 10-K, the Company did not purchase or sell any carbon credits or offsets. Currently, the Company has not budgeted nor is expected for any future period to purchase or sell a material amount of carbon credits or offsets. To the extent in any future periods our purchases or sales of carbon credits or offsets are material to our business, financial condition or results of operations, we will provide the appropriate disclosures in accordance with applicable legal requirements regarding such transactions.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 6, 2023: 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2023 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 10, 2023 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked
We note your response to prior comment 2. Please further address the following items: • You acknowledge that climate-related changes in consumer preferences may affect demand and lead to increased competition to develop innovative new products that result in lower emissions.
Rest of the question

You further indicate that “action on climate change is an area of focus for our industry” and expect “additional future opportunities to develop and sell sustainable products.” Explain to us how you considered providing specific disclosure regarding these climate-related changes and opportunities, and tell us how you assessed materiality. • Clarify whether your efforts to limit emissions in the manufacturing process and to purchase electricity from renewable sources are related to changes in demand and competition for goods that result in lower emissions, are not related to carbon-based energy sources, and/or are produced using alternative energy sources. • Your response indicates that you sourced 17% of your purchased electricity from renewable energy (for the period covered by the 2021 Sustainability Report) and that you expect to continue investing in innovative processes, materials, and technologies within your sustainability strategy. Tell us more about your renewable energy purchases and sustainability investments and provide support for your determination of materiality, including quantitative information for each of the periods covered by your Form 10-K and expected to be incurred in future periods. • Your response indicates that your brand image and reputation could be harmed if you were perceived to not be progressing on your sustainability strategy, yet the risk factor disclosure cited does not appear to address climate-related reputational risks. Tell us how you considered providing disclosure regarding reputational risks resulting from the production of greenhouse gas emissions from your operations or products.

MIDD answered
Our customers' purchasing decisions take into consideration many legal and regulatory product requirements and customerspecific operational factors such as safety, price/cost, efficiency, ease of use, flexibility and sustainability. The impact of these considerations and the decisions the Company has made in response to them are already reflected in our results of operations and, to the extent material, discussed in our SEC filings.
Rest of the answer

When considering the information to be disclosed in the Form 10-K, however, we did not identify material changes in our product mix or customer demand for such product mix, such as material decreases in demand for gas products or a material increase in demand for electric equipment that we believe were required to be disclosed in the Form 10-K. As always, we intend to continue to monitor and evaluate whether the disclosure of additional information is required in future filings.

* Clarify whether your efforts to limit emissions in the manufacturing process and to purchase electricity from renewable sources are related to changes in demand and competition for goods that result in lower emissions, are not related to carbon-based energy sources, and/or are produced using alternative energy sources.

The Company continues to strive to reduce the environmental footprint of our products by working to develop manufacturing processes that limit emissions and waste, in furtherance of our sustainability goals. We believe our customers evaluate many important factors when purchasing our products. We do not believe, however, that the Company's efforts to limit emissions within our manufacturing processes and to purchase electricity from renewable sources are related to changes in demand and competition for goods that result in lower emissions, are not related to carbon-based energy sources, and/or are produced using alternative energy sources. We also do not believe that our efforts to limit emissions have had a direct or material impact on the demand or competition for our products.

* Your response indicates that you sourced 17% of your purchased electricity from renewable energy (for the period covered by the 2021 Sustainability Report) and that you expect to continue investing in innovative processes, materials, and technologies within your sustainability strategy. Tell us more about your renewable energy purchases and sustainability investments and provide support for your determination of materiality, including quantitative information for each of the periods covered by your Form 10-K and expected to be incurred in future periods.

Our renewable energy purchases from providers that rely on hydroelectric, wind and solar sources are typically for indirect operations at our facilities. Our investments in innovative processes, materials, and technologies are primarily related to reducing our energy consumption in our manufacturing processes. This has entailed streamlining such processes and increasing efficiency by evaluating and improving the allocation of floor space and equipment, as well as machinery function and energy efficiency. For each of the periods covered by the Form 10-K, the Company's total utility costs represented, on average, less than 1% of the Company's total operating costs. As a result, neither our total utility costs, representing, on average, less than 1% of our operating costs, nor the value of renewable purchases as 17% of the utility costs or .0017% of our total operating costs, were material to the Company's financial condition, liquidity or results of operations. Thus, we concluded that further disclosures on such trends within the MD&A in the Form 10-K was not warranted. Finally, our spend trends have remained generally consistent with the utility costs as a percentage of our operating costs for the periods covered by the Form 10-K and we do not expect a material change in these trends in future periods.

* Your response indicates that your brand image and reputation could be harmed if you were perceived to not be progressing on your sustainability strategy, yet the risk factor disclosure cited does not appear to address climate-related reputational risks. Tell us how you considered providing disclosure regarding reputational risks resulting from the production of greenhouse gas emissions from your operations or products.

"Item 1A. Risk Factors" (the "risk factors") of the Form 10-K includes a risk factor titled, "We are subject to risks associated with possible climate change legislation, regulation and international accords," which describes how government mandates, standards or regulations intended to reduce greenhouse gas emissions or projected climate change impacts have resulted in, and are likely to continue resulting in, increased energy, manufacturing, transportation and raw material costs. Further, the risk factor titled, "The company's reputation, ability to do business, and results of operations may be impaired by the improper conduct of any of its employees, agents, or business partners" discusses how violation of laws or improper actions by the Company, its employees, agents, or business partners could "lead to increased costs of compliance and damage the company's reputation." Additionally, the risk factor titled, "The company faces intense competition in the commercial foodservice, food processing, and residential kitchen equipment industries and failure to successfully compete could impact the company's results of operations and cash flows" discusses how if the Company is unable to successfully compete on a number of factors, including brand recognition, energy efficiency, changing technology and evolving industry standards, there can be no assurance that the Company's customers will continue to choose the Company's products over products offered by its competitors.

We believe these risk factors provide the required disclosure regarding what the Company has determined to be a material risk, including the potential reputational risks and potential adverse impacts of increased competition to evolve with changes in technology and industry standards and the development of innovative products. Taken as a whole, we remain comfortable that this disclosure conveys to investors the material reputational risks resulting from the production of greenhouse gas emissions from our operations or products. Nevertheless, in response to the Staff's comment, we intend to provide additional narrative disclosure in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ending December 30, 2023 that includes specific risk factor disclosure directly addressing the reputational risks resulting from the production of greenhouse gas emissions from our operations or products and the potential adverse consequences for our business, financial condition and results of operations.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 26, 2023: 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2023 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 10, 2023 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked
Your response to the first item of prior comment 1 reiterates information provided in your initial response, dated October 6, 2023, and continues to include a materiality qualification. Accordingly, we reissue this portion of our comment.
Rest of the question

Explain to us how you considered providing specific disclosure regarding the climate-related changes and opportunities identified in our prior comment, and tell us how you assessed materiality. Your response should discuss the climate-related changes in demand and competition you have experienced, and explain how you determined there were not material for purposes of disclosure, taking into account your statements that "action on climate change is an area of focus for our industry" and you expect "additional future opportunities to develop and sell sustainable products."

MIDD answered
The Company assessed the materiality of the impact of climate-related changes and opportunities on its financial condition and results of operations by considering a number of factors. Those factors included the Company's insights regarding climate-related changes in demand and competition, the fact that the Company has not significantly changed its product mix in response to climate-related changes in demand or competition, the fact that the Company had not in the period covered by the Form 10-K significantly increased its focus on sustainability in the marketing of its product offerings and
Rest of the answer

the fact that acquisitions, improving market conditions and certain pricing increases primarily contributed to the Company's results of operations. The Company identified a number of items in the Form 10-K that it identified as having a material impact on its financial condition and results of operations, including higher sales volumes, increases in sales commissions, the impact of recent acquisitions and the impact of foreign exchange rates. However, the Company did not believe that climate-related changes in demand and competition (both when considered as a standalone item and when considered in comparison to the aforementioned items) had or were reasonably likely to have a material impact on its financial condition or results of operations.

As noted in our prior responses, Company insights have revealed changing stakeholder expectations regarding product sustainability. Accordingly, as discussed in our Form 10-K, the Company has focused on acquiring leading brands and introducing innovative products to remain competitive as customers continue to prioritize sustainability as part of their business goals. For decades, we have developed and promoted energy star products and we continue to see strong demand for these products. Additionally, the Company has observed that climate-related changes in consumer preferences has led to increased research, development and innovation and competition in our industry to develop new energy-efficient products that result in lower emissions and help customers meet their sustainability goals. In response, our research and development (which comprises about 1.5% of Net Sales on average, annually) and product development teams are focused on delivering products that are designed to reduce energy consumption and that are environmentally safe in order for us to remain competitive and serve our customers' needs. The Company determined, after considering the points discussed above, that any further disclosure in this area was not warranted and that the narrative disclosure in the Form 10-K provides a useful and complete description of these impacts and our efforts(including to develop products that reduce energy consumption).

As noted in our prior responses, the Company intends to continue to assess the materiality of any impacts of climate-related changes and opportunities on its financial condition and results of operations and will address those matters in future SEC filings, if material.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Nov 24, 2023: 10-K filed Feb 28, 2024 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 1, 2023 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2023-12-05

Form 10-K for the year ended January 1, 2022

2022-09-28 to 2022-10-13 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2022-10-13
Results discussion (MD&A)Liquidity and cashInventory
Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked
We note your disclosure on page 16 that you have experienced disruptions to parts of your supply chain as a result of COVID-19. We further note disclosure in your 10-Q for the quarterly period ended June 30, 2022 regarding inflationary impacts to your inventory. Please discuss in future filings whether supply chain disruptions or inflation have materially affected your outlook or business goals.
Rest of the question

Specify whether these challenges have materially impacted your results of operations or capital resources and quantify, to the extent possible, how your sales, profits, and/or liquidity have been impacted. Revise also to discuss in future filings any known trends or uncertainties resulting from mitigation efforts undertaken, if any. Explain whether any mitigation efforts introduce new material risks, including those related to product quality, reliability, or regulatory approval of products.

MIDD answered
We have reviewed and acknowledge the Staff's comments. In response, the Company respectfully advises the Staff that in our future filings commencing with our quarterly report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended October 1, 2022, and to the extent applicable, the Company will discuss whether supply chain disruptions or inflation have materially affected our outlook or business goals.
Rest of the answer

The disclosures, if applicable, will specify whether these challenges have materially impacted our results of operations or capital resources and quantify, to the extent possible, how our sales, profits, and/or liquidity have been impacted. Additionally, we will disclose, as applicable, any known trends or uncertainties resulting from the Company's supply chain disruption and inflation mitigation efforts. We will explain, to the extent applicable, whether such mitigation efforts introduce new material risks, including those related to product quality, reliability, or regulatory approval of products.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 4, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 10, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 11, 2022 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2022-10-13

Form 10-K

2018-04-25 to 2018-06-12 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2018-06-12
Results discussion (MD&A)Goodwill and impairmentCritical estimatesRevenueSegments
Management’s Discussion and Analysis and Results of Operations, page 23 · Critical Accounting Policies and Estimates, page 34
SEC asked (1)
We note that you recorded an impairment charge related to the Viking tradename within the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group primarily due to weaker than expected revenue performance in the current year and a corresponding reduction of future revenue expectations, as well as a decline in revenues attributable, in part, to the 2015 Viking product recall.
Rest of the question

In order to provide information for investors to assess the probability of future goodwill impairment charges, and with specific emphasis related to your Residential Kitchen operating segment, please expand your disclosures to address the following:  Define the reporting unit level at which you test goodwill for impairment;  Clarify whether your most recent goodwill impairment test was a qualitative or quantitative assessment and explain the factors you considered in making that determination;  To the extent you performed quantitative assessments, disclose, if accurate, that the estimated fair values of the reporting units you tested substantially exceeded their carrying values. Otherwise, for any reporting unit whose estimated fair value did not substantially exceed its carrying value, provide the following additional disclosures: o The percentage by which fair value exceeded carrying value at the date of the most recent step one test; o The amount of goodwill allocated to the reporting unit; o A detailed description of the methods and key assumptions used and how the key assumptions were determined; o A discussion of the degree of uncertainty associated with the key assumptions; and o A description of potential events and/or changes in circumstances that could reasonably be expected to negatively affect the key assumptions. Please refer to Item 303(a)(3)(ii) of Regulation S-K and Section V of the Commission's Guidance Regarding Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, SEC Release No. 34-48960.

MIDD answered
We have reviewed and acknowledge your comments. In order to enhance our discussion of Critical Accounting Policies, we will provide additional disclosure in future filings to provide information for investors to assess the probability of future goodwill impairment charges. Below we provide an example of how we will enhance the disclosure in future filings, using the identified disclosure from the Form 10-K (changes noted in bold):

“Goodwill and Indefinite-Life Intangibles

The company’s business acquisitions result in the recognition of goodwill and other intangible assets, which are a
Rest of the answer

significant portion of the company’s total assets. The company recognizes goodwill and other intangible assets under the guidance of ASC Topic 350-10, “Intangibles — Goodwill and Other.” Goodwill represents the excess of acquisition costs over the fair value of the net tangible assets and identifiable intangible assets acquired in a business combination. Identifiable intangible assets are recognized separately from goodwill and include trademarks and trade names, technology, customer relationships and other specifically identifiable assets. Trademarks and trade names are deemed to be indefinite-lived. Goodwill and indefinite-lived intangible assets are not amortized, but are subject to impairment testing.

Goodwill Valuations

On an annual basis on the first day of the fourth quarter, or more frequently if triggering events occur, the company compares the estimated fair value to the carrying value to determine if a potential goodwill impairment exists. The reporting units at which we test goodwill for impairment are our operating segments. These consist of the Commercial Foodservice Equipment Group, the Food Processing Equipment Group and the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group. If the fair value is less than its carrying value, an impairment loss, if any, is recorded for the difference between the implied fair value and the carrying value of goodwill.

In conducting a qualitative assessment, the company analyzes a variety of events or factors that may influence the fair value of the reporting unit including, but not limited to: the results of prior quantitative assessments performed; changes in the carrying amount of the reporting unit; actual and projected revenue and operating margin; relevant market data for both the company and its peer companies; industry outlooks; macroeconomic conditions; liquidity; changes in key personnel; and the company's competitive position. Significant judgment is used to evaluate the totality of these events and factors to make the determination of whether it is more likely than not that the fair value of the reporting unit or indefinite-life intangible is less than its carrying value.

In performing a quantitative assessment, we estimate each reporting unit's fair value under an income approach using a discounted cash flow model. The income approach uses each reporting unit's projection of estimated operating results and cash flows that are discounted using a market participant discount rate based on a weighted-average cost of capital. The financial projections reflect management's best estimate of economic and market conditions over the projected period including forecasted revenue growth, operating margins, tax rate, capital expenditures, depreciation, amortization and changes in working capital requirements. Other assumptions include discount rate and terminal growth rate. The estimated fair value of each reporting unit is compared to their respective carrying values. Additionally, we validate our estimates of fair value under the income approach by comparing the fair value estimate using a market approach. A market approach estimates fair value by applying cash flow multiples to the reporting unit's operating performance. The multiples are derived from comparable publicly traded companies with similar operating and investment characteristics of the reporting units. We consider the implied control premium and conclude whether it is reasonable based on other recent market transactions.

We performed a qualitative assessment as of October 1, 2017 over the Commercial Foodservice Equipment Group and the Food Processing Equipment Group reporting units and determined it is more likely than not that the fair value of our reporting units are greater than the carrying amounts.

We performed a quantitative assessment over the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group as of October 1, 2017 due to weaker than expected revenue performance and a corresponding reduction of future revenue expectations. Based on the results of our annual quantitative assessment conducted on October 1, 2017, we concluded that no impairment existed as the fair value of our Residential Kitchen Equipment Group reporting unit substantially exceeded its carrying value.

In estimating the fair value of specific intangible assets, management relies on a number of factors, including operating results, business plans, economic projections, anticipated future cash flows, comparable transactions and other market data. There are inherent uncertainties related to these factors and management’s judgment in applying them in the impairment tests of goodwill and other intangible assets. If actual results are not consistent with management's estimate and assumptions, a material impairment could have an adverse effect on the company's financial condition and results of operations.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 23, 2018: 10-Q filed Aug 9, 2018 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Management’s Discussion and Analysis and Results of Operations, page 23 · Critical Accounting Policies and Estimates, page 34
SEC asked (2)
We note that the impairment charge related to the Viking tradename appears to have been recorded in your fourth quarter of fiscal year 2017 without any prior forewarning of potential impairment related to this asset. Please revise your discussion of your indefinite-lived intangible assets to address any trademarks or tradenames whose fair values are not substantially in excess of their carrying values.
Rest of the question

Address any material uncertainty associated with those assets, and address the degree of uncertainty associated with the key assumptions used to determine their fair value.

MIDD answered
We have reviewed and acknowledge your comments. In order to enhance our discussion of Critical Accounting Policies, we will provide additional disclosure in future filings to provide information for investors to assess the probability of future indefinite-lived intangible asset impairment charges. Below we provide an example of how we will enhance the disclosure in future filings, using the identified disclosure from the Form 10-K (changes noted in bold):

“Indefinite-Life Intangible Valuations

In performing a quantitative assessment of indefinite-life intangible assets other than goodwill,
Rest of the answer

primarily trademarks and trade names, we estimate the fair value of these intangible assets using the relief-from-royalty method which requires assumptions related to projected revenues from our long-range plans; assumed royalty rates that could be payable if we did not own the trademark; and a discount rate using a market based weighted-average cost of capital. If the estimated fair value of the indefinite-life intangible asset is less than its carrying value, we would recognize an impairment loss.

Based on the quantitative assessment performed as of October 1, 2017, an impairment of our Viking tradename was determined to exist, primarily the result of weaker than expected revenue performance in the current year and a corresponding reduction of future revenue expectations. The impairment resulted from the decline in revenues attributable, in part, to the product recall announced in 2015 primarily related to products manufactured prior to the acquisition of Viking. The fair value of the Viking tradename was estimated to be $93.0 million as compared to the carrying value of $151.0 million and resulted in a $58.0 million indefinite-lived intangible asset impairment charge.

In performing the quantitative analysis on these trademark assets, significant assumptions used in our relief-from-royalty model included revenue growth rates, assumed royalty rates and the discount rate, which are discussed further below.

•

Revenue growth rates relate to projected revenues from our long-range plans and vary from brand to brand. Adverse changes in the operating environment or our inability to grow revenues at the forecasted rates may result in a material impairment charge. We performed a sensitivity analysis on the estimated fair values noting a 1% reduction of forecasted revenues to the Viking trade name projections would result in an impairment charge of approximately $6 million.

In determining royalty rates for the valuation of our trademarks, we considered factors that affect the assumed royalty rates that would hypothetically be paid for the use of the trademarks. The most significant factors in determining the assumed royalty rates include the overall role and importance of the trademarks in the particular industry, the profitability of the products utilizing the trademarks, and the position of the trademarked products in the given market segment. Based on this analysis, we determined a royalty rate of 7% for our Viking trade name. We performed a sensitivity analysis on the estimated fair values for Viking noting a 50 basis point reduction to the royalty rates would result in an impairment charge of approximately $7 million.

In developing discount rates for the valuation of our trademarks, we used the market based weighted average cost of capital, adjusted for higher relative level of risks associated with doing business in other countries, as applicable, as well as the higher relative levels of risks associated with intangible assets. Based on this analysis, we determined the discount rate to be 11.0% for Viking. We performed a sensitivity analysis on the estimated fair values for

Viking noting a 100 basis point increase to the discount rate would result in an impairment charge of approximately $10 million.

We performed a qualitative assessment as of October 1, 2017 over the other trademarks and trade names and determined it is more likely than not that the fair value of our other indefinite-life intangible assets are greater than the carrying amounts.

If actual results are not consistent with management's estimate and assumptions, a material impairment charge of our trademarks and trade names could occur, which could have an adverse effect on the company's financial condition and results of operations.”

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 23, 2018: 10-Q filed Aug 9, 2018 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2018-06-12

Form 10-Q

2015-12-17 to 2016-01-20 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2016-01-20
Results discussion (MD&A)SegmentsLiquidity and cash
Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page · Results of Operations, page 35
SEC asked (1)
Please expand your disclosure to quantify and discuss how price changes affected your segment sales and segment gross margins from the prior periods.
MIDD answered
In future filings, the Company will further expand its disclosure in the Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations to include the effect of price changes on segment sales and segment gross margins. An example of that disclosure is (additional disclosure language in bold):

Three Months Ended October 3, 2015 as compared to Three Months Ended September 27, 2014

NET SALES. Net sales for the third quarter of fiscal 2015 were $449.0 million as compared to $404.3 million in the third quarter of 2014.
Rest of the answer

Of the $44.7 million increase in net sales, $46.3 million, or 11.5%, was attributable to acquisition growth, resulting from the fiscal 2014 acquisitions of Concordia and U-Line and the fiscal 2015 acquisitions of Desmon, Goldstein Eswood, Marsal, Induc, Thurne and AGA. Excluding acquisitions, net sales decreased $1.6 million, or 0.4%, from the prior year. The impact of foreign exchange rates on foreign sales translated into U.S. Dollars for the third quarter reduced net sales by approximately $12.4 million or 3.1%. On a constant currency basis, organic sales increased by 2.7% for the quarter, reflecting a net sales increase of 9.7% at the Commercial Foodservice Group, 4.4% decrease at the Food Processing Group and a 17.0% decrease at the Residential Equipment Group.

·

Net sales of the Commercial Foodservice Equipment Group increased by $28.1 million, or 10.7%, to $290.9 million in the third quarter of 2015, as compared to $262.8 million in the prior year quarter. Net sales resulting from the acquisitions of Concordia, Desmon, Goldstein Eswood, Marsal and Induc, which were acquired on September 8, 2014, January 7, 2015, January 30, 2015, February 10, 2015, and May 30, 2015, respectively, accounted for an increase of $10.9 million during the third quarter of 2015. Excluding the impact of these acquisitions, net sales of the Commercial Foodservice Equipment Group increased $17.2 million, or 6.5%, as compared to the prior year quarter. On a constant currency basis, organic net sales increased 9.7% at the Commercial Foodservice Group. Domestically, the company realized a sales increase of $24.1 million, or 13.3%, to $205.1 million, as compared to $181.0 million in the prior year quarter. This includes an increase of $2.7 million from the recent acquisitions. Excluding the acquisitions, the net increase of $21.4 million, or 11.8%, in domestic sales includes continued growth with customer initiatives to improve efficiencies in restaurant operations by adopting new cooking and warming technologies. International sales increased $4.0 million, or 4.9%, to $85.8 million, as compared to $81.8 million in the prior year quarter. This includes an increase of $8.2 million from the recent acquisitions offset by a reduction of $10.0 million due to the unfavorable impact of exchange rates. The change in both domestic and international net sales also includes the favorable impact of increased prices over the prior year, which is estimated to have increased net sales by 2% to 3% as compared to the prior year quarter.

Net sales of the Food Processing Equipment Group decreased by $1.0 million, or 1.3%, to $74.2 million in the third quarter of 2015, as compared to $75.2 million in the prior year quarter. Net sales resulting from the acquisition of Thurne, which was acquired on April 7, 2015, accounted for an increase of $5.7 million during the third quarter of 2015. Excluding the impact of this acquisition, net sales of the Food Processing Equipment Group decreased $6.7 million, or 8.9%, as compared to the prior year quarter. On a constant currency basis, organic net sales decreased 4.4% at the Food Processing Equipment Group. Domestically, the company realized a sales increase of $17.6 million, or 50.0%, to $52.8 million, as compared to $35.2 million in the prior year quarter. This includes an increase of $5.4 million from the recent acquisitions. International sales decreased $18.5 million, or 46.3%, to $21.5 million, as compared to $40.0 million in the prior year quarter. This includes an increase of $0.3 million from the recent acquisitions offset by a reduction of $3.2 million due to the unfavorable impact of exchange rates. Additionally, international sales were impacted by the nature and timing of large orders associated with this business, impacting the growth in comparative periods. Due to the nature of competitive bidding on large jobs and variability of equipment mix in comparison to the prior year quarter, the impact of price changes are not estimated to be a significant or meaningful factor in the change in net sales from the prior year quarter.

Net sales of the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group increased by $17.6 million, or 26.5%, to $83.9 million in the third quarter of 2015, as compared to $66.3 million in the prior year quarter. Net sales resulting from the acquisitions of U-Line and AGA, which were acquired on November 5, 2014, and September 23, 2015 respectively, accounted for an increase of $29.7 million during the third quarter of 2015. Excluding the impact of acquisitions, net sales of the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group decreased $12.1 million, or 18.3%, as compared to the prior year quarter. On a constant currency basis, organic net sales decreased 17.0% at the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group. Domestically, the company realized a sales increase of $8.5 million, or 13.5%, to $71.5 million, as compared to $63.0 million in the prior year quarter. This includes an increase of $19.3 million from the recent acquisitions. International sales increased $9.2 million, or 278.8%, to $12.5 million, as compared to $3.3 million in the prior year quarter. This includes an increase of $10.4 million from the recent acquisitions. Organic sales growth for the quarter was impacted by the discontinuation in 2014 of certain other non-Viking manufactured products sold by the Viking Distributors 2014, resulting in comparatively lower sales in 2015. Additionally, sales in the third quarter were impacted by disruption related to the initial production startup for a new line of Viking refrigeration in the first half of 2015. The net organic decrease in sales is net of price increases, which are estimated to have added approximately 2% to net sales in comparison to the prior year quarter.

Gross Profit. Gross profit increased to $177.2 million in the third quarter of 2015 from $162.4 million in the prior year period, reflecting the impact of higher sales volumes. The gross margin rate decreased from 40.2% in the third quarter of 2014 to 39.5% in the third quarter of 2015. The impact of increased selling prices net of higher input costs is not estimated to have a meaningful impact to the gross margin rate in comparison to the prior year quarters.

Gross profit at the Commercial Foodservice Equipment Group increased by $5.6 million, or 5.0%, to $116.7 million in the third quarter of 2015, as compared to $111.1 million in the prior year quarter. The gross margin rate amounted to 40.1% as compared to 42.3% in the prior year quarter. The reduction in the gross margin rate reflects the impact of sales mix, including lower margins at recent acquisitions.

Gross profit at the Food Processing Equipment Group increased by $1.0 million, or 3.4%, to $30.0 million in the third quarter of 2015, as compared to $29.0 million in the prior year quarter. The gross margin rate increased to 40.4% as compared to 38.6% in the prior year quarter. The increase in the gross margin rate reflects the benefit of acquisition integration initiatives.

Gross profit at the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group increased by $6.6 million, or 29.6%, to $28.9 million in the third quarter of 2015, as compared to $22.3 million in the prior year quarter. Gross profit from the acquisition of U-Line and AGA accounted for approximately $10.2 million of the increase in gross profit during the period. The gross margin rate increased to 34.4% as compared to 33.6% in the prior year quarter. This increase in the gross margin rate reflects the benefit of cost savings initiatives and lower warranty costs on new product sales.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 11, 2016: 10-K filed Mar 2, 2016 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 4, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Financial Statements · Note 5- Restructuring, page 33
SEC asked (2)
We note your disclosure stating that you recorded restructuring expenses in the amount of $11.8 million for the fiscal quarter ended October 3, 2015. Please expand your disclosure about the restructuring program, in accordance with SAB Topic 5:P.4, to quantify, if material, the total amount of costs expected to be incurred in connection with the program, the cumulative amount incurred to date, the expected effects
Rest of the question

on future earnings and cash flows resulting from the program, (for example, reduced depreciation, reduced employee expense, etc.), and the initial period in which those effects are expected to be realized.

MIDD answered
In future filings, the Company will further expand its disclosure for restructuring expenses in the Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements in order to comply with ASC 420-10-50 and SAB Topic 5.P.4. An example of that disclosure is:

15) Restructuring

During the fiscal year 2015, the company incurred restructuring charges relative to each of its business segments.
Rest of the answer

The costs and corresponding reserve balances (by segment) are summarized as follows (in thousands):

Commercial Foodservice Equipment Group:

During the third quarter of 2015, the company closed one manufacturing facility within the Commercial Foodservice Equipment Group and transferred production to another existing manufacturing facility within the company. This action, which is not material to the company’s operations, resulted in a charge of $0.9 million for severance and lease costs in general and administrative expenses in the consolidated statements of comprehensive income for the quarter and year ended, October 3, 2015.

The company estimates that these restructuring initiatives will result in future cost savings of approximately $1.0 million annually, beginning in fiscal year 2016 and no significant future costs related to this action are expected.

Food Processing Equipment Group:

During the third quarter of 2015, the company closed one manufacturing facility within the Food Processing Equipment Group and transferred production to another existing manufacturing facility within the company. This action, which is not material to the company’s operations, resulted in a charge of $2.5 million for severance and lease costs in general and administrative expenses in the consolidated statements of comprehensive income for the quarter and year ended, October 3, 2015. The company estimates that these restructuring initiatives will result in future cost savings of approximately $2.0 million annually, beginning in fiscal year 2016 and no significant future costs related to this action are expected.

Residential Kitchen Equipment Group:

During the fiscal year 2015, the company has taken actions to improve the operations of Viking within the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group. These initiatives included organizational restructuring and headcount reductions, consolidation and disposition of certain facilities and business operations. The company recorded expense in the amount of $2.4 million and $8.4 million, respectively in the three months and nine months ended October 3, 2015, respectively. This expense is reflected in the general and administrative expenses in the consolidated statements of comprehensive income for such periods. The company estimates that these restructuring initiatives will result in future cost savings of approximately $3.0 million annually, beginning in fiscal year 2015, primarily related to compensation and facility costs. The company anticipates that all severance obligations for the Residential Kitchen Equipment Group will be satisfied by the end of the second quarter of 2016. The lease obligations extend through November 2018.

Severance/

Benefits

Facilities/

Operations

Other

Total

Balance as of January 3, 2015

$

147

--

184

Expenses

3,160

5,298

(29

)

8,429

Payments

(2,090

(1,641

(10

(3,741

Balance as of October 3, 2015

1,217

3,657

(2

4,872

****

Company Acknowledgement

The Company hereby acknowledges that:

• the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

After you have had the opportunity to review these responses, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned at (847) 429-7744. Facsimile transmissions may be sent to the undersigned at (847) 429-7544.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 11, 2016: 10-K filed Mar 2, 2016 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 4, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2016-01-20

Form 10-K

2012-12-27 to 2013-01-31 · 5 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2013-01-31
Executive payPensions
General
SEC asked (1)
Refer to comment two in our letter dated June 28, 2010. We note that the fifth amended and restated credit agreement was filed as Exhibit 10.1 to the Form 8-K filed with the Commission on August 9, 2012. Please advise whether the content of the schedules to the credit agreement has been intentionally omitted.
Rest of the question

As noted in our prior comment two, you must file a complete version of your credit agreement, including all of its schedules.

MIDD answered
The Company confirms that it filed a complete version of its credit agreement as Exhibit 10.1 to its Form 8-K that was filed with the Commission on August 9, 2012. For certain schedules to the credit agreement (such as Schedules 9.6 and 9.7), the Company did not schedule any exceptions to the underlying representations in the credit agreement. Accordingly, such schedules have a reference to “None” or “N/A”.
Read in the reply
Signatures, page 80
SEC asked (2)
In future filings, please have the annual report also signed by the principal accounting officer or controller. Refer to General Instruction D(2)(a) of Form 10-K.
MIDD answered
The Form 10-K was signed by Timothy J. FitzGerald in his capacity as the Company’s principal financial officer and principal accounting officer. In future filings, Mr. FitzGerald’s title that appears opposite his signature will be revised to further clarify that he is signing the report in each such capacity.
Read in the reply
Annual Performance-Based Incentive Programs, page 16 · Value Creation Incentive Plan, page 16
SEC asked (3)
Please tell us, and in future filings disclose, how the compensation committee determined the amount of target and maximum payouts with respect to each named executive officer.
MIDD answered
As noted in the Company’s 2012 proxy, the compensation committee had retained an independent advisor, Grant Thornton, to inform its decisionmaking process for setting board and executive compensation. In determining the amount of target and maximum payouts under the Value Creation Incentive Plan, the compensation consultants were asked to evaluate the proper incentive criteria and performance targets.
Rest of the answer

Grant Thornton analyzed the Company’s historical performance in order to determine measures which would appropriately drive shareholder value creation, for example, in the creation of increased market capitalization. As a result of this analysis, the compensation committee selected EBITDA and earnings per share (EPS) as the appropriate metrics for performance measurement.

In setting the performance levels required to earn awards, the compensation committee, with the advice of its compensation consultants, also studied shareholder expectations of Company growth, while at the same time considering current economic and industry conditions as well as effectiveness in incentivizing management (among other factors, the compensation committee considered the fact that management members each hold a significant number of Company shares, which aligns their objectives with those of non-management shareholders in attaining a long-term Company share price growth). The compensation committee specifically considered the impact of acquisitions on the targets, and determined that given the historic creation of shareholder value associated with acquisitions and the level of management effort required in completing successful acquisitions, it would be appropriate to include the results of acquisitions in performance measurement. Ultimately, the compensation committee agreed on targets which it viewed to be aggressive in pushing Company growth and shareholder value creation (for example, the minimum required growth for both EBITDA and EPS targets were 10% per annum, a figure which significantly exceeded expected industry growth rates at the time), while at the same time being realistically achievable and thereby retaining the desired effect of incentivizing management performance towards these goals. The maximum levels set for each officer were determined by the compensation committee to be at the high end of aggressive but attainable goals. The compensation committee in its overall assessment concluded the Value Creation Incentive Plan achieved the objective and proper balance of retaining and motivating the key employees who drive the Company’s organic and acquisition growth with performance targets and criteria that are aligned with the creation of shareholder value.

In setting the levels of compensation to be provided if threshold, target or maximum levels of the dual performance metrics were achieved, the compensation committee chose levels that it thought were appropriate when compared to the relevant level of shareholder value attained by virtue of such achievement, and considered data provided by, and discussed market appropriateness with, its compensation consultants. The Company respectfully notes that the 2012 Proxy provided on page 17 a table detailing for each officer the target and maximum payouts, the required target and maximum levels of EBITDA and EPS that would be required to earn such payouts and the actual performance achieved with the related payouts under the Value Creation Incentive Plan.

In future filings, the Company will disclose how the compensation committee determined the amount of target and maximum payouts with respect to each named executive officer.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 24, 2013: 10-K filed Feb 27, 2013 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Summary Compensation Table, page 23
SEC asked (4)
In footnote (4) you disclose that “All Other Compensation” for Mr. Bassoul included $55,000 in director fees. Since Mr. Bassoul is the company’s CEO and an employeedirector, please provide us with an understanding of the board’s policy with respect to these payments. To the extent applicable, please include relevant disclosure in your future filings.
MIDD answered
Prior to 2012, the Company’s policy regarding director compensation did not distinguish between independent and employee directors. In connection with a review of director compensation practices in 2012, the practice was identified as unusual in the market and the Company’s board of directors determined to change the policy prospectively after fiscal year 2012. Thus, no separate payment will be made to Mr. Bassoul in respect of his board service in 2013 and future years. The Company will include the relevant disclosure in its future filings.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 24, 2013: 10-K filed Feb 27, 2013 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Director Compensation for Fiscal Year 2011, page 36
SEC asked (5)
Refer to footnote (4) to the director compensation table. Please explain to us, and in future filings expand your disclosure related to, the pension distribution payments to the nonemployee directors, by discussing among other things, the material terms of any pension plan pursuant to which these distributions are being made.
MIDD answered
The payment referred to in footnote 4 to the director compensation table does not represent an ongoing pension payment, but rather, a lump sum liquidation of Mr. Streeter’s vested pension benefit in connection with the termination of the director pension plan. As noted in the Company’s 2012 proxy and prior filings with the Commission, in November 2006, participation in the plan was frozen with respect to new directors and directors with less than 10 years of service.
Rest of the answer

Then-participating directors with 10 or more years of service continued to vest in benefits under the director pension plan until attaining the plan’s retirement age of 70, at which point benefits became distributable.

The plan was terminated by the Company’s board of directors in December 2010 and the Company will not be making any future payments to its independent directors under any pension plan. The Company will clarify in its 2013 proxy filing that the director pension plan is terminated and that the Company has no further obligations under the plan.

****

Company Acknowledgement

The Company hereby acknowledges that:

▪ the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

After you have had the opportunity to review these responses, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned at (847) 429-7744. Facsimile transmissions may be sent to the undersigned at (847) 429-7544.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 24, 2013: 10-K filed Feb 27, 2013 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2013-01-31

Form 8-K

2012-05-22 to 2012-05-25 · 3 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2012-05-25
SEC asked (1)
You currently disclose that during the fiscal years ended January 1, 2011 and December 31, 2011 and the subsequent interim period through March 31, 2012, there were no reportable events or disagreements with the former accountant.
Rest of the question

The disclosure should state whether during the registrant's two most recent fiscal years and any subsequent interim period through the date of dismissal there were any reportable events or disagreements with the former accountant on any matter of accounting principles or practices, financial statement disclosure, or auditing scope or procedure, which disagreement(s), if not resolved to the satisfaction of the former accountant, would have caused it to make reference to the subject matter of the disagreement(s) in connection with its reports. As such, please amend your Form 8-K to also disclose whether there were any reportable events or disagreements with the former accountant through May 10, 2012, the date of dismissal. In the event of disagreement(s) and/or reportable event(s), provide the specific disclosures required by Item 304(a)(1)(iv) and (v) of Regulation S-K.

MIDD answered
In response to your comment, the language in the fifth and sixth paragraphs of the Form 8-K has been revised to clarify that the prior disclosure applies to the subsequent interim period through May 10, 2012.
Read in the reply
SEC asked (2)
You currently disclose that during the fiscal years ended January 1, 2011 and December 31, 2011 and the subsequent interim period through March 31, 2012, you did not consult with your new accountant. Please amend your Form 8-K to state, if true, that you did not consult with your new accountant during the fiscal years ended January 1, 2011 and December 31, 2011 and through the date of engagement of your new
Rest of the question

accountant, which is May 10, 2012. Refer to Item 304(a)(2) of Regulation S-K.

MIDD answered
In response to your comment, the language in the second paragraph of the Form 8-K has been revised to clarify that the prior disclosure applies to the subsequent interim period through May 10, 2012.
Read in the reply
SEC asked (3)
To the extent that you make changes to the Form 8-K to comply with our comments, please obtain and file an updated Exhibit 16 letter from the former accountants stating whether the accountant agrees with the statements made in your amended Form 8-K.
MIDD answered
A copy of the updated Exhibit 16.1 from the former accountants has been filed with the Amended Form 8-K.

****

Company Acknowledgement

The Company hereby acknowledges that:

• the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United
Rest of the answer

States.

After you have had the opportunity to review these responses, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned at (847) 429-7744. Facsimile transmissions may be sent to the undersigned at (847) 429-7544.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2012-05-25

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended January 1, 2011

2011-12-28 to 2012-02-03 · 9 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 0 from the company
Review closed 2012-02-03
Results discussion (MD&A)Liquidity and cashAcquisitionsCritical estimatesRevenueInventory
SEC letter of Dec 28, 2011 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR
Results of Operations, page 21
SEC asked (1)
Please expand your discussion of results of operations in future filings to provide additional quantification and explanation of the underlying reasons for changes between the periods. For example, quantification and additional explanation of the underlying factors behind the increase in international and domestic sales improvement and the reasons cited for the improvement in gross margin appears necessary to
Rest of the question

provide investors with an understanding of the business through the eyes of management. For additional guidance, please refer to SEC Release 33-8350.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

In its next report

First report after the SEC's letter of Dec 28, 2011: 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2011 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Results of Operations, page 21
SEC asked (2)
In your discussion of results of operations you cite cost reduction initiatives that were instituted in 2009 as a reason for improvement in your gross margin. In future filings, please describe these initiatives, explain how they resulted in cost reductions and provide quantified information. Discuss the closing of the facility in Nevada and the expected impact on future operations.
Rest of the question

Provide us with an example of future intended disclosure and unless evident, explain how such disclosure complies with ASC 420-10-50 and SAB Topic 5.P.4.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

In its next report

First report after the SEC's letter of Dec 28, 2011: 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2011 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Financial Condition and Liquidity, page 24
SEC asked (3)
Days sales in ending accounts receivable increased significantly from January 2, 2010, to January 1, 2011. In future filings, please discuss underlying reasons for changes in the accounts receivable balance relative to sales.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

In its next report

First report after the SEC's letter of Dec 28, 2011: 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2011 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Financial Condition and Liquidity, page 24
SEC asked (4)
Please tell us and disclose in future filings the reasons for significant changes in your allowance for doubtful accounts. Discuss the reasons your allowance for doubtful accounts exceeds nine years of write-offs, based on the average write-off over the last three years, and almost 15 years of write-offs, based on the last two years.
Rest of the question

Also, we note you recognized a net benefit of $556,000 in 2009, apparently as a result of amounts recorded in connection with acquisitions. Please describe this accounting to us, including the amount of the gross adjustment, the quarter(s) it was recorded in and whether it significantly impacted your results of operations in any period.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

In its next report

First report after the SEC's letter of Dec 28, 2011: 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2011 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Contractual Obligations, page 25
SEC asked (5)
In future filings, please revise your contractual obligations table to include scheduled interest payments. To the extent that the interest rates are variable and unknown, you may use your judgment to determine whether or not to include estimates of future variable rate interest payments in the table or in a footnote to the table.
Rest of the question

Regardless of whether you decide to include variable rate estimated interest payments in the table or in a footnote, you should provide appropriate disclosure with respect to your assumptions. To the extent that you are in the position of paying cash rather than receiving cash under any interest rate swaps, please disclose estimates of the amounts you will be obligated to pay.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

In its next report

First report after the SEC's letter of Dec 28, 2011: 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2011 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Critical Accounting Policies and Estimates, page 26
SEC asked (6)
The discussion of critical accounting policies substantially duplicates the description of accounting policies that is already disclosed in the notes to the financial statements. Please expand this disclosure in future filings to provide greater insight into the quality and variability of information regarding financial condition and operating performance.
Rest of the question

While accounting policy notes in the financial statements generally describe the method used to apply an accounting principle, the discussion in MD&A should present your analysis of the uncertainties involved in applying a principle at a given time or the variability that is reasonably likely to result from its application over time. Please refer to Section V of SEC Release 33-8350.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

In its next report

First report after the SEC's letter of Dec 28, 2011: 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2011 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Accounts Receivables, page 42
SEC asked (7)
If receivables include amounts due under long-term contracts, state the following amounts separately in future filings:  Balances billed but not paid by customers under retainage provisions in contracts.  Amounts representing the recognized sales value of performance that had not been billed and were not billable to customers at the date of the balance sheet  Billed or unbilled amounts representing claims or
Rest of the question

other similar items subject to uncertainty concerning their determination or ultimate realization. Include a description of the nature and status of the principal items comprising such amount.  Also state the amounts included in each item that are expected to be collected after one year. Also state, by year, if practicable, when the amounts of retainage are expected to be collected. Refer to Rule 5-02 (3)(c) of Regulation S-X for guidance.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

In its next report

First report after the SEC's letter of Dec 28, 2011: 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2011 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Revenue Recognition, page 46
SEC asked (8)
Please tell us and quantify and disclose in future filings where you recognize the asset for revenue recognized but not yet billed on contracts accounted for under the percentage of completion method. Also, if material, please disclose the effect of revisions to your estimate of completion. Refer to ASC 605-35-50-9.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

In its next report

First report after the SEC's letter of Dec 28, 2011: 10-K filed Mar 15, 2012 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 2, 2011 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Inventory, page 61
SEC asked (9)
In future filings for all long-term contracts or programs, please provide the disclosure required by Rule 5-02(6)(d) of Regulation S-X.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2012-02-03

Form 10-K

2010-06-28 to 2010-08-02 · 8 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2010-08-02
ControlsExecutive pay
Item 9A. Controls and Procedures, page 80 · Management's Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting, page 81
SEC asked (1)
In future filings, please include in management’s report a statement that the registered public accounting firm that audited the financial statements included in the annual report has issued an attestation report on your internal control over financial reporting. Please refer to Item 308(a)(4) of Regulation S-K.
MIDD answered
In future filings, we will revise our management’s report to state that the registered public accounting firm that audited the financial statements included in our annual report has issued an attestation report on our internal control over financial reporting.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 27, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 12, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 13, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Item 15. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedule, page 84
SEC asked (2)
We note that you do not appear to have publicly filed all of the schedules and exhibits to Exhibit 10.1 (Fourth Amended and Restated Credit Agreement) and all of the exhibits and signature pages to Exhibit 10.13 (First Amendment to the Fourth Amended and Restated Credit Agreement).
Rest of the question

Please file complete versions of these agreements, including all of their schedules, exhibits and signature pages, with your next periodic report or, if you wish, a current report on Form 8-K. In addition, regarding Exhibit 10.13, we note that the exhibit index states that you filed the underlying agreement with a current report on Form 8-K filed on August 8, 2008; however, the EDGAR system reflects this filing as having been made on August 14, 2008. Please revise your exhibit index accordingly in future filings.

MIDD answered
We will file complete versions, including all of the schedules, exhibits and signature pages, of (i) the Fourth Amended and Restated Credit Agreement, dated as of December 28, 2007, among The Middleby Corporation, Middleby Marshall, Inc., Various Financial Institutions, Wells Fargo Bank, Inc., Wells Fargo Bank N.A., as syndication agent, Royal Bank of Canada, RBS Citizens, N.A., as Co-Documentation Agents, Fifth Third Bank and National City Bank as Co-Agents and Bank of America N.A., as Administrative Agent, Issuing Lender and Swing Line Lender (Exhibit 10.1 to our annual report on Form 10-K
Rest of the answer

for the fiscal year ended January 2, 2010) and (ii) the First Amendment to the Fourth Amended and Restated Credit Agreement, dated as of August 8, 2008, among The Middleby Corporation, Middleby Marshall Inc., Various Financial Institutions and Bank of America, N.A. as administrative agent, (Exhibit 10.13 to our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 2, 2010) with our next periodic report. Additionally, in future filings, we will revise our Form 10-K exhibit index to reflect that the First Amendment to the Fourth Amended and Restated Credit Agreement, dated as of August 8, 2008, among The Middleby Corporation, Middleby Marshall Inc., Various Financial Institutions and Bank of America, N.A. as administrative agent was filed with our current report on Form 8-K on August 14, 2008.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 27, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 12, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 13, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended April 3, 2010 · Item 4.Controls and Procedures, page 32
SEC asked (3)
We note your statement that “As of April 3, 2010, the company carried out an evaluation, under the supervision and with the participation of the company's management, including the company's Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, of the effectiveness of the design and operation of the company's disclosure controls and procedures.” As the requirements of Item 307 of Regulation S-K pertain to the
Rest of the question

effectiveness of your disclosure controls and procedures, rather than the effectiveness of the design and operation of you disclosure controls and procedures, in future filings please revise your disclosure accordingly to comply with the requirements of the regulation.

MIDD answered
In future filings, we will revise our disclosure to reflect that we evaluate the effectiveness of our disclosure controls and procedures, rather than the effectiveness of the design and operation of our disclosure controls and procedures.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 27, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 12, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 13, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Definitive Proxy Statement on Schedule 14A filed March 24, 2010 · General
SEC asked (4)
We note that the company does not appear to have included any disclosure in response to Item 402 (s) of Regulation S-K. Please advise us of the basis for your conclusion that disclosure is not necessary and describe the process you undertook to reach that conclusion.
MIDD answered
The Compensation Committee, together with the Chairman of the Audit Committee and executive management, have considered risks arising from the Company’s compensation policies and practices for its employees and have concluded that the compensation policies and practices are not reasonably likely to have a material adverse effect on the Company. In connection with the Company’s adoption of performance-based compensation for employees, an important objective of the Compensation Committee was ensuring that none of the targets would pose excessive risks.
Rest of the answer

The Compensation Committee discussed the relationship between the Company’s compensation and benefits programs and its risk profile with input from the Chairman of the Audit Committee and executive management. During its review, the Compensation Committee focused upon our short-term incentives, long-term incentives, and change-in-control benefits as having the greatest potential to create incentives for individual or collective risk taking. Following a thorough review of these and the other components of the Company’s compensation and benefits program, the Compensation Committee determined that the program does not create any incentives with respect to individual or collective behavior that are reasonably likely to have a material adverse effect upon either our risk profile or our overall approach to risk management.

Read in the reply
Risk Oversight, page 7
SEC asked (5)
In future filings, please disclose the effect that the board's role in the risk oversight has on the board's leadership structure. Please refer to Item 407(h) of Regulation S-K.
MIDD answered
In future filings, we will disclose the effect that the board’s role in risk oversight has on the board's leadership structure.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 27, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 12, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 13, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Compensation Discussion and Analysis, page 9 · Compensation Decision-Making Process, page 10
SEC asked (6)
We note your disclosure that “[t]he total compensation of Named Executive Officers and senior management of the Company are set at levels intended to be competitive with amounts paid to executive officers and senior managers with comparable qualifications, experience, and responsibilities at other businesses of similar type or market capitalization, with an emphasis on pay for performance.” Notwithstanding your
Rest of the question

statement that you do not benchmark compensation, this process appears to constitute benchmarking for purposes of Item 402(b)(2)(xiv) of Regulation S-K. With a view toward future disclosure, please tell us what impact this information had on your compensation decisions for the most recently completed fiscal year. In doing so, please clarify how you gather this information and the extent to which your compensation decisions are derived from or based on a comparison to peer companies, being sure to identify the peer companies by name, or otherwise describe your methodologies for utilizing comparative information when implementing your compensation policies or making specific compensation awards. To the extent any specific elements of compensation are tied to a benchmark, please identify the benchmark and discuss where your actual payments and awards fell with respect to the benchmark, and to the extent that actual compensation deviated from the benchmark, please provide an explanation of the reasons for this deviation. Please refer to Item 402(b)(2)(xiv) of Regulation S-K and Question 118.05 of the Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations of the staff of the Division of Corporation Finance concerning Item 402 of Regulation S-K, which can be found on our website.

MIDD answered
The Compensation Committee does not utilize specific compensation data as a basis for either the total compensation or a material portion of compensation paid to the Company’s executive officers, including the Named Executive Officers. Rather, each member of the Compensation Committee has brought to the process his own professional experience and knowledge of executive compensation practices generally, derived from each of their respective past and present positions at other companies, including in the case of Messrs. Robert L. Yohe, Gordon O’Brien and John R.
Rest of the answer

Miller III, as members of the board of directors of such other companies. Accordingly, we reconfirm that the Compensation Committee has not engaged in benchmarking in determining the elements and levels of compensation paid to the Named Executive Officers. Depending on the then applicable facts and circumstances, in future filings we will clarify our belief that we do not benchmark compensation.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 27, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 12, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 13, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Annual Performance-Based Incentive Programs, page 11 · Management Incentive Compensation Plan, page 11
SEC asked (7)
With a view towards future disclosure, please tell us what the dollar amounts of the EBITDA goals were for 2009 and, for the goals that were satisfied, the dollar amounts of EBITDA actually achieved with respect to those goals. In addition, please tell us in detail how you determined the specific amounts of the MICP awards for 2009 shown in the summary compensation table.
MIDD answered
The EBITDA goals for Messrs. Bassoul and FitzGerald were based upon a long term incentive plan incorporated into their respective employment agreements which established the criteria for the period from 2005 through 2011. A description of the MICP and the related goals for Messrs. Bassoul and FitzGerald was set forth in their employment agreements (Exhibits 10.3 and 10.5, respectively, to our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 2, 2010). Under their respective employment agreements, Messrs.
Rest of the answer

Bassoul and FitzGerald are eligible to earn 100% and 80%, respectively, of their base salary upon the achievement of the pre-determined EBITDA target and an additional $35,000 and $5,800, respectively, for each $120,000 of additional EBITDA over the EBITDA target. However, in no case can the total incentive compensation under the MICP exceed $3,500,000 for Mr. Bassoul or $600,000 for Mr. FitzGerald.

The EBITDA goals under the MICP were based upon a 12% year over year EBITDA growth rate utilizing the Company’s 2004 EBITDA as the baseline. The EBITDA targets for the periods from 2005 through 2011 were as follows:

2005

$48,985,685

2006

$54,863,967

2007

$61,447,643

2008

$68,821,360

2009

$77,079,923

2010

$86,329,515

2011

$96,689,057

To the extent that the Company’s actual EBITDA for a fiscal year exceeds the target for such fiscal year, the actual EBITDA amount for the prior year replaces the pre-determined objective in the employment agreement for the succeeding fiscal year. For 2009, the actual EBITDA goal amounted to $142,751,000 and the actual EBITDA achieved amounted to $153,665,000.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 27, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 12, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 13, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Long Term Equity-Based Incentive Programs, page 13
SEC asked (8)
With a view towards future disclosure, please tell us how you define return on equity for purposes of the replacement equity awards.
MIDD answered
We define “return on equity” as the percentage equal to (1) net earnings or loss for the period as set forth in the audited consolidated financial statements of the Company for the applicable period divided by (2) stockholders’ equity as of the first day of the applicable period as set forth in the Company’s consolidated financial statements.
Rest of the answer

The board of directors of the Company has retained discretion to adjust net earnings and average stockholders’ equity, otherwise determined in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, to take into account the impact of specific non-recurring income or expense items in the given period, such as income or expense items resulting from restructuring charges, acquisition initiatives, litigation matters, investments associated with significant growth initiatives, changes in accounting principles or the application thereof, discrete tax items, disposal of property or equipment, or gains and losses from non-operating sources. We will include such definition in our future filings.

Company Acknowledgement

The Company hereby acknowledges that:

· the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

· Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and

· the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

* * * * *

After you have had the opportunity to review these responses, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned at (847) 429-7744. Facsimile transmissions may be sent to the undersigned at (847) 429-7544.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 27, 2010: 10-Q filed Aug 12, 2010 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 13, 2010 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2010-08-02

Form S-4

2008-10-03 to 2008-11-10 · 46 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 0 from the company
No closing letter
Income taxesRisk factorsRevenueResults discussion (MD&A)Reserves and insuranceLiquidity and cashDebt
SEC letter of Oct 3, 2008 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
S-4 · General
SEC asked (1)
Disclosure on page 39 indicates that TurboChef intends to submit a proposal to its shareholders to adjourn or postpone the TurboChef special meeting to a later date or dates if necessary to solicit additional proxies.
Rest of the question

Please ensure that the form of proxy identifies the matter of adjournment as a separate matter to be acted upon, with an opportunity for the person solicited to specify by boxes a choice between approval or disapproval of or abstention to the matter of adjournment. See Rule 14a-4 of Schedule 14A. Revise also proposal 2 in the notice to TurboChef’s stockholders to make clear that TurboChef’s stockholders will vote on adjourning the special meeting to solicit additional proxies.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

S-4 · General
SEC asked (2)
Please discuss the anticipated cost savings and operating synergies mentioned throughout the prospectus.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

S-4 · General
SEC asked (3)
Please disclose the identity of the officers and directors after the merger.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Additional Information, page i; Voting by Interest, Telephone or Mail, page i
SEC asked (4)
Other than information required by Item 2 of Form S-4, please move the information here so that it follows the summary and risk factors sections. See Items 502 and 503(c) of Regulation S-K.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Summary, page 1
SEC asked (5)
Please note that Item 1001 of Regulation M-A requires a summary term sheet beginning on the first or second page of the disclosure document which includes page number cross references to further discussion in the prospectus provided to stockholders. See Item 14(b)(1) of Schedule 14A and instruction 2 to Item 1001 of Regulation M-A. Please revise.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Summary, page 1
SEC asked (6)
Please disclose the total amount of consideration to be received in the merger. Please also disclose the amount of restricted stock units and options that are outstanding and will be converted into the merger consideration. Q: What are the material United States federal income tax consequences of the merger?, page 5;
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions to Completion of the Merger, page 8; Material United States Federal Income Tax · Consequences of the Merger, page 57; Conditions to Obligations to Complete the Merger, page
SEC asked (7)
We note the “Assuming the merger so qualifies” language on page 8 and the “It is assumed” language on page 58. Please remove this language, and provide clear, definitive statements on the United States federal income tax consequences of the merger.
Rest of the question

Note that the United States federal income tax consequences of the merger must be covered by an opinion of counsel and that it is inappropriate for counsel to assume the tax consequences in issue or the legal conclusions underlying the opinion. Since the tax opinion must be filed prior to effectiveness, please state that counsel has opined that…” and delete the language that “counsel will deliver an opinion… .” Similarly, please delete the language on page 58 that “the merger is intended to qualify as a “reorganization.””

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions to Completion of the Merger, page 8; Material United States Federal Income Tax · Consequences of the Merger, page 57; Conditions to Obligations to Complete the Merger, page
SEC asked (8)
Please delete the word “general” in the first sentence on page 58 because the word general may imply that you have not disclosed all material United States federal income tax consequences and that stockholders cannot rely on the disclosure.
Rest of the question

Similarly, delete the word “generally” in the first and fourth bullet points under “Tax Consequences of the Merger” on page 58, under “TurboChef Stockholders Exercising Appraisal Rights” on page 59, and under “Reporting Requirements” on page 60, and the words “In general” in the second bullet point under “Tax Consequences of the Merger” on page 58 for the same reason.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions to Completion of the Merger, page 8; Material United States Federal Income Tax · Consequences of the Merger, page 57; Conditions to Obligations to Complete the Merger, page
SEC asked (9)
Although the conditions to completion of the merger include receipt of a tax opinion from legal counsel to Middleby or TurboChef that the merger constitutes a reorganization under Section 368(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, we note that the conditions may be waived.
Rest of the question

Please: • File executed tax opinions before the registration statement’s effectiveness even though the merger condition is conditioned upon receipt of a favorable tax opinion at closing. • Undertake to recirculate and resolicit if the condition for a favorable tax opinion is waived and the change in tax consequences is material.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions to Completion of the Merger, page 8; Material United States Federal Income Tax · Consequences of the Merger, page 57; Conditions to Obligations to Complete the Merger, page
SEC asked (10)
We understand that you intend to file tax opinions by amendment. Note that if Middleby’s counsel and TurboChef’s counsel elect to file short form tax opinions, the opinions and the proxy statement/prospectus both must state clearly that the discussion in the proxy statement/prospectus constitutes counsels’ opinions.
Rest of the question

The disclosure in the proxy statement/prospectus and the opinions should not state merely that the discussion in the proxy statement/prospectus is a fair and accurate summary of the United States federal income tax consequences.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Unaudited Pro Forma Condensed Balance Sheets, page 19
SEC asked (11)
Your pro forma adjustment (k) of $24.8 million to long-term deferred tax liability takes the adjusted balance to zero. Please revise your filing to clarify this adjustment and discuss the source of this tax liability. If the proposed merger is not completed, TurboChef and Middleby will have incurred substantial costs…, page 26
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Unaudited Pro Forma Condensed Balance Sheets, page 19
SEC asked (12)
Please quantify the “substantial” costs that TurboChef and Middleby have incurred and will incur in connection with the proposed merger.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Background of the Merger, page 40
SEC asked (13)
In the third and fourth paragraphs, explain briefly why Strategic Company 1 and Strategic Company 2 terminated discussions about a potential transaction with TurboChef.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Background of the Merger, page 40
SEC asked (14)
Please state which party initiated contact in the sixth paragraph and why they chose the other party.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Background of the Merger, page 40
SEC asked (15)
Please disclose why TurboChef was trying to sell or license its residential business in the spring of 2007.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Background of the Merger, page 40
SEC asked (16)
Please disclose why TurboChef engaged Goldman Sachs in October 2007 to find financial alternatives.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Background of the Merger, page 40
SEC asked (17)
Please disclose why Middleby reestablished communications with TurboChef in April 2008.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Background of the Merger, page 40
SEC asked (18)
In the fourteenth paragraph, indicate the capacity in which representatives from Lehman Brothers met with representatives of TurboChef, Middleby, and Goldman Sachs in Chicago on May 29, 2008. Please tell us whether Lehman Brothers prepared a fairness opinion and if so, why it is not summarized in the prospectus.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Background of the Merger, page 40
SEC asked (19)
Please elaborate on the state of the industry in the fifteenth paragraph.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Reasons for the Merger, page 44
SEC asked (20)
Please elaborate on each of the bullet points on pages 45-46 as necessary for investors to understand how consideration of the listed factors impacted the decision of TurboChef’s board of directors to approve the merger and to recommend that TurboChef’s stockholders vote to adopt the merger agreement.
Rest of the question

For example: • Please revise the first bullet point on page 45 to include a meaningful discussion and analysis of how the various components of this factor informed the board’s decision and recommendation. • In the fourth bullet point on page 45, please explain what the combined company will look like going forward. For example, explain how each company complements or overlaps the other, whether both companies are focused on the same markets, and, if so, what plans you have to integrate operations or eliminate duplicative functions and positions. To the extent practicable, include quantitative data on the known or anticipated benefits of the merger. • In the tenth bullet point on page 45, other than the possibility of continuing to operate TurboChef as an independent entity, disclose what other possible alternatives to the merger TurboChef’s board considered and describe each of the other possible alternatives. Alternatively, if there was no other possible alternative to the merger, so indicate and explain why. Further, describe the board’s assessment of TurboChef’s current business, competitive position, strategy, and prospects if TurboChef were to remain an independent entity. Please revise, as necessary, the factors listed in the bullet points on pages 45-46 accordingly.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Opinion of TurboChef’s Financial Advisor, page 49
SEC asked (21)
Please provide us two copies of any outlines, summaries, reports, or board books prepared and furnished by Goldman Sachs to TurboChef’s board of directors.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Opinion of TurboChef’s Financial Advisor, page 49
SEC asked (22)
Please describe the “Synergies” and “Middleby Estimates” discussed on page 50.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Selected Companies Analysis, page 50; Selected Transactions Analysis, page 51
SEC asked (23)
Disclosures states that the financial advisor calculated multiples and ratios for TurboChef using information provided by TurboChef’s management that exclude TurboChef’s residential kitchen equipment business. Explain why TurboChef’s residential kitchen equipment business was excluded.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Regulatory Matters, page 60
SEC asked (24)
As appropriate, please update the disclosure relating to the status of any required regulatory approval.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Merger Consideration, page 64
SEC asked (25)
We note the parenthetical phrase “subject to adjustment in certain circumstances to preserve the intended treatment of the merger as a “reorganization” for United States federal income tax purposes” in the first paragraph. Explain the circumstances under which an adjustment would be made, and disclose the magnitude of any adjustment.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Representations and Warranties, page 67
SEC asked (26)
We note your statements that “the merger agreement is described… and included… only to provide you with information regarding its terms and conditions, and not to provide any other factual information… .” and that “you should read the information provided elsewhere in this proxy statement/prospectus and in the documents incorporated by reference… .” Please either delete these sentences or revise them to remove any
Rest of the question

potential implication that the referenced merger agreement does not constitute public disclosure under the federal securities laws.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Middleby’s Common Stock, page 82
SEC asked (27)
Disclose whether holders of Middleby’s common stock have cumulative voting rights.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Legal Matters, page 89
SEC asked (28)
Please provide the address of each counsel as required by paragraph 23 of Schedule A to the Securities Act.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Where You Find More Information, page 89
SEC asked (29)
Please include the Commission’s filing number for filings by each of Middleby and TurboChef under the Exchange Act.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Undertakings, page 92
SEC asked (30)
Provide the Rule 430C undertaking required by Item 512(a)(5)(ii) of Regulation S-K.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (31)
We note the statement “We do not express any opinion as to the laws of any jurisdiction other than the General Corporation Law of the State of Delaware.” Please provide written confirmation tagged as correspondence on the EDGAR system that counsel concurs with our understanding that the reference and limitation to the Delaware General Corporation Law includes the statutory provisions and all applicable provisions of
Rest of the question

the Delaware constitution, including reported judicial decisions interpreting those laws.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (32)
We note the statement “The opinions expressed herein are based on laws in effect on the date hereof.” Since the opinion must speak as of the date of the registration statement’s effectiveness, please delete. Alternatively, please file a new opinion immediately before the registration statement’s effectiveness because the opinions must speak as of that time.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 99.2
SEC asked (33)
We note the statement “our consent is being delivered solely in connection with the filing of the above-mentioned version of the Registration Statement.” Please file an updated consent with any amendment to the registration statement.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 99.2
SEC asked (34)
We note the statement “our consent is not to be used, circulated, quoted or otherwise referred to for any other purpose...except in accordance with our prior written consent.” We view these limitations as inappropriate since the opinion is being provided to stockholders in a public disclosure document under the federal securities laws.
Rest of the question

Please delete these limitations or disclose the basis for the financial advisor’s belief that stockholders cannot rely on the opinion to support any claims against it arising under applicable state law. Describe any applicable authority or disclose that the availability of this defense will be resolved by a court of competent jurisdiction. Also disclose that the resolution will have no effect on the rights and responsibilities of the board of directors under applicable state law and disclose that the availability of the defense would have no effect on the rights and responsibilities of the financial advisor or the board of directors under federal securities laws. See our Current Issues Outline, Section II.D.1, November 14, 2000, available at http://www.sec.gov.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit 99.3
SEC asked (35)
We note that you intend to file by amendment the form of proxy as required by Rule 14a6(a) of Regulation 14A. Identify the form as preliminary as required by Rule 14a-6(e)(1) of Regulation 14A. See also Rule 14a-4 of Regulation 14A.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Other
SEC asked (36)
We understand that TurboChef has three confidential treatment applications pending. We intend to process concurrently the registration statement and the confidential treatment applications. Before requesting acceleration of the registration statement’s effectiveness, TurboChef must resolve any issue concerning the applications and file publicly the portions of the exhibits for which it is not requesting confidential
Rest of the question

treatment.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

The Middleby Corporation June 30, 2008 10-Q · Item 3. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures about Market Risk, page 33
SEC asked (37)
Disclosure states that Middleby’s senior secured credit facility contains ratios of indebtedness and fixed charge coverage. In future filings, please state what the limits of all material financial ratios and tests are under Middleby’s outstanding debt instruments. Closing As appropriate, please amend the registration statement in response to these comments.
Rest of the question

You may wish to provide us marked courtesy copies of the amendment to expedite our review. Please furnish a cover letter with your amendment that keys your responses to our comments and provides any requested information. Detailed cover letters greatly facilitate our review. Please understand that we may have additional comments after review of your amendment and responses to our comments.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

SEC letter of Nov 10, 2008 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
S-4 · General
SEC asked (1)
Please provide updated consents from your independent auditors pursuant to Item 601 of Regulation S-K and updated financial statements pursuant to Rule 3-12 of Regulation S- X.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Summary, page 1
SEC asked (2)
Refer to prior comment 5. As noted previously, Item 1001 of Regulation M-A requires a summary term sheet beginning on the first or second page of the disclosure document which includes page number cross references to further discussion in the prospectus provided to stockholders.
Rest of the question

Additionally, Item 1001 of Regulation M-A specifies that the summary term sheet must describe briefly in bullet format the most material terms of the proposed transaction and provide securityholders sufficient information to understand the essential features and significance of the proposed transaction. Please revise to comply with all of the item’s requirements. Q: What are the material United States federal income tax consequences of the merger?, page 5;

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions to Completion of the Merger, page 8; Material United States Federal Income Tax · Consequences of the Merger, page 57; Conditions to Obligations to Complete the Merger, page
SEC asked (3)
We note the revised “should not recognize any loss” language on pages 8 and 58. Explain why counsel is unable to provide a “will not” conclusion rather than a “should not” conclusion, and disclose any resulting risks to United States holders of TurboChef common stock.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions to Completion of the Merger, page 8; Material United States Federal Income Tax · Consequences of the Merger, page 57; Conditions to Obligations to Complete the Merger, page
SEC asked (4)
Refer to prior comment 8. As requested previously, delete the word “generally” in the fourth bullet point under “Tax Consequences of the Merger” on page 59.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Interests of Executive Officers and Directors of TurboChef in the Merger, page 55
SEC asked (5)
Disclose also any TurboChef shares to be exchanged for the merger consideration and any cash to be received in lieu of any fractional share of common stock. See Item 5 of Schedule 14A.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Where You Can Find More Information, page 89
SEC asked (6)
We note that TurboChef’s current report on Form 8-K dated September 9, 2008 and filed September 16, 2008 which is incorporated by reference discloses a shareholder class action lawsuit challenging the proposed merger. Advise what consideration you have given to disclosure of the shareholder class action lawsuit in the proxy statement/prospectus.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibit Index
SEC asked (7)
List the consent of Paul, Hastings, Janofsky & Walker LLP as an exhibit in the exhibit index and indicate that the consent is included in exhibit 8.2.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibits 8.1 and 8.2
SEC asked (8)
We note that you filed forms of tax opinions as exhibits 8.1 and 8.2 in response to prior comments 9 and 10. As noted previously, you must file executed tax opinions before the registration statement’s effectiveness since the conditions for receipt of a tax opinion from legal counsel to Middleby or TurboChef may be waived. Please file executed tax opinions before the registration statement’s effectiveness.
MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibits 8.1 and 8.2
SEC asked (9)
We note the statement in exhibit 8.1 “This opinion is expressed as of the date hereof, and we are under no obligation to supplement or revise our opinion” and the statement in exhibit 8.2 “we undertake no responsibility to advise you of any new development in the application or interpretation of the federal income tax laws.” Since the opinions must speak as of the date of the registration statement’s effectiveness,
Rest of the question

please delete this language in the executed tax opinions filed before the registration statement’s effectiveness. Alternatively, please file newly executed tax opinions immediately before the registration statement’s effectiveness because the tax opinions must speak as of that time. Closing As appropriate, please amend the registration statement in response to these comments. You may wish to provide us marked courtesy copies of the amendment to expedite our review. Please furnish a cover letter with your amendment that keys your responses to our comments and provides any requested information. Detailed cover letters greatly facilitate our review. Please understand that we may have additional comments after review of your amendment and responses to our comments.

MIDD answered

No reply letter found.

Letters without questions

Other letters

UPLOAD and CORRESP
4 other letters: notices that a filing will not be reviewed, requests to declare a registration effective, and the like

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 36 letters filed since 2008-10-06. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/MIDD/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.