Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0001567094 /10-K filed Feb 26, 2026, compared with Feb 28, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
NYSE Industrials · Construction Machinery

CNH Industrial N.V. CNH

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

5 reviews of CNH's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 5 latest letter Sep 28, 2022
Questions asked 117 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 1 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 10 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 117 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 12 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 4 of 5 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 55 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 20-F for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2021

2022-09-28 to 2022-11-22 · 3 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 3 from the company
Review closed 2022-11-22
RevenueNon-GAAP measuresLiquidity and cashDebt
B. Liquidity and Capital Resources · Consolidated Debt, page 55
SEC asked (1)
We note you include a subtotal for "operating cash flow of industrial activities" within your free cash flow of industrial activities reconciliation; however, this subtotal does not agree to the GAAP operating cash flow of industrial activities as disclosed within the supplemental information on page 47. Please advise.
Rest of the question

If the amount shown on page 56 is a non-GAAP adjusted cash flow measure, revise to clarify that and to reconcile from GAAP operating cash flow of industrial activities as disclosed on page 47.

CNH answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, we note that we use the non-GAAP measure, Free Cash Flow from Industrial

Activities, to provide useful and relevant information regarding our operating results and enhance the readers’ ability to assess CNH Industrial’s financial performance. Management uses this non-GAAP measure to identify operational trends, as well as make decisions regarding future spending, resource allocations and other operational decisions as it provides additional transparency with respect to our core operations.
Rest of the answer

Pursuant to SEC rules and published guidance, we also provide a reconciliation of Cash flow provided by operating activities (the most directly comparable U.S. GAAP measure) to Free Cash Flow from Industrial Activities (the “Free Cash Flow Reconciliation”). We have included in our annual report on Form 20-F operating cash flow of Industrial Activities as a subtotal to assist the reader in understanding the reconciliation. We note the Staff’s comment and in future filings we will not include the subtotal

Operating Cash Flow of Industrial Activities. Please see an updated example of our Free Cash Flow Reconciliation Below.

(in millions)

2021

2020

Net cash provided by (used in) Operating Activities

$

4,082

5,529

Less: Cash flows from Operating Activities of Financial Services net of Eliminations

(975

)

(2,214

Change in derivatives hedging debt of Industrial Activities

(15

Investments in assets sold under buy-back commitments and operating lease assets of Industrial Activities

(728

(687

Operating cash flow of Industrial Activities

2,470

2,613

Investments in property plant and equipment, and intangible assets of Industrial

Activities

(706

(481

Other changes (1)

(13

(206

Read in the reply
Note 2: Summary of Significant Accounting Policies · Revenue Recognition, page F-11
SEC asked (2)
We note you record revenue from sales of goods when the goods are made available to the customer, which signifies transfer of control. Please revise to disclose how you evaluate when the goods are made available to the customer. For example, disclose whether this is when legal title is transferred, when you have an obligation for payment from the customer, when the asset has been physically transferred, etc.
Rest of the question

Refer to ASC 606-10-25- 30. As part of your response, please provide us with your proposed disclosure. In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.

CNH answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we will revise our revenue recognition accounting disclosure to clarify when the goods are made available to the customer. Our proposed revised disclosure is as follows. Changes from the existing disclosure are noted by the underlines:

The Company has determined that the customers from the sale of vehicles, equipment and parts are generally dealers, distributors, public entities, and retail customers.

The Company recognizes revenue at a point in time when control has is transferred to the customer at a sales price that the Company
Rest of the answer

expects to receive. Transfer of control occurs when title and risk of ownership have transferred to the customer, which generally occurs upon delivery as specified in the contract, which is primarily upon shipment. and thus related revenue recognition, generally corresponds to when the vehicles, equipment and parts are made available to the customer. Therefore, the Company recognizes revenue at a point in time when control is transferred to the customer at a sales price that the Company expects to receive.

For all sales, no significant uncertainty exists surrounding the purchaser’s obligation to pay for vehicles, equipment, and parts. The Company records appropriate allowance for credit losses and anticipated returns as required. Fixed payment schedules exist for al sales, but payment terms vary by geographic market and product line.

Thank you again for your time. Please feel free to contact me at +39 335 828 3371 or by email

([email protected]) or our external counsel, Scott D. Miller of Sullivan & Cromwell LLP at (212) 558-3109 or by email ([email protected]) with any questions you may have.

Read in the reply
Note 2: Summary of Significant Accounting Policies · Revenue Recognition, page F-11
SEC asked
We note the proposed disclosures provided in response to prior comment 2. Please revise to clearly indicate whether the transfer of control occurs upon delivery or upon shipment.
CNH answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we will revise our revenue recognition accounting disclosure to clarify when the transfer of control occurs. Our proposed revised disclosure is as follows. Changes from the previous disclosure are noted by the underlines:

The

Company recognizes revenue at a point in time when control has transferred to the customer at a sales price that the Company expects to receive.
Rest of the answer

Transfer of control occurs when title and risk of ownership have transferred to the customer, which generally occurs based upon delivery the terms specified in the contract. which is primarily. In most of the jurisdictions where the Company operates, and subject to specific exceptions, transfer of control occurs upon shipment.

Thank you again for your time. Please feel free to contact me at +39 335 828 3371 or by email ([email protected]) or our external counsel, Scott D. Miller of Sullivan & Cromwell LLP at (212) 558-3109 or by email ([email protected]) with any questions you may have.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Nov 3, 2022, closing letter, 2022-11-22

Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2019

2020-07-29 to 2020-10-08 · 8 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 3 from the company
Review closed 2020-10-08
SegmentsNon-GAAP measuresIncome taxes
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements · Note 11. Income Taxes, page F-34
SEC asked (1)
Please provide us with your analysis supporting the release of your Italian valuation allowance including the positive and negative evidence considered and how you weighted such evidence. Refer to ASC 740-10-30-17 through 30-25. We note from disclosure in the Form 6-K furnished on November 12, 2019 that the planned spin-off of your On- Highway operation was considered as part of your analysis.
Rest of the question

As the spin-off is subject to shareholder approval, please tell us how you considered management's ability to control the planned transaction in your analysis. Refer to ASC 740-10-30-19. Further, in future filings, please revise your Operating and Financial Review Prospects disclosure to discuss the specific circumstances that led to the release and the circumstances that could reasonably cause you to adjust your valuation allowance in the future. Refer to Section III.B.3 of SEC Release No. 33-8350.

CNH answered
Analysis of evidence as part of the valuation allowance (“VA”) release

As it does for each quarterly financial reporting period, at

September 30, 2019, the Company performed a detailed analysis to assess the realizability of the Italian deferred tax assets (“DTAs”), which considered all positive and negative evidence. We considered the four possible sources of taxable income of our Italian tax filing group (the “Italian Fiscal Unit”).
Rest of the answer

In doing so, we noted that carrybacks are not available under Italian tax law and future reversals of existing taxable temporary differences would be more than offset by reversals of deductible temporary differences. Further, we concluded available tax planning strategies, which did not include the planned spin-off of our on-highway operations, would not generate a significant amount of taxable income. Therefore, the analysis relied primarily on future taxable income (exclusive of reversing temporary differences) to support the realization of the DTAs.

As background, the Italian Fiscal Unit generated pre-tax losses for several consecutive years. However, towards the end of 2018, the Italian Fiscal Unit began showing signs of profitability due, in part, to restructuring and other actions taken in prior years and the overall improvement in demand for the Italian Fiscal Unit’s various products. The positive pre-tax profitability trend of the Italian Fiscal Unit continued for the first nine months of 2019.

The following table shows the pre-tax income (loss) for the Italian Fiscal Unit for periods 2013 through 2018 and the first nine months of 2019:

Period

FY 2013

FY 2014

FY 2015

FY 2016

FY 2017

FY 2018

YTD 2019

Pre-tax income (loss), €M

(292

)

(199

(8

143

100

This trend was expected to continue based on the Company’s most recently updated full-year 2019 forecast which was completed in the third-quarter of that year. Additionally, during the third-quarter of 2019, the Company completed a 2020 budget as part of its long-term (five-year) Strategic Business Plan (“SBP”). The SBP was publicly disclosed at the

Company’s Capital Markets Day (“CMD”) on September 3, 2019. It reflected the Company’s expectation for the industries and markets in which it operates, including its expectation regarding the ‘Eurozone’ and assumptions for future research and development spending, capital allocation and its manufacturing footprint. This SBP forecasted sustained profitability in 2020 and beyond.

Consistent with ASC 740-10-30-18(b), this expectation of future taxable income, was significant positive evidence as the Italian Fiscal Unit operates in multiple cyclical industries that largely depend on the macroeconomic status of the ‘Eurozone’. The combination of actual recent pre-tax income and long-term forecasted profitability developed through the SBP indicated the Italian

Fiscal Unit had returned to sustained profitability, which was a key element supporting the Company’s conclusion it was more likely than not the DTAs would be realized and, accordingly, the VA should be adjusted. Lastly, the SBP addressed the

Company’s future spending on research and development, capital allocation and manufacturing footprint in a manner that further mitigated some of the negative evidence that existed in previous periods (as noted in the disclosures in the

Company’s Annual Report on Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2018).

As noted above, the decision to adjust the VA was primarily driven by the Italian Fiscal Unit generating recent pre-tax earnings, the completion of a long-term forecast that indicated sustained future profitability and the favorable resolution, via the Company’s SBP issued during the third-quarter of 2019, of several previously unsettled circumstances whose unfavorable resolution could have adversely affected the future results of the Italian Fiscal Unit.

Accordingly, based on the weight of all available evidence, as required by ASC 740-10-30-17 through 30-25, and highlighted by the above, the Company concluded during the period ended September 30, 2019, the positive evidence more than outweighed the negative evidence and, accordingly, it would more likely than not realize the Italian Fiscal Unit’s DTAs. Accordingly, the Company adjusted the VA during that period.

Spin-off related matters

As noted above, the continued profitability through 2019 resulting in a sustained period of pre-tax profits, the 2020 budget, and the long-term forecast included in the SBP were key elements supporting the Company’s conclusion to reduce the VA at September 30, 2019. The 2020 budget and SBP forecast were publicly communicated at the CMD, when the Company also announced its intention to spin-off its on-highway operations. Because these two significant pieces of information (the SBP and intention to spin-off the on-highway operations) were communicated concurrently to the public, the Company felt it important, for completeness purposes, to note the proposed transaction in its income tax disclosures for the period ended September 30, 2019. The plan to spin-off of the on-highway operations, however, was not considered a tax planning strategy, under ASC 740-10-30-19, that factored into the analysis to adjust the VA.

Disclosures in future filings

In its future filings with the SEC, the Company will include, in its Operational and Financial Review Prospects, disclosures of the specific circumstances leading to the release of a VA and the circumstances that could reasonably cause a future adjustment to a VA.

Read in the reply
Note 20: Segment Reporting, page F-60
SEC asked (2)
We note your reconciliation from Net income to Adjusted EBITDA does not comply with ASC 280-10-50-30. Please reconcile the total of the reportable segments’ measures of profit or loss to consolidated income before income taxes.
CNH answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we will revise our reconciliation from Net income to Adjusted EBITDA to include a subtotal for Income before taxes, in compliance with ASC 280-10-50-30. Please see an example of this reconciliation included in Appendix A.
Read in the reply
Note 20: Segment Reporting, page F-60
SEC asked (3)
Your disclosures indicate that the chief operating decision maker (CODM) uses EBIT and EBITDA to assess segment performance and make decisions about resource allocation. If the CODM uses more than one measure of a segment's profit or loss, the reported (single) measure shall be the one that management believes is determined in accordance with the measurement principles most consistent with those used in measuring
Rest of the question

the corresponding amount in your consolidated financial statements. Refer to ASC 280-10-50-28. Please tell us your consideration of disclosing only one measure of segment profit or loss.

CNH answered
After considering the Staff’s comment, we have determined that Adjusted EBIT for the Industrial Activities segments is the one measure of an Industrial Activities segment’s profit or loss that is determined in accordance with the measurement principles most consistent with those used in measuring the corresponding amount in our consolidated financial statements.

Our response to question 4 addresses the financial measure the CODM uses to assess the financial performance of our Financial Services segment.

In future filings, we will remove Adjusted EBITDA from our segment footnote.

Please see
Rest of the answer

an example of our updated segment footnote included in Appendix A.

Read in the reply
Note 20: Segment Reporting, page F-60
SEC asked (4)
We also note your disclosure that the CODM assesses the performance of the Financial Services segment using net income. However, we note that you do not disclose Financial Services net income in your segment footnote but instead disclose EBIT and EBITDA. Please tell us which measure is the segment measure of performance for the Financial Services segment and how your disclosures comply with ASC 280-10-50-22 and -28.
Rest of the question

If net income is the segment measure of performance, EBIT and EBITDA for the Financial Services segment would be considered non-GAAP measures and should be removed from the footnotes. See Item 10(e)(1)(ii) of Regulation S-K. Also, refer to Section 104 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.

CNH answered
The CODM assesses the performance of the

Financial Services segment on the basis of net income prepared in accordance with U.S. GAAP. In our Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2019, net income from Financial Services was disclosed in the supplemental information footnote (Footnote 22). In future filings, we will update our segment disclosure to include Financial Services net income.
Rest of the answer

We included Financial Services Adjusted EBIT and Adjusted EBITDA in our Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2019 to allow for the full reconciliation of measures to the consolidated results of the Company. We note the Staff’s comment and in future filings we will not include references to Financial Services Adjusted EBIT and Adjusted EBITDA and Consolidated Adjusted EBIT and Adjusted EBITDA. Please see an example of our updated segment footnote included in Appendix A.

Read in the reply
Note 20: Segment Reporting, page F-60
SEC asked (5)
Considering the nature of the Financial Services segment, please disclose interest income and interest expense separately for this segment. Refer to ASC 280-10-50-22.
CNH answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we will disclose interest income and interest expense separately for the Financial Services segment. Please see Appendix A for an example of our updated footnote disclosure.
Read in the reply
Note 20: Segment Reporting, page F-60
SEC asked (6)
We note the presentations here are the same as those on page 36. Notwithstanding the comments noted above, any additional segment profit or loss measures that are presented outside of the financial statements and footnotes are non-GAAP measures and the disclosures should comply with Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K.
CNH answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment. As noted in our response to question 2, management has determined that Adjusted EBIT is the one profitability measure that the CODM uses to assess segment performance and make decisions about resource allocation with reference to our Industrial Activities. In light of this determination and in response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we will adjust the disclosure in Operating and Financial Review and Prospects to remove the Adjusted EBITDA reconciliation as it is not our measure of segment profitability for Industrial Activities segments under
Rest of the answer

ASC 280.

Read in the reply
Note 22. Supplemental Information, page F-65
SEC asked (7)
Please tell us why you include the supplemental schedules in the footnotes to the financial statements. As part of your response, explain your basis for including the Financial Services segment using the equity method of accounting in your presentation of Industrial Services. Please tell us how you considered Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
CNH answered
We include the supplemental schedules in the footnotes to the financial statements as we believe that this information is relevant for investors. As we describe in the footnote, the operations, key financial measures, and financial analysis differ significantly for manufacturing and distribution businesses (the “Industrial Activities”) and financial services (“Financial

Services”) businesses; therefore, management believes that certain supplemental disclosures are important in understanding the consolidated operations and financial results of the Company.

In response to the Staff’s comment,
Rest of the answer

in future filings, in order to clarify this information, we will present consolidating information for each of the statements presented, using the following format:

Consolidated

Industrial Activities

Financial Services

Eliminations

Results

Revenues

Net sales

26,149

Finance and interest income

2,011

(179

1,930

Total Revenues

26,247

28,079

Costs and Expenses

Cost of goods sold

21,832

Selling, General & Administrative Expenses

1,998

218

2,216

Reseach and Development expenses

1,030

Restructuring (income)/expenses, net

105

109

Interest Expense

380

597

798

Other Expenses/(Income), net

187

737

924

Total Costs and Expenses

25,532

1,556

26,909

Income before income taxes and equity in income of unconsolidated subsidiaries and affiliates

715

455

1,170

Income Taxes provision (benefit)

(391

120

(271

Equity in income (loss) of unconsolidated subsidiaries and affiliates

(13

Result from intersegment Investments

361

(361

Net Income / (Loss)

1,454

Furthermore, in future filings, the Company will present this disclosure in its MD&A section of its Annual Report on Form 20-F and not in the notes to the financial statements.

The Company believes that the revised presentation will make it clearer to the reader of the financial statements that the presentation of Industrial Activities and Financial Services are sub-combinations of the CNH Industrial N.V. consolidated financial statements. The operating results for Industrial Activities will show the manufacturing and distribution results for the Company with the impact of Financial Services in a separate line which is eliminated as part of the consolidation. The Financial Services legal entities are directly or indirectly owned and controlled by legal entities included in Industrial Activities. The reader will be able to reconcile the information with the consolidated U.S. GAAP financial results.

In determining to include such information in our filing, we considered whether such disclosure would be misleading to investors and other users of the financial statements. Management determined that this was not misleading as it allows users to review the two businesses separately, given that the financial analysis performed on each type of business is different.

We also note that such disclosures are not uncommon for manufacturing entities with captive finance businesses, including the treatment of financial services under the equity method. This allows the users to compare our results with those of our peers.

We considered Question 100.04 of the non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosures Interpretations as we developed the revised presentation to include the consolidation of the sub-combinations with the addition of the eliminations and the consolidated CNH Industrial N.V. results. This allows the reader to see Industrial Activities, Financial Services and how they consolidate to the

CNH Industrial financial statements. Furthermore, moving the presentation to the MD&A is consistent with the fact that these disclosures are not required by U.S. GAAP, but are included because management believes they may assist readers in understanding the Company’s two distinct businesses.

Thank you again for your time. Please feel free to contact me at +39 335 828

3371 or by email ([email protected]) or Scott D. Miller of Sullivan & Cromwell LLP at (212) 558-3109 or by email ([email protected]) with any questions you may have.

Read in the reply
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements · Note 22. Supplemental Information, page F-65
SEC asked
We note your response to prior comment 7. Please revise in future filings to remove the presentation of the Financial Services segment using the equity method of accounting. Refer to Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
CNH answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, in future filings, we confirm that we will remove the Supplemental Information contained in Note 22 which includes removing the presentation of the Financial Services segment using the equity method of accounting.

Thank you again for your time. Please feel free to contact me at +39 335 828 3371 or by email ([email protected]) or Scott D. Miller of Sullivan & Cromwell LLP at (212) 558-3109 or by email ([email protected]) with any questions you may have.
Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Aug 3, 2020, closing letter, 2020-10-08

CNH Industrial N.V. · 20-F for Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2016 · Filed March 2, 2017 · File No. 001-36085

2017-06-06 to 2017-07-13 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2017-07-13
Russia and UkraineRevenue
General
SEC asked (1)
In a letter to us dated September 22, 2014, you stated that your foreign subsidiaries sold agricultural equipment and parts under the New Holland brand to customers located in Sudan and Syria including, in certain cases, to an independent distributor or importer that may be partially or wholly state-owned.
Rest of the question

You state on page 18 of the 20-F that you sell agricultural equipment under the New Holland Agriculture and Case IH Agriculture brands. Websites for these brands identify Case IH dealers and New Holland Agriculture distributors in Sudan and Syria. Additionally, a press release on your website indicates that Case IH and New Holland machinery is assembled in Sudan. As you know, Sudan and Syria are designated by the Department of State as state sponsors of terrorism, and are subject to U.S. economic sanctions and export controls. Please describe to us the nature and extent of any past, current, and anticipated contacts with Sudan and Syria since your 2014 letter, whether through subsidiaries, affiliates, distributors, partners, joint ventures or other direct or indirect arrangements. You should describe any services, products, information or technology you have provided to Sudan or Syria, directly or indirectly, and any agreements, commercial arrangements, or other contacts you have had with the governments of those countries or entities they control.

CNH answered
CNH Industrial is incorporated in and under the laws of The Netherlands. CNH Industrial has its corporate seat in Amsterdam, The Netherlands, and its principal office in London, United Kingdom. CNH Industrial engages, primarily through its subsidiaries, in the design, production, marketing, sale and financing of agricultural and construction equipment, trucks, commercial vehicles, buses and specialty vehicles for firefighting, defense and other uses, as well as engines and transmissions for those vehicles and engines for marine and power generation applications.
Rest of the answer

CNH Industrial has industrial and financial services subsidiaries located in 45 countries and a commercial presence in approximately 180 countries around the world. CNH Industrial provides certain financial information by geographic area. CNH Industrial’s geographic regions are: (1) NAFTA; (2) EMEA; (3) LATAM; and (4) APAC. The geographic designations have the following meanings:

•

NAFTA—United States, Canada and Mexico;

EMEA—member countries of the European Union, member countries of the European Free Trade Association, Ukraine, Balkans, African continent and the Middle East (excluding Turkey);

LATAM—Central and South America, and the Caribbean Islands; and

APAC—Continental Asia (including Turkey and Russia), Oceania and member countries of the Commonwealth of Independent States (excluding Ukraine).

Sudan and Syria fall within the EMEA region (Sudan and Syria are referred to collectively hereinafter as the “Subject Countries”). Foreign

(i.e. non-U.S.) subsidiaries of CNH Industrial are responsible for sales and marketing of CNH Industrial products in the EMEA, LATAM and APAC regions. In some cases, goods sold by foreign subsidiaries of CNH Industrial have U.S. origin content and/or are the subject of an intra-company sale between a U.S. subsidiary and a foreign subsidiary of CNH Industrial and thus have shipped from the United States to Sudan. In such cases, the U.S. subsidiary applied for and received licenses from the Office of Foreign Assets Control of the U.S. Department of the Treasury (“OFAC”) to ship such agricultural and construction equipment (including tractors, hay and forage equipment, cotton pickers, sprayers and light construction equipment) to Sudan. The U.S. subsidiary obtained from OFAC a number of licenses during the period from January 1, 2014 through January 17, 2017. On January 17, 2017, OFAC issued a general license authorizing transactions involving

Sudan, subject to certain terms and conditions, and our U.S. subsidiary has since that date shipped agricultural and construction equipment to Sudan under that general license.

U.S. law does not prohibit foreign companies from doing business with or in the Subject Countries. Transactions involving U.S. origin goods or goods subject to an intra-company sale and shipped from a U.S. location but sold by CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries have been limited to Sudan and have been conducted under licenses granted by OFAC. Further, CNH Industrial has an export management system, dedicated global export compliance personnel, and a compliance program which includes appropriate training designed to ensure that all business activity relating to, among others, the Subject Countries is conducted in conformity with all applicable laws. The program includes policies and procedures to ensure that no U.S. personnel are involved in activity in which their involvement would be prohibited.

Over the period from January 1, 2014 through March 31, 2017, certain of CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries sold (1) agricultural and construction equipment and spare parts under the New Holland brand to customers located in Sudan; (2) commercial vehicles and spare parts under the Iveco brand to customers located in Sudan and Syria and (3) engines and spare parts under the FPT Industrial brand to a customer located in Sudan. When these transactions have involved U.S. origin content or goods subject to an intra-company sale where shipment initiates from a U.S. location, they have been completed under license granted by OFAC; however, none of these transactions have been sales by a

U.S. subsidiary directly to a customer located in the Subject Countries. Net revenues by CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries over each of the last three years and the first three months of 2017 are approximately as follows:

Sudan:

2014:

$24,208,140

2015: $23,248,300

2016: $17,874,365

20171: $5,489,098

Syria:

$1,624,043

2015: $107,073

2016: $655,428

20172: $232

Net revenues by all of CNH Industrial foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries constituted approximately the following percentages of CNH

Industrial’s total consolidated worldwide revenue for the relevant periods: 0.0793% in 2014, 0.0901% in 2015, 0.0745% in 2016, and 0.0966% in 2017 (through March 31).

The New Holland brand agricultural equipment sold into Sudan during the period from January 1, 2014 through March 31, 2017 included the following:

tractors, combines (and headers), hay and forage equipment and sugar cane harvesters. The New Holland brand construction equipment sold into Sudan during the period from January 1, 2014 through March 31, 2017 included excavators, wheel loaders and backhoe loaders. The Iveco brand commercial vehicles sold into Sudan and Syria during the period from January 1, 2014 to March 31, 2017 included a mix of heavy and medium trucks and buses. The FPT Industrial brand engines and spare parts sold into Sudan during the period from January 1, 2014 until March 31, 2017 were used for power generation units.

Subject to market and other economic conditions as well as applicable laws (including OFAC licensing requirements), CNH Industrial anticipates that its foreign subsidiaries will continue to conduct business in the Subject Countries at levels substantially consistent with its historical practice.

CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries sell agricultural equipment, commercial vehicles and parts for such equipment into the Subject Countries through different distribution channels. With respect to Sudan, CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries only sell agricultural and construction equipment, commercial vehicles and parts for such equipment to independent distributors or importers. Additionally, in Sudan, CNH Industrial also sells agricultural equipment to an importer in a semi-knock down configuration (i.e., a kit containing the components needed to assemble the equipment), and the importer performs basic final assembly operations and resells the equipment to local end users. CNH Industrial has no

2017 figures are for the period January 1, 2017 through March 31, 2017.

investments in Sudan related to the equipment assembled in Sudan. With respect to Syria, CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries only sell commercial vehicles and parts for such equipment to an independent distributor.

While CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries provides technical support to the independent distributors located in the

Subject Countries, no U.S. citizens or residents employed by such CNH Industrial foreign subsidiaries have travelled to or provided any kind of support with respect to the independent distributors or other third parties located in the Subject

Countries. Technical support of independent distributors in the Subject Countries generally includes sales and marketing and product support training, and providing sales and marketing and product support literature to the extent necessary and appropriate to service the customers’ necessities. As a result of the foregoing, the names of such independent distributors and importers may be listed on web sites maintained by CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries, such as the websites of New Holland Agriculture, New Holland Construction and Iveco.

CNH Industrial understands that certain of its New Holland brand agricultural and construction equipment and Iveco brand commercial vehicles sold by its foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries (through the distribution channels described above) may be purchased by municipalities and state corporations as well as farms, cooperatives, businesses or other entities, some of which may be partially or wholly state-owned. The business relationship between such foreign subsidiaries and the independent distributor or importer is governed by a sale and purchase agreement or comparable agreement between the applicable foreign subsidiary and the independent distributor or importer. Other than as set forth above, neither CNH Industrial nor any of its subsidiaries has any agreement or commercial arrangement with the government of any Subject Country or, to the best of CNH Industrial’s knowledge, any entity controlled by such government.

Read in the reply
General
SEC asked (2)
Please discuss the materiality of any contacts with Sudan and Syria you describe in response to the comment above, and whether those contacts constitute a material investment risk for your security holders. You should address materiality in quantitative terms, including the approximate dollar amounts of any associated revenues, assets, and liabilities for the last three fiscal years and the subsequent interim
Rest of the question

period. Also, address materiality in terms of qualitative factors that a reasonable investor would deem important in making an investment decision, including the potential impact of corporate activities upon a company's reputation and share value. Various state and municipal governments, universities, and other investors have proposed or adopted divestment or similar initiatives regarding investment in companies that do business with U.S.- designated state sponsors of terrorism. You should address the potential impact of the investor sentiment evidenced by such actions directed toward companies that have operations associated with Sudan and Syria.

CNH answered
Please note the sales figures and other information contained in the Response to Comment 1 above. As set forth above, CNH Industrial’s aggregate sales to the Subject Countries in each of the last three years and for the three months ended March 31, 2017, has represented not more than

0.0966% of CNH Industrial’s total consolidated worldwide revenue in any such period.
Rest of the answer

CNH Industrial does not consider this level of activity with the Subject Countries to be quantitatively material.

CNH Industrial does not believe that its foreign subsidiaries’ sales into the Subject Countries should or would be regarded as qualitatively material by a reasonable investor in making an investment decision given the limited nature and extent of such sales, particularly because CNH Industrial believes that it conducts such sales in compliance with all applicable laws. In addition, we discussed this matter with representatives of CNH Industrial’s Investor Relations function. The CNH Industrial Investor Relations function confirmed that, generally, institutional investors do not consider CNH

Industrial’s dealings in the Subject Countries to be a material issue. In addition, we have received no inquiry from any state with divestment initiatives; and, if any inquiry is received, we will address it with the relevant state but in any event, we do not believe that divestment would create a material impact on our investor base.

The agricultural and construction equipment products sold by CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries into Sudan are designed for use in the growth of food and other agricultural products and building and repair projects. The commercial vehicles sold in Sudan and Syria are used to transport goods and the engines sold in Sudan are used to build generators. CNH Industrial understands that certain of its agricultural and construction equipment and commercial vehicles sold by its foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries (through the distribution channels described in Response to Comment 1) may have been purchased by municipalities and state corporations as well as farms, cooperatives, businesses or other entities, some of which may be partially or wholly state-owned. The business relationship between such foreign subsidiaries and the independent distributor or importer would be governed by a sale and purchase agreement or comparable agreement between the applicable foreign subsidiary and the independent distributor or importer. Other than as set forth above, neither CNH Industrial nor any of its subsidiaries has any agreement or commercial arrangement with the government of any Subject Country or, to the best of CNH Industrial’s knowledge, any entity controlled by such government. To the best of CNH Industrial’s knowledge, none of the goods sold by its foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries has been used for any military purpose. For the foregoing reasons, CNH Industrial does not believe investors would reasonably consider sales by CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries to be qualitatively material or that such sales would have a negative impact on CNH Industrial’s reputation or share value.

If you require additional information or clarification with respect to CNH Industrial’s responses, or wish to discuss the responses further, please contact me at (630) 887-2233 or Michael P. Going at (630) 887-3766.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Jun 14, 2017, closing letter, 2017-07-13

Form 20-F

2014-08-22 to 2014-09-30 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2014-09-30
SegmentsRussia and UkraineRevenue
General
SEC asked (1)
You disclose on page 19 of the 20-F that your Agricultural Equipment segment sells equipment under the New Holland Agriculture brand and that your Commercial Vehicles segment sells vehicles under the Iveco brand. The New Holland Agriculture website provides addresses for distributors in Sudan and Syria. The Iveco website provides an address for a distributor in Cuba. Cuba, Sudan and Syria are designated by the U.S.
Rest of the question

Department of State as state sponsors of terrorism, and are subject to U.S. economic sanctions and export controls. Please describe to us the nature and extent of your past, current, and anticipated contacts with Cuba, Sudan and Syria, whether through subsidiaries, affiliates, distributors, partners, customers, joint ventures or other direct or indirect arrangements. You should describe any services, products, information or technology you have provided to Cuba, Sudan or Syria, directly or indirectly, and any agreements, commercial arrangements, or other contacts you have had with the governments of those countries or entities controlled by their governments.

CNH answered
CNH Industrial is incorporated in and under the laws of The Netherlands.

CNH Industrial has its corporate seat in Amsterdam, The Netherlands, and its corporate office in Basildon, United Kingdom. CNH Industrial is engaged in the design, production, marketing, sale and financing of agricultural and

Page construction equipment, trucks, commercial vehicles, buses and specialty vehicles for firefighting, defense and other uses, as well as engines and transmissions for those vehicles and engines for marine and power generation applications.
Rest of the answer

CNH Industrial has industrial and financial services subsidiaries located in 44 countries and a commercial presence in approximately 190 countries. CNH Industrial provides certain financial information by geographic area. CNH Industrial’s geographic regions are: (1) NAFTA; (2) EMEA; (3) LATAM; and (4) APAC. The geographic designations have the following meanings:

•

NAFTA—United States, Canada and Mexico;

EMEA—28 member countries of the European Union, member countries of the European Free Trade Association, Ukraine, Balkans, African continent and the Middle East (excluding Turkey);

LATAM—Central and South America, and the Caribbean Islands; and

APAC—Continental Asia (including Turkey and Russia), Oceania and member countries of the Commonwealth of Independent States (excluding Ukraine).

Cuba falls within the LATAM region and Sudan and Syria fall within the EMEA region (Cuba, Sudan and Syria are referred to collectively hereinafter as the

“Subject Countries”). Foreign (i.e. non-U.S.) subsidiaries of CNH Industrial are responsible for sales and marketing of CNH Industrial products in the EMEA, LATAM and APAC regions. Neither CNH Industrial nor any of its subsidiaries has offices or any company-owned locations in the Subject Countries.

U.S. law does not prohibit foreign companies from doing business with or in the

Subject Countries. CNH Industrial has an export management system, dedicated North American export compliance personnel, and a compliance program which includes appropriate training designed to ensure that all business activity relating to, among others, the Subject Countries is conducted in conformity with all applicable laws. The program includes policies and procedures to ensure that no U.S. personnel are involved in prohibited activity.

Certain of CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries sell agricultural equipment and parts under the New Holland brand to customers located in Sudan and

Syria and commercial vehicles under the Iveco brand to customers located in Cuba. The total consolidated sales by CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries over each of the last three years and the first six months of

2014 are approximately as follows:

Cuba:

2011:

$

11,121,965

2012:

12,706,819

2013:

17,480,476

20141:

2,066,550

2014 figures are for the period January 1, 2014 through June 30, 2014.

Sudan:

26,346,417

35,117,044

24,444,059

20142:

7,502,760

Syria:

21,156,748

747,162

894,597

20143:

1,119,515

Total consolidated sales by all of CNH Industrial foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries constituted approximately the following percentages of CNH Industrial’s total consolidated worldwide revenue for the relevant periods: 0.175% in 2011, 0.148% in 2012, 0.126% in 2013, and 0.065% in 2014 (through June 30).

The Iveco brand commercial vehicle products sold into Cuba during the period from January 1, 2011 through June 30, 2014 included the following:

light vehicles (3.5 – 6 ton) and extra heavy off-road (45 ton) trucks. The New Holland brand agricultural equipment sold into Sudan and Syria during the period from January 1, 2011 through June 30, 2014 included the following:

tractors, combines (and headers) and hay and forage equipment.

Subject to market and other economic conditions, CNH Industrial anticipates that its foreign subsidiaries will continue to conduct business in the Subject Countries at levels substantially consistent with its historical practice.

CNH

Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries sell agricultural equipment, commercial vehicles and parts for such equipment into the Subject Countries through different distribution channels. With respect to Cuba, CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries sold commercial vehicles and parts for such vehicles to one independent distributor/importer in 2011. With respect to Sudan, CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries only sell agricultural equipment and parts for such equipment to one or more independent distributors or an importer. Finally, with respect to Syria, CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries only sell agricultural equipment and parts for such equipment to one or more independent distributors. While CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries support the independent distributors located in the Subject Countries, no U.S. citizens employed by such CNH Industrial foreign subsidiaries have travelled to or provided support with respect to the independent distributors or other third parties located in the Subject Countries. Support of independent distributors in the Subject Countries generally includes sales and marketing and product support training, and providing sales and marketing and product support literature.

As a result of the foregoing, the names of such independent distributors and importers may be listed on web sites maintained by CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries, such as the websites of New Holland Agriculture and Iveco.

CNH Industrial is aware that certain of its New Holland brand agricultural equipment and Iveco brand commercial vehicles sold by its foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries (through the distribution channels described above) have been purchased by farms, cooperatives, businesses or other entities, some of which may be partially or wholly state-owned. In addition, in certain very limited cases, we believe that the applicable independent distributor or importer for the Subject Countries may be partially or wholly state-owned. The business relationship between such foreign subsidiaries and the independent distributor or importer is governed by a dealer/distributor agreement or comparable agreement between the applicable foreign subsidiary and the independent distributor or importer, with terms similar to those contained in the applicable foreign subsidiary’s standard dealer/distributor agreements. Other than as set forth above, neither CNH Industrial nor any of its subsidiaries has any agreement or commercial arrangement with the government of any Subject Country or, to the best of CNH Industrial’s knowledge, any entity controlled by such government.

Read in the reply
General
SEC asked (2)
Please discuss the materiality of your contacts with Cuba, Sudan and Syria described in response to the comment above, and whether those contacts constitute a material investment risk for your security holders. You should address materiality in quantitative terms, including the approximate dollar amounts of any associated revenues, assets, and liabilities for the last three fiscal years and the subsequent interim
Rest of the question

period. Also, address materiality in terms of qualitative factors that a reasonable investor would deem important in making an investment decision, including the potential impact of corporate activities upon a company’s reputation and share value. Various state and municipal governments, universities, and other investors have proposed or adopted divestment or similar initiatives regarding investment in companies that do business with U.S.- designated state sponsors of terrorism. You should address the potential impact of the investor sentiment evidenced by such actions directed toward companies that have operations associated with Cuba, Sudan and Syria.

CNH answered
Please note the sales figures and other information contained in the Response to Comment

1 above. As set forth above, CNH Industrial’s aggregate sales to the Subject Countries in each of the last three years and for the six months ended June 30, 2014, has represented not more than 0.175% of CNH Industrial’s total consolidated worldwide revenue for such periods, with the percentage declining over such periods.
Rest of the answer

CNH Industrial does not consider this level of activity with the Subject Countries to be quantitatively material.

CNH Industrial does not believe that its foreign subsidiaries’ sales into the Subject Countries should or would be regarded as qualitatively material by a reasonable investor in making an investment decision given the limited nature and extent of such sales. In addition, CNH Industrial believes that it conducts such sales in compliance with all applicable laws. Moreover, we discussed this matter with representatives of CNH Industrial’s Investor Relations function. The CNH Industrial Investor Relations function confirmed that, generally, institutional investors do not seem to consider CNH Industrial’s dealings in the Subject

Countries a material issue.

The commercial vehicles sold by the CNH Industrial foreign subsidiaries into Cuba are designed for transporting goods. The agricultural equipment products sold by the CNH Industrial foreign subsidiaries into Syria and Sudan are designed for use in the growth of food. CNH Industrial is aware that certain of its agricultural and commercial vehicles sold by its foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries (through the distribution channels described in Response to Comment 1) have been purchased by farms, cooperatives, businesses or other entities, some of which may be partially or wholly state-owned. In addition, in certain very limited cases, we believe that the applicable independent distributor or importer for the Subject Countries may be partially or wholly state-owned. The business relationship between such foreign subsidiaries and the independent distributor or importer would be governed by a dealer/distributor agreement or comparable agreement between the applicable foreign subsidiary and the independent distributor or importer, with terms similar to those contained in the applicable foreign subsidiary’s standard dealer/distributor agreements. Other than as set forth above, neither CNH Industrial nor any of its subsidiaries has any agreement or commercial arrangement with the government of any Subject Country or, to the best of CNH Industrial’s knowledge, any entity controlled by such government. To the best of CNH Industrial’s knowledge, none of the goods sold by its foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries has been used for any military purpose. For the foregoing reasons, CNH Industrial does not believe investors would reasonably consider sales by CNH Industrial’s foreign subsidiaries into the Subject Countries to be qualitatively material or that such sales would have a negative impact on CNH Industrial’s reputation or share value.

CNH Industrial acknowledges that the company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in its filing;

staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

If you require additional information or clarification with respect to CNH Industrial’s responses, or wish to discuss the responses further, please contact me at (630) 887-2233; Michael P. Going at (630) 887-3766 or Roberto Russo at +39 0110062393.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Sep 5, 2014, closing letter, 2014-09-30

Form F-4

2013-02-14 to 2013-06-03 · 102 questions · 4 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
No closing letter
Results discussion (MD&A)Risk factorsLiquidity and cashRevenueDebtLegal and contingenciesIncome taxesPensionsSegments
SEC letter of Feb 14, 2013 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
Fee Table
SEC asked (1)
We note from your prospectus that following the merger, persons who hold DutchCo common shares for at least three years may elect to receive special voting shares. As such, since it appears you contemplate an ongoing offer of the special voting shares, please confirm that you intend to maintain an effective registration statement for such offering.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Questions and Answers, page iv
SEC asked (2)
In the forepart of your document, please provide a clear presentation of the ownership structure of DutchCo after the completion of the merger, including the number of shares to be held by the current holders of Fiat Industrial shares and the number of shares to be held by the current holders of CNH shares.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

What is the Merger, page iv
SEC asked (3)
Please provide us with your analysis of the applicability of Rule 13e-3 to the transaction. In your response, please address the impact on your analysis of (1) the $10 dividend paid to the CNH shareholders, and (2) the offering of the special voting shares in connection with the transaction.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Will I have the right to elect to receive special voting shares, page v
SEC asked (4)
Please expand the question and answer section to clarify the extent to which the purpose of the special voting shares is to encourage Fiat Industrial’s controlling shareholder to approve the transaction, as indicated on page 57.
Rest of the question

In an appropriate section, please address in more detail the reasons for adopting the loyalty share program, addressing both (1) the “loyalty” portion of the plan and the reasons for encouraging long-term investment in the company, addressing any influence this structure might have on management, and (2) the multiple voting aspect of the plan.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Will I have the right to elect to receive special voting shares, page v
SEC asked (5)
It appears that if a portion of your minority investors either elect not to receive special voting shares in this transaction or later transfer their common shares, the voting power of Fiat Industrial’s controlling shareholder in the combined company may increase significantly; in this regard, we note your disclosure in the first bullet point on page 61 and the provisions of Article 12 of the Articles of Association
Rest of the question

filed as exhibit 3. Please revise to clarify the extent to which a shareholder may control greater than 50% of your voting power. Also, revise the appropriate section or sections of your document to provide disclosure discussing the anti-takeover effects of the special voting shares.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Will I have the right to elect to receive special voting shares, page v
SEC asked (6)
We note your disclosure on page vi that in the Netherlands additional voting power is “granted through a separate security.” Please explain to us in more detail the legal requirements and business considerations that led you to structure your additional voting power this way, citing the relevant authority. Also, we are aware of litigation relating to loyalty share programs in the Netherlands.
Rest of the question

Please tell us of any developments in the area and, if appropriate, provide disclosure of any associated risks.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

How do I vote my Fiat Industrial ordinary shares, page xi
SEC asked (7)
Please expand the disclosure in the forepart of your prospectus to clarify whether Fiat Industrial or CNH will mail materials to their shareholders that will enable them to exercise their voting rights, and provide us with any such materials. To the extent that voting materials will not be mailed to the shareholders of these companies, please revise to make this clear.
Rest of the question

Also, clarify whether you will mail the materials investors will need to submit in order to receive special voting shares, such as the initial election form; if you will not mail such materials, prominently disclose the steps investors will need to take to receive the special voting shares, including how they may obtain the necessary forms. Please provide us with copies of the materials.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Cautionary Statements, page 4
SEC asked (8)
Given that this transaction is the initial public offering of the registrant, please revise your disclosure to remove the implication that the safe harbor for forward looking statements applies to statements in connection with this offering. Refer to Exchange Act Section 21E(b)(1)(D). Also, you may not disclaim responsibility for your disclosure. Please revise the second to last paragraph on page 4 accordingly.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Merger Consideration, page 7
SEC asked (9)
We note your disclosure that the CNH shareholders will receive 3.828 DutchCo common shares as consideration in the merger. However, we note that your disclosure describing the recommendation of the special committee and the board of directors, as well as the financial analyses and fairness opinions provided by your financial advisors, includes the $10.00 cash dividend together with the 3.828 DutchCo common shares in
Rest of the question

the merger consideration. Please revise throughout your document as necessary to present the merger consideration to be received by CNH shareholders consistently.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions, page 7
SEC asked (10)
We see that a condition to the transaction was the delivery by Reconta Ernst & Young S.p.A. of a report with respect to the fairness of the Fiat Industrial exchange ratio. Please tell us how you considered the guidance in Regulation S-X Article 2-01 (b) and (c)(4)(iii) when obtaining and using an opinion with respect to the fairness of the Fiat Industrial exchange ratio from Reconta Ernst & Young S.p.A, the firm
Rest of the question

which is also your auditors. Discuss the factors you considered persuasive in concluding that this was appropriate.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions, page 7
SEC asked (11)
Please provide us with copies of the fairness reports discussed in the carryover paragraph starting at the bottom of page 7. Tell us how you have satisfied your disclosure obligations under Form F-4 Item 4(b) with respect to these reports, or revise.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Failure to timely complete the Merger, page 20
SEC asked (12)
Please tell us the extent of the agreements that may be triggered by the merger agreement that you reference on page 21, and describe more specifically the impact on your business and financial condition if you are unable to renegotiate the agreements. For instance, quantify the extent of the payments you will owe if you are unable to renegotiate the agreements.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Interests in the Transaction, page 37
SEC asked (13)
In an appropriate section or sections, please revise to quantify the material interests of CNH’s and Fiat Industrial’s affiliates on an aggregate and individual basis.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

The Merger, page 42
SEC asked (14)
When you discuss the prior offers from Fiat Industrial in this section please clarify the extent of the offer, including the proposed exchange ratio. Please also revise to discuss in greater detail how each of the final exchange ratios were determined and which party or parties proposed the final ratios.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

The Merger, page 42
SEC asked (15)
You refer to reports or opinions of outside parties throughout this section, such as the August 3 financial advisors’ analysis mentioned in the second paragraph on page 48 and the analysis referenced in the second paragraph on page 49. Please provide all disclosure required by Item 4(b) of Form F-4 for each of the reports or opinions.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

The Merger, page 42
SEC asked (16)
We note that management prepared CNH financial projections and forecasts that are related to the transaction. Please revise your registration statement to disclose these projections.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

The Merger, page 42
SEC asked (17)
We note the references on page 49 regarding the internal financial forecasts of Fiat Industrial provided to the Special Committee. Please revise your prospectus to disclose the financial projections of Fiat Industrial, or provide your analysis as to how you determined that these projections need not be disclosed.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Stable and Supportive Long-Term Shareholder Base, page 57
SEC asked (18)
With a view towards revised disclosure, please tell us any differences between the multiple voting mechanisms of the companies you have identified here and the structure of your special voting share program.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Opinion of J.P. Morgan to the Special Committee, page 61
SEC asked (19)
Please revise to disclose the fees paid by CNH to the financial advisors in the last two years.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Opinion of J.P. Morgan to the Special Committee, page 61
SEC asked (20)
Please provide us with copies of the materials prepared by J.P. Morgan and Lazard in connection with their fairness opinions, including, among other things, any “board books,” drafts of fairness opinions, and any summaries of presentations made to the board. Also, please provide us with the inadequacy opinion referenced on page 49 and the related materials.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Opinion of J.P. Morgan to the Special Committee, page 61
SEC asked (21)
We note that the exhibit index on page II-1 does not appear to reflect that you intend to file any materials prepared by your financial advisers. Please file the materials referenced in Item 21(c) of Form F-4 as exhibits to your registration statement and revise your exhibit index accordingly, or advise.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Recommendations of the CNH Special Committee, page 58
SEC asked (22)
With a view toward disclosure, please tell us the extent of the demerger liabilities to which the minority shareholders could be exposed referenced in the sixth bullet point on page 60.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Tax Consequences, page 77
SEC asked (23)
Here and throughout your document, as appropriate, please provide unequivocal disclosure regarding the tax consequences, rather than merely what the tax consequences may be “generally.” Also, if you are unable to provide unequivocal disclosure, you should disclose why, describing the degree of uncertainty and providing risk factor disclosure setting forth the risks to investors due to the uncertainty.
Rest of the question

For example, we note your disclosure in the penultimate paragraph on page 78 that “the IRS might assert that the CNH Dividend should be treated as additional consideration paid to the CNH shareholders in the CNH Merger.” To the extent the tax consequences would change in that event, please provide disclosure of the alternative tax treatment.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Material U.K. Tax Consequences, page 95
SEC asked (24)
Here or elsewhere, include discussion of the controlled foreign company rules discussed in your risk factor on page 24. Also, include a substantive discussion of the exemptions referenced in the last paragraph of that risk.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Italian tax consequences of the Merger on DutchCo, page 101
SEC asked (25)
Please revise your disclosure here or in the risk on page 25 to make clear whether you will be submitting a request to the Italian tax authorities for a tax ruling on any tax losses.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Environmental and other regulatory matters, page 153
SEC asked (26)
Include discussion of the labor laws and government incentives discussed in your risks on pages 27 and 29.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Management’s Discussion and Analysis, page 162 · Results of Operations, beginning on page 165
SEC asked (27)
We see that you have incurred restructuring charges in each of the periods presented. Please expand the discussions of the restructuring efforts to quantify the savings you expect to derive from the actions and to identify when you expect those savings will be realized. As applicable, also disclose whether the expected results of the restructuring plans were achieved. Please refer to “4.
Rest of the question

Disclosures” under SAB Topic 5-P.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Contractual Obligations, page 198
SEC asked (28)
Tell us why it is appropriate to exclude asset-backed financing liabilities from the body of the table of contractual obligations. In that regard, we note that those liabilities are included in your consolidated balance sheet prepared according to IFRS.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Contractual Obligations, page 198
SEC asked (29)
Please expand footnote (*) to explain why obligations for pensions, post-retirement benefits and uncertain tax positions have been excluded from the table of contractual obligations. Unless insignificant, please also quantify the amount related to uncertain tax positions excluded from the table.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Index to Financial Statements, page F-1
SEC asked (30)
Please update the financial statements when required by Item 8 of Form 20-F.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Consolidated Statement of Financial Position, page F-6
SEC asked (31)
Tell us why you believe it is appropriate in IFRS to present on the face of the balance sheet the alternative measures of total assets and of total equity and liabilities, both as adjusted to remove amounts related to asset-backed financing.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Consolidated Statement of Financial Position, page F-6
SEC asked (32)
Tell us why you do not present a line item for “total liabilities” on the face of the balance sheet.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Consolidated Statement of Cash Flow, page F-7
SEC asked (33)
Tell us why your indirect method presentation does not show the components of the changes in working capital. Refer to IAS 7.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Consolidated Statement of Cash Flow, page F-7
SEC asked (34)
Further, we see that changes in financing receivables and certain financial payables presented as investing or financing activities are presented on a net basis. Tell us how you evaluated the requirements of IAS 7 in determining that “net” basis presentation is appropriate.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Significant Accounting Policies, page F-11 · Revenue Recognition, page F-23
SEC asked (35)
We note that you recognize revenue on transactions with non-group dealers when vehicles are made available to those dealers and other criteria from your disclosure are met. Please further explain to us your revenue policies with respect to non-group dealers.
Rest of the question

In that regard, tell us how the risks and rewards of ownership have been transferred when goods have been “made available” to the purchaser other than through delivery. Tell us when title passes in these transactions.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Significant Accounting Policies, page F-11 · Revenue Recognition, page F-23
SEC asked (36)
Tell us when you apply construction contract accounting and describe the significance of this activity.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Significant Accounting Policies, page F-11 · Revenue Recognition, page F-23
SEC asked (37)
With respect to extended warranties and maintenance contracts, please disclose the method utilized in recognizing revenues over the lives of the arrangements.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Note (31) Segment reporting, page F-100
SEC asked (38)
We see that a significant amount of assets are attributed to “other operating segments.” Please clarify the nature of these other operating segments and the related assets.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Item 21. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules, page II-1 · Exhibits 23.1 through 23.4
SEC asked (39)
Please provide consents from your independent accountants with your first nonconfidential amendment filed in EDGAR. Afterward, to the extent there is a delay in requesting effectiveness of your registration statement, or there is any change, other than typographical, made to the financial statements, or there have been intervening events since the prior filing that are material to the company, please provide
Rest of the question

currently dated and signed consents from your independent accountants with subsequent amendments.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

The Relationship Between CNH and Fiat Industrial, page 213
SEC asked (40)
Please revise this table to reflect the conversion of the shares held by Fiat Netherlands to “common shares B” as disclosed on page 113. Also, when you provide a table showing the share ownership in the combined company, please ensure you reflect the special voting shares to be issued as part of this transaction.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Special Voting Shares, page 215
SEC asked (41)
We note your disclosure that the special voting shares are not transferable and that they have “minimal economic entitlements.” Please reconcile your disclosure regarding the transferability of the special voting shares with the provisions of Article 12 of your Articles of Association, which indicate that special voting shares may be transferred upon approval by the board of directors.
Rest of the question

Please also revise to clarify the nature of the economic entitlements and reconcile your disclosure with the provisions of Article 4, paragraph 7 and Article 12, paragraphs 4 and 5 of your Articles, which indicate there may be a cash value associated with the special voting shares and that the shares may be purchased. Finally, also clarify how Article 2:87 paragraph 2 of the Dutch Civil Code, referenced in Article 12, paragraph 5 of your Articles, operates to determine the price at which special voting shares may be purchased. Also, please revise throughout to disclose the terms and conditions reflected in exhibit A-2 to the merger agreement, including the covenants in section 7 and the “liquidated damages” provision in section 10.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Dutch Corporate Governance Code, page 223
SEC asked (42)
To the extent practicable, please consider expanding your discussion to include the list of Dutch Corporate Governance Code principles and best practice provisions.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Comparison of Rights, page 228
SEC asked (43)
Rather than merely reciting applicable law, please explain the effect of the differences between applicable laws and the differences between the articles of incorporation.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Enforcement of Civil Liabilities, page 251
SEC asked (44)
Include discussion of other material jurisdictions as necessary, for example, the United Kingdom.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Exhibits
SEC asked (45)
Please provide us with the missing attachments to the merger agreement. To the extent that you do not intend to file these attachments, please provide the list of omitted attachments required by Regulation S-K Item 601(b)(2).
Rest of the question

General If you intend to respond to these comments with an amended draft registration statement, please submit it and any associated correspondence in accordance with the guidance we provide in the Division’s October 11, 2012 announcement on the SEC website at http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cfannouncements/drsfilingprocedures101512.htm. Please keep in mind that we may publicly post filing review correspondence in accordance with our December 1, 2011 policy (http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cfannouncements/edgarcorrespondence.htm). If you intend to use Rule 83 (17 CFR 200.83) to request confidential treatment of information in the correspondence you submit on EDGAR, please properly mark that information in each of your confidential submissions to us so we do not repeat or refer to that information in our comment letters to you.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

SEC letter of Apr 4, 2013 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
What is the Merger, page iv
SEC asked (1)
We note your response to prior comment 3. As stated in Release No. 34-17719, and in Release No. 34-16075, which you cite in your response, all holders of the class of subject security must be on an equal footing and must be offered or receive the same form and amount of consideration.
Rest of the question

We understand that only certain holders of CNH common shares will be receiving special voting rights, and that not all holders of CNH common shares whose shares are purchased in the transaction will necessarily have received the CNH Dividend. Please address this in your Rule 13e-3 analysis.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

What is the Merger, page iv
SEC asked (2)
We note that Rule 13e-3(g)(2) applies to any transaction “in which security holders are offered or receive only an equity security.” Approval of the merger is assured, without the vote of any unaffiliated security holders of CNH, given that Fiat Industrial will cause CNH to vote in favor of the transaction.
Rest of the question

Fiat Industrial also committed itself, pursuant to the terms of the merger agreement, to cause CNH to declare and pay the CNH Dividend to unaffiliated security holders as consideration for the entry by CNH into the merger agreement. Thus, unaffiliated security holders of CNH will be receiving, in connection with the transaction and without any action on their part, a certain number of DutchCo common shares, plus the CNH Dividend in cash, in exchange for their current interest in CNH. The Rule 13e-3(g)(2) exception is not available when security holders receive consideration in the transaction consisting of a combination of cash and stock. Given these factors, please advise how you determined that Rule 13e-3 is not applicable to this transaction.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Will I have the right to elect to participate in the loyalty voting structure, page v
SEC asked (3)
Please expand your response to prior comment 5 to clarify how you determined that your shareholders will not be able to increase their voting interest by acquiring special voting shares, as indicated in the last sentence of your response, given the provisions in Article 12 of your articles of incorporation regarding the process for transfer of these shares.
Rest of the question

Please address how Article 12 relates to the provisions in Article 4 and to the transfer restrictions in Section 8. To the extent that the transfer provisions in Article 12 will not be available to shareholders, please revise the appropriate section or sections of the prospectus to make this explicit.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

How can I elect to participate in the loyalty voting structure, page vi
SEC asked (4)
We note your response to prior comment 7, and the declaration required in section 3(a) of the form included as appendix F. Please revise, here and where appropriate, to address the extent to which the terms in the special voting share terms and conditions conflict with the transfer provisions in Article 12 of your articles of incorporation.
Rest of the question

Also address how Article 12 impacts the agreement in section 3(b) of appendix F.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Merger Consideration, page 7
SEC asked (5)
We note your response to prior comment 9; however, it remains unclear how you determined that the cash dividend should not be presented as part of the transaction consideration given that the merger was conditioned on payment of the dividend and the dividend would not have been paid had the parties not entered into the merger.
Rest of the question

We also note your disclosure on page 79 that the IRS might assert that the dividend should be treated as additional consideration paid to the CNH shareholders in the CNH merger. Please advise. Please also revise the appropriate sections to highlight the fact that the aggregate consideration of Dutchco shares together with the cash dividend serves the basis for the fairness opinions of the financial advisors. Finally, where you present the amount of consideration to be received in the merger, revise to state that unaffiliated CNH holders who purchased subsequent to the cash dividend record date will receive merger consideration that, in the opinion of your financial advisors, is inadequate.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions, page 7
SEC asked (6)
We refer to your response to our prior comment 10. Please confirm that you will include in your filing the Fairness Opinion and related consent from Reconta Ernst & Young. For guidance, refer to the last sentence of the second-to-last paragraph of the letter dated August 24, 2000 from the Office of the Chief Accountant.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Conditions, page 7
SEC asked (7)
Please expand your response to prior comment 11 to address how you determined that the fairness reports you reference in your response are not reports, opinions or appraisals within the meaning of Form F-4 Item 4(b) and Item 1015 of Regulation M-A, citing all authority upon which you rely.
Rest of the question

Specifically address the fact that the transaction was conditioned on the receipt of the reports, that the reports relate to the consideration to be received in the transaction, and that the reports are referenced in the agreement that is included in the prospectus. Alternatively, revise to provide the disclosure required by Form F-4 Item 4(b) with respect to these reports.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

The Merger, page 43
SEC asked (8)
Please expand your response to prior comment 15 to clarify how you determined the analysis referenced in the last sentence of your response “is not relevant to investors,” or revise your disclosure accordingly. Also, please explain in detail how you determined that the analyses presented prior to October 12, 2012 would be largely duplicative of the analyses described on pages 63 through 76 of the document given the
Rest of the question

different transaction under consideration and the different conclusion regarding the fairness of the transaction reached in the opinion referenced in the sixth paragraph on page 50. Alternatively, revise your disclosure accordingly.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

The Merger, page 43
SEC asked (9)
We note your response to prior comment 16. Given that, as you disclose on page 70, the CNH management projections were utilized in the discounted cash flow analysis, that the analysis is described in the prospectus, and that you discuss on page 71 the per share range of implied value based on management’s projections, these projections should be disclosed.
Rest of the question

Please also disclose the reasons for the differences between management’s projections and those based on public information that the financial advisors relied upon in performing the discounted cash flow analysis. Also disclose why the Special Committee directed the advisors to use only independent analysts’ projections in rendering their opinions. Finally, to the extent that the projections differ from actual results as indicated in your response to prior comment 17, the projections should be presented in a format that will facilitate analysis of the reasons for differences between actual and forecast results. Please revise accordingly, or advise.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

The Merger, page 43
SEC asked (10)
We note your response to prior comment 17. Given, in part, that the shareholders of Fiat Industrial and CNH will receive stock consideration in the transaction and the disclosure that the financial advisors utilized the Fiat Industrial management projections when preparing the analysis discussed in the first full paragraph on page 74, the Fiat Industrial management projections should be disclosed. Please revise.
Rest of the question

To the extent that the projections differ from actual results as indicated in your response, the projections should be presented in a format that will facilitate analysis of the reasons for differences between actual and forecast results. You should also revise your Management’s Discussion and Analysis and any other appropriate section or sections of your document to address the basis for any change in operating trends that resulted in the differences between the actual and forecast results.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Opinions of the Financial Advisors, page 63
SEC asked (11)
Please expand your response to prior comment 21 to address specifically the reports referenced in your response to prior comment 11 and the materials referenced in your response to prior comment 20, including the inadequacy opinions.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Tax Consequences, page 78
SEC asked (12)
Please expand your response to prior comment 23 to clarify why you are not able to provide an opinion addressing the treatment of the CNH dividend, and to discuss the risks to investors of the different tax consequences addressed in the second to last paragraph on page 79.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Loyalty Voting Structure, page 208
SEC asked (13)
Please expand your response to prior comment 41 to disclose the specific covenants that might lead to the breach compensation payment discussed on page 210. Discuss in more detail how these payments will be enforced. Also, address the extent to which shareholders could be liable after following the transfer provisions in Article 12 of your articles of incorporation.
CNH answered

No reply letter found.

Enforcement of Civil Liabilities, page 243
SEC asked (14)
Please make clear whether shareholders may originate actions in Italy based upon U.S. securities laws. General If you intend to respond to these comments with an amended draft registration statement, please submit it and any associated correspondence in accordance with the guidance we provide in the Division’s October 11, 2012 announcement on the SEC website at
Rest of the question

http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cfannouncements/drsfilingprocedures101512.htm.

CNH answered

No reply letter found.

General
SEC asked (1)
We note that you have not yet filed a Schedule 13E-3. We may have further comment upon reviewing that filing.
CNH answered
On behalf of FI CBM Holdings N.V. (“DutchCo”), we are writing in connection with the above-referenced registration statement on Form F-4 that was filed on May 14, 2013 (the “Registration Statement”). On that date, DutchCo, Fiat Industrial S.p.A. (“Fiat Industrial”), CNH Global NV (“CNH”), and Exor S.p.A. (“Exor”) filed a transaction statement on Schedule 13E-3 (the “Schedule 13E-3”) with respect to the Merger described in the Registration Statement. In the course of telephone conversations regarding the Registration Statement, the Staff asked DutchCo to consider whether Fiat S.p.A. (“Fiat”) should be a “filing person” of the Schedule 13E-3 and we are writing in response to that question.
Rest of the letter

DutchCo does not believe that Fiat is an “affiliate engaging in a Rule 13E-3 transaction” within the meaning of Rule 13e-3 and, therefore, does not believe that Fiat is required to be a filing person of the Schedule 13E-3. Fiat did not initiate, instigate, or participate in, any of the contacts or negotiations with CNH or with the Special Committee, and was not involved in any capacity in the process leading to the Merger Agreement or the other transactions between Fiat Industrial and CNH described in the Registration Statement. Although - the Chairman of Fiat Industrial, who is also chief executive officer of Fiat, actively participated in the process leading to the Merger, as described in the Registration Statement, he did so exclusively in his capacity as Chairman of Fiat Industrial and not in any capacity on behalf of Fiat. Fiat is not a party to any agreement with respect to the Merger or the vote of Fiat Industrial shareholders to approve the Merger. Fiat will not receive any benefit from the transaction other than in its capacity as a holder of approximately 2.7% of the outstanding shares in Fiat Industrial (as described below). Furthermore, DutchCo does not believe that Fiat controls Fiat Industrial. While prior to December 31, 2010, the businesses now comprising Fiat Industrial were part of Fiat, effective January 1, 2011, Fiat completed a “demerger” of the Fiat Industrial business pursuant to Italian law by (1) transferring direct and indirect shareholdings in CNH, Iveco, FPT Industrial and other assets and liabilities to Fiat Industrial and (2) distributing to its shareholders one share of Fiat Industrial for each share of the corresponding class held in Fiat. As a result, Fiat owns no shareholding interest in Fiat Industrial or its subsidiaries, other than the shares of Fiat Industrial that Fiat received pursuant to the demerger in connection with Fiat’s holding of treasury shares (and therefore itself being a “shareholder” of Fiat under Italian law) as of the record date of the demerger. Fiat Industrial shares held by Fiat represent approximately 2.7% of Fiat Industrial’s share capital and continue to be held by Fiat principally for the purposes of servicing existing share incentive plans. Fiat is not a party to any shareholders agreement relating to the exercise of voting rights in Fiat Industrial. There are no contractual arrangements giving Fiat, directly or indirectly, the power to direct or cause the direction of the management or policies of CNH.1 Furthermore, other than the Chairman of Fiat Industrial who is also the chief executive officer of Fiat, Fiat Industrial and Fiat share only one Board member in common (out of, respectively, nine and eleven Board members) and Fiat Industrial is aware of no meaningful overlap in shareholders other than Exor. Although Fiat is not required to be a filing person of the Schedule 13E-3, nevertheless Fiat may be deemed to be an affiliate of CNH in light of the fact that Exor is the largest shareholder of each of Fiat and Fiat Industrial. Exor owns approximately 30% of the share capital of each company and representatives of Exor are members of the Board of Directors of each company. Information required by Schedule 13E-3 regarding Fiat as an The most significant contractual relationship between Fiat and Fiat Industrial is a master services agreement setting forth the primary terms and conditions pursuant to which the various service provider subsidiaries of Fiat and Fiat Industrial provide services (such as purchasing, invoicing and other back office accounting services, security and training) to the various service receiving subsidiaries. Those agreements are referred to in the Registration Statement under “Major Shareholders of Fiat Industrial and CNH – Relationship Between CNH and Fiat Industrial”. For further information regarding CNH’s relationships and transactions with Fiat and Fiat Industrial see “Note 21: Related Party Information” in CNH’s consolidated financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2012 included in the Annual Report on Form 20-F of CNH incorporated by reference in the Registration Statement. affiliate of CNH is either included in the Registration Statement and Schedule 13E-3 filed on May 14, 2013 or will be included in amendments thereto. Any questions or comments with respect to the Registration Statement and this letter may be communicated to the undersigned at (212) 558-3109 or by email ([email protected]). Please send copies of any correspondence relating to this filing to the undersigned by email and facsimile (212-291-9101) with the original by mail to Sullivan & Cromwell LLP, 125 Broad Street, New York, New York 10004.

One letter for all the questions, without numbered answers. Read the reply
General
SEC asked (2)
Please make the disclosures required by the following sections of Regulation M-A:
CNH answered

See the reply above.

 Item 1014(e), with respect to CNH ·  Item 1015(b)(4), with respect to Goldman Sachs, including fee information
SEC asked (3)
Please remove all references to “arm’s length” negotiations with respect to the Rule 13e-3 transaction. These references are inappropriate in a transaction with affiliates.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Will I have the right, page v
SEC asked (4)
We note your response to prior comment 3. Please expand your disclosure in the forepart of your document and where appropriate to highlight (1) the extent to which minority shareholders will be prohibited from transferring their special voting shares despite the provisions in Article 12, and (2) the extent to which the provisions restricting a shareholder from obtaining majority voting control by acquiring
Rest of the question

additional special voting shares are contractual provisions in the terms and conditions of the special voting shares, rather than provisions within your governing documents that would require shareholder approval to amend. Given the difference in how each document governing the special voting shares can be changed, also add appropriate risk factor disclosure. Also, revise to clarify the extent to which there is any uncertainty as to the priority of Article 12 and Section 8 under Dutch law, or advise. To the extent uncertainty exists in the interpretation of these provisions that you have described in your response, add appropriate risk factor disclosure.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

How can I elect, page vi
SEC asked (5)
We note your response to prior comment 4. Please highlight, here and where appropriate, the extent to which shareholders will agree to forgo the provisions for transfer of their special voting shares reflected in your articles of association by making the declaration in section 3(a) of the form included as appendix F.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

As a CNH shareholder, will I receive fractional interests in DutchCo…?, page vii
SEC asked (6)
We note that security holders will receive cash consideration of an indeterminate amount corresponding to a fractional entitlement to DutchCo common shares. Please tell us how you determined that this is consistent with Item 1004(a)(2)(ii) of Regulation M-A, which requires disclosure of the consideration offered to security holders.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Background to the Merger, page 17
SEC asked (7)
We note your response to comment 8 from our letter dated April 4, 2013 and the disclosure added to pages 24 and 48. Please revise to provide the disclosure required by Item 1015(b)(6) of Regulation M-A with respect to the preliminary analyses presented by J.P. Morgan and Lazard referenced in your response, or advise. Refer to Item 9 of Schedule 13E-3.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Background to the Merger, page 17
SEC asked (8)
Please revise to provide the disclosure required by Item 1015(b)(6) of Regulation M-A with respect to the analyses presented by Goldman Sachs on October 31, 2012. This presentation contains several financial analyses which appear material to security holders.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Background to the Merger, page 17
SEC asked (9)
We note that preliminary projections were provided to the Special Committee on September 24, 2012. Please disclose these projections, or confirm that they have already been disclosed in full. All financial projections that management has access to in connection with a going-private transaction must be disclosed to security holders.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Position of Fiat Industrial and DutchCo, page 34
SEC asked (10)
Please tell us what consideration was given as to whether Exor should be included as a “filing person” on the Schedule 13E-3. To the extent that you do not believe that Exor should be added as a filing person, please provide us with your legal analysis supporting that conclusion.
Rest of the question

Otherwise, please include Exor on your Schedule 13E-3 and revise your document to include all of the disclosure required of Exor under Schedule 13E-3.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

Position of Fiat Industrial and DutchCo, page 34
SEC asked (11)
Please disclose the filing persons’ substantive and procedural fairness determinations with respect to unaffiliated security holders, rather than to “CNH’s minority shareholders.” See Item 1014(a) of Regulation M-A.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Position of Fiat Industrial and DutchCo, page 34
SEC asked (12)
Refer to the last bullet point on page 34 and the first bullet point on page 35. Please revise, here and in the recommendation section starting on page 37, to address how the filing persons considered the fairness of the transaction with respect to the unaffiliated security holders that purchased shares after the December 28, 2012 cash dividend.
Rest of the question

If they did not consider the fairness of the transaction to this group of shareholders, please revise to so state.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

Position of Fiat Industrial and DutchCo, page 34
SEC asked (13)
We note the reference to the fairness opinions dated November 25, 2012 in the third bullet point on page 35 and the first bullet point on page 36. Please expand your disclosure, here and in the recommendation section starting on page 37, to address how the filing persons considered the opinions filed as exhibits 99.12 and 99.13. Refer to Regulation M-A Item 1014 Instruction 2(vii).
Rest of the question

Also, tell us how you determined that further disclosure regarding the consideration of the reports to be filed as exhibits 99.3 and 99.4 is not required, or revise.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

Position of Fiat Industrial and DutchCo, page 34
SEC asked (14)
We note disclosure on page 36 stating that the filing persons did not consider net book value as a factor in their fairness determinations, despite Instruction 2(iii) to Item 1014. Please disclose the net book value here.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Recommendation of the CNH Special Committee, page 37
SEC asked (15)
Please revise, here and where appropriate, to expressly disclose whether each filing person, including the CNH board of directors, reasonably believes that the transaction is substantively and procedurally fair to unaffiliated security holders.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Recommendation of the CNH Special Committee, page 37
SEC asked (16)
To the extent the CNH board’s discussion and analysis does not address each of the factors listed in Instruction 2 to Item 1014 of Regulation M-A, the board must discuss the unaddressed factors in reasonable detail or explain why the factors were not deemed material or relevant.
Rest of the question

We note for example that the analysis of the board of directors does not appear to address the factors described in clauses (i) – (vi) of Instruction 2 to Item 1014. Please revise. To the extent the board has based its fairness determination on the analysis undertaken by others, the board must expressly adopt this analysis and discussion as its own in order to satisfy the disclosure obligations of Item 1014.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

Opinion of J.P. Morgan to the Special Committee, page 40
SEC asked (17)
Please disclose the fees paid to J.P. Morgan or its affiliates by CNH or its affiliates within the past two years. We note in particular the joint bookrunning by J.P. Morgan affiliates described on page 43.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Summary of Joint Financial Analyses of J.P. Morgan and Lazard , page 46
SEC asked (18)
With respect to the results of each analysis, disclose where in the specified range the merger consideration fell.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exchange Ratio Analysis, page 54
SEC asked (19)
Please enhance your discussion of the meaning and significance of this analysis.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Directors and Executive Officers of Fiat Industrial, page 171
SEC asked (20)
Please include Fiat in the representations appearing in the final paragraph of this section. See Item 1003(b) of Regulation M-A.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Directors and Executive Officers of Fiat Industrial, page 171
SEC asked (21)
Please include a similar section disclosing the information required by Item 1003(c) of Regulation M-A with respect to Instruction C persons of CNH.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Information relating to the purchase of CNH shares in the past two years, page 223
SEC asked (22)
Please confirm that Fiat has not purchased any CNH shares in the past two years, or provide the disclosure required by Item 1002(f) of Regulation M-A.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Recent transactions in CNH Common Shares, page 223
SEC asked (23)
Please include directors, executive officers and Instruction C persons of Fiat in the table appearing on page 224.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Loyalty Voting Structure, page 230
SEC asked (24)
Please revise to disclose the substance of your response to our prior comment 13.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Appendix B – Opinion of J.P. Morgan Securities LLC
SEC asked (25)
The final paragraph of this opinion states that it is furnished “solely for benefit of the Special Committee.” This limitation is inconsistent with the disclosures relating to the fairness opinion. Please delete the term “solely.” Alternatively, if you retain this limitation, disclose the basis for the financial advisor's belief that shareholders cannot rely upon the opinion including (but not limited to) whether
Rest of the question

the financial advisor intends to assert the substance of the disclaimer as a defense to shareholder claims that might be brought against it under applicable local law. Describe whether applicable local law has addressed the availability of such a defense to the financial advisor in connection with any such shareholder claim; if not, a statement must be added that the issue necessarily would have to be resolved by a court of competent jurisdiction. Also disclose that the availability or non-availability of such a defense will have no effect on the rights and responsibilities of the board of directors under governing local law or the rights and responsibilities of either the financial advisor or the board of directors under the federal securities laws. Refer to Section II.D.1 of the Current Issues and Rulemaking Projects Outline (November 14, 2000). If you intend to respond to these comments with an amended draft registration statement, please submit it and any associated correspondence in accordance with the guidance we provide in the Division’s October 11, 2012 announcement on the SEC website at http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cfannouncements/drsfilingprocedures101512.htm.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

SEC asked (1)
Please revise to provide the information required by Instruction C to Schedule 13E-3 with respect to each person controlling Exor and/or each executive officer and director of any corporation or other person ultimately in control of Exor.
CNH answered
On behalf of FI CBM Holdings N.V. (“DutchCo”), we are writing in connection with the above-referenced registration statement on Form F-4 that was filed on May 28, 2013 (the In the course of a telephone conversation regarding the Registration Statement on May 31, 2013, the Staff asked DutchCo to provide an expanded analysis of whether the inclusion in the prospectus of a risk factor relating to the transfer restrictions provisions of the special voting shares would be appropriate; further, the Staff reiterated its request that any statement relating to the legal interpretation of those provisions be attributed to counsel and that, consequently, the consent of such counsel be filed as an
Rest of the letter

exhibit to the Registration Statement. In response to comment 3 in the Staff comment letter dated May 24, 2013, reiterated by the Staff in the conversation referred to above, DutchCo proposes to amend the disclosure on page 263 of the Registration Statement to include the following statement: “Based on the advice of its Dutch counsel, Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP, DutchCo does not believe there to be any meaningful uncertainty regarding the interpretation and expected operation of Article 12 of the Articles of Association and Section 8 of the terms and conditions of Securities and Exchange Commission the special shares, also taking into account the provisions of Article 4 of the Articles of Association and the remainder of the contractual provisions included in the terms and conditions of the special voting shares”. The consent of Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP to the inclusion of such statement will be filed as an exhibit to the Registration Statement. DutchCo does not believe that it would be appropriate to include in the prospectus a risk factor relating to the interpretation of those provisions, for the several reasons discussed below. DutchCo recognizes that if the transfer restriction provisions of the special voting shares proved ineffective, this would lead to unintended results and potentially allow the transfer of influence or (if enough voting rights were transferred) control over DutchCo to a person not acquiring any economic interest in DutchCo. However, DutchCo does not believe there to be any risk of such event occurring. No shareholder other than a Qualifying Shareholder (i.e. a holder of Qualifying Common Shares) can hold a special voting share; and A Qualifying Shareholder may only hold one special voting share for each Qualifying Common Share held Accordingly, based on that provision of the Articles of Association alone, no transfer of special voting shares allowing the transferee to exercise additional voting rights may occur (other than in the very limited circumstances in which such acquisition is permitted under the Articles of Association in conjunction with the acquisition of the associated common shares). DutchCo will, for the avoidance of any doubts, amend Article 12 of the Articles of Association to state explicitly that the transfer provisions described therein are subject to the restrictions of Article 4.2. Furthermore, Article 4.4 and Article 4.5 of the Articles of Association provide that if a holder of special voting shares transfers any associated common shares, all rights pertaining to the special voting shares are immediately suspended. 2 Article 4.2 of the DutchCo Articles of Association states: “Special voting shares may only be held by a Qualifying Shareholder and the company itself. A Qualifying Shareholder may hold one (1) special voting share for each Qualifying Common Share held by such shareholder.” Article 4.4 of the DutchCo Articles of Association states: “In the event of a Change of Control in respect of a Qualifying Shareholder or in the event that a Qualifying Shareholder requests that some or all of its Qualifying Common Shares be de-registered from the Loyalty Register, as referred to in Article 10 paragraph 3, or transfers some or all of its Qualifying Common Shares to any other party (other than a Loyalty Transferee): As a result of those provisions, under the Articles of Association of DutchCo: No person may hold a special voting share other than in conjunction with holding a Qualifying Common Share; and If a holder transfers a Qualifying Common Share, any rights of the associated special voting share are suspended immediately. In addition to the provisions of the Articles of Association referred to above, the terms and conditions of the special voting shares contractually prohibit any transfer of special voting shares (other than in the very limited circumstances in which such acquisition is permitted under the Articles of Association in conjunction with the acquisition of the associated common shares) and impose on any holder of special voting shares the obligation to transfer its special voting shares to DutchCo for no consideration upon a transfer of the associated common shares. Furthermore, the terms and conditions of the special voting shares impose a penalty on any shareholder attempting to breach its obligations under or otherwise violating the terms of the special voting shares terms and conditions. As set forth in our letter dated April 22, 2013, DutchCo submits that the restrictions of Section 8 of the special voting shares terms and conditions are binding on the holder of special voting shares and on the Board of Directors of DutchCo. However, whilst the transfer restrictions included in the terms and conditions of the special voting shares are intended a. such shareholder shall be obliged to immediately offer all such special voting shares to the company; and b. any and all voting rights attached to the special voting shares issued and allocated to such Qualifying Shareholder in respect of such Qualifying Common Shares, will be suspended with immediate effect.” Article 4.5 of the DutchCo Articles of Association states: “In the event a Qualifying Shareholder does no longer qualify as a Qualifying Shareholder: a. any and all voting rights attached to the special voting shares issued and allocated to such Qualifying Shareholder in respect of such Qualifying Common Shares, will be suspended with immediate effect; and b. such shareholder shall be obliged to immediately offer all such special voting shares to the company.” to provide additional clarity, more detailed mechanics and administrative convenience to the functioning of the loyalty voting mechanism, they are not necessary to achieve the objective of making the special voting shares non-transferrable. Accordingly, even disregarding the terms and conditions of the special voting shares, DutchCo submits that under the Articles of Association of DutchCo no person may validly acquire special voting shares from another holder (other than in the limited circumstances described in the prospectus). It would be incorrect to suggest to investors that any doubt or risk exists with respect to this question. Any questions or comments with respect to the Registration Statement and this letter may be communicated to the undersigned at (212) 558-3109 or by email ([email protected]). Please send copies of any correspondence relating to this filing to the undersigned by email and facsimile (212-291-9101) with the original by mail to Sullivan & Cromwell LLP, 125 Broad Street, New York, New York 10004.

One letter for all the questions, without numbered answers. Read the reply
SEC asked (2)
We note your supplemental letter dated May 20, 2013 regarding the consideration given to whether Fiat S.p.A. should be a “filing person” on the Schedule 13E-3 and your statement that Fiat S.p.A. “may be deemed to be an affiliate” of CNH given the common control by Exor. Please provide an expanded analysis as to why Fiat S.p.A. is not “engaged in” the transaction in light of the positions held by Mr.
Rest of the question

Marchionne as Chairman of Fiat Industrial and Chief Executive Officer of Fiat S.p.A., the agreements noted in your letter and described on pages 240 – 241, and the greater than 2.7% stock ownership that Fiat S.p.A. holds in CNH Global.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

Will I have the right, page v
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to prior comment 4 regarding the advice of your Dutch counsel with respect to the inter-relation of Article 12 and Section 8. Please provide us with your analysis as to how you determined that you are not required to attribute this statement to your counsel in your registration statement, filing the necessary consent, or revise.
Rest of the question

For guidance, please refer to the last paragraph of CD&I 233.02 of Securities Act Rules. Also, please expand your response to clarify whether the provision for amending the terms and conditions of the special voting shares requires shareholder approval before any amendment, or whether it requires shareholder ratification of such amendment after the terms have been amended.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

Recommendation of the CNH Special Committee, page 39
SEC asked (4)
We note your revised disclosure on page 40 in response to prior comment 16 indicating that the Special Committee and the Board of Directors considered the current and historical market prices as factors in determining the fairness of the transaction. Please expand to quantify the specific prices used and discuss how they related to the consideration being offered.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Preliminary Financial Analyses, page 58
SEC asked (5)
We note your revisions in response to prior comment 7 with respect to the October 9, 2012 presentation discussed on pages 59 – 60. In particular, we note that the low end of the per share range for most of the analyses presented on that date is significantly higher than the implied per share value of the consideration to be received in the merger, and the low end of the exchange ratios similarly exceeds the exchange
Rest of the question

ratio provided in the merger agreement. Please expand your discussion to disclose the reason for the difference between the results of the analyses and the consideration to be received in the merger. Please also advise, with a view towards revised disclosure, whether the Special Committee and the Board of Directors gave these figures any consideration.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

Preliminary Financial Analyses, page 58
SEC asked (6)
The November 20, 2012 presentation of J.P. Morgan and Lazard indicates on slide 3 that several matters of substance were discussed between October 25th through November 19th, but these matters do not appear to be reflected in the background section. Please revise or advise.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

The CNH Exchange Ratio Report, page 143
SEC asked (7)
Please explain why Mazars Paardekooper Hoffman N.V. is not identified in exhibit 99.3 given the discussion here and the information in the exhibit index on page II-2.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Information relating to directors and executive officers of CNH, page 237
SEC asked (8)
You are providing the information required by Item 1003(c) of Regulation M-A with respect to the executive officers and directors of CNH by incorporating by reference to your Form 20-F. Please cite the authority for providing this information in your goingprivate disclosure document in this manner, or revise your disclosure document to include the information.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Information relating to directors and executive officers of CNH, page 237
SEC asked (9)
Please disclose in your proxy statement the information regarding Exor specified in Item 1003(b) of Regulation M-A, or direct us to where this information appears.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibits, page II-2
SEC asked (10)
We note the reference in your legal opinion to a deed of incorporation. Please file the deed as an exhibit or tell us why it is not required to be filed.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (11)
We note that many of the documents identified in section 2 of the opinion are dated. Please tell us how counsel determined that the documents that it reviewed were the most recent versions of the documents as of the date the opinion was filed.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (12)
Please tell us why the limitation of the opinion to the execution of the documents referenced in paragraphs 2(i) and 2(j) is necessary and appropriate, or file a revised opinion that does not contain this limitation.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (13)
Please tell us how paragraph 3(k) and paragraph 4 of the opinion are consistent with the guidance regarding limitations on reliance in section II.B.3.d of Staff Legal Bulletin No. 19 (CF) (Oct. 14, 2011), or file a revised opinion.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (14)
Given the confirmation referenced in paragraph 2(c) of the opinion, please tell us why the assumption in paragraph (e) of Schedule 1 is necessary and appropriate, or file a revised opinion that omits the assumption in paragraph (e) of Schedule 1.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (15)
Please tell us why the assumptions in paragraphs (d) and (f) of Schedule 1 are appropriate, given that they appear to reflect necessary requirements of the conclusions in paragraph 4 of the opinion. Alternatively, file a revised opinion without these assumptions.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (16)
Please tell us how the qualification relating to insolvency proceedings in paragraph (a) of Schedule 2 is consistent with section II.B.3.a of Staff Legal Bulletin No. 19, or file a revised opinion.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (17)
Please explain how the provisions of Section 2:81 of the Dutch Civil Code address whether shareholders can be required to pay an amount in addition to the amount required for such share to be fully paid. Please also confirm whether Section 2:81 addresses whether shareholders may become liable for assessments or calls on the security by persons other than the issuer.
Rest of the question

If not, please file a revised opinion that also addresses whether a shareholder may become liable for assessments or calls on the security by the registrant or its creditors.

CNH answered

See the reply above.

Exhibit 8.1
SEC asked (18)
Please file an opinion that states clearly that the disclosure in the applicable section of the prospectus constitutes the opinion of counsel, rather than simply stating that the statements contained in the disclosure are “true and accurate and provide a fair and complete summary” of the tax consequences. Please also apply this comment to Exhibits 8.2 and 8.3.
CNH answered

See the reply above.

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 26 letters filed since 2013-02-14. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/CNH/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.