Comment 2A: In future filings, the Corporation will revise its descriptions of Refinery gross margin, Renewables gross margin and Marketing gross margin to “Adjusted refinery gross margin,” “Adjusted renewables gross margin” and “Adjusted marketing gross margin,” respectively, to help avoid confusion with the
measure “gross margin.” The Corporation plans to describe Refining segment net operating margin and Renewable segment net operating margin as “Adjusted refinery gross margin, less operating expenses” and “Adjusted renewables gross margin, less operating expenses,”
Rest of the answer
respectively. Each of these non-GAAP measures may also be presented per produced barrel or per produced gallon. Please see the below revised descriptions and reconciliations as an example of these changes.
Response to Comment 2B: The Corporation respectfully acknowledges the
Staff’s comment. The Corporation considers segment gross margin as the most directly comparable GAAP measure for each of Refinery gross margin and Refining segment net operating margin per produced barrel sold, Renewables gross margin and
Renewables segment net operating margin per produced gallon sold, and Marketing gross margin per gallon sold. The Corporation has considered Item 10(e)(1)(i) of Regulation S-K and plans to revise its presentation of these financial measures going forward to clarify that the most directly comparable GAAP measure is segment gross margin and present its reconciliations of the newly renamed non-GAAP measures of:
•
Adjusted refinery gross margin and Adjusted refinery gross margin per produced barrel sold,
Adjusted refinery gross margin, less operating expenses, per produced barrel sold,
Adjusted renewables gross margin and Adjusted renewables gross margin, per produced gallon sold,
Adjusted renewables gross margin, less operating expenses per produced gallon sold, and
Adjusted marketing gross margin and Adjusted marketing gross margin per gallon sold to reconcile from segment gross margin and to present segment gross margin per produced barrel or gallon sold, beginning with our Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ending June 30, 2024.
Illustrations of our revised descriptions and reconciliations of these non-GAAP measures for the year ended December 31, 2023 are shown below. The revisions are marked with underlines to facilitate the Staff’s review. We have also revised the titles of these non-GAAP measures as described in Comment 2A above.
Reconciliations of refinery operating information (non-GAAP performance measures) to amounts reported under generally accepted accounting principles in financial statements.
RefineryAdjusted refinery gross margin and net operating margin are is a non-GAAP performance measures that are is used by our management and others to compare our refining performance to that of other companies in our industry. We believe these this margin measures are measure is helpful to investors in evaluating our refining performance on a relative and absolute basis, including against publicly available crack spread data. RefineryAdjusted refinery gross margin per produced barrel sold is total Refining segment revenues less total Refining segment cost of products sold, exclusive of gross margin plus lower of cost or market inventory valuation adjustments, depreciation and amortization and operating expenses, divided by sales volumes of produced refined products sold. Net operating margin per barrel sold is the difference between refinery gross margin and refinery operating expenses per produced barrel sold. These two margins do This margin measure does not include the non-cash effects of lower of cost or market inventory valuation adjustments and depreciation and amortization. Each of these component performance measures can be reconciled directly to our consolidated statements of income, which relate to volumes in inventory at the end of the period. Adjusted refinery gross margin is not a calculation provided for under US GAAP and should not be considered in isolation or as a substitute for Refining segment gross margin. The GAAP measure most directly comparable to Adjusted refinery gross margin is Refining segment gross margin. Other companies in our industry may not calculate these performance measures in the same manner.
Reconciliation of Refining segment gross margin to Adjusted refinery gross margin to Adjusted refinery gross margin per produced barrel sold and Adjusted refinery gross margin, less operating expenses per produced barrel sold
Three Months Ended March 31,
2024
2023
(In thousands, except per barrel amounts)
Refining segment
Sales and other revenues
$
6,204,245
6,718,615
Cost of products sold (exclusive of lower of cost or market inventory adjustment)
5,474,522
5,641,131
Lower of cost or market inventory adjustment
(220,558
)
—
Operating expenses
472,086
501,759
Depreciation and amortization
117,370
100,083
Gross margin
360,825
475,642
Add (subtract) lower of cost or market inventory adjustment
Add operating expenses
Add depreciation and amortization
Adjusted refinery gross margin
729,723
1,077,484
Produced barrels sold (BPD)
631,470
515,960
Gross margin per produced barrel sold
6.28
10.24
Adjusted refinery gross margin per produced barrel sold
12.70
23.20
Less refinery operating expenses per produced barrel sold
8.22
10.81
Adjusted refinery gross margin, less operating expenses per produced barrel sold
4.48
12.39
Reconciliation of renewables operating information (non-GAAP performance measures) to amounts reported under generally accepted accounting principles in financial statements.
Renewables Adjusted renewables gross margin and net operating margin are is a non-GAAP performance measures that are is used by our management and others to compare our renewables performance to that of other companies in our industry. We believe these this margin measures are measure is helpful to investors in evaluating our renewables performance on a relative and absolute basis. Renewables Adjusted renewables gross margin per produced gallon sold is the total Renewables segment revenues less the total Renewables segment cost of products sold, exclusive of gross margin plus lower of cost or market inventory valuation adjustments, depreciation and amortization and operating expenses, divided by sales volumes of produced renewables products sold. The net operating margin per produced gallon sold is the difference between the renewables gross margin and the renewables operating expenses per produced gallon sold. These two margins do This margin measure does not include the non-cash effects of lower of cost or market inventory valuation adjustments and depreciation and amortization. Each of these component performance measures can be reconciled directly to our consolidated statements of income, which relate to volumes in inventory at the end of the period. Adjusted renewables gross margin is not a calculation provided for under US GAAP and should not be considered in isolation or as a substitute for Renewables segment gross margin. The GAAP measure most directly comparable to Adjusted renewables gross margin is Renewables segment gross margin. Other companies in our industry may not calculate these performance measures in the same manner.
Reconciliation of Renewables segment gross margin to Adjusted renewables gross margin to Adjusted renewables gross margin per produced gallon sold and Adjusted renewables gross margin, less operating expenses per produced gallon sold
(In thousands, except per gallon amounts)
Renewables segment
239,559
298,016
230,273
262,738
1,188
47,597
26,461
31,371
20,272
19,974
(38,635
(63,664
Adjusted renewables gross margin
9,286
35,278
Produced gallons sold (in thousand gallons)
61,172
46,012
Gross margin per produced gallon sold
(0.63
(1.38
Adjusted renewables gross margin per produced gallon sold
0.15
0.77
Less renewables operating expense per produced gallon sold
0.43
0.68
Adjusted renewables gross margin, less operating expenses per produced gallon sold
(0.28
0.09
Reconciliation of marketing operating information (non-GAAP performance measures) to amounts reported under generally
Marketing Adjusted marketing gross margin is a non-GAAP performance measure that is used by our management and others to compare our marketing performance to that of other companies in our industry. We believe this margin measure is helpful to investors in evaluating our marketing performance on a relative and absolute basis. Marketing Adjusted marketing gross margin per gallon sold is the total Marketing segment revenues less the total Marketing segment cost of products sold gross margin plus depreciation and amortization, divided by sales volumes of marketing products sold. This margin does not include the non-cash effects of depreciation and amortization. This component performance measure can be reconciled directly to our consolidated statements of income Adjusted marketing gross margin is not a calculation provided for under US GAAP and should not be considered in isolation or as a substitute for Marketing segment gross margin. The GAAP measure most directly comparable to Adjusted marketing gross margin is Marketing segment gross margin. Other companies in our industry may not calculate these performance measures in the same manner.
Reconciliation of Marketing segment gross margin to Adjusted marketing gross margin to Adjusted marketing gross margin per gallon sold